09.34971.Rbr.miscmotion

transcript

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

FORT LAUDERDALE DIVISION www.flsb.uscourts.gov

IN RE: CASE NO.: 09-34791-RBR ROTHSTEIN ROSENFELDT ADLER, P.A., CHAPTER 11 Debtor. ____________________________________/

AGREED EX PARTE MOTION FOR ENTRY OF STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER AND CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER BY

AND BETWEEN TRUSTEEAND FRANK SPINOSA (Expedited Relief Requested)

Herbert Stettin, the Chapter 11 Trustee (“Trustee”) of the Debtor, Rothstein Rosenfeldt

Adler, P.A. (“RRA”), and Frank Spinosa (“Spinosa”), Defendant in state court actions: 1)

Razorback Funding, LLC v. Scott Rothstein, et al., In the Circuit Court of the 17th Judicial Circuit

in and for Broward County, Florida, Case No. 09-062943; and 2) Edward J. Morse, et al. v. Scott

W. Rothstein, et al., In the Circuit Court of the 17th Judicial Circuit in and for Broward County,

Florida, Case No. 10-24110, by and through undersigned counsel, do hereby file this Stipulated

Protective Order (“SPO”) and Agreed Confidentiality Order (“ACO”) by and between the

Trustee and Spinosa, attached hereto as Exhibits “A” & “B”, and in support thereof state:

1. Pursuant to this Court’s Order Granting Trustee’s Motion Seeking a Protective

Order and Approving Proposed Document Production Protocol (“Order”) [D.E. #672] and Order

Granting Trustee’s Motion to Modify Document Production Protocol (“Modified Order”) [D.E.

#1989], the Trustee and Spinosa jointly move for the entry of the SPO and ACO attached hereto

as Exhibits “A” & “B”.

Case 09-34791-RBR Doc 2513 Filed 12/21/11 Page 1 of 21

2. The Trustee and Spinosa request that the SPO and ACO be entered without a

hearing as the relief requested herein is in compliance with the Court’s Order and Modified

Order.

3. The Trustee and Spinosa are requesting expedited relief so that Spinosa can

quickly begin the process of reviewing and analyzing any responsive documents.

WHEREFORE, the Trustee and Spinosa jointly move for the entry of the Stipulated

Protective Order and Agreed Confidentiality Order by and Between Trustee and Spinosa

attached hereto as Exhibits “A” & “B”, and for any and all other relief this Court deems just and

equitable.

Dated: December 21, 2011.

Respectfully submitted: By:s/ Michael L. Cotzen ____ By:s/ Charles H. Lichtman MICHAEL L. COTZEN CHARLES H. LICHTMAN Florida Bar No. 166472 Florida Bar No. 501050 mc@scflalaw.com clichtman@bergersingerman.com SCHLESINGER & COTZEN BERGER SINGERMAN Counsel for Defendant Counsel for the Chapter 11 Trustee 799 Brickell Plaza, Suite 700 350 East Las Olas Boulevard, 10th Floor Miami, FL 33131 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 Tel: (305) 373-8993 Tel: (954) 525-9900 Fax: (305) 373-8098 Fax: (954) 523-2872

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true copy of the foregoing has been furnished via the

Court’s CM/ECF electronic noticing system to all electronic filing participants with respect to

this proceeding, this 21st day of December, 2011.

By: s/ Charles H. Lichtman____ Charles H. Lichtman Florida Bar No. 501050 clichtman@bergersingerman.com Berger Singerman, P.A.

Attorneys for Trustee 350 E. Las Olas Boulevard, Suite 1000 Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 Telephone: (954) 525-9900 Facsimile: (954) 523-2872

