Post on 08-Mar-2020
transcript
TABLE OF CASES
l. A. Narain Rao v. Dr. G. Ramkrishna Reddy,(1993) 1 C.P.J. 110 (N.C.).
2. A.C. Modagi v. Grosswell Tailors,(1991) 2 C.P.J. 586 (N.C.).
3. A.S. Mittal v. State of U.P.,(1989) 3 S.C.C. 223.
4. Achutrao Haribau Khodwa v. State of Maharastra,J.T. (1996) 2 S..C. 624.
5. Additional Director C.G.H.S. v. Dr. R.C. Bhutani,(1996) 1 C.P.J. 255 (N.C.). ‘
6. Ahern v. Veteran Administration,537 F.2d 1098, C.C.A. 10, 1976.
7. Airedale National Health Service Trust v. Bland,(1993) 1 All E.R. 821 (H.L.).
8. Ajay Enterprises Ltd. v. Kamalesh Aggarwal,(1998) l C.P.J. 77 (N.C.).
9. Akhil Bharathiya Grahak Panchayat v. State of Gujarath,(1994) 1 C.P.J. 114 (N.C.).
10. Al-Kandari v. J.R. Brown & Co.,(1988) 1 All E.R. 833 (C.A.).
11. Aleyamma Varghese v. Dewan Bahadur,(1997) 3 C.P.J. 165 (Kerala S.C.D.R.C.).
12. Allen v. Sri Alfred McAlpline & Sons Ltd.,[1968] 1 All E.R. 543 (C.A.).
13. Amelea Flounders v. Dr. Clement Perreira,(1947) ().C.J. Appeal No. 27 of 1947 (unreported).
xi
Page. 192
. 18
.26, 49
.56, 79,80
. 186
.54
.30, 46
.318
.289
.278
.. 58
.. 286
.. 91
Anderson v. Chasney,[1950] 4 D.L.R. 223.
Anderson v. Martzke,226 N.E. 2d 137, I11. 1970.
Anglia Television v. Reed,[1972] 1 Q.B. 60.
Anns v. London Borough of Merton,[1977] 2 All E.R. 492 (H.L.).
Aphraim J ayanand Rathod v. Dr. Shailesh Shah,(1996) 1 C.P.J. 243 (Gujarath S.C.D.R.C.).
Arenson v. Arenson,[1977] A.C. 405.
Arvindkumar Himmatlal Shah v. Bombay Hospital Trust,(1992) 2 C.P.R. 154 (Maharastra S.C.D.R.C.).
Ashcroft v. Mersey Regional Health Authority,[1983] 2 All E.R. 245 (Q.B.).
Ashton v. Wainwright,[1936] 1 All E.R. 805 (K.B.).
Aubrey J acobus and Partners Ltd., v. Gerrad, unreported,
Auburn Municipal Council v. A.R.C. EngineeringPvt. Ltd., [1973] N.S.W.L.R. 523.
Aulen v. Truimph Explosive D.C.M.D.,58 F.Supp. 4.8.
B.L. Holdings Ltd. v. Wood,[1978]l0 Build. L.R. 48.
B.N. Venkatesh Murthy v. Bangalore DevelopmentAuthority, (1994) 3 C.P.J. 96 (N.C.).
B.S. Hegde v. Dr. Sudhanshu Bhattacharya,(1992) 2 C.P.J. 449 (Maharastra S.C.D.R.C.).
xii
56
89
287
315, 323
197
319
40
22
267
304
320
2
306
307, 322
40, 150
B.S. Hegde v. Dr. Sudhanshu Bhattacharya, ..(1993) 3 C.P.J. 388 (N.C.).
Bagely v. North Herts Health Authority, ..[1986] 136 N.L.J. 1014.
Bagot v. Stevens Scanton and Co. Ltd.,[1966] 1Q.B. 197.
Bailey v. Bullock,[1950] 2 Al1E.R. 1167 (K.B.).
Bailey v. Williams,189 Neb. 484, 486, 203 N.W. 2d 454, 456 (1973).
Bannerman Brydone Folster & Co. v. Murray, ..[1972] N.Z.L.R. 411.
Barnett v. Chelsea & Kensington Hospital ..Management Committee, [1968] 1 All E.R. 1068 (Q.B.).
Batten v. Wedgwood Coal and Iron & Co., ..(1886) 31 Ch. D.346.
Batty v. Metropolitan Realizations Ltd.[1978] 2 All E.R. 445 (C.A.).
Beatty v. Cullingworth,(1896) 2 B.M.J. 1525.
Beausoleil v. La Communaute des Soeurs de la ..charite de la Providence, [1963] 53 D.L.R.65.
Benson v. Thomas Eggar & SonDec. 2, 1977, (unreported).
Bevan Investments Ltd. v. Blackhall & Struthers, ..[1973] 2 N.Z.L.R. 45 (first instance).
Bevan Investments Ltd. v. Blackhall and Struthers (No.2), ..[1977] 2 N.Z.L.R. 45.
xiii
, IO
41, 150
180
16
288
23
260
176
275
16, 315
105
102
260
313,320
301, 321
Bharathi Knitting Company v. D.H.L. WorldwideExpress Courier Division of Airfreight Ltd., ..A.I.R. 1996 S.C. 2508.
Bhavachandbhai Manjibhai Lakhani v.Dr. Bhupendra D. Sagar,(1994) 1 C.P.J. 361 (Gujarath S.C.D.R.C.).
Bhupendranath Das v. Maharaj Ramkrishna Mission S.P., ..(1998)1 C.P.J.377 (West Bengal S.C.D.R.C.).
Biju @ Paul Joseph v. Dr. K. Kunhu Mohammed, ..(1997) 3 C.P.J. 316 (Kerala S.C.D.R.C.).
Bird v. Pritchard,291 N.E. 2d 769, Ohio 1973.
Blair v. Eblen,461 S.W. 2d 370,373 (Ky.l970)
Blyth v. Birmingham Water Works Co., ..(1856) 11 Ex.781.
