Post on 10-Feb-2020
transcript
Neuromodulator-Evoked Synaptic Metaplasticity within a Central Pattern Generator Network 1
2
Mark D. Kvarta1,2, Ronald M. Harris-Warrick1 and Bruce R. Johnson1 3
4
1Department of Neurobiology and Behavior, S.G. Mudd Hall, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 5
14853 USA 6
2Current Address: Department of Physiology, Program in Neuroscience, Medical Scientist 7
Training Program, University of Maryland School of Medicine, 655 W. Baltimore Street 8
Baltimore MD 21201 9
10
Abbreviated Title: Metaplasticity at a graded chemical synapse 11
12
Corresponding Author: 13
Bruce R. Johnson 14
Department of Neurobiology and Behavior, S.G. Mudd Hall, Cornell University 15
Ithaca, NY 14853 USA 16
Telephone: 607-254-4323 17
FAX: 607-254-1303 18
E-Mail: brj1@cornell.edu 19 20
Articles in PresS. J Neurophysiol (August 29, 2012). doi:10.1152/jn.00586.2012
Copyright © 2012 by the American Physiological Society.
2
21 Abstract 22 23 Synapses show short-term activity-dependent dynamics that alter the strength of neuronal 24
interactions. This synaptic plasticity can be tuned by neuromodulation as a form of 25
metaplasticity. We examined neuromodulator-induced metaplasticity at a graded chemical 26
synapse in a model central pattern generator (CPG), the pyloric network of the spiny lobster 27
stomatogastric ganglion. Dopamine, serotonin and octopamine each produce a unique motor 28
pattern from the pyloric network, partially through their modulation of synaptic strength in the 29
network. We characterized synaptic depression and its amine modulation at the graded PDLP 30
synapse, driving the PD neuron with both long square pulses and trains of realistic waveforms 31
over a range of presynaptic voltages. We show that the three amines can differentially affect the 32
amplitude of graded synaptic transmission independently of the synaptic dynamics. Low 33
concentrations of dopamine had weak and variable effects on the strength of the graded synaptic 34
potentials (gIPSPs), but reliably accelerated the onset of synaptic depression and recovery from 35
depression independently of gIPSP amplitude. Octopamine enhanced gIPSP amplitude but 36
decreased the amount of synaptic depression; it slowed the onset of depression and accelerated 37
its recovery during square pulse stimulation. Serotonin reduced gIPSP amplitude but increased 38
the amount of synaptic depression, and accelerated the onset of depression. These results 39
suggest that amine-induced metaplasticity at graded chemical synapses can alter the parameters 40
of synaptic dynamics in multiple and independent ways. 41
42
43
44
45
Key words: graded synaptic transmission; synaptic depression; lobster pyloric neurons; 46
dopamine, serotonin, octopamine 47
48
3
Introduction 49
50 Short-term synaptic dynamics, such as facilitation and depression, alter synaptic strength 51
in activity-dependent ways (Abbott and Regehr 2004). Synaptic dynamics have been studied 52
most extensively at synapses using action potential-evoked transmitter release (Fioravante and 53
Regehr 2011; Fisher et al. 1997; Thomson, 2000; Zucker and Regehr 2002). Transient, activity-54
dependent changes in synaptic strength can alter synaptic transmission to increase the response 55
to novel stimuli, enhance directional sensitivity, adapt to repeated sensory stimuli, and detect 56
bursts of activity in sensory networks (Chacron et al. 2009; Fortune and Rose 2001; Klug 2011). 57
They can also contribute to gain control and network stabilization in central networks (Abbott 58
and Regehr 2004), and help regulate motor network activity (Gelman et al. 2011; Li et al. 2007; 59
Nadim and Manor 2000; Parker and Griller 2000; Sanchez and Kirk 2002). 60
Chemical synapses using graded transmitter release, where release is a continuous 61
function of presynaptic membrane potential, also show short-term dynamics (Goutman and 62
Glowatzki 2007; Jackman et al. 2009). The roles of graded synaptic dynamics have been 63
analyzed in the pyloric network of the lobster stomatogastric ganglion (STG). In this 14 neuron 64
central pattern generator (CPG) network, graded chemical synapses help determine the phasing 65
of pyloric neurons to produce coordinated motor patterns (Hartline et al. 1988). The synaptic 66
strength in this network dynamically tracks activity levels, and thus alters network connectivity 67
as a function of cycle frequency (Nadim and Manor 2000; Mouser et al. 2008). Synaptic 68
depression during pyloric network activity is thought to control the transition to different 69
oscillatory modes of the network (Nadim et al. 1999), and to promote phase maintenance over 70
different cycle frequencies (Nadim et al. 2003; Manor et al. 2003). 71
4
Short-term synaptic plasticity can be regulated through neuromodulation. This is a form 72
of metaplasticity (Philpot et al. 1999), where neuromodulators alter the characteristics of 73
activity-dependent changes in synaptic strength (Fischer et al. 1997; Kreitzer and Regehr 2000; 74
Parker 2001; Parker and Grillner 1999; Qian and Delaney 1997). In the pyloric network, we 75
previously demonstrated that monoamines such as dopamine and octopamine can alter the steady 76
state synaptic depression at pyloric synapses (Johnson et al. 2005, 2011). In addition, the peptide 77
proctolin can change the sign of synaptic plasticity from depression to facilitation at a pyloric 78
graded synapse to help stabilize the cycle period (Zhao et al. 2011). 79
In this paper we examine amine modulation of synaptic dynamics at the pyloric PDLP 80
synapse. This synapse provides an important output from the pacemaker kernel, which sets the 81
cycle frequency of its follower cells, and thus helps regulate network activity. The PDLP 82
graded synapse shows synaptic depression when the PD neuron is driven with presynaptic square 83
pulses (Graubard et al. 1983; Johnson and Harris-Warrick 1990), and when the PD neuron is 84
artificially driven with realistic voltage waveforms that resemble its normal activity (Rabbah and 85
Nadim 2007). Graded synaptic strength at non-depressed PDLP synapses is reduced by 86
dopamine and serotonin, and enhanced by octopamine (Johnson and Harris Warrick 1990), but 87
the effects of amines on PDLP synaptic strength under conditions of realistic rhythmic activity 88
are unknown. Here we show that the three amines can have independent effects on synaptic 89
strength, the magnitude and temporal dynamics of synaptic depression and the recovery from 90
depression. 91
Materials and Methods 92
General procedures. California spiny lobsters (Panulirus interruptus) were supplied by Don 93
Tomlinson Commercial Fishing (San Diego, CA) and maintained in marine aquaria at 16° C. 94
5
After lobsters were anesthetized in ice, the stomatogastric nervous system (STNS) was removed 95
and pinned in a Sylgard–coated petri dish in chilled Panulirus saline of the following 96
composition (mM): 479 NaCl, 12.8 KCl, 13.7 CaCl2, 3.9 Na2SO4, 10.0 MgSO4, 2 glucose, 11.1 97
Tris base, pH 7.35 (Mulloney and Selverston 1974). The STG was desheathed and enclosed in a 98
1 ml pool walled with Vaseline and superfused at 5 ml/min with oxygenated Panulirus saline. 99
Experiments were performed at 19°C to enhance the strength of graded synaptic transmission 100
(Johnson et al. 1991). Dopamine (DA:10-5 M), octopamine (Oct: 10-5 M) and serotonin (5HT: 101
10-5 M), were dissolved in saline just before application (amine conditions). If the amine’s 102
effects did not reverse after a 15-60 min wash, the experiment’s results were discarded. Amines 103
were purchased from Sigma Chemical Co. 104
Electrophysiological recording and cell identification. Pyloric neuron activity was monitored 105
using pin electrodes to record extracellular action potentials from appropriate motor roots 106
(differential AC amplifier, model 1700, A-M Systems) and intracellular electrodes (3 M KCl, 10-107
15 MΩ) to record from cell bodies in the STG. We identified pyloric neuron somata during 108
ongoing rhythmic activity by matching the extracellularly recorded action potentials with 109