SERVICE LIST

Geoffrey S. Aaronson on behalf of Creditor FEP Victims Group gaaronson@aspalaw.com, tdmckeown@mckeownpa.com;sbeiley@aspalaw.com;dlinder@aspalaw.com Thomas L Abrams on behalf of Defendant Rubin Vine tabrams@tabramslaw.com, lmillspaugh@tabramslaw.com;fcolumbo@tabramslaw.com Alberta L. Adams on behalf of Interested Party St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co. aadams@mpdlegal.com, jnelson@mpdlegal.com Melissa Alagna on behalf of Creditor Investors Risk Advantage LLC mma@segallgordich.com, jxp@segallgordich.com Joaquin J Alemany on behalf of Defendant Mayor's Jewelers of Florida, Inc. joaquin.alemany@hklaw.com, jose.casal@hklaw.com Grisel Alonso on behalf of Defendant United States of America grisel.alonso@usdoj.gov, andrea.neumann2@usdoj.gov Brett M Amron on behalf of Creditor Todd Snyder bamron@bastamron.com, jeder@bastamron.com,dquick@bastamron.com,kparrales@bastamron.com,jmiranda@bastamron.com,afiorentino@bastamron.com Eric N Assouline on behalf of Creditor Nick Wilder ena@assoulineberlowe.com, ah@assoulineberlowe.com Kristopher Aungst on behalf of Plaintiff Herbert Stettin kaungst@bergersingerman.com, sochoa@bergersingerman.com;efile@bergersingerman.com Scott L. Baena on behalf of Defendant Centurion Structured Growth LLC sbaena@bilzin.com, eservice@bilzin.com;cvarela@bilzin.com;lflores@bilzin.com;abeck@bilzin.com Jeffrey P. Bast on behalf of Creditor Todd Snyder jbast@bastamron.com, jdepina@bastamron.com;dquick@bastamron.com;jmiranda@bastamron.com;afiorentino@bastamron.com Christopher G Berga on behalf of Defendant ABS Capital Funding, LLC cgb@lydeckerlaw.com, gh@lydeckerlaw.com Eyal Berger on behalf of Creditor Committee Official Committee of Creditors eyal.berger@akerman.com, jeanette.martinez@akerman.com Jeffrey M Berman on behalf of Creditor Emess Capital, LLC jberman@klugerkaplan.com

John G. Bianco III on behalf of Creditor Edward Morse jgb@trippscott.com, bankruptcynoticecenter@trippscott.com Gary S Blake on behalf of Creditor Litton Loan Servicing LP gblake@lglaw.net, bk@lglaw.net Mark D. Bloom on behalf of Defendant TD Bank, N.A. bloomm@gtlaw.com, MiaLitDock@gtlaw.com;miaecfbky@gtlaw.com;reisinoa@gtlaw.com Mark D. Bloom on behalf of Defendant TD Bank, N.A. bloomm@gtlaw.com, MiaLitDock@gtlaw.com;miaecfbky@gtlaw.com;reisinoa@gtlaw.com Alain E Boileau on behalf of Interested Party Ironshore Indemnity, Inc. aeb@mcintoshschwartz.com, rdm@mcintoshschwartz.com;wxs@mcintoshschwartz.com Mark F Booth on behalf of Creditor VRLP1, LLC mfbooth@rmzlaw.com Robert C Buschel on behalf of Defendant Qtask, Inc., a California corporation buschel@bglaw‐pa.com, srodgers@cmk‐law.com Darol H M Carr on behalf of Creditor Blue Oak Construction, LLC cenos@farr.com, dcarr@farr.com Francis L. Carter on behalf of Creditor Circle K Family, LLC flc@katzbarron.com, lcf@katzbarron.com David C. Cimo on behalf of Plaintiff Herbert Stettin dcimo@gjb‐law.com Roderick F. Coleman on behalf of Creditor Prince International Ventures, LLC rfc@colemanattorneys.com Marissa C Corda on behalf of Creditor Circle K Family, LLC mcc@katzbarron.com, af@katzbarron.com Ileana Cruz‐Bongini on behalf of Creditor Coquina Investments icruz@stearnsweaver.com, tcotter@stearnsweaver.com;mmesones‐mori@stearnsweaver.com;rross@stearnsweaver.com Carlos L De Zayas on behalf of Defendant ABS Capital Funding, LLC cdz@lydeckerlaw.com Joseph A. DeMaria on behalf of Creditor Gibraltar Private Bank and Trust jad@tewlaw.com, ecs@tewlaw.com;mm@tewlaw.com Adrian C. Delancy on behalf of Defendant Maple Leaf Drilling Partners adelancy@mrthlaw.com, gruiz@mrthlaw.com;ecfnotices@mrthlaw.com;mrthbkc@gmail.com

