Post on 28-Jul-2020
transcript
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Human Rights Committee –
103rd session
Geneva, 17 October – 4 November 2011
Follow-up table: addendum to the report of the Special Rapporteur on follow-up to concluding observations of the Human Rights Committee
(103rd session, October 2011)
Reply of the State party
External information received
Meetings held with the State party
Recommended actions to be taken before the next session
1
United Nations
International Covenant onCivil and Political Rights
Distr.: Restricted
13 October 2011
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
BALANCE OCT. 2011 (since July 2006) Number of States parties
Total of states parties considered under the FU procedure since 2006 51
FU process discontinued as new periodic report due 13
FU process completed 3 (Austria, Monaco, San Marino)
FU process continues 35
STATE PARTY Report considered
COB
Paragraphs under review
Date FU info. due
Correspondence exchanged / measures taken
Evaluation of information provided by SP
State of FU process and recommended actions
Next periodic report due
Acceptance of LOIPR
87th session: July 2006
Central African Republic
Second report submitted 03/06/2005
CCPR/C/CAF/CO/2
Paras. 11, 12 , 13
27/7/2007 No information received from SP
FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
1/8/2010
2
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
28/09/2007: Reminder sent
10/12/2007: Reminder sent
20/02/2008: Request for SP meeting
18/03/2008: Request for SP meeting
01/04/2008: Consultations during 92nd session. No responses provided.
11/06/2008: Reminder sent
22/09/2008: Reminder sent
16/12/2008: Request for SP meeting
29/05/2009: Reminder sent
02/02/2010: Request for SP meeting
25/06/2010: Request for SP meeting
28/09/2010: SP invited to reply to all COB in next periodic report
13/10/2010: Consultations during 100th session. No reply received.
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
3
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
USA Combined second and third report submitted 28/11/2005 (due 1998)
CCPR/C/USA/CO/3/Rev.1
Paras. 12, 13, 14, 16, 20, 26. Also requested to report on implementation at both federal and state level, as well as the adoption of mechanisms for follow-up
27/7/2007 FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
01/08/2010
28/09/2007: Reminder sent
01/11/2007: Partial reply 12, 13, 14, 16, 26 incomplete. 20 complete?
11/06/2008: Request for SP meeting
10/07/2008: Meeting during 93rd
4
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
session
06/05/2009: Reminder sent
15/07/2009: Partial reply 12, 13: satisfactory in parts. 14, 16, 26: incomplete
26/04/2010: SP invited to reply to all COB in next periodic report
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
UNMIK Report submitted 07/02/2006.
CCPR/C/UNK/CO/1
Paras. 12, 13, 18
21/01/2007 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/04/2015
April – Sept. 2007: 3 reminders sent
10/12/2007: request for a meeting
11/03/2008: SP reply Incomplete
11/06/2008: new request for a meeting
22/07/2008: meeting held Additional info provided - incomplete
5
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
07/11/2008: SP reply Incomplete
03/06/2009: request for additional information
27/08/2009: Reminder about above request
12/11/2009: Information received – measures partially implemented
28/09/2010: Letter sent: none of the recommendation fully implemented
10/05/2011: Letter sent: meeting required
30/06/2011: SP agreed to meeting
20/07/2011: Meeting held Agreement: UNMIK will send additional information before the October session.
09/09/2011: Reply received Two letters should be sent:
1. Letter to UNMIK:
6
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
- take note of the Mission’s inability to implement the recommendations of the Committee
- thank UNMIK’s commitment to coordinate the elaboration of a consolidated report between the other actors involved in the promotion of human rights in Kosovo
- indicate that the information should be submitted to the Committee by the 15th January 2012.
2. A letter by the Chair of the Committee to the Office of Legal Affairs (Mrs. O’Brian) to request advice on the general status of
7
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Kosovo and on the strategy to adopt in the future to maintain the dialogue of the Committee with Kosovo.
88th session: October 2006
Honduras Initial report submitted 21/02/2005 (due 1998)
CCPR/C/HND/CO/1
Paras. 9, 10, 11, 19
27/10/2007 FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
31/10/2010
07/01/2007: reply of SP Answer not relevant to recommendations
20/01/2007: additional information requested
01/01/2008: reminder
11/06/2008: 2nd reminder
8
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
22/09/2008: request for a meeting
15/10/2008: reply of SP Initial actions taken – implementation still pending
10/12/2008: request for additional information
06/05/2009: reminder
27/08/2009: 2nd reminder
02/02/2009: request for a meeting.
28/09/2010: request for a meeting (reminder).
Oct. 2010: External info received – CCPR (CPTRT)
Par. 10
21/10/2010: meeting held. Progress made but additional action required
16/12/2010: invitation to reply to COB as a whole in next periodic report (due 31 October 2010).
