. ,

1 DENNIS J. HERRERA, StateBar#l39669 City Attorney

2 THOMAS S. LAKRITZ, State Bar #161234 Chief Attorney

3 Neighborhood and Resident Safety Division MICHAELS. WEISS, StateBar#l68378

4 MEGAN CESARE-EAS1MAN, State Bar #253845 VICTORIA L. WEATHERFORD, StateBar#267499

5 Deputy City Attorneys Fox Plaza

6 1390 Market Street, Sixth Floor San Francisco, California 94102-5408

7 Telephone: (415) 554-3824 Facsimile: (415) 437-4644

8 E-Mail: michael.weiss@sfgov.org E-Mail: megan.cesare@sfgov.org

9 E-Mail: victoria.weatherford@sfgov.org

1 O Attorneys for Plaintiffs

~. (1Rl61NAl:

ENDORSED suferioJ Co~rt o~arJ?rnia

County of San Francisco

DEC 15 2015 CLERK OF THE COURT

BY: SEAN KANE Deputy Clerk

CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO and 11 PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO

UNLIMITED JURISDICTION

CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO, a Municipal Corporation, and the PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA, by .and through DENNIS J. HERRERA, City Attorney for the CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO,

Plaintiffs,

vs.

Case No. CGC-15-546152 ·~~

[P.&OPOSEI>] ORDER OVERRULING DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO STRIKE PORTIONS OF THE FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT

Hearing Date: Hearing Judge: Time: Place:

December 15, 2015 Hon. Harold E. Kahn 9:30 a.m. Dept. 302

22 ANNE KIHAGI aka ANNA KIHAGI aka Date Action Filed: June 4, 2015 ANNA SW A1N aka ANNE KIHAGI SWAIN Trial Date: Not Yet Set

23 aka ANNA KIHAGI SWAIN, JULIA MW ANG! aka JULIA MUNENE,

24 CHRISTINE MW ANGI aka CHRISTINA MW ANGI aka CHRISTINE JOHNSON,

25 XELAN PROP 1, LLC, RENKA PROP, LLC, NOZARI 2, LLC, ZORIALL, LLC, and DOE

26 ONE THROUGH DOE FIFTY,

27 Defendants.

28

1

I

ORDER DENYING DEF'S MOTION TO STRIKE; CGC-15-546152 n:\codenNi2015\l S 1349\01068385.doc

r

1 Defendants ANNA KIHAGI, JULIA MW ANGI, CHRISTINE MW ANGI, XELAN PROP 1,

2 LLC, RENK.A PROP, LLC, NOZARI 2, LLC, and ZORIAl.L, LLC's (collectively, "Defendants")

3 Motion to Strike Portions of the First Amended Complaint ("Motion to Strike") .in the above-entitled

4 action came on for hearing on December 15, 2015 at 9:30 a.m. in Department 302 of the San Francisco

5 Superior Court, the Honorable Harold E. Kahn presiding. Plaintiffs CITY AND COUNTY OF ~AN

6 FRANCISCO and PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA (collectively "Plaintiffs") appeared

7 through their counsel of record, Deputy City Attorney Megan Cesare-Eastman of the San Francisco

8 City Attorney's Office. Defendants appeared through their counsel of record

9 /\ \ « s avid r \Io l lt-crv , \?;~Gl:r. 10 Based on the evidence presented, the complete file in this matter, the oral argument of the

11 parties, and GOOD CAUSE APPEARING, it is the order of this Court that Defendants' Motion to

12 Strike is DENIED in its entirety.

13 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT:

14

15

1.

2.

Defendants' request for judicial notice is~CWl±uf as +o ±Vie-Pf31 llGCorof.S C?Vlk/) ol~Joed As +o -H-i~ u.'91 . . bvo . vr,~ a"'-0( inGm-1 Pl~ Co~elt?f..fht-.. Even if the Court were to take Judicial notice of the contents ofDepmtment ofBwlding

16 Inspection ("DBI") records, Defendants are not entitled to have any portions of the First Amended

17 Complaint stricken. All of the portions of the first amended complaint that Defendants seek to strike

18 are evidentiary facts which have independent relevance apart from the DBI records.

19 3. The doctrines of res judicata and collateral estoppel apply only to claims or issues that

20 have been fully adjudicated. Neither of these doctrines apply to the allegations of evidentiary or facts.

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

ITIS SO ORDERED.

Dated: l d \,5"'hf

CCSF, et al. v. Kihagi, et al. S.F. Superior No. CGC 15-546152

HON. HAROLD E. KAHN JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT

2 ORDER DENYING DEF'S MOTION TO STRIKE; CGC-15-546152 n:\codenf\li2015\151349\01068385.doc