(ICAO Annex 14 Volume II Heliports) WORKSHOP Annex 14 Heliport Design... · icao annex 14: volume...

transcript

Leverton Associates, Inc

ICAO ‘Annex 14 Update’ Workshop – HAI HeliExpo 2010

ICAO ‘ANNEX 14 UPDATE’

(ICAO Annex 14 Volume II –Heliports)

WORKSHOP

Dr John W. Leverton

IFHA Representative to ICAO Aerodrome Panel

HAI Heliport Design Focal Point

Vice President Infrastructure Development, AHS

HELIPORT/HELIDECK DESIGN

International Federation of Helicopter Associations

ANNEX 14 Vol II WORKSHOP

Comments based on my involvement as the IFHA Representative to the ICAO Aerodrome Panel (AP), the Heliport Design Working Group (HDWG), the Visual Aids Working Group (VAWG) and associated Sub-groups …. …. and Rapporteur of the HDWG Visual Aids Sub-group (VASG).

COMMENTS SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN AS STATEMENT OF ACTUAL ICAO POLICY OR WHAT WILL APPEAR IN THE

NEW ‘TRANCHE 2’ ICAO ANNEX 14 VOLUME II - HELIPORT DESIGN TO BE ISSUED IN 2011 (or 2012!!)

THE VIEWS EXPRESSED ARE MY OWN AND MUST NOT BE TAKEN AS BEING REPRESNTATIVE OF THOSE OF THE

ICAO HDWG, IFHA, HAI OR AHS.

ICAO ‘ANNEX 14 UPDATE’

(ICAO Annex 14 Volume II –Heliports)

WORKSHOP # 1

Dr John W. Leverton

IFHA Representative to ICAO Aerodrome Panel

HAI Heliport Design Focal Point

Vice President Infrastructure Development, AHS

HELIPORT/HELIDECK DESIGN

ICAO ANNEX 14 Vol IIHELIPORTS

(Heliport/Helideck/Shipboard Heliport Design)

ICAO ANNEX 14: VOLUME II – HELIPORTS

New ‘Tranche 1’ Annex 14 = THIRD EDITION – JULY 2009

2004 Annex 14 = SECOND EDITION – Amendment 3 – July 2004

***********************

FAA Advisory Circular (AC) 150-5390-2B (2004)

= AC-2B

PRESENTATION TERMINLOGY

Annex 14 UPDATE PROGRESS

HDSG formed late 2003

HDSG/1 Meeting May 2004 [AP formed Dec 2004]

HDWG/1 Meeting June 2005

[Agreed changes should be addressed in 2 parts – tranche 1 and 2]

HDWG/2 – June 2006

First set of changes (Tranche 1) agreed at HDWG/2 (June 2006) –

Changes endorsed by the „WG of the Whole‟ at WGoTH/3 meeting

(August 2006)

Approved by Aerodrome Panel at AP/1 December 2006.

Tranche 1 Changes approved by ICAO ANC May 2007

ICAO „State Letter‟ ** issued with „Tranche 1 changes‟ August 2007.

** State Letter included also changes to Annex 14 Volume 1 related to Aerodromes

CURRENT STATUS

Updated Annex 14 Volume II – Heliports (Tranche 1)

.......... Issue July 2009:

................applicability date 19 November 2009!

Note: Some ‘helideck requirements’ have later applicability date of 2012

HDWG now finalizing ‘Tranche 2’ Changes

ICAO AP/2 to address ‘tranche 2’ changes, originally planned for 2009, now October 2010.

HDWG planning to ‘start work’ on updating the ICAO Heliport Design Manual (Doc 9261) in 3rd Quarter of 2010 ? – this is of major importance since Manual will detail how to apply ‘Annex 14 Volume II’

CURRENT STATUS

Updated Annex 14 Volume II – Heliports (Tranche 1)

.......... Issue July 2009:

................applicability date 19 November 2009!

Note: Some ‘helideck requirements’ have later applicability date of 2012

HDWG now finalizing ‘Tranche 2’ Changes

ICAO AP/2 to address ‘tranche 2’ changes, originally planned for 2009, now October 2010.

