Post on 30-May-2018
transcript
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
1/21
Starter
Create a catchy slogan about the eventsin the Balkans in the lead up to WWI.
Who, in your opinion should the fingerhave pointed at for the outbreak of war?
What are your reasons for this?
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
2/21
To What Extent wasGermany Responsible for
WWI?
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
3/21
Learning Objectives:
Assess the contribution of Germany incausing the First World War
Success Criteria:
Assess the contribution of historiansFischer & Ferguson in the debate of
blame for origins of WWI.
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
4/21
The debate about responsibility beganimmediately after the war had
ended..The Treaty of Versailles blamed Germany for
the outbreak of the war.
How would Germany have reacted to clause231?
Germany published selective documents thatpushed the blame for the war onto other
shoulders.By the late 1930s many accepted Lloyd
Georges words of slithering over the brink.
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
5/21
Franco German HistoriansCommission
This belief lasted until after the Second World War.
In 1951 a group of French & German historians metin a Franco-German Historians Commission. One ofthe subjects discussed was the outbreak of the First
World War.
Their conclusions were accepted by most historiansfor the next 10 years. They were determined tobuild a peaceful relationship between France &
Germany.
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
6/21
Source
The documents do not permit attributing aconscious desire for a European War to any onegovernment or people. Mutual distrust had hit apeak, and in leading circles it was believed that
the war was inevitable. Each one accused theother of aggressive intentions, and only saw aguarantee for security in an alliance system andcontinual armament increases.
From the Franco-German Historians Commission 1951
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
7/21
Question
The history textbooks in France &Germany in the 1950s & 60s werebased on the line expressed by the
Franco-German HistoriansCommission.
In your opinion, was that lineaccurate?
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
8/21
Key Term
Historiographical Revolution
Turning points in the writing of historywhen new ideas are put forward that
change how people think. Theseideas can constitute a revolution in
the writing of history.
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
9/21
The Fischer Controversy
In 1961, a German historian, FritzFischer, launched a historiographicalrevolution. In his book Griff nach der
Weltmacht, which became abridgedinto the English version Germanys
Aims in the First World War (1967)
Fischer came to several conclusions:
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
10/21
Germany had gone to war to achieve
Europe & Worldwide domination verysimilar to that aimed for by Hitler and theNazis in the Second World War; it was a bidfor power.
Germany had hoped that the blankcheque given to Austria in July 1914 wouldresult in war.
The root cause of German expansionism
were to be found as much in the social,economic and political tension in Germanyin the period pre-1914
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
11/21
Sensational views.
From what you know, how far do youagree with Fischer?
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
12/21
Fischers evidence
Fischer based his evidence partly on a document found in theGerman archives written by Bethmann-Hollwegs privatesecretary Kurt Riezler on 9th Sept 1914 in which he outlinesthe Chancellors plans for the peace negotiations, which heexpected to take place in the near future. Fischer argued thatthese plans were the continuation of policy made by
politicians, military leaders and industrialists before theoutbreak of war in 1914. The plans were not just the ideas ofBethmann-Hollweg or even the leading political, military andindustrial figures of the day. To Fischer, these plans had thesupport of the wider political nation. To Fischer the plans inthe 9th Sept programme represented
a complete revolution in European political and powerrelations.
The logic was clear: plans for annexation that were beingwritten down in Sept 1914 did not come from nowhere theymust have been already considered in July 1914. Therefore,Germany was not the victim but the perpetrator of war.Fischers thesis broke new ground in other ways:
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
13/21
It placed Chancellor Bethmann-Hollweg at the centre of the drive forexpansion.
It removed the distinction betweenthe expansionist military and the
supposedly more moderatepoliticians.
It linked foreign and domestic policy
by suggesting that the proposedannexations were seen as a means ofmaintaining domestic dominance.
L k t th f ll i
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
14/21
Look at the following sourcesand answer the questions
below1. What is the significance of The SeptemberProgramme for Fischer and what areFerguson's criticisms.
2. Who do you believe is right and why?3. Summarise the arguments from all foursources about the extent of Germanblame for the outbreak or war.
4. To what extent do Sources C & D agreewith A & B? Explain your answer fully withreference to the sources and your ownknowledge.
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
15/21
Fischer Challenged
Fischers analysis brought a great deal of protestHistorians Gerhard Ritter & Egmont Zechlin attacked
Fischer
They objected to Bethmann-Hollweg being central to
the push for warOthers said that there was little evidence for the
outbreak of war being about world power
They believed it was born out of defence rather than
agressionHistorians such as Klaus Hildebrand & Andreas
Hillgruber thought war came about becauseGermany wanted to break her encirclement
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
16/21
Task
Look at the following sources andanswer the 2 questions.
To what extent do Sources E, F & Ggive the impresion that Bethmann-Hollweg drove the agenda for war?
What other issues are picked up bythese sources?
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
17/21
War of illusions
In War of Illusions (1969) Fischer made even greater playof the relationship between German domestic tensionsand foreign policy. He argued that:
The German government used war a solution to difficult
internal problems and the idea that there was a strongwill to war.
War in 1914 was a bold leap forward Flucht nach vorn(flight or push forward) to establish German dominanceand to keep domestic peace.
The whole decision making elite had to takeresponsibility for war. Germanys leaders were culturallypeesimistic and needed to break encirclement.
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
18/21
Fischer used the diaries of AdmiralMuller
In these was a reference to a meeting on8 Dec 1912 of the Kaiser & militaryadvisers
War Council of 1912 was evidence warhad already been decided upon
Fischer said it was only delayed becauseBethmann atated Germany need to
prepare diplomatically and Tirpitzwanted to wait for the Kiel Canal to beopened.
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
19/21
How Significant was the1912 War Council?
In the winter of 1912:
There was major tension across Europe
Serbia were expanding to the sea alarming Austria,who voiced their opposition
In response Russia began to mobilise and Austriasought support from Germany and Italy
5th December Triple Alliance renewed
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
20/21
At the war council meeting, the following points weremade:
The Kaiser insited that Autria-Hungary be supported in her
actions against Serbia If Russia decided to fight then so be it. Austria would be
supported by Turkey, Romania, Bullgaria & Albania, whichwould leave Germany free to deal with fRance on land & Britainat sea
Moltke (TMS) thought that war against Russia was inevitableand the sooner the better
Tirpitz suggested that the navy needed another 12 to 18months to prepare the fleet and for the Kiel Canal to haveopened to allow large German Naval vessels passage from theBaltic into the North Sea.
But while many historians praised much of what Fischer had tosay in War of Illusions, there has subsequently beenconsiderable debate about the importance of the so-called WarCouncil of 8 December 1912.
8/14/2019 Create a Catchy Slogan About the Events in the Balkans
21/21
Task
Look at the following 3 sources (H, I & J)
Discuss as a group, the amount of weight we
should give to the war council.
Does it show that Germany was ready to go towar or was it just a meeting at a time of
diplomatic exceitement.