Post on 12-Jul-2020
transcript
3rd IPv6 Task Force Meeting
IPv6 Strategy
CITCNovember 18th, 2008
Agenda
Recap of Previous Task Force Meetings
Objective of Meeting
Previous Studies’ Findings IPv6 Current State Assessment
IPv6 Countries Benchmark Study
IPv6 International Organizations and Bodies
IPv6 Strategy Development Methodology
IPv6 Proposed StrategyObjectives
Strategy Tracks
Milestones & Timeline
Questions and Discussions
What is Next?
Recommendations2
Recap of Previous Meetings
3
Kick-off meeting of the National IPv6 Task Force (30, July 2008)
2nd Task Force meeting (21, September 2008)
Attendants: CITC, STC, ITC, Mobily, KACST and Bayanat
Presentation of the CITC IPv6 Subproject to FBPs
Preliminary Findings of the IPv6 Current State Assessment Study
Presentation on the initial draft and elements of the IPv6 Strategy
Questions and Discussions
Previous Studies Findings
IPv6 Current State Assessment
4
IPv6 Current State Assessment
5
Available
Free Space
RIRs
LIRs
ISPs
End Users
IPv4 Address Delegation Hierarchy RIRs Geographical Scope
August 2008: 88 LIRs in KSA(Source: RIPE NCC)
IPv6 Current State Assessment
6
Total IPv4 Space Distribution As of June 2008(256 /8 Blocks)
35 Unavailable Blocks:Experimental(16),Multicast(16), ,Loopback(1),Local Identification(1),Private Use(1)
91 Blocks distributed by central registry before 1998
94 Blocks allocated by IANA to RIRs
Only 36 free unallocatedblocks at IANA
Source: Number Resource Organization (NRO) and IANAhttp://www.nro.net/statistics/index.html
IPv4 Address Space Status
IPv6 Current State Assessment
7
IPv4 Depletion Predictions at IANA and RIRs
Source:
“The IPv4 Address Report”
By Geoff Huston
http://www.potaroo.net/tools/ipv4/
As of Nov. 2008:
Projected Depletion date at IANA:
February 2011
Projected Depletion date at RIRs:
March 2012
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
IANA Depletion
Feb. 2011
RIRs Depletion
March 2012
Today
Today
IPv6 Current State Assessment
8
2.17 Million IPv4 Addresses –July 2008
73% Advertised
0.08 IPv4 Address Per Capita(Source: http://resources.potaroo.net/iso3166/v4cc.html)
IPv4 Status Locally
IPv6 Status: Only: KACST (2001:1490::/32) & STC (2001:16a0::/32)(Source: RIPE NCC)
Date Size LIR Date Size LIR
20080625 /14 STC 20050428 /16 Bayanat
20050209 /15 Arabic Com. Sys 20050905 /16 STC
20060523 /15 Nesma 20061208 /16 STC
20080131 /15 STC 20070719 /16 AL Faisaliah
19990128 /16 KACST 20071228 /16 Ettihad Etisalat
20030820 /16 Orbitnet 20080218 /16 Ogertel
49152
270336 307200 348416
372992 482560
633088
1003520
1387008
1687552
2177280
0
500000
1000000
1500000
2000000
2500000
1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
IPv4 Cumulative Status KSAAs of July 2008 - RIPE NCC
Biggest IPv4 Allocations
/14 block equates to 262,144 IPs
/15 block equates to 131,072 IPs
/16 block equates to 65,536 IPs
IPv6 Current State Assessment
9
0
500000
1000000
1500000
2000000
2500000
3000000
3500000
4000000
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Pre-Depletion Phase< Oct. 2010
Depletion PhaseOct. 2010 – Oct. 2011
Post -Depletion Phase> Oct. 2011
KSA Allocation Forecast: 2008-2012 Linear Regression based on past data from: 2004-2008. Assumptions: Same growth, no acceleration/deceleration
Actual IPv4 Allocation Status
Linear Forecast of IPv4 Allocation (2012)
IPv6 Current State Assessment
10
