Post on 27-Mar-2018
transcript
Financial Statement Analysis Understanding and Using Financial Ratios
Introduction • The four financial statements contain much of the
information need to make business decisions • How can this information be used to analyze a farm
or a business? • Decision making can be improved through financial
planning in five ways ▫ Identify and learn from past mistakes ▫ Make fewer mistakes ▫ Take timely and appropriate action to correct mistakes
that are made ▫ Identify strengths and weaknesses ▫ Spot opportunities
2
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/13/2013
Analyzing Financial Position and Performance • Techniques For Analysis ▫ Financial Statements Trends Cost vs. Market Asset vs. Debt Structure Cash vs. Accrual
▫ Pro Forma Analysis What if Commodity and Weather Cycles Breakeven
3
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Analyzing Financial Position and Performance ▫ Monitoring and Control Projected vs. Actual Variance Analysis Operations and plan adjustments
▫ Ratio Analysis Standards – Ranges Trend (direction and slope) Historical variability Projected vs. Historical Average Sensitivity Analysis Interrelationships (DuPont Model)
4
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Ratio Analysis • Three standards of comparison for ratios ▫ Compare the business against itself Past performance to present Present performance to budgeted performance Able to identify trends
▫ Compare the business to a set of benchmarks Benchmarks must be first determined (e.g. Peer
Groups) ▫ Compare the business to an average or quartiles
for firms of similar size and type Regional databases, ag lenders, ag accounting firms
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
5
Notes of Caution • Apples to Apples ▫ Income calculation Before or after tax Cash or accrual Business only or combination of business and personal
▫ Business organization form ▫ Balance Sheet Cost basis valuation or market based Business only or combination of business and personal Deferred taxes included or not
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
6
Financial Measures
• Five criteria ▫ Liquidity ▫ Solvency ▫ Profitability ▫ Repayment capacity ▫ Financial efficiency
• All measure financial position or financial performance
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
7
Liquidity Measures • Liquidity ratios ▫ Measures the ability of the farm business to meet
financial obligations as they come due, without disrupting the normal, ongoing operations of the business
• Analyzed two ways ▫ Structural liquidity Balance sheet measures Relationship between assets and liabilities
▫ Operational liquidity Cash flow measures
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
8
Liquidity Measures
• Working Capital ▫ Measure of the amount of funds that would be
available to purchase inputs after the sale of current farm assets and payment of all current farm liabilities
• Equation ▫ Working Capital = Total Current Farm Assets –
Total Current Farm Liabilities
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
9
Issues of Working Capital
• Absolute dollar amount ▫ Difficult to make comparisons between businesses ▫ Unable to establish one standard ▫ Dependent upon size of firm
• Future projections ▫ Reflects amount at one point in time ▫ Does not reflect timing of future cash flows
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
10
Current Ratio
• Used to evaluate the relationship between total current farm assets and total current farm liabilities
• Equation ▫ Total Current Farm Assets/Total Current Farm
Liabilities
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
11
Current Ratio
• Relative measure • Higher the ratio, the more liquid the business • Acceptable values vary with business type • Not dependent on size of firm, can be used for
comparisons
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
12
Working Capital to Gross Revenues
• FFSC found it to be more useful than the current ratio
• Equation ▫ Working Capital/Gross Farm Income
13
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Cash Flow Coverage Ratio
• Assesses the business’s ability to meet cash obligations
• Calculated from the cash flow statement • Equation ▫ Total Cash Available/Total Cash Required
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
14
Cash Flow Coverage Ratio
• The higher the ratio, the higher the liquidity • Can be used for scenario analysis
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
15
Budgeting Error
• Equation ▫ [(Actual Total Cash Available – Actual Total Cash
Required) – (Projected Total Cash Available – Projected Total Cash Required)] ÷ (Projected Total Cash Available – Projected Total Cash Required) X 100
16
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Solvency
• Measures the amount of borrowed capital or debt, leasing commitments and other expense obligations relative to the amount of owner’s equity invested in the business.
• Solvency measures provide an indication of the firm’s ability to repay all financial obligations if all assets were sold, and an indication of the ability to continue operations as a viable business after a financial adversity.