HDWG planning to ‘start work’ on updating the ICAO Heliport Design Manual (Doc 9261) in 3rd Quarter of 2010 ? – this is of major importance since Manual will detail how to apply ‘Annex 14 Volume II’

Annex 14 STATUS

•Chapter 1: General (Definition) - main changes completed in ‘tranche 1’ - addition changes to be made in tranche 2 to cover ‘floating (pontoon) heliports’ etc., and to ensure requirements for VFM (VFR) heliports cover also heliports where an instrument

(Point in Space/PinS) approach is used.

•Chapter 2: Heliport Data – tranche 2 minor changes.

•Chapter 3: Physical Characteristics – main changes completed in ‘tranche 1’: someadditional changes and new term ‘FATO/TLOF’ for elevated heliports and helidecks to be made in tranche 2.

•Chapter 4: Obstacle Restriction and Removal (Airspace) : Study completed for VFM (VFR) heliports - to be issued as part of tranche 2.

•Chapter 5: Visual Aids (Markings & Lighting) - minor changes issued in tranche 1 –changes to ‘markings’ to be issued as part of tranche 2, lighting 40 % complete – still being ‘worked’ – changes to ‘lights’ to be made post-tranche 2.

•Chapter 6: Heliport Services (Fire Fighting) – being addressed by separate RFFWG

Annex 14 Future Work

ICAO agreed –at AP1 (Dec 2006)- for Annex 14 to be reformatted to

make it easier to use – the existing and „new‟ text will be grouped in

the following Chapters:-

Chapter 1. General

Chapter 2. Surface-level Heliports

Chapter 3. Elevated Heliports

Chapter 4. Instrument Heliports

Chapter 5. Helidecks

Chapter 6. Shipboard Heliports and Winching Areas

... and each Chapter will consist of the following sections:-1. General

2. Heliport Data

3. Physical Characteristics

4. Obstacle Restriction and Removal

5. Visual Aids

5.1Marking

5.2Lights

6. Heliport Services

Annex 14 Future Work

Annex 14 to be reformatted to make it easier to use – the existing and

„new‟ text will be grouped in the following Chapters:-

Chapter 1. General

Chapter 2. Surface-level Heliports

Chapter 3. Elevated Heliports

Chapter 4. Instrument Heliports

Chapter 5. Helidecks

Chapter 6. Shipboard Heliports and Winching Areas

... and each Chapter will consist of the following sections:-1. General

2. Heliport Data

3. Physical Characteristics

4. Obstacle Restriction and Removal

5. Visual Aids

5.1Marking

5.2Lights

6. Heliport Services

ICAO DOCUMENTS

THIRD EDITION – JULY 2009

HELIPORT MANUAL; THIRD EDITION – 1995

(DOC 9261 – AN/903)

RELATED DOCUMENTS

ICAO ANNEX 6, PART III INTERNATIONAL OPERATIONS –

HELICOPTERS: SIXTH EDITION – JULY 2004

ICAO ANNEX 14, VOLUME I – AERODROME DESIGN AND OPERATIONS –

JULY 1990

ICAO DOCUMENTS

SECOND EDITION -- JULY 1995

[ AMENDMENT 2 (Minor change re Aeronautical Data): NOVEMBER 1997

ADMENTMENT 3 (Major Lighting Changes): NOVEMBER 2004

ICAO DOCUMENTS

ICAO Heliport Manual, which is out of date and incorrect in some sections folowing the issue of the Tranche 1 changes, needs to be updated: HDWG is starting work on the sections on helidecks … no specific plans for addressing heliports: aim to decide by 3rd

quarter of 2010…. even so a replacement will not be available for a number of years!!

Silverstone Paris

‘Free Field‟ Performance Class 1*

„Elongated FATO‟ Performance Class 2 & 3*

* NOT ICAO terms

Silverstone Paris

‘Free Field‟ Performance Class 1*

„Elongated FATO‟ Performance Class 2 & 3*

* NOT ICAO terms

Tranche 2 Proposal – to be called “Runway-type FATOs.”

Runway-type FATO. A FATO having characteristics similar in shape to a fixed wing

runway with a length-to-width ratio of at least 3:1.

