Questioning Information sources

Post on 28-May-2015

92 views 0 download

Tags:

description

When you are deciding what information to use for a paper -- or any other purpose -- there are some questions you should ask about the information you're using. This presentation offers some ways to question information sources and decide whether they are appropriate for your work.

transcript

Who?What

?

Why?Who? What ? Why?

Questioning information sources

Anybody canedit Wikipedia!

Anybody canedit Wikipedia!

Would you click on these links?

What is it?

Open

web

• Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Wikipedia• self-hosted blogs, not hosted by an

organization

News

sources

• Newspapers, magazines and trade publications

• blogs of organizations, often newspapers or magazines

Academic scholarship

• books• journal articles

Who created it?

Who are they?

• A journalist?• A scholar?• A blogger?

What is their background or experience?

• Education?• Work on the topic?• Previous writing?

Does their experience make them a credible source on the

topic? • Given what you know about them, do you trust their opinion or point of view to speak for you?

• What do other people say about them online?

Why was it published?

Sharing original research results

Selling you a product

Selling you an idea

Introducing a new

idea

Sharing original research results

Selling you a

product

Selling you an idea

Introducing a new

idea

For each source:

• What kind of source is it? • Who wrote it and their background?• Who published it? What is their point

of view or purpose in sharing the information?

• Would you use this source in an academic paper?

• Would you use it for other purposes?