17
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Solvency Measures • Concerned with long-term as well as short-term
assets and liabilities • Evaluates what would happen if all assets were sold
and converted to cash and all liabilities were paid • Indicates the business’s ability to withstand risks
and to continue operations after financial adversity • The most straightforward measure ▫ Owner equity Difficult to measure Depends on size of firm
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
18
Solvency Measures
• Debt to Asset • Debt to Equity • Equity to Asset • All three are equivalent because they use 2 of the
3 parts of the balance sheet identity equation, TA = TL + OE. If you know any two of the variables, you can determine the third.
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
19
Debt to Asset Ratio
• Expresses total farm liabilities as a proportion of total farm assets
• One way to express financial risk exposure • If the ratio is more than .5:1 the creditors have
more money in the business than the owners • Equation ▫ Total Farm Liabilities/Total Farm Assets
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
20
Debt to Asset Ratio
• Three main issues ▫ Greatly influenced by the value placed on farm
assets Market based Cost based
▫ Impact of deferred taxes ▫ Reasonable standard will vary from one type of
enterprise to another No single standard Depends on how debt is being used
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
21
Debt to Equity Ratio
• Reflects the extent to which farm debt is being combined with farm equity capital
• Often called the leverage ratio, but all the solvency measures are measures of leverage
• If the ratio is less than 1:1 the creditors have less money in the business than the owner
• Equation ▫ Total Farm Liabilities/Total Farm Equity
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
22
Equity to Asset Ratio
• Expresses the proportion of total assets financed by the owner’s equity capital
• Also called percent ownership • Mirror image of debt to asset ratio • If the ratio is more than .5:1 the owners have
more money in the business than the creditors • Equation
Total Farm Equity/Total Farm Assets
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
23
Profitability Measures • Measures the extent to which a business generates
profit from the use of labor, management, and capital
• Relationship between revenues and expenses • Net Farm Income ▫ Represents the returns to the farm for unpaid operator
and family labor, management and owner’s equity. ▫ Absolute dollar amount Difficult to make comparisons Before tax amount Organizational form
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
24
Return on Farm Assets (ROA)
• Used an overall index of profitability • Most meaningful for comparisons • Equation ▫ (Net Farm Income From Operations + Farm
Interest Expenses – Family Living Withdrawals) / Average Total Farm Assets
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
25
ROA Issues
• Family withdrawals • Realized and unrealized capital gains are not
included ▫ May distort the ratio
• Method of valuation • Pre-tax basis • Non-farm assets should be excluded
9/13/3013 Financial Management in Agriculture
26
Rate of Return on Farm Equity (ROE)
• Measures the rate of return on the owner’s equity in the farm business ▫ Differs from ROA because ROA considers both
owned and borrowed capital • Equation ▫ (Net Farm Income From Operations – Family
Living Withdrawals) / Average Farm Equity
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
27
ROE Issues
• Same as ROA • Higher the ratio, the more profitable the
business • If ROE is less than ROA (ROE/ROA is called the
power ratio) ▫ Business is paying more interest on borrowed
money than is being earned
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
28
Operating Profit Margin Ratio
• Measures the returns to capital per dollar of gross revenue
• Two ways to increase profit ▫ Increase profit per unit produced ▫ Increasing the volume of production ▫ This ratio is concerned with the first
• Equation ▫ (Net Farm Income From Operations + Farm
Interest Expense) / Gross Farm Income
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
29
EBITDA
• Equation ▫ Net Farm Income (pre-tax) + Farm Interest
Expense + Depreciation & Amortization
30
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Repayment Capacity
• Measures the ability to repay debt from both farm and non-farm income
• Evaluates the capacity of the business to service additional debt
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
31
Capital Debt Repayment Capacity
• Equation ▫ Net Farm Income + Depreciation + Net Non-Farm
Income + Interest on Term Loans – Family Living Withdrawals & Income Taxes
32
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Capital Debt Repayment Margin
• Equation ▫ Capital Debt Repayment Capacity – Scheduled
Principal & Interest on Term Loans (includes payments on capital leases)
33
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Debt to Income Ratio
• Measures the amount by which total debt exceeds annual income
• Recognizes that equity is not the only thing a borrower can leverage
• Useful for tracking the overall financial health of the farm sector.