intracellularly recorded action potentials, by the characteristic shape and amplitude of membrane 110
potential oscillations and action potentials of pyloric neurons, and by the known synaptic 111
connections between pyloric neurons (Johnson et al. 2011). 112
Isolation of graded PDLP synapse 113
Inhibitory glutamatergic synapses in the pyloric network were blocked by 5x10-6M 114
picrotoxin (PTX, Sigma Chemical Co.) to pharmacologically isolate the PDLP synapse 115
(Bidaut 1980). The AB neuron, which is electrically coupled to the PD neurons, was 116
photoinactivated by intracellular iontophoresis of 5, 6-carboxyflourescein and illumination with 117
6
bright blue light (Miller and Selverston 1979). This eliminated any amine-induced AB activity 118
spreading to the PD neuron through the ABPD electrical synapse. We waited at least 1 hour 119
after AB photoinactivation to start our experiments, to allow the preparation to recover from the 120
acute effects of the light exposure (Flamm and Harris-Warrick 1986). 121
Dynamics of PDLP graded synaptic transmission 122
LP graded inhibitory post-synaptic potentials (gIPSPs) were recorded after adding 10-7 M 123
tetrodotoxin (TTX, Tocris) to Panulirus saline to block action potentials. We studied the 124
PDLP graded chemical synapse using two different presynaptic stimulation protocols. The 125
first used single, 3 sec square pulses as voltage clamp commands to drive the PD neuron, while 126
the second used a train of 12 linked realistic PD waveforms as voltage clamp commands to drive 127
PD oscillations (see Johnson et al. 2005, 2011 for realistic waveform construction). Averaged 128
and filtered PD waveforms from pyloric recordings had a mean amplitude of 15.5 ± 3.5 mV and 129
a mean cycle period of 688 ± 199 ms (n = 10); we used this shape and cycle period as pre-130
synaptic stimuli. Although realistic presynaptic waveforms are more physiologically relevant 131
than square pulse waveforms, we used both stimulation regimes for two reasons. First, some 132
basic characteristics of synaptic depression and its modulation at the PDLP synapse can only 133
be measured with square pulse stimulation, for example, accurate measurements of the onset of 134
synaptic depression (see below). Second, previous studies of graded synaptic transmission 135
between pyloric neurons have often used square pulse stimulation (for example, Graubard et al. 136
1983; Johnson et al. 1995; Manor et al. 1997; Zhao et al. 2011), and we wished to compare our 137
results with these earlier studies and determine whether postsynaptic responses differed between 138
the two stimulus forms. Both stimulation protocols used two electrode voltage clamp to drive 139
the PD from a Vhold of -55 mV in increasing amplitudes of 5 mV increments up to -25 mV. 140
7
Stepping the PD up to -25 mV evokes near-maximum gIPSPs in the LP neuron (Johnson and 141
Harris-Warrick 1990; Rabbah and Nadim 2007). We separated stimulation runs by a minimum of 142
thirty seconds, which was sufficient to eliminate all effects of the previous stimulation. We used 143
two electrode current clamp to hold the post-synaptic LP membrane potential at -50 mV; 144
postsynaptic electrodes were filled with 0.6M K2SO4 + 0.02 M KCl and presynaptic electrodes 145
with 3M KCl. In these experiments we used Axoclamp-2A and 2B amplifiers (Molecular 146
Devices). 147
Under control and amine conditions (at least 5 min amine superfusion), we measured the 148
initial peak and steady state amplitudes of the gIPSPs to calculate input-output (I/O) curves and 149
dynamics of synaptic depression (Figs. 1A, B). The steady state amplitude was measured as the 150
gIPSP plateau level at the end of the square pulse stimulation, or as the mean amplitude of the 151
last 5 gIPSPs in response to the realistic PD waveform train. A synaptic depression index (DI) 152
was calculated as the fractional gIPSP decrease from the initial peak response at steady state: 153
DI= (initial peak amplitude– steady state amplitude)/initial peak amplitude. Thus, a larger DI 154
corresponds to greater synaptic depression. The time constant (τDep) of the gIPSP depression was 155
measured during presynaptic square pulse stimulation by fitting the voltage decay from the initial 156
peak to the steady state amplitude with a single exponential function (Fig. 1A). The rate of 157
synaptic depression was rapid enough that it could not be measured accurately from the 158
separated peaks of the realistic waveform series. 159
In a separate measurement, we quantified the time constant of recovery from synaptic 160
depression, τRec, for both realistic and square waveform stimulation under control and amine 161
conditions. We evoked steady state depression by stimulating the PD neuron (Vhold, -55 mV) as 162
described above, followed by a single square pulse or realistic oscillation test stimulation at 163
8
increasing times after the end of the last conditioning stimulus. The percent recovery of the test 164
pulse back to the initial peak value over time was fitted with a single exponential in each 165
experiment to calculate τRec (see Figs. 2B, C). 166
Data acquisition and analysis. Electrophysiological recordings were digitized at 4KHz using a 167
PCI-6070-E board (National Instruments), and stored on a PC using custom-made recording 168
software (Scope) written in Lab Windows/CVI (National Instruments). This software also 169
controlled the injection of oscillatory and square pulse waveforms as voltage clamp commands 170
into the PD neuron (Johnson et al. 2005, 2011). All data were analyzed with the related custom-171
made software program ReadScope, also written in Lab Windows/CVI; these programs were 172
kindly provided to us by Dr. F. Nadim (http://www.stg.rutgers.edu/software/index.html). Data 173
were exported to Clampfit software (Molecular Devices) to calculate τDep and τRec. For statistical 174
comparisons, we used JMP software (SAS Institute, Inc.) to run multivariate analysis followed 175
by post-hoc tests to determine the statistical significance of differences between individual data 176
groups. Statistical differences between mean values were accepted with p < 0.05 (2-tailed 177
probability) for F and t values. Mean measured values and percentages are reported ± SD. 178
179
Results 180
Synaptic dynamics of the PDLP graded synapse under control conditions 181
We first characterized the baseline synaptic dynamics of the PDLP graded synapse 182
under control conditions, using single 3 sec square pulses (n = 10) and repeated presynaptic 183
activation with trains of 12 realistic oscillations (n= 7). As described previously for square pulse 184
stimulation of the PD neuron (Graubard et al. 1983; Johnson and Harris-Warrick 1990; Rabbah 185
and Nadim 2007), above the threshold for graded PD transmitter release (approximately -50 186
9
mV), the LP response is a rapid initial peak hyperpolarization which rapidly depresses to a 187
significantly smaller steady state hyperpolarization (p < 0.001 across PD depolarizations; Fig 1A, 188
C). The LP responds to a train of repeated PD oscillations with an initial peak gIPSP followed 189
by subsequent gIPSPs whose amplitudes depress with repetition to a significantly smaller steady 190
state value over several oscillations (p < 0.001 across PD depolarizations; Figs. 1B, D; see also 191
Rabbah and Nadim 2007). Peak and steady state gIPSP amplitudes increased with increasing PD 192
voltage commands from -40 to -25 mV under both stimulation protocols (Figs. 1C, D). The 193
amplitude of the initial peak LP gIPSP tended to be larger when elicited with PD square pulse 194
stimulation than with realistic waveform stimulation (compare Figs. 1C and D open and closed 195
circles), and this difference was significant during PD depolarizations to -30 and -35 mV (p = 196
0.03 and 0.05, respectively). However, the mean steady state gIPSP amplitudes were 197
significantly greater when elicited with oscillations compared to square steps at strong PD 198
depolarizations (to -30 and -25 mV: compare Figs. 1C and D open and closed squares; p = 0.05 199
