Man and nanotechnology

Post on 22-May-2015

699 views 1 download

Tags:

description

With the advance of micro and nanotechnology progress is made in many fields of technology. Examples of this are given from work at the MESA+ Institute for nanotechnology at the University of Twente, where the author worked up to 2008. The progress is really amazing and there is real reason for being optimistic about the role of technology for future human development. But technology alone is not able to guarantee well-being as there is also guidance needed to use the new technology according to human dignity. The ethical dimension, therefore, is of great importance and should be considered and studied together with the technological aspects. Only in this way nanotechnology can provide a solid foundation of welfare of human beings. The talk was presented on June 22, 2007 at the European Meeting of university professors in Rome.

transcript

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 1 date: 22 June 2007

man and micro-

nanotechnology

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 2 date: 22 June 2007

Alfred Driessen MESA+ Institute, Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands

http://ioms.ewi.utwente.nl

e-mail (2011): Driessen.Alfred@gmail.com

Relation between man and micro-

nano-technology

European Meeting of University Professors

WORKSHOP C2: Centrality of Human Being in the Universe

A new Humanism for Europe: the role of Universities

Rome, 21-24 June 2007

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 3 date: 22 June 2007

1. Introduction

2. Examples of micro/nanotechnology

3. An optimistic view on the role of technology

4. The need of ethical considerations

5. Conclusions

Content

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 4 date: 22 June 2007

Back to the sixties:

6 transistor radio

price: 2 hours of workman

6 transistor radio (~1965)

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 5 date: 22 June 2007

today: 1,000,000,000 transistors in a single PC

price: 20 hours of workman

Moore's law

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 6 date: 22 June 2007

The fabrication of an electronic chip

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 7 date: 22 June 2007

The fabrication of an electronic chip

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 8 date: 22 June 2007

With regards to technology: yes, we can!

time schedule for implementation

year x: discovery of scientific phenomenon

year x+10: demonstration of application in laboratory

year x+20: start of commercial production

year x+30: impact on society visible

year x+??: ethical and juridical aspects studied & solved

Let's look for micro/nanotechnology now!

Can we look into future?

Xenon atoms on nickel (Don Eigler, IBM)

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 9 date: 22 June 2007

“As soon as I mention this, people tell me… about electric motors that are the size of a finger nail, and that there is a device on the market which can write the Lord’s prayer on the head of a pin. “But that’s nothing; that’s most primitive” I want to discuss the staggeringly small world below.”

Richard P. Feynman (1960)

“What I want to talk about is the problem of manipulating and controlling things on a small scale.”

“There is Plenty of Room at the Bottom”

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 10 date: 22 June 2007

“There is Plenty of Room at the Bottom”

close-up of a

human hair

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 11 date: 22 June 2007

1970

transistors

1 Å 1 μm 100 nm 10 nm 1 nm 10 μm

2003

transistors

130 nm

Smallest

lithography nanotube

atom DNA

protein

virus

cell

What is NANO?

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 12 date: 22 June 2007

H. Rohrer G. Binnig

Scanning Tunneling Microscope

1986

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 13 date: 22 June 2007

56 iron atoms on cupper

‘Quantum coral’

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 14 date: 22 June 2007

Reading of nano-structures

Multiple probes

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 15 date: 22 June 2007

Writing with molecules

Nano-pattern writing by transport of molecules by water meniscus

Mirkin group Northwestern University

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 16 date: 22 June 2007

1970

1980

1990

2003

Lab on a Chip

2006

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 17 date: 22 June 2007

Micro tweezers

Nano-sieve

Fluidics channels

Lab on a Chip

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 18 date: 22 June 2007

CO2 CO2 H+ P

Advantages

• No reference electrode

• Small thus integratable

in a catheter

• Easily accepted in the

medical field

V

Example: CO2 sensor

BIOS, UTwente

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 19 date: 22 June 2007

Dimensions 2.9x0.9x0.7 mm3

PCB stick

Pressure sensor

Porous cover

Gas permeable membrane

BIOS, UTwente

Example: CO2 sensor

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 20 date: 22 June 2007

Clinical trials -> constructing prototype catheter in cooperation with a company and Medisch Spectrum Twente (MST)

Diameter: 2 mm

BIOS, UTwente

CO2 sensor, future developments

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 21 date: 22 June 2007

Nanomechano-optical interaction

• Raster scanning the probe

over the sample

• Record the transmission at

each probe position

W.C.L. Hopman, et al., Opt. Express 14, 8745-8752 (2006)

Transmission Scanning Near-field Optical Microscopy (T-SNOM)

Exploit the tip-induced disturbance for field mapping

Device (SEM image)

1 mm

input output

T-SNOM setup

W.C.L. Hopman et al., JLT (accepted 2007)

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 22 date: 22 June 2007

The exact location of

the resonator “hot spots”

can be found by combining

both AFM (height) and

optical data

possible applications:

nanosensor

nano-optical switch

W. C. L. Hopman et al., “Nano-mechanical tuning and imaging of a

photonic crystal micro-cavity resonance,” Optics Express 14, 8745-8752 (2006).

