Bennett, Ch. 8 THE FUTURE OF NEWS: SOLUTIONS FOR CITIZENS, POLITICIANS, & JOURNALISTS.

transcript

Bennett, Ch. 8

THE FUTURE OF NEWS: SOLUTIONS FOR CITIZENS, POLITICIANS, & JOURNALISTS

REMEMBER THESE PROBLEMS…

• 4 information biases

• Sensational political campaigns

• Decline of objective journalism

• Market-based values in journalism

• Failure of media to serve as 4th estate

• Growing reliance on opinion news and entertainment media

• Potential of web 2.0 and the internet is not embraced by all

6 PROPOSALS FOR CITIZENS1. Think critically about our current news

2. Recognize stereotypes, plot formulas, and spin

3. Look for information that doesn’t fit the plot

4. Seek additional sources of information to partisan claims

5. Learn to become self-critical

6. Think critically about alternatives

6 PROPOSALS FOR CITIZENS

1. Think Critically About Our Current News

• Go beyond understanding who, what, where, when, and how

• See beyond the images and read between the lines

• Decode news with an analytical eye for the causes and consequences of events

• Don’t be cynical, be critical

• Don’t distrust all authority, trust your own judgment

6 PROPOSALS FOR CITIZENS2. Recognize Stereotypes, Plot Formulas, and Spin

• Trust named sources over anonymous sources

• Be wary of inflammatory labels (e.g., religious fundamentalists, socialist) and dig deeper

• Know the language of spin (e.g., terrorist vs. freedom fighter)

• Know a pseudo-event when you see one

3. Look for Information That Doesn’t Fit the Plot

• Go beyond rhetoric

• Search for documented facts

• Understand political agendas and reasons for spin

4. Seek Additional Sources of Information to Check Partisan Claims

• In-depth documentaries

• Alternative publications: Examples: Opednews and Human Events

• Critics and opposition groups

• Academic observers

• International news sites: BBC, The Guardian, Al Jazeera

• Political comedy: The Daily Show, Bill Maher, Dennis Miller, The Onion

5. Learn to Become Self-Critical

• Know your prejudices and challenge them

• Don’t let prejudices get in the way of facts and reality

• Beliefs should be flexible rather than absolute

• Don’t limit your news to confirmatory news

6. Think Critically About Alternatives

• Should we encourage partisan political reporting?

• More analysis in news stories?

• Watch more perspective-building political comedy?

IN-CLASS ASSIGNMENT #21• Which do you like the best?

• Which are most practical for you?

1. Think critically about our current news

2. Recognize stereotypes, plot formulas, and spin

3. Look for information that doesn’t fit the plot

4. Seek additional sources of information to partisan claims

5. Learn to become self-critical

6. Think critically about alternatives

5 PROPOSALS FOR JOURNALISTS1. Use Personalization And Dramatization Creatively

2. Include More Of The Journalist’s Background Knowledge Into Stories

3. Resist The Standard Plot Formulas

4. Define Politics In Terms That Appeal To Ordinary People

5. So What? Explain Why The Story Matters

5 PROPOSALS FOR JOURNALISTS

1. Use Personalization and Dramatization Creatively

• Thematic reporting of issues

• Social, institutional, and historical personalization and dramatization

• Avoid the bizarre, grotesque, and sinister personalization and dramatization

2. Include More of the Journalist’s Background Knowledge into Stories

• Avoid complete reliance on sources to tell the story

• Move toward observer-centered narrative

• Use their expertise to tell the story

3. Resist The Standard Plot Formulas

• Lessen the typical plot and language (e.g., horseraces for elections)

• Increase the thematic, social, institutional, and historical plots

4. Define Politics In Terms That Appeal To Ordinary People

• News today is more and more for the already-informed

• Explain definitions, events, meanings, etc., to encourage comprehension

5. So What? Explain Why The Story Matters

• People are busy and need help with whittling down information

• No time to “read between the lines”

• Explicitly report why a story is reported and featured

5 PROPOSALS FOR POLITICIANS & GOVERNMENT

1. Limit The Flow Of Money To Politicians

2. Develop Better Formats For Candidate Debates And Coverage Of Legislation

3. Control Media Monopolies

4. Provide More Funding And More Creative Mandate For Public Broadcasting

5. Strengthen Public Service Requirements For Cable And Broadcast License Holders

• Corporations are treated like constituents

• Campaign finance reform needed

• Debates now are watered-down; candidates stick to talking points

• Create debates that are truly open and probing issue exchanges

• Legislation coverage is too horserace-oriented

• Need legislation coverage with explanation of policy issues

• Press freedom vs. corporate freedom

• More channels, but same information

• Need laws to discourage media monopolies

• More government funding to avoid corporate sponsorship

• Allow creativity of programming

• Political party channels, public interest channel, social group channels

• Free public airwaves

• Government grants licenses to use them

• Require public affairs programs, community forums, community access

• Keep net neutrality

IN-CLASS ASSIGNMENT #22• Do you agree with Bennett’s proposals for government intervention?

• Which are most practical?

TO SUM IT UP• http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NA5KaAr7eno&feature=related

• Robert McChesney is Founder and President of Free Press, a non-profit media reform organization, professor at the University of Illinois and the author and editor of several books on media and democracy.

Bennett, Ch. 8 THE FUTURE OF NEWS: SOLUTIONS FOR CITIZENS, POLITICIANS, & JOURNALISTS.

Documents