Denise D Dell‐Powell on behalf of Interested Party Baron Von Wolfsheild ddpowell@burr.com, ahutchinson@burr.com;greid@burr.com Drew M Dillworth on behalf of Defendant Miami Heat Limited Partnership ddillworth@stearnsweaver.com, marocha@stearnsweaver.com;rross@stearnsweaver.com;mmesones‐mori@stearnsweaver.com;dillworthcdp@ecf.epiqsystems.com Maureen Donlan on behalf of Interested Party United States of America maureen.donlan@usdoj.gov, andrea.neumann2@usdoj.gov John D Eaton on behalf of Defendant SFS Capital Funding, LLC jeaton@rascoklock.com, jshawde@rascoklock.com;ogonzalez@rascoklock.com;nsingh@rascoklock.com Robert F. Elgidely on behalf of Plaintiff Herbert Stettin relgidely@gjb‐law.com, sanderson@gjb‐law.com;ekelly@gjb‐law.com;chopkins@gjb‐law.com;vlambdin@gjb‐law.com Matthew J Feeley on behalf of Creditor Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney PC matthew.feeley@bipc.com, christopher.hudson@bipc.com;amin.rajani@bipc.com Robert G Fracasso Jr on behalf of Defendant Bodner Family Foundations rfracasso@shutts.com Robert C Furr on behalf of Creditor Greenwood Capital Partners, LLC bnasralla@furrcohen.com David L Gay on behalf of Defendant Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler, P.A. dgay@bergersingerman.com, jalvarez@bergersingerman.com;efile@bergersingerman.com John H Genovese on behalf of Petitioning Creditor Aran Development Inc. jgenovese@gjb‐law.com, dsanchez@gjb‐law.com;gjbecf@gjb‐law.com Larry I Glick on behalf of Defendant Bodner Family Foundations lglick@shutts.com Michael I Goldberg on behalf of Creditor Committee Official Commitee of Unsecured Creditors michael.goldberg@akerman.com, charlene.cerda@akerman.com Alvin S. Goldstein on behalf of Interested Party Robert Furr mmitchell@furrcohen.com Jason B Gonzalez on behalf of Defendant Republican Party of Florida jgonzalez@ausley.com Lawrence Gordich on behalf of Creditor Investors Risk Advantage LLC LAG@segallgordich.com, jxp@segallgordich.com;mma@segallgordich.com

John S Graham on behalf of Interested Party Jeffrey Epstein jgraham@fowler‐white.com, LAS@fowler‐white.com;AKS@fowler‐white.com;qsurrency@fowler‐white.com;adial@fowler‐white.com;jackerman@fowler‐white.com Gregory S Grossman on behalf of Creditor Fifth Third Bank ggrossman@astidavis.com Nancy E Guffy on behalf of Plaintiff Thirteen Aqua Holdings Ltd mkoskey@feamanlaw.com Jordi Guso on behalf of Debtor Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler, PA jguso@bergersingerman.com, fsellers@bergersingerman.com;efile@bergersingerman.com Hollie N Hawn on behalf of Creditor Broward County Records,Taxes & Treasury hhawn@broward.org John L. Heller john.heller@marcumllp.com, fl03@ecfcbis.com Bart A Houston on behalf of Defendant Africat Marine U.S.A., Inc. houston@kolawyers.com, hylton@kolawyers.com;berger@kolawyers.com John B. Hutton III on behalf of Defendant TD Bank, N.A. huttonj@gtlaw.com, thompsonc@gtlaw.com;mialitdock@gtlaw.com;miaecfbky@gtlaw.com John B. Hutton III on behalf of Plaintiff TD Bank, N.A. huttonj@gtlaw.com, thompsonc@gtlaw.com;mialitdock@gtlaw.com;miaecfbky@gtlaw.com Geoffrey D Ittleman on behalf of Creditor Steven Bitton geoffrey@ittlemanlaw.com Allan A Joseph on behalf of 3rd Party Plaintiff Jody Alu ajoseph@davidjosephlaw.com Bruce A Katzen on behalf of Creditor Emess Capital, LLC bkatzen@klugerkaplan.com, miglesias@klugerkaplan.com Roy S Kobert on behalf of Creditor Caro Group, LLC orlandobankruptcy@broadandcassel.com Brian R Kopelowitz on behalf of Defendant Chris M. Salamone & Associates kopelowitz@kolawyers.com, herrington@kolawyers.com Harris J. Koroglu on behalf of Creditor American Express Travel Related Services Company, Inc. hkoroglu@shutts.com, jgoodwin@shutts.com Matthew G Krause on behalf of Defendant Braman Motors, Inc. mkrause@ls‐law.com