“s
Blyth v. Bloomsbury Health Authority,[1993] 4 Med. L.R. 151(C.A.)
Boase v. Paul,[1931] 1 D.L.R. 562.
Bolam v. Friern Hospital Management Committee, ..[l957]2 All E.R. 118 (Q.B.).
Bolitho v. City and Hackney Health Authority, ..[1993] 4 Med. L.R. 381 (C.A.).
Bonnington Castings Ltd. V. Wardlaw,[1956] 1 All E.R. 615 (H.L.).
Boorman v. Brown,(1842) 3 Q.B. 511.
Boyce v. Rendells,[1983] 268 E.G. 268.
xiv
172
189
81
78
70
24
6
104, 120
104
21, 22, 97
30, 31
177
15
268
Bravery v. Bravery,[1954] 3 Al1E.R. 59 (C.A.).
Braisher v. Harefield & Northwood Hospital GroupManagement Committee, [1966] 2 Lancet 235.
Breen v. Williams,186 C.L.R. 71.
Brickfield Properties Ltd. v. Newton,[1971] 3 A11E.R. 328 (C.A.).
Brijmohan Kher v. Dr. H.N. Banka(1995) 1 C.P.J. 99 (N.C.).
Browne v. Brandth,[1902] l K.B. 696.
Bryan v. Maloney,[1995] 69 A.L.J.R. 375.
Bryant v. Goodrich,[1966]11O S.J. 108.
C.S. Sarma v. P. Venkataswamy,(1997) 1 C.P.J. 425 (Andra Pradesh S.C.D.R.C.).
Caaradine Properties Ltd. v. D.J. Freeman & Co.,[1982] 126 S.J. 157 (C.A).
Caldeira v. Gray,[1936] 1 A1lE.R. 540 (P.C.).
Cannon v. Pearson,383 S.W.2d 565, Tex. 1964.
Canterbury v. Spence,464 F.2d 772 (1972).
Capuono v. Jacobs,305 N.Y.S. 2d 837, N.Y. 1969.
XV
106
35
220
299
192
148
325
281
289
282
48
88
121, 127, 131211
156
71. Carr v. Inland Revenue Commissioner, .. 3[192l]2 K.B. 332.
72. Carr v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Co.,384 F. Supp. 821, Dc. Ark.l974.
73. Chairman, Tamilnadu Housing Board v.N. Sivasailam(1996) 1 C.P.J. 321 (N.C.).
74. Chamber v. Goldthorpe,[1901] 1Q.B. 624.
75. Champs v. Stone,58 N.E. 2d 803, Ohio 1944.
76. Chanchal Oswal v. Santhokba Durlahjhi MemorialHospital, [1995] 1 C.P.J. 42 (Rajasthan S.C.D.R.C.).
77. Chapman v. Karlson,240 So. 2d 236, Miss. 1970.
78. Chatterton v. Gerson,[1981] 1 All E.R. 257 (Q.B.).
79. Chelmsford D.C. v. Evers,[1983] 25 Build. L.R. 99.
80. Chin Keow v. Govemment of Malaysia,[1967] 1 W.L.R. 8l3(P.C.).
81. Christian v. Wilmington General Hospital,135 A.2d 727, Del.1957.
82. Christian Medical Centre v. Shajahan,(1998) 3 C.P.J. 242 (Andra Pradesh S.C.D.R.C.).
83. Chumbler v. McClure,505 F. 2d 489, 492 <6“ Cir.1974).
84. City of Brantford v. Kemp and Wallace — Carmthersand Associates Ltd., [1960] 23 D.L.R. 641.
xvi
252
303
311
64, 69
69
86
115, 119
299
22, 36
84
37
26
312
Clark v. MacLennan,[1983] 1 All E.R. 416 (Q.B.).
Clark v. United States,402 F. 2d 950, C.C.A. 4, 1968.
Clarke v. Adams,[1950] 94 S.J. 599.
Clarke v. Bruce Lance & Co.,[1988] 1 All E.R. 364 (C.A.).
Cobbs v. Grant,502 P. 2d 1 (1972).
Collins v. Hertfordshire County Council,[1947] 1 All E.R. 633 (K.B.). '
Collins v. Wilcock,[1984] 3 All E.R. 374 (Q.B.).
Columbus v. clowess,[1903] 1 K.B. 247.
Colvin v. Smith,276 App. Div. 9, 92 N.Y.S. (2d) 794 (1949).
Commissioner of Inland Revenue v. Maxse,[1919] 1 K.B. 647.
Connolly v. Camden and Islington Area Health Authority,[1981] 3 All E.R. 250 (Q.B.).
Constantine v. Imperial London Hotels,[1944] 2 All E.R. 171 (K.B.).
Consumer Education and Research Centre v.Dr. Rathilal Patel,(1991) 2 C.P.R. 204 (Gujarath S.C.D.R.C.).
Consumer Protection Council v. Rudradattu AmarkantVyas, (1996) 2 C.P.J. 97 (Gujarath S.C.D.R.C.).
xvii
24
34, 79
45
278
122, 130, 134
SO
100
302
161
3
54
148
187
309
99. Consumer Unity and Trust Society v. The State ofRajasthan, (1992) 1 C.P.J. 259 (N.C.).
100. Cook v. Swinfen,[1967] 1 All E.R. 299 (C.A.).
101. Cooper v. Nevill,[1961] E.A. 63 (P.C.).
102. Cope v. Sharpe,[1912] 1 K.B.496.
103. Craze v. Meyer Dumore Bottlers Co. Ltd.,[1936] 2 All E.R. 1150 (C.A.).
104. Crossman v. Stewart,[1977] 5 C.C.L.T. 45.
105. Crouch v. Most,432 P. 2d 250, 254 (1967).
106. Crysler v. Pearse,[1943] 4 D.L.R. 738.
107. Curley v. McDonald,160 N.E. 796, Mass. 1928.
108. Cutler v. McPhai1,[1962] 2 Q.B. 292.
109. D. & F. Estates Ltd. v. Church Commissioner for England,[1988] 2 All E.R. 992 (H.L.).
110. Darling v. Charleston Comm.Mem. Hospital,33 Ill. 2d 326, 211 N.E. 2d 253 (1965).
111. Dashiell v. Griffith,35 All. 1094 Md. 1896.
112. Davis v. Barking Havering & Brenthood Health Authority,[1993] 4 Med. L.R. 85.
Xviii
Dr. A.N. Mukherji v. State,A.I.R. 1969 All. 489.