• Equation ▫ Total Farm Liabilities/Net Farm Income
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
34
Term-Debt Coverage Ratio
• Equation ▫ Capital Debt Repayment Capacity/Scheduled
Principal & Interest on Term Loans (includes payments on capital leases)
35
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Financial Efficiency Measures
• Measures the intensity with which a business uses its assets to generate gross revenues and the effectiveness of production, purchasing, pricing, and financing, and marketing decisions.
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
36
Equations • Asset Turnover Rate ▫ Gross Farm Income/Average Total Farm Assets ▫ Operating Profit Margin X Asset Turnover = ROA
• Operating Expense Ratio ▫ (Total Farm Operating Expenses – Farm Interest &
Depreciation) / Gross Farm Income • Depreciation Expense Ratio ▫ Depreciation/Gross Farm Income
• Interest Expense Ratio ▫ Farm Interest Expense/Gross Farm Income
• Net Farm Income From Operations Ratio ▫ Net Farm Income From Operations/Gross Farm Income
37
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Other Measures
• Average Collection Period ▫ Accounts Receivable / (Annual Credit Sales ÷ 360)
• Average Days Payable ▫ Accounts Payable / (Annual Credit Purchases ÷
360) • Days Inventory ▫ Inventory/(Annual Cost of Goods Sold ÷ 360)
• Inventory Turnover ▫ Gross Sales/Average Inventory
38
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
Other Measures
• Labor Productivity ▫ (Labor & Salary Expenses + Family Living
Withdrawals) / Gross Farm Income ▫ (Labor & Salary Expenses + Family Living
Withdrawals) / Total Tillable Acres • Machinery & Equipment Productivity ▫ Machine & Equipment Expenses (including
depreciation) / Gross Farm Income ▫ Machinery & Equipment Expenses (including
depreciation) / Total Tillable Acres
39
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
DuPont Analysis
40
Financial Management in Agriculture
9/17/2013
ROE = [ ROA - Interest Assets
[ Assets Equity
ROE = [
[ Income Gross Revenue
Assets Equity Assets
Gross Revenue Interest Assets -
Profit Margin
Asset Turnover
Interest Cost
Leverage
DuPont Model
Current Liab.
+
Long-term Liab.
Total Assets
Total Liab.
less
Total Assets
Net Worth
Divided by Financial Leverage
Sales
COGS
Gross Profit
Operating Expense
Expense Percent
Gross Margin
less
less Operating Profit
less Federal Taxes
After-tax Profit
Sales
Divided by Net Profit Margin
Inventory Turnover
Age of Accts. Rec.
Inventory
Accts Receivable
+
+
Cash
Current Assets
+
Fixed Assets
Total Assets
Divided by
Sales
Asset Turnover
Return on Assets
X
Return on Equity
X
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
41
DuPont Model Base
Current Liab. $69,406
+ Long-term
Liab. $266,970
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Total Liab.
$336,376
less
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Net Worth
$1,198,927
Divided by Financial Leverage
1.28
Sales $1,345,803
COGS $878,633
Gross Profit $467,170
Operating Expense
$392,924
Expense Percent
29%
Gross Margin
35%
less
less Operating
Profit $74,246
less Federal Taxes
$0
After-tax Profit $74,246
Sales $1,345,803
Divided by Net Profit
Margin 5.52%
Inventory Turnover
1.61
Age of Accts. Rec.
55
Inventory $833,393
Accts Receivable
$202,085
+
+
Cash $35,502
Current Assets
$1,070,980
+ Fixed Assets $464,323
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Divided by
Sales $1,345,803
Asset Turnover
0.88
Return on Assets
4.84%
X
Return on Equity
6.19%
X
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
42
Increase Gross Margin by 2%
Current Liab. $69,406
+ Long-term
Liab. $266,970
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Total Liab.
$336,376
less
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Net Worth
$1,198,927
Divided by Financial Leverage
1.28
Sales $1,345,803
COGS $878,633
Gross Profit $467,945
Operating Expense
$392,924
Expense Percent
29%
Gross Margin
37%
less
less Operating
Profit $105,021
less Federal Taxes
$0
After-tax Profit $105,021
Sales $1,345,803
Divided by Net Profit
Margin 7.80%
Inventory Turnover
1.61
Age of Accts. Rec.
