Post on 27-May-2015
description
transcript
Brandon Webb - CJ 242 04/12/2023 1
CASE 8500063AXC
MIKE TEMPLEITT
DORMITORYPORTLAND, OR.
Methodology, findings, and conclusion
HOMICIDE INVESTIGATION
Occurred 11/9/09: Mike Temple, deceased 6’4”, 235 lbs. 28 years old Caucasian Student at ITT; living in dorm Found by dean Last seen by I.T. instructor (Dr. House)
at class; 2230 Seen arguing with James Jackson over
lab project Smokes Marlboro lights
INVESTIGATION
James Jackson African-American 6’2”, 200 lbs. Smokes Marlboro menthols Dr. House did not see Jackson leave
building
INVESTIGATION
Deceased found lying face down in dorm room (possibly in pool of blood)
Wearing blue t-shirt and blue jeans Shirt torn at the neck Wallet not found on person Turned vic over, scratches on face and
neck Bullet hole on front of blood stained
shirt Slight case of rigor mortis 78 degrees inside room
INVESTIGATION
Elvira Black Caucasian 5’6”, 125 lbs. Dark hair (often died black or red) Known to wear white face paint/black lipstick “Goth” Lives off campus, attends same classes as vic and
Jackson Dating vic, friends w/Jackson Last seen entering vic’s dorm 2300 Regular visits to dorm Whereabouts unknown Executed search warrant on apartment, found pistol
INVESTIGATION
Questioning revealed Temple also dating Bambi White
Caucasian 5’10”, 127 lbs. long blonde hair Wears a lot of make up/perfume Painted nails/jewelry Exotic dancer, does not attend school Vic “snuck” Bambi into dorm She did not work on night of homicide With “special customer” Consented to search Took hair/blood samples/fingerprints Searched home/car, found semi auto handgun
SECURING THE SCENE
Taped off entrance to dorm room Called for back up units Placed officer outside dorm room Restricted access to detectives and crime
scene technicians After questioning, cleared residents out of
floor of crime scene with help of dean Placed officers at points of ingress/egress for
authorized entry/exit only Closed off elevator use to dorm residents,
must use stairs Utilized mobile lab to store and transport
evidence
RECORDING THE SCENE
Crime scene tech team arrive Photographed: Scene in unaltered state All areas in dorm Body; in relation to evidence and scene After body removed Completed rough sketch including
essential info and measurements Completed precise computer-drafted
finished sketch
CRIME SCENE SKETCH
EVIDENCE: CRIME SCENE PHOTOGRAPHS
Blood spatter: 15 ft. from victim’s body
EVIDENCE:CRIME SCENEPHOTOGRAPHS
Blood trail
CRIME SCENE
CRIME SCENE
CRIME SCENE
CRIME SCENE
CRIME SCENE
CRIME SCENE
CRIME SCENE
RECORDING THE SCENE
Detailed notes taken: (Sandra, Jill, Amy) Description of scene Location of items Location of physical evidence recovered Time evidence discovered Who discovered How discovered How/Who packaged, marked Disposition of item after collected Maintain proper chain of custody
INVESTIGATION: NOTES
SYSTEMATIC EVIDENCE SEARCH
Appointed techs Phil and Brandon for evidence search
Phil served as control/supervisor Utilized spiral search method beginning
at door of dorm All techs/detectives authorized to enter
crime scene required to wear ppe/safety equipment to avoid transference
Investigative requirements performed separately to minimize traffic
EVIDENCE COLLECTION
EVIDENCE: CHAIN OF CUSTODY
COLLECTING/PACKAGING EVIDENCE
Tools: Forceps Paper bags Plastic sealable pouches Swabs Gloves Goggles Face shields Protective suits Shoe covers
COLLECTING/PACKAGING EVIDENCE
All items obtained as evidence properly packaged and marked
Hair, DNA (cigarette butts), blood (spatter) packaged in plastic pouches and marked
Ashtray, rock star can, tissue, buss pass, t-shirt, hat, firearms packaged and marked in paper bags
Obtained reference samples: hairs, DNA swabs, fingerprints, firearm
SUBMITTING EVIDENCE
All evidence obtained delivered in person to the lab for analysis via mobile crime lab coordinated by Phillips
Items submitted with evidence submission form
Types of analysis requested on evidence noted on form
List of all items obtained as evidence submitted on form
CRIME SCENE: LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS
No evidence was obtained improperly Search and seizure performed at
Black’s apartment based on search warrant
Search and seizure performed on White based on consent from White
Evidence obtained at crime scene with consent of school
PHYSICAL EVIDENCE
Types in relation to homicide investigation:
Blood Fingerprints Firearms/Ammunition Hair Impressions Powder residues
EVIDENCE ANALYSIS
Blood: DNA typing ID blood as victim’s at
scene Hair: Microscopic comparison performed
matching samples from White to hair found at scene
CODIS and AFIS analysis provided no significant matches
CODIS analysis provided profile of African-American from cigarette butt
EVIDENCE ANALYSIS
Fingerprints: Lab comparison analysis matching
prints on White’s handgun and on coffee cup found at scene to prints taken from White
Luminal analysis located blood on White’s shirt
Shell casing: Match found after test fire with White’s
handgun
FINDINGS
FINDINGS
EVIDENCE: PRINTS
CONCLUSION FROM FINDINGS
Likely suspect in homicide: Bambi White 5’10”, 127 lbs. Caucasian, blonde hair,
painted nails, make up, perfume Known to be dating Temple Does not attend ITT or live on campus Temple “Sneaks” White into dorm Bambi claims to have not seen Temple on
night of homicide. Last saw Temple week prior
Bambi consented to supply hair and blood samples; consented to fingerprinting
Consented to search of apartment and vehicle
EVIDENCE CONNECTING WHITE TO HOMICIDE
Partial shoe print found at crime scene, match to White’s sandals
Shell casing 9mm, weapon located from White’s car, 9mm semi-automatic handgun. Test fire confirms casing is a match to White’s handgun
Hairs located on Temple’s shirt determined to be blonde; match with White’s hair samples
Print lifted from handgun match with partial print found on coffee cup found in dorm prints match White’s prints
Lipstick on cigarette butt, lipstick on coffee cup consistent with White’s lipstick
White has long-painted fingernails, victim had scratches on face and neck, consistent with fingernail scratches
Performed luminal test on Bambi’s shirt, consistent with spatter
RECONSTRUCTION OF CRIME SCENE
Evidence places Bambi at dorm on night of homicide Temple and White agree to get together at dorm Temple sneaks Bambi in (no sign of forced entry, vic knew
perpetrator) No one saw her enter/leave that evening Possible Bambi was angry with Temple, may have discovered
he was seeing Elvira, Mike may have broken up with Bambi Visit started out civil, coffee cup cigarettes Bambi confronts Mike about Elvira, argument ensues
(physical) Hair transfer, blood transfer Bambi scratches Mike pulls weapon then shoots Mike at
point blank range Possible Mike fell on/towards Bambi causing her to
move/step in blood Possible rag was used to clean blood off Bambi Mike either stumbled and collapsed or was placed Bambi leaves
OPPORTUNITY/MOTIVE
Opportunity Night Snuck into dorm
by Temple Temple knew
Bambi Very few if no
one else around Quick egress
Motive Anger/jealousy High school
sweet heart May have
learned about Elvira
Mike may have tried to break up with Bambi