Thomas R. Lehman on behalf of Defendant Sussco, Inc. trl@lkllaw.com, jmh@lkllaw.com;esf@lkllaw.com;cag@lkllaw.com Seth Lehrman on behalf of Interested Party Farmer, Jaffe, Weissing, Edwards, Fistos & Lehrman, P.L. seth@pathtojustice.com Michael D Lessne on behalf of Defendant Marcy Lippman michael.lessne@gray‐robinson.com, jessica.cartagena@gray‐robinson.com;abby.srour@gray‐robinson.com David M. Levine on behalf of Interested Party Harden & Associates, Inc. dml@lkllaw.com, rb@lkllaw.com;lv@lkllaw.com Joan M Levit on behalf of Creditor Committee Official Committee of Creditors joan.levit@akerman.com, charlene.cerda@akerman.com Charles H Lichtman on behalf of Defendant Herbert Stettin clichtman@bergersingerman.com, ctarrant@bergersingerman.com;lwebster@bergersingerman.com;efile@bergersingerman.com John E Lucian on behalf of Defendant Mary Noa lucian@blankrome.com Matthew A Mannering on behalf of Defendant RL Pearson and Associates, Inc. mmannering@hunton.com, dparry@hunton.com Alan K. Marcus on behalf of Defendant Albert Peter amarcus@lrxgroup.com, ronmiam@aol.com;nvicente@lrxgroup.com Isaac M Marcushamer on behalf of Defendant Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler, P.A. imarcushamer@bergersingerman.com, fsellers@bergersingerman.com;efile@bergersingerman.com Marilee A Mark on behalf of Plaintiff Herbert Stettin mmark@gjb‐law.com, gjbecf@gjb‐law.com Jerry M Markowitz on behalf of Defendant Maple Leaf Drilling Partners jmarkowitz@mrthlaw.com, gruiz@mrthlaw.com;msalazar@mrthlaw.com;rrubio@mrthlaw.com;ycandia@mrthlaw.com;joyecf@mdrtlaw.com;mrthbkc@gmail.com Ronald J. Marlowe on behalf of Defendant Satoriquest, Inc. rjmarlowe@arnstein.com, federal‐notices@marlowe.cc Jason S Mazer on behalf of Plaintiff Herbert Stettin jmazer@vpl‐law.com, kshaw@vpl‐law.com;csteklof@vpl‐law.com;cgudaitis@vpl‐law.com;lrodriguez@vpl‐law.com;receptionist@vpl‐law.com

Frank F McGinn on behalf of Creditor Iron Mountain Information Management, Inc. ffm@bostonbusinesslaw.com Niall T McLachlan on behalf of Defendant Mooring Capital Fund, LLC nmclachlan@carltonfields.com, cguzman@carltonfields.com Paul J McMahon on behalf of Interested Party Philip Arvidson pjm@pjmlawmiami.com James C. Moon on behalf of Creditor Banyon 1030‐32, LLC jmoon@melandrussin.com, ltannenbaum@melandrussin.com;mrbnefs@yahoo.com Harold D Moorefield Jr. on behalf of Creditor Gibraltar Private Bank and Trust hmoorefield@stearnsweaver.com, cgraver@stearnsweaver.com;larrazola@stearnsweaver.com;rross@stearnsweaver.com;mmesones‐mori@stearnsweaver.com;dillworthcdp@ecf.epiqsystems.com Norman A Moscowitz on behalf of Defendant Berenfeld Spritzer Schechter & Sheer, LLP nmoscowitz@moscowitz.com, jpaya@mmmpa.com;rbithman@mmmpa.com;jmoscowitz@mmmpa.com John H. Mueller on behalf of Defendant HN Associates jmueller@clarkmueller.com, jhaner@sclegal.com Barry E. Mukamal bankruptcy@marcumllp.com Arthur C. Neiwirth on behalf of Interested Party Arthur Neiwirth aneiwirthcourt@qpwblaw.com Ari Newman on behalf of Witness TD Bank, N.A. newmanar@gtlaw.com, thompsonc@gtlaw.com;mialitdock@gtlaw.com Timothy J Norris on behalf of Defendant Ballamor Capital Management, Inc. tjnorris@duanemorris.com Office of the US Trustee USTPRegion21.MM.ECF@usdoj.gov Christian A Petersen on behalf of Respondent Al Lamberti cpetersen@gunster.com, flessard@gunster.com Gary S Phillips on behalf of Defendant Barry Lipsitz gphillips@phillipslawyers.com Robert M Quinn on behalf of 3rd Party Plaintiff Mooring Capital Fund, LLC rquinn@carltonfields.com, lrodriguez@carltonfields.com;tpaecf@cfdom.net Ivan J Reich on behalf of Interested Party Columbia Casualty Company