Dr. C.S. Subramaniam v. Kumarasamy,(1994) 1 C.P.J. 509 (Mad. D.B.).
.. 200
187
Dr. N.T. Subrahmanyam v. Dr. B. Krishna Rao, ..80(1996) 2 C.P.J. 233 (N.C.).
Dr. Ashok Dhawan v. Surjeet Singh,(1997) 1 C.P.J. 82 (N.C.).
Dr. Jacob George v. State of Kerala,(1994) 3 S.C.C. 430.
Dr. J yothi Vivek v. Pradeep,(1998) 1 C.P.J. 191 (Kerala S.C. D.R.C.).
Dr. Laxman Balkrishna J oshi v. Dr. Trimbak BabuGodbole, A.I.R 1969 S.C. 128.
Dr. Pinnamaneni Narasimha Rao v. GundavarapuJayaprakasu, A.I.R. 1990 A.P. 207.
Dr. Rashmi B. Fadnavis v. Mumbai Grahak Panchayat,(1998) 3 C.P.J. 21 (N.C.).
Dr. S.B. Jain v. Smt. Munnidevi,(1998) 2 C.P.J. 239 (Haryana S.C.D.R.C.).
Dr. Sr. Louie & Anr v. Kannolil Puthuma,(1993) 1 C.P.J. 30 (N.C.).
Dr. T.T. Thomas v. Elisa,A.I.R. 1987 Ker. 52.
Deshbir Verma v. The Hamirpur Co-operativeHouse Building Society Ltd.,(1996) 3 C.P.J. 165 (Himachalpradesh S.C.D.R.C.).
Devendra Kanthilal Nayak v. Dr. Kalyaniben Dhruv Shah(1997) 1 C.P.J. 103 (Gujarath S.C.D.R.C.).
xix
.. 48
253
66
25, 83
51
185
44, 181
39, 151
21, 26, 94,109
296
181
l27.Digvijaya Singh A. Zala v. Dr. Narendra T.Vani, .. 155(1995) 1 C.P.J. 186 (Gujarat S.C.D.R.C.).
128. Dilbagh Rai v. Housing Board Haryana, .. 296, 306, 316(1994) 3 C.P.J. 23 (N.C.).
129. Dilbagh Rai v. Housing Board Haryana, .. 326(1998) 2 C.P.J. 23 (N.C.).
130. Doerr v. Villate, -- 169220 N.E. Zd 767, Ill. 1966.
131. Donoghue v. Stevenson, .. 275[1932] All E.R. 1 (H.L.).
132. Downer v. Veilleux, .. 23322 A. 2d 82, 88 (Me. 1974).
133. Driver v. William Willet (Contractors) Ltd., .. 315[1969] 1 All E.R. 665.
134. Dunning v. Board of Governors of the UnitedLiverpool Hospitals, .. 213[1973] 2 All E.R. 454 (C.A.).
135. Dutton v. Bognor Regis United Building Co. Ltd., .. 315[1972] 1 A11E.R. 462 (C.A.).
136. Eames London Estates Ltd. v. North Hertfordshire D.C., .. 301[1980] 259 E.G. 491.
137. Edler v. Greenwich and Deptford Hospital Management .. 32Committee, (1953), Times, 7 March.
138. Edward Wong Finance Co.Ltd. v. Johnson Stokes and .. 261Masters, [1984] A.C. 296 (P.C.).
139. Emeh v. Kensington Chelsea West Minister Area Health .. 180Authority, [1986] 2 W.L.R. 233.
140. Equitable Debenture Assets Corporation v. William Moss, .. 305, 317[1984] 2 Con. L.R.1.
XX
Esso Petroleum Co. Ltd. v. Mardon[1976] 2 All E.R. 5 (C.A.).
Eyre v. Measday,[1986] 1 All E.R. 488 (C.A.).
F.v.R.,[1983] 33 S.A.S.R. 189.
F.v. West Berkshire Health Authority, ..[1989] 2 All E.R. 545 (H.L.).
F.G. Minter Ltd. v. Welsh Health Technical Services ..
7
Organisation, [1979] ll Build. L.R.l.
Faithful] v. Kesteven,[1910] 103 L.T. 56.
Farquar v. Murray,(1901) 3 F.(Ct. of Sess.) 859.
Fish v. Kapur,[1948] 2 All E.R. 176 (K.B.).
Flannagan v. Mate,(1876) 2 Vict. L.R. (Law) 157.
Fletcher & Son v. Jubb, Booth and Helliwell, ..[1920] 1 K.B. 275.
Florida Hotels Pvt. Ltd., v. Mayo,[1965] 113 C.L.R. 588.
Flynn v. Stearns,145 A. 2d 33, N.J. 1958.
Force Society v. M. Ganeswara Rao,(1997) 3 C.P.J. 228 (Andra Pradesh S.C.D.R.C.).
Fraser v. Vancour General Hospita[1952] 3 D.L.R. 785.
1,
xx
16
162
137
30, 101
315
281
38
176
305
259
300, 310
73
24, 107, 181
32
Freeborn v. Leeming, .. 32[1926] 1 K.B. 160
Freeman v. Home Office, .. 93[1984] 1 All E.R. 1036 (C.A.).
G. J ayaprakash v. State, .. 74A.I.R. 1977 A.P. 20.
G + K Ladenbau v. Crawley and De. Reya, ..271, 287[1978] 1 W.L.R. 266 (Q.B.).
Gaskin v. United Kingdom, .. 224[1989] 11 E H.R.R. 402.
