Post on 11-Sep-2021
transcript
title:LivingOntheBoott:HistoricalArchaeologyAttheBoottMillsBoardinghouses,Lowell,Massachusetts
author: Mrozowski,StephenA.;Ziesing,GraceH.;Beaudry,MaryCarolyn
publisher: UniversityofMassachusettsPressisbn10|asin: 1558490345printisbn13: 9781558490345ebookisbn13: 9780585212814
language: English
subject
Lowell(Mass.)--Antiquities,Archaeologyandhistory--Massachusetts--Lowell,BoottMills(Lowell,Mass.),Boardinghouses--Massachusetts--Lowell,Workingclass--Massachusetts--Lowell--History.
publicationdate: 1996lcc: F74.L9M761996ebddc: 974.4/4
subject:
Lowell(Mass.)--Antiquities,Archaeologyandhistory--Massachusetts--Lowell,BoottMills(Lowell,Mass.),Boardinghouses--Massachusetts--Lowell,Workingclass--Massachusetts--Lowell--History.
Pagei
LivingontheBoott
Pageii
Frontispiece1.AviewoftheBoottCottonMillyard
publishedinGleason'sPictorialin1852
Frontispiece2.BostonUniversitygraduatestudentsexcavatingawell
discoveredintherearyardofBoottBoardinghouseUnit#48
Pageiii
LivingontheBoottHistoricalArchaeologyattheBoottMillsBoardinghouses,Lowell,Massachusetts
StephenA.Mrozowski,GraceH.Ziesing,andMaryC.Beaudry
Copyright©1996bytheLowellHistoricPreservationCommissionAllrightsreservedPrintedintheUnitedStatesofAmericaLC95-52177ISBN1-55849-034-5(cloth);035-3(pbk.)DesignedbySallyNicholsSetinNewBaskervillePrintedandboundbyThomson-Shore,Inc.
LibraryofCongressCataloging-in-Publicationdata
Mrozowski,StephenA.LivingontheBoott:historicalarchaeologyattheBoottMillsBoardinghouses,Lowell,Massachusetts/StephenA.Mrozowski,GraceH.Ziesing,andMaryC.Beaudry.
p.cm.Includesbibliographicalreferencesandindex.ISBN1-55849-034-5(cloth:alk.paper).ISBN1-55849-035-3(pbk.:alk.paper)1.Lowell(Mass.)Antiquities.2.ArchaeologyandhistoryMassachusetts-Lowell.3.BootMills(Lowell,Mass.)4.BoardinghousesMassachusettsLowell.5.WorkingclassMassachusettsLowellHistory.I.Ziesing,GraceH.II.Beaudry,MaryCarolyn,1950-.III.Title.F74.L9M761996974.4'4dc2095-52177CIP
BritishLibraryCataloguinginPublicationdataareavailable.
ThisbookispublishedwiththesupportandcooperationoftheUniversityofMassachusettsBostonandtheLowellHistoricPreservationCommission.
Pagev
BothofuswouldliketothankGraceZiesingforherkindnessinallowingustodedicatethisbooktothememoriesofourfathers,
EugeneJamesBeaudryandStephenAlbertMrozowskiSr.
Pagevii
ContentsListofIllustrations ix
Preface xi
Introduction 1
TheBoottMillsandItsBoardinghouses 4
ArchaeologyinaParkingLot 9
HistoricalArchaeologyinContext 13
ToolsoftheTrade 15
PuttingthePiecesTogether 34
ArchaeologyattheBoottMills 36
Lowell'sUrbanLandscape 38
ALandscapeChanged 38
Pageviii
ThePlannedCity 39
TheBackyardStory 43
LivingConditionsofBoottMillsWorkers 49
LifeinanUrbanBoardinghouse 50
Sanitation 52
Hygiene 53
Health 55
ThePersonalTouch 57
MealtimesattheBoott 59
Working-ClassMeals 60
ATellingComparison 64
LeisureTimeattheBoott 66
CigarsandCutties 67
Alcohol 71
Postscript 74
ClothingandPersonalAdornment 75
JewelryandBeads 77
HairCombsandOrnaments 78
ButtonsandStuds 79
TheBiggerPicture 81
SourcesandFurtherReading 85
Index 91
Pageix
Illustrations1.BoottmillyardonSidney&NeffmapofLowell,1850 6
2.Bird's-eyemapofLowell,1876 8
3.Jackhammerarchaeology 10
4.Boardinghousewallrevealed 14
5.ProbateinventoryofAmandaFox 20
6.ResidentBlancheGrahamwithMaryBeaudryandKathleenBond
22
7.Recoveredplatefragments 24
8.Whitewarecoffeecup 25
9.Eveningprimrosepollengrain 28
10.Goldenrod/aster-typepollengrain 29
11.Laboratoryanalysisofceramicfragments 33
12."PatucketFarmsintheTownofChelmsford,"1822 40
13.Lowellin1825 41
Pagex
14.Bird's-eyeviewofLowell,1876 41
15.KirkStreetagents'housetoday 42
16.Elevationsof"oneofthe...BoardingHouses,"1836 43
17.Excavatedrearyardoftenement. 45
18.Planofexcavatedrearyard 46
19.SketchofinterioroftheJohnStreetboardinghouse 50
20.Floorplansandelevationsforboardinghouses,1836 51
21.Washdayinaboardinghousebacklot 54
22."KissMeI'mSterilized"button 56
23.Thediningroomofaboardinghouse 60
24.Whitewarecupfragments 60
25.Pearlwarecupfragments 61
26.Claypipewithstampedstem 68
27.Embossedpipebowl 68
28.Illustrationofwomansmokingapipe 69
29.One-pintliquorbottles 70
30.Sodabottles 71
31.Liquorbottlesfoundoutsideaprivy 72
32.Copperalloybrooch 76
33.Combs 77
34.UnidentifiedworkersstandingoutsideBootthousing,ca.1889
82
Pagexi
Preface''LivingontheBoott"wasaphraseemployedbytheworkersattheBoottCottonMillsinLowell,Massachusetts,thatcametosymbolizeawayoflife.Forthosewholaboredinthemillsandthenmadetheshortwalktothecompany-suppliedboardinghouses,"theBoott"wasbothworkplaceandlivingaccommodation.Throughoutmuchofthenineteenthcentury,workingtwelvehoursaday,sixdaysaweek,skilledandunskilledlaborershadlittlebreakfromtheirtoilinthemills.Theirfreetimewasoftenspentwithotherworkerslivingintheboardinghousesor,inthecaseofsomeskilledworkers,withtheirfamiliesincompany-suppliedtenements.DespitethehistoriesthathavebeenwrittenconcerningtheindustrialrevolutionandLowellinparticular,thereisstillmuchtobelearnedaboutthedailylivesofmillworkersandtheirworld.Thesepeoplewerepivotalactorsinoneofthemostimportantdramasinhumanhistory.Theirexperienceswouldcontributetothegrowthofworking-classconsciousnessand
Pagexii
helptoformanAmericanculture.Theirlivesaretooimportanttobeleftinobscurity.Buthowdoweretrievethemfromthepast?Howdowebringthemillworkersandtheirworldbacktolifesothatwecanbetterunderstandthelivestheyexperienced?
Historicalarchaeologyprovidesonemethodforrediscoveringthesepastlives.Unlikethescientistsseekingtheprehistoricdawnofhumankind,historicalarchaeologistsplytheircraftfillinginthegapsinhistory.Theirsearchisnotforthehistoryofgreatmenorgreatbattles,butforahistoryrichintexture,fullofthelivesofordinarypeople.Toooften,theselivesfallbelowthethresholdofahistorybasedsolelyonthewrittenword.Throughexcavation,theanalysisofartifacts,andawiderangeofinterdisciplinarytechniques,historicalarchaeologistscanweavetogetherthestrandsofpastlives.Oneofthechiefpurposesofthisbookistoexplainthisprocessofdiscovery.
Attheheartofthisprocessisourconcernforboththepeopleandtheworldinwhichtheylived.Peopledonotliveinavacuum.Theirlivesareinfluencedbythetimesinwhichtheylive.Contextgavemeaningtopeople'slivesinthepastjustastoday'sworldgivesmeaningtoourownlives.Languageprovidesagoodexampleoftheimportanceofcontext.Inthe1985filmBacktotheFuture,MichaelJ.Fox(whogoesbackintimetothe1950s)oftenusestheterm"heavy"todescribevarioussituations.Doc,his1950sfriend,isperplexedbythetermbecauseheassumesitisusedliterallytomeanthatthingsweighmuchmoreinthefuture.Hedoesnotunderstandthecontextinwhichthetermwasapplied.Thesameistrueforarchaeologiststryingtocomprehendthepast.Unlessweexaminethepastinitstotality,takingintoaccountafullrangeofevidence,wetendtolearnmostlyaboutthelivesofwealthyandimportantpersons.ThismeansweneedtopayasmuchattentiontothebackyardofaboardinghouseinhabitedbytheworkingpoorastothebiographieswrittenabouttheinfluentialfoundersofLowell.Ifourgoalisatotal,moredemocratichistory,
botharenecessary.
Archaeologyisaninterdisciplinaryfieldthatdrawsupondiverse
Pagexiii
disciplineswithinthesocialsciences,humanities,andnaturalsciences,bringingtogethermultiplelinesofevidencetoexaminetheculturalandsocialaspectsofmateriallifeinthepast.Historicalarchaeologyisasubfieldofarchaeologythatfocusesontherelativelyrecentpast,employingwrittenrecordsincombinationwithexcavatedevidenceasprimarysourcematerialsandusingwrittenhistories,oraltestimony,andpictorialevidenceinconjunctionwithartifactanalysisandenvironmentalreconstructiontoframecontextsforinterpretation.HistorianshaveapproachedLowell'spastfrommanyanglesandfromtheperspectiveofmanydisciplinesandsubdisciplines:laborhistory,businessandeconomichistory,women'sstudies,immigrationhistory,thehistoryoftechnology,architecture,anthropology,folklore,politicalscience,publicadministration,urbanstudies,andsoforth.EachperspectivebringsfreshinsightintoourunderstandingofLowellanditsplaceinAmericanhistory.Historicalarchaeology,whichreliesonthemethodsandproductsofmanydisciplinestoproducenewwaysoflookingatlifeinthepast,alsohasavalidroletoplay.Inthislittlebook,weofferacasestudythatillustratessomeofthecontributionshistoricalarchaeologyismakingtothebroaderstudyofthecity'spast,notingthatalthoughhistoricalarchaeologycannotstandaloneasanavenueofinvestigation,itisavaluablecomplementtohistoriesbasedonwrittenrecordsalone.
Thearchaeologicalrecordseldomgivesuseverythingwewant.Wehavetotakewhatwecanget.InthecaseoftheBoottMillsboardinghousestherecordvaries.ThewrittenrecordcoversthespanofLowell'shistory.OurdataontheevolutionofLowell'surbanlandscape,thestandingbuildingsandthestreetsaswellasthewealthofarchaeologicalinformationlockedinthesoils,arerichindetailandcoverthecenturyasawhole.Intermsofartifacts,however,therecordismostrepresentativeofthelastthreedecadesofthe1800sandinparticulartheperiodattheendofthecentury.Intellingthestorythat
thearchaeologyreveals,wehavetriedtominimizethecon-
Pagexiv
fusionthatcouldarisefrommovingbetweenthesedifferentperiodsoftime,whileattemptingtomaintaintheflowofournarrative.
Forthesamereason,wechosenottointerruptthetextwithcitationsandreferencesthatmightprovedistracting;instead,thereaderwillfindattheendofthebookalistofsourcesforeachchapter,forin-depthreadingonspecificpointsaswellasforfurther,moregeneralexplorationofthetopicsweaddress.
Manypeopledeservecreditformakingthisbookpossible.MostimportantarethemembersandstaffoftheLowellHistoricPreservationCommissionwhoprovidedfundsanddirectionfortheproject.InparticularwewouldliketothankPeterAucella,executivedirectoroftheCommission;PeterPromutico,contractingofficerfortheCommission;andespeciallyCulturalAffairsOfficerJulietMofford,whoprovidedhelp,encouragement,andeditorialassistancethroughouttheprojectaswellaspatienceandunderstanding.OtherswhoplayedaroleintheLowellProjectwereFrancisP.McManamon,whowaschiefofculturalresourcesfortheNorthAtlanticRegionoftheNationalParkServicewhentheprojectbegan,andMyraHarrison,whoservedinthesamecapacitywhentheideaofthebookwasformulated.ShealsodeservesspecialthanksforhercontinuingsupportoftheprojectasamemberoftheLowellHistoricPreservationCommission.SomanyofthestaffattheLowellHistoricalNationalParkdeserveacknowledgmentthatwearesuretomisssome;however,wewouldliketothankChrysandraWalterandLarryGallfortheirsupportoftheproject.MichaelWurm,MartinBlatt,andMarkBogradallreadportionsofthemanuscriptandforthiswethankthem.Theircommentsandsuggestionsprovedvitalinseeingthebooktocompletion.OtherreviewersincludedJohnWorrellofOldSturbridgeVillage;JamesKrowlikowski,whoteacheshighschoolinManchester,NewHampshire,oneofNewEngland'sgreatmilltowns;andRobertPaynteroftheUniversityofMassachusetts,Amherst.
SpecialthankstoMarkVagos,whowasalwayshelpfulinthefield.AnneLangandJaneMcKinneyhavehelpedtoeditthefinalversionandLeslieDriscoll
Pagexv
hashelpedwiththegraphics.GregoryBrownoftheColonialWilliamsburgFoundationhandledtheproductionofthefinaltext.TothemanyBostonUniversitygraduatestudentswhoparticipatedintheLowellproject,thankyouforyoureffortsandenthusiasm.Thanksalsotoourfriendandcolleague,GeraldKelso,whoseknowledgeofpalynologyandthelandscapewasoneofthekeystotheproject'ssuccess.Toalltheseandanywehaveforgotten,thankyou.
Page1
IntroductionLowellislocatedattheconfluenceoftheMerrimackandConcordRiversinnorthernMassachusetts,neartheNewHampshireborder.LikemostofNewEnglandatthebeginningofthenineteenthcentury,thispartofMassachusetts,thenknownasEastChelmsford,wasfarmland.Bythesecondquarterofthenineteenthcentury,however,manyNewEnglandtownswerealreadyintransitionfromagricultureandhouseholdmanufacturetoindustrializationandtheconsumptionofshop-andfactory-madegoods.EastChelmsfordwasnoexception;itslocationnearthefallsoftheMerrimackanditsrecentlycompletedpowercanalforavarietyoflocalfactoryandmillingoperationsmadeitanidealsitefortheBostonAssociates,agroupofwealthyinvestorsledbythecannymerchant-manufacturerNathanAppleton,todevelopfortheexpansionofoperationsbeyondthelimitedcapacityoftheirfirstmechanizedfactoryinWaltham,Massachusetts.
Page2
ThefoundingofLowellin1825wasaplannedventureshapedbytheneedsofindustryandtheinterestsofcapital.Thefactories,streetlayout,andworkeraccommodationswereconstructedaccordingtodetailedplans,carefullythoughtout;inlikemanner,companyregulationspromulgatedapolicyofcorporatepaternalismintendedtoguideandprotectthemoralsofworkers.TheBostonAssociatesweremotivatedbythenegativemodelofindustrialcitiesofEurope;theysoughttocreateatotal,plannedindustrialcommunity,todeterthegrowthofcrowded,unsanitaryslumsforwhichtheymightbeblamedasmuchastoavoidconditionsthatmightleadtolaborunrest.Initially,thecorporationssoughttoattractyoungwomenfromNewEnglandfarmstoserveastheunskilledlaborforceforthemills.TheYankee"millgirls,"astheywerecalled,livedincloselysupervised,company-runboardinghousesonlyashortdistancefromthemills.Byday,inred-brickfactoriesstretchedalongthegrowingnetworkofpowercanals,themillgirlstendedrankuponrankofwater-poweredmachinesthatwovemillionsofyardsofcloth.Beyondthemills,acommercialdistrictandresidentialneighborhoodstookshapeinalessorderlyfashion.Bythemiddleofthenineteenthcentury,EastChelmsfordhadbeentransformedfromafarmingcommunityboastingsomefiftyfamiliestoa"spindlecity"ofmorethantwentythousandresidents,manyofwhomlivedinboardinghousesandtenements.
Bymidcentury,however,theYankee"millgirls"werebeingreplacedbyimmigrantworkers,atfirstIrishandFrenchCanadian.Asthenineteenthcenturyprogressed,newwavesofemigrantsfromeasternEuropemovedtoLowellandtookuptheunskilledjobsinthemills.Corporatepaternalism,thepolicyintendedtosafeguardthemoralcharacterandphysicalwell-beingofyoungwomenfactoryworkers,erodedastheworkforcechangedandimmigrantworkers,ofteninfamilygroups,predominatedasboardinghouseresidents.Increasingly,
thecorporationsfoundthatmaintaininghousingforitslaborforcewastoogreatadrainonresources,andtheybegantoinvestinwaystoimprovetheefficiencyofmachinesandpeople.
Page3
Towardtheendofthecentury,themillsbegantoselloffhousingtoprivatelandlordsandtodemolishboardinghousestomakewayforwarehousesandotherstructures.Inthetwentiethcentury,organizedlabormadestrikesaneffectivetoolforimprovingworkingconditionsandpay,butthepriceprovedtoohighforindustrialiststobear.TheNewEnglandtextileeconomywentintodeclineasmanufacturersrelocatedtoplaceswherelaborwascheapandunionswereweak.
TodayLowellhasemergedfromdeclineanddeteriorationtoserveasthehomefornewindustriesandhightechnology.MuchofLowell'srebirthstemsfromitspeople'sdeterminationtoextolthecity'spastandfromitscontinuinggrowthasadiverse,multiculturalcommunity,demonstratingthatitsgreatestresourceshavealwaysbeenitspeopleandthestoriesoftheirlives.Thecityhasmemorializeditshistoryanditspeopleinnumerousways:withscholarlyandpopularbooks,museumexhibits,parks,festivals,and,asweshallsee,archaeologicalresearchthathighlightsandcelebratesLowell'sworkersandtheirdiverseexperiences.
AgreatdealhasbeenwrittenaboutLowell,itsplaceinindustrialhistory,thetechnologicaldevelopmentsofitstextilemills,andevenaboutitsworkersandmanagers.Thereisanabundanceofhistoricalmaterialfromwhichtogatherinformation,includingthestories,letters,anddiariesoftheworkersthemselves.Buttheserecords,asrichastheyare,canonlygiveusonesideofthestory,thatwhichthepeoplethemselveschosetotellinwords.Thereisyetanotherstoryburiedbeneaththestreets,parkinglots,andyardsofpresent-dayLowell.Withthetoolsandskillsofthearchaeologist,wecanretrievethestoryoftheeverydaylivesofworkersinLowell.Wecandothisbylookingattheobjectstheyleftbehindandthephysicalworldtheyinhabited.