ELEVATED HELIPORTS

SURFACE LEVEL HELIORTS

HELIDECKS

SHIPBOARD HELIPORT

Floating (Pontoon) Heliport Heliport on „structure‟ over water

Surface-level heliport. A heliport located on the ground or on

the water.

Tranche 2 Proposal:

Surface-level heliport. A heliport located on the ground or on

a structure on the surface of the water.

Elevated heliport. A heliport located on a raised structure on land

Tranche 2 Proposal:

Elevated heliport. A heliport located on a raised structure on land.

Proposed „Tranche 2‟ Definition Changes

Melbourne, Australia

Safety

HELIPORT TERMINLOGY

FATO: Final Approach and Takeoff Area

TLOF: Touchdown and Liftoff Area

Can be any shape – usually square or round

Safety

TLOF/Central Zone

HELIPORT TERMINLOGY

FATO: Final Approach and Takeoff Area

TLOF: Touchdown and Liftoff Area

TLOF can be outside of FATO located in a helicopter stand

Protection Area

Helicopter Stand

PRESENTATION TERMINOLOGY

RD = ROTOR DIAMETER

D = „D-value‟ = OVERALL LENGTH (OL)

UCw = UNDERCARRIAGE WIDTH/LENGTH

PC1, PC2 & PC 3 is used to refer to heliports designed on

the assumption that they are “intended to be used by

helicopters operated in performance class 1” or

“performance class 2 and 3” respectively.

The „diagrams‟, although illustrating the approximate relative sizes are

NOT to scale - this is not stated on all diagrams.

OEI200 ft

Reject T/O DistanceFATO

Safe forced landing – outside heliport

AEO OE

I200 ft

Safe forced landing – outside heliportFATO

PERFORMANCE CLASSIFICATIONS

PERFORMANCE CLASS 1

PERFORMANCE CLASS 2

PERFORMANCE CLASS 3

[Chart Based on Figures supplied by Jim Lyons]

US (FAA) AC150/5390-2B

FAA AC 150/5390-2B-2B (AC-2B) Heliport Design was issued on 9/30/04 (30 September 2004) and is available on a number of FAA and other web sites - the following is one useful web site to obtain the document:-

http://www.faa.gov/arp/publications/acs/5390-2/5390-2b.pdf

Hardcopies are NOT available from the FAA – they are available from a number of commercial suppliers at a fee.

NOTE: AC-2B is an “Advisory Circular” i.e. Guidelines … but is a Requirement for heliports which use Federal Funds and is a Requirements in a number of the US States.

Annex 14/FAA

MAJOR DIFFERENCES

ICAO ANNEX 14 ~ FAA AC 150-5390-2B*

• ANNEX 14 BASED ON “OPERATIONAL

PERFORMANCE” REQUIREMENTS (HELICOPTER PERFORMANCE CLASS) DEFINED IN ANNEX 6

• FAA AC-2B BASED ON HELIPORT TYPE (USE).

• Main Technical Differences • Load Bearing Area Size Requirements**• Airspace Requirements

*Issued by FAA in September 2004.

** Differences between „Annex 14 Vol II‟ and FAA AC-2B are considerably less

as a result of the „tranche 1‟ changes.

AIM•EXPLANATION OF TERMINOLOGY AND CONCEPTS USED IN

ICAO ANNEX 14 Vol II

•DISCUSSION AND OUTLINE OF :-

(i) Changes in Annex 14 „tranche 1‟ issued July 2009

(ii) Additional changes being considered by the ICAO HELIPORT

DESIGN WORKING GROUP (HDWG) for „tranche 2‟ .... and some

„Post-Tranche 2‟ changes.

(iii) Review of main differences between US/FAA Heliport Design AC

150/5390-2B (AC-2B) and „tranche 1‟ ICAO Annex 14 „standards and

recommended practices‟ (SARPS) for heliports

ICAO ANNEX 14

(i) Changes in Annex 14 „tranche 1‟ to be issued April/May 2009

DESIGN WORKING GROUP (HDWG) for „tranche 2‟.