Gerber v. Pines, .. 43(1934) 79 S.J. 13.
Giallinza v. Sands, .. 154316 So. 2d 77, Fla. 1975.
Gill v. Lougher, .. 272(1830) 1 C. & J. 170.
Gillette v. Tucker, .. 14965 N.E. 865, Ohio, 1902.
Gillick v. West Nortfolk and Wisbech Area Health .. 96Authority, [1985] 3 All E.R. 402 (H.L.).
Gloning v. Miller, .. 56[1954] 1 D.L.R. 372.
Gokul Prasad v. Emperor, .. 148A.I.R. 1930 All. 262.
Gold v. Essex County Council, .. 55[1942] 2 All E.R. 237 (C.A.).
Gold v. Haringey Health Authority, .. 133[1987] 2 All E.R. 888 (C.A.).
xxii
Goody v. Baring,[1956] 2 All E.R. 11 (Ch.D.).
Gopinathan v. Eskeycee Medical Foundation Pvt. Ltd., ..(1994) 1 C.P.J. 147 (N.C.).
Gordon v. Millar,(1838) 1 D.(Ct. of Sess.) 832.
Gramm v. Boener,56 Ind. 497, 1877.
[1992] 1 All E.R. 865 (Ch.D.).
[1975] 1 W.L.R. 1095 (C.A.).
Griffiths v. Evans,[1953] 2 All E.R. 1364 (C.A.).
Groom v. Crocker,[1939] 1 K.B. 194.
Guilment v. Campbell,188 N.W. 2d 601, Mich. 1971.
Haase v. Garfinkel,418 S.W.2d, 108, 114 (Mo. 1967)
Hall v. Lees,[1904] 2 K.B. 602.
Hall v. Meyrick,[1957] 1 All E.R. 208 (Q.B.).
Haluska v. University of Saskatchewan, ..[1965] 53 D.L.R. 436.
Hanley v. Spencer,115 P. 2d, Colo. 1941.
. Gran Gelato Ltd. v. Richcliff (Group) Ltd., ..
. Greaves & Co. v. Baynham Meikle,
xxiii
265
27
309
74
278
4, 297
282
16, 266
159
28
55
281
136
70
183. Harbans Singh v. Lucknow Development Authority, ..(1994) 1 C.P.J. 130 (N.C.).
184. Harjoth Ahluwalia v. M/s. Spring Meadows Hospital, ..(1997) 2 C.P.J. 9s (N.C.).
185. Harkies v. Lord Dufferin Hospital[1931] 66 D.L.R. 572.
186. Harris v. Newcastle Health Authority,[1989] 2 All E.R. 273 (Ch.D.).
187. Hatcher v. Black,(1954), Times, 29, 30 June, 1, 2, July.
188. Hatwell v. South-West Metropolitan Regional ..Hospital Board, (1976) Nov. 5, (C.A.).
189. Hawkins v. Clayton,[1988] 62 A.L.J.R. 240.
190. Hedley Byme Co. Ltd. v. Heller and Partners Ltd., ..[1963] 2 All E.R. 575 (H.L.).
191. Helling v. Carey,83 Wash. 2d 514,519 P.2d 981 (1974).
192. Henderson v. Henderson,[1955] 1 B.M.J. 672.
193. Heywood v. Wellers,[1976] 1 All E.R. 300 (C.A.).
194. Higgins v. Arfon Borough Council,[1975] 2 All E.R. 589 (Q.B.).
195. Hills v. Potter,[1983] 3 All E.R. 716 (Q.B.).
196. Hill v. Van Erp.,[1997] 71 A.L.J.R. 487.
xxiv
327
48, 50,58, 189
56
214
141
46
277
275, 323, 325
25
47
288
315
32, 120
276
Hoglin v. Brown,481 P.2d 458, Wash. 1971.
Holt v. Nesbitt,[1953] 1 D.L.R. 671.
Hopp v. Lepp,[1980] 112 D.L.R. 67.
Hothi v. Greenwich Health Authority,[1982] 2 Lancet 1474.
Hotson v. East Berkshire Area Health Authority, ..[1987] 2 All E.R. 909 (H.L.).
Hucks v. Cole,[1968] 118 N.L.J. 469.
Hunt v. Luck,[1902] 1 Ch.D. 428.
Hurley v. Eddingfield,59 N.E. 1058, Ind. 1901.
Hutchinson v. Harris,[1978] 10 Build. L.R. 19.
I.B.A.v. E.M.I. and B.I.C.C.,[1979] 11 Build. L.R. 29 (C.A.).
I.B.A.V. E.M.I. and B.I.C.C.,[1980] 14 Build. L.R. 1 (H.L.).
Ill. People v. Chrone,123 N.E. 291, 288 App. Div. 490
Incollingo v. Ewing,444, Pa. 263, 282 A. 2d, 206(l97l).
Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha, ..(1995) 6 S.C.C. 651.
XXV
78
56
116, 124
184
32, 179
22, 31
265
145
305, 322
298
298, 300
290
23
26, 107, 186
In Re A.,[1992] 3 Med. L.R. 303.
In Re B. Munnuswami Naidu,A.I.R. 1926 Mad. 568.
In Re C,[1994] 1 W.L.R. 290.
In Re Eve,[1981] 115 D.L.R. 283.
. In Re Gondika Sathyanarayana Murthy, A PleaderA.I.R. 1938 Mad. 965.
. In Re Johnson’s Estate,16 N.W. 2d 506, Neb. 1944.
In Re K. and Public Trustee,[1985] 19 D.L.R. 255.
In Re L.,[1992] 3 Med. L.R. 78.
In Re Prem Narain Advocate, Agra,A.I.R. 1940 All. 289.
In Re Ram Chandra Prasad Sinha,A.I.R. 1963 Patna 233.
In Re Wingfield and Blew,[1904] 2 Ch.D. 665.
In the Matter of An Advocate,A.I.R., 1935 Cal. 484.
Introvigne v. Commonwealth of Australia,[1980] 32 A.L.R. 251.