S-curve trend of Internet Penetration of KSA (Internet Service Development Phase I Project) along with IPv4 address allocation forecast for 2008-2012
Actual IPv4 Allocation Status
Linear Forecast of IPv4 Allocation (2012)
S-Curve Trend KSA Internet Penetration
IPv6 Current State Assessment - Methodology
11
Questionnaires
•Questions Covered:
•Infrastructure IPv6 Status
•IPv6 Addressing
•Business case and economic drivers
•IPv6 Knowledge and Training
•Participation in IPv6 bodies
Workshop with FBPs
• Presentation of the CITC IPv6 Project
• Discussions and Questions
• Preliminary feedback
ISD Phase I Findings
• Findings related to:
• KSA Internet Infrastructure
• Consumer findings and internet growth
CITC Devoteam Discussions
• Periodic meetings and discussions to steer and align the different inputs
FBPs
Assessment
Other Stakeholders Assessment Methodology
ISPs, Enterprise Questionnaires
SaudiNIC .sa cc TLD Direct Meetings with the DNS experts
SW/HW Vendors Information from official online homepages
Methodology for FBPs
IPv6 Current State Assessment - FBPs
12
Question Results Question Results
Level of IPv6 Knowledge 2 In-Depth2 Medium1 Basic
Inclusion of IPv6 compliance in SW/HW Procurement
1 Yes3 No1 Partly
IPv6 Addressing Status Only 2 out of 5:KACST (advertised) &STC (not advertised)
IPv6 Training Plans 1 Yes Ongoing2 Near Future (2008-2010)2 No Plans
IPv6 Upstream Status 1 Yes (KACST)4 No
Economic Drivers and Value Added to Business
2 Yes3 No Assessment
IPv6 Peering Readiness 1 Yes (KACST)4 No
Critical to Future Business Activity
1 Not Critical4 No Assessment
OS Support for IPv6 2 Partly2 Supported but feature notenabled1 No assessment
Most Important Obstacle towards IPv6 Deployment
All:No Market Demand
Applications Support for IPv6
2 Partly3 No assessment
Membership in IPv6Bodies, WGs or Forums
5 No
Plans to offer connectivity for end users
1 ongoing, 1 already available, 1 no plans1 near future initiation (2008-9-10), 1 dist. Fut. >2011
Willingness to participatein the National IPv6 Task Force
3 Active Participation2 Only Attendance
Questionnaires were sent to 8 FBPs and KACST. Four (4) FBPs and KACST answered.
IPv6 Current State Assessment – Other Stakeholders
13
Stakeholder Status Assessment
ISPs and Enterprise
No interestOnly 3/62 ISPs answered QuestionnairesNo Consideration for IPv6No Future PlansNo IPv6 Addressing
-Not ready
SaudiNICcc .sa TLD Registry
No IPv6 Transport Support yetThe necessary software andprocess changes to add IPv6 GlueRecords into the DNS zone havebeen implemented in July/August2008 already
-Not Fully Compliant
-Work is Ongoing
SW/HW Vendors
Major vendors are already shipping IPv6 within their products
-Major Vendors are ready
Assessment of other stakeholders: ISPs, Enterprise, .sa ccTLD Registry (SaudiNIC), SW/HW Vendors
Previous Studies Findings
IPv6 Countries Benchmark
14
IPv6 Countries Benchmark (Methodology)
15
Research Worldwide IPv6 Deployment
Countries Selection
Countries Assessment
Lessons Learned
Resources
•Global IPv6 Forum Contacts
•National IPv6 Forum Chapters Worldwide
•ICT Ministries and Regulators Official Websites
•National Internet Registries
•ICANN, IANA, RIRs
•Worldwide IPv6 Summits, Conferences and Seminars
•ITU, OECD
•Geoff Huston Online IPv4/IPv6 Reports
Selection Criteria
•Criticality of IPv4 Exhaustion
•Maturity
•Governance
•Three Classes of Countries
•Established: Japan, Korea, Taiwan, China