and 0.03, respectively). Since square pulse stimulation evoked larger peak initial gIPSPs and 200
smaller steady-state amplitudes than oscillation stimulation, it also evoked greater synaptic 201
depression at all PD stimulation voltages (Fig. 1E; p < 0.001 at all PD voltages). For example, 202
the mean Depression Index (DI, defined as (Peak – Steady State)/Peak) was twice as large, at PD 203
depolarization to -25 mV, using square waves compared to oscillations (Fig. 1E). This probably 204
results from the greater depression during continued presynaptic stimulation than during trains of 205
oscillations, where the synapse could partially recover between oscillations (see Discussion). 206
There was no significant effect of PD voltage on the magnitude of the depression index over the 207
voltage range of either PD stimulation protocol (Fig. 1E; p = 0.23 and 0.21 for square pulse and 208
oscillations, respectively). 209
10
We also characterized the time constants of synaptic depression and recovery from 210
depression at the PDLP graded synapse using the square pulse series. The decay of the LP 211
response to PD stimulation (Fig. 1A) was well fit by a single exponential (fit correlation r = 0.99 212
± 0.001, n = 11). The mean time constant of synaptic depression, τDep, was 400 ± 200 ms during 213
PD square pulse steps to -25 mV. There was no voltage dependence of τDep during square step 214
stimulation (p = 0.95; Fig. 2A). Due to the comparatively slow cycle frequency of the oscillation 215
stimulation (cycle period 688 msec), we were unable to calculate the faster τDep from the 216
oscillation data. 217
In a separate measurement, we characterized the time constant of recovery from 218
depression, τRec, using both stimulation protocols (PD steps to -25 mV only), and fitting the 219
gIPSPs at increasing post-stimulation intervals with a single exponential (Figs. 2B, C; square 220
pulse: exponential fit correlation r = 0.95 ± 0.03; oscillation: fit correlation r = 0.98 ± 0.01). 221
Recovery from synaptic depression was over twice as fast with square pulse PD stimulation (n = 222
13) as with oscillation stimulation (n = 12; Fig. 2D; p = 0.003). This may result from increased 223
mobilization of the recovery process during maintained presynaptic depolarization (see 224
Discussion). 225
226
Amines change the synaptic dynamics of the PDLP graded synapse 227
Dopamine, 5HT and Oct affect synapses in the pyloric network by a complex set of pre- and 228
post-synaptic actions (Harris-Warrick and Johnson 2010, Johnson and Harris-Warrick 1997). In 229
addition, they can alter synaptic strength indirectly by modifying the waveforms of the pre-or 230
post-synaptic neuronal oscillations (Johnson et al. 2005). In order to focus on synaptic 231
metaplasticity, we attempted to limit the other consequences of amine modulation. For square 232
11
pulse stimulations, we held the pre-synaptic neuron at -55 mV by voltage clamp both before and 233
during amine application. For oscillation stimulation, we used the realistic waveforms obtained 234
from PD oscillations during the normal pyloric rhythm for both control and amine conditions. 235
Thus, the effects of amine-evoked changes in PD oscillations were eliminated. The post-236
synaptic LP neuron was held at -55 mV under all conditions, to prevent indirect effects of 237
neuronal membrane potential changes evoked by the amines (Flamm and Harris-Warrick 1986). 238
Dopamine 239
The physiological DA concentrations normally achieved in vivo will depend on the spike 240
frequency of the dopaminergic neurons, and are not known. We demonstrated previously that 10-241
4M DA greatly reduces or abolishes the LP gIPSP in response to square pulse PD stimulation 242
(Johnson and Harris-Warrick 1990). This also occurs using realistic waveform PD stimulation 243
(data not shown), so we decided instead to use a lower concentration of 10-5M DA, which does 244
not eliminate PDLP transmission (Fig. 3), to examine DA’s effects on PDLP graded 245
synaptic dynamics. At this lower concentration, DA had weak and highly variable effects on the 246
LP gIPSPs in different preparations. Using square pulse PD stimulation, DA reversibly 247
increased initial gIPSP amplitudes in about half the preparations (Fig. 3A), and reduced or had 248
little effect on gIPSP amplitudes in the other half (Figs. 3B, C); all of these effects reversed upon 249
washout of DA. We suggest that this variability is caused by the known opposing effects of DA 250
to decrease pre-synaptic PD transmitter release and increase post-synaptic LP input resistance 251
(Harris-Warrick and Johnson 2010), but to differing amounts in different preparations. On 252
average, 10-5M DA did not significantly change the mean amplitude of the peak and steady state 253
components of the LP gIPSP during PD square pulse stimulation (Fig. 3D, n = 5; p > 0.3 for 254
both). In contrast, during oscillation stimulation, DA significantly increased the mean first 255
12
gIPSP amplitude when compared across all PD depolarizations (example shown in Fig. 3E; p = 256
0.02; n = 16). However, this effect was weak, and only produced a trend to increase initial peak 257
gIPSP amplitude at single PD voltage step amplitudes (Fig. 3D; p = 0.08; n = 4 each). DA did 258
not significantly change the steady state gIPSP amplitude across PD oscillation steps (Fig 3D; p 259
= 0.26). 260
With regard to synaptic depression, there was no significant effect of DA on the 261
amplitude of synaptic depression, as measured by the DI, for either square pulses (Control DI: 262
0.68 ± 0.07, DA DI: 0.70 ± 0.10 at -25 mV) or oscillations (Control DI: 0.32 ± 0.06, DA DI: 0.37 263
± 0.17 at -25 mV) at any PD voltage (p > 0.10 for both). 264
Despite these weak and variable effects on the amplitudes of LP gIPSPs, DA consistently 265
accelerated both the onset of, and the recovery from, synaptic depression. Figure 3C shows a 266
typical square wave measurement, where τDep was accelerated by DA compared to the control 267
gIPSP response, with little change in gIPSP amplitude. The mean τDep was significantly 268
decreased over the entire PD voltage range (Fig. 4A; n = 5, p < 0.005), but the DA effect showed 269
no significant voltage dependence (p = 0.78). Recovery from depression was also faster with 270
both square pulse and realistic waveform stimulation (Fig. 4A). This is seen in the example 271
using oscillation stimulation in Figure 4B, which shows more complete recovery of the 272
depressed gIPSP 1 sec after the stimulus train during DA (89% recovery) than under control 273
conditions (72% recovery). The mean τRec at -25 mV PD depolarization was significantly faster 274
in DA for both square pulse PD stimulation (Fig. 4A, 39 ± 23% τRec decrease; p < 0.001, n = 5) 275
and realistic waveform PD stimulation (Fig. 4A, 43 ± 19% τRec decrease; p = 0.03, n = 4). This 276
acceleration of onset and recovery from depression did not depend on the sign of the rather 277
variable DA effect on gIPSP amplitudes described above. As summarized in Figure 4C, in all 278
13
but 1 experiment the τDep and τRec values were smaller while DA either increased or decreased 279
gIPSP amplitude. Thus, while DA (10-5 M) had highly variable effects on gIPSP amplitude, it 280
had reliable, significant and independent effects to accelerate the time course of synaptic 281
depression onset and recovery from synaptic depression. 282
283
Octopamine 284
We previously demonstrated that 10-5M Oct strengthens the PDLP synapse when 285
tested with square wave PD stimulation (Johnson and Harris-Warrick 1990). In our current 286
experiments, Oct consistently increased the amplitude of gIPSPs over the full range of 287
presynaptic voltages using both square pulse (n = 5) and realistic (n= 4) PD waveforms (Figs. 288
5A, B). The peak and steady state responses to square pulse stimulation were significantly larger 289
during Oct application at all PD depolarizations (p < 0.0001 and p = 0.004, respectively): during 290