Invercagril C.C. v. Hamlin,[1994] 3 N. Z.L.R. 513.
xxvi
23
225.
226.
227.
228.
229.
230. Jarvis v. Moy, Davies, Smith, Vanderwell and Company, ..
231.
232.
233
234
235
237
238
6.
Investors in Industry Commercial Properties Ltd. v.South Bedfordshire D.C. [1986] 1 All E.R. 787 (C.A.)
Ishwar Das v. Vinayakumar Gupta,(1992) 2 C.P.J. 118 (N.C.).
J .N. Shrivastava v. Ram Bihari Lal,A.I.R. 1982 M.P.l32.
James v. Spear,338 P. 2d 22, Cal. 1959.
Jameson v. Simon,(1899) 1 F. (Ct. of Sess.) 1211.
[1936] 1 K.B. 399.
Jayendra Maganlal Padiya v. Dr. Lalith P. Trivedi,(1997) 1 C.P.J. 11 (Gujarath S.C.D.R.C.).
Jeffries v. Mc Cague,363 A. 2d 1167, Pa. 1976.
Johnson v.United States,271 F. Supp 205, D.C. Ark.1967.
Jones v. Manchester Corporation[1952] 2 All E.R. 125 (C.A.)
Joseph @ Animon v.Dr. Elizabeth Zacariah,(1997) 1 C.P.J. 96 (Kerala S.C.D.R.C)
Juggankhan v.The state,A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 831.
Junor v. McNicol,(1959), Times, 26 March.
K.N. Lal v.R.K. Akhuary,(1998) 3 C.P.J. 112 (Bihar S.C.D.R.C.).
xxvii
315, 317
57
82
252
310
16
33
117
71
55
182
17
22
35, 44
Kailashkumar Sharma v.Dr.Haricharan Mathur,(1997) 3 C.P.J. 41 (N.C.)
Kay v. Ayrshire and Arran Health Board,[l987]2 A11E.R. 417 (H.L.)
Kenyon v.Bel1,[1953] S.C.125 (Scotland case).
Kharaithilal v.Kewal Krishnan,(1998) 1 C.P.J. 181 (Punjab S.C.D.R.C.)
King v. King,[1987] 1 Lancent 991.
Kitchen v. Royal Air Forces Association,[1958]2 A1lE.R. 241 (C.A.).
Krishnan v. G. Rajan,1994 M.L.J (cr.) Mad. 731.
La Fluer v. Carnelis,(1979) 28 N.B.R. (2d) 569.
Lake v. Bushby,[l949]2 All E.R. 964 (K.B.)
Lanphier v. Phipos,(1838) 8 C. & P. 475
Lee v.Andrews,545 S.W. 2d 238, Tex. 1977.
Lee v. South West Thames Regional Health Authority,[1985] 2 All E.R. 385 (C.A.)
Lekh Raj v. Bharaj Nursing Home,(1998)2 C.P.J. 335 (Punjab S.C.D.R.C.).
Lim Poh Choo v.Camden and Islington Area HealthAuthority, [1979]2 All E.R. 910 (H.L.)
xxviii
196
178
179
47
49
286
98
161
264. 286
4, 21
41
213, 230
85
193
London Borough of Merton v.Lowe,[198l]18 Build L.R. 130
London Congregational Union Inc. v.Hariss & Hariss, ..[l985]l All E.R. 335 (Q.B.)
Losner v.Micheal Cohen & Co[1975] 119 S.J. 340.
Lucas v. Hamm,11 Cal. Rptr. 727 (1961).
M. Arunachala Vadivel v. Dr. N. Gopalkrishnan, ..(1992)2 C.P.J. 764 (Tamilnadu S.C.D.R.C.).
M. Jeeva v. Smt. Lalitha,(1994) 2 C.P.J. 73 (N.C.).
‘U
M.D. Aslam v. Ideal Nursing Home,(1997)3 C.P.J. 81 (.N.C.).
M.D. Bhoopathy v. Mrs. Sarada,[1996]l C.P.J. 168 (N.C.).
M/s Spring Meadows Hospital v. Harjoth Ahluwalia, ..(1998)1 C.P.J. 1(S.C.).
Maben v. Rankin,358 P.2d 681, Cal. 1961.
MacDonald v. Mclnermey[1990] 66 D.L.R. 736
Mahon v. Osbome,[1939]2 K.B. 14.
Mainfort v. Giannestras,111 N.E. 2d 692, Ohio. 1951.
Malyon v. Lawrance, Messer & Co.,[1968] 2 Lloyd’s Rep. 539.
xxix
317
300
272
278, 279
94
190
65, 182
295, 307
50, 58, 194
34
218
56, 197
75
287
Marshall v. Curry,[1933] 3 D.L.R. 260
Martin v. Bralliar,540 P. 2d 1118 (Colo. App. 1975).
Master Ashok Kumar v. Agadi Nursing Home,(1995)3 C.P.J. 142 (Kamataka S.C.D.R.C.).
Master P.M. Ashwin v. Manipal Hospital Bangalore,(l997)l C.P.J. 238 (Kamataka S.C.D.R.C.).
Mathew v. Maughold Life Assurance Co Ltd.,[1985]1 P.N. 142.
Maynard v. West Midlands R.H.A.,_[1985] 1 All E.R. 635 (H.L.).
Mazer v. Lipshutz,360 F.2d 275, C.C.A. 3, 1966.
McCormak v. Redpath,(1961), Times, 24 March.
McDermott v. Manhattan Eye, Ear Nose & ThroatHospital, 228 N.Y.S. 2d 143, 203, N.E. 2d 469, N.Y.
Mclnemey v. MacDonald,[1992] 93 D.L.R. 415
McLean v. Weir,[1980] C.A. 77 C, 785.
Mclvor v. Southem Health and Social Board,[1978] 2 All E.R. 625 (H.L.).
McNamara v. Martin Mears & Co.,[1983] 126 S.J. 69.
Meachem v. Mcleay,227 N.W. 2d 829, Neb. 1975.