•Recent: USA, India, Malaysia
•Just Started: Australia, Thailand, Hong Kong, Germany
Assessment Criteria
•Governmental Initiatives
•Commercial Offerings
•Promotional and Awareness Activities
•R&D and Technical Activities
•Extract Lessons Learned
Categories of Lessons
•Regulatory
•Commercial
•Promotional
• R&D, Technical
IPv6 Countries Benchmark (Lessons Learned)
16
Lesson Learned Impact Lesson Learned Impact
Role of IPv6 Plans Owner Promoter and Facilitator: All Countries, raise awareness and encourage deploymentEnforcer: USA, only to Federal Agencies
e-Gov adoption of IPv6 Creates demand for IPv6 and drives stakeholders dealing with e-Gov to adapt IPv6
Inclusion of IPv6 into major ICT initiatives
Including IPv6 into major ICT initiatives is the fastest and most efficient way of promoting IPv6
IPv6 Test BedsIPv6 R&D, R&E Networks
Chance for stakeholders to connect, build IPv6 technical experience, train staff and try equipment without endangering their production networks
IPv6 Specific Initiatives and Promotion Plans
Specifically targets IPv6 deployment instead of being a part of a greater plan as mentioned above
IPv6 into Procurement Policies
Creates demand for IPv6 capable SW/HW
Inclusion of IPv6 Compliance into the normal IT Cycle of Stakeholders
Minimizes risks and costs of a sudden migration and thus insuring a “smooth” adoption of IPv6
Training and HR IPv6 training is essential to nurture the needed IPv6 technical personnel and expertise.
IPv6 expertise is rare
National IPv6 Task Force Gathers different stakeholders, solidifies efforts, serves as an IPv6 knowledge platform, establishes contacts with international IPv6 organizations such as the IPv6 Forum
IPv6 R&D Funding R&D funding would foster know-how expertise and help establish the needed IPv6 expertise (in addition to training)
Previous Studies Findings
IPv6 International Bodies and Organizations
17
IPv6 International Organizations and Bodies
18
Standardization
• IETF
• ISOC
• Others
Address Management
• ICANN
• IANA
• RIRs
• Others
Awareness & Promotional
• IPv6 Forum
• IPv6 Portal
• MENOG
• AP IPv6 TF
• Others
R&D –Deployment
Projects
• 6Net
• SixXS
• Others
AssessmentRecommendations to join/follow up
Assessment Criteria
• IPv6 Role• Membership
Structure• Geographical
Scope• Relevance to KSA
Recommendations
Examples
• Join RIPE IPv6 Mailing List
• Join IETF IPv6 WG Mailing List
• Attend RIPE NCC Meeting Oct. 2008
Organizations and Bodies Categories
Proposed IPv6 Strategy
19
IPv6 Strategy Development Methodology
20
IPv6 Current State
Assessment
IPv6 Countries
Benchmark
IPv6 International Bodies and
Organizations
Findings, Conclusions and
Recommendations
IPv6 Proposed Strategy
CITC Devoteam Internal
Discussions
The Methodology for developing the IPv6 Proposed Strategy made use of inputs from the IPv6 current state assessment, the benchmark study and the international organizations and bodies study
Proposed Objectives &Strategy Tracks
21
Strategy Objectives
•Prepare for the IPv4 exhaustion bysupporting IPv6 and ensure stability,business continuity and room forcontinued growth of the internet in SaudiArabia
•Ensure a smooth adaption of IPv6 bystakeholders so as to minimize risks
•Raise overall IPv6 awareness nationwideby approaching stakeholders of both thepublic and private sectors highlighting thenecessecity to adopt IPv6
Infrastructure
