Post on 03-Jun-2018
transcript
8/12/2019 EU Startup Ecosystem - More Hype Than Reality
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-startup-ecosystem-more-hype-than-reality 1/7
MENU
While you were boasting about your localstartup ‘ecosystem’, others were trying to
actually build itA long rant about why people should resist the urge to boast about their local tech startup scene
with unnecessary and counter-productive hyperbole – because it doesn’t really help anyone at
all.
DRobin Wauters(http://tech.eu/author/robin/)
Co-founder and editor-in-chief of
Tech.eu, with previous stints atThe Next Web and TechCrunch
under his belt. Deeply in love
with his family, technology,
traveling and Belgian beer.
Posted in EU startups(http://tech.eu/on/eu-startups/),European startups(http://tech.eu/on/european-startups/)
UPDATEDMarch 17th, 2014.
ue to the nature of my work and our dedication
(http://tech.eu/inside/42/we-have-lift-off/) to covering all of
Europe’s tech innovation (http://tech.eu/about-us/), not just the
movers and shakers in the major hubs, I travel quite a lot in order to
meet with interesting founders and investors from across the
continent.
When people ask me where I’m from and where I reside (the answer
to both of which is ‘Belgium, very close to Brussels’), a good chunk
of them follow up to inquire ‘what the local startup ecosystem is
like’.
My response is always something to the tune of ‘obviously small,
but growing, communities are starting to form and mature, and thereare some interesting startups – like X and Y – doing some amazing
things in their fields’. Nothing to boast about, nothing to be ashamed about.
8/12/2019 EU Startup Ecosystem - More Hype Than Reality
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-startup-ecosystem-more-hype-than-reality 2/7
And I really make an effort not to use the word ‘ecosystem’ when it comes to Belgium during
those conversations – because there really isn’t one to speak of, at least not yet (and that’s
alright).
Coincidentally, that’s also exactly how I feel about many of Europe’s smaller regional tech startup
scenes, from Copenhagen to Amsterdam to Prague to Bucharest to Athens.
Europe’s emerging startup hotspots are, well, still emerging
They’re compact, but growing. Compelling to follow, but still in the very early stages of truly
developing an ecosystem. Some activity and startups that jump out, but mostly a fledgling
community that’s – crucially – starting to take shape around them. And a handful of key people
in the driver’s seat – there are always a few – who are often the unsung heroes of the country or
region.
That’s all very good and noteworthy. Of course things could always be better, and the maturation
swifter, but overall you can almost sense that there’s a relatively slow but steady
(http://tech.eu/features/647/european-tech-exits-2014/) evolution taking place pretty much
across the board (or map, in this case). It’s genuinely fascinating to watch
(http://tech.eu/features/186/ignorance-is-remiss/).
And it’s always nice when there are people feeling the urge to give their local startup stars and
tech clout more visibility. We’re enormous fans of the likes of ArcticStartup(http://arcticstartup.com/), Inventures (http://inventures.eu/), Rude Baguette
(http://www.rudebaguette.com/), Venture Village (http://venturevillage.eu/), Goal Europe
(http://goaleurope.com/) and plenty of other regionals blogs and news sites, each of which have
a mission to shine a light on what’s happening on the ground, whether that means the Nordics,
France, Germany, Central and Eastern Europe, Turkey or wherever. It makes a lot of difference,
especially when it’s done in English so a broader audience can take note.
But there’s a certain kind of coverage coming from those and other sites that really puts me off.
The kind where people publish absurd claims such as “X is the new Silicon Valley” or “Y will be
the new center of activity, cfr. Tech City UK” or “Z might just become Europe’s next major startup
hub”.
No, it isn’t. No, it likely won’t ever be, either. And that’s fine.
A misplaced sense of local pride
I understand where it comes from. You don’t even have to be that much of a nationalist to look at
your local startup scene – particularly if you’re knee deep in it – and feel the need to tell the world
how awesome it is. Why can’t everyone else see it? Why aren’t we placed on the same pedestal
(http://twitter.com/share?url=http://on.tech.eu/1icXM9a&text=On @tech_eu:
While+you+were+boasting+about+your+local+startup+%E2%80%98ecosystem%E2%80%99
(http://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=http://on.tech.eu/1icXM9a) (https://
url=http://on.tech.eu/1icXM9a) (mailto:?Subject=While you were boasting about yo
trying to actually build it&Body= http://on.tech.eu/1icXM9a)
8/12/2019 EU Startup Ecosystem - More Hype Than Reality
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-startup-ecosystem-more-hype-than-reality 3/7
as Silicon Valley (http://www.technologyreview.com/view/521486/why-the-next-silicon-valley-
doesnt-really-exist/), Tel Aviv, London or Berlin? Just look at what X has accomplished, and what
Y is doing!
But it’s not because you’re a fan and make valid (if slightly exaggerated) points that people will
suddenly start consistently paying closer attention. It’s by building and supporting more
examples to point at, by professionalizing the environment, by assembling and organising a
community, by advocating the verifiable assets – not just by shouting loudly in a futile effort to
‘rise above the noise’.
It all stems from a sense of pride, but a misplaced one, in my opinion. Every time someone feels
the need to shout from the rooftops how their local ecosystem are able to compete with the best
of them, I ask myself: why does this perception of competition exist in the first place? What does
it matter?
This opinion piece (well, rant) was prompted
(https://twitter.com/robinwauters/status/445465769934336000) by a post on Bitspiration, a
recently started site that aims to highlight tech startup news and more from Poland. Entitled “5
Reasons Krakow Will Top Global Startup Map” (http://bitspiration.com/featured/5-reasons-
krakow-will-top-global-startup-map/) (sic), it was basically a list of things that are great about
the second-largest city of Poland. It had some interesting information in it, yet all of it was
published in vain, as far as I’m concerned, largely because of the ridiculously hyperbolic headline.