a PD step to-25 mV, the mean peak gIPSP increased by 55 ± 29% while the steady state gIPSP 291
increased by 157 ± 32% (Fig. 5C). As can be seen in Figure 5C, Oct increased the steady state 292
gIPSP amplitude significantly more than the initial peak amplitude across the voltage steps (p = 293
0.04). Using the oscillation protocol, Oct also increased the first peak and steady state gIPSP 294
amplitudes across all PD stimulation voltages (p <0.0001 for both); for example, at -25 mV, the 295
peak amplitudes increased by 57 ± 33% while the steady state amplitudes increased by 48 ± 37% 296
(Fig. 5C). Unlike the results using square pulse stimulation, during oscillation stimulation there 297
was no significant difference between Oct’s enhancement of the peak and the steady state gIPSP 298
amplitudes at any PD voltage (p = 0.15; Fig. 5C). There was no voltage dependence of the Oct 299
effect on gIPSP amplitude. 300
14
During square pulse stimulation, the greater Oct enhancement of the steady state over the 301
peak gIPSP amplitude resulted in a significant decrease in the depression index across PD 302
depolarizations (16 ± 6% decrease at -25 mV, p = 0.0001; Fig. 5D). However, there was no 303
equivalent DI decrease using oscillation stimulation, because Oct did not differentially increase 304
the first peak and steady state amplitudes of the gIPSP (Fig. 5C, D; p = 0.15). 305
Octopamine significantly altered the onset and recovery of synaptic depression in 306
response to square pulse PD stimulation, in a way that is quite different from DA. Octopamine 307
significantly slowed τDep across PD steps (increase by 80 ± 41 % at -25 mV; n = 5, p < 0.0001; 308
Fig. 6A). This slowing of synaptic depression was not caused simply by the larger gIPSPs 309
evoked during Oct. When gIPSP amplitudes were matched in the presence and absence of Oct 310
using different amplitude pre-synaptic PD steps in the same preparation, τDep remained slower 311
during Oct (Fig. 6B). In contrast, Oct significantly accelerated the recovery from depression 312
using square pulse PD stimulation (Fig. 6C), by an average of 47 ± 24% using -25 mV steps (n = 313
4; p = 0.026, Fig. 6A). However, when measured with oscillation stimulation, Oct had highly 314
variable effects on τRec which could either accelerate or slow down, and were not significant 315
overall (Control: 1120 ± 610 ms, Oct: 1510 ± 1510 ms; p= 0.63). Thus the main effect of Oct 316
was to increase PDLP synaptic strength using both PD stimulation protocols. Using square 317
pulse PD stimulation, Oct reduced the depression amplitude and slowed the onset of synaptic 318
depression, while speeding up the rate of recovery from depression. 319
Serotonin 320
We previously showed that 10-5M 5HT weakens the PDLP synapse when tested with 321
square wave PD stimulation (Johnson and Harris-Warrick 1990). In our recent experiments, we 322
have reproduced these results using both square pulse (n = 4) and oscillation (n= 6) PD 323
15
waveforms (Figs. 7A, B). Using square pulse stimulation, the mean initial peak and steady state 324
responses were consistently and significantly smaller during 5HT application at all PD 325
depolarizations (p < 0.0001 for initial peak and p = 0.004 for steady state). This effect did not 326
show any voltage dependence: with -25 mV steps, the peak gIPSPs fell by 28 ± 17% and the 327
steady state gIPSPs fell by 40 ± 12% (Fig. 7C). Similar results were seen using oscillation PD 328
stimulation at all voltages (p = 0.0035 and < 0.0001 for initial peak and steady state responses, 329
respectively): at -25 mV PD depolarization, the peak gIPSPs fell by 20 ± 12% and the steady 330
state gIPSPs by 27 ± 10% (Fig. 7C). During 5HT application, synaptic depression was 331
significantly greater across all PD depolarizations using square pulse (12 ± 8% greater at -25 332
mV; p = 0.0015; Fig. 7D), and oscillation stimulation (32 ± 38% greater at -25 mV; p = 0.004; 333
Fig 7D). 334
Serotonin significantly accelerated the time course of synaptic depression measured with 335
square pulse PD stimulation, and tended to accelerate the time course of recovery from 336
depression (Fig. 8A), though this effect did not reach statistical significance. The acceleration in 337
τDep was not caused by a smaller gIPSP during 5HT. For example, the trace in Fig. 8B shows 338
that when sized matched (using different pre-synaptic voltage steps), the gIPSP recorded during 339
5HT depressed more quickly than in control conditions. Serotonin significantly accelerated τDep 340
with square pulses across PD voltages (p = 0.02); at -25 mV PD depolarization, τDep was reduced 341
by 25 ± 34 % (Fig. 8A; n = 4). In 3 of 3 experiments, 5HT decreased τRec by 28 ± 14%, but this 342
did not reach statistical significance with the small sample size and variability, (p = 0.10; Fig. 343
8A). Serotonin also decreased τRec in 5 of 5 experiments by 26 ± 27 %, measured by oscillation 344
stimulation to -25 mV (see example in Fig. 8C), but this also did not reach our criterion for 345
statistical significance (p = 0.07; Fig. 8A). Thus, 5HT reduces PDLP synaptic strength, 346
16
increases the rate of onset of synaptic depression and the amount of synaptic depression, while 347
tending to weakly accelerate the recovery from depression. 348
349
17
Discussion 350
Amine-induced metaplasticity at the PDLP graded synapse 351
Graded chemical synapses of the pyloric and gastric CPG networks of the lobster STG show 352
marked synaptic depression with prolonged voltage steps or repeated trains of presynaptic 353
activation; all pyloric synapses are tonically depressed at normal pyloric cycle frequencies 354
(reviewed by Hartline and Graubard, 1992; see also Johnson et al. 2005, 2011; Mamiya and 355
Nadim 2004; Manor et al. 1997). Synaptic depression is commonly seen at graded chemical 356
synapses, such as those between retinal neurons and from hair cells to afferent fibers (Edmonds 357
et al. 2004; Wan and Heidelberger 2011), although not all graded chemical synapses show short 358
term activity-dependent changes in synaptic strength (Narayan et al. 2011; Simmons 1981). 359
Aside from studies with pyloric network synapses, little previous work has examined 360
neuromodulation of synaptic dynamics at graded chemical synapses. 361
We have previously described amine effects on the strength of the PDLP graded 362
synapse (Johnson and Harris- Warrick 1990), and here we demonstrate that the magnitude and 363
kinetics of short-term synaptic dynamics are also modulated by amines at this synapse. The most 364
surprising conclusion from our results is that the synaptic strength and the magnitude of synaptic 365
depression, as well as the kinetics of its onset and recovery, can be independently modulated by 366
each amine. We suggest that this may occur through multiple pre and post-synaptic mechanisms 367
of neuromodulatory actions that shape synaptic strength in a functioning network. 368
Dopamine 369
We have previously demonstrated that DA (10-4M) increases graded synaptic strength at the 370
LPPY and LPPD synapses, but only changes (increases) the amount of synaptic depression 371
at the LPPY synapse (Johnson et al. 2005, 2011). Thus DA can have differential effects on 372
18
synaptic depression and synaptic strength depending on the postsynaptic target. We used 10-5M 373
DA in the present study because 10-4M DA abolishes functional synaptic transmission at the 374
PDLP graded synapse (Johnson and Harris Warrick 1990). At the lower concentration, DA 375
consistently accelerated τDep and τRec despite small and variable effects on PDLP synaptic 376
strength and on the magnitude of synaptic depression. This demonstrates that the kinetics of 377
synaptic depression can be modulated independently of synaptic strength and the magnitude of 378
synaptic depression. At present, we cannot correlate 10-5 M DA’s variable actions on synaptic 379
strength with its effects on other cellular properties. None of the known effects of DA on pre- or 380
postsynaptic ionic currents described previously (Harris-Warrick and Johnson 2010) can account 381