Thisbookpresentstheresultsofthearchaeologicalinvestigations
undertakenbytheNationalParkServiceandtheCenterforArchaeologicalStudiesatBostonUniversityattherequestoftheLowellHistoricPreservationCommission.Thisresearchfocusedonthemill
Page4
workers,thosepeoplewhoranthemillsbutwhohaveremainedinthebackgroundoftraditionalindustrialarchaeology.Thepurposeoftheresearchwastoilluminatetheeverydaylivesofthesepeopleoutsidetheworkplaceandintheirhomes,whichwere,forthemostpart,thecorporation-runboardinghousesandtenements.(Thetermboardinghousecommonlyreferstoboththeunitsforunskilledlaborersandthetenementsforskilledlaborersandtheirfamilies.Throughoutthetextthetermboardinghousewillbeemployedtorefertobothformsofhousingexceptwhennoted.)
TheBoottMillsandItsBoardinghouses
TheBoottCottonMillswasincorporatedonMarch27,1835,forthemanufactureofcottonandwoolencloth.Housingformillworkerswassuppliedbythecorporationandwasonlyashortwalkfromthemills.Thishousingconsistedofthirty-twoboardinghousesoriginallydesignedforunskilled,unmarriedworkers,andthirty-twotenements(morelikeapartments)forsupervisorsorskilledlaborersandtheirfamilies.Theseunitswerearrangedineightlongblocks,eachwithfourboardinghousesandfourtenements.
Tenementsweremuchlikeapartmentsorindependentlivingunitswithindividualkitchenfacilities.Theseweretheplaceswherefamilieslived.Theboardinghouseswereverydifferent.Theyweredesignedaslow-costcommunallivingunitsforaboutthirtypeople.ThepersoninchargeoftheboardinghousewasemployedbytheBoottMillsCorporationandcalleda"keeper."Housingcosts,includingboard,weredeductedfromwages.Onaverage,anunskilledlaborerreceived$1.50to$2.00perweekabovethefeeof$1.25to$1.50deductedforroomandboard.Forthisthelaborersgotcookedmeals,washedlinens,andabed,whichtheysometimeshadtoshare.Therewereseveralcategoriesofunskilledandskilledworkersandthesalariesvariedaccordingtotheresponsibilitiesandcapabilities
requiredforthejob.Wageschangedovertimeandwerealsoaffectedbyprofits.Ifprofitsdroppedsodidwages.
Page5
Theprimaryfocusofourresearchwastheunskilledmillworkerswholivedinthecompany-ownedboardinghousesandtheskilledlaborersandtheirfamilieswholivedintheadjoiningtenements.Excavationswereconductedintheyardbehindboardinghouseunit#45aswellasintheyardoftenementunit#48inthebuildingblockalongJames(laterSirk)Street.ThiswasoneofeightboardinghouseblocksthattheBoottMillsconstructedbetween1835and1839.Historicalresearchbeforeexcavationgaveusafairlygoodideaofwhohadlivedthere.
InordertoprovideapointofcomparisonwealsoconductedexcavationsintherearyardoftheKirkStreetagents'house,whichwasconstructedin1845.ThiswasthehouseinwhichtheagentsfortheBoottandMassachusettsCottonMillslived.Theagentservedafunctionsimilartothechiefexecutiveofficerofamajorcompanytoday.Hewashiredbytheownersofthemillstorunthemills.Thiswasamultifacetedtaskthatincludedeverythingfromoverseeingtheconstructionofthemillstosupervisingcompanypersonnel.Thecomparisonoftheordinaryworkers'backyardsandtheagents'backyardhighlightedaspectsofnineteenth-centurylifesuchasdiet,landuse,anddiseasethatmaynothavebeenobviousotherwise.
BoardinghouseResidents
ThereissomeinformationrecordedabouttheresidentsofBoottunits#45and#48,butsincethepersonallivesofemployeeswerenotconsideredimportant,theinformationisrathervague.Workerscameandwent,butusuallyonlytheirnames,ages,andsometimestheirplacesofbirthwererecorded.
Boardinghouseunit#45wasinhabitedalmostexclusivelybywomenfrom1850through1880(usuallyaroundtwenty-fivetothirtywomenatanygiventime)whileitwasunderthecontrolofonekeeper,AmandaFox.LettersfromformertenantsandBoottCompanycorrespondencepaintAmandaasahard-workingwidowwhotookher
responsibilitiesasakeeperseriously.ThecharacteroftheboardinghousechangedafterAmanda'sdeath.Censusesfrom1900and
1.Theview(lookingwest)ofBoottmillyardshownontheSidney&Neff1850mapofLowell.(CourtesyofLowellHistoricalSociety.)
Page7
1910showthatthehousewasoccupiedthenalmostentirelybymen,themajorityofwhomwereFrenchCanadianin1910.Also,in1910thehousewasnolongeroverseenbyawoman,butbyJosephCroteau.Weshallexaminethispopulationchangelater.
Thetenement,unit#48,hadaverydifferentoccupationhistory.Fromatleast1850through1900ithousedaseriesoffamilies,allofwhichincludedsmallchildren.Inthecensuses,themenwerelistedasskilledworkersinthemillandtheirwiveskepthouse.
TheboardinghousesandtenementsalongJamesStreetweresoldbytheBoottMillsCorporationintoprivatehandssometimearound1907.Theywereturnedintoprivaterentalunits,thoughthetenantscontinuedtobemillemployees.Bothunits#45and#48ceasedtobeusedasdwellingsby1918,andwereturnedintostoragefacilitiesinstead.Theentireblockwastorndownin1934,afterwhichitwasusedasacoalyardandthenasaparkinglot.
Amorepersonalviewoftheboardinghousesisofferedbytheoralhistoryofawomanwholivedinoneasachildintheearlypartofthiscentury.BlanchePelletierGrahamlivedinaBoottMillsboardinghouseonJohnStreet(oneblockoverfromtheboardinghouseweexcavated)from1907to1912.BecauseBlanchewasachildwhenshelivedonJohnStreet,shehadthememoriesofachild,notthoseofanadultmillworker.Butshewasabletorememberthelayoutofthehouseshelivedinandeventomakeasketchofthefirstfloor.Sherememberedhelpingthekeepersetandclearthetableatmealtimes,andthatthemealswerehearty.Shesleptinabedwithhersisterinthesameroomastheirparents,andplayedinthemillyardandalongthecanalsusingspoolsandrustywheelsaspropsforplayinghouse.
TheBoardinghouseBackyards
Mapsandbuildingplansfromthenineteenthcenturyshowtheyards
onlyasspaces;wehavenootherinformationdetailingtheirappearance.ThebackyardsoftheBoottboardinghouseblockalongJamesStreetseemtohavebeendesignedforutilitarianpurposes.Themapsshowaone-storywoodenshedthatrantheentirelengthoftheblock
Page8
2.Detailof1876bird's-eyemapofLowellshowingtheareaoftheBoottCorporationmillsandhousing.
Page9
andseparatedtheyardsfromthealleybehind.Weassumedthatinthisshedwereprivies(outhouses)foreachhousingunitandstoragespacesforfirewood.
Atsomepoint,probablybyaround1876,additionsweremadetothehousestoconnectthemwiththeirshedssothatpeoplecouldgettotheprivieswithoutgoingoutside.Afterabout1900theprivieswerefilledinwithdirtandreplacedbywaterclosetsinsidetheboardinghousesthemselves.Theshedswereconvertedforuseascoalstoresandtrashreceptacles.Backyardwellssuppliedthebuildings'residentswithwater.PublicwaterwasavailabletoBoottpropertiesasearlyas1873,butsomeunitsreliedonwellwaterintothe1890s.
Weknowthattheyardswereusedbyallresidentsuntilabout1900,aslongastheprivieswerehousedinthebacksheds.AlthoughverylittleisknownaboutthespecificappearanceoftheyardsofBoottMillsunits#45and#48andwhatactivitieswentonthere,photographsofotherboardinghousesandtenementsprovideanidea.Thesephotographsdepictutilitarianspacesputtomultipleuses.Amongthewashtubs,scatteredtrash,andplankwalkwayschildrenmightplayastheirmothersworked.Whiletheyardsinthephotographsarenotablefortheirdisarray,therearenonethelesstouchesofdecorationsuchasflowerboxesinwindowsoverlookingtheclotheslines.
ArchaeologyinaParkingLot
Therewasnohintthatablock-long,three-storybuildingoncestoodonwhatisnowtheparkinglotweweretoexcavate.Thebuildingwasrazedin1934andthelotwaspaved.Alongonesideoftheparkinglot,anidenticalbuildingrecentlyrestoredstillstands,soweknewwhattheoriginalbuildinglookedlike.Therewas,however,littleinformationaboutwhattheyardslookedlikeorhowtheywereused.Inordertoprythesecretsoftheboardinghouses'backyardsfromthe
ground,wefirsthadtoconfrontsomeoftheproblemsinherentinurbanarchaeology.Whatcananarchaeologistdowhenasiteiscov-
Page10
3.Jackhammerarchaeology:removingblacktopfromBoottMills'parkinglotbeforeexcavation.
eredwithasphalt?Notonlydidtheparkinglothideanyevidenceofaboardinghouseblockoritsbackyard,butaseaofcarshidmuchoftheparkinglot.Sincethelotwasinactiveuseduringourinitialexcavations,wewerelimitedtoeightparkingspaces.Thismeantthatwehadtoconformourexcavationstothedimensionsofthesespaces.Wecouldnottailorthesizeorshapeofourexcavationunitstoanyexpectedremains.Thislimitationdidnotaffectthesuccessoftheinitialoperation,however,becausewewereabletodeterminepreciselywheretodigbycarefullystudyingamapmadein1892forinsurancepurposes.Thismap,matchedtoexistingreferencepoints,allowedustoestablishtheexactlocationofthedemolishedboardinghousesandtheirbackyards.
Thefirstphaseofexcavationwassimplyatesttodeterminehowintactandhowextensivetheboardinghouseremainswere.Theexca-
Page11
vationunitsweremarkedoutontheparkinglotwithspraypaint,andajackhammerremovedtheasphalt.Directlybelowthecinderandsandparkinglotbedding,weencounteredtheexpectedremainsoftheboardinghousesandtheiroutbuildings.
Encouragedbytheseimmediateresults,wewereabletofocusontwospecificbackyards,thoseofBoardinghouse#48andTenement#45.Westrippedofftheblacktopfrombothyards,andaftersomecarefulcleaningandexcavation,weexposedtheyardstoview.Fromabove,theylookedmuchastheyprobablydidintheearlypartofthiscentury,afterthebuildingshadbeentorndown.
Oncetheyardswereexposed,wecarefullysetaboutthetaskofexcavatingthemlayerbylayerandexploringthemanyfeaturesweencountered,suchasbuildingfoundations,filled-inwells,outhousepits,andoldplantingholes.Eachofthesehadtobemeasured,drawn,andphotographedaspartoftherecordingprocessthatistheheartofanyarchaeologicalproject.Thistypeofdetailisnecessarytoreconstructthedifferentperiodsofuse.Somefeaturesarefoundaboveorbelowothers,andrecordingthishelpsustounderstandtheirtemporalrelationship.Anotherimportantpartofthearchaeologicalprocessisthecollectionofsamplesforlateranalysis.Soilsfromfeaturessuchasplantingholesordrainscanbeinvestigatedusingavarietyoftechniquesthatwillbediscussedinmoredetailinthechapterthatfollows.Withouttherecordingofthelocationsofartifactsandfeaturesandthecollectionofsoilsamplesforanalysis,ourpictureofthepastwouldbeanimprecise,impressionisticimageratherthanthecontrolled,richlydetailedportraitthatiscreatedbyusingthetechniquesofhistoricalarchaeology.
Weuncoveredawealthofinformation,mostlyfromtheperiodtowardtheendofthe1800s.Thiswasatimewhenthemillsemployedmoreforeign-bornworkersthantheydidatthebeginningofthecentury.At
thesametimethecompanybegansellingsomeoftheboardinghouses.TheboardinghousethatweinvestigatedwassoldtoSaimonSirk,thusendingcompanycontrolandupkeep.
Theseareimportantfactstokeepinmindwhileconsideringdif-
Page12
ferentaspectsoflifeinthecorporation-runhousing.ButbeforewetrytopulltogetherthepiecesofinformationexcavatedfromtheBoottMillsbackyards,weshouldexplorethenatureofarchaeologicalresearchandexaminethedifferenttoolsanarchaeologistusestoreconstructthepast.
Page13
HistoricalArchaeologyinContextPeoplealwayswanttoknowwhatkindof''goodstuff"archaeologistshavefound,butarchaeologistsarenotprimarilyinterestedinfindingobjectsofbeautyorvalue.Toanarchaeologist,everythingfromcharredbonetomicroscopicremainsoffoodispotentiallyexcitingandinformative.Objectsalonecannottellusverymuchaboutthepast;itisonlythroughtheircontextthatwecanlearnsomething.Aceramicvesselonamuseumshelfismeaninglessunlessweknowwhereitcamefromandinwhatcontextitwasfound.Thevesselneednotbebeautifulorvaluableinordertohavemeaning;afewsherdsofplainpotteryinagravetellusthatpeoplewereburiedwithgravegoods,whichinturntellsussomethingaboutthebeliefsystemoftheculturetowhichthepersonbelonged.
Aburialisaformofarchaeologicalcontext,butitisalsoaculturalcontext.Byculturalcontextwemeanwhatpeoplethought
Page14
4.Blacktopremovedrevealingboardinghousewallremains.
Page15
aboutthetimeinwhichtheylived:theiropinionsortheirbeliefs.Thephrasealsoreferstopeople'spreferencesforcertainkindsoffoodorclothing,ortheirbehaviorslikesmokingordrinking.Thephysicalenvironmentinwhichpeoplelivedisalsoimportanttoarchaeologists,whetherwearestudyingtheclimateofaregionorthespecificconditionsthatexistedinsomeone'sbackyard.Anotherimportantaspectofcontextissocialclass.Considerthreedifferenthousingsites:anabandonedcitylot,weed-infestedandlitteredwithdebris;anarrowurbanhouselotwithanelongated,narrowtownhouseandsmallfrontgarden,tinybutwelltended;thecarefullygroomedandexpansivelawnoftheWhiteHouse.Eachcontexthasdifferentmeanings,andtheappearanceofeachisameasureoftheregardowners,residents,caretakers,ortaxpayershaveforthepropertyandthesocialstandingoftheownersorresidents.Allthesefactorscontributedtoformthecontextthatgavemeaningtopeople'slivesinthepast.Thisiswhysomucharchaeologicalresearchisconcernedwithtryingtoreconstructandunderstandcontext.
Aneffectivewaytogetthemostoutofanarchaeologicalinvestigationistouseeverykindofevidenceavailable.Historicalarchaeologistsusemanyofthesametoolsthatprehistoricarchaeologistsuse,buttheycangofurtherbyincorporatingelementsofwrittenandspokenhistoryintotheirinvestigations.Theyhavewidersourcesbecausehistoricalarchaeologistsstudytimeperiodsforwhichwrittenrecordsexist.Thesamecanbesaidofindustrialarchaeology,whichfocusesontheremains,aboveandbelowground,ofindustryandonthematerialevidenceforthehistoryoftechnology.Historicalarchaeologyfocusesonpeopleandculture,andcomplementsindustrialarchaeologywhenitisappliedtotheexaminationofthedomesticlivesofworkers.Thefollowingsectionpresentssomeofthemethodsthatweusetoilluminatethelivesofeverydaypeoplelivinginthepast.
ToolsoftheTrade
Thefollowinglistisnotmeanttobeexhaustive,butratherasample
Page16
oftherangeoftoolsthatthehistoricalarchaeologistrelieson.AllthesetoolsplayedanimportantpartinourinvestigationsinLowell.
Excavation
Excavationistheactivitythatdefinesarchaeologyasawayoflearningaboutthepastanddistinguishesitfromdigginginthegroundforanyotherreason.Archaeologicalexcavationisthesystematicexaminationoffeaturessuchasfoundations,postholes,wells,andsoforthandofartifacts,plantandanimalremains,andotherevidencecontainedinsitesoilsinrelationshiptothesoillayersinwhichtheyoccur.Sitesareformedbybothhumanandnaturalactions,andeachkindofactivityleavescluesofsomesort,althoughsomearefaintanddifficulttodecipherwithoutscientificprocedures,anumberofwhichwedescribebelow.Thewayanarchaeologistapproachesasitedependsonavarietyoffactors,includingthekindofsiteitis,whereitislocated,thequestionsthearchaeologistwouldliketoanswerthroughexcavation,andtheamountoftimeandmoneyavailableforthework.Thereareneverthelesssomeverybasiccharacteristicsofanyarchaeologicalexcavation.
Archaeologistsfirstdivideupasiteintoagrid,aseriesofunitsor"squares,"thecornersofwhicharepreciselylocatedinspace.Workingwithinonegridunitatatime,theexcavatorsremovesoilcarefully,ingradualincrements.Forthemostpart,excavationrequirespatienceandagoodeyeforchangesinthesoil;archaeologiststakecaretoobserveandrecordinformationaboutchangesinthecolor,texture,andcomposition(e.g.,sand,silt,gravel)ofsoillayers.Theyalsopaycloseattentiontowhattheyfindinordertointerpretwhatwentonindifferentpartsofasite(Wasthereafirehere?Isthiswheretheybutcheredacow?Wasthisagarden,atrashdump,anoldpath,orjustapackrat'snest?)andtoestablishthechronologyorsequenceinwhichthesoillayerswereformed.
Archaeologyisatermoftenusedtodescribeothersortsofstudiesthatinvolvetakingthingsapartsystematically,recordingeverythingastheprocessofdismantlingtheevidenceproceeds.Architecturalhis-
Page17
torians,forinstance,practiceakindof"architecturalarchaeology"whentheyexaminetheconstructionhistoryofahousebyexposinglayersofpaintorwallpaper,removingwallcoveringstofindclosed-upwindowsanddoors,andsoon.Thereisadramaticdifferencebetweenthissortofabove-groundarchaeologyandbelow-groundexcavation,however.Justlikethearchaeologist,thearchitecturalhistoriankeepscarefulrecordsandnumbersthearchitecturalpiecesastheyareremoved,butahousecanberestoredorreconstructed.Onceasiteisexcavated,evenwhenthishasbeendonesystematicallyandcarefully,itcanneverbereassembledorreconstructedexceptthroughtherecordskeptbyarchaeologists.