•Five (5) Initiatives:
•IPv6 Addressing
•IPv6 Commercial Support for Nation Wide Infrastructure
• .SA ccTLD IPv6 Compliance
•IPv6 Compliant Internet Filtering
•IPv6 Lab
Awareness
•Five (5) Initiatives:
•IPv6 Task Force
•Outreach Activities
•International Cooperation
•IPv6 Training
•IPv6 Compliant Procurement
Strategy Tracks
Infrastructure TrackIPv6 Addressing
22
Only two (2) LIRs have acquired IPv6 address blocks from RIPE NCC:
1. KACST: 2001:1490::/3206/2003Advertised
2. STC: 2001:16a0::/3212/2003Not-Advertised
Source: RIPE NCC
IANA
RIPE NCC
LIRs
ISPs, End Users
IPv6 Address Delegation
Service Providers to decide IPv6 Address blocks size based on their future needs
If the service provider is not an LIR, it should request IPv6 addressing from its upstream provider
Currently no IPv6 Provider Independent (PI) Addressing in RIPE Region
The objective of this initiative is for Service Providers to acquire IPv6 Address Blocks
Important PointsLocal IPv6 Address Status
Infrastructure TrackIPv6 Commercial Support for Nationwide Infrastructure
IPv6 Internet
FBP2IGWs
ISPs
23
The objective of this initiative is for ServiceProviders to provide commercial IPv6services through:
-FBPs to implement IPv6 in their Networks
-FBPs to acquire IPv6 Upstream Service
-FBPs to Implement IPv6 in Future Peering
-FBPs to implement IPv6 in theirapplications/services
FBPs support for IPv6 is essential for regular ISPs to connect to the IPv6 internet
ISPs
ISPs
ISPs
ISPs
ISPs
Upstream International SPs –Outside KSA
FBP1IGWs
FBP3IGWs
Regular ISPs
Infrastructure Track.SA ccTLD IPv6 Compliance
.SA ccTLD IPv6 Capable
IPv6 .SA Internet Content
FBPs, ISPs
Local End Users
Step 1.SA IPv6 Content Request
Step2Request IPv6 Address
Step 3Reply with IPv6 Address
Step4.SA IPv6 Content RequestStep5
Receive IPv6 .SA Page
Step6DeliverIPv6 .SA Page
24
The objective of this initiative is for SaudiNIC to prepare the .sa cc TLD to be IPv6 ready
Infrastructure TrackIPv6 Compliant Internet Filtering
25
The objective of this initiative is for Service Providers to implement IPv6 Internet Filtering by realizing both of an:
- IPv6 Ready WWW Content Filter
- IPv6 Ready Access Lists Filter
FBPs
IPv6Internet
ISPs, Local End Users
IPv6 WWW
Content Filter
IPv6 Access List
Filter
Infrastructure TrackIPv6 Lab
IPv6 Test LabFBPs, ISPs,
IPv6 Labs, etc
- Open for FBPs/ISPs to connect
- IPv6 Upstream Connectivity
-Build IPv6 Experience
- Disseminate and Publish Experience Online
IPv6 Upstream
26
The objective of this initiative is for Service Providers to connect to IPv6 Lab and build IPv6 Experience
Awareness TrackIPv6 Task Force Establishment
Raise Awareness
•IPv6 Workshops
•IPv6 Summits
•Liaison with IPv6 Forum
Gather Stakeholders
•FBPs
•ISPs
•Government Sector and Ministries
•Private Sector
•Academy
Encourage Deployment
•Repository of IPv6 Knowledge
•Dissemination of IPv6 Experience
•Policies, Procedures and Guidelines
27
The objective of this initiative is to establish an IPv6 Task Force that will own and drive the National IPv6 Strategy.
•CITC
•STC
•Mobily
•Bayanat
•ITC
•Atheeb
•KACST
•ZAIN
•Devoteam
IPv6 Task Force Scope of Activities IPv6 Task Force Members
Awareness TrackOutreach Activities
Media
IPv6 TF
Website
International
Dissemination
28
The objective of this initiative is for raise awareness of all stakeholders to encourage the deployment of IPv6 nationwide.