ireich@gray‐robinson.com, abby.srour@gray‐robinson.com;jessica.cartagena@gray‐robinson.com Robert F. Reynolds on behalf of Defendant David Boden rreynolds@slatkinreynolds.com, imalcolm@slatkinreynolds.com Claudio Riedi on behalf of Creditor Gibraltar Private Bank and Trust criedi@tewlaw.com Heather L. Ries on behalf of Creditor Nova Bank hries@foxrothschild.com, mbird@foxrothschild.com;rputnam@foxrothschild.com Kenneth B Robinson on behalf of Interested Party George Levin krobinson.ecf@rprslaw.com Alan B Rose on behalf of Defendant Charles Rucks arose@pm‐law.com, pwiley@pm‐law.com;mchandler@pm‐law.com David L Rosendorf on behalf of Creditor Razorback Funding, LLC dlr@kttlaw.com, rcp@kttlaw.com;CWT@kttlaw.com;ycc@kttlaw.com Alex P Rosenthal on behalf of Defendant MLC 350, LLC alex@rrcounsel.com Jeffrey C. Roth on behalf of Defendant Blue Capital US East Coast Properties, L.P. jeff@rothandscholl.com, christine@rothandscholl.com Steven Safra on behalf of Creditor Joseph Sparveri Steven.Safra@csklegal.com Luis Salazar on behalf of Defendant Stuart Rosenfeldt luis.salazar@izhmlaw.com, linda.jackson@InfanteZumpano.com;araceli.aguilar@InfanteZumpano.com;karina.dominguez@InfanteZumpano.com;kevin.cabrera@InfanteZumpano.com;alina.fadhel@InfanteZumpano.com William G Salim Jr on behalf of Creditor NF Servicing, LLC wsalim@mmsslaw.com, cleibovitz@mmsslaw.com Reggie David Sanger on behalf of Creditor Marika Tolz ecfmail@reggiedsangerpa.com, rdsoffice@gmail.com Harry R Schafer on behalf of Defendant Marcy Lippman hschafer@kennynachwalter.com Steven D Schneiderman on behalf of U.S. Trustee Office of the US Trustee Steven.D.Schneiderman@usdoj.gov Matthew H Scott on behalf of Counter‐Defendant Carolina Casualty Insurance Company mhs@trippscott.com, bankruptcy@trippscott.com

Patrick S. Scott on behalf of Defendant Michael Ashton, Inc. patrick.scott@gray‐robinson.com Frank P Scruggs on behalf of Plaintiff Herbert Stettin fscruggs@bergersingerman.com, clamb@bergersingerman.com Michael D. Seese on behalf of Defendant Kimberly Rothstein mseese@hinshawlaw.com, sseward@hinshawlaw.com;lportuondo@hinshawlaw.com Steven E Seward on behalf of Defendant Kimberly Rothstein sseward@hinshawlaw.com John C. Shawde on behalf of Creditor SFS jshawde@rascoklock.com, ogonzalez@rascoklock.com;nsingh@rascoklock.com Bradley S Shraiberg on behalf of Counter‐Defendant Carolina Casualty Insurance Company bshraiberg@sfl‐pa.com, dwoodall@sfl‐pa.com;vchapkin@sfl‐pa.com;lrosetto@sfl‐pa.com;scusack@sfl‐pa.com;blee@sfl‐pa.com James D. Silver on behalf of Attorney Conrad & Scherer, LLP jds@conradscherer.com, jkaufman@conradscherer.com;raldama@conradscherer.com Paul Steven Singerman on behalf of 3rd Pty Defendant Herbert Stettin singerman@bergersingerman.com, mruiz@bergersingerman.com;efile@bergersingerman.com Jason Slatkin on behalf of Defendant Katie Adler jslatkin@slatkinreynolds.com, imalcolm@slatkinreynolds.com Steven J. Solomon on behalf of Defendant Suntrust Bank, N.A. steven.solomon@gray‐robinson.com, lnegron@gray‐robinson.com;marilyn.rivera@gray‐robinson.com Jeffrey R Sonn on behalf of Petitioning Creditor Roger Wittenberns, jsonn@sonnerez.com James B Sowka on behalf of Interested Party Columbia Casualty Company jsowka@seyfarth.com Jesus M Suarez on behalf of Plaintiff Herbert Stettin jsuarez@gjb‐law.com, gjbecf@gjb‐law.com;chopkins@gjb‐law.com Joel L Tabas on behalf of Intervenor‐Defendant Whitney Education Group, Inc. jtabas@tabasfreedman.com, karen@tabasfreedman.com;rdecker@tabasfreedman.com;francis@tabasfreedman.com Deborah Talenfeld on behalf of Trustee Herbert Stettin dtalenfeld@bergersingerman.com, efile@bergersingerman.com