Forthisreasonyouwillfindmanypeopleonanarchaeologicalsitetakingnotes,writinguptheirobservationsandideasaboutwhattheyarefindingandwhatitmightmean,andmakingscaledrawingsongraphsheets.Theyrecord,forexample,plansofthe"floors"oftheexcavationunitsaseachnewlevelisexposedortheysketchprofilesofthewallsofunitstoillustratethesoillayersexactlyastheyappear.Archaeologistsalsotakephotographsinblackandwhiteandcolorateverystageofanexcavation;someusevideocamerasasyetanotherwayofrecordingeverythingthatisuncovered.Moreandmorearchaeologistsareturningtocomputersinthefield,usinglaptopsforkeepingnotesandlasertransitstorecordtheexactpositionsoftheirfindssothatlatertheycanfeedthedataintoapowerfulcomputertogenerateprecisemapsofwherethingswerefound.Somecomputerprogramspermitanarchaeologisttoproduceathree-dimensionalrepresentationofasitetheclosestwecanevergettoputtingasitebacktogetheragain!
Theexcavationswedescribeherebothtookplacein1986.Attheboardinghouse'sbacklotsacrewofeightworkedforfiveweeksinlatefall,assistedbymanyvolunteers,manyofwhomwerestudentsinanintroductoryarchaeologyclassatBostonUniversity.AttheKirk
StreetsiteoftheduplexthathousedagentsfortheBoottandMassachusettsMills,wespenttwoweeksinthesummerof1986withacrewoffour.Attheagents'houseweexcavatedarowofsix2m.x2m.unitsand
Page18
twounitseach1m.x2m.insizeatthebackofthelotassignedtotheagentoftheMassachusettsMills;attheboardinghousesite,weexcavatedtwohugeareas,each10m.x12m.,exposingthebacklotsintheirentirety.Wefoundnofeaturesintheagents'backlotthatwerenotofrecentdate,buttheboardinghouse'sbacklotscontainedfeaturessuchasdrains,privies,wells,andfoundationsthatcoveredtheentireperiodofthehousingforworkersattheBoottMills.Inadditiontothesefeatures,werecoveredfoodremainsintheformofanimalbonesandplantparts,fragmentsofglassandpotteryeatinganddrinkingvessels,claysmokingpipes,corrodednails,thousandsofpiecesofbrokenwindowglass(oneunithadmorethan7000piecesinasinglesoillayer!),andvarioussmall,personalitemsthatpeoplelostorthrewawayinthebacklots,includingbuttons,beads,haircombs,pins,jewelry,andcollarstuds.
Foreveryweekinthefield,wespentthreetofiveweeksinthelab,cleaning,cataloging,andanalyzingallofthefinds.Wealsospentagreatdealoftimeexaminingoriginaldocumentsthathelpedustointerpretoursiteandlearnaboutthepeoplewholivedthere.
Documents
Oneofthemajordifferencesbetweenhistoricalandprehistoricarchaeologyisthathistoricalarchaeologistsoftencanputnamesandfacesonthepeopletheyarestudying.Historicalarchaeologistshaveagoodchanceofacquaintingthemselveswiththepeopletheyarestudyingbylookingattherecordsinwhichtheirnamesappearandatthepaintings,drawings,andphotographsthatdepictthem.Wecantalkabouttheeventsinsomeone'slife,andsometimesactuallyobservetheveryobjectsthatthispersonmadeorusedandleftbehind.Inthisway,theworkofhistoricalarchaeologistscantakeonpersonalandbiographicaldimensions,makingtheexperienceofthepastevenmoreimmediateforus.
Whenarchaeologiststalkaboutdocumentstheyarereferringtowrittenrecords,usuallythosethatwereproducedduringthetimeperiodbeingstudied.Documentscomeinmanyforms,notjustpub-
Page19
lishedsourcessuchasbooks,newspapers,andmagazines,butalsounpublishedrecordssuchasletters,personalfinancialaccounts,orpropertydeeds.
Personaldocumentsincludeletters,diaries,andmemoirsinwhichpeoplerecordedtheirthoughtsandfeelingsabouttheprivateeventsoftheirlives.Embeddedinthemarecluesaboutthevaluesandsocialmoresofthetime.Usuallytheresearcherlooksbeyondtheliteralstatementsaboutfactsoreventsinthesedocumentsandtriesto"interrogate"thesource,usingcorroborativeorcontradictoryinformationfromothersourcestodeterminethewriter'saccuracy,veracity,andperhapswhathisorherunspokenassumptionswere.
Otherdocumentsarelesspersonal,moreofficialrecordsofevents,transactions,oraccounts.Examplesincludetaxrecords,propertydeeds,censusreports,andcourtrecords.Whilethesedocumentscanalsohaveculturalcluesembeddedinthem,theycontainapparentlyobjectiveinformationaboutpopulationdemographics,includingdetailsaboutpeople'sfinances,propertyownership,andlegalproblems.Sincethesedocumentsareoftenstandardized(foragivenareaatagivenpointintime),theycanbeusedtoanswerquestionsaboutwholegroupsofpeople.
Oneofthethingsthatahistoricalarchaeologististrainedtodoistoreaddocumentscritically,toknowwhatquestionstheycananswer,andwhatthelimitationsofthevariousdocumentsare.Abriefdiscussionofonekindofdocumenttheprobateinventorywillserveasanexampleofhowanarchaeologistmightmakeuseofthewrittenrecord.
"Probate"isthelegaltermusedtodescribeahostofactivitiesthatarecarriedoutatthetimeapersondiesinordertomanageanddisposeofpersonalproperty.Oneelementofprobateisaninventoryoftheperson'sassets,includingthemovablehouseholditems.Inthis
countrytoday,onlythetotalmonetaryvalueoftheestateisusuallyrecorded.Upuntiltheendofthe1800s,however,probateinventorieswereverydetailed,oftenlistingaperson'sbelongingsroombyroomanditembyitem.Whenyoureadsuchaninventoryyoucanimagine
Page20
5.ProbateinventoryofAmandaFox.
Page21
therecorderwalkingthroughthehousewithpenandpaperinhand,examiningeachobjectcarefully,countingcandlesticks,chairs,andspoons,andfinallyassigningamonetaryvaluetoeachpossession.Onecaneasilyimaginethevalueofsuchalistingtoarchaeologists.Notonlycanresearchersascertaintheobjectsapersonpossessed,buttheycanalsolearnthecolloquialnamesfortheseobjects.Whatismoresignificant,researcherscandeterminetheveryroominwhichagivenobjectwasusedoratleaststored.Inthiswaywecangetanideaofhowpeopleorganizedtheirspace,andhence,howtheirlivesdifferedfromorweresimilartoourown.
Figure5showstheprobateinventoryofAmandaFox'sboardinghouse,madeshortlyafterherdeathin1895.Althoughthehandwritingisdifficulttoread,thetranscriptionshowswhatkindsofitemswereinthehouse.
Ascompellingandevocativeasadetailedprobateinventoryis,theserecordsdonotprovideuswitheverything.Foronething,thelistingisusuallynotverydescriptive.Anentrymightread"6dinnerplates,"butwhatkind?Weretheyfancyandexpensive,orplain,durable,andinexpensive?Weretheyingoodconditionandtreatedastreasuredobjects,orweretheychippedandtreatedcarelessly?Didthesixplatesmatch,orweretheredifferentcolorsanddesigns?Anotherproblemwithprobateinventoriesisthatnoteveryonewhodiedhadanestatelargeenoughtorequireone.Onlypeoplewithasignificantamountofpropertywereinventoried.Thepoorestmembersofsocietyhadnothingofmonetaryvaluetopasson,soinventorieswereunnecessary.Thisdiscrepancycreatesaseriousdistortioninthehistoricalrecord,andonethattheresearcherwhoisinterestedinallclassesofpeopleinaculturecannotignore.Aprobateinventory,likemanyotherkindsofdocuments,isthereforeonlyonesourceofinformation.Itcanprovideastartingpointforourinquiryandabackdropforthematerialsthatareexcavated,butdocumentsarenot
enough.Theyarejustonecomponentinawidearrayofresourcesavailabletothehistoricalarchaeologist.
Page22
6.FormerboardinghouseresidentBlancheGrahamdescribesherlifeontheBootttoMaryBeaudry(center)andKathleenBond(left).
OralHistories
Althoughthedocumentaryrecordiscomposedofhistorythathasbeenwrittendown,oralhistoryisthehistorythathasbeenrememberedbylivingpeople.Oralhistoriesaretheverbalanalogiesofpersonaldocuments.Theyarenarratedrecollectionsofpeople,usuallyintheformoftaperecordedinterviews,andcontainvaluableinformationaboutthespecifictimeperiodandplacebeinginvestigatedbythearchaeologist.Anoralhistorycanalsoderivefromaseriesofinformalconversationsandoralhistoriesarenowsometimesrecordedonfilmorvideo.Theprimaryadvantageofanoralhistoryisthatitprovidesapersonalandinterestingpictureofthepast.Therearesomedrawbacks,however.First,oralhistoriesarelimitedtotherelativelyrecentpastessentiallythelengthofalifetime.Oralhistoriesrecordedby
Page23
earlierresearchersaresometimesavailable,butthesetoocanbefrustratingifthekindsofquestionsaskedbytheinterviewerdifferfromthoseofinteresttothecurrentresearcher.Thebiggestdrawback,however,istheveryqualitythatmakesoralhistoriessointeresting:theirsubjectivity.People'smemoriesarenotoriouslyinaccurate,andfactsuncoveredinanoralhistoryusuallyrequireindependentcorroboration.Justasresearchersmustreadbetweenthelinesofapersonaldocument,theymustlearntolookbeneaththesurfaceofanoralhistoryandferretoutitsculturalsignificance.
Features
Nonportablematerialremainssuchasbuildingfoundations,wells,graves,andlandscapingelementsarereferredtoasfeatures.Archaeologistsgivespecialattentiontofeaturesbecausetheyaresohighlyinformativeaboutculturalpracticesandsociallife.Architecturalfeaturessuchaspostholes,foundations,andcellarholesrevealthesortsofhousespeoplelivedinandthekindsofpublicbuildingsorspacestheyusedforworship,commerce,ormanufacturing.Therelationshipamongfeaturestheirlayoutinspaceisevidenceofsocialstructureandclassdistinctions.
Otherfeaturesreflectthewaysinwhichpeoplerespondedtobasicneedsandchangingtechnology.Installationsforwasteandwatermanagementandotherutilitiesareveryrevealingaboutconditionsofsanitationandhygieneandoverallqualityoflife.Manyfeaturesbecamereceptaclesforrefuseanddebrisoncetheynolongerservedtheiroriginalpurpose.Archaeologistscanlearnagreatdealfromthediscardedobjectstheyfindinabandonedwells,privies,borrowpits(holesdugtofindclayorgravel),cellars,andthelike.Theytakespecialcaretorecordtheprofileorverticalsequenceofdepositioninsuchfeaturessotheycaninterprethowlongafeatureperformeditsoriginalfunctionbeforeitwasusedforthedisposalofwastes,how
longittooktofillit,andexactlywhenandwhythisprocesstookplace.Oftenitispossibletolinktheremainswithspecificfamiliesorhouseholdslivingatasiteandtodeterminewhether
Page24
7.Blue-edgedwhitewareplatefragmentsrecoveredfromboardinghouseyard.
theartifactsfromthedepositwerethrownawaybecauseawidowdisposedofthingsoncebelongingtoherhusband,oranewwifechosetogetridofunpleasantremindersofherpredecessor,orsimplythatmovingdaywastheoccasionforaverythoroughjobofhousecleaning!
Artifacts
Artifactsarethetraditionalsourceofinformationthatarchaeologistsrelyontointerpretthepast.Insimplestterms,artifactsarethematerialobjectsthathumansmake,buy,use,discard,orloseduringtheirlifetimes.Inthearchaeologist'svocabulary,artifactsareusuallythoseobjectsthatareportable,suchasstonetools,ceramicdishes,jewelry,andbuildingmaterials.Becausethestudyofartifactsissooftenmisunderstoodbynonarchaeologists,letuslookatoneofthemostcommonartifactsrecoveredfromarchaeologicalsites:ceramics.
Ceramicsfigureprominentlyinthepreparation,storage,andservingoffood.Byexaminingthetypesofceramicvesselsfoundatasite,thearchaeologistcanlearnaboutthebasicdietarypatternsanddininghabitsoftheinhabitants.OneaspectofouranalysisofceramicsfromtheBoottCorporationhousinginvolvedacomparisonofthetypesof
vesselsfoundindepositsbehindthetenementforskilled
Page25
workersandtheirfamilieswiththetypesofvesselsfromtheboardinghousedeposits.Thedifferencesthatwediscoveredweresubtle.Forexamplewefoundthatsupervisors'familiespurchasedandusedagreatervarietyofdishesintendedfortheindividualdiner,suchasbreadplates.Thisdiscoveryledus,inturn,totheconclusionthatsupervisors'wivestriedtomaintainthevaluesoffamilylifebysettingtheirtablesaccordingtocontemporarynotionsofappropriatediningcustoms.Attheboardinghouse,therewaslittleevidenceofrefinementsofthissort.Herecommunaldiningwassuggestedbytheassortmentofservingbowlsandplattersintendedtocontainlargequantitiesoffood.Therewasnothingtoindicateindividuallypresentedservingsorothernicetiesthatwentalongwiththesociallychargedcharacterofnineteenth-centuryformaldining.Thus,ceramicanalysiscanrevealthesocialdifferencesthatfamiliesandboardersbroughttomealtimes.
Apartfromwhatartifactsrevealaboutculturalpractices,everyday
8.Partiallyreconstructed,plainwhitewarecoffeecuppiecedtogetherfromfragmentsrecoveredfromboardinghouseyard.
Page26
behavior,andsocialdifferences,theyplayacriticalroleinhelpingarchaeologiststoassigndatestotheirsitesandtothefeaturesandsoillayersinthem.Stylesandtasteschangeovertime,resultingintheintroductionofnewformsandnewtypesofdecorationonobjects.Sometimesoldideasandstylesarerecycledandintroducedasnewormaybeevenasfashionably''retro."Technologicaladvancesovertimemeanthatthingsaremadedifferentlyatdifferentperiods,oftenwithnewlydiscoveredorinventedmaterials.Soeven"retro"itemsRomancopiesofGreekstatues,forinstance,or1950sclothingstylesusingVelcrofastenersprovidecluestotheiractualdateofmanufacture.Archaeologistsemployseverallinesofevidenceinarrivingatdatesforsitesandportionsofsites.Prehistoricarchaeologistsoftenusescientificallybasedproceduresthatmeasureelapsedtimebasedonratiosofdecayofcarbonorotherunstablematerialsoverthousandsofyears.Historicalarchaeologistsaresometimesluckyenoughtofindobjectswithdatesrightonthemcoins,forexamplebutthisisrelativelyrare.Usuallytheyreasonfrominformationgleanedfromwrittensourcesincombinationwiththeevidenceofwheretimesarefoundwithinthesite.
Forexample,attheLowellboardinghousesitewefoundhundredsoffragmentsofwhiteclaysmokingpipes,manyofwhichboreletteringnamingtheircityandcountryofmanufacture.Byconsultingsourcesonvariousmanufacturedgoods,welearnedthatpipesmarkedwiththecountryofmanufacture(inthiscaseScotland)weremadeafter1890,whentheUnitedStatesgovernmentbegantoenforcetheMcKinleyTariff,whichimposedtaxesonimportedgoods.Earlierpipestemsweremarkedwithonlythecityofmanufactureorwithnothingconcerningwheretheywereproduced.Thus,eveninatinyobjectsuchasapipestemarchaeologistshaveacluetothedateofthesoillevelinwhichtheartifactwasfound,plusevidencefortradepatterns,nottomentionsmokinghabits!
Stratigraphy
Underidealcircumstances,thearchaeologist'sgeneralruleofthumbisthattheoldestthingswillbefoundinthedeepestlayersofasite,
Page27
whereasthenewestarenearoratthesurface.Thisprincipleisbasedonthefactthatlayersofsoiltendtobuildupandburyanythingleftonorinanoldgroundsurface.Soillayersareformedfromthedeteriorationoftherocksthatmakeupthenaturalbedrockofaregion,whichitselfisformedbyvariousgeologicalprocessesincludingmetamorphosisoftheearth'smoltencoreintorock,sedimentationinbodiesofwater,andvolcaniceruptions.Thelayerstakeonthecharacteristicsoftheparentmaterialandbuildupovertime.But,aswementionedearlier,bothnatureandculturetendtointerveneinthisidealizedschemeofthings,alteringthearrangementofsoillayersandtherelationshipsbetweenfeaturesandartifactspeoplemayhaveleftbehind.
Almosteverythingthatpeopledoaspartoftakingshelter,gettingandeatingfood,andjustgoingaboutdailylifeleavesevidenceinsomeform.Theymaybuildfires,butcheranimals,gatherplantsandseedsandconvertthemintofoodorusefulitems,andsoon.Theyareverylikelytodigholesinthegroundinordertostoregoodsordeposittrash,shelterafirefromthewind,buryadepartedrelative,constructahouse,ormineclayfromwhichtheycanfashionbrickstobuildthehouse.Sitestratigraphy,astheinterpretationofsoillayersiscalled,involvesdecipheringthewaysinwhichhumanshavealteredthelandscapebyaddingtoandsubtractingfromthenaturallyoccurringsequenceofsoilstratainagivenlocale.
Evenafterhumanshaveabandonedasiteandceasedtohaveaneffectonit,naturecontinuesitswork.Inadditiontolong-termgeologicalprocesses,localandregionalnaturaleventssuchasrodentburrowing,erosionbywindandwater,floods,earthquakes,landslides,andfrostheavealtertheconditionofsitesandtheremainstheycontain.
Peoplelivinginprehistorictimeshadanimpactontheirenvironment,tobesure,butathistoricalsitesweoftenfindextremeexamplesof
deliberatemanipulationoftheenvironment.Inplaceswherepeoplelivedformanygenerations,theyoftenrepeatedlydugthroughaccumulatedlayersofsoilandsealedoverevidenceofpreviousoccupationperiods,mixingtogetherthesoilsandartifactsfrom
Page28
earliertimeswithsoilsandartifactsfromtheirown.Thearchaeologist'staskistosortoutalloftheseeventsandtoreconstructthesequenceofdepositionandredeposition.Thegoal,essentially,istoreconstructthelifehistoryofasite.
Citydwellersandfarmersalikehaveatendencytoreshapethelandscapetosuitthemselves.Attimestheycreatevastamountsofrealestate,forminglandwhereoncetherewasnonebyusingsoil,trash,buildingrefuse,oracombinationofthesematerialsaslandfilltoreclaimswampyorlow-lyingareasoreventomakenewlandalongshorelines.Landfillcanbethoughtofasanartifactinitsownright;inthelifehistoryofasiteitusuallyrepresentsasingle,massiveoccurrenceratherthanagradualorcumulativeseriesofevents.
PlantRemains
Peopleuseplantsinavarietyofways,notonlyforfoodbutalsoasrawmaterialformakingusefulobjects,clothing,andshelter.Wecanlearnagreatdealaboutpeoplebyexaminingthekindsofplantsavailabletothematagivenplaceandtime,discoveringwhichonestheyused,andunderstandinghowtheyusedthem.
