Post on 02-Jan-2016
transcript
Ethical Concerns in the Practice of Medicine
Otis W. Brawley, MD, MACP, FASCO, FACEChief Medical and Scientific Officer
American Cancer SocietyProfessor of Hematology, Medical Oncology,
Medicine and Epidemiology Emory University
Atlanta, Georgia, USA
Disclosures
• Employment:– American Cancer Society– Emory University– Turner Broadcasting (CNN)
• Consulting– National Institutes of Health– Centers for Disease Control– Department of Defense
• I do not accept money from drug and device manufacturers
3
Medical ethics is a system of moral principles that apply values and judgments to the practice of medicine.
4
Principles of Ethics
• Beneficence• Non-maleficence• Respect for Autonomy• Justice
5
Healthcare
• An issue that must be approached ethically, logically and rationally
• We must realize the truth:– What we know.– What we do not know.– What we believe.
6
Overview
• The U.S. health economy.• Observations about our attitude
toward medicine.• Lessons from the history of medicine. • The future increased effort to prevent
chronic disease.
The Cost of Healthcare
8
U.S. Health Care Spending
In 2011, the U.S. spent
$2.7 TRILLION on Health Care
9
U.S. Health Care Spending
•How Big is a Trillion?
1 million seconds Last week
1 billion seconds Richard Nixon’s Resignation
1 trillion seconds 30,000 BCE
10
Spending in Context
2011
* Excludes alcoholic beverages ($150 billion) and tobacco products ($92 billion)
Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis; National Bureau of Statistics of China, MGI analysis
17.9%
$2.7 trillion
$1.1 trillion
$1.4 trillion
Gross Domestic Product
11
Gross Domestic Product by Country, 2011Thrillion Dollars, at Official Exchange Rate
• United States 14.45• China
5.74• Japan
5.46• Germany 3.28• France
2.56• Brazil
2.09CIA Fact Book, 2012
12
Healthcare in Three Countries (2010)
• Canada
Switzerland U.S. • Infant Mortality 5.04 4.53 6.22 per 1000
live births
• White Male Life Exp 78.0 79.7 76.8 Years
• Per Capita Costs 4445 5270 8233 US Dollars
• Proportion of GDP 11.4% 11.4% 17.9%
13
Disparities in Health
• Some consume too much – (Unnecessary care given)
• Some consume too little– (Necessary care not given)
• We could decrease the waste and improve overall health!!!!
Disparities in Health
Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in health care is the most shocking and inhumane
• ML King, Jr. Presentation at: The Second National Convention of the Medical Committee for Human Rights; March 25, 1966; Chicago, IL.
15
Is there value in American healthcare?
Bringing rationality to American healthcare
Orthodox application of the science
“Rationality” not “Rationing”
The American Healthcare System
• Overconsumption of Healthcare
• The Greedy Feeding the Gluttonous
• A Subtle form of Corruption
17
Themes
• Greed
• Ignorance
• Apathy
18
Themes
People
– Who should know better, but do not
– Who do not appreciate scientific findings nor the scientific method
– Who discourage those who question
19
“A professional is someone who puts the interests of his patients above his own.”
Hal Sox, MD, MACP
20
The Doctor Culture
• Respect for tradition (Unwilling to evolve or change).
• Intolerant of those who question.
• Hubris
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”
Upton Sinclair
22
The Patient Culture
The Situation.
– Demands irrational patterns of consumption
– Unreasonable expectations
– Advocacy often worsens healthcare by stressing the wrong things
The Patient Culture
For true transforming of healthcare the public needs to believe there is a crisis and it affects them.
– Personal responsibility
– Solid financial incentives (skin in the game)
The American Healthcare SystemInefficient!!!
We often do not follow the science
• We often use treatments and interventions that are lucrative to the providers but not proven effective.
• We often ignore and fail to use simple, inexpensive, and effective interventions.