Again, I get it. I’ve been to Poland, and I’ve roamed around Krakow’s startup community and met
a few of its key actors. No doubt that the way it’s developing is interesting, because there are lots
of similarities to other places in Europe (which, in turn, makes it something of a burgeoning
trend).
But does anyone really believe Krakow will ever top the global startup map, whatever that
means?
Why not just point out the strengths (http://www.thenordicweb.com/2014/03/14/the-rise-of-
norways-startup-scene/) without proving yourself oblivious to the weaknesses, so your audience
can take informed decisions and judge the worth based on facts mixed with observations?
Why not try to identify the good along with the bad (http://tech.eu/features/779/corporate-run-
startup-accelerators-good-bad-plain-ugly/)? What does one gain by this senseless boasting?
More helicopters, fewer navel-gazers please
8/12/2019 EU Startup Ecosystem - More Hype Than Reality
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-startup-ecosystem-more-hype-than-reality 4/7
Since Tech.eu was launched, I’ve received quite a lot of offers from people suggesting they guest-
write about their local startup ecosystems. Up until now, I’ve categorically refused to commission
contributions of that kind, even if they’d be completely free of charge, because I know how
incapable of taking a helicopter’s view of things people can be when they’re passionate about
something.
I can (http://thenextweb.com/insider/2013/05/01/barcelona-startup-ecosystem-deep-dive). That
doesn’t necessarily mean you need to agree with or even listen to me, but at least you’ll always
know I make an effort to look at the bigger picture. I champion, but I’m not a cheerleader.
I know that I could write a post about what a wasteland for tech startup activity e.g. Italy is or at
the very least appears to be, and immediately get retorts from people who ‘are actually there’ who
will happily tell me why I’m delusional. Some of that would probably result in a very worthwhile
discussion, but I know a lot of reactions would get lost in an ocean of comments about how I’m
just not seeing the light or understanding the subtleties or misrepresenting the facts.
And again, I won’t fully understand the need for that particular type of rhetoric. It doesn’t help
anyone.
Perhaps people simply desire a sense of belonging and being able to ‘play in the big league’ –
understandable human feelings and thoughts to have – and therefore feel the urge to write about
their local tech startup scene with added hyperbole. Perhaps it’s because it will likely garner more
attention than articles with more intellectually honest headlines. Perhaps because it can
definitely be frustrating not to be recognised by the media as much as others – for whatever
reason.
I don’t know, but until the hyperbole stops, it will actually stand in the way of the progress we all
seek.
As much as I dislike the phrase “Europe needs to focus on building bridges, not valleys”, there’s a
grain of truth in it that is difficult to ignore. So the next time you feel the urge to talk about the
European tech industry or your local startup scene, take a step back and absorb all the
information, data and facts available to you, make up your mind and write from a position of
‘offence’ rather than ‘defence’.
I promise I’ll read it attentively and tell you why you’ve got it all backwards.
Just kidding – just try to leave out the hyperbole and we’ll get along just fine.
Featured image credit : Denis Vrublevski / Shutterstock (http://www.shutterstock.com/pic-
111215291/stock-photo-map-route-marked.html?src=lb-22345823)
8/12/2019 EU Startup Ecosystem - More Hype Than Reality
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-startup-ecosystem-more-hype-than-reality 5/7
Posted in EU startups (http://tech.eu/on/eu-startups/), European startups (http://tech.eu/on/european-
startups/)
KEEP READING
(http://tech.eu/features/804/eu-accelerators-research-seed-db-europe/) A spotlight on the EUstartup accelerator ecosystem: quantitative and qualitative analysis (part 1)(http://tech.eu/features/804/eu-accelerators-research-seed-db-europe/)
(http://tech.eu/features/779/corporate-run-startup-accelerators-good-bad-plain-ugly/)Corporate-run startup accelerators: the good, the bad and the plain ugly(http://tech.eu/features/779/corporate-run-startup-accelerators-good-bad-plain-ugly/)
8/12/2019 EU Startup Ecosystem - More Hype Than Reality
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-startup-ecosystem-more-hype-than-reality 6/7
Health 2.0 in Europe – Here’s 35 startups
to watch
•
— What about WellBiome?
Sequencing gut microflora DNA for better
health. Lab and HQ located in Tallinn, …
Your local European tech hub probably
won’t be The Next Silicon Valley – and …
•
— T his article is academically
illiterate. It entirely overlooks why hubs form
in the first place and should be ignored. A …
The 7 faces of London’s tech scene•
— James/Ferenz - nice bit of
research and love the learning, but curious of
one thing: what are the meanings of the two …
Toca Boca makes the kind of games kidscan’t possibly beat – so why have their …
•
— Toca Bocca is a truly amazing
app studio. they deserve all the success. one
thing to note though they got so much …
2 Comments
• •
Ramon Suarez •
Instead of boasting, what people should do is work to build it.
• •
Gilbert West •
I agree that not being in the ecosy stem or hub or whatever term people choose next is alright,
but you should have easy access to one and place yourself in it from time to time. It's useful
to step up a bit and not get complacent.
When you are in an ecosystem, you k now it. You can feel it in the fabric of the city, or at
least the few square kilometres of that city that host it. Wherever you sit down there will be
startup people to the left and right of you. People will be carrying out job interviews in cafés
or hustling to get to their next sale. In other words, clear signals of economic activity.
Oh and the coffee is usually better than in Brussels :-p
Copyright © 2014 Fores Media Ltd. All rights reserved.
8/12/2019 EU Startup Ecosystem - More Hype Than Reality
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/eu-startup-ecosystem-more-hype-than-reality 7/7
Powered by (http://wpengine.com/)
Back to top