Jeffrey A Tew on behalf of Creditor Gibraltar Private Bank and Trust jt@tewlaw.com, jab@tewlaw.com Melinda S Thornton on behalf of Creditor Miami‐Dade County Tax Collector cao.bkc@miamidade.gov Marika Tolz TolzECFmail@aol.com, mtolz@ecf.epiqsystems.com Rhett Traband on behalf of Creditor Caro Group, LLC rtraband@broadandcassel.com, nfundora@broadandcassel.com Trustee Services Inc 2 court@trusteeservices.biz, sandirose.magder@gmail.com Peter F. Valori on behalf of Creditor Caro Group, LLC pvalori@dvllp.com, spitta@dvllp.com Theresa M Van Vliet on behalf of Plaintiff Herbert Stettin tvanvliet@gjb‐law.com Laura J. Varela on behalf of Defendant Barry Lipsitz lvarela@phillipslawyers.com Victor H Veschio on behalf of Defendant Bank Of America, N.A. firm@vlgfl.com, VictorLawGroup@gmail.com;JEM@vlgfl.com Roy L. Weinfeld on behalf of Defendant AT&T Corp. rlw@weinfeldlaw.com Bryan T West on behalf of Creditor Gibraltar Private Bank and Trust btw@tewlaw.com Henry S Wulf on behalf of Creditor 123 MA Exchange One LLC hwulf@carltonfields.com, kvickers@carltonfields.com

Exhibit A

In re: ROTHSTEIN ROSENFELDT ADLER, P.A., Case No. 09-34791-BKC-RBR

Chapter 11 Debtor.

_____________________________________/

STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER BY AND BETWEEN TRUSTEE AND FRANK SPINOSA

Plaintiff, Herbert Stettin, the Chapter 11 Trustee (“Trustee”) of Rothstein Rosenfeld

Adler, P.A. (“RRA” or “Debtor”), and Frank Spinosa (“Spinosa”), Defendant in state court

actions: 1) Razorback Funding, LLC v. Scott Rothstein, et al., In the Circuit Court of the 17th

Judicial Circuit in and for Broward County, Florida, Case No. 09-062943; and 2) Edward J.

Morse, et al. v. Scott W. Rothstein, et al., In the Circuit Court of the 17th Judicial Circuit in and

for Broward County, Florida, Case No. 10-24110, by and through their undersigned counsel, and

pursuant to this Court’s Order Granting Trustee’s Motion Seeking a Protective Order and

Approving Proposed Document Production Protocol (D.E. 672) and Order Granting Trustee’s

Motion to Modify Document Production Protocol (D.E. 1989 ), hereby agree to and request

Court approval of the following stipulation:

It is expected that, to facilitate the sharing of RRA documents and electronically stored

information (“ESI”), Spinosa will submit search criteria, including names of targeted custodians,

search terms, date ranges, to/from, subject line contents, or other criteria to the Trustee to utilize

in identifying ESI potentially responsive to the search terms provided by Spinosa. It is further

anticipated that the Trustee’s counsel and Spinosa will agree upon certain such search criteria

prior to the Trustee’s counsel performing searches of ESI. Both Parties seek the protection of the

Court to ensure that they may share such information while preserving all applicable privileges,

including those pertaining to RRA’s former clients. It is therefore

ORDERED as follows:

1. Should any information, including documents and ESI, provided to Spinosa in

accordance with this Stipulation contain information protected by the attorney/client privilege or

work-product doctrine, the production of such information shall be deemed inadvertent and the

privilege or protection regarding such material shall not be deemed waived by such disclosure in

this or any other action in any other Federal or State proceeding, pursuant to Federal Rule of

Evidence 502(d),(e) and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(5)(B), regardless of state

decisional law. Spinosa shall immediately return any documents, ESI or other RRA information

produced by the Trustee that is, or appears that it may be protected by attorney/client privilege

including any privileges pertaining to RRA’s former clients.