for the DA-induced changes in depression kinetics. DA may be acting postsynaptically to 382
accelerate the kinetics of transmitter receptor desensitization and recovery from desensitization 383
(Papke et al. 2011). Motor patterns produced by the lobster pyloric network are qualitatively 384
different when treated with 10-4 and 10-5M DA (Flamm and Harris-Warrick 1986). 385
Concentration-dependent DA effects on the onset and recovery of synaptic depression may 386
contribute to shaping distinct DA-induced network activity. 387
Octopamine 388
Octopamine’s enhancement of synaptic strength was accompanied by reduced synaptic 389
depression, slowed τDep and accelerated τRec for PD square pulse stimulation, but not PD 390
oscillation stimulation. Part of the synaptic strength increase by Oct may be due to its increase in 391
postsynaptic LP input resistance (Johnson et al. 1993), but the change in synaptic depression 392
suggests more dynamic effects on synaptic transmission. AP-evoked synaptic transmission at 393
crustacean and vertebrate central synapses depresses more at synapses with high transmitter 394
output than with low transmitter output and depresses less with low transmitter output (Miller 395
19
and Atwood 2004; Thomson 2000). Reduced synaptic depression coupled with increased 396
synaptic strength during Oct does not fit this pattern, which would directly link transmitter 397
release probability with short term synaptic dynamics. Instead, at the PDLP graded synapse, 398
enhancement of presynaptic ICa by Oct could lead to both greater transmitter release and more 399
rapid mobilization of vesicles into the readily releasable pool, thus leading to reduced depression 400
and accelerated recovery from depression (Babai et al. 2010; Gomis et al. 1999; see below). 401
However, the effects of Oct on PD ionic currents are not known. 402
Serotonin 403
Serotonin reduced PDLP graded synaptic strength but increased synaptic depression; again, 404
this does not fit a pattern directly linking synaptic dynamics with the amount of transmitter 405
release. Serotonin’s effects could reflect pre-synaptic mechanisms such as a reduction in ICa(V), 406
which would reduce release and slow the rate of vesicle mobilization. Serotonin may have 407
additional postsynaptic effects besides decreasing LP input resistance (Johnson et al. 1993), as 408
described above for DA. Serotonin showed a trend to accelerate both the onset and recovery 409
from depression, which would allow greater flexibility of the synapse as the cycle frequency 410
changes; the accelerated recovery may limit the reduction in synaptic strength during the normal 411
oscillating activity of the neurons in the pyloric rhythm. More work is needed to clarify the 412
mechanisms for the metaplastic effects of amines, but it is clear that amines have complex and 413
sometimes opposing effects on short term dynamics of graded synaptic transmission in the 414
pyloric network. 415
Characteristics of synaptic dynamics at the PDLP graded synapse 416
The use of both square pulse and oscillation stimulation protocols allowed us to probe 417
characteristics of synaptic depression and its modulation at the PDLP graded synapse of the 418
20
pyloric that might not be evident with either stimulation protocol alone. First, we found that the 419
magnitude of the synaptic depression was greater using square pulse stimulation of PD than with 420
trains of PD oscillations, emphasizing that realistic oscillation stimulation allows a more 421
physiological characterization of pyloric synapses (Manor et al. 1997). Weaker synaptic 422
depression with realistic oscillation stimulation may be explained simply by the partial recovery 423
from depression that occurs between the PD oscillations. Second, we could more accurately 424
determine the time course of onset of depression with long square pulse PD stimulation. The 425
onset of depression, measured with square pulse PD stimulation, had a time constant of ~400 ms, 426
and could not be accurately measured with oscillations occurring every 688 msec. Values for 427
τDep vary from ms to tens of seconds at other AP-evoked and graded chemical synapses (Cho et 428
al. 2011; Wang and Manis 2008; Zucker and Regehr 2002). The recovery from depression was 429
over twice as fast using square pulse PD stimulation (τRec~600 ms) compared to PD oscillations 430
(τRec~ 1600 ms). Our τRec times are longer that those previously reported by Rabbah and Nadim 431
(2007) at the PDLP graded synapse, but the stimulation protocols differed between the two 432
studies. Time constants for recovery from depression range from 10s of msec at hair cell 433
synapses to seconds at other graded synapses, again depending on experimental conditions (Rabl 434
et al. 2006; Wan and Heidelberger 2011). Finally, amines sometimes affected synaptic 435
depression and its onset and recovery kinetics differentially (see discussion above), suggesting 436
more complex actions on synaptic dynamics than would be seen with PD oscillation stimulation 437
alone. 438
The most common mechanism of synaptic depression at both action potential evoked and 439
graded chemical synapses is transmitter depletion during prolonged or repeated synaptic activity 440
(von Gersdorff and Matthews 1997; Zucker and Regher 2002); other reported pre-synaptic 441
21
mechanisms include calcium channel inactivation (Xu et al. 2007), autoreceptor activation 442
(Davies et al. 1990), and accumulating refractoriness of the transmitter release mechanism 443
(Waldeck et al. 2000). Our experiments were not designed to determine the site of depression, 444
but they suggest a mixed mechanism for depression at the PDLP graded synapse. Changing 445
the length of the pre-synaptic square pulse, or the duration of the PD oscillations, altered the 446
level of depression (Johnson et al. 2005). In addition, the faster τRec using square pulse PD 447
stimulation, which would accumulate more intracellular calcium, is consistent with a calcium-448
dependent replenishment of the readily releasable transmitter pool, seen at AP-evoked (Neher 449
and Sakaba 2008) and graded synapses (Babai et al. 2010; Gomis et al. 1999). We also found 450
that the magnitude of PDLP depression and its onset kinetics were not sensitive to presynaptic 451
voltage stimulation, suggesting that depression was independent of the amount of transmitter 452
release. The pre-synaptic voltage independence of both the depression magnitude and τDep is 453
inconsistent with a simple pre-synaptic transmitter depletion model of synaptic depression. The 454
lack of correlation between the amount of synaptic depression and gIPSP amplitude at the PD 455
LP graded synapse is also seen at AP-evoked synapses from other preparations where synaptic 456
depression is clearly due to a presynaptic mechanism, but its magnitude is independent of PSP 457
amplitude (Hefft et al. 2002; Wu et al. 2005). There may also be a postsynaptic contribution at 458
our synapse, such as receptor desensitization (Jonas and Westbrook 1995; Papke et al. 2011; 459
Trussell et al. 1993). 460
Possible functional importance of metaplasticity in the pyloric network 461
Short term synaptic depression plays an important role in organizing a flexible pyloric 462
motor pattern. The magnitude of depression and its onset and recovery kinetics dynamically 463
determine the synaptic strength at different pyloric cycle periods, and when pyloric rhythm 464
22
periods are perturbed by interactions with linked networks such as from the cardiac sac and 465
gastric mill motor networks (Ayali and Harris Warrick 1998; Russell and Hartline 1981; Thurma 466
and Hooper 2002, 2003). Synaptic depression promotes phase maintenance as the pyloric 467
network changes its cycle frequency (Greenburg and Manor 2005; Manor et al. 2003; Nadim et 468
al. 2003), and contributes to stabilization of the rhythm period (Mamiya and Nadim 2004). It 469
can enable a switch between different forms of network bistability (Nadim and Manor 2001; 470
Nadim et al. 1999), and can even determine the sign of a synaptic interaction (Johnson et al. 471