XXX
1964
109
122
65
197
263
22, 30
88
35
126
217
117, 124
213
274
69
Mercer v. King,(1859) 1 F. & F. 490.
Midland Bank Trust Ltd. v. Hett, Stubbs & Kemp,[1978] 3 All E.R. 571 (Ch.D.).
Mitchel v. Dixon,[1914] App. D. 519.
Mitchell v. Hounslow and Spelthorne Health Authority,[1984] 1 Lancet 579.
Mohammad Ibrahim Mulla v. Hamid Aboobakar Memon(1996) 1 C.P.J. 28 (N.C.).
Mohr v. Williams,[1905] 104 N.W. 12.
Moneypenny v. Hartland,(1826) 2 Car. & P. 378.
Montriou v. Jefferies,(1895) 2 C. & P. 113.
Moore v. Lewisham Group Hospital ManagementCommittee, (1959), Times, 5 Feb.
Moresk Cleaners Ltd. v. Hicks,[1966] 2 Lloyds Rep. 338.
Morgan v. Sheppard,91 Ohio L. Abs. 579, 188 N.E. 2d 808 (1963).
Morrison v. Mckillop,563 P. 2d 220, Wash. 1977.
Morris v. Winsbuiy-White,[1937] 4 All E.R. 494 (K.B.).
Moulton v. Huckleberry,150 Or. 538, 546, 46 P. 2d 589, 592 (1932).
xxxi
273
256
34, 47
179
302
104
303
259
27
318
23
1 18
154
28
Mulloy v. Hop Sang,[1935] 1 W.W.R. 714.
Mumbai Grahak Panchayath v. Dr. Rashmi B. Fadnavis,(1998) 1 C.P.J. 49 (N.C.).
Muraleedharan Nair v. N. J. Antony,1985 K.L.T. 1.
Muralidhar Eknath Masane v. SushrushaCo-opertative Hospital Ltd.,(1995) 1 C.P.R. 606 (Maharastra S.C.D.R.C.).
Murphy v. Brentwood D.C.,[1990] 2 All E.R. 908 (H.L.).
Murray v. McMurchy,[1949] 2 D.L.R. 442.
Myers v. Elman,[1939] 4 A1lE.R. 484 (H.L.).
Natanson v Kline,354 P.2d 670, Kans. 1960.
National Consumer Protection Council v.Poorva Deep Corporation,(1997) 1 C. P.J. 497 (Gujarath S.C.D.R.C.).
Naylor v Preston Area Health Authority[1987]2 All E. R. 353 (C.A.)
Neushul v Mellish & Harkavy[1967] 11 S.J. 339.
Nickolls v Minister of Health and Another,(1955), Times, 4 Feb.
Nishi v. Hartwell,473 P.2d 116 (1970).
Nivrutui G. More v Dr. Vinayak Deshmukh,(1994) 2 C.T.J. 614 (Gujarath S.C.R.D.C.).
xxxii
103
170
148
38, 151
323
105
200
125
327
214
270
43
130
152
Nocton v Ash Burton,[1914] A. C. 932 (H.L.).
Noel v. Proud,Kan. 367 P.2d 61, 1962.
Nutbrown v. Sheffield Health Authority,[1993] 4 Med. L.R. 187.
O. Brain v. Cunnard S. S. Co.,28 N.E. 266 (Mass.1891).
Old School v. Gleeson (Contractors Ltd.),[1976] 4 Build. L. R. 103.
Oliver v. Brock, _342 So.2d 4 Ala. 1977.
O’ Malley Williams v Govemors of National Hospitalfor Nervous Diseases, [1975]1 B.M.J. 635.
Orissa State Housing Board v. ChandrasekharpurHousing Board, (1994)1 C.P.J. 109 (N.C.).
Otter v. Church Adams, Tatham & Co.,[1953] 1 Ch. D. 280.
P.P. Ismail v. Mrs. K.K. Radha,(l998)1 C.P.J. 16 (N.C.).
Page. v. Brodaff,169 A. 2d 901, Conn. 1961.
Parmanand Katara v. Union of India,A.I.R. 1989 S.C. 2039.
Parkell v. Fitzporter,256 S. W. 239, Mo. 1923.
Parslow v. Masters,[1993] 6 W.W. R. 273 (Sask. Q.B.).
xxxiii
Paschim Banga Khet Mazdoor Samity v.State of West Bengal, A.I.R. 1996 S.C. 2426.
Patrick v. Sedwick,391 P. 2d 453, 413 P.2d 169, Alaska 1964.
Payne v. St. Helier Group Hospital ManagementCommittee, (1952), Times, 12 November.
Pederson v. Dumouchel,431 P. 2d 976, Wash. 1967.
Pendergast v. Sam and Dee Ltd.,[1989] 1 Med. L.R. 36 (C.A.).
Pfizer Corporation v. Ministry of Health,[1965] 1 All E. R. 450 (H.L.). ‘
Philips India Ltd. v. Kunju Punnu,A.I.R. 1975 Bomb. 306.
Pilkington v. Wood,[1953] 2 All E. R. 810 (Ch.D.).
Planned Parenthood of Control Mo. v. Danforth,428 U.S. 52 (1976).
Poonam Medical Foundation Ruby Hall Clinic v.Maruti Rao L Titkare, (1995) 1 C.P.J. 232 (N.C.)
Poonam Verma v. Dr. Ashwin Patel,(1995) 1 C.P.J. ll (N.C.).
Poonam Verma v. Dr. Ashwin Patel,(1996) 4 S.C.C. 332.
Premnath Hospital v. Smt. Poonam Mangala,(1998) 2 C.P.J. 205 (Haryana S.C. D.R.C.).
Pretty v. Fowke,[1887] 3 T.L.R. 845.
xxxiv
147, 198
251
42
152
49
145
76
284, 289
97
225
68
190
80
287
Puffin Barger v. Day,24 Cal. Rrptr. 533, Cal. 1962.