NewspapersTVsOnline Media Outlets
Publish Plans, IPv6 Knowledge, Announce Events and other Activities
Liaison with Global IPv6 Forum, Regional Forums and International events
IPv6 policies, procedures guidelines and other IPv6 knowledge
Awareness TrackInternational Cooperation
RIPE
•IPv6 Address Policy Mailing List
•IPv6 WG
IETF•IETF v6
Operators mailing list
MENOG•MENOG
Mailing List
APNIC
& APRICOT
29
IPv6
Forum
Regional Forums
Asia Pacific
TF
-UAE-Egypt-Tunisia
Technical Cooperation Non-Technical Cooperation
The objective of this initiative is share IPv6 experience with international IPv6 bodies and establish Saudi Arabia’s presence in relevant IPv6 international organizations
Awareness TrackIPv6 Training
IPv6 Task Force
Service Providers
Universities
Colleges
Training Institutions
- Work with universities, colleges and commercial training institutions to bring IPv6 to their curriculum
- IPv6 Training Plan contents to be developed
- Very important to make sure IPv6 skilled engineers are available in 2011 when IPv4 runs out and IPv6 will become unavoidable
30
The objective of this initiative is to enhance the training curricula and programs to cover IPv6
Awareness TrackIPv6 Compliant Procurement
Vendors
Supply/DemandOf
IPv6 Capable Equipment
31
IPv6 CompliantIT Procurement
Policies
The objective of this initiative is to highlight the importance that stakeholders include IPv6 compliance in SW/HW procurement
FBPs
e-Gov
ISPs
Enterprise
All Stakeholders
Milestones & Timeline
Milestone Why? Suggested Date Alternative
IPv6 at ONE FBPs Essential and Enough to start offering IPv6 to ISPs and End Users
Early 2009 Universal Service Provider Act –STC to offer IPv6 Connectivity by Mid-2009
IPv6 Task Force Saudi Arabia Essential to raise awareness and encourage deployment
End of 2008 Already Established
Establish an IPv6 Lab Establish and Disseminate practical IPv6 Experience
End of 2008 Installation on track
IPv6 National Event Raise awareness and encourage the IPv6 deployment
Early 2009 Preliminary Agendas and tentative date (Feb 9, 2009)
IPv6 at Multiple FBPs Important for ISPs and End Users to have more than one Choice
End of 2009 CITC Legislative Measure and/or Financial Incentives
IPv6 Compliant.SA ccTLDRegistry
Essential to run IPv6-only hosts or an IPv6-only infrastructure
End of 2009 Regulatory measures and/or “Universal Services Fund” tohire experts to implement DNSv6 (mid-2010)
Commercial IPv6 Services available from Five (5) ISPs
More choices to end users End of 2010 Regulatory measures and/or “Universal Services Fund” tohelp ISPs adopt IPv6
322008 2009 2010 2011
IPv6 Task Force EstablishmentIPv6 Lab
IPv6 Support at Multiple FBPsIPv6 Compliant .sa cc TLD
Commercial IPv6 Services at Five (5) ISPs
IPv6 available at one FBPIPv6 National Event
Questions and Discussions
Feedback on Strategy
Finalization of Proposed IPv6 Strategy
33
What is Next?
IPv6 4th Task Force Meeting (Jan 2009)
– Sponsorship Volunteers for the Meeting are Welcomed!!
– Tentative Agenda:Technical Presentation
Break
FBPs to present 5 minutes updates on their IPv6 activities
Discussions – Q&A
– Propose Topics to be Discussed
34
What is Next?
IPv6 National Event (Tentative Feb 9, 2009)
– Tentative date: 1 Day event
– Agenda to be distributed soon
– Invite Local Stakeholders: Service Providers, Governmental Sector and Ministries, Private Sector, Academia and others
– Invite local, regional and international IPv6 groups and experts
– Event to cover awareness IPv6 topics
35
What is Next?
Documents to be Finalized and Distributed:
– IPv6 Status Quo and Readiness Assessment
– IPv6 International Countries Benchmark
– IPv6 International Bodies and Organizations
– IPv6 Strategy for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
– IPv6 Policies, Procedures and Guidelines
36
Recommendations and Actions
FBPs to Commit to the IPv6 Strategy and Speed Up IPv6 Deployment
FBPs to Acquire Needed IPv4 Address Space
FBPs to Actively Participate in IPv6 Task Force Activities 4th Task Force Meeting (Jan 2009)
IPv6 National Event (Feb 2009)
FBPs to Support IPv6 in Infrastructure Start Acquiring IPv6 Address Space
Networks, Services and Applications
IPv6 Internet Filtering (WWW Content - Access List Filtering)
DNSv6
Connect to future IPv6 Test Lab
IPv6 Task Force to Meet with the e-Gov Program (Yesser) and Address the Importance of IPv6 Adoption
37
IPv6 Strategy for KSA
Thank You!
38