2005; Mamiya et al. 2003). 472
Neuromodulator-induced metaplasticity could help maintain or reset synaptic strengths 473
between network neurons to adjust the post-synaptic neurons’ firing phase. For example, the 10-474
5M DA effects to accelerate both τDep and τRec with no change in gIPSP amplitude or depression 475
could stabilize PDLP synaptic strength as the cycle frequency changes in DA (Johnson et al. 476
2011). Octopamine enhances LP excitability, but does not change the LP firing onset phase 477
(Johnson et al. 2011). The greater PDLP synaptic strength in Oct, with reduced depression 478
and faster onset and recovery kinetics, could balance enhanced LP excitability to maintain LP 479
phasing at its pre-Oct values (Johnson et al. 2011). There is also no change in LP onset firing 480
phase during 5HT despite a reduction in LP excitability (Johnson et al. 2011). A faster τDep 481
might contribute to weakening the PDLP gIPSP and to enhanced depression, and this may be 482
mitigated by the accelerated τRec to maintain the LP firing onset phase. At the crab LPPY 483
graded synapse, the peptide proctolin changes the sign of synaptic plasticity from depression to 484
facilitation at certain presynaptic voltage levels, and functions to help stabilize the cycle period 485
(Zhao et al. 2011). 486
23
Metaplasticity through the actions of many different neuromodulators is a common 487
feature of many neural networks (Barriere et al. 2008; Carey et al. 2011; Kreitzer and Regehr 488
2000; Parker 2001; Sakurai and Katz 2009), and should be considered one of the building blocks 489
of network operation. Although well studied at AP-evoked synapses, there is relatively little 490
known about metamodulation at graded chemical synapses. The pyloric network of crustaceans 491
provides an excellent model system to explore the ranges of expression of metaplasticity at 492
graded synapses, and its functional role in organizing network operation and plasticity (Johnson 493
et al. 2005; 2011; Zhao et al. 2011). 494
495
496
24
497 Acknowledgements 498
We thank Françoise Vermeylen from the Cornell Statistical Consulting Unit for help with the 499
statistical analysis. 500
501
Grants 502
Research supported by NIH NS17323 to R.M. Harris-Warrick 503
504
Disclosures 505
No conflicts of interest financial or otherwise, are declared by the authors. 506
507
Author Contributions 508
B.R.J., R.M.H.-W. and M.D.K. designed the research; M.D.K. performed experiments; M.D.K. 509
and B.R.J. analyzed data, and interpreted results with R.M.H.-W.; B.R.J. and M.D.K. prepared 510
figures; B.R.J., R.M.H.-W., and M.D.K. wrote and edited the manuscript. 511
512
25
513 References 514 515
Abbott LF, Regehr WG. Synaptic Computation. Nature 431: 796-803, 2004. 516
517
Ayali A, Harris-Warrick RM. Interaction of dopamine and cardiac sac modulatory inputs on the 518
pyloric network in the lobster stomatogastric ganglion. Brain Res 794: 155-161, 1998. 519
520
Babai N, Bartoletti TM, Thoreson W.B. Calcium regulates vesicle replenishment at the cone 521
ribbon synapse. J Neurosci 30: 15866-15877, 2010. 522
523
Barriere G, Tartas M, Cazalets J-R, Bertrand SS. Interplay between neuromodulator-induced 524
switching of short-term plasticity at sensorimotor synapses in the neonatal rat spinal cord. J 525
Physiol 586.7: 1903–1920, 2008. 526
527
Bidaut M. Pharmacological dissection of the pyloric network of the lobster stomatogastric 528
ganglion using picrotoxin. J Neurophysiol 44: 1089-1101, 1980. 529
530
Carey MR, Myoga MH, McDaniels KR, Marsicano G, Lutz B, Mackie K, Regehr WG. 531
Presynaptic CB1 receptors regulate synaptic plasticity at cerebellar parallel fiber synapses. J 532
Neurophysiol 105:958-963, 2011. 533
534
Chacron MJ, Toporikova N, Fortune ES. Differences in the time course of short-term depression 535
across receptive fields are correlated with directional sensitivity in electrosensory neurons. J 536
Neurophysiol 102: 3270-3279, 2009. 537
538
Cho S, Li G-L, von Gersdorff H. Recovery from short-term depression and facilitation is 539
ultrafast and Ca2-dependent at auditory hair cell synapses. J Neurosci 31:5682–5692, 2011. 540
541 Davies CH, Davies SN, Collingridge GL. Paired pulse depression of monosynaptic GABA-542
mediated inhibitory postsynaptic responses in rat hippocampus. J Physiol 424: 513–531, 1990. 543
26
Edmonds BW, Gregory FD, Schweizer FE. Evidence that fast exocytosis can be predominantly 544
mediated by vesicles not docked at active zones in frog saccular hair cells. J Physiol 560: 439-545
450, 2004. 546
547
Fioravante D, Regehr WG. Short-term forms of presynaptic plasticity. Cur Opin Neurobiol 21: 548
269-274, 2011. 549
550
Fisher SA, Fischer TM, Carew TJ . Multiple overlapping processes underlying short-term 551
synaptic enhancement. Trends Neurosci 20: 170-177, 1997. 552
553 Fischer TM, Blazis DEJ, Priver NA, Carew TJ. Metaplasticity at identified inhibitory synapses in 554 Aplysia. Nature 389: 860-865, 1997. 555 556
Flamm RE, Harris-Warrick RM. Aminergic modulation in lobster stomatogastric ganglion. II. 557
Target neurons of dopamine, octopamine and serotonin within the pyloric circuit. J Neurophysiol 558
55:847-865, 1986. 559
560
Fortune ES, Rose GJ. Short-term synaptic plasticity as a temporal filter. Trends Neurosci 24: 561
381-385, 2001. 562
563
Gelman S, Grove CL, Faber DS. Atypical properties of release and short-term depression at a 564
specialized nicotinic synapse in the Mauthner cell network. J Exp Biol 214: 1560-1570, 2011. 565
566
Gomis A, Burrone J, Lagnado L. Two actions of calcium regulate the supply of releasable 567
vesicles at the ribbon synapse of retinal bipolar cells. J Neurosci 19: 6309-6317, 1999. 568
569
Goutman JD, Glowatzki E. Short-term facilitation modulates size and timing of the synaptic 570
response at the inner hair cell ribbon synapse. J Neurosci 31: 7974-7981, 2011. 571
572
Graubard K, Raper JA, Hartline DA. Graded synaptic transmission between identified spiking 573
neurons. J Neurophysiol 50: 508-520, 1983. 574
575
27
Greenberg I, Manor Y. Synaptic depression in conjunction with A-current channels promote 576
phase constancy in a rhythmic network. J Neurophysiol 93:656-77, 2005. 577
578
Harris-Warrick RM, Johnson BR. Checks and balances in neuromodulation. Front Behav 579
Neurosci 4:46. doi: 10.3389/fnbeh.2010.00047, 2010. 580
581
Hartline DK, Graubard K. Cellular and synaptic properties in the crustacean 582
stomatogastric nervous system. In: Dynamic Biological Networks: the Stomatogastric Nervous 583
System, edited by Harris-Warrick RM, Marder E, Selverston AI, and Moulins M. Cambridge, 584
MA: MIT Press, 1992, p. 31-85. 585
586
Hartline DK, Russell DF, Raper JA, Graubard K. Special cellular and synaptic 587
mechanisms in motor pattern generation. Comp Biochem Physiol 91C: 115-131, 1988. 588
589
Hefft S, Kraushaar U, Geiger JRP, Jonas P. 2002. Presynaptic short term depression is 590
maintained during regulation of transmitter release at a GABAergic synapse in rat hippocampus. 591
J Physiol 539.1, 201-208, 2002. 592
593
Jackman SL, Choi SY, Thoreson WB, Rabl K, Bartoletti TM, Kramer RH. Role of the synaptic 594
ribbon in transmitting the cone light response. Nat Neurosci 12: 303-310, 2009. 595
596
Johnson BR, Harris-Warrick RM. Amine modulation of graded synaptic transmission in the 597
lobster stomatogastric ganglion. J Neurosci 10: 2066-2076, 1990. 598
599
Johnson BR, Peck JH, Harris-Warrick RM. Temperature sensitivity of graded synaptic 600
transmission in the lobster stomatogastric ganglion. J Exp Biol 156:267-285, 1991. 601
602
Johnson BR, Peck JH, Harris-Warrick RM. Amine modulation of electrical coupling in the 603
pyloric network of the lobster stomatogastric ganglion. J Comp Physiol A 172:715-732, 1993. 604
605
28
Johnson BR, Peck JH, Harris-Warrick RM. Distributed amine modulation of graded chemical 606
transmission in the pyloric network of the lobster stomatogastric ganglion. J Neurophysiol 74: 607
437-452, 1995 608
609
Johnson BR, Harris-Warrick RM. Amine modulation of glutamate responses from pyloric motor 610