9.Enlargementofeveningprimrosepollengrainasseenthroughmicroscope.
Page29
10.Enlargementofgoldenrod/aster-typepollengrainasseenthroughmicroscope.
Plantremainscomeindifferentforms;woodandseedsaremostcommon.Thepersonresponsiblefortheiranalysisisusuallycalledanarchaeobotanistoranethnobotanist.Woodsurvivesunderconditionsofextremewetnessordryness.Somewoodentools,weapons,buildingmaterials,andfiguresthatarethousandsofyearsoldhavebeenfoundonarchaeologicalsites.Inorderforaseedtosurvive,itusuallyneedstobecharredorrecoveredfromanarchaeologicalfeaturethatcontainswetsoils,suchasawell,aprivy,oradrain.Intheseinstancesthepreservationofevenuncharredseedscansometimesberemarkable.Seedsareagoodsourceofinformationaboutwhatpeopleindifferentculturesate,whattheygrew,andthekindofenvironmentinwhichtheylived.
Pollen
Besidesbeinganuisancetopeoplewithallergies,pollenisanimportantsourceofinformationaboutplants.Plantpollenthatdoes
notmakeitswaytofertilizeanotherplantsettlesonthegroundand
Page30
becomesburiedovertime.Pollencansurviveforlongperiodsinthisway,andsincethepollenofdifferentplantsisidentifiableunderamicroscope,atrainedspecialist,calledapalynologist,candeterminewhatplantswerepartofaparticularenvironmentatagivenpointintime.
Pollendatahasmostlybeenusedbyresearcherstogetanideaofwhatplantswereavailabletopeopleinthenaturalsurroundingswheretheylived.Pollenmovesaroundinseveralways,themostcommonbeingonthewindandonthebodiesofanimalsandinsects.Wind-bornepollencantravelgreatdistancesbeforeitcomestorest,whileanimal-bornepollentendstoremainclosertohome.Thismeansthatpalynologistsmustknowwhichplantsproducewhichkindofpollen.Wind-bornepollengivesaregionalenvironmentalpicture,whileanimal-bornepollengivesmoreofalocalenvironmentalpicture.
Recentpollenstudieshaveshownthatcarefulanalysiscanprovidedetailedandsite-specificinformationabouthowverylocalenvironmentssuchasasinglebackyardchangedovertime.Changesinpollenfrequenciesandratesofdeteriorationcanindicateepisodesoflandscaping,lawnmaintenance,anddisuse.
Phytoliths
Phytoliths,theinorganiccastsofplantstructures,includingcells,areanothersourceofinformationaboutplants.Softunstableorganictissuesofmanylivingplantscanbefilledwithhardinorganicsilicatesthatareresistanttodamageanddeterioration.Sincethecellshapesofdifferentplantsaredistinguishable,phytolithsofvariousplantscanbeidentified.Aparticularadvantageofphytolithstoarchaeologicalresearchisthattheytendtoremainpreciselywheretheirparentplantdied,thusprovidingextremelylocalizedinformation.Thedisadvantageofphytolithsisthattheyareonlyidentifiablebygrossshape,whichdoesnottendtovarybetweenspecies.Thismeansthat
onlyhighertaxonomiclevelssuchasfamiliescanbedistinguished.However,inconjunctionwithpollendataphytolithscanalsobeusedtoreconstructlocalenvironmentalevents.
Page31
AnimalRemains
Bonesconstitutethemostcommonformofanimalorfaunalremainsencounteredbyarchaeologists.Bonesaremostoftentheby-productsofamealbuttheycanalsobetheremainsoftools.Insomecasestheyarethemortalremainsofpetsorpests,or,asisusuallythecasewithhumanbones,theyarewhatisleftfromaburial.Inanineteenth-centuryurbansitesuchasLowell,themostcommonbonestendtobefromanimalsthatwereeaten,domesticated,ordisdained,suchasrodents.Thezooarchaeologistswhoanalyzetheanimalremainsalsowishtoknowwhatkindsofnonfoodanimalsfrequentedaplacesincethisinformationcanprovidehintsregardinghowwellkeptanareawasandwhatkindsofdiseasesthehumanslivingtherewereexposedto.Butarchaeologistspayevenmoreattentiontothebonesofanimalsthatpeopleconsumed.Wecanlearnnotonlywhatkindsofmeatpeopleate,butalsohowtheybutcheredtheirgameandlivestock.
Oneexampleofhowthisinformationcanbeusefulcomesfromobservationsconcerningthemannerinwhichbutcheringpracticeschangedinthenineteenthcentury.Beforethis,manyanimalcarcasseswerebutcheredbychopping,probablywithanax.Marksleftbyanaxareusuallyidentifiable.Attheveryendoftheeighteenthcentury,however,sawsbegantobeusedtodividecarcassesintomanageablesizes.
Thischangecorrespondedtoachangeinthewaypeopleatemeals.Before1800manypeopletendedtoeatstewsthatcombinedamixtureoffoodsandwereservedinlargebowls.InAmericathiscustomstartedtochangearoundtheturnofthecenturyasmoreandmorepeoplebeganeatingavarietyofcutsofmeat.Infact,beef,themainstayofmanyAmericandiets,begantobebutcheredintocutsthatarefamiliartoustoday,suchaschuckroast.
Parasites
Organismsthatlivewithinthebodiesofanimals(includinghumans)canleavebehindeggsthatsurviveinarchaeologicalsoils.Theexaminationoftheseeggsprovidesarchaeologistswithatleast
Page32
twodifferentkindsofinformationaboutasite.
First,parasiteeggsarepresentinverydenseconcentrationsonlyinfecalsoils,thatis,soilsderivedfromanimalorhumanexcrement.Thisissignificantbecausetheinterpretationoftheeggsthemselvesandanyothermaterialfoundinthatsoilwouldbedifferentforfecalandnonfecalsoils.Seedsinafecaldeposit,forexample,comefromplantsthattheanimalate.Seedsinanonfecaldepositcomefromplantsthatexistedintheareaandthatmayormaynothavebeeneatenbytheanimalslivingthere.
Second,sometimesthekindoforganismthatinhabitedthepersonoranimalcanbeidentifiedfromitsegg.Sincespecificparasitesfrequentparticularanimals,wecaninferwhatkindsofanimalswerepresent.Theidentificationofparasiteeggsprovidesaglimpseintothestateofhealthandhygieneofthehumanslivinginthearea.
SoilCompounds
Althougharchaeologiststendtofocusonculturalremainssuchasartifacts,theyalsoexaminethesoilitselfforcluestohumanactivity.Notonlydohumansshapetheirlandscape,leavebehindobjectsthatbecomeburiedintheearth,anddiscardfoodremains,buttheyalsoaffectthechemicalandphysicalpropertiesofthesoilitself.Phosphorusisonechemicalthatoccursinhigherconcentrationsinplaceswherehumansandanimalshavelivedthanitdoesnaturally.Mostphosphorusproducedbyhumanscomesfromurine,feces,trash,food,anddeadbodies.Thismeansthathighlevelsofphosphorusinthesoilmaybeusedtoidentifyplaces,wheregarbagehasbeendepositedorwhereanimalswerekept.
Analysisofsoilsattheboardinghousesproducedstrikinglyhighreadingsofleadinthesoil,possiblyfromtheuseofleadpaint.Lead,then,couldhavecontributedtotheoveralldeteriorationinworker
healthnotedbylatenineteenth-centuryreformers.
Page33
11.Laboratoryanalysisofceramicfragmentsunearthedinboardinghousebackyards.
Page34
PuttingthePiecesTogether
Therearetwobroadstagesofallarchaeologicalinvestigations:theactualgatheringofdatathroughexcavationandotherfieldwork;andtheanalysis,whichincludestheprocessingandsynthesisofthedatainthelaboratory.Theanalysisphasenormallytakesfarlongerthantheexcavation.Atfirstthespecialistsworkindividually.Soilsamplesaredistributedtothevariousscientistswhoseevidenceisliterallysuspendedinthedirt.Thesoilspecialistmeasuresthechemicalcomponentsofthesoils;thepalynologistandphytolithexpertextracttheirevidencefromsoilsamples;thearchaeobotanistseparatesseedsandotherplantremainsfromthesoilbyflotation.Thisprocessinvolvesimmersingthesoilsampleinwaterandskimmingofftheplantremainsthatfloattothetopwhileothersarecaughtinveryfinemeshedscreens.Pollen,phytoliths,andseedsthenareidentifiedandcountedunderamicroscope.Thezooarchaeologistusesacomparativecollectiontoidentifytheanimalbonesandstudiesthebutcherymarksonthem.
Atthesametime,laboratorytechniciansprocesstheartifactsbycleaningallofthefindsandlabelingthemwithnumbersthatidentifyexactlywheretheywerefoundonthesite.Theneachartifactiscataloged.Thecatalogentryincludesinformationaboutwhattheobjectis(afragmentofthestemofawhiteclaypipe,forinstance),itsdistinctivecharacteristics(forexample,embossedletteringalongthestemthatreads"GlasgowScotland"),andmanufacturinginformationaboutwhentheitemmighthavebeenmade.
Aftereachitemiscataloged,theinformationisplacedintoacomputer,whichstoresthedata.Computersareanessentialpartofanyarchaeologicalproject.Theynotonlystoremanyoftheoftenhundredsofthousandsofpiecesofinformationgatheredfromtheanalysisoftheartifacts,buttheyalsoprovidethemeanstoanalyzethe
information.Theresultcanbesomethingassimpleasachartoragraphthatrecordsthenumberofceramicsfoundonasite,orascomplicatedasamapofthehorizontaldistributionofartifactsthatillus-
Page35
trateswherespecificactivitiestookplaceonasite.Althoughcomputersarenotabsolutelynecessarytocarryoutthiskindofspatialanalysis,thecomputerprovidesthebesttoolforthearchaeologisttomanage,analyze,anddisplaymanythousandsofpiecesofinformation.Byplottingwherethingswerefoundonthesite,welearnaboutpatternsofrubbishdisposalaswellaspatternsofotheractivitiesindifferentareasthesite.
Theanalysisdoesnotstopwiththecomputer,however.Oftenartifactsofspecialinterest,suchasceramics,glass,tobaccopipes,andsoforth,aregroupedtogetherformoredetailedanalysis.Thisprocedurecaninvolvepiecingtogetherthebrokenfragmentsofceramicorglassvesselssothatwhatiscalleda"minimumvesselcount"canbemade.Inthisway,itispossibletofigureoutfromthefragmentshowmanyactualvesselsexistedoriginally.Knowingthenumberofvesselsthatwerecollectedonasite,aswellastheirsizesandshapes,tellsusagreatdealaboutdrinkinghabitsandconsumerpatternsofthepeoplewholivedthere.Afterall,peopleusedwholeobjects,notfragments!
Thissortofdetailedstudyalsoinvolvesfurtherresearchintodocumentsandbooksaboutobjectsandhowtheywereused.Theultimateaimofallthispainstakingartifactanalysisallthewashing,counting,sorting,andreconstructingcarriedonbyindividualspecialistsistobeabletoplacetheobjectsbackintotheirculturalcontextsothathistoricalarchaeologistscanunderstandhowpeopleusedthemintheirdailylives.
Inthefinalphaseofanalysis,allofthespecialistssitdownwiththearchaeologistsandexchangeideasaboutwhattheythinktheirfindingsmean.Oftenthisexchangeisanon-goingprocessthattakesplaceduringperiodicmeetingsoftheprojectteaminwhichresultsoftheindividualanalysesarediscussedtoseewheredataagreeor,insomecases,conflict.Thiscollaborationistheessenceof
interdisciplinaryresearch,andoftenthisphaseoftheprojectisthemostexcitingbecause,essentially,everyonebecomesanarchaeologist.Frequently,areasneedingfurtherresearchmaybeapparentand,morelikelythannot,prelimi-
Page36
naryinterpretationsbasedononlyonetypeofanalysiswillhavetoberevised.Interdisciplinaryresearchisaninteractiveeffort.Atrulythoroughandreliableinterpretationofanysitecomesfromtheinterchangeofideasamongallthespecialistswhohaveparticipatedintheproject.
ArchaeologyattheBoottMills
ThearchaeologicalinvestigationsattheBoottMillsinLowellusedallofthesourcesofinformationdescribedabovetoformwhatiscalledaninterdisciplinarystudy.Together,thecollectionandanalysisofthesevariousformsofdataallowedustoreconstructaspectsofpeople'slivesinthepast.FortheLowellprojectthismeantconveyingapictureoflifeasexperiencedbyworkersinanindustrialcityofthelate1800s.Wewantedtounderstandhowthepeoplewhorantheindustrialmachinerystructuredtheirlivesandshapedtheirworld.Weknowthatmanyaspectsoftheirliveswereprogrammedforthembytheirpowerfulandinfluentialcorporateemployers,butwewantedtoexplorewaysinwhichtheyexpressedthemselvesandmadetheirownimpactontheirphysicalsurroundings.
Thespecificwayweapproachedthesequestionswastoexcavatetheirbackyards.Whiletheseareaswereownedbythecorporation,theywereusedbytheworkers.Byexaminingthesespacesarchaeologicallywewereabletolearnhowpeopleusedtheyardsovertime.Thiswasjustastart,however.Throughinterdisciplinaryanalysiswecouldinvestigatetheseyardsasmicroenvironments;theiruseovertime,whatotherplantsandanimalslivedthere
BackyardArchaeology
Excavatingabackyardmaynotseemtobeafruitfulapproachtolearningaboutpeople'slives,butthereareseveralreasonswewereasinterestedinthebackyardsasinthehouses.Foronething,weknew
exactlywherethehouseswerebecausewehaddetailedhistoricalmaps,andweknewwhattheylookedlikefromexistingplans,arestoredsisterblockofbuildings,andphotographsanddrawings.We
Page37
knewmuchlessaboutthephysicalappearanceofthebackyards.
Yetfindingoutwhatthebackyardslookedlikewasonlyonedetailinwhichwewereinterested.Thereisalottobelearnedfromexcavatingayard,becausethatiswheremuchoftheday-to-daylivingdebrisendsup.Alargepartofbackyardarchaeologyconsistsoflookingatpeople'sgarbage.Whatpeoplethrowaway,howtheydisposeofit,andwheretheyputittellussomethingaboutwhattheycareaboutandwhattheirattitudesaretowardtheirlivingspaces.Specificquestionstobeinvestigatedwerehowwell-caredfortheyardswere,whethertheyhadbeenlandscapedormaintainedbytheBoottcorporation,andwhatkindsofactivitiesmighthavetakenplacethere.
Thearchaeologistsexcavatedthousandsofartifacts,conductedchemicalanalysesonthesoil,extractedpollenandphytoliths,andspentseveralyearsresearchingwrittenrecordsalltolearneverythingtheycouldabouttheworkerswhoinhabitedtheBoottMillsboardinghouses.TherestofthisbookisdevotedtospecifictopicsonwhichinformationwasgatheredduringtheLowellinvestigations.Takentogether,thesetopicsreflectthefabricofeverydaylifeinLowellasexperiencedbyatleastsomeoftheBoottMills'textileworkers.
Page38
Lowell'sUrbanLandscape
ALandscapeChanged
Beforethemillcorporationsmovedin,thesitewhereLowellwouldbebuiltwasafarmingcommunityknownasEastChelmsford.Therewerefarmhouses,fields,andpasturesalongtheshoresoftheConcordandMerrimackRivers,inadditiontoanumberofmillingoperationstakingadvantageofthewaterpowertobehadfromtherivers.Thislandscapewouldbedramaticallyalteredinordertomakethesettingsuitableforlarge-scaletextilemanufacturing.Sincemuchofthelandwaspartofthefloodplainforthetworiversandthereforewetandunstable,largequantitiesofearthhadtobebroughtintolevelthegroundandmakeitsolidenoughtosupportlargebuildings.Deepfeaturessuchasprivyshaftsorfoundationswerenotdugintoglacialsubsoil,aswouldnormallybethecase,butintosoilfilledwith
Page39
artifactsfromevenoldersites,reducedtolandfill.
Afterfillingintheland,canalshadtobebuilt,insomecasesthroughthefill.Thesecanalsbroughtwaterinlandfromtheriverstothemillmachinerythroughtheuseofwaterwheels.Inadditiontoallthisfillingandearthmoving,themillsthemselvesandthebuildingsthatwouldhousetheworkershadtobeconstructed.
Finally,landscapingthatwouldmakepeoplefeelcomfortableandmoreathomehadtobecompleted.Treesandgrasshadtobeplanted,fencesputup,andstreetsandpathslaidout.TheresultofthisworkwasanewcitythatcompletelytransformedtherurallandscapeofEastChelmsford.
ThePlannedCity
TheCityofLowellwastheresultofcarefulplanning.TheappearanceofthebuildingsandofthelandscapesgivesusanideaoftheimpressiontheplannersofLowellintendedtoconveytothevariouscityresidents.Thesourcesforthisinformationarewrittenrecords,paintings,drawings,photographs,archaeologicalexcavations,andexaminationsofexistingbuildings.Fromallthisevidenceitseemsthat,atleastintheearlyyearsofoperation,themillownerstriedtomakeLowelllookandfeelwellcaredforandmorelikehomethanlikeagrim,impersonalcity.OneoftheearlymillworkersofLowell,LucyLarcom,describedtheway''longstretchesofopenlandbetweenthecorporationbuildingsandthestreetmadethetownseemcountry-like."Indeed,itwastothecorporations'benefittomakethecityattractivesincethemillownersneededtobringpeopletheretowork.AcloserlookattheKirkStreetagents'houseandtheboardinghouseswillillustratesomeofthecity'sprominentfeatures.
KirkStreetAgents'House
TheKirkStreetagents'housewasaduplexbuiltin1845tohousethehighest-levelmanagersoftwotextilemills,theBoottMillsandthe
Page40
12.Hale's1822mapof"PatucketFarmsinthetownofChelmsford,"whichwaschosenbytheBostonAssociatesforthesiteofLowell.
MassachusettsMills.Thecorporationswantedtoconveyasenseofauthoritythroughthedesignofthisstructure,andthereforeitwasquiteformal.
EverythingabouttheKirkStreetagents'housespokeofpower.Itwasclosetotheboardinghousesbutraisedabovetheotherstructuresandabovethestreetonanartificialterraceheldinplacebyimpressive,cut-graniteblocks.Itwasalsocutofffromtheboardinghousesbyanimposingwrought-ironfencethatencloseditsentireyard.Therearyardallottedtothehouseholdofeachagentwasinitiallynearlyaslargeastheyardspacetotherearofoneoftheboardinghouseunits,althoughtheagent'sfamilysharedtheyardwithnoone.Eventhebuildingmaterialswereofhighquality:pressedbrickwithbrown-
Page41
13.Lowellin1825lookingnorthacrosstheMerrimackRiver
14.Bird's-eyeviewofLowell,1876.