R.v. Adomako,[1994] 3 All E. R. 79 (H.L.).
R.v. Architects Registration Tribunal Ex. P. Jaggar,[1945] 2 All E. R. 131(K.B.).
R.v. Bateman,[1925] A11 E. R. Rep. 45 (C.C.A.).
R. v. Higgins,[1948] 1K.B. 165
R.v. Mid Glamorgan Family Health Services Authority& Another, Exparte Martin, [1993] 1 Med.‘L.R. 378.
R.v. Mid Glamorgan Family Health Serivces Authority& Another, Exparte Martin, [1995] 1 A11E.R. 356 (C.A.)
R.v. Rymer,(1877) 2 Q.B. 136.
R. M. Joshi v. Dr. P.B. Thahilramami,(1993) 3 C.P.J. 1265 (Maharastra S.C.D.R.C.).
Rajasthan Housing Board v. Dr. Veer Singh Mehta,(1997) 1 C.P.J. 66 (N.C.).
Rajkumar Agrawal v. Dr. B. Mukhupadhyay,(1995) 1 C.P.J. 260 (Bihar S.C.D.R.C.).
Rambihari Lal v. J .N. Shrivatsava,A.I.R. 1985 M.P. 150.
Ramp v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Co.,269 So. 2d 239, 244 (La. 1972) '
Reibel v. Hughes,[1980] 114 D.L.R. 1.
XXXV
73
51
294
21, 42, 201
148
210
209, 212
148
189
321, 322
27
73
268
115,117,124,127,131
Reiner v. Grossman, .. 164107 Cal. Rptr. 469, Cal. 1973.
Rewis v. United State,536 F. 2d 594, C.C.A. 5, 1976.
Riaz Ahamad Sharif Khan v. Babu Mustafa Khan, .. 249, 266, 274(1998) 3 C.P.J. 559 (Maharastra S.C.D.R.C.).
Rishworth v. Moss,(1913)159 S.W. 122.
Robinson v. The Post Office,[1974] 2 All E.R. 737 (C.A.).
Rochester v. Katalan,320 A. 2d 505, 704 Md. 1974.
Roe v. Minister of Health,[1954] 2 All E. R. 131 (C.A.).
Rogers v. Lawson,170 F. 2d 157, D.C. C.A., 1948
Rogers v. Whittakar,[1992] 175 C.L.R. 479.
Ross v. Caunters,[1979] 3 All E. R. 580 (Ch.D.).
Russel v. Palmer,(1767) 2 Wilson 325.
.. 36
.. 98
49, 176
67
22, 76, 183
167
31, 117, 123,127
275
l5
S. Ramaswamy v. Centre Point, .. 327(1997) l C.P.J. 113 (Karnataka S.C.D.R.C.).
S. P. Dhavaskar v. The Hosuing Commissioner ..Karnataka Housing Board, (1996) l C.P.J. 65 (N.C.).
Sabapathy v. Huntley,[1938] 1 W.W.R. 817.
299
35
Salinetro v. Nystrom,341 So. 2d 1059, Fla. 1977.
Samuels v. Davis,[1943] 1 K.B. 526.
Sanjaynagar Residents Welfare Association v.The Vice Chairman, G.D.A., (1995) 2 C.P.J. 58 (N.C.)
Sankaranarayana Pillai v. Executive Officer,A.I.R. 1966 Mad. 262.
Sanzari v. Rosenfield,167 A. 2d 625, N. J. 1961.
Sau Madhuri v. Dr. Rajendra,(1996) 3 C.P.J. 75 (N.C.). ‘
Savage v. Board of School Trustees,[1951] 3 D.L.R. 39.
Sealand of the Pacific v. Robert C. McHaffie,[1974] 51 D.L.R. 702.
Sethuraman Subramaniam Iyer v. Triveni NursingHome, (1998) 1 C.P.J. 10 (N.C.).
Shibu v. St. Joseph,(1995) 3 C.P.R. 177 (Kerala S.C.D.R.C.).
Shivaji Gendeo Chavan v. Wanless Hospital,(1995) 3 C.P.J. 43 (Maharastra S.C.D.R.C.).
Sidaway v. Board of Governors of Bethlem RoyalHospital and the Maudsley Hospital,[1985] 1 All E. R. 643 (H.L.).
Simmons v. Health Laundry Co.,[1910] 1 K.B. 543.
Simmons v. Pennington & Sons,[1955] 1 All E.R. 240 (C.A.).
xxxvfi
54
163
296. 326
2, 3
53
56, 194
304
296
52, 68
45
189
22, 30, 119,120, 130,139211
187
260, 284
Sinclair v. Victoria Hospital,[1943] 1 D.L.R. 302.
Skodge v. Hardey,288 P.2d 471, Wash. 1955.
Sky Pak Agency v. K.K. Pillai(1995) 1 C.P.J. lO6(Kerala S.D.R.C.).
Slater v. Baker and Stapleton,(1767) 2 Wills 359.
Smart v. Kansas City,105 S.W. 709, Mo. 1907.
Smith v. Barking Havering and BrenthoodHealth Authority, [1994] 5 Med. L.R. 285. ..
Smith v. Brighton and Lewes Hospital ManagementCommittee, [I958], Times, 2 May.
Smith v. Rae,[1919] 51 D.L.R. 323.
Smith v. Shankman,25 Cal. Rptr. 195, Cal. 1962.
Smt. Rita Roy v. Shyamali Chug,(1998) 1 C.P.J. 438 (West Bengal S.C.D.R.C.).
Smt. Rohini Pritam Kabadi v. Dr. R.T. Kulkarni, ..(1996) 3 C.P.J. 441 (Karnataka S.C.D.R.C.).
Sparham - Souter v. Town and County Developments[Essex] Ltd., [1976] 2 All E. R. 65 (C.A.). ..
Stack v. Wapner,368 A. 2d 292, Pa. 1976.