55
Inventory $833,393
Accts Receivable
$202,085
+
+
Cash $35,502
Current Assets
$1,070,980
+ Fixed Assets $464,323
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Divided by
Sales $1,345,803
Asset Turnover
0.88
Return on Assets
6.84%
X
Return on Equity
8.76%
X
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
43
Cut Overhead Expense as a Percent of Sales by 3%
Current Liab. $69,406
+ Long-term
Liab. $266,970
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Total Liab.
$336,376
less
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Net Worth
$1,198,927
Divided by Financial Leverage
1.28
Sales $1,345,803
COGS $878,633
Gross Profit $467,170
Operating Expense
$349,909
Expense Percent
26%
Gross Margin
34.71%
less
less Operating
Profit $117,261
less Federal Taxes
$0
After-tax Profit $117,261
Sales $1,345,803
Divided by Net Profit
Margin 8.71%
Inventory Turnover
1.61
Age of Accts. Rec.
55
Inventory $833,393
Accts Receivable
$202,085
+
+
Cash $35,502
Current Assets
$1,070,980
+ Fixed Assets $464,323
Total Assets
$1,535,303
Divided by
Sales $1,345,803
Asset Turnover
0.88
Return on Assets
7.64%
X
Return on Equity
9.78%
X
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
44
Increase Inventory Turns By 1
Current Liab. $69,406
+ Long-term
Liab. $266,970
Total Assets
$1,219,526
Total Liab.
$336,376
less
Total Assets
$1,219,526
Net Worth $883,150
Divided by Financial Leverage
1.38
Sales $1,345,803
COGS $878,633
Gross Profit $467,170
Operating Expense
$392,924
Expense Percent
29.20%
Gross Margin
34.71%
less
less Operating
Profit $74,246
less Federal Taxes
$0
After-tax Profit $74,246
Sales $1,345,803
Divided by Net Profit
Margin 5.52%
Inventory Turnover
2.60
Age of Accts. Rec.
55
Inventory $517,616
Accts Receivable
$202,085
+
+
Cash $35,502
Current Assets $755,203
+ Fixed Assets $464,323
Total Assets
$1,219,526
Divided by
Sales $1,345,803
Asset Turnover
1.10
Return on Assets
6.09%
X
Return on Equity
8.41%
X
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
45
Reduce Receivables To 30 Days
Current Liab. $69,406
+ Long-term
Liab. $266,970
Total Assets
$1,443,832
Total Liab.
$336,376
less
Total Assets
$1,443,832
Net Worth
$1,107,456
Divided by Financial Leverage
1.30
Sales $1,345,803
COGS $878,633
Gross Profit $467,170
Operating Expense
$392,924
Expense Percent
29.20%
Gross Margin
34.71%
less
less Operating
Profit $74,246
less Federal Taxes
$0
After-tax Profit $74,246
Sales $1,345,803
Divided by Net Profit
Margin 5.52%
Inventory Turnover
1.61
Age of Accts. Rec.
30
Inventory $833,393
Accts Receivable
$110,614
+
+
Cash $35,502
Current Assets $979,509
+ Fixed Assets $464,323
Total Assets
$1,443,832
Divided by
Sales $1,345,803
Asset Turnover
0.93
Return on Assets
5.14%
X
Return on Equity
6.70%
X
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
46
Combined Effects • Increase Gross Margin 2% • Cut Overhead by 3% • Increase Inventory Turns by 1 • Reduce Age of Accts. Rec. to 30 days
Current Liab. $69,406
+ Long-term
Liab. $266,970
Total Assets
$1,128,055
Total Liab.
$336,376
less
Total Assets
$1,128,055
Net Worth $791,679
Divided by Financial Leverage
1.42
Sales $1,345,803
COGS $878,633
Gross Profit $497,947
Operating Expense
$349,909
Expense Percent
26%
Gross Margin
37%
less
less Operating
Profit $148,038
less Federal Taxes
$0
After-tax Profit $148,038
Sales $1,345,803
Divided by Net Profit
Margin 11%
Inventory Turnover
2.60
Age of Accts. Rec.
30
Inventory $517,616
Accts Receivable
$110,614
+
+
Cash $35,502
Current Assets $663,732
+ Fixed Assets $464,323
Total Assets
$1,128,055
Divided by
Sales $1,345,803
Asset Turnover
1.19
Return on Assets
13.12%
X
Return on Equity
18.70%
X
9/13/2013 Financial Management in Agriculture
47