Page42
15.KirkStreetagents'houseasitappearedin1988.
stonetrim,dressedgraniteatthefoundationlevel,andwood-paneleddoubledoors.Thefrontandsideyards,whichwerevisiblefromthestreet,wereplantedandmaintainedwithalawn,afactsupportedbythethicklayersofrichsoilencounteredbythearchaeologists.
TheBoardinghouses
Therowsofboardinghousesthatwerebuiltnearbybetween1835and1839conveyedadifferentmessage.Althoughtheytooweremeanttobeinvitingthemoststrikingaspectofthesestructures,perhaps,wastheirorderlinessandsymmetry.EightidenticalblocksofboardinghouseswereoriginallyconstructedfortheBoottMillsworkers.Eachblockcontainedfourboardinghousesflankedateitherendbytwotenementsconsistingofapartmentsforskilledworkers,supervisorypersonnel,andtheirfamilies.ThebuildingmaterialswereplainerandcheaperthanthoseusedintheKirkStreetagents'house,andtherewerenoformalfrontorsideyardstosuggestalifeofleisure.Thesewereneat,orderedtownhousesdesignedforefficiency
ratherthan
Page43
comfort.Thebuildingswerewellmaintainedontheoutside.Theywerewhitewashedeveryyear,andthecorporationstookpainstoenforcestandardsofcleanliness:therearemanylettersonfilereprimandingboardersformessyyards.
TheBackyardStory
ThebackyardsoftheKirkStreetagents'houseandtheboardinghousesalsotoldverydifferentstoriesabouthowpeopleinLowellactuallylivedtheirlives.Itmadesensethattheprofit-mindedcorporationownerswouldwanttoidealizetheirmanufacturingcenter,notonlytoattractworkersbutalsotostaveoffcriticismfrompoliticiansandfarmerswhocampaignedagainstwhattheysawastheevilsofindustrialization.Thinkofthegreatlengthstowhichmoderncorporationsgotoconvincepotentialcustomersthattheyarenotinsensitiveprofiteersbutareecologicallyresponsible,caringpeopletryingtoimproveourlives.
16.FrontandendelevationsofoneoftheBoottBlocksofboardinghouses,1836.(LocksandCanalsCollection.CourtesyLowellHistoricalSociety
andUniversityofMassachusetts,Lowell,CenterforLowellHistory.)
Page44
KirkStreetAgents'House
Eventheformalandwell-maintainedKirkStreetagents'househadasecretlife,hiddeninthebackyardwellawayfromthepublic'seye.Archaeologicalexcavationsshowedthatthiswasaworkingyardwhereallkindsofactivitiesoccurred.
Thechemistryofthesoilwasexamined,andhighlevelsofphosphatesandcalciumwerefound.Thiswasinterpretedasevidencethatgarbagewasallowedtodecaythere,afindingthatwassupportedbythemanyanimalbonesthatwerealsofoundintheyard.Theseweremostlybonesfromcutsofmeat,butsomewerewastepartssuchasheadandfeet,suggestingthatsomeslaughteringorbutcheringwentonbehindthescenes.Therewerealsonolayersofrichlandscapingsoilinthebackyard,justlotsofdomestictrash.Thiswasapparentlyanopenyardusedforwashing,foodprocessing,andgarbagedisposal.Ofcourse,itwasprobablyservants,nottheagents'families,whoworkedintheyard.Thefamiliesmighthaverarelyenteredthebackyardsincetheyhadanindoorbathroom.
OneofthemoreinterestingthingswelearnedabouttheKirkStreetagents'housebackyardcamefrompollenandphytolithanalyses,whichsuggestedthatweedsweregraduallyreplacedbygrasses.Thismeantthattheyardbecamemoreornamentalovertime,forasanygardenerknows,youhavetomakeadeliberateefforttogetridofweedsandgrowgrassinstead.Bytheendofthetimethatmillagentslivedinthehouse,thebackyardwasmuchmorelikeamodernbackyardaplaceforplayingandrelaxationratherthanforwork.Thiswasnottrueoftheboardinghousebackyards.
BacktotheBoardinghouses
Eachboardinghousehadanenclosedbackyardthatseemedtoosmallforrecreationalactivitiesbutwasusedasaworkingyard.Theseyards
wereapproximately25ft.x25ft.insize.Ourexcavationsrevealedthetypicallayoutoftheseyards.Connectedtothebackofthehousewasabulkheadentrytothebasementandasmallbackroomcontainingpartofawellthatwassharedwiththeadjoiningboardinghouse.At
Page45
17.ExcavatedrearyardofBoardinghouseUnit#48,Tenement.
therearoftheyardwasawoodshedwithastone-linedprivypitinit.
Theyardsoftheboardinghousescontainedallkindsoftrashandgarbage.Archaeologicalevidencesuggestedthatconditionsintheboardinghousebackyardsdeterioratedovertime.Bonesandotherrefuseseemtohavebeenthrowninpitsorwithinthecellarintheearlyyearsofoccupation,thusconcealingthemfromview.Laterontheyseemtohavebeenstrewnrandomlyacrosstheyardwithlittleregardforappearances.This1889letterfromthemanagementtoaboardinghousetenantgivesanideaofwhatmanyoftheyardsmighthavelookedlikeinlateryears:
Complaintismadethatyourfamilythrowsswillteagroundsetc.intothecesspoolinyourbackyardandthesamehascloggedthedrainandwillhavetobecleanedoutwhichourMr.Crawfordwillattendto,butyoumuststopthrowingsuchstuffintothedrainandnothaveit[happen]again,anduseyourswillbucketforsuchthings.[A]lsoyouhadadeadcatinyourashbarrellastFridaywhichhadlainsolongthatitwasmaggatey.Youmustbe
Page46
18.PlanofexcavatedrearyaardofBoardinghouseUnit#45.
Page47
morecleanly,andnothavesomuchlitteraboutyourpremises,asitwillbreeddiseaseandcan'tbeallowed.
Thelandscapingevidencemirroredthistrendtowardlaxness.FortheearlyyearsoftheBoott'shistorytherewererelativelyhighandstablelevelsofgrasspollen,whichsuggestedthattheyardswerewellmaintained.Inlateryearsthepollenrecordbecamedominatedbyweeds.ManyseedsfromthecommonNewEnglandweednightshadewerealsofound.Thisweedisaclimberandprobablyclusteredalongthefencesattheedgesoftheyards.Thecenteroftheyardsseemedtohavebeenlefttodustandmud,althoughthediscoveryofwoodenplankssuggestedthattheymayhavebeencovered.
Lestwepaintamoresqualidpictureoftheurbanlandscapethanreallyexisted,weshouldpointoutthatpeopleintheboardinghousedidmakesomeeffortstobeautifytheirbackyards.Wefoundplantingholesthatprobablyhousedsmalltreesorshrubs.Oneholehadelderberrypollenandseedsinit,identifyingitasthelocationofanelderberrybush.(Elderberrieswereusedtomakeapopularcider.)Wealsofoundgrapepollenandseedsinvariouspartsoftheyard,alongwithaseriesofholesforpoststhatmighthavesupportedagrapearbor.Eventhoughboththeseplantswerepotentiallyusefulasfood,theymustalsohavesoftenedtheotherwiseharsh,utilitarianappearanceoftheyards.
Inanycase,thewaythebackyardsoftheKirkStreetagents'houseandtheboardinghouseswereusedwasnotatallunusualforthetime.Outsidespacesweremuchmoreutilitarianinthe1800sthantheyaretoday.WhatwediscoveredabouttheLowellbackyardsthrougharchaeologicalinvestigationsisinterestingforseveralotherreasons.Foronething,theyardsattheKirkStreetagents'houseshowedthetransitionfromutilitariantodecorative,startingwithaformalfront
andsideyardcombinedwithaworkingbackyard,andendingwithnooutdoorworkingspaceatall.Itisinterestingtoobservethatthe
Page48
boardinghousesdemonstratedtheexactoppositetrend,movingfromawell-maintained,thoughprobablyworking,yardtoaweedy,trash-strewncitylot.
Whatbothyardsshowbest,though,istherealityoftheurbanlandscapealandscapelivedinandusedbypeopledespitethebesteffortsofthecorporationstoportrayitasaneat,controlledenvironment.
Page49
LivingConditionsofBoottMillsWorkersAswehaveseen,historicalarchaeologistspursuemanylinesofevidenceintheirattemptstogobeyondwrittenandoralstatementsthatglorifythepastandignoreorglossoveritsvariety,complexity,andhumbleorignoblecharacteristics.Becausethemethodsweusecanrevealconditionsaspeopleinthepasttrulyexperiencedthem,weareabletoexaminethequalityoflifeatitsmostintimate.Thearchaeologicalrecordprovidescluesabouthowpeopleusedthespacesavailabletothemintheboardinghousesforacceptableaswellasillicitactivities;ittellsofcleanlinessandsanitation,orthelackthereof;andityieldsdetailsaboutthepropertiesofwater,soil,andotherelementsoftheimmediateenvironmentthataffectedeverydaylife.Eventhesmallestofarchaeologicalfinds,somethingasplainand
Page50
simpleasasherdfromabrokenflowerpot,canindicateactionspeopletooktoimproveorembellishthemselvesandtheirsurroundings.
LifeinanUrbanBoardinghouse
WeknowthebasiclayoutoftheboardinghousesbylookingatoldfloorplansandbyexaminingtheoneremainingstructureinLowellaswellassimilarbuildingsthatsurviveinothercommunities.Therewasadiningroom,asittingroom,awashingandstoragearea,androomsfortheboardinghousekeeperonthefirstfloor.Thesecondandthirdfloorscontainedbedroomssharedbyboardersandheated
19.BlancheGraham'ssketchofinterioroftheJohnStreetboardinghouseshelivedinasachild.
Page51
20.FloorplansandelevationsforBoottMillsboardinghouses,1836.(ProprietorsofLocksandCanalsCollection.CourtesyofUniversityofMassachusetts,LowellSpecialCollections.)
byfireplaces.UnliketheKirkStreetagents'house,therewerenomodernconveniences.Throughoutthe1800sresidentshadtouseanoutdoorprivyintheshedatthebackoftheyard.Therewasnosenseofprivacyintheboardinghouseseither.Accordingtoanearlyresident,asmanyassixpeoplehadtosharearoommeasuring14ft.x16ft.,''withallthetrunks,andboxesnecessarytotheirconvenience."Eventhoughprivacywasnotcommonplaceinthe1800sunderanycircumstances,beforecomingtoLowell,millworkersprobablyhadnotbeenaccustomedtosharingtheirspacewithstrangers.
AmoreintimateviewoftheboardinghousesisofferedbythememoriesofBlancheGraham.Shelivedintheboardinghouseasachildwithherparentswhoworkedinthemillsduringtheearlyyearsofthetwentiethcentury.Sheremembersenteringthebuildingintoalonghallwaythatledintoareceptionroomwithwoodentablesandchairswheremensatandtalkedandplayedcards.Sheremembers
Page52
thediningroomwiththreelongwoodentablesandthekitchenwithasinkandablackstovealongonewall.Herdescriptionofheryouthrevealsastarkexistence:"[There]wasn'tmuchfurniture,causethemdaystheydidn'thavemuchfurniture....Mattresswaslikestraworsomedarnthing...ormaybefeathers...andwoodenchairs,everythingwaswood...therewasnofanciness.Maybeaplainwoodenbureauwithafewdrawerstoputyourclothesinandamirrortostickuponthewall.Thatwasthefurniture."
AsBlancheremembers,thelightingwaskeroseneandtherewasjustonewaterclosetcontainingatoiletandasinkwithcoldrunningwater.Thisonebathroomwasfortheentirehouse.Therewerechamberpotsineveryone'sbedroom.Thiswas,however,animprovementontheoutdoorprivythatwasusedbyboardinghouseresidentsduringthe1800s.
Sanitation
Privieswerenotaverypleasantsolutionfortheproblemofhumanwaste.Withthenumberofpeopleusingthemattheboardinghouses,theywouldhaverequiredfairlyfrequentcleaningtokeepthemfrombecomingoffensive.InLowellthistaskwasaccomplishedthroughwhatwascalledthe"night-cart"system.Farmersfromoutlyingareasweregivenlicensestocleanpriviesandcartoffthecity'ssewerageandrubbishduringtheevening(hence,"night-workers").Thissystemprovedunsatisfactoryasproblemswithleakingnight-cartsandthefarmers'demandsforhigherwagesexceededthebenefitsofmaintainingtheprivies.
By1890theBoardofHealthoftheCityofLowellorderedthatallpriviesbeabandonedandreplacedbywaterclosetshookeduptosewerlines.Archaeologicalinvestigationsshowedthatthecorporationswereslowtocomplywiththelaw.Oversevenhundred
machine-madebottlefragmentswereexcavatedfromtwopriviesintheboardinghousebackyards.Becausetheprocessformakingthiskindofbottlewasnotputintouseuntil1910,weknowthattheprivieswerenot
Page53
abandonedandfilledinuntilatleast1910,twentyyearsafterthecitydemandedthatitbedone.
Becauseoftheprivies,drinkingwaterwasunsanitaryfortheboardinghouseresidents.Mostwaterwasobtainedfromwellsinthebackyardorfromthecanals.Thewellswereeasilysubjecttocontaminationbecausetheywereshallowandwereplacedtooclosetothepriviesalookatthelayoutofthebackyardsconfirmsthis.Thecanalswerenocleaner.Steppedtowerprivieswereusedinallthemillsalongthecanals,andthehumanwastewasreleaseddirectlyintothewater.Thecitybegantoprovidepipedwaterasearlyasthe1870s,butmanyboardinghousescontinuedtorelyontheirprimitivesourcesintothe1890s.
Oneunpleasantsideeffectoftheseunsanitaryconditionswasthattheboardinghouseresidentshadtoputupwithrats.BlancheGrahamrememberedratsatherboardinghouse,andwefoundplentyofevidenceoftheminthearchaeologicalrecord.Notonlydidwefindratbones,butwealsofoundevidenceoftheireatinghabits.Manyoftheanimalbonesandplantremainsfoundintheboardinghousebackyardhadrodentgnawmarksonthem.ThiswasinstarkcontrasttotheevidencefromtheKirkStreetagents'house,wherenoratboneswerefoundandonlyonepieceofboneshowedsignsofhavingbeengnawed.Theratsprobablypreferredtheboardinghousenotonlybecauseofitsmoreunsanitaryconditions,butalsobecausefoodwasstoredinbulkinthebasement.Thepresenceofratsinoneplaceandtheirabsenceintheotherpointedtoafundamentaldifferenceinthequalityoflifeexperiencedbythesetwogroupsofpeople.
Hygiene
Itdidnotsurpriseanyofustolearnthatworkinginthemillswasaverydirtybusiness.Thevariousprocessesinvolvedinmakingcloth
releasedcloudsoflintthatstucktobodiescoveredwithsweatandmachinegrease.Washingfacilitiesattheboardinghouseswerenotequaltothetaskofkeepingtheresidentsclean.Wewouldprobablyconsiderthe
21.LewisHinephotographofwashdayinaHomestead,Pennsylvania,boardinghousebacklot.(ReproducedfromByington,1910.)
Page55
workers'personalhygieneinadequatebytoday'sstandards.
Beforewemakeanyjudgmentsaboutthecleanlinessofboardinghouseresidents,however,wehavetounderstandthefacilitieswithwhichtheyhadtolive.Therewasnorunningwaterasweknowittodayintheboardinghouses.Aswehavealreadymentioned,waterwasbroughtinfromawellinthebackyard.Aleadpipefoundinoneofthewellsmayhavecarriedwatertoacisterninthebasementortothekitchen.Justwhenwaterhook-upswereinstalledisunclear,however.Evenintheearlytwentiethcenturybathingfacilitieswerenonexistent.
Thehardshipsofdoinglaundrycontributedadditionalproblemstoworkerstryingtokeepclean.Clothingwasscrubbedinatubofwaterandhungonalinetodry,aprocedurethattookaconsiderableamountoftime.Oneoftheprivilegesofboardingwasthatyourbedlinenswerewashedforyoubytheboardinghousekeeper.Personalclothingwasnotincluded,however,andwouldhavebeeneithersentouttobelaunderedforapriceorwashedduringpreciousleisuretime.
Severalartifactsrelatedtopersonalgroomingwerefoundintheboardinghouseexcavations.Werecoveredtwokindsofcombsthatwereusedingrooming.Onewastheregularstraightcombusedtogettanglesout,buttheotherwasafine-toothedcomb.Fine-toothedcombswereusedinthe1800stocombdirtandliceoutofthehair.Anotherpieceofevidenceforremedialgroomingcameintheformofglasscosmeticandcolognecontainers,severalofwhichwereexcavatedfromthebackyards.Thesesmallluxurieswereprobablyprizedpossessionsthataidedpersonalhygiene.Theywouldhavehelpedtodisguisetheodorsandirregularitiesofcomplexionthatmightresultfrominfrequentbathing.
Health
Ourcurrentunderstandingofgermsastheagentsofdiseasewasnotfullyaccepteduntiltheveryendofthe1800s.Formostofthenineteenthcenturypeoplebelievedthatdiseasewascarriedincloudsof
Page56
poisonousgases(miasmas)emittedbydecayingwaste.Theonlydefenseagainstdiseasebornebythesethreateningvaporswasplentyofsunlight,ventilation,anddryness,allofwhichthecorporationsrecommendedbutdidnotprovide.And,aswehaveseen,theverysourcesofthese"miasmas"theaccumulatedrefuseinthebackyards,theuncappedprivyvaults,andthecontaminatedwellswerenotattendedto.Evenconsideringthediseasetheoryoftheday,workersdidnotliveinveryhealthfulconditions,andtherealculpritsincludingvirusesandbacteriathatspreadthroughhumancontactandincontaminateddrinkingwaterwereallowedtorunrampant.
SicknesswasafrighteningrealityoflifeinLowellinthe1800sandearly1900s.DiseasesthatareseldomathreattoAmericanstodaycouldkillhundredsofpeopleintheprimeoflifeahundredyearsago.Acaseinpointistheinfluenzaepidemicof1918,whichspreadthroughouttheworld.Thisdisease,calledSpanishInfluenza,wasaparticularlyvirulentstrainofthefluvirusthatcirculatesthroughoutthepopulationeveryyear.Weallknowtheachesandchillsandcongestionassociatedwiththeflu,buttheSpanishstrainattackedthelungsandbroughtonpneumonia,mostfrequentlyinyoungpeoplebetweentheagesof
22.The"KissMeI'mSterilized"buttonrecoveredfromboardinghouseprivy.
Page57
twentyoneandtwentynine.Lowellwashitbythefluepidemicinthefallof1918,andduringtheweekofOctober612,141influenza-relateddeathswerereported.
