Post on 18-Mar-2020
transcript
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
RuleofLawinPost-ISISMosul
VeraMironovaSamWhi.
Survey• InDecember2018400CiviliansweresurveyedinMosulontheiropinionontheRuleofLawinPostISISIraqandISISrelatedtrials.
• Randomsampleacross11Mosulneighborhoods.Dec23-30,2018.
• In10-25January2019,200membersofISISfamiliesweresurveyedincampsaroundMosul(QayyarahJad’ah,HamamAlAlil,andSalamyiah)
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
Demographics
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
34
14
20
38
2832
1518
Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies
18-25 26-36 36-50 50+
Age
3
36
25
32
47
32
23
0
Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies
none Primary Secondary Higher
Educa*onQ:Whatisthehighestlevelofeduca3onthatyouhavecompleted?
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
51
18
1116
19
75
2
40
16
36
2925
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Employer/manageroffirm
Professionalworker
Officeworker Manualworker Farmer Unemployed Student
EmploymentQ:Whattypeofworkhaveyoubeendoingoverthepastyear?(%)
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
20 19
70
53
10
28
Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies
from1to4 from5to9 from9to15
HouseholdSizeQ:Howmanypeoplearecurrentlylivingwithyouinthishouseholdincluding
yourself?(%)
91
44
3
39
157
79
Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies
HaveSavings NoDifficulbes FaceSomeDifficulbes FaceSignificantDificulbes
HouseholdIncomeQ:Whichofthesestatementscomesclosesttodescribingyourhouseholdincome
now?(%)
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
14
52
Civilians ISISfamilies
Familymemberontrial
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
21
4
55
17 2011
64
WorkedforISIS SpouseworkedforISIS
FamilymemberworkedforISIS
RespondentfounghtforISIS
relabvefoughtforISIS
SpousefoughtforISIS
FamilymemberoftrialforISIS
Rela*onstoISIS(ISISFamilies)
47
3638
9 8
1
11
3
79
11
2
24
13
21
6
10
6
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
PunishedforISISrulesviolabon
Familymembers
punishedforISISrulesviolabons
InjuredbyISIS Familymembers
injuredbyISIS
Familymemberskilled
ImprisonedbyISIS
FledhomebecauseofISIS
PropertylootedbyISIS
WomenabusedbyISIS
Vic*miza*onbyISISQ:DidanyofthefollowinghappentoyouwhileISISwasincontrolof
Mosulfrom2014through2017?(%)
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
6
139
61
8
2
50 51
7
13
34
73
34
64
36
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
Civilians ISISfamilies
WasWounded FamilyWounded FamilyKilled HomeDamaged WasDetained FledHome PropertyLooted Womenabused
Vic*miza*onduringtheLibera*onQ:DuringbaJlesin2017toretakeMosulfromISIS,didanyofthesethings
happentoyou?(%)
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
ISISandRuleofLaw
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
2
6
13
56
81
34
4
1
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Almost
everyone
Mostp
eople
Somepe
ople,
butn
ota
majority
Almostn
oon
eatall
Percep*onsofPublicSupportforISISinMosulQ:Ingeneral,howmanypeopleinMosuldoyouthinksupportedISISwhenittook
controlofthecity?(%)
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
47.1
56
21
30
24
44
33
31
10
9
34
33
43
48
41
38
35
42
23
11
11
9
22
13
17
13
18
13
28
16
8
2
14
9
17
6
14
14
38
64
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Mon
eyand
Po
wer
Beliefin
Ideo
logy
ForJihad
Toopp
osethe
Iraqi
governmen
tOutofFear
Explana*onsforPublicSupportofISISinMosul(I)Q:WhydoyouthinksomepeoplemighthavesupportedISIS?(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
21
46
20
38
24
38
27
45
24
17
38
11
39
13
31
14
34
23
39
16
34
13
34
16
33
16
31
11
31
10
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Toim
provelaw
andorde
rTo
fightcrim
eandcorrup
bonTo
improvethe
econ
omy
Tom
ake
governmen
tmoreeff
ecbve
Tofight
immoralit
yin
society
Explana*onsforPublicSupportofISISinMosul(II)Q:WhydoyouthinksomepeoplemighthavesupportedISIS?(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
14
12
9
42
7
17
14
18
27
22
27
12
8
50
34
9
39
10
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Anyone
who
helpe
dISISOnlythoserespon
ciblefor
crim
es
OnlyTo
pLeadership
HoldingISISAccountableQ:Whodoyouthinkshouldbeheldaccountablefortheirroleinsuppor3ng
ISIS?(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
14
15
28
60
39
8
20
27
2
6
19
17
30
3
34
1
1
1
5
56
2
13
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Leadership
Fighters
CivilianFollowersForeignFighters
AssigningBlametoISISQ:Towhatextentdoyouthinkthefollowingdeserveblameforcrimes
commiJedbyISIS?(%)
AGreatDeal AFairAmount NotVeryMuch Noneatall
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
3012
2746
2539
1719
2949
3531
1015
3828
409
4016
2641
3823
2014
2848
2035
2412
2713
4021
203
92
4319
CiviliansISISfamilies
CiviliansISISfamilies
CiviliansISISfamilies
CiviliansISISfamilies
CiviliansISISfamilies
CiviliansISISfamilies
CiviliansISISfamilies
Females
working
forISIS
Wivesof
fighters
Wivesof
Leaders
Foreign
