Post on 27-Apr-2018
transcript
Publish or Perish: Step by Step Process for Writing a
Manuscript Alayna E. Loiselle, PhD
June 27, 2016
WheretoStart
• Whyareyoutryingtopublishthiswork?• logically,notchronologically• Context-convincethereviewerstocare
• WHATISYOURPOINT?
Outline
• Whatisyourcentralmessage?Alwayscomebacktothis
• Whatarethemethodsyouused?• SummarizetheQ’sandproblems-whydidyoudothisstudy?
• Whatareyourresults?• WhataretheimplicaKonsofthesedata?• Wheredoesthisfitintothe‘bigpicture’,literature?
Figures
Letyourfiguresbeyourguide1. Knowyouraudience
-Broadorsub-specialtyjournal?2. IdenKfyyourmessage
-usethefiguretoyouradvantage3. Adapttothemedium4. CapKonsarenotopKonal5. Donottrustthedefaults6. UsecoloreffecKvely7. Donotmisleadthereader8. Avoid‘chartjunk’
-everythingmusthaveapurpose9. Messagetrumpsbeauty10. Gettherighttool
Results
• NOTADISCUSSION• ProvideaheadingforeachsubsecKon• Canprovidebriefcontext,butnointerpretaKon
• Sequenceshouldtellastory• Proceedinthesameorderasyourfigures• Refertoyourfiguresinthetext• ObjecKve
Introduc6on
• WhatwasthemoKvaKonforthestudy?ConvincemethisisanimportantproblemWhatisthe‘gapinknowledge’?Whathaveyoudonetoaddressthisgap?Briefly,whatareyougoingtoshowme?
Funnel:Bigpicturetosmalldetail
Materials&Methods:ARRIVE
Nc3rs.org.uk
Discussion
• NOTTHERESULTSSECTION• Don’tignorethingsthatarecountertoyourcurrentdata/conclusion.ExplainwhytheymaybedifferentandwhatyournewinterpretaKonis
• Howdidyoufillinthosegapsinknowledgefromtheintro?
• Howdidyouaddressyourhypothesis?• LimitaKons• WhatistheapplicaKon/translaKon?
Abstract
• Writethislast• UsuallythefirstinteracKonw/reviewers
Edi6ng
• Donotsimplyskimoreditlightly
• ReadcriKcally-thinkabouteachsentenceandifitsayspreciselywhatyoumeantosay.
ChoosingaJournal
• Consider:audience,editors,reviewKmes• comparisonvspapersyouarereferencing• ‘Aims&Scope’
Authorship• Anauthorshouldhavemadeasubstan'al,direct,intellectualcontribuKon
• Thefundingandprovisionoftechnicalservices,paKents,materialsalonearenotsufficient
• EveryonemakingasubstanKalintellectualcontribuKontotheworkshouldbeanauthor
• EveryonemakingothersubstanKalcontribuKonsshouldbeacknowledged
• Allauthorsshouldreviewmanuscriptdrajsandapprovethefinalversion
• Transparency• CollaboraKon ICMJEguidelines