ThatthisoutbreakwasapartoftheLowellworkers'consciousnesswasmadeapparentbyaparticularlyfascinatingartifactexcavatedfromthefillofaprivyvault.Itwasaplasticpin-backbuttonresemblingacampaignbutton.Itdepictedamanandawomankissingandsurroundedbythewords,"KISSME[illegible]I'MSTERILIZED."Thefigureswererenderedwithsimplelinestocreateacartoonisheffect,withcostumesandhairstylessuggestingadateoftheearly1900s.Whatwasmostcuriouswasanobjectprotrudingfromthewoman'srightshoulderthatlookedlikeahypodermicneedle.Itseemedthatthisbuttonwasmeanttoadvertisethefactthatthewearerhadbeenvaccinatedagainstadisease(probablytheSpanishInfluenza)andwassafeforkissing!
ThePersonalTouch
FewAmericanstodaywouldbecomfortablelivingwiththeconditionsofsanitation,hygiene,andhealththatprevailedintheboardinghousesofLowellinthe1800s.Althoughthedomestictechnologyforimprovingconditionswasnotavailabletoallcitizensuntiltheearlytwentiethcentury,themiddle-classresidentsoftheKirkStreetagents'houseenjoyedamuchhigherstandardoflivingduringthemid-nineteenthcentury.Thehousewasequippedwithindoorplumbing,includingrunningwaterinthekitchenandwaterclosetsfortheresidents.Evenwhenthetechnologyforindoorplumbingbecameavailable,thecorporationsseemedtohavebeenreluctanttospendmoneyonimprovementstotheboardinghouses.Asaresult,theboarderslivedinanatmospherethatwasnotonlyunpleasant,but,insomecases,unhealthy.
Inthefaceofthisratherharshenvironmentpeopledidwhattheycouldtomaketheplacefeellikehomeandtoexpresstheirindividuality.Somekeepers,whofurnishedtheirhouseswithaneyetoecon-
Page58
omy,seemedtohavelavishedattentionontheparlorwheretheresidentsconvenedandguestswerereceived.OnevisitortoaLowellboardinghousein1886remarkedonhow"handsomely-furnished"theparlorwas.Theroomwasequippedwithacarpet,wallpaper,curtains,framedprintsonthewalls,upholsteredchairs,atablewithknickknacks,andapiano.(ThisiscertainlymorewelcomingthanthesparselyfurnishedcardroomofBlancheGraham'smemory!)
Otherattemptsatbeautificationwerefoundinthearchaeologicalrecord.Wehavealreadymentionedtheelderberriesandgrapesplantedinthebackyards;wealsofoundmanyfragmentsofplantpots,suggestingthatthekeeperandtheboardersraisedplantssomewhereinoraroundtheboardinghouse.Wedonotknowwhetherthesepotswereusedtogrowherbsforuseinthekitchenortogrowflowers.
Lifeintheboardinghousesmayhavebeencrampedandlackinginprivacy,butnodoubtmanyresidentsfoundthatthebenefitsofcommunallivingoutweigheditsshortcomings.Neverthelessthearchaeologicalevidencefordeterioratingconditionsattheboardinghousesisunmistakable.Wewouldbewrong,however,toprojectourownstandardsofcleanlinessandhygieneontothepastwithoutattemptingtocomprehendtheexperiencesofnineteenth-centuryworkersandtheirnotionsofwhatwasappropriateandacceptable.Archaeologyoffersusrawdata,the"nakedtruth"thatneedstobeinterpretedwithintheculturalandhistoricalcontextnotofourowntimesbutofthepeoplewhomweseektolearnmoreaboutthroughourwork.Closeexaminationofartifactsthatreflectpositiveandconstructiveactionsbyboardinghouseresidentstotakechargeofsomepartsoftheirlivesteachesusthatworkerswhoresidedherewerenotallhaplessvictimsofindustrializationbutpeoplewhowereproudoftheirwork,proudoftheirappearance,and,indeed,proudofthemselves.
Page59
MealtimesattheBoottFoodmusthavehadspecialmeaningforBoottCottonMillstextileworkersasmealsprovidedpreciousmomentsawayfromthestressfulpaceandlonghoursofwork.Indeed,foodisanintegralpartofeveryone'slife,andhistoricalarchaeologistsdomorethanjuststudywhichfoodspeopleateinthepast.Theyarealsointerestedinthewayfoodwasproduced,themannerinwhichitwasprepared,andevenhowfoodremainswerediscarded.Historicalarchaeologyiswellsuitedtostudyingalldimensionsofdietaperspectivethatwecall"foodways".Wecandiguptheremainsofmealsintheformofanimalbonesandplantseedsandthefragmentsofthedishesandcutlerywithwhichthefoodwasserved.Fromthesematerialremains,aswellasinformationfromdocuments,memories,andphotographs,
Page60
wecangainanunderstandingofhowtheworkersoftheBoottspenttheirmealtimes.
Working-ClassMeals
Mealtimesattheboardinghouseswereaverydifferentkindofexperiencefromthefamilymealsmostofusenjoytoday.Forthepriceofaroom,aboarderwasalsogiventhreemealsaday.Themealswere
23.ThediningroomatCroteau'sboardinghouse,ca.1908.(CourtesyofLowellNationalPark.)
24.Plainwhitewarecupfragments
recoveredfromboardinghouseyard.
Page61
25.Pearlwarewithcobaltbluetransferprintingandpurplelustreglaze.Theprint
isafloraldesignmanufacturedbetween1795and1840inEngland.CupfragmentsrecoveredfromyardoftheKirkStreetagent'shouse.
servedinthediningroom,whereallboarderswouldcometogethertoeat.Rowsoftablesweresetforeveryone,andthefoodwasbroughtinonlargeplattersorinbowlsfromwhichthedinersservedthemselves.
TheTable
Atotalof7,183ceramicfragments,accountingforaminimumof305individualdishes,wereexcavatedfromthebackyardsofBoottunits#45,theboardinghouse,and#48,thetenement.Ofthesedishes,almost75percentweremadeofaninexpensiveandutilitarianmaterialcalledwhiteware.Morethanathirdofthesedisheswerecompletelyundecorated.Apparentlytheboardinghousetablewassetmostlywithplainwhitedishes.
Theimpressionofstarktablesettingswasreinforcedbyotheraspects
oftheceramicanalysis.Oftheceramicfragmentsthatwere
Page62
decorated,noneofthepatternsmatchedanyotherexceptincolor,suggestingthatlittleeffortwasmadetoobtainmatchedsets.Apparently,themotivatingforcebehindtablewarechoicewascost.
Theinexpensive,mismatcheddinnerwarebespokeaquiethumilitybutmealtimeswereprobablylively,filledwithtalkofwork,talkoffamily,andtalkofleisuretime.Incontrast,thetableattheagents'housewassetwithmatchingplates,saucers,andservingplatters,colorfulandattractivedisheswithtransfer-printedscenesofexoticruinsandforeignlocales.Fineglasswareandsilverplatemusthavebeencarefullylaidoutbyservants.Here,thefamilyanditsguestswerewaitedonandserved.
Thekindsofceramicvesselsinthecollectioncanalsotellussomethingabouthowthemealswereserved.Attheboardinghousethereweremostlyplates,largeplatters,andbowls,suggestingthecommunalnatureofthefoodservice.Therewerealsoveryfewspecializedformssuchasvegetabledishes,breadplates,orsaladplates.Boardinghouseresidentswereapparentlyprovidedwithonlythebasicsforfoodserviceandconsumption.Completemealswereservedtoindividualsonasingleplatewithfewornoaccessories,reducingthenumberofdishestheboardinghousekeeperhadtopurchase,carry,wash,andreplace,andrenderingmealsstraightforwardandpractical.
Thingswereonlyslightlybetterforthefamilieslivinginthetenements.Hereonedifferencewasthepresenceofteaservices.Althoughtheceramicswerenotfancy,theydidevokeimagesoffamilylifethatmightnothavebeencommonintheboardinghouses.Toshareteawiththefamilyorotherswasaformofentertainmentnotopentomanyofthemillworkers.
MealChoice
Thefoodservedwasthechoiceoftheboardinghousekeeperandnottheindividualresidents.Itwasprobablyalsochosenwitheconomyinmindbecausethekeeperwastryingtomakeadecentliving.Writtenrecordsshowthatkeepersboughtgrains,flour,andvegetablesinbulk
Page63
andstoredtheminthebasement.Therearenorecordedcomplaintsaboutthefood,althoughitseemsthattothetenantsquantitywasasimportantasquality.BlancheGrahamdescribedboardinghousemealsthisway:''Inthemornin'youhadbaconandeggsandallthatstuff.Itwasgoodfood,ohyeah.Ifyoufeltliketoast,Frenchtoast,oroatmeal,thenshehadit.Atdinnertimeshe'dhavemaybeabigcornbeefandcabbagedinner....Atsupper,wellyahadalightsupper.She'dwarmitupandgiveittoyou."
Ananalysisofthekindsofbonesfoundduringtheexcavationscontributessomeinsightsaboutthemeatportionofthemeal.Eventhoughthenumbersaresmall,thefoodbonesidentifiedshowthattherewassomevarietyintheboarders'meals.Cow,pig,sheep,goat,andchickenboneswerefound,butitseemsthatbeefdominatedtheirdiet.
Thekindofmeateatenisnottheonlyinformationthattheboneshavetotell.Thezooarchaeologistalsolookedatmarksonthebonestodeterminehowthemeatwasbutcheredandwhatcutsofmeatwerepurchasedbytheboardinghousekeeperandpreparedfortheboarders.Atotalofninety-fiveboneshadbutcherymarksonthem,themajorityofwhichwereshearsorsawmarks.Theseareprimarybutcherymarks,thoseresultingfromtheinitialdivisionofthecarcass.Manyofthesebonescouldbeidentifiedaccordingtowhatcutofmeattheywere,animportantcriterionindeterminingstandardofliving.Theresultsweresomewhatsurprisinginthattherewasmuchmorevarietythanexpected.Apparently,theboardinghouseresidentswereservednotonlycost-efficientlegofmutton,butalsomoreexpensivecutssuchasbeefshortloinandsirloin.
Meatwasnottheonlycomponentoftheboarders'diet,butitisthemostidentifiabletypeoffoodarchaeologically.Anothersourceofinformationaboutfoodisplantremains,bothmacroscopic(seeds)and
microscopic(pollen).Seedsfoundintheprivy(andthereforeprobablyconsumedbytheboardinghouseresidents)includedstrawberry,blueberry,andblackberry.Otherareasoftheyardscontainedseedsofpeachandelderberry.Bothpollenandseedsofgrapewere
Page64
found,indicatingthatgrapesmaynothavebeenjusteaten,butalsogrownintheboardinghousebackyards.Itiscertainfromthisevidencethatfruitsconstitutedpartoftheboardinghouseresidents'diet,whethereatenfresh,aspiefilling,oraspreserves.
ATellingComparison
Onewaytounderstandwhatmealtimeswerelikeintheboardinghousesistoexplorehowtheymighthavedifferedfromafamilymealservedatthehomeofthewealthiermillagents.Theexcavationsbehindtheagent'shouseonneighboringKirkStreetprovidedthiscomparativeinformation.WecouldprobablyassumethatmealtimesattheKirkStreetagents'houseandattheboardinghousesmusthavebeenverydifferentexperiences.Theformerwaslikelyasmallfamilygatheringwithservantsinattendance,whilethelatterwasaboisterouscommunalaffairthatbroughttogetherpeoplewhosharedalivingspaceandworkingexperience.Througharchaeologicalexcavations,however,wewereabletoputourfingeronpreciselyhowthesedifferencesmightbeexpressedinthephysicalaspectsofmealtimes.
Itwaswithsomesurprisethatwediscoveredthatitwasnotinthefooditself,butratherinthewayitwasserved,thatthemanagersweredistinguishedfromtheworkersinnineteenth-centuryLowell.Oftheboneslefttorotinthebackyardoftheagents'house,morethanhalfofthosethatcouldbeidentifiedwerecowbones.Beefwasapparentlythepreferredmeat,althoughpork,lamb,fish,turkey,andchickenboneswerealsofound.Thecutsofthesemeatswerealsoidentified,anditwassurprisingtonotethatinexpensivecutsweremuchmoreusualthanexpensiveones.Wehadexpectedthat,becausecompanyagentsmademoremoneythanthemillworkers,theycouldaffordmoreexpensivecutsofmeat.Thekindoffoodserved,then,wasapparentlynotparticularlylavishorextravagant,butthewayitwas
servedmighthavebeen.
ThetablewareweexcavatedfromtheKirkStreetagents'housebackyardbeliedtherathercommonplaceselectionofmeats.We
Page65
foundlargesetsoffancyEnglishchinadecoratedwithfloralmotifs,travelandlandscapescenes,andgeometricpatternsincolorsofbrown,blue,green,black,purple,andred.Wealsofoundevidenceoffineglasswareandglassglobesfromgaslights,whichwereanewinnovation.Manyofthedisheswerelargebowlsorplattersfromwhichfoodwasprobablyservedbythedomestichelp.Whiletheagentsandtheirfamiliesateratherplainmealsoffsumptuouschina,theboardinghouseresidentsgenerallyatethesameplainmealsservedonstarklyplainwhitechinaoroccasionallyondecoratedtableware.
Page66
LeisureTimeattheBoottWehavedevotedmuchofourdiscussiontothoseaspectsofworkers'livesthatwerecontrolledbythecompany.Nowwecanturnourattentiontowhattheworkersdidwithsomeofthelittletimetheyhadlefttothemselves.Betweenworkinginthemillsandeatingmealswithfellowworkers,boardinghouseresidentshadverylittleleisuretime.WeknowfromlookingatthewrittenrecordthatthiswasparticularlytrueoftheearlyyearsofLowellwhentheworkforcewasdominatedbyyoungwomenfromtheNewEnglandcountryside.Inordertoreassurethefamiliesoftheseyoungwomenthattheirmoralitywasbeinglookedafter,thecorporationsadoptedapaternalroleandtriedtocontroleventheleisuretimeoftheworkforce.Rulesandregulationswereestablished,includingtherequirementsthatworkersliveincompany-runboardinghouses(whichwouldbelockedat10:00P.M.),attendSundaychurchservices,andnotdrinkalcohol.Workhourswerelong,usuallyfromMonday
Page67
throughSaturday,leavingworkerswithonlyafewhoursintheeveningsandonSundaystodoastheypleased.
After1840,thecompositionoftheworkforceshiftedastheNewEnglandfarmgirlsabandonedthemillsandwerereplacedbyimmigrantlabor.The"moral"controlexercisedbythecorporationsseemedtowaneatthistime.Workerswerenolongerrequiredtoliveincompany-runboardinghouses,andtherewerenorecordedchurchrequirementsorbansonalcohol.Thepublishedregulationsfocusedmoreontheresponsibilitiesofthekeepers,mostofwhichwererelatedtoinsuringanincomeforthecorporations.Leisuretimewasstillasscarceasitwasbefore1840,butitseemedthatwhatworkersdidwithitwaslessprescribedbythecorporations.Itisthisperiodafter1840thatweinvestigatedarchaeologically.
Thebackyardoftheboardinghousewasoneoftheplaceswhereworkersmighthavespentsomeoftheirleisurehours,particularlyintheshorteveningsbetweenmealsandbedtimewhenitwouldhavebeendifficulttogoanywherefarfromhome.Itiseasytoimaginepeoplegatheringinthebackyardonawarmsummerevening,playingcards,mullingovertheeventsoftheday,andsharingopinionsorgossipwithahousemateorneighbor.Whiletheboardinghouseresidentssocialized,someindulgedinadrinkorasmoke,evidenceofwhichwefoundduringthearchaeologicalinvestigations.Thereweremanypipesandpiecesofbrokenbottlesburiedinthebackyards.Theseunprepossessingartifactssparkedourinterestandledustosomeveryinterestingconclusionsabouthowtheseactivitieswereincorporatedintotheeverydaylivesoftextileworkers.
CigarsandCutties
SmokingtodayisrapidlydeclininginpopularityintheUnitedStatesasthepubliclearnsmoreandmoreabouttherisksitposestohealth
andlongevity.Smokinghadfewofthesenegativeconnotationsinthe1800s.Whatyousmokedandwhereyousmoked,however,werevery
Page68
26.ClaypipewithMcDougallstampedonstemandT.(TD)onbowl.MadebyMcDougall&Co.,Glasgow,Scotland.
27.Pipebowlembossedwith"HomeRule"slogandatingtothe1880s.
muchtiedupwithwhoyouwereandtowhatsocialclassyoubelonged.Aslongasyousmokedinamannersuitedtoyourstationinlife,smokingwasprettywellaccepted.
Cigarettesdidnotbecomewidelyavailableuntiltheendofthenineteenthcentury.Beforethat,middle-andupper-classmentendedtosmokecigarsbecausetheywereexpensiveandtosmokelongpipes
becausethehighlyfragilestemsimpliedtheabilitytosmokeinaleisurelymanner.Thelengthofapipewasamatterofsomeimportance.Thelongertheshaft,thecoolerthesmokewouldbebythetimeitreachedthemouth.Yetalongpiperequiredspecialattention.Thesmokerhadtoholdthepipeinonehand,andsometimesevenhadtobeseatedtocontrolitproperly.Onlyamanofconsiderableleisurewouldhavethetimetosmokealongpipe.Withinthemiddleandupperclasses,smokingwasmostlylimitedtomensincewomenwhosmokedriskedbeingconsidered"loose."
Amongtheworkingclasses,claypipeswerefavored.Theseweremuchlessexpensivethancigarsandcouldbebrokentoanydesiredlength.Shorterpipes,called"cutties,"werepreferabletoaworkingpersonbecausetheycouldbegrippedbytheteethanddidnotrequireafreehand.Thisallowedthesmokertopartakewhileonthe
Page69
28.Nineteenth-centuryillustrationsshowingwomanseatedandsmokingapipe.
Page70
29.Threeone-pintliquorbottlesrecoveredfromtheboardinghousebackyard.
job,thoughatextileworkerwouldneverhavebeenallowedtosmokeatworkbecauseofthedangeroffire.Anotherdifferenceinworking-classsmokingbehaviorwasthatwomenwerenotbarredfromtheactivity.
Itwaswithinterestandaneyetotheseknownclassdistinctionsthatweexaminedthenearlyfivehundredwhiteclaypipefragmentsthatwereexcavatedfromtheboardinghousebackyards.Someofthepipeshadmarksonthemthatindicatedtheirmanufacturer.Mostoftheseweremarked"T.D.,"thenameofaveryinexpensivekindofpipethatcostonlyafewcents.Someofthemarkingssuggestedpoliticalaffiliations."HOMERULE,"whichreferredtotheIrishfightforindependencefromtheBritish,appearedonseveralpipes,andonepipeevenborethenameofWolfTone,anIrishpoliticalmartyr.Theseareclearindicationsofworking-classandethnicidentitybeingexpressedthroughsmokingparaphernalia.