Culprits in Inefficiency
• Doctors and Nurses• Patients (Consumers)• Hospital Administrators• Lawyers and Politicians• Marketers and Salesmen
(Drug and Device Companies)
Clinical Lessons Learned Late
• Chest X-ray screening for lung cancer• Urine screening for neuroblastoma• Cryotherapy for prostate cancer
Clinical Lessons Learned Late
• Lidocaine after MI • Hyper-vitaminosis (Vit E, Beta Carotene, Selenium)• Rofecoxib and Celecoxib for arthritic pain
– (Vioxx and Celebrex)• Rosiglitazone (Avandia) for diabetes
Clinical Lessons Learned Late
• Postmenopausal Hormone replacement therapy
• Halsted mastectomy
• Adjuvant bone marrow transplant for breast cancer
• Erythropoetin for anemia
Clinical Lessons Learned LateOverused Interventions
• Hysterectomy• Caesarian section• Carotid endarterectomy• Coronary Artery Bypass Grafting• Tonsillectomy• Tympanostomy
Our History of Not Respecting the Science
• The Halsted Mastectomy• Bone Marrow Transplant in Breast Cancer• Erythropoetin to stimulate blood production in
cancer patients• Mass Prostate Cancer Screening• Lung Cancer Screening
Our History of Not Respecting the Science
The Halsted Mastectomy
– Defined by Halsted in 1896– Appropriate treatment in the early 20th
century (tumors large at diagnosis)– Doctors who questioned it in the 1940’s
were disciplined– Shown obsolete in 1970’s through studies of
Fisher and Veronesi
Our History of Not Respecting the Science
Bone Marrow Transplant in Breast Cancer
• Began in 1980’s due to theory that more chemotherapy was better
• Women sued insurances to pay for it• Laws passed forcing insurances to pay for it• Clinical trials impeded• 1999, three studies show it net harmful and
200 transplant centers close in U.S.
Our History of Not Respecting the Science
Erythropoetin to stimulate blood production in cancer patients
• Approved without full testing during the AIDS epidemic as an alternative to blood transfusion
• Advertising to push the envelope in terms of FDA approval
• Suppression of studies to show it is a stimulant of cancer cell growth
Our History of Not Respecting the Science
Mass Prostate Cancer Screening
• Pushed based on early detection principles from 1991 onward
• Professional organizations warn of proven harms and unproven benefit
• Studies published 2009 to present show small benefit if any.
American Urological Association*
Given the uncertainty that PSA testing results in more benefit than harm, a thoughtful and broad approach to PSA is critical.
Patients need to be informed of the risks and benefits of testing before it is undertaken. The risks of overdetection and overtreatment should be included in this discussion.
*Taken from the AUA PSA Best Practice Statement 2009 and markedly different from statements made in press conferences
Our History of Not Respecting the Science
Lung Cancer Screening
• Pushed based on early detection principles before good trials showed it saves lives
• Professional organizations warn of proven harms and suggest informed decision making
• Some hospitals push it hard and even offer at low cost without any mention of harm!
Offers Low Dose Spiral CT of the Lung to those at risk for lung cancer. ($325 cash).
“At risk for lung cancer,” according to St Joe’s, includes 40 year old non-smoking women who have lived in an urban area for more than ten years.
The business plan relies on insurance to pay for the follow-up testing of the 25% or more abnormal screens.
39
Rational vs. Irrational Medicine
• Rofecoxib (Vioxx) vs. Naproxen• Once a day vs. twice a day• $90 per month vs. $12 per
month
40
Rational vs. Irrational Medicine
Omeprazole (Prilosec)
41
Rational vs. Irrational Medicine
Omeprazole (Prilosec)
vs.
Esomeprazole (Nexium)
25 cents per day vs. six dollar per dayEight dollars per month vs. 180 dollars per month
42
True Healthcare Reform
A transformation in how we view medicine:-Less overindulgence-Less focus on treatment-Greater focus on prevention
43
True Healthcare Reform
The use of “Evidence Based Care and Prevention”
That is: The rational use of medicine
Not the rationing of medicine
Comparative Effectiveness Research
44
U.S. Smoking Prevalence by Gender 1955-2010
1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 20100
10
20
30
40
50
60
MaleFemale
US Continues to Lead the World in Obesity Rates
OECD Obesity Update 2012
A Tsunami of Chronic Disease
– Diabetes– Cardiovascular Disease– Orthopedic Disease– Cancer
A Tsunami of Chronic Disease
• Will surpass tobacco as leading cause of cancer
• Think of the number of people we could save from a cancer death if we did what we know we should do
48
An Ethical Issue
• We need to focus on the prevention of disease
• We have been too treatment centered.
True Healthcare Reform(An Efficient, Value Driven Health System)
• Rational use of healthcare is necessary for the future of the U.S. economy (an issue of U.S. security)
• There is a healthcare fiscal cliff!!!
• It is possible to decrease costs and improve healthcare by using science to guide our policies 50
Otis W. Brawley, MD, MACP, FASCO, FACE
Chief Medical and Scientific Officer American Cancer Society
Professor of Hematology, Medical Oncology, Medicine and Epidemiology
Emory University
51