~

DECLASSIFIED UNDER AUTHORITY OF THE INTERAGENCY SECURITY CLASSIFICATION APPEALS PANEL EO13S26 SECTION S3(b)(3)

ISCAP APPEAL NO 2012-107 document no 1 DECLASSIFICATION DATE December 192013

~ 10 l9fi

PlDSOIlAl amp COW~

DeU AlleD

~IO~ mtZViNM roa SOCIAL81UImj PRO t8I

t)Yer ~ PUt wekamp 1 baw bad MVenu 1IIIIMtiDsa QQ the aubject or htber imiddotl Cl4h1s UDlwnaJty the itIDa lCICen~ GlMtiDS haVUlg ~oeen lU~ Jut betore Han7 tuce J8t~ toace

--lanor

DB~18 pn bullbullbull at~middot

middotazd b1OQ8btmiddot the rstller atpUloant __ bullbullbull centu41Iaal $1J1 1M bea eout1llllad by ~ Vatlaan _ 1IoPeoc~tiCa1 ~ _ the outfit fwDtah1ma the ~ betiwee th1e~ ~vWattY and bliampbJat1can PQl1ct

DaADplu alaomiddotmiddot cOn~ middottIIattbe t1~Jal~1_ mltaljmiddot bullbull prettylQl14tP1_ ~ tl1e~middotmiddottat It coWi1be 8Ul1lar~middotmiddoteOlt4U1ec1 tC th1a COUDtIy bull bl 0rdU tomiddot balp he 8aid tbat 8eP41ic ~1A ~MrAI_~ BDalUi11 ~1ng ~ Jlri_t bullbull~ ~ abcat JJraquol)Io bullbullbull al8O bullbull bid bull certain ~tOtnm4lIIi1IC -~~ to theUS bull 1ri JaIwIIryin ~ to lKIlP wt~

All 1Jl ail~15 bull a rather middotbcpehl~iDa~ ~

~t thee tba bcIIiI)b6li bullbullbull WMC atter tbe-Uta ~ DO~ adv1H4 118 ~ JOU l2a4 -td84DOt to ~ ODWiC avppcn bullbull tbat the 1956 ~ vb1ch iw lWlorii2_1lyen _Vi __ middot~1bl9 bull ~~tjf middot1Ddeeda ~ ~

lb18 e MIllewqmiddot 41fflCu1t )IOlgtleIw ac ODJJ doealt --that tbeprlYate ~ 11111middotbullbull ve to bullbullbullbull thtt dsftenmce middotlJut it alAIo bullbullbullbullbullbull that ilbatever private bullbullbullbull 1C8Di1 baw ~ 1l1volVtamp4 ill Ui at 7OUI UpJlcit Or iJIplic1t requt are DOV really Do14lDc middotthe _

ADdmiddot1118 bull verytlJn1CIJt baS toboJA or au tobaYU1w out-alde ect1Ylt1 bullbull 111 wil a1rwOlftl4 th1a OM beCauIIe of 1t VOrt bullbull ampun u4 the -1 -tblIa- M opuate8 CCHWDeII IIIorerzen hOvn tbaR almo8t 8D3 otbe~ ~I am ~ in the VWT ~artable a1t-t1oa at a1phca1na ~ 0t3 of Barrmiddottuce - - bull luge part of blav1llllJCDMa to be atpncced 1 b1 belief tbat 70U eooa1der tht CliDlpolteDtactlv1ty

r

- 2

middot R~ JlDWI bullbull t__ with ~ ~ ce bullbull kiDS him tor -- ~ ItCJlyenIq ad bull plAtdp t_ 1957_middot IIIlIGl _ tbG bullbullbull tta baViagto ~ bill tat 1QU__ 0IIt of ~ raquo1cture iiJe8idea I baw uvolvecl tbe S~ OU at rJev J~ aa4 tevenl middototber ~1fe ~iOaa

All los1e iacl1catea tJatlmiddot ehoUi4 MU LUee~ ita DO ~ ~Ue to CCDt1nue biS acotribUt1ona ad ~ X ~lt bMu4 8tctpmiddotbitt~ ~ CD tbe heatmiddot Y1th thte rtleular

tlwm ~ a4v18_ 1N tbat 8Dd 1 are ~

ktai _ iet the wtt1t t1$bt1~ out of the ~ ora 1ts oWn C fOld

taow ~ n_- bat I am~t~ ittc 10U bullbull aplObl_ 1Gftter ~ ia

becatlMll th1Dk ~ ~middot1 nal val 1Dmiddotthe outrlt tt tbf 1bullbull wremiddot 1rpp1~ ncm bull ~ 41fferfllDt fiD8le thiUl tbe oaew-lCb liM olrtaiiM ~ to IMN bullbullbull tbat taere 1amp sutrtci~