Anotherinterestingfindingwasthearchaeologicalevidenceof
Page71
modificationstothepipes.Itwasclearthatmanyofthepipeshadbeendeliberatelybrokentomakethemshorterbecausealmostnoneoftheidentifiablefactory-mademouthpieceshadanytoothmarksonthem.Incontrast,manyofthestemfragmentshadtoothmarksorshowedmarksofhavingbeenmodifiedbywhittlingorgrinding,forexample.Onestemfragmentshowedsignsofhavingbeendeeplyscoredwithaknifeandthensnappedatthatpoint.Itwasapparentthatshortpipesweremoreusefultotheworking-classboardinghouseresidents,andthatifthepipestheyboughtwerenotshortenough,theycouldeasilybemadeso.
Alcohol
Withinthemiddleclassinthemid-tolate-1800s,therewasastrongtemperanceoranti-alcoholmovementheadedbysocialreformers,whichultimatelyledtothelegalprohibitionofalcoholduringthe1920s.Theseviewswerenotheldbyeverybody,butthemiddle-class
30.SodabottlesofPKelley&Co.,manufacturedinLowell.
Page72
31.Cacheofliquorbottlesfoundoutsideaboardinghouseprivy.
opponentswereinpositionsofpower,whichenabledthemtoinfluencepublicopinionandsuccessfullyportrayalcoholconsumptionasavicethatwasresponsibleforcrime,insanity,andpoverty.
ApparentlytheLowellcorporationsconcurredwiththereformers.Whilecompanyregulationsdidnotexplicitlystateaprohibitiononalcohol,lettersfromthecompanytoboardinghousekeepersmadeitclearthatexcessivedrunkennesswasaseriousoffense.Oneletterfrom1899said,"WeareinformedthatAnnieDriscoll...hasbeendrunkatyourhouseallthisweekYouprobablyknowthatthisiscontrarytoyourorderfromagt.andthatallcasesofdrunkennessmustbereportedtothecountingroom.YouwillatoncedismissDriscollfromyourhouse."
Thispolicywasinstitutedprimarilyforthegoodofthecorporation.Drunkenemployeeswouldslowproduction,threatenprofits,andgiveabadpublicimpression.Moreover,inebriatedworkersmightinjurethemselves,causingadditionalproblemsanddisruptions.
Page73
Thearchaeologicalevidencemadeitclearthatboardinghouseresidentsimbibedalcoholdespitecompanypolicydiscouragingit.Thousandsofglassfragmentswereexcavatedfromtheboardinghousebackyards.Amongthesewerepiecesofwineglasses,beermugs,andatleastseventytwoindividualalcoholbottles,includingflasksforhardliquoraswellaswineandbeerbottles.Theseflasksandbottlesprobablyrepresentjustasmallpercentageofwhatwaspurchasedbytheresidentsoverthecourseofthecentury,sincebottlescouldbereturnedforadepositandmanyprobablywerereturned,forreasonsofeconomy.
Twoimportantobservationscanbemadeaboutthecollectionofalcoholvessels.Foronething,theyseemtohavebeenboughtwitheconomyinmind.Mostoftheliquorbottlesweresmall,suggestingthatworkerscouldonlyaffordsmallamountsatatime.Theyalsocontainedlocallymadebrands,whichwerelessexpensivethanimportedbrands.
Thesecondobservationisthatworkersmayhavetriedtoconcealtheevidenceoftheirdrinkingfrompryingeyes.Thesmallnessofthebottles,whileprobablyduetoeconomicnecessity,alsoallowedthemtobeeasilyhiddeninpocketsorbags.Thebottlesseemtohavebeendiscardedinout-of-the-wayplaces,suchascornersofbuildingsorfencelines,intheprivies,andinwhatwouldhavebeencrawlspacesbeneathbuildings.Thestrongestevidenceofsecrecywasa''cache"ofwholebottlesfoundinthewoodshedatthebackoftheboardinghouseyardneartheprivy.Thefactthatthebottlesremainedlargelyintactsuggestedthattheywerecarefullyplacedsomewhereprotected,suchasunderastep,aplatform,oreventhewoodshedfloor.Perhapsworkersdrankinthewoodshedwhereneitherkeepersnoragentscouldseethemandthenhidthebottles,eitheremptyorfull.
Suchindicationsthattheworkersdrankinsecretdoesnotmean,
however,thattheyallthoughtoftheirbehaviorasillicit.Whenwelookattheevidenceforalcoholuseintheboardinghousebackyards,itisimportanttokeepinmindthatmostoftheworkerslivingthereinthelate1800swereimmigrantswhomaynothavesharedthe
Page74
Americanmiddle-classviewofalcohol.Thesepeoplecamefromculturesthatmayhaveacceptedalcoholratherthanconsideringitavice.Itwasonlywhentheycametothiscountrythatwhattheyconsiderednormalbehaviorwastransformedintosomethingthathadtobehidden.Hadtheybeenabletoaffordtheirownhomes,perhapstheywouldnothavebeenassubjecttothecorporations'middle-classmoralityandwouldnothavebeenforcedintoclandestinebehavior.
Postscript
Smokinganddrinkingwerejusttwoleisureactivitiesinwhichmillworkersengaged,andtherewereprobablymanyindividualswhodidneither.Thenatureofarchaeologicalinvestigation,however,isthatwecanexamineonlytangibleremainsofpeople'sactivities.Wecannotknowthrougharchaeologyhowmuchtimepeoplespenttalking,sewing,reading,singing,orplaying,althoughoraltestimonyindicatesthatsuchactivitieswerecommon.Asithappens,smokinganddrinkingleavebehindplentifulartifactualevidence,andthusbecomethefocusofourinvestigationofleisurebehavior.
Page75
ClothingandPersonalAdornmentClothingandpersonalornamentsweresomeoftheveryfewitemsthatworkerspurchasedforthemselves,andforthisreasontheymusthavehadpersonalsignificance.Bylookingattheartifactsofclothingandpersonaladornment,archaeologistscanlearnsomethingabouthowtheworkerswholivedintheLowellboardinghouseschosetoexpressthemselves.
Archaeology,thoughnotwithoutitslimitations,hasadvantagesoverwrittenhistoryforthiskindofinvestigation.Foronething,contemporarywrittensourcestendtofocusonhighfashionasopposedtothekindsofclothesworking-classpeoplemighthaveworn.Justthinkabouttoday'sVoguemagazine,orthefashionpagesoftheNewYorkTimes.Thesehardlyconveyasenseofthekindsofclothesmostpeopleweartoworkeveryday,orthebluejeans,t-shirts,andsneakerswedonforleisure.Moreover,wearenotsomuchinterestedin
Page76
whatmostpeopleworeasinwhattheparticularpeoplewholivedintheboardinghouseswore.Wecanusethewrittenrecordasastandardagainstwhichtocomparetheclothinghabitsofoursubjects,butnothinginthewrittenrecordtellsusasmuchastheactualbuttons,beads,andjewelrythatthesepeopleboughtandwore.
Aswehavealreadysaid,archaeologyisnotwithoutitsproblems.Actualarticlesofclothingdonottendtosurviveburiedintheground.Clothdeterioratesfairlyquicklyunlessitispreservedunderverydryconditions.Evenifwedofindcloth,itisusuallyintheformofsmallfragmentsthatarenotveryilluminating.Whatwefrequentlyfindaretheaccessoriesofclothing:beads,jewelry,buttons,andhaircombs.Yeteventhesesmallitemscantellussomethingaboutthepeoplewhousedthem.
32.Copperalloybroochrecoveredfromboardinghousebackyard.
Anotherdrawbackofarchaeologyisthattheitemswefindareusuallythosethatwerediscardedorlost.Themostpreciousandvaluedpersonalpossessionstendtobeguardedbytheowner.Theseareprobablypassedonfromgenerationtogenerationasheirlooms,andarerarelyfoundburiedinsomeone'sbackyard.Despitethesedrawbacks,however,wedidfindsomeinterestingobjectsandwereableto
Page77
identifytheirsharedcharacteristics,whichseemedtotellussomethingaboutthepeoplewholivedintheboardinghouses.
JewelryandBeads
Weexcavatedmorethanthirtyitemsofjewelry,includingbeads,fromthebackyardsofthetwoboardinghouses.Severalpiecesofjewelrywerestriking.Thereweretwodelicateroundbroocheswithhingedpinsthatseemedtohavecontainedphotographicorpaintedminiaturesatonetime.Bothpiecesofjewelryweremadeofcopperandhadasimilardesign.Onebroochwithabraidedborderframedapieceofglassbehindwhichtheminiaturewasmounted.Theotherbrooch,whichwasaroundpieceofmetalontowhichaphotographwasmounted,hadaswirlingborderthatwassuggestiveoffoliage.
Anotherhandsomepieceofjewelrythatweexcavatedwasacopperalloyandrhinestonepinthatheldnineclearglassstonesina
33.Combsrecoveredfromtheboardinghousetenementbackyards.
Page78
straightline.Hadthestonesbeenreal,thiswouldhavebeenaveryexpensiveandimpressivepieceofornamentation.Ascostumejewelry,itprobablywasnotveryvaluable,thoughitmighthaveexcitedspeculationamongitsowner'sfriendsandacquaintances.Infact,oneofthemostinterestingthingsaboutthejewelrythatwefoundisthatallofitwasmadefromimitationmaterialsthatlookedvaluable,butwerenot.Thefemaleboardinghouseresidentswantedtolookfashionablewhilepurchasingaccessoriesthatwerewithintheirmeans.
HairCombsandOrnaments
Excavationsinthebackyardsoftheboardinghousesyieldedmorethanfortyhaircombsandornaments.Someofthesewereutilitariancombsusedtogetouttanglesorremovedirtandlice,butmanymoreweredecorativecombsthatwereusedinwomen'shair.Womeninthelate1800sworetheirhairlongandneededtokeepitupandawayfromtheirfaces.Thiswasespeciallyimportantforfemaletextileworkers,whoriskedinjuriesiftheirhairbecameentangledinthemovingpartsoflooms,belts,orspinningmachines.Combsandhairpinswereplacedatthebackortopoftheheadaccordingtothecurrentstyle,andalthoughfashionsinhairstyleschangedduringthecourseofthecentury,shorthairdidnotcomeintovogueuntilthe1920s.
Again,theoverwhelmingimpressionmadebyallofthecombsandhairornamentsthatwefoundwasthattheyweremadefromimitationmaterialsandmusthavebeenveryinexpensive.Plasticwasdevelopedandmarketedasearlyas1870,anditwasperfectforimitatinggenuinetortoiseshellaveryexpensivecommodity.Mostofthedecorativehaircombsandpinsweremadeofplastic,someofwhichlookedverymuchliketortoiseshell.Aswastruewiththejewelry,thehairdecorationshadtobebothattractiveandinexpensive.Becausetheboardersprobablycouldnotaffordtortoiseshell,theyboughtthe
nextbestthing:plastic.
Page79
ButtonsandStuds
Byfarthemostplentifulartifactsofclothingandpersonaladornmentthatwefoundwerebuttonsandstuds.Studs,likebuttons,wereusedtofastenclothing.Theyhaveashortshaftattachedtoaknobordiskateitherendandlooksortoflikeminiaturebarbells.Eachknobwasputthroughahole,oneoneachsideoftwopiecesofclothingthatwerebeingfastenedtogether.Fromthefront,thestudwouldhavelookedjustlikeabuttonwithnoholes.Studswereusedbybothmenandwomen.Fromthemiddleofthe1700s,theywereusedbymentoattachseparatecuffstotheirshirts.Bythe1830sstudswereusedonthefrontofshirtsasbuttonsareusedtoday.Around1860menbegantouseseparatecollarsbecausetheywereeasiertowash,andstudswereusedtoattachthemtotheshirts.Studswerealsousedonmen'svestsaswellasonwomen'scollars,cuffs,andshirtwaists,whichwereblousesordressesthatbuttonedor"studded"downthefront.
Weexcavatedatotalof131buttonsandstudsfromtheboardinghouseandtenementbackyards.Wefoundbuttonsandstudsmadeofmanymaterials,includingmetal,shell,plastic,wood,andglass,butmorethanthree-quartersofthemweremadeofplainwhiteporcelain.Mostoftheplainwhitebuttonshadtwoorfourholesandlookedverymuchlikeanywhitebuttononeseestoday.ThedifferencewasthatthebuttonsweexcavatedinLowellweremadeofporcelain,andthebuttonsyouseetodayareusuallymadeofshellorplastic.Shellbuttonswereavailabletoconsumersinthe1800s,butporcelainwasmuchlessexpensive.Theywereadvertisedinthemail-ordercatalogsofthetimeaslookinglikeshell,whichsuggeststhatpeopleboughtthemasacheapersubstitute.Indeed,whereasshellbuttonscosttwentycentsperdozeninaMontgomeryWardmail-ordercatalogof1895,porcelainbuttonsofthesamesizecostonlytencentsfor144buttons.Wealsofoundanumberofbuttonsmadeofblackglassand
shapedintosomeveryinterestingandwonderfuldesigns.Onepairofbuttonswasfacetedwithasmilingman-in-the-moonsilhouette
Page80
fashionedalongitsedge.Anotherbuttonhadaswirlingdesignofpolishedfacetsrunningdownitscenter,reminiscentofgalaxiesinaclearnightsky.Blackglasswasprobablyasubstitutefortherareandexpensivematerial"jet,"whichwasmadefromadenseblackcoal.Jetornamentsbecamepopularinthe1860swhenQueenVictoriaofEnglandwentintomourningforherhusband,Albert.Onceagain,weseethewomenoftheboardinghousesashavingbeeninterestedinkeepingupwithfashions,butunabletopaytheprice.
Thepersonalitemsweexcavatedfromtheboardinghousebackyardsdonottellusthewholestoryofwhatpeopleworeorhowtheyadornedthemselves,buttheydoallowustomakesomeinterestingobservations.Boardinghouseresidentsworkedlonghoursandlivedamongstrangerswithverylittlespaceortimetothemselves.Ontheplussidethemillworkersreceivedwagesfortheirlabors.Formany,Lowellrepresentedtheirfirstrealeconomicfreedom.Moneycouldbeusedtopurchasemanythings,includingthetypesofpersonalitemswerecovered.Lowellwasatownwithmanystores,andbytheendofthecentury,numerousmail-ordercatalogswereavailablethatallowedpeopletoshopwithoutleavingtheirhomes.Theboardinghouseresidentsapparentlytookadvantageoftheseopportunitiestostayabreastofchangingfashions,eventhoughtheirworking-classwagesforcedthemtomakecompromisesintheirpurchases.
Page81
TheBiggerPictureGovernedbytheconceptofcorporatepaternalism,theestablishmentofLowell,Massachusetts,setinmotiononeofthelargestandmostinnovativeindustrialexperimentsinAmerica'shistory.Wedonotknowwhethertheworkerswhotoiledinthemillssawtheirlaborsasacontributiontoalargerpictureorwhethertheymeasuredtheirlivesweektoweek.Usingthecomprehensiveapproachofhistoricalarchaeology,wewereabletoretrievepartofthematerialworldofthenineteenth-centurymillworkers.Atthesametime,wewereabletochroniclethelife-historyofLowellasanexperiment.Whatwefoundwasthatbythelate1800sLowellwasanexperimentwhoselusterhadfaded.
Bythelateryearsofthenineteenthcentury,boardinghouseyardsthathadoncebeenwellmaintainedwerenowweed-chokedspacesstrewnwithtrash.Thepresenceofgarbageintheyardsattractedratstotheboardinghouses.Leadfrompaintchipsandothersources
Page82
34.Stereopticonview,ca.1889,showingunidentifiedworkersstandingoutsidetheBootthousinginAmoryStreet.TheBoottMillscomplexistotheright;totheleft,theendoftheboardinghouseblockcanbeseen.
madeitswayintoyardsoilsandrepresentedahealthhazardforyoungchildrenandadultsalike.Theseobservations,gleanedfromthearchaeologicalrecord,contributetoaportraitnotunliketheimageswehavetodayofAmerica'sworkingpoor.ThispicturewasfurtherrefinedbycomparingourresultsfromtheboardinghousewiththosefromthetenementandtheKirkStreetagents'house.Atatimewhentheboardinghouseswerestartingtodecay,thecompanywasaddingthelatestinhouseholdinnovationstotheagent'shouse.
Page83
Thesedifferencesextendedtotheyardsthatsurroundedthebuildings.Thefrontandsideyardsofagents'houseweretailoredandneatlykeptforpubliceyes.Thebackyard,however,wasjustasmuchaworkingyardasweretheboardinghouseandtenementyards.
Aslivingandworkingconditionscontinuedtodeteriorate,workerunrestgrew.Workers'callsforimprovedwages,jobsecurity,andbetterworkingconditionswentunheeded,leadingtostrikesandtheformationoflaborunionsbytheearlydecadesofthetwentiethcentury.ThisusheredinLowell'sfinalphaseasacenterfortextileproduction.Eventuallylowerprofitsandcompetitionfromsouthernmillscontributedtotheclosingofmanyofthemills.Insomecasesmillcomplexesandworkers'housingweredemolished.
Incomparingwhatwefoundintheboardinghouse,tenement,andagents'housebackyards,wewerestruckbythedifferencesintheappearanceoftheyardsandthemannerinwhichmealsweretaken.Yetitmaybewrongtomaketoomuchofthesecontrasts,asstrikingastheyare.ThereismuchthatwassharedbythemanyactorsinLowell'sdrama.Whattheysharedwasanewwayoflife,onethatwasdistinctlyurbaninflavor.Formanythecitywasexcitingifnotsomewhatoverwhelming.Thepaceoflifecontrastedsharplywithruralliving.Therewerestores,placestoeat,andthingstobuy.Andtherewerepeople,lotsofpeople,fromalloverNewEngland,andlaterfromdifferentpartsoftheworld.Thiswascitylife.
Fromourperspective,lifeintheworkers'housingmayseemstarkandunderprivileged,butthearchaeologycanspeaktousinotherways.Despitetheseemingomnipresenceofthecorporation,workersmadetheirownlivesandtookprideintheirwork,theirpersonalappearance,andevenintheyardsoftheircorporation-ownedhomes.Thisisevidentinthepersonaltoucheswedetectedinthebackyardsandinthewidearrayofitemsofpersonaladornmentandgrooming.
Workerswerecertainlylimitedtosomeextentbytheirincomes,butevenso,itseemsclearthattheywerewillingparticipantsintheworldofcommerce.Theyexpressedthemselvesinthejewelry,haircombs,andbuttonstheybought,andintheflowerpotswithwhichtheychose
Page84
todecoratetheirhomes.Somefeltstronglyenoughabouttheirownethnicidentitiestocommunicatetheirprideinthepipestheysmokedandperhapseveninthefruitvinestheygrewintheiryards.Somepeoplemayhavesuccumbedtotheilleffectsofalcohol,butmostforgedanindelibleidentityaworking-classculturethatcontributedinapowerfulwaytothechangingfabricofAmericanculture.