2. Neither Spinosa nor its counsel shall publish, disseminate, or make public any

documents or ESI, or the contents thereof, provided by the Trustee pursuant to this Stipulation

without first submitting the documents or ESI to be used to the Trustee or his counsel for

authorization, unless Spinosa or their counsel obtained the identical information from another

non-privileged source. The Trustee shall examine any documents or ESI to be used by Spinosa

for privilege or protection before authorizing its use by Spinosa, which authorization shall not be

withheld unreasonably. Spinosa shall promptly return any documents or ESI identified by the

Trustee as containing privileged material. Spinosa must receive written authorization from the

Trustee prior to any publication, dissemination, or use of any documents or ESI received from

the Trustee pursuant to this Stipulation which would make those documents or ESI public. If the

parties, after their best good faith efforts to resolve any disputes, disagree as to the privilege

nature of any documents or ESI produced according to this Stipulation, Spinosa shall have the

right to bring the matter before the Court for resolution.

3. Neither the Trustee nor his counsel shall publish, disseminate, or make public the

list of search criteria submitted by Spinosa or their counsel, nor a list of the documents or ESI

supplied to Spinosa or their counsel unless ordered to do so by a court of competent jurisdiction.

4. If the Trustee or any third party identifies that privileged documents or ESI have

been produced to Spinosa, and Spinosa fails to promptly return such information, or if any

unauthorized publication, dissemination or any other prohibited use of information provided by

the Trustee to Spinosa occurs in violation of this Stipulated Protective Order, the Trustee may

move for injunctive relief on an emergency and/or expedited basis, including the application for

an ex parte order enjoining possession, publication or other use of any documents or ESI

provided by the Trustee to Spinosa.

5. This protective order is not intended to nor does it apply to any person or party

not explicitly named herein.

Submitted by: Charles H. Lichtman, Esq. BERGER SINGERMAN, P.A., Attorneys for Chapter 11 Trustee, Herbert Stettin 350 E. Las Olas Blvd. Suite 1000 Telephone: (954) 525-9900 Facsimile: (954)523-2872 Direct Telephone: (954) 712-5138 clichtman@bergersingerman.com Copy furnished to: Charles H. Lichtman, Esq. (Attorney Lichtman is directed to serve this Order to all parties of interest and to file a Certificate of Service.)

Exhibit B

In re: CASE NO.: 09-34791-BKC-RBR ROTHSTEIN ROSENFELDT ADLER, P.A., CHAPTER 11

Debtor. ________________________________________/

AGREED CONFIDENTIALITY ORDER BY AND BETWEEN

TRUSTEE AND FRANK SPINOSA

THIS MATTER came before the Court without hearing upon the Agreed Ex Parte

Motion for Entry of a Stipulated Protective and Confidentiality Order by and Between

Trustee and Frank Spinosa [D.E. __] (the “Motion”). Upon consideration of the

Motion, the agreement of the parties, good cause appearing and the Court being otherwise

fully advised in the premises, IT IS

ORDERED as follows:

1. The Motion is GRANTED.

2. This Confidentiality Order governs the treatment of all documents and other

written, recorded, computerized, electronic or graphic matters, copies, excerpts or summaries of

documents (“Discovery Material”) produced by any party or non-party in the Proceeding.

3. Any party or non-party that produces Discovery Material in this Proceeding may

designate as “Confidential” any Discovery Material that it believes in good faith contains

confidential and/or proprietary information. All Discovery Material so designated shall be

referred to in this Confidentiality Order as “Confidential Discovery Material” and shall be

handled in strict accordance with the terms of this Confidentiality Order.

4. To designate Discovery Material as “Confidential,” the party shall mark the

document as “CONFIDENTIAL” on the face of the document and on each page or portion

thereof so designated or, in the case of electronically-stored or computer-stored documents (e.g.,

pdf documents or documents stored on CDs, DVDs or other media), identify the document by

document number, file number or in any other manner that will enable the ready identification of

the subject document.