State of M.P. v. Dr. Barthi Patider,(1995) Cr. L.R. 243 (M.P.).
xxxviii
56
165
258
101
157
128
183
42, 169
34
306
56
315
251
52
Stevens v. Bermondsey and Southwark GroupHospital Management Committee,[1963] 107 S. J. 478.
Stinchombe & Cooper Ltd. v. Addison, Cooper,Jessen & Co., [1971] 115 S.J..
Stirling v. Poulgrain,[1980] 2 N.Z.L.R. 402.
Stohlman v. Davis,220 N. W. 247, Neb. 1928.
Strangways v. Clayton,[1936] 2 K.B.11.
Stronghold Investments Ltd. v. Renlcema,[1984] 7 D.L.R. 427.
Strongman v. Sincock,[1955] 3 Al1E.R. 90 (C.A.).
Subhlatha v. Christian Medical College,(1995) 1 C.P.J. 365 (Punjab S.C.D.R.C.).
Suburban Hospital Association v. Mewhinney,187 A. 2d 671, Md. 1963.
Sushil Kumar Gupta v. Housing Board,(1996) 2 C.P.J. 479 (Chandigarh S.C.D.R.C.).
Sutcliffe v. Thackrah,[1974] 1 All E.R. 859 (H.L.).
Sutherland v. Public Trustee,[1980] 2 N.Z.L.R. 536.
. Suvarna Baljekar v. Rohit Bhatt,(1996) 2 C.P.J. 75 (N.C.).
Sykes v. Midland Bank Executor & Trustee Co. Ltd[1971] 1Q.B. 113.
xxxix
185
266, 285
256
153
50
263
308
68
168
326
311, 119
283
181
269, 285
Sylvia v. Gobeille,220 A. 2d 222, R.I. 1966.
T. Rama Rao v. Vijaya Hospitals,(1997) 2 C.P.J. 177 (Tamilnadu S.C.D.R.C.).
T.v.T,[1988] 1 All E.R. 613.
Tapan Kumar Nayak v. State of Orissa,[1997] 2 C.P.J. 14 (N.C.).
Tefft v. Wilcox,6 Kan. 46 (1870).
Thake v. Maurice,[1984] 2 All E. R. 513 (Q.B.).
Thake v. Maurice,[1986] 1 All E. R. 497 (C.A.).
The General Consumer Protection and WelfareAssociation v. Gaziabad Development Authority,(1995) 1 C.P.J. 158 (N.C.).
Todd v. Eithel,237 N. W. 2d 357 (Minn. 1975).
Tomarino Marcel D’cruz v. Management ofSt. Joseph’s Boys Higher Secondary School,(1998) 1 C.P.J. 340 (Tamil Nadu S.C.D.R.C.).
Toth v. Common Hospital at Glen Cove,239 N.E. 2d 368 (1968).
Townsend (Builder) Ltd. v. Cinema NewsProperty Management,[1982] 20 Build. L.R. 118.
Truman v. Thomas,611 P. 2d 902, Cal. 1980.
xl
170
226
111
182
160
158,160
132,161
296
28
86, 108
29
308
142
Tyrer v. District Auditor of Monmouthshire,[1974] 230 E.G. 973.
Unreported case, The Week, Jan 8-14 (1989).
Urbanski v. Patel,[1978] 84 D.L.R. 650.
Usha v. G.P. Nambiar,1985 K.L.T. 970 (D.B.).
V.L. Bhanu Kumar v. Dega Sundara Rama Reddy,(1996) 1 C.P.J. 278 (N.C.).
V.S. Shukla v. Brijesh Kumar Dwivedi,(1997) 3 C.P.J. 334 (Madhya Pradesh S.C.D.R.C.)
Variety Children’s Hospital v. Osle,292 So. 2d 382, Fla. 1974.
Veerabrahmachari v. B Venkateswara Rao,(1997) 1 C.P.J. 147 (Andhra Pradesh S.C.D.R.C.).
Venkatesan v. Fusion Constructions,(1,998) 1 C.P.J. 177 (Tamilunadu S.C.D.R.C.).
Victoria Laundry (Windsor) Ltd. v. New ManIndustries Ltd., [1949] 2 K.B. 528.
Vidrine v. Mayes,127 So. 2d 809, La. 1961.
Victoria University of Manchester v. Hugh Wilson[1984] 2 Con. L.R. 43.
Vinitha Ashok v. Laxshmy Hospital,(1992) 2 C.P.J. 372 (N.C.).
Voli v. Inglewood Shire Council,[1963] A.L.R. 657.
Waliati Ram v. Ruper Municipality,A.I.R. 1960 Punj. 669.
xli
, OI
305
202
58
85
297, 309
274
156, 165
290
309
182
165
314
27, 83, 124, 129
299, 313
..4
Walker v. Boyle,[1982] 1 All E.R. 634 (Ch.D.).
Wall v. Brim,138 F. 2d 478, C.C.A. 5., 1943.
Weintraub v. Rosen,93 F. 2d 544, C.C.A. 7, 1937.
Welfare Association ‘E’ Block Gaziabad v. GaziabadDevelopment Authority, (1995) 2 C.P.J. 29 (N.C.).
VVhite v. Jones,[1995] 1 All E.R. 691 (H.L.).
Whitefield v. Whittakar Memorial\Hospital,169 S. E. 2d 563, Va. 1969.
Whiteford v Hunter,[1950] W. N. 553 (H.L).
White House v. Jordon[1981] 1 All E. R. 267 (H. L.).
VVhittingham v. Craease and Co.,[1979] 88 D.L.R. 353.
Wilsher v. Essex A. H. A.,[1986] 3 All E. R. 801 (C. A.)
Wilsher v. Essex Area Health Authority,[1988] 1 Al1E.R 871 (H. L.).
Wilson v. Pringle,[1986] 2 All E. R. 440 (C.A.).
Wilson v. Tucker,[1822] 3 Stark 154.
Winnipeg Condominium Corporation No. 36 v. BirdConstruction, [1995] 121 D. L. R. 193.
xlii
269
1 16
86
297, 31 1
275
52
77
30, 78, 280
275
22
178
100
270
324