neurons in lobster stomatogastric ganglion. J Neurophysiol 78: 3210-3221, 1997. 611
612
Johnson BR, Schneider LR, Nadim F, Harris-Warrick RM. Dopamine modulation of phasing of 613
activity in a rhythmic motor network: contribution of synaptic and intrinsic modulatory actions. J 614
Neurophysiol 94: 3101-3111, 2005. 615
616
Johnson BR, Brown, JM, Kvarta MD, Lu JYJ, Schneider LR, Nadim F, Harris-Warrick RM. 617
Differential modulation of synaptic strength and timing regulate synaptic efficacy in a motor 618
network. J Neurophysiol 105: 293-304, 2011. 619
620
Jonas MV, Westbrook GL. Desensitized states prolong the GABAA channel responses to brief 621
agonist pulses. Neuron 15, 181–191, 1995. 622
623
Klug A. Short-term synaptic plasticity in the auditory brain stem by using in-vivo-like 624
stimulation parameters. Hear Res 279: 51-59, 2011. 625
626
Kreitzer AC, Regehr WG. Modulation of transmission during trains at a cerebellar synapse. J 627
Neurosci 20: 1348-1357, 2000. 628
629
Li W-C, Sautois B, Roberts A, Soffe SR. Reconfiguration of a vertebrate motor network: specific 630
neuron recruitment and context-dependent synaptic plasticity. J Neurosci 27: 12267- 12276, 631
2007. 632
633
Mamiya A, Manor Y, Nadim F. Short-term dynamics of a mixed chemical and electrical synapse 634
in a rhythmic network. J Neurosci 23: 9557-9564, 2003. 635
636
29
Mamiya A, Nadim F. Dynamic interaction of oscillatory neurons coupled with reciprocally 637
inhibitory synapses acts to stabilize the rhythm period. J Neurosci 24: 5140-5150, 2004. 638
639
Manor Y, Nadim F, Abbott LF, Marder E. Temporal dynamics of graded synaptic 640
transmission in the lobster stomatogastic ganglion. J Neurosci 17: 5610-5621, 1997. 641
642
Manor Y, Bose A, Booth V, Nadim F. Contribution of synaptic depression to phase maintenance 643
in a model rhythmic network. J Neurophysiol 90: 3513-3528, 2003. 644
645
Millar AG, Atwood HL. Crustacean phasic and tonic motor neurons. Integr Comp Biol 44: 4-13, 646
2004. 647
648
Miller JP, Selverston AI. Rapid killing of single neurons by irradiation of intracellularly injected 649
dye. Science 206: 702-704, 1979. 650
651
Mouser C, Nadim F, Bose A. Maintaining phase of the crustacean tri-phasic pyloric rhythm. J 652
Math Biol 57: 161-181, 2008. 653
654
Mulloney B, Selverston AI. Organization of the stomatogastric ganglion of the spiny lobster. I. 655
Neurons driving the lateral teeth. J Comp Physiol 91: 1-32, 1974. 656
657
Nadim F, Manor Y. The role of short-term synaptic dynamics in motor control. Cur Opin 658
Neurobiol 10: 683-690, 2000. 659
660
Nadim F. Booth V, Bose A, Manor Y. Short-term synaptic dynamics promote phase maintenance 661
in multi-phase rhythms. Neurocomput 52-54: 79-87, 2003. 662
663
Nadim F, Manor Y, Kopell N, Marder E. Synaptic depression creates a switch that controls the 664
frequency of an oscillatory circuit. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 8206-8211, 1999. 665
666
30
Narayan A, Laurent G, Sternberg PW. Transfer characteristics of a thermosensory synapse in 667
Caenorhabditis elegans. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 108; 9667-9672, 2011. 668
669
Neher E, Sakaba T. Multiple roles of calcium ions in the regulation of neurotransmitter release. 670
Neuron 59: 861-872, 2008. 671
672
Papke D, Gonzalez-Gutierrez G, Grosman C. Desensitization of neurotransmitter-gated ion 673
channels during high-frequency stimulation: a comparative study of Cys-loop, AMPA and 674
purinergic receptors. J Physiol 589: 1571-85, 2011. 675
676
Parker D. Spinal-cord plasticity: independent and interactive effects of neuromodulator and 677
activity-dependent plasticity. Mol Neurobiol 22: 55-80, 2001. 678
679
Parker D, Grillner S. Activity-dependent metaplasticity of inhibitory and excitatory synaptic 680
transmission in the lamprey spinal cord locomotor network. J Neurosci 19: 1647-1656, 1999. 681
682
Parker D, Grillner S. The activity-dependent plasticity of segmental and intersegmental synaptic 683
connections in the lamprey spinal cord. Eur J Neurosci 12: 2135-2146, 2000. 684
685
Philpot BD, Bear MF, Abraham WC. Metaplasticity: the plasticity of synaptic plasticity. In: 686
Beyond Neurotransmission: Neuromodulation and its importance for information processing, 687
edited by Katz PS. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 1999, p 160-197. 688
689
Qian S-M, Delaney KR. Neuromodulation of activity-dependent synaptic enhancement at 690
crayfish neuromuscular junction. Brain Res 771: 259-270, 1997. 691
692
Rabbah P, Nadim F. Distinct synaptic dynamics of heterogeneous pacemaker neurons in an 693
oscillatory network. J Neurophysiol 97: 2239-2253, 2007. 694
695
Rabl K, Cadetti L, Thoreson WB. Paired-pulse depression at photoreceptor synapses. J Neurosci 696
26: 2555-2563, 2006. 697
31
698
Russell DF, Hartline DK. A multiaction synapse evoking both EPSPs and enhancement of 699
endogenous bursting. Brain Res 223: 19–38, 1981. 700
701
Sakurai A, Katz PS. State-, timing-, and pattern-dependent neuromodulation of synaptic strength 702
by a serotonergic interneuron. J Neurosci 29: 268-279, 2009. 703
704
Sanchez JAD, Kirk MA. Ingestion motor programs of Aplysia are modulated by short-term 705
synaptic enhancement in cerebral-buccal interneuron pathways. Invert Neurosci 4: 199-212, 706
2002. 707
708
Simmons PJ. Synaptic transmission between second- and third-order neurons of a locust ocellus. 709
J Comp Physiol A 145:265–276, 1981. 710
711
Thomson AM. Molecular frequency filters at central synapses. Prog Neurobiol 62: 159-196, 712
2000. 713
714
Thuma JB, Hooper SL. Quantification of gastric mill network effects on a movement related 715
parameter of pyloric network output in the lobster. J Neurophysiol 87: 2372-84, 2002. 716
717
Thuma JB, Hooper SL. Quantification of cardiac sac network effects on a movement-related 718
parameter of pyloric network output in the lobster. J Neurophysiol 89: 745-753, 2003. 719
720
Trussell LO, Zhang S, Raman IM. Desensitization of AMPA receptors upon multiquantal 721
neurotransmitter release. Neuron 10: 1185-96, 1993. 722
723
von Gersdorff H, Matthews G. Depletion and replenishment of vesicle pools at a ribbon-type 724
synaptic terminal. J Neurosci 17: 1919-1927, 1997. 725
726
Waldeck RF, Pereda A, Faber DS. Properties and plasticity of paired-pulse depression at a 727
central synapse. J Neurosci 20: 5312-20, 2000. 728
32
729
Wan Q-F, Heidelberger R. Synaptic release at mammalian bipolar cell terminals. Vis Neurosci 730
28: 109-119, 2011. 731
732
Wang Y, Manis PB. Short-term synaptic depression and recovery at the mature mammalian 733
endbulb of Held synapse in mice. J Neurophysiol 100: 1255-1264, 2008. 734
735
Wu Y, Kawasaki F, Ordway RW. Properties of short-term synaptic depression at larval 736
neuromuscular synapses in wild-type and temperature-sensitive paralytic mutants of Drosophila. 737
J Neurophysiol 93: 2396-2405, 2005. 738
739
Xu J, He L, Wu LG. Role of Ca(2+) channels in short-term synaptic plasticity. Curr Opin 740
Neurobiol 17: 352-359, 2007. 741
742
Zhao Z, Sheibanie AF, Oh M, Rabbah P, Nadim F. Peptide neuromodulation of synaptic 743
dynamics in an oscillatory network. J Neurosci 31: 13991-14004, 2011. 744
745
Zucker RS, Regehr, WG. Short-term synaptic plasticity. Ann Rev Physiol 64:355-405, 2002. 746
747
33
748 Figure legends 749 750
Figure 1. Synaptic dynamics of graded synaptic transmission at the PDLP chemical synapse. 751
A. LP gIPSPs in response to 3 second PD square pulse depolarizations. Initial peak and steady 752
state IPSP amplitudes and the time constant (τDep) for synaptic depression were measured for all 753
PD depolarizations from Vhold = -55 mV. B. LP gIPSPs during a train of 12 realistic PD 754
oscillations of increasing amplitude from Vhold = -55 mV. The first gIPSP amplitude (initial 755
peak) and the mean of the last 5 gIPSPs amplitudes (steady state) were measured for all PD 756
depolarizations. C. Mean input/output relationship for the amplitude of the initial peak (open 757
circles) and steady state (open squares) gIPSPs using square pulse PD stimulation (n = 11). D. 758