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Initial report submitted
01/11/2007 FU procedure discontinued: new
01/11/2010
9
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
24/11/2005 (due 2003)
CCPR/C/BIH/CO/1
Paras. 8, 14, 19, 23
periodic report due
21/12/2007: Partial reply All incomplete
17/01/2008: Reminder sent
22/09/2008: Requested SP meeting
Oct. 2008: External info received – CCPR (Helsinki Committee)
Paras. 8, 14, 19, 23
31/10/2008: Meeting during 94th session. Reply to be submitted after govt. Approval
01/11/2008: Partial reply All incomplete
04/03/2009: Partial reply All incomplete
29/05/2009: Add. info requested
27/08/2009: Reminder sent
11/12/2009: Reminder sent
14/12/2009: Supplementary follow-up report
8: implementation begun but not
10
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
completed
14,19: partially satisfactory
23: Cooperative but incomplete
11/12/2009: SP invited to reply to all COB in next periodic report (due 01/11/2010)
Sept. 2010: External info received – TRIAL
Par. 14 NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
Ukraine Sixth report submitted 03/11/1999
CCPR/C/UKR/CO/6
Paras. 7, 11, 14, 16
02/11/2007 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues.
02/11/2011
17/01/2008: Reminder sent
19/05/2008: Partial reply All incomplete
06/05/2008: Add. info requested
Oct. 2008: External info received – CCPR (UHHRU, International
Paras. 7, 11, 14, 16
11
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Renaissance Foundation, Donetsk, Vinnytsya Human Rights protection group, Kharkiv Human Rights Group)
06/05/2009: Reminder sent
28/08/2009: Supplementary follow-up report
7: part incomplete, part unimplemented, 11,16: part satisfactory, part incomplete, 14: incomplete
26/04/2010: Letter sent asking for supplemental information and underlining unimplemented recommendations
28/09/2010: Reminder sent
19/04/2011: Reminder sent
10/05/2011: Request for a meeting
2/08/2011: Reminder of request for a meeting
Letter to SP informing that the FU procedure has come to an end and that the requested FU
12
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
information should be included in the next periodic report due on 2/11/2011
Republic of Korea
Third report submitted 10/02/2005
CCPR/C/KOR/CO/3
Paras. 12, 13, 18
02/11/2007 FU procedure discontinued: additional information to be included in next periodic report
02/11/2010
17/01/2008: Reminder sent
25/02/2008: Partial reply 12,13: incomplete 18: unsatisfactory
11/06/2008: Request for SP meeting
21/07/2008: Meeting during 93rd session. Add. info to be provided in next periodic report
22/07/2008: Letter summarizing outstanding issues sent
06/05/2008: Reminder sent
27/08/2009: Reminder sent NO OTHER ACTION
13
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
RECOMMENDED
89th session March 2007
Madagascar Third report submitted 24/05/2005 (due 1992)
CCPR/C/MDG/CO/3
Paras. 7, 24, 25
23/03/2008 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due.
23/03/2011
11/06/2008: Reminder sent
22/09/2008: Reminder sent
16/12/2008: Request for SP meeting
03/03/2009: Partial reply 7,24,25 incomplete
29/05/2009: Add. info requested
03/09:2009: Reminder sent
11/12/2009: Reminder sent
25/06/2010: Request for SP meeting
28/09/2010: Reminder sent
14
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
10/05/2011: Reminder sent
17/05/2011: Follow-up response dated 29/09/2010
The follow-up replies should be included in the analysis of the next periodic report.
Chile Fifth report submitted 07/02/2006 (due 2002)
CCPR/C/CHL/CO/5
Paras. 9, 19
26/03/2008 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/04/2012
11/06/2008: Reminder sent
22/09/2008: Reminder sent
21 & 31/10/2008: Partial reply 9,19: incomplete on certain issues
10/12/2008: Add. info requested
25/03/2009: External info received – CCPR (Centro de Derechos Humanos,
Paras. 9, 19
15
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Universidad Diego Portales; Observatorio de Derechos de los Pueblos Indígenas)
22/06/2009: Requested SP meeting
28/07/2009: Meeting with SP. Add. info in preparation to be sent ASAP.
11/12/2009: Reminder sent
23/04/2010: Reminder sent
28/05/2010: Supp. follow-up report 9,19: incomplete on certain issues
16/12/2010: Letter sent specifying add. info needed and which recommendations had not been adequately implemented
31/01/2011: Letter demanding clarifications on the add. info requested.
20/04/2011: Letter clarifying what add. info was requested
02/08/2011: Reminder sent
16
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
5/10/2011: Reply of State party Analyse SP reply at the next session
Barbados Third report submitted 18/07/2006 (due 11/04/1991)
CCPR/C/BRB/CO/3
Paras. 9, 12, 13
29/03/2008 FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
29/03/2011
11/06/2008: Reminder sent
22/09/2008: Reminder sent
16/12/2008: Request for SP meeting
19/03/2009: External info received – CCPR (BONGO; Global Initiative to End All Corporal Punishment of Children; IGLHRC)
Paras. 9, 12, 13
31/03/2009: Meeting during 95th session. Partial reply received.