5. Absent further agreement of the parties, or an order of this Court, all Confidential

Discovery Material and its contents shall be used only for this Proceeding (including mediation,

arbitration, trial, and appeals) (collectively, the “Pending Actions”), and such Confidential

Discovery Material shall not be voluntarily disclosed or produced to any person, entity or party

other than the following: (A) the parties or officers or employees or other authorized agent(s) of

any party to the Pending Actions, (B) the attorneys, their staff members, and any third-party

contractors, including employees and agents thereof involved solely in one or more aspects of

organizing, filing, copying, coding, converting, sorting, or otherwise duplicating documents,

retrieving data or designing programs for handling data in connection with the Pending Actions,

including the performance of such duties in relation to a computerized litigation support system

provided that such persons, (C) independent experts, consultants, and advisors employed or

retained by counsel for the parties solely for the purpose of litigation of the Pending Actions,

including but not limited to proposed expert witnesses, with whom counsel for any of the parties

deems it necessary to consult concerning investigative, technical, financial or other aspects of the

Pending Actions, (D) testifying witnesses in any of the Pending Actions, and (E) this Court,

including its clerks, reporters and staff.

6. Should any person to whom this Confidentiality Order applies wish to disclose

any Confidential Discovery Material to any person, entity or party or use any such confidential

or proprietary information for any purpose other than as authorized herein, such person, through

counsel, shall advise counsel for all other parties of the requested disclosure or use. If any party

does not agree to the requested disclosure or use, the person requesting disclosure may file a

motion in this Court seeking Court approval of the proposed disclosure or use, and, upon notice

and a hearing, the Court shall determine the confidentiality of the Confidential Discovery

Material at issue and determine whether good cause exists to permit the disclosure or use of such

Confidential Discovery Material other than as provided herein.

7. If any Confidential Discovery Material is to be disclosed in any brief, exhibit,

discovery request, or response or other court paper served on any party or non-party, such brief,

exhibit, discovery request, or response or other court paper shall be filed under seal, unless

otherwise agreed between the parties in writing or ordered by the Court after notice and a

hearing, prior to the filing of such Confidential Discovery Material with the Court. Furthermore,

in the event a party seeks to use any Confidential Discovery Material in any hearing or at the trial

of this action, the parties agree to seek relief from these confidentiality provisions or to advise

the Court to take whatever measures may be reasonably necessary to maintain the confidentiality

of said Confidential Discovery Material.

8. The inadvertent failure to mark any Discovery Material, or a portion thereof, with

the “Confidential” designation in no way alters or waives the protected and confidential nature of

the Discovery Material otherwise deserving of such a designation and does not remove it from

the scope of this Confidentiality Order, provided that the party designating such a Discovery

Material as “Confidential” gives such notice in writing within thirty days after becoming aware

that the Discovery Material was not properly designated. Such written notice shall identify with

specificity the Discovery Material that the party is then designating to be “Confidential” and the

designating party shall promptly provide a replacement copy of such material with the

appropriate designation thereupon. Treatment of inadvertently produced Confidential Discovery

Material in a manner inconsistent with this Confidentiality Order prior to notice of such

inadvertent production is not a breach of this Confidentiality Order.

9. Except as otherwise agreed in writing by the parties, within 45 days after the

expiration of the resolution or final judgment of this Proceeding, all Confidential Discovery

Material and all copies thereof (including, without limitation, copies provided to testifying or

consulting experts) shall, at the possessing party’s choice, be returned to the party producing

such Confidential Discovery Materials, or the party’s counsel shall certify to the party producing

such Confidential Discovery Materials that all such materials have been destroyed, except that

counsel for each party subject to this Confidentiality Order may retain one complete and

unredacted set of pleadings and papers filed in this Proceeding or served upon the other party to

this Proceeding solely for reference. This Confidentiality Order shall survive the final

termination of this Proceeding with respect to any such Confidential Discovery Material.

10. Pursuant to the Rules of Court, the parties agree to the disposal by the

Clerk of any Confidential Discovery Material filed under seal by destroying such documents six

months after the closing of this case.

Submitted by: Charles H. Lichtman, Esq. BERGER SINGERMAN, P.A., Attorneys for Chapter 11 Trustee, Herbert Stettin 350 E. Las Olas Blvd. Suite 1000 Telephone: (954) 525-9900 Facsimile: (954)523-2872 Direct Telephone: (954) 712-5138 clichtman@bergersingerman.com Copy furnished to: Charles H. Lichtman, Esq. (Attorney Lichtman is directed to serve this Order to all parties of interest and to file a Certificate of Service.)

09.34971.Rbr.miscmotion

Documents