middot ~ ~ ~ OpmItieD to W1rint etthC jCwecmtSmiefl~or atlc bull real eftart CIIlytNr puot to Hlraquo tiad ~ ilalt ltIoHD or bull ~tcea 1ad1vidwl firampl~1Qrraquo ~ ~ to _ enerpttc ~b) ~ trz ~

middotamptnu tbe_1 See it 18 the fClWwtilg~tatlQUl rea4tJ4r~t ~ I __ tbe 0Ut8td8 tiJeretore Hn~ f4 lIba~ middot~Y1thm- bullbullbullbull lS ~ bull be bull

I ~ ~ ~ ~ tbat the ~t1ek lCUilave 1Ipltd 1~ OJ1iSt ~ ad ~ ~ )IaW bOea receiv1ae y~ bullbull VOlth

1 do DOt ~ ~ the t14-l11t middot~teu~ that tbe8e ptqJe C8Il hnliith 1QU VUl ~cot1tutemiddot tttUmiddot~middot Wrth(4 ~ I 1[00 ~ ~ iiI tat ~r thia18 ~ bullbull ~e 1~1_ ~1la~~ ~ bull tqre$IOMSl bull

iJttlattdli

ir litiW tbe vtA1dVtde ~i bullbull tlQnJ bullbull Mntld br the Catllclic middotChurch_ 01 ~_ tomiddotthe tareign polle-4 tile lh1te4 8ta_ it 1tf~ lbt ~ tJ tae ~liC ~oo tbe elk of the ProteataDt ~ en the ~al J~ of Ca-mtau but the Church 1tt tUSo inmiddot bull poaltlc cfl areat tect1clLi ~ue in atIIt fJt tbe bullbullbull that bullbullbull ~ ~ liP bullbullbull NeUlt or tbe~~cn in the Soviet_U In PolaDdbull CIam1-lWteb1nski 1D~ ~lW1ltttnda~ elsewb8ftj 8114 bullbull ~temiddot occur tobeN will al be 8Qfl8 ct~tcmiddot Pre1ate~ trora ~middotiBQU vtcvUl ~iate~oc~y l k~ ~ eruat1til eM poll~1cGl)X41tiQl1ntbe aNa bull

H1lht DOV to Po~18h IIiIIa4 ~lan tbitc 1S ~ taactDatfag lAtle are tteee two Cer41Damp1eI ~le iTelatee

~

bullbull

c

~

rhe otber alCI$U middotteat _ ajor vtlcamiddot tontaD pollcrv ~ middotcoat lDies Qbullbull lcp 8n4 bes1D to awl- SfN CQIl4 be tIIIilV1ae4 bullbullbull 1_ U4 91th ~ detaU S34~ty ~ bull~ bullbullbull ~ll lD1ellipnoeltiIIL

In lteel tha haV1aS __ ~ __ avkfCC1 ~

pUDa tac1t1A~ bullbullbull wtoi-Qm8te SMhMINU- ja4 a ~t t4 nepp1DgllZOQa4 the outfit U liiNca tbe thNabUld of ac1UeV1ne Ieal a1p1t1eallee _ ~t 1raquoUl f tbe Cilu7ch

middot aD4 tOJ 1Clt bullbull ycvz ~ - aDd ~on tIdJs 1ti ~ tbe ~ to _ $t ~_ ~ ~ bcpba ~ -wttbilt a ~ M ltIenot ~1cularh - - r poojj) ~ - vallab14 1n betri~IDtell~ oa~ bull

1be cUtnmta that bull d now ~ ~ ~1C8D 8tl4 DOV ~of bull real11llkmiddot~ P-o 1laio bull 0 ~ IDi ~ teltlraquo1 _tOJOaaDiampampti~ ccruat1t __ I touI ~ Qttbe bullbulll-l-U lIibullbullbull~1ch taft ta$be bullbullbullbull iIiID4~ Y1lltn ~ t$ure ~~ ~ taG

middot ~ Of m1l1t~ Qt people ~ UO ~ore the ~rampblW vtI1- ~flljQ fleW to1OU Wr ~ 1~ bull -~ be ~ce bullbull ~J48_ ~ bullbull ~la~ bull ~=~~~r~ -~ anaW1c1-