*** Tranche 2 Proposal – also cover heliports with PinS approaches

ICAO ANNEX 14

(i) Changes in Annex 14 „tranche 1‟ to be issued April/May 2009

DESIGN WORKING GROUP (HDWG) for „tranche 2‟.

ELEVATED HELIPORTS

FATO AND TLOF ARE “COINCIDENTAL” *

(i.e. SAME SIZE – 1D or 0.83 D)… and FATO IS DLB.

DLB = Dynamic Load Bearing **

* Also applies to Helidecks

** Currently difference in DLB requirements:

FAA 1.5 x MTOW Annex 14 2.5 x MTOM

[Both applied through 2 points of contact.]

Covered in Heliport Manual – NOT addressed in Annex 14 – not reviwed to date by HDWG or any Sub-group.

ICAO/International MTOM (Max Takeoff Mass) = US MTOW (Max Takeoff Weight)

ELEVATED HELIPORTS

FATO AND TLOF ARE “COINCIDENTAL” *

(i.e. SAME SIZE – 1D or 0.83 D)… and FATO IS DLB.

DLB = Dynamic Load Bearing **

* Also applies to Helidecks

** Currently difference in DLB requirements:

FAA 1.5 x MTOW Annex 14 2.5 x MTOM

[Both applied through 2 points of contact.]

Covered in Heliport Manual – NOT addressed in Annex 14 – not reviwed to date by HDWG or any Sub-group.

ICAO/International MTOM (Max Takeoff Mass) = US MTOW (Max Takeoff Weight)

Tranche 2 Proposal – new term FATO/TLOF

DIFFERENCES

AC-2B ANNEX 14

PARKING AREA = HELICOPTER STAND

HOVER-TAXI = AIR-TAXI

ICAO FRAMEWORK

• PPR (Private Use) Heliports Not Directly Considered In Annex 14 [Only Brief Reference To PPR Heliports Made In This Presentation]

• Annex 14 covers Hospital Heliports ** - Most European Nations consider Annex 14 Applies To All „Public Interest‟ Facilities including Hospital Heliports.

• “Europe” considers Hospital Heliports should be designed for Performance Class 1 operations –requirement of JAR OPS 3 …

... or with a DLB Area (FATO + Safety area) of 2D

** US/FAA considers HOSPITAL HELIPORTS are „PRIVATE USE‟

GENERAL

• PC2 and PC3 Heliports in ICAO Annex 14

corresponds to General Aviation Heliport in FAA

• PC1 Heliport in ICAO Annex 14 is approximately

the same as Transport Heliport in FAA AC … but is

Annex 14 based on PC1/Cat A performance rather

that dimensions related to size of helicopter as in

FAA AC-2B: in this case Annex 14 generally less

demanding and more logical than FAA AC-2B!

GENERAL

• PC2 and PC3 Heliports in ICAO Annex 14

corresponds to General Aviation Heliport in FAA

• PC1 Heliport in ICAO Annex 14 is approximately

the same as Transport Heliport in FAA AC … but

is Annex 14 based on PC1/Cat A performance

rather that dimensions related to size of helicopter

as in FAA AC-2B: Annex 14 generally less

demanding and more logical than FAA AC-2B!

PC2/PC3 Heliports

2004 Annex 14

- FATO is equivalent to TLOF in FAA AC

- TLOF of 1.5UC is similar to PPR ‘2UC paved portion

of the TLOF’.

‘New’ 2009 Tranche 1 ‘ Annex 14

– FATO and TLOF in general terms same as in FAA AC

HELIPORT TERMINOLOGY CHANGES

ICAO ANNEX 14 - HELIPORTS

• PERFORMANCE CLASS 1 (PC1)

• PERFORMANCE CLASS 2 & 3 (PC2/PC3)

NOTE: ICAO ANNEX 14 APPLIES TO SURFACE

(GROUND) LEVEL AND ELEVATED HELIPORTS

…….AND HELIDECKS

US/FAA USES AIRWORTHINESS CATORGIES – CAT A and CAT B. NO

FAA PERFORMANCE CLASS / CAT REQUIREMENTS RELATED TO

OPERATIONS AT HELIPORTS – SOME „TRANSPORT/CAT A

REQUIREMENTS‟ APPLIED IN CASE OF SCHEDULE OPERATIONS.