9: part largely satisfactory, part not implemented, 12: not implemented, 13: incomplete and not
17
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
implemented
29/07/2009: Add. info requested. Invited to include answers in next periodic report.
23/04/2010: Reminder sent
28/09/2010: Reminder sent
10/05/2011: SP invited to include requested additional information in next periodic report
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
90th session July 2007
Zambia Third report submitted 16/01/2006 (due 30/06/1998)
CCPR/C/ZMB/CO/3
Paras. 10, 12, 13, 23
20/07/2008 FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
20/07/2011
Sept. 2008 – May 2009: Three reminders sent
07/10/2009: Request for SP meeting
18
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
28/10/2009: SP meeting. Reply in preparation to be sent ASAP (Nov. 2009)
09/12/2009: Follow-up report 10: no reply, 12,13,23: incomplete
25/01/2010: External info received – CCPR (AWOMI; WILDAF; ZCEA)
Paras. 10, 12, 13, 23
26/04/2010: Add. info requested
28/09/2010: Reminder sent
28/01/2011: Reply Implementation partially initiated (10a and 23b), but further action required for other recommendations.
20/04/2011: SP invited to include requested additional information in next periodic report
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
Sudan Third report submitted 29/06/2006 (due 07/11/2001)
26/07/2008 FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
26/07/2010
19
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
CCPR/C/SDN/CO/3
Paras. 9, 11, 17
22/09/2008: Reminder sent
19/12/2008: Reminder sent
22/06/2009: Request for SP meeting
07/10/2009: Request for SP meeting
19/10/2009: FU report received. Annexes have not been received
9,11,17: incomplete. Replies to a number of paragraphs not requested for FU.
26/02/2010: Note verbale requesting the annexes
16/12/2010: Invited to reply in the next periodic report
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
Czech Republic
Second report submitted 24/05/2006 (due by 01/08/2005)
CCPR/C/CZE/CO/2
25/07/2008 FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
01/08/2011
20
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Paras. 9, 14, 16
June 2008: External info received – CCPR (Zvule Prava; Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions; European Roma Rights Centre; Peacework Development Fund)
Par. 16
11/06/2008: Reminder sent
18/08/2008: Partial reply 9,14,16: Incomplete
10/12/2008: Add. info requested
06/05/2009: Reminder sent
06/10/2009: Reminder sent
Feb. 2010: Request for SP meeting
22/03/2010 & 01/07/2010: Supp. FU report
9,14,16: incomplete
20/04/2011: Letter sent considering info satisfactory on 9c, 14a, 14c, 16c, 16d, 16f. Incomplete on 9a, 9b, 16e. 14b not implemented.
Letter to SP: the requested info should be included in the next periodic report
91st session October 2007
21
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Georgia Third report submitted (07/11/2006) (due in 01/04/2006)
CCPR/C/GEO/CO/3
Paras. 8, 9, 11
26/10/2008 FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
01/11/2011
16/12/2008: Reminder sent
13/01/2009: Partial reply 8,9,11: incomplete
29/05/2009: Add. info requested
27/08/2009: Reminder sent
28/10/2009: Add. info received 8,9,11: part satisfactory, part incomplete
28/09/2010: Complementary info requested on specific issues
20/04/2011: Reminder sent
02/08/2011: Reminder sent Letter to SP: the requested info should be included in the next periodic report
22
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Libyan Arab Jamahiriya
Fourth report submitted 05/12/2006 (due by 01/10/2002)
CCPR/C/LBY/CO/4
Paras. 10, 21, 23
30/10/2008 FU procedure discontinued
30/10/2010
30/10/2008: External info received – Alkarama for Human Rights
Paras. 21, 23
16/12/2008: Reminder sent
09/06/2009: Reminder sent
24/07/2009: Partial reply 10,21,23: part implemented, part incomplete
23/04/2010: Reminder sent and request for SP meeting
28/09/2010: Request for SP meeting
12/10/2010: Consultations with SP during 100th session. Demand to be conveyed to Govt.
18/11/2010: Confirmation letter of
23
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
above.
05/11/2010: FU report (hard copy) received
18/11/2010:request for FU report in word format
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
10/05/2011: Reminder sent that periodic report was five months overdue
Austria Fourth report submitted 21/07/2006 (due 01/10/2002)
CCPR/C/AUT/CO/4
11, 12, 16, 17
30/10/2008 FU completed (14/12/2009)
30/10/2012
15/10/2008: Partial reply 11,12,16,17: Incomplete
12/12/2008: Add. info requested
29/05/2009: Reminder sent
22/07/2009: Supp. FU report Largely satisfactory
24
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
23/07/2009: External info received – CCPR (asylkoordination Österreich; Integrationshaus; SOS Mitmensch)
Paras. 11, 12, 16, 17
14/12/2009: Letter sent stating FU procedure considered completed
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
Costa Rica Fifth report submitted 30/05/2006 (due 30/04/2004)
CCPR/C/CRI/CO/5
Paras. 9, 12
01/11/2008 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/11/2012
16/12/2008: Reminder sent
17/03/2009: Partial reply Cooperative but incomplete
30/07/2009: More precise comp. info requested
17/11/2009: Info received 9: incomplete, 12: mainly satisfactory
28/09/2010: Letter sent stating that 12 is satisfactory, requesting comp.