Fighters
Civilian
Followers
Fighters
Leader
sPunishingISIS
Q:Doyouagree/disagreethatthefollowingarenowbeingsufficientlypunishedfortheirroleinISIS?(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
34
10
33
27
37
30
39
24
18
37
15
45
19
33
24
50
3
41
2
22
1
20
5
13
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Wom
enwereas
radicalasm
an
Wom
encou
ldbeas
dangerou
sinthe
futureasm
an
ISISwivesplayidan
impo
rtantrolein
ISIS
ISISwives
played
im
portant
role
supp
orbn
gfighters
FemalesinISISQ:InthinkingaboutwomenandISIS,towhatextentdoyouagreeordisagree
withthefollowing:(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
24
19
20
23
46
10
44
10
21
1
29
1
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
ISISwivessh
ouldnotbepu
nished
be
causetheyjustfo
llowed
man
Wom
eninISISsh
ouldnotbe
punished
becausem
anwerein
charge
PunishmentforISISFemalesQ:InthinkingaboutwomenandISIS,towhatextentdoyouagreeor
disagreewiththefollowing:(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
33
10
17
15
31
74
17
1
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
IraqiCou
rtsin
Mosulwith
local
judges
IraqiCou
rtso
utsid
eMosulwith
no
nlocaljudges
Internab
onal
Courtswith
internab
onal
judges
NoCo
urts,letth
eIra
qiArm
yde
cide
ResponsibilityforJus*ceQ:WhoshouldbeinchargeofholdingISISaccountable?(%)
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
60
11
10
56
23
31
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Brou
ghttojusbceinIraqBr
oughttojusbceinhom
ecoun
try
Brou
ghttojusbcein
internab
onaltribun
al
BringingForeignFighterstoJus*ceQ:WhatinyouropinionshoulddonewithISISforeignfighters?(%)
55
65
47
50
10
8
9
58
28
32
28
39
32
13
33
26
15
2
21
8
42
28
38
14
2
1
3
2
15
51
20
2
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Iraqicou
rtsw
ith
punishFFmore
severelyth
enth
eir
homecoun
tries
Iraqicou
rtsw
ith
punishFFmore
severelyth
en
internab
onal
tribun
al
FFarelesslikelyto
getfairtria
linIra
qthen
ath
ome
FFareless
likelytoget
fairtrialin
internab
onal
tribun
al
Prosecu*onofForeignFightersQ:WithrespecttoISISforeignfighters,towhatextentdoyouagreeordisagreewith
thefollowingstatements:(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
8
8
0
5
0
4
0
7
27
51
0
41
0
33
0
8
17
31
4
14
3
41
2
28
20
12
14
30
8
21
11
17
27
81
11
89
1
85
40
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Hizba,Amni
ForeignFighters
LocalFighters
Leaders
AssigningPunishmenttoISIS(I)Q:TheIraqigovernmentmustdecidewhattodowithpeoplewhosupportedISISand
workedforthem.
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison DeathSentence
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
85
77
14
60
13
85
10
73
5
17
3
39
31
12
26
21
3
3
21
1
22
23
3
1.5
15
14
2
21
3
4.5
3
18
19
20
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Paidta
xtoISIS
Civilianworking
forISIS(trafic
police)
Civiliansworking
forISIS
(con
strucbon
,sanitabo
n)
Civilians
workingfo
rISIS(coo
ks,
mechn
ics)
AssigningPunishmenttoISIS(II)Q:TheIraqigovernmentmustdecidewhattodowithpeoplewho
supportedISISandworkedforthem.
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison DeathSentence
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
18
55
8
49
10
53
29
41
37
41
41
35
31
3
41
9
38
9
21
1
13
2
11
1
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Trialsarebiased
against
Sunn
is
Judgesm
ainlywantreven
ge
againstISIS
Courttrailsare
biased
againstISIS
Percep*onsofIraqiCourtSystem(I)Q:Towhatextentdoyouagreeordisagreewiththefollowingstatements?
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
8
49
63
32
68
66
43
51
37
41
29
63
25
26
42
36
41
9
6
4
5
7
9
11
13
2
2
1
2
0
5
1
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Judgesm
ainlywant
revengeagainstISIS
ISISprison
ersc
an
influ
encejudges
throughbribery
Corrup
boninIraqi
courts
SomeofISIS
convictscou
ld
beinno
cent
Percep*onsofIraqiCourtSystem(II)Q:Towhatextentdoyouagreeordisagreewiththefollowingstatements?
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
3
3
8
6
6
7
18
9
23
40
18
26
68
50
55
60
IfamnestyisgiventoISISfighters,theywillstopfighbng
ISISfighterswhosurrenderandcooperatewiththeIraqiauthoribesshouldbepardoned
OfferingamnestytoISISfightersduringthe2017liberabonwouldhaveendedtheba.lesoonerandreducedcasualbes.
TheIraqigovernmentshouldhavenegobatedwithISIStopeacefullyresolvetheconflict
Percep*onsonNego*a*onswithISIS(Civilians)Q:Towhatextentdoyouagreeordisagreewiththefollowingstatements?
(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
39
29
24
15
25
37
11
13
6
3
5
2
11
4
5
2
3
financialaid
protectedfromIraqiretribubon
protectedfromISISretribubon
reducedprisonsentnece.
nodeathpenalty
notorture
Condi*onsforISIStosurrender(ISISfamilies)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
34
4
12
11
10
7
42
38
28
7
35
15
20
47
40
33
33
33
3
97
20
48
22
45
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
IraqiArm
edForces
TheIra
qiGovernm
entin
Baghdad
Localautho
ribesin
Mosul
Ins*tu*onalTrustandtheRuleofLaw(I)Q:Howmuchdoyoutrustthefollowingwhenitcomestofollowingtherule
oflaw?(%)
GreatDeