Post on 22-Feb-2016
description
transcript
Principle Number One: The Road to Hell is Paved with Good Intentions
Izzy Kalman
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/psychological-solution-bullying/201008/principle-number-one-the-road-hell-is-paved-good-intenti
Examples of Good Intentions with Bad Effects:
Examples of Good Intentions with Bad Effects:
Examples of Good Intentions with Bad Effects:
Examples of Good Intentions with Bad Effects:
Examples of Good Intentions with Bad Effects:
Examples of Good Intentions with Bad Effects:
How many examples do you need to prove a point?
“Good intentions do not automatically lead to moral actions. We must consider the possible negative consequences before we institute anti-bullying
interventions. If our interventions cause more harm than good, the interventions are not moral regardless
of the loftiness of our intentions.”
James Rachels, “Killing and Letting Die”
James Rachels, “Killing and Letting Die”
Smith: Intends to kill cousin for $, plans to do so, prepares to do so, travels to the location, and holds cousin underwater to kill him
Jones: Intends to kill cousin for $, plans to do so, prepares to do so, travels to the location, but finds cousin drowning and lets him die
James Rachels, “Killing and Letting Die”
Rachels: Jones is no better than Smith; they are morally equivalent; their actions have the same effect (namely, the death of the cousin)
“Good intentions do not automatically lead to moral actions. We must consider the possible negative consequences before we institute anti-bullying
interventions. If our interventions cause more harm than good, the interventions are not moral regardless
of the loftiness of our intentions.”