25
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
info on 9.
20/04/2011: Reminder sent A new reminder should be sent
Algeria Third report submitted 22/09/2006 (due 01/06/2000)
CCPR/C/DZA/CO/3
Para.: 11, 12, 15
01/11/2008 FU procedure discontinued: new periodic report due
01/11/2011
07/11/2007: FU reply (CCPR/C/DZA/CO/3/Add.1). 11,12,15 partial replies
30/10/2008: External info received – Algeria-Watch
Paras. 11, 12
05/11/2008: External info received – Alkarama for Human Rights
Paras. 11, 12, 15
16/12/2008: Reminder sent
14/01/2009 & 12/10/2009: Letter repeating position of memorandum, requesting memo to be issued as
26
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
annex to annual report
25/06/2010: Request for SP meeting
27/07/2010: Communication that SP representatives were available for the 99th session
28/07/2010: Request for SP meeting at 100th session
11/10/2010: Consultations with SP during 100th session. Request to be transmitted to Govt. No reply received.
16/12/2010: Invited SP to reply to COB in next periodic report.
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
92nd session March 2008
Tunisia Fifth report submitted 14/12/2006 (due 04/02/1998)
CCPR/C/TUN/CO/5
Paras. 11, 14, 20,
COB: 28/03/2009
CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
31/03/2012
27
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
21
16/03/2009: Partial reply 11: cooperation but incomplete, 14: not implemented, 20,21: acknowledged but imprecise info
11/03/2009: External info received – Alkarama for Human Rights
Paras. 11, 20
23/07/2009: External info received – CCPR/FIDH (CNLT; LTDH)
Paras. 11, 14, 20, 21
30/07/2009: Comp. info requested. Some issues not to be considered in the FU process, but should be dealt with in next periodic report.
Aug. 2009: External info received – OMCT
Paras. 11, 14, 20, 21
02/03/2010: Supp. FU report
04/10/2010: Letter noting issues on which FU discontinued and specifying requested info.
28
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
20/04/2011: Reminder sent informing that the next periodic report is due 31/3/2012
20/09/2011: Letter received asking to postpone the examination of Tunisia due to the January 2011 revolution.
Letter acknowledging the request of the State party and informing that the next periodic report is now due on 31 March 2014, but that the FU reply remains pending and should sent to the Committee within a year.
Botswana Initial report submitted 23/11/2006 (due 08/12/2001)
CCPR/C/BWA/CO/1
Paras. 12, 13, 14, 17
28/03/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
31/03/2012
08/09/2009: Reminder sent
29
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
11/12/2009: Reminder sent
28/09/2010: Request for meeting
19/04/2011: Request for meeting
06/07/2011: Positive response (for meeting) via telephone
27/07/2011: Meeting with Ambassador. Comp. info to be sent before the Oct. session 2011.
05/10/2011: FU report received 12, part 13, 17: incomplete
Part 13 and 14: not implemented
Letter asking the SP to provide additional info in its next periodic report on para. 12, 13, 17, and stating that part of 13 and 14 have not been implemented.
The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia
Second report submitted 06/11/2006 (due 01/06/2000)
CCPR/C/MKD/CO/2
03/04/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/04/2012
30
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Paras. 12, 14, 15
23/07/2009: External info received – CCPR (Helsinki Committee)
Paras. 12, 14, 15
27/08/2009: Reminder sent
31/08/2009: FU report 12,15: incomplete, 14: part unimplemented, part no reply
26/04/2010: Request for comp. info
28/09/2011: Reminder sent
20/04/2011: Reminder sent
24/06/2011: Partial reply
19/9/2011: Letter sent
- requesting additional info. on para. 15 and part of para. 12
- stating that no info was provided on part. of para 12 (investigation, prosecution and sanction of HR violations)
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
31
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
- requesting additional info on para. 14 in the next periodic report
Panama Third report submitted 09/02/2007 (due 31/03/1992)
CCPR/C/PAN/CO/3
Paras. 11, 14, 18
03/04/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
Considered to not be collaborating with the FU procedure
01/03/2012
27/08/2009: Reminder sent
11/12/2009: Reminder sent
23/04/2010: Reminder sent
28/09/2010: Request for SP meeting
19/04/2011: Request for SP meeting
June – July 2011: Four calls to the Perm. Mission but unable to confirm SP meeting
19/10/2011: Phone call to Permanent Mission recalling the request for a meeting. Said they will consult with the Representative and
32
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
reply to the request.