Nanomechano-optical interaction

1 μm

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 23 date: 22 June 2007

Optical communication: wavelength router

1x1 cm2 area of mask picture of processed device

(lithography done in cooperation with ASML) 1.4 x 1.6 mm2

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 24 date: 22 June 2007

Pigtailed and packaged device

Klein et al. 2006

with thanks to ASML

and BSIK, Broadband Access

Optical communication: wavelength router

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 25 date: 22 June 2007

Ronald Dekker, MESA+

Optical switch based on ring resonators

<1 ps switching time, > 200 Gbit/s data-rate

pump pulse: off pump pulse: on picture of device

area: 0.004 x 0.003 mm2

R. Dekker et al., Optics Express, Vol. 14 (18), pp 8336-8346, 2006.

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 26 date: 22 June 2007

•unlimited tele-presence, audio, video (later including smell and touch)

in field of:

• entertainment

• education

• health and care

• safety

•creation of a virtual world with unlimited access

•"intelligence" everywhere: at home, in office, on road

•cheap work power - robots - available for routine tasks

•sensor networks enabling efficient use of energy and other resources

What can we espect within a generation?

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 27 date: 22 June 2007

apparatus for personal use:

• computers: PC's everywhere, at least one per person

• mobile phone

• MP3 player

• USB memory stick

• navigation system

• broad-band access

• (nearly) free communication

• internet

• digital camera

globalization

• cost of factory of advanced electronic ICs : 5 000 000 000 $

• same software and hardware used worldwide

Current impact of nano/micro technology

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 28 date: 22 June 2007

An example of history

Thomas Robert Malthus:

On population (1798)

main hypothesis:

Unchecked population growth always exceeds

the growth of means of subsistence.

some numbers:

Great Britain world

population

1798

10 000 000 <1 000 000 000

population

2007

60 000 000 >6 000 000 000

population growth in Great Britain in 19th century: 4 x

growth of national product: 14 x

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 29 date: 22 June 2007

An example of history

Paul Kennedy:

Preparing for the twenty-first century (1993)

Why was Malthus wrong?

Malthus did not foresee:

•migration

•increased agricultural productivity

•industrialization

more in general:

Malthus ignored dynamics of system

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 30 date: 22 June 2007

The anthropic principle

Brendon Carter (1973) The Universe (and hence the fundamental

parameters on which it depends) must be such as

to admit the creation of observers within it at some

stage.

A generalized version of the anthropic principle

The Universe (and hence its evolution in time) is

such that man always will develop the technology

and culture needed to live according to human

dignity.

Example of an actual challenge: energy

Fossil fuels have been stored during million of years to provide an

easy accessible energy source for humanity during 1-2 centuries.

Thereafter man will have had time to develop alternative technologies.

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 31 date: 22 June 2007

Scientific and technological knowledge: fundamentally good

but: with new technologies:

•new weapons for aggressive wars

•new totalitarian systems

•new forms of intimidation and criminal behavior

•new forms of addiction and abuse

•new forms of exploitation

•enormous control (manipulation) of behavior of individuals

and groups

needed: ethical assessment and support

ethics is art to make good use of the technology

new scientific journal: NanoEthics (Springer)

A too optimistic view?

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 32 date: 22 June 2007

Further development of science and technology is

necessary for the current and future world population to

live according to human dignity,

but it is not sufficient,

it is a necessary condition, conditio sine qua non.

An important distinction

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 33 date: 22 June 2007

1) Create conditions for the dialogue between experts in

technique and humanity (ethics)

How to make good use of technology?

characteristics

expert in technology expert in humanity

specialist generalist

trained in science and

technology

trained in humanities

layman in ethical aspects layman in technical aspects

industry & business (semi-) government and

ngo

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 34 date: 22 June 2007

2) work out scenarios for the introduction of new

technologies incl. economic, juridical, pedagogical, psychological, sociologic and

ethical aspects

3) anticipate on opportunities and threats example:

use of multimedia and internet by children and youth

•educate for convenient use

•prevent addiction

•protect against unwanted contacts

•recognize long-term consequences of intense use of multimedia on

health (RSI, obesity), social behavior, creativity, concentration, etc.

How to make good use of technology?

affiliation (2007)

Integrated Optical Micro Systems (IOMS)

man_and_nanotech.ppt slide 35 date: 22 June 2007

We just have made a begin with the application of

micro/nano technology

There is reason for optimism of the technological

development by man

There is urgent need to study and implement ethical

issues of the application of new technologies.

Acknowledgments: Albert van den Berg, Dave Blank of MESA+

Ronald Dekker, Wico Hopman, Edwin Klein of IOMS-MESA+

Conclusions