Mean input/output relationship for initial (closed circles) and steady state (closed squares) LP 759
gIPSP amplitudes using PD oscillation stimulation (n = 7). E. Mean depression index for square 760
pulse (open bars) and oscillation (closed bars) stimulation across PD stimulation voltages. * 761
indicates that the depression index for PD square pulse stimulation is significantly greater than 762
for PD oscillation stimulation (p < 0.001 for all PD voltages). The depression index did not 763
show voltage dependence with either stimulation protocol (p > 0.20 for both). 764
765
Figure 2. Synaptic depression and recovery at the PDLP graded synapse. A. Mean τDep 766
across PD square pulse stimulation voltages (n = 11). τDep did not show any voltage dependence 767
(p = 0.95). B. Measurement of the time constant of LP gIPSP recovery from depression (τRec) in 768
response to PD square pulse depolarization to -25 mV. C. Measurement of τRec using PD 769
oscillation depolarization to -25 mV. D. Mean τRec for LP gIPSPs elicited by PD square pulse (n 770
= 13) and oscillation (n = 10) stimulation. * indicates significantly longer τRec with PD 771
oscillation stimulation (p = 0.003). 772
773
Figure 3. Dopamine (10-5M) modulation of synaptic strength at the PDLP synapse. 774
Examples of variable effects of DA to reversibly enhance (A), reduce (B), or have no effect (C) 775
on the initial LP gIPSP amplitude with PD square pulse stimulation. D. Mean effects of DA on 776
amplitudes of initial peak and steady state LP gIPSPs elicited by PD square pulse (initial peak, 777
open bars; steady state, light gray bars) and oscillation stimulation (initial peak, closed bars; 778
34
steady state, dark gray bars) at -25 mV PD depolarization. E. Example showing DA 779
enhancement of the initial peak gIPSP during PD oscillation stimulation. 780
781
Figure 4. Dopamine acceleration of synaptic depression and recovery at the PDLP synapse. 782
A. Mean effects of DA on τDep (left open bars; n = 5), and τRec (middle open bars; n = 5) for PD 783
square pulse stimulation, and for τRec during PD oscillation stimulation (right closed bars; n = 4). 784
* indicates significantly shorter τ in DA compared to control conditions (p < 0.005 for all). B. 785
Example showing more rapid recovery of gIPSP amplitude during DA after a 1 sec interval 786
following PD oscillation stimuli, and no effect of DA on the initial peak gIPSP. Gray lines mark 787
the amplitude of the initial peak gIPSP. C. Lack of correlation between DA effects on initial 788
peak LP gIPSP and its effects on depression and recovery in individual experiments. Open 789
squares, τDep and open circles, τRec for PD square pulse stimulation; closed circles, τRec for PD 790
oscillation stimulation. 791
792
Figure 5. Octopamine (10-5M) enhances synaptic strength and reduces synaptic depression at 793
the PDLP synapse. Examples showing Oct enhancement of initial peak and steady state gIPSP 794
amplitudes using PD square pulse (A) and oscillation stimulation (B). Black traces, control 795
conditions; gray traces, Oct. C. Oct enhances mean absolute amplitudes of initial peak and 796
steady state LP gIPSPs elicited by PD square pulse (initial peak, open bars; steady state, light 797
gray bars; n = 5) and oscillation stimulation (initial peak, closed bars; steady state, dark gray 798
bars; n = 4) at -25 mV PD depolarization. *: significant increase (p < 0.004 for all); #: Oct 799
enhances the initial peak gIPSP amplitude significantly less than the steady state gIPSP during 800
PD square pulse stimulation (p = 0.04). D. Oct significantly decreases synaptic depression with 801
PD square pulse but not with oscillation stimulation at -25 mV PD depolarization. *: significant 802
reduction (p < 0.0001). 803
804
Figure 6. Octopamine modulation of synaptic depression and recovery at the PDLP synapse. 805
A. Octopamine increases τDep (left open bars; n = 5) and decreases τRec (right open bars; n = 4) at 806
-25 mV PD square pulse depolarization. *: significant effects (p < 0.03 for both). B. Example 807
using PD square pulse depolarizations of differing amplitudes to adjust the LP gIPSP to the same 808
amplitude under control and Oct conditions, showing the Oct-induced increase in τDep in size 809
35
matched LP gIPSPs (control, black traces; Oct, gray traces). C. Example of normalized initial 810
peak gIPSPs in control (black traces) and Oct (gray traces), with more rapid gIPSP recovery in 811
Oct during PD square pulse depolarizations to -25 mV. 812
813
Figure 7. Serotonin (10-5M) decreases synaptic strength and enhances synaptic depression at the 814
PDLP synapse. Examples showing 5HT reduction of initial peak and steady state gIPSP 815
amplitudes using PD square pulse (A) and oscillation stimulation (B). Black traces, control 816
conditions; gray traces, 5HT. C. 5HT reduces the amplitudes of initial peak and steady state LP 817
gIPSPs elicited by PD square pulse (initial peak, open bars; steady state, light gray bars; n = 4) 818
and oscillation stimulation (initial peak, closed bars; steady state, dark gray bars; n = 6) at -25 819
mV PD depolarization. *: significant at p < 0.005 for both stimulation protocols. D. 5HT 820
increases synaptic depression. *: significant at p < 0.004 for both stimulation protocols. 821
822
Figure 8. Serotonin modulation of kinetics of synaptic depression and recovery at the PDLP 823
synapse. A. 5HT reduces τDep (left open bars; n = 4) and has only weak effects on τRec (middle 824
open bars; n = 3) using -25 mV PD square pulse depolarization, and τRec (right closed bars; n = 825
5) using -25 mV PD oscillation depolarization. *: significant at p = 0.002. B. Example with PD 826
square pulse depolarizations adjusted in control and 5HT conditions to show the 5HT-induced 827
acceleration of τDep in size matched LP gIPSPs (control, black traces; 5HT, gray traces). C. 828
Example showing normalized initial peak gIPSPs in control (black traces) and 5HT (gray traces), 829
and more rapid gIPSP recovery in 5HT 1 sec after the end of PD oscillations. Gray lines mark 830
the amplitudes of initial peak gIPSPs. 831
832
833
834
835
PD
LP
-55 mV
-50 mV
10 mV
steady state
1 s
2 mVτDep
A
2 mV1 s
steady stateinitial peak
B
D
-45 -40 -35 -30 -25
0
2
4
6
8
PD Potential (mV)
PD OscillationC
LPgIPSP(mV)
-45 -40 -35 -30 -25
0
2
4
6
8
steady state
initial peak
PD Square Pulse
PD Potential (mV)
E
-40 -35 -30 -250
0.8
0.4
0.6
0.2DepressionIndex
* * **PD Square
PD Oscillation
PD Potential (mV)
A
C D
PD
LP
τRec = 2900 ms
-55 mV-50 mV
PDSquare
3000
1500
1000
500
0
2000
2500
gIPSP
τ Rec(ms)
*
1 mV
1 s
20 mV
PDOscillation
B
PD Potential (mV)
PD
LP
τRec = 516 ms
-55 mV
-50 mV
-40 -35 -30 -25
800
600
400
200
0
gIPSP
τ Dep(ms)
10 mV
1 mV
1 s
Ctl
DAWash
PD
-55 mV
LP
-50 mV
B
C-50 mV DA
-50 mV
DA
Ctl
WashCtl
LPgIPSP(mV)
PD Oscillation
DA CtlCtl DA
PD Square
10
8
6
4
2
0
DA
EPD
LP
10 mV
2 mV
5 mV
2 mV
1 s DA 1 s
1 mV
-50 mV-55 mV
10 mV
25
0
-25
-50
-75
-100100 150500-50
%Change
τ
% Change Initial Peak gIPSP
C
τDepτRecSqτRecOsc
BPD
LP
-55 mV
-50 mV
-50 mV
1 s
1 mV
1 mV
Ctl
DA
10 mV
A
gIPSP
τ(ms)
PDSquare
PDSquare
2500
1500
1000
500
0
2000
Ctl DA Ctl CtlDA DA
*
**
τRecτRecτDep
PDOscillation
BAPD
LP5 mV
1 s 1 s5 mV
-50 mV
-55 mV
Oct
Ctl
10 mV
Oct
10 mV
DC
LPgIPSP(mV)
PD Square Pulse
0
6
9
12
15
3 steady state
initial peak
PD OscillationPD Square PD OscillationPD Square
DepressionIndex
0
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.2
**
*
*
*#
Oct CtlCtl Oct Oct CtlCtl Oct
CPD
LP
-55 mV
-50 mV
10 mV
1 mV
1 s1 mV
B
A
gIPSP
τ(ms)
PD Square PD Square
900
600
300
0
1200
Ctl Oct Ctl Oct
PD
LP
-55 mV
-50 mV
1 s
5 mV
Ctl
Oct10 mV
**
Ctl
Oct
τRecτDep
BA
2 mV
1 s
10 mV
DC
LPgIPSP(mV)
PD Square Pulse
0
4
6
8
2
PD OscillationPD Square
**
*
PD OscillationPD Square
DepressionIndex
0
0.4
0.6
0.8
0.2
*
-50 mV
-55 mV
PD
LP Ctl
5HT
Ctl
10 mV
1 s
5 mV
*
*
*
5HT CtlCtl 5HT 5HT CtlCtl 5HT
1 s
2 mV
Ctl
5HT
5HT
Ctl
-50 mV
-55 mV
PD
LP
10 mV
C
B
A
gIPSP
τ(ms)
PDSquare
PDSquare
1800
1200
600
0
2400
Ctl 5HT Ctl 5HT
*
*
Ctl 5HTPD
Oscillation
τDep τRecτRec
*
PD
LP
-55 mV-50 mV
10 mV
1 s1 mV
1 mV
5HT
Ctl