26/10/2011: Meeting with the SP. The ambassador, Mr. Navarro, indicated that the info will be provided by the PM in the forthcoming weeks.
None
93rd session July 2008
France Fourth report submitted 13/02/2007 (due 31/12/2000)
CCPR/C/FRA/CO/4
Paras. 12, 18, 20
COB: 22/07/2009
CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
31/07/2012
20/07/2009: FU report Largely satisfactory, 18,20: part incomplete
11/01/2010: Request for comp. info, FU procedure completed in certain issues
09/07/2010: Supp. FU report 12: largely
33
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
satisfactory, 18,12: part incomplete
16/12/2010: Letter specifying 12 as complete, comp. info requested for certain issues on 18,20
17/01/2011: Clarifications requested by the SP on the comp. info
20/04/2011: Letter sent specifying the comp. Info
02/08/2011:Reminder sent
08/11/2011:FU reply Analyse at the next session
San Marino Second report submitted 31/10/2006
CCPR/C/SMR/CO/2
Paras. 6, 7
COB: 22/07/2009
FU considered completed (09/05/2011)
31/07/2013
LOIPR: for adoption Oct. 2011
05/11/2010: Reply received Largely satisfactory
34
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
09/05/2011: Letter sent stating that replies are sufficient to consider the FU procedure completed.
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
Ireland Third report submitted 23/02/2007 (due 31/07/2005)
CCPR/C/IRL/CO/3
Paras. 11, 15, 22
23/07/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
31/07/2012
31/07/2009: Reply 11,15,22: incomplete, 15: not implemented
Aug. 2009: External info received – FLAC; ICCL; IPRT
Paras. 11, 15, 22
04/01/2010: Request comp. info. on 11
Consider FU procedure on 15 ,22 completed
28/09/2010: Reminder sent
21/12/2010: FU report 11: incomplete
35
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
25/04/2011: Letter sent stating that parts of 11 are complete, request comp. info on parts of 11.
2/8/2011: Reminder sent A second reminder should be sent
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
Sixth report submitted 01/11/2006 (due 01/11/2006)
CCPR/C/GBR/CO/6
Paras. 9, 12, 14, 15
18/07/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
31/07/2012
Aug. 2009: External info received – British Irish Rights Watch
Paras. 3-4, 6-11, 13-18, 24-39
07/08/2009: FU report 9: incomplete, 12: parts not replied to, 14: part implemented, part satisfactory, part incomplete, 15: part satisfactory, part incomplete
24/08/2009: External info received – Northern Ireland Human Rights
Par. 9
36
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Commission
26/04/2010: Request for comp. info on 9,14,15
28/09/2010: Reminder combined with request for comp. info on 12
10/11/2010: FU report 9,14: Incomplete, add. info required
20/04/2011: Request for comp. info on 9,14,15
02/08/2011: Reminder sent
19/10/2011: Reply of the State party Analyse SP reply at the next session
94th session October 2008
Nicaragua Third report submitted 20/06/2007 (due 11/06/1997)
CCPR/C/NIC/CO/3
Paras. 12,13,17,19
29/10/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
29/10/2012
37
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
23/04/2010: Reminder sent
08/10/2010: Reminder sent
20/04/2011: Request for SP meeting
04/05/2011: Positive response for meeting (through phone call), set to 18/07/2011, but no representative showed up.
02/08/2011:Reminder sent expressing regret that no representative showed up 18/07/2011, and requesting new meeting
11/10/2011: FU report and note verbale of the Permanent Mission explaining and apologizing for their absence at the July meeting.
Analyse SP reply at the next session
Monaco Second report submitted 04/03/2007 (due 01/08/2006)
CCPR/C/MCO/CO/2
28/10/2009 FU considered completed (08/10/08)
28/10/2013
LOIPR: for adoption Oct. 2011
38
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Para. 9
26/03/2010: FU report Largely satisfactory
08/10/08: Letter stating FU process completed and inviting SP to keep Ctte informed on developments of specific forms of violence + training of judges and officials
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
Denmark Fifth report submitted 23/07/2007 (due 31/10/2005)
CCPR/C/DNK/CO/5
Paras. 8, 11
28/10/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
31/10/2013
LOIPR: for adoption Oct. 2011
04/11/2009: FU report 8: incomplete, 11: largely satisfactory
28/01/2010: External info received – CCPR (The Danish Institute for Human Rights)
Par. 11
26/04/2010: Letter stating FU procedure complete for 11, request comp. info on 8
39
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
28/09/2010: Reminder sent
20/04/2011: Reminder sent
5/8/2011: SP reply 8: largely satisfactory
Letter to SP informing that the FU procedure has come to an end and taking note of the SP acceptance of the LOIPR procedure.