Page85
SourcesandFurtherReading
Introduction
DiscussionsofandhistoriesofLowellabound;somewerewritteninthenineteenthcenturybypeopledirectlyinvolvedwiththemills,andanumberhavebeenwritteninthetwentiethcenturybytraditionalhistoriansaswellasbysocial,labor,andpublichistorians.
ContemporarysourcesthatjustifiedanddefendedindustrializationinLowellincludeNathanAppleton,IntroductionofthePowerLoomandOriginofLowell(Lowell:B.H.Penhallow,1858);ElishaBartlett,AVindicationoftheCharacterandConditionoftheFemalesEmployedintheLowellMillsAgainsttheChargesintheBostonTimesandtheBostonQuarterlyReview(Lowell:LeonardHuntress,1841);andRev.HenryA.Miles,Lowell,AsItWas,andAsItIs(1846;Facsimile,NewYork:ArnoPress,1972).
Criticsofthemillsalsohadtheirsay:AzerAmes,Jr.,M.D.,SexinIndustry:APleafortheWorkingGirl(Boston:JamesR.Osgood&Co.,1875);JamesCookAyer,SomeoftheUsesandAbusesintheManagementofOurManufacturingCorporations(Lowell,1863);ErastusB.Bigelow,RemarksontheDepressedConditionofManufactures
Page86
inMassachusetts,withSuggestionsastoItsCauseandItsRemedy(Boston,1858);andFemaleLaborReformAssociation,FactoryLifeasItIs,byanOperative(1845;reprint,Lowell:LowellPublishingCo.,1982).
WritingsbythewomenwhoworkedinthemillsduringLowell'searlydecadesincludefirsthandaccounts,letters,autobiographies,andevenshortliteraryworkssuchasthosepublishedinthe''millgirls'own"periodical,TheLowellOffering.SeeThomasDublin,ed.,Farm&Factory:TheMillExperienceandWomen'sLivesinNewEngland,18301860(NewYork:ColumbiaUniversityPress,1982);BenitaEisler,ed.,TheLowellOffering:WritingsbyNewEnglandMillWomen,(18401845)(NewYork:HarperTorchbooks,1977);LucyLarcom,ANewEnglandGirlhood:OutlinedfromMemory(1889;reprint,Boston:NortheasternUniversityPress,1986);HarriettH.Robinson,LoomandSpindle,OrLifeAmongtheEarlyMillGirls(Boston:ThomasV.Cromwell&Co.,1898).
Twentieth-centuryhistorianshaveexaminedmanyaspectsofLowell'sindustrialpast,oftenrevisingoldnotionsaboutthecity'shistory.AsamplingoftheseincludesMaryH.Blewett,TheLastGeneration:WorkandLifeintheTextileMillsofLowell,Massachusetts,19101960(Amherst:UniversityofMassachusettsPress,1990);FredCoburn,HistoryofLowellandItsPeople(NewYork:LewisHistorical,1920);JohnCoolidge,MillandMansion:AStudyofArchitectureandSocietyinLowell,Massachusetts,18201865(1942;2ded.,Amherst:UniversityofMassachusettsPress,1993);RobertF.Dalzell,Jr.,EnterprisingElite:TheBostonAssociatesandtheWorldTheyMade(NewYork:Norton,1993);ThomasDublin,WomenatWork:TheTransformationofWorkandCommunityinLowell,Massachusetts,18261860(NewYork:ColumbiaUniversityPress,1981);ArthurL.Eno,,Jr.,ed.,CottonWasKing:AHistoryofLowell,Massachusetts(Lowell:LowellHistoricalSociety,1976);HannahJosephson,The
GoldenThreads:NewEngland'sMillGirlsandMagnates(NewYork:Duell,Sloan,andPearce,1949);G.F.Kenngott,TheRecordofaCity:ASocialSurveyofLowell,Massachusetts(NewYork:Macmillan&Co.,1912);andRobertWeible,ed.,TheContinuingRevolution:AHistoryofLowell,Massachusetts(Lowell:LowellHistoricalSociety,1991).
ThehistoryoftheBoottMillshasbeenexaminedindepthbyLaurenceF.Grossinhisbook,TheCourseofIndustrialDecline:TheBoottCottonMillsofLowell,Massachusetts,18351955(Baltimore:JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress,1993)andinhisessays,"BuildingonSuccess:LowellMillConstructionandItsResults,"inIA:TheJournaloftheSocietyforIndustrialArcheology.14,2(1988):23-34and"TheGameIsPlayedOut:TheClosingDecadesoftheBoottMills,"inWeible,TheContinuingRevolution,281-99.AthoroughdiscussionofthearchitecturalfabricofportionsofthesurvivingBoottcomplexcanbefoundinLaurenceF.GrossandRussellA.Wright,HistoricStructureReportHistoryPortion:Building6;TheCountingHouse;TheAdjacentCourtyard;andtheFacadesofBuildings1and2.BoottMillComplex,LowellNationalHistoricalPark,LowellMassachusetts(Denver,Colorado:NationalParkService,1985).
Page87
HistoricalArchaeologyinContext
UsefulintroductionstoarchaeologyincludeWendyAshmoreandRobertJ.Sharer,DiscoveringOurPast:ABriefIntroductiontoArchaeology(MountainView,Calif.:MayfieldPress,1988);BrianM.Fagan,Archaeology:ABriefIntroduction(5thed.,NewYork:HarperCollins,1994).Introductory-levelbooksonhistoricalarchaeologyareappearingwithincreasingfrequency,althoughtodatenoonebookdoesjusticetothefieldasawhole.Amongthoseavailable,werecommendJamesDeetz,InSmallThingsForgotten:TheArchaeologyofEarlyAmericanLife(NewYork:AnchorBooks,1977);IvorNoelHume,HistoricalArchaeology(NewYork:AlfredA.Knopf,1968)(thoughseriouslyoutdated,muchofitscontentremainsrelevant);andCharlesE.Orser,Jr.,andBrianM.Fagan,HistoricalArchaeology:ABriefIntroduction(NewYork:HarperCollins,1994).Athought-provokingcollectionofessayscanbefoundinBernardL.HermanandLuAnDeCunzo,eds.,HistoricalArchaeologyandtheStudyofAmericanCulture(Winterthur,Del.:TheHenryFrancisduPontWinterthurMuseum,1995).HistoricalArchaeology,publishedbytheSocietyforHistoricalArchaeology,isthemajorjournalforthefieldand,althoughfocusingonNorthAmerica,isglobalinscope;NortheastHistoricalArchaeology,thejournaloftheCouncilforNortheastHistoricalArchaeology,publishesarticlespertainingtohistoricalarchaeologyinthenortheasternUnitedStatesandeasternCanada.OnlyonecomprehensivegeneralworkonindustrialarchaeologyinNorthAmericaisavailable:RobertB.GordonandPatrickM.Malone,TheTextureofIndustry:AnArchaeologicalViewoftheIndustriesofNorthAmerica(NewYork:OxfordUniversityPress,1994).TheSocietyforIndustrialArchaeologypublishesIA:TheJournaloftheSocietyforIndustrialArchaeology.
ExplorationsofhowhistoricalarchaeologistsapproachtheanalysisanduseofdocumentarysourcescanbefoundinMaryC.Beaudry,ed.,DocumentaryArchaeologyintheNewWorld(Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,1988);MaryEllinD'Agostino,MargotWiner,ElizabethPrine,andEleanorCasella,eds.,TheWrittenandtheWrought:ComplementarySourcesinHistoricalAnthropology,KroeberAnthropologicalSocietyPapers,78(Berkeley,Calif.:DepartmentofAnthropology,UniversityofCaliforniaatBerkeley,1995);andBarbaraJ.Little,ed.,Text-AidedArchaeology(BocaRaton,Fla.:CRCPress,1992).RussellJ.Barberhaspreparedaworkbookontheuseofsourcesinhistoricalarchaeology:DoingHistoricalArchaeology:ExercisesUsingDocumentary,Oral,andMaterialEvidence(NewYork:Prentice-Hall,1994).ThestandardreferenceforartifactidentificationinhistoricalarchaeologyisIvorNoelHume'sGuidetoArtifactsofColonialAmerica(NewYork:AlfredA.Knopf,1970),which,asthetitleindicates,focusesonthecolonialperiodinNorthAmerica.Studentsofnineteenth-centurymaterialculturelacksuchacomprehensiveresourceonartifactidentification.Ausefulsourcetoconsult,however,isGeorgeL.Miller,OliveR.Jones,LesterA.Ross,andTeresitaMajewski,comps.,ApproachestoMaterialCultureResearchforHistorical
Page88
Archaeologists:AReaderfromHistoricalArchaeology(Tucson,Ariz.:SocietyforHistoricalArchaeology,1991).
OverviewsoftheLowellArchaeologicalSurveyProjectareprovidedinStephenA.MrozowskiandMaryC.Beaudry,"TheArcheologyofWorkandHomeLifeinLowell,Massachusetts:AnInterdisciplinaryStudyoftheBoottCottonMillsCorporation,"IA:TheJournaloftheSocietyforIndustrialArcheology14,2(1988):1-22andinStephenA.Mrozowski,"HistoricalArchaeologyandtheIndustrialRevolution:TheLowellArchaeologicalSurvey,"HistoryNews45,4(1990):24-26.TheresultsarereportedindetailinaseriesofthreemonographspublishedbytheNationalParkService:MaryC.BeaudryandStephenA.Mrozowski,eds.,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,Lowell,Massachusetts.vol.1,:LifeintheBoardingHouses:APreliminaryReport,CulturalResourcesManagementSeries,18(Boston:NationalParkService,NorthAtlanticRegionalOffice,1987);InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,Lowell,Massachusetts,vol.2,:TheKirkStreetAgents'House,CulturalResourcesManagementSeries,19(Boston:NationalParkService,NorthAtlanticRegionalOffice,1987);andInterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,Lowell,Massachusetts,vol.3,:TheBoardingHouseSystemasaWayofLife,CulturalResourcesManagementSeries,21(Boston:NationalParkService,NorthAtlanticRegionalOffice,1989).
Lowell'sUrbanLandscape
ThebuiltenvironmentandurbanlandscapeofLowellarediscussedinThomasBender,TowardanUrbanVision:IdeasandInstitutionsinNineteenth-CenturyAmerica(Baltimore:JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress,1975);RandolphLangenbach,"FromBuildingtoArchitecture:TheEmergenceofVictorianLowell,"HarvardArchitecturalReview2(1981):90-105;MaryC.Beaudry,"TheLowellBoottMillsComplex
andItsHousing:MaterialExpressionsofCorporateIdeology,"HistoricalArchaeology23,1(1989):19-32;StephenA.MrozowskiandMaryC.Beaudry,"ArchaeologyandtheLandscapeofCorporateIdeology,''inEarthPatterns:EssaysinLandscapeArchaeology,WilliamM.KelsoandRachelMost,eds.,(Charlottesville:UniversityPressofVirginia,1990);StephenA.Mrozowski,"LandscapesofInequality,"inTheArchaeologyofInequality,ed.RandallMcGuireandRobertPaynter,(Oxford:BasilBlackwell,1991);WilliamF.FisherandGeraldK.Kelso,"TheUseofOpalPhytolithAnalysisinaComprehensiveEnvironmentalStudy:AnExamplefrom19th-CenturyLowell,Massachusetts,"NortheastHistoricalArchaeology16(1987):30-45;andGeraldK.Kelso,"Pollen-RecordFormationProcesses,InterdisciplinaryArchaeology,andLandUsebyMillWorkersandManagers:TheBoottMillsCorporation,Lowell,Massachusetts,18361942,"HistoricalArchaeology27,1(1993):70-94.Foraseriesofessaysonthearchaeologyoftheurbanenvironment,seeA.R.HallandH.K.Kenward,eds.,EnvironmentalArchaeologyintheUrbanContext,CouncilforBritishArchaeology
Page89
ResearchReports43(London:CouncilforBritishArchaeology,1982).
LivingConditionsofBoottMillsWorkers
Livingconditions,hygiene,andsanitationintheBoottboardinghousesarediscussedbyEdwardL.Bell,"APreliminaryReportonHealth,Hygiene,andSanitationattheBoottMillsBoardingHouses:AnHistoricalandArcheologicalPerspective,"inBeaudryandMrozowski,eds.,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,vol.1;GeraldK.Kelso,WilliamF.Fisher,StephenA.Mrozowski,andKarlJ.Reinhard,"ContextualArchaeologyattheBoottMillsBoardinghouseBacklots,"inBeaudryandMrozowski,editors,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,vol.3;StephenA.Mrozowski,EdwardL.Bell,MaryC.Beaudry,DavidB.Landon,andGeraldK.Kelso,''LivingontheBoott:HealthandWellBeinginaBoardinghousePopulation,"WorldArchaeology21,2(1989):298-319;MaryC.Beaudry,"PublicAestheticsversusPersonalExperience:ArchaeologyandtheInterpretationof19th-CenturyWorkerHealthandWellBeinginLowell,Massachusetts,"HistoricalArchaeology27,2(1993):90-105;andDavidB.Landon,"DomesticIdeologyandtheEconomicsofBoardinghouseKeeping,"inBeaudryandMrozowski,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,vol.3.
MealTimesattheBoott
DavidH.Duttonanalyzedtheceramicsfromtheboardinghouseexcavationsin"Thrasher'sChinaorColoredPorcelain:CeramicsfromaBoottMillsBoardinghouseandTenement,"inBeaudryandMrozowski,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,vol.3andin"Thrasher'sChinaorColoredPorcelain:MealtimeattheBoott"(M.A.thesis,DepartmentofArchaeology,BostonUniversity,1990).
AnalysisofthedocumentaryandzooarchaeologicalevidenceispresentedinDavidB.Landon,"FoodwaysintheLowellBoardinghouses:TheHistoricalandZooarchaeologicalEvidence,"inBeaudryandMrozowski,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,vol.1;andinDavidB.Landon,"FaunalRemainsfromtheBoottMillsBoardinghouses,"inBeaudryandMrozowski,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,vol.3.
LeisureTimeattheBoott
AspectsofleisurebehaviorreflectedbyartifactsfromtheboardinghousesarediscussedinLaurenJ.Cook,"Tobacco-RelatedMaterialCultureandtheConstructionofWorkingClassCulture,"andinKathleenH.Bond,"'thatwemaypurifyourcorporationbydischargingtheoffenders':TheDocumentaryRecordofSocialControlintheBoottBoardinghouses,"and"TheMedicine,Alcohol,andSoda
Page90
VesselsfromtheBoottMills,"allinBeaudryandMrozowski,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,vol.3;andinKathleenH.Bond,"AlcoholUseintheBoottMillsBoardinghouses:TensionbetweenWorkersandManagement,aDocumentaryandArchaeologicalStudy"(M.A.thesis,DepartmentofArchaeology,BostonUniversity,1988).
ClothingandPersonalAdornment
TheartifactsofgroomingandpersonaladornmentfromtheboardinghousebacklotswereexaminedindetailbyGraceH.Ziesing:"AnalysisofPersonalEffectsfromExcavationsoftheBoottMillsBoardinghouseBacklotsinLowell,Massachusetts,"inBeaudryandMrozowski,InterdisciplinaryInvestigationsoftheBoottMills,vol.3;aswellasinher"PersonalEffectsfromtheBacklotsofBoottMillsCorporateHousinginLowell,Massachusetts:AGenderStudyinHistoricalArchaeology"(M.A.thesis,DepartmentofArchaeology,BostonUniversity,1990).
TheBiggerPicture
FordiscussionsofthedeclineofthetextileindustryinLowellanditsrepercussions,seeGross,CourseofIndustrialDeclineandessaysinWeible,ContinuingRevolution.
Page91
Index
A
Agents:
dietof,6465;
healthof,53,57;
houseof,3942;
responsibilitiesof,5;
yardof,44
Alcoholconsumption,7174
Animalremains,31,6365
Appleton,Nathan,1
Archaeobotanist,29,34
Archaeologicalsubdisciplines:
archaeobotany,29;
historicalarchaeology,xiixiii,11,15,18;
industrialarchaeology,4,15;
palynology,30;
prehistoricarchaeology,15;
zooarchaeology,31,34,63
Architecturalhistorians,17
Artifacts:
adornment,7580;
botanicalremains,29,47,6364;
buttons,7980;
ceramics,2426;
claypipes,6871;
clothing,55,7576;
combs,55,78;
definitionof,2426;
faunalremains,32,6365;
glass,65,73;
metal,77,79;
phytoliths,30;
pollenremains,2930,63
B
Backyards,79,3637,4348
Boottcottonmills:
asexampleofcorporatepaternalism,3839,6667;
historyof,13,3843;
locationof,38
Buildingfoundations,11,24
C
Ceramics:
fromagents'house,6465;
fromboardinghouse,6162;
dating,2426
Clothing,76
Page92
Computers,useof,inarchaeologicalanalysis,3436
Context:
archaeological,13;
cultural,1314
CorporatepaternalismatBoottmills,2,66
Croteau,Joseph,7
D
Diet:
ofagents,6465;
differencesbetweenworkers,2425,64;
ofunskilledworkers,6264
Disease,5556
Documents,1821
E
Excavations,1618
F
Features:
buildingfoundations,11,23,38;
cellars,23,45;
definitionof,11,2324;
privies,23,45,5153,56,63;
postholes,23;
wells,23,38,53,56
Flotation,34
Foodways:
definitionof,59;
dietofagents,6465;
dietofunskilledworkers,6264;
disposaloffoodandceramics,45;
preparationofmeals,5965;
tablewareofskilledworkers,25,62;
tablewareofunskilledworkers,25,6162
Fox,Amanda,5
G
Garbage,45,
Graham,BlanchePelletier,7,5152,63
Grid,16
H
Health:
innineteenthcentury,5556;
ofunskilledworkers,5253,5557
Hygiene:
ofagents,57;
innineteenth-century,55;
ofunskilledworkers,5355
I
Immigrantworkers,effectivenessofcorporatepaternalismon,23
Industrialarchaeology,4,15
Industrialrevolution,2
Interdisciplinaryresearch,3536
L
Landscape,3839
Landuse:
byagents,44;
overtime,3,79;
byunskilledworkers,4447
Larcom,Lucy,39
Leisuretime,6674;
activitiespresentinarchaeologicalrecord,67;
ofagents,68;
alcoholconsumption,7174;
beautificationofbackyard,4748;
smoking,6771;
ofunskilledworkers,68,73
Lowell:
constructionof,3839;
historyof,13
M
Maggots,4547
Millgirls:
effectivenessofcorporatepaternalism,23,6667;
implementationofcorporatepaternalism,23,6667;
replacedbyimmigrantworkers,23
Millworkers:
immigrantworkersandcorporatepaternalism,66;
millgirls,2
Minimumvesselcount,35
N
Nightcartsystem,52
O
Oralhistory,2223
P
Palynologist,30,34
Parasites,3132
Phytoliths,30,34
PlannedindustrialcommunitiesandcorporatepaternalismatBoottcottonmills,39
Plantremains,2830,47