bull lt bull ~~ bull

l4o~ ipoundtlw U rCNmiddotmiddotbullbull ~~too_ bullbullbull~ Operatfoa 1n~~ It JC tiaDOt middotciIJd It 70U thUUt iaytbetJ1_ _VIIl~t)omiddotl ~ ~ ~ ~ wwldhave wrdmiddot fitb b1m~~

middot1fU~~ _U~s Q09 ~~ DOt VUh tomiddot NVlVe the ~_lia ~QPHat1GB tbe tGP1W1CfW 1n tile 1Is~ ac-at~ ~ ~lt ~ bull iwatmiddotto_w bullbullbull k1li4 of t~ to vatic tb1UlAg bull4 ~t bullbull Atr4 1eN 18 bull ~ raacbaD1m llhiOb ~ IJQt aroue ~ ~IAS bullbullbullbullbull

t woul4 ~ bull bullbullbull 1afe bullbullbull WICJold ~~ ~ cDl7 bullbull to QIo~ ~ 47--

theplMt1aamplmiddotFcbleSl1 OItlalne4 at ~ start of thU lotwr butmiddot ao- to ~ IDIift plUllt)linphlca1 prob_ VblAb ~1t

iU-t ~l~

Mr Al1Gi w ~ 2430 E SCreet w t4UMngtltX 25 1) c

be Mr Jreder1cl)olbeere ~ John C IUghea Mr IJenrf Ih ~

bullbull

c

~

rhe otber alCI$U middotteat _ ajor vtlcamiddot tontaD pollcrv ~ middotcoat lDies Qbullbull lcp 8n4 bes1D to awl- SfN CQIl4 be tIIIilV1ae4 bullbullbull 1_ U4 91th ~ detaU S34~ty ~ bull~ bullbullbull ~ll lD1ellipnoeltiIIL

In lteel tha haV1aS __ ~ __ avkfCC1 ~

pUDa tac1t1A~ bullbullbull wtoi-Qm8te SMhMINU- ja4 a ~t t4 nepp1DgllZOQa4 the outfit U liiNca tbe thNabUld of ac1UeV1ne Ieal a1p1t1eallee _ ~t 1raquoUl f tbe Cilu7ch

middot aD4 tOJ 1Clt bullbull ycvz ~ - aDd ~on tIdJs 1ti ~ tbe ~ to _ $t ~_ ~ ~ bcpba ~ -wttbilt a ~ M ltIenot ~1cularh - - r poojj) ~ - vallab14 1n betri~IDtell~ oa~ bull

1be cUtnmta that bull d now ~ ~ ~1C8D 8tl4 DOV ~of bull real11llkmiddot~ P-o 1laio bull 0 ~ IDi ~ teltlraquo1 _tOJOaaDiampampti~ ccruat1t __ I touI ~ Qttbe bullbulll-l-U lIibullbullbull~1ch taft ta$be bullbullbullbull iIiID4~ Y1lltn ~ t$ure ~~ ~ taG

middot ~ Of m1l1t~ Qt people ~ UO ~ore the ~rampblW vtI1- ~flljQ fleW to1OU Wr ~ 1~ bull -~ be ~ce bullbull ~J48_ ~ bullbull ~la~ bull ~=~~~r~ -~ anaW1c1-

bull lt bull ~~ bull

l4o~ ipoundtlw U rCNmiddotmiddotbullbull ~~too_ bullbullbull~ Operatfoa 1n~~ It JC tiaDOt middotciIJd It 70U thUUt iaytbetJ1_ _VIIl~t)omiddotl ~ ~ ~ ~ wwldhave wrdmiddot fitb b1m~~

middot1fU~~ _U~s Q09 ~~ DOt VUh tomiddot NVlVe the ~_lia ~QPHat1GB tbe tGP1W1CfW 1n tile 1Is~ ac-at~ ~ ~lt ~ bull iwatmiddotto_w bullbullbull k1li4 of t~ to vatic tb1UlAg bull4 ~t bullbull Atr4 1eN 18 bull ~ raacbaD1m llhiOb ~ IJQt aroue ~ ~IAS bullbullbullbullbull

t woul4 ~ bull bullbullbull 1afe bullbullbull WICJold ~~ ~ cDl7 bullbull to QIo~ ~ 47--

theplMt1aamplmiddotFcbleSl1 OItlalne4 at ~ start of thU lotwr butmiddot ao- to ~ IDIift plUllt)linphlca1 prob_ VblAb ~1t

iU-t ~l~

Mr Al1Gi w ~ 2430 E SCreet w t4UMngtltX 25 1) c

be Mr Jreder1cl)olbeere ~ John C IUghea Mr IJenrf Ih ~