Japan Fifth report submitted 20/12/2006 (due in Oct. 2002)
CCPR/C/JPN/CO/5
Paras. 17,18,19,21
29/10/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
29/10/2011
01/12/2009: External info received – JWCHR; JLAF; KYUENKAI; League Demanding State Compensation for the Victims of the Public Order Maintenance Law)
Paras. 19, 21
40
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
21/12/2009: FU report 17: part unimplemented, part incomplete 18: incomplete, 19: part implemented, 21: part unimplemented, part satisfactory,
22/01/2010: External info received – Japan Federation of Bar Associations
Paras. 17, 18, 19, 21
28/09/2010: Add. Info necessary on 17,18,19, and specifying parts unimplemented in 17,19,21
Letter to SP stating that FU procedure has come to an end, and that the requested FU info should be included in the next periodic report due on 29/10/2011
Spain Fifth report submitted 11/12/2007 (due 28/04/1999)
CCPR/C/ESP/CO/5
30/10/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/11/2012
41
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Paras. 13, 15, 16
04/02/2010: External info received – CCPR (BEHATOKIA)
Paras. 11, 13, 14, 15, 19
23/04/2010: Reminder sent
16/06/2010: FU report 16: implementation begun, 13,15: implementation begun but not achieved
25/04/2011: Letter sent noting the beginning implementation of 16, and requesting add. info on 13,15
29/06/2011: Reply with add. Info on para. 13, 15, 16
22/09/2011: Letter sent requesting updated info to be included in next periodic report on progresses realized on para. 16; and additional info on 13; and stating that para. 15 not implemented.
NO OTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED
24/10/2011: Supplementary FU reply received.
The SP reply should be analysed at the next
42
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
session.
95th session March 2009
Australia Fifth report submitted 07/08/2007 (due 31/07/2005)
CCPRC/AUS/CO/5
Paras. 11,14,17,23
02/04/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
LOIPR: accepted.
01/04/2013
20/11/2009: External info received - Human Rights Law Resources Centre Ltd
Paras. 9-15, 17-21, 23, 25, 27
28/09/2010: Reminder sent
17/12/2010: FU report Implementation begun, but not achieved
19/10/2011: Letter sent requesting additional info on the implementation of 11, 14, 17
None
Rwanda Third report submitted 12/09/2007 (due
30/03/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
10/04/2013
43
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
in 1992)
CCPR/C/RWA/CO/3
Paras. 12,13,14,17
28/09/2010: Reminder sent
21/12/2010: FU report
15/01/2011: External info received – CCPR (LDGL)
Paras. 12, 13, 14, 17
25/04/2011: Add. info requested on 12,13,14,17
19/09/2011: English translation of letter previously sent in French (after request from SP)
None (see delay)
Sweden Sixth report submitted 20/07/2007 (due 01/04/2007)
CCPR/C/SWE/CO/6
Paras. 10,13,16,17
02/04/2009 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/04/2014
44
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
18/03/2010: FU report 10,13: largely satisfactory, 16: incomplete
17: Part implemented, part without response
28/09/2010: Letter stating that FU procedure is completed for 10, 13, requesting add. info for 13,17, highlight that 17 is not implemented.
24/10/2010: External info received – CCPR (Swedish Disability Federation)
Par. 10
20/04/2011: Reminder sent
5/08/2011: SP reply on para. 17 17: largely satisfactory
Letter to SP: the answers provided are largely satisfactory and the FU procedure has come to an end.
96th session July 2009
United Republic of Tanzania
Fourth report submitted 16/10/2007 (due
28/07/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/08/2013
45
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
June 2002)
CCPR/C/TZA/CO/4
Paras. 11,16,20
16/12/2010: Reminder sent
20/04/2011: Reminder sent
02/08/2011: Request for a meeting
19/10/2011: Phone call to the Permanent Mission asking for a reply to the request for a meeting. Said they will consult with the Representative, but that the person in charge of HR issues is away until the end of November.
A reminder should be sent
Kingdom of the Netherlands
Fourth report submitted 09/05/2007 (due 01/08/2006)
CCPR/C/NLD/CO/4
Paras. 7,9,23
28/07/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/07/2014
16/12/2010: Reminder sent
46
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
20/04/2011: Reminder sent
20/07/2011: phone call of Perm. Mission: reply should be sent before Oct. 2011 session.
16/09/2011: FU report received 9, 23: partially satisfactory
7: not implemented
Letter to SP requesting additional info on para. 9 and part of 23; updated info on part of para. 23; and stating that para. 7 has not been implemented
Chad Initial report submitted 18/09/2007 (due 08/09/1996)
CCPR/C/TCD/CO/1
Paras. 10,13,20,32
29/07/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
31/07/2012
16/12/2010: Reminder sent
20/04/2010: Reminder sent
02/08/2011: Request for a meeting
47
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
19/10/2011: Phone call to the Permanent Mission recalling the request for a meeting. Said they will consult with the Representative and reply to the request.