PERFORMANCE

REQUIREMENTS

ICAO ANNEX 6*(JAR-OPS 3) US/FAA**

PERFORMANCE CLASS 1 CAT A

PERFORMANCE CLASS 2 CAT B***

PERFORMANCE CLASS 3 CAT B

*ANNEX 6: UPDATED/REVISED BY THE ICAO HELICOPTER TILTROTOR STUDY GROUP

(HTSG) – New version issued in 2007.

** CAT A (CATEGORY A) AND CAT B (CATEGORY B) ARE AIRWORTHINESS

CERTIFICATION DESIGNATIONS. –

*** PC 2 – AKIN TO “CAT B TAKEOFF AND LANDING + CAT A EN-ROUTE/CRUISE”: SOME

US/FAA CAT A/OEI EN-ROUTE REQUIREMENTS.

OEI200 ft

AEO OE

I200 ft

PERFORMANCE CLASS 1

PERFORMANCE CLASS 2

PERFORMANCE CLASS 3

OEI200 ft

AEO OE

I200 ft

PERFORMANCE CLASS 1

PERFORMANCE CLASS 2

PERFORMANCE CLASS 3

„Cat A‟

„Cat A‟ Enroute - Cat B T/O + Land

„Cat B‟

PERFORMANCE CLASS 1

(FREE-FIELD) CAT. A.

ICAO Annex 14 FATO

„RESTRICTED FIELD LENGTH‟ CAT. A.

PC1 GROUND SPACE

„Clearway‟: area to be protected – not required to be

load bearing

Free-field/Clear-area Cat A

„Clearway‟: area to be

protected – not required to

be load bearing

Area defined in the H/RFM

PC1 GROUND SPACE

Restricted Area/Short-field Cat A

IMPACT OF HELIDECK HEIGHT

IMPACT OF HELIPORT HEIGHT

„NO-Drop Down‟ for Scheduled!!

Ground Level

ICAO/FAA RELATIONSHIP?

ICAO FAA

PC 1 TRANSPORT

PC 2 GENERAL AVIATION*

PC 3 HOSPITAL

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------GROUND GROUND

ELEVATED ELEVATED

HELIDECKS [Not addressed by FAA]

* ALSO INCLUDES PRIVATE USE/PPR

NO DIRECT

ICAO ANNEX 14 – FAA AC

RELATIONSHIP

BUT ……

MAJOR DIFFERENCES

ICAO ANNEX 14 ~ FAA AC 150-5390-2B*

• ANNEX 14 BASED ON “OPERATIONAL

PERFORMANCE” REQUIREMENTS (HELICOPTER

PERFORMANCE CLASSES)

• FAA AC-2B BASED ON HELIPORT USE.

• MAIN TECHNICAL DIFFERENCES

• LOAD BEARING AREA REQUIREMENTS

• AIRPSACE REQUIREMENTS

* ISSUED BY FAA IN SEPTEMBER 2004.

GROUND SPACE FATO

• ICAO ANNEX 14* „LINKED‟ TO ICAO ANNEX 6

i.e. DESIGN REQUIREMENTS LINKED TO HELICOPTER PERFORMANCE CLASS (PERFORMANCE CLASS 1, 2 AND 3)

• FAA AC 150/5390-2B „RELATED‟ TO HELIPORT USE

GENERAL AVIATION [PRIVATE USE/PPR]

HOSPITAL

TRANSPORT **

i.e. NO DIRECT „LINK‟ BETWEEN DESIGN AND OPERATIONAL / PERFORMANCE REQUIREMENTS

** EXCEPTION IN THAT CONSIDERATION IS GIVEN TO OPERATIONAL PERFORMANCE NEEDS IN DESIGN OF „TRANSPORT HELIPORTS‟.

*AND ASSOCIATED HELIPORT MANUAL

End of this section ….

…… MORE TO COME

(ICAO Annex 14 Volume II Heliports) WORKSHOP Annex 14 Heliport Design... · icao annex 14: volume...

Documents