27/10/2011: Meeting with the SP: the First Secretary, Mr. Awada, informed that he will insist to get the reply from Chad as soon as possible.
None
Azerbaijan Third report submitted 04/10/2007 (due 01/11/2005)
CCPR/C/AZE/CO/3
Paras. 9,11,15,18
30/07/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
Send letter demanding add. info on 9,11,15,18; highlight implementation of 9,11
01/08/2013
06/07/2010: FU report – Sent to translation and received in June 2011
Add. Info necessary on all paragraphs
30/10/2011: Letter sent requesting additional information on all paragraphs.
None
48
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
97th session October 2009
Switzerland Third report submitted 12/10/2007 (due 01/11/2006)
CCPR/C/CHE/CO/3
Paras. 10,14,18
27/10/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
Send letter stating that answers to 10,14 do not satisfy the Cttee
01/01/2015
01/11/2010: FU report
22/02/2011: NGO reports – Humanrights.ch/MERS, Schweizerische Flüchtlingshilfe.
Paras. 10, 14, 18
25/04/2011: Letter of the HRC stating that 18 and parts of 14 are satisfactory. Requesting add. info on 10,14
30/08/2011 : letter sent : reply not satisfactory. Request for additional information (par. 14 et 10)
20/09/2011: SP reply Reply globally satisfactory (10, 14).
Letter informing that the FU procedure has come to an end, and recalling that the next
49
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
periodic report is due on 1/1/2015.
Republic of Moldova
Second report submitted 05/10/2007 (due 17/01/1992)
CCPR/C/MDA/CO/2
Paras. 8,9,16,18
29/10/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
31/10/2013
LOIPR: for adoption Oct. 2011
03/12/2010: FU report Implementation initiated, but not completed
05/03/2011: External report – Legal Resources Center (LCR), La Strada, Doina Ioana Straistenau Human Rights Lawyer, Promo Lex
Paras. 8, 9, 16, 18
06/06/2011: External report: UNCT
19/9/2011: Letter sent requesting additional info. on para. 9a, 9b, 16, 18b and stating that no info was provided on para. 8b and 18 (recommendation not implemented)
None (see delay)
50
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Croatia Second report submitted 28/11/2007 (due 01/04/2005)
CCPR/C/HRV/CO/2
Paras. 5,10,17
28/10/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
30/10/2013
LOIPR: accepted
17/01/2011: Reply 5: part satisfactory, part incomplete, 10,17: incomplete
09/05/2011: Letter sent stating that implementation had begun but not completed. Add. info requested on 5,10. Init. info requested on 17.
14/06/2011: Reply to the request of additional information
10(c): largely satisfactory
5, 10(a), 10(b): incomplete
17: not implemented
Letter informing that the reply was largely satisf. for 10(c), that 17 has not been implemented, and requesting add. info. on 5, 10(a), 10(b).
Russian Federation
Sixth report submitted 20/12/2007 (due
28/10/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
01/11/2012
51
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
01/11/2007)
CCPR/C/RUS/CO/6
Paras. 13,14,16,17
22/10/2010: FU report Not implemented
01/03/2011: External info received – CCPR (Memorial; AGORA; International Youth Human Rights Movement; Civil Assistance)
Paras. 14, 16, 17
Feb. 2011: External info received – Amnesty International
Paras. 13, 14, 16
19/10/2011: Letter sent requesting additional information on para. 13, 14, 16.
None (see delay)
Ecuador Combined periodic reports 5 and 6 submitted 22/01/2008 (due 2001 and 2006 respectively)
CCPR/C/ECU/CO/5
Paras. 9, 13, 19
29/10/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
30/10/2013
52
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
10/05/2011: Reminder sent
31/05/2011: SP reply Incomplete
20/09/2011: External info received –(Comisión Ecuménica de Derechos Humanos – CCPR)
Paras. 9, 13, 19 Letter requiring additional information on para. 9, 19 and 13
98th session March 2010
New Zealand Fifth report submitted 25/11/2008 (due 31/10/2003)
CCPR/C/NZL/CO/5
Paras. 12, 14, 19
25/03/2010 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
30/3/2015
LOIPR: accepted
19/04/2011: SP reply
2/8/2011: Reminder sent
11/04/2011 (not received until August 2011): reply of the SP
12, 14, 19: incomplete
20/10/2011: External info received – AIR Trust
Paras. 12, 14, 19 (erroneously labelled as 16)
Letter to SP requesting additional information on para. 12, 14, 19
53
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Mexico Fourth Report submitted 17/07/2008 (due 31/07/2002)
CCPR/C/MEX/CO/5
Paras. 8, 9, 15, 20
23/03/2011 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
30/03/2014
21/3/2011: SP reply 8, 9: Largely satisfactory; 15, 20: incomplete
22/9/2011: additional information requested on 15, 20. Updated info requested in next periodic report on 8, 9.
None
Argentina Fourth report submitted 17/12/2008
CCPR/C/ARG/CO/4
Paras. 17,18,25
23/03/2011 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
30/03/2014
24/05/2011: Reply 17, 18, 25: incomplete
29/06/2011: External info received – Paras. 17, 18
54
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
La Memoria de la Provincia de Buenos Aires
30/06/2011: External info received – CELS
Paras. 17, 18, 25
18/07/2011: External info received - Ministry of Justice and Human Rights, Mendoza Province
22/09/2011: Additional information requested on para. 17, 18, 25
None
Uzbekistan Third report submitted 31/03/2008
CCPR/C/UZB/CO/3
Paras. 8,11,14,24
24/03/2011 CCPR/C/102/2: FU procedure continues
30/03/2013
2/8/2011: Reminder sent A new reminder should be sent
99th session July 2010
Cameroon Fourth periodic report submitted 25/11/2008
29/07/2011 30/07/2013
LOIPR: for adoption Oct. 2011
55
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
CCPR/C/CMR/CO/4
Paras. 8, 17, 18
A letter should be sent informing the SP that, in the absence of a reply to the FU questions, the Committee will maintain them in the LOIPR.
Colombia Sixth periodic report submitted 12/12/2008 (due 01/04/2008)
CCPR/C/COL/CO/6
Paras, 9, 4, 16
28/07/2011 01/04/2014
08/08/2011: FU report
18/09/2011: Meeting of the secretariat with the Comisión Colombiana de Juristas
22/09/2011: External info received – Comisíon Colombiana de Juristas
Paras. 9, 14, 16 Analyse SP reply and external info at the
56
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
next session
Estonia Third periodic report submitted 10/12/2008 (due 01/04/2007)
CCPR/C/EST/CO/3
Paras. 5, 6
27/07/2011 30/07/2015
12/8/2011: FU report 5, 6: incomplete
05/10/2011: External info received – Legal Information Centre for Human Rights
Paras. 5, 6 Letter requesting additional information on para. 5-6
Israel Third periodic report submitted 25/07/2008 (due 01/08/2007)
CCPR/C/ISR/CO/3
Paras. 8, 11, 22, 24
29/07/2011 30/07/2013
LOIPR: accepted
01/08/2011: External info received – Defence for Children International
Par. 22
26/08/2011: External info received – Paras. 8, 24
57
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
BADIL
30/08/2011: External info received – CCPR (Negev Coexistence Forum for Civil Equality)
Par. 24
31/08/2011: External info received – CCPR (Adalah)
Paras. 8, 11, 22, 24
31/10/2011: FU report Analyse SP reply and external info at the next session
100th session October 2010
El Salvador Sixth periodic report submitted 13/01/2009 (due 01/08/2007)
CCPR/C/SLV/CO/6
Paras. 5, 10, 14, 15
27/10/2011 01/07/2014
Poland Sixth periodic report submitted 15/01/2009 (due 01/11/2008)
CCPR/C/POL/CO/6
26/10/2011 26/10/2015
58
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Paras. 10, 12, 18
Belgium Fifth periodic report submitted 28/01/2009 (due 01/08/2008)
CCPR/C/BEL/CO/5
Paras. 14, 17, 21
26/10/2011 31/10/2015
Jordan Third periodic report submitted 12/03/2009
CCPR/C/JOR/CO/3
Paras. 5, 11, 12
27/10/2011 27/10/2014
Hungary Fifth periodic report submitted 15/03/2009 (due 01/04/2007)
CCPR/C/HUN/CO/5
Paras. 6, 15, 18
27/10/2011 29/10/2014
101st session March 2011
59
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Serbia Second periodic report submitted 30/04/2009 (due 01/08/2008)
CCPR/C/SRB/CO/2
Paras. 12, 17, 22
29/03/2012 01/04/2015
Slovakia Third periodic report submitted 26/06/2009 (due 01/08/2007)
CCPR/C/SVK/CO/3
Paras. 7, 8, 13
28/03/2012 01/04/2015
Mongolia Fifth periodic report submitted 22/06/2009 (due 31/03/2003)
CCPR/C/MNG/CO/5
Paras. 5, 12, 17
30/03/2012 01/04/2015
Seychelles [Report][COB]
60
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
Togo Fourth periodic report submitted 10/07/2009 (due 01/11/2004)
CCPR/C/TGO/CO/4
Paras. 10, 15, 16
28/03/2012 01/04/2015
102nd session July 2011
Ethiopia Initial report submitted 28/07/2009
CCPR/C/ETH/CO/1
Paras. 16, 17, 25
25/07/2012 28/07/2014
Kazakhstan Initial report submitted 27/07/2009
CCPR/C/KAZ/CO/1
Paras. 7, 21, 25, 26
26/07/2012 29/07/2014
Bulgaria Third periodic report submitted 31/07/2009
25/07/2012 29/07/2015
61
CCPR/C/103/2Add.I
CCPR/C/BGR/CO/3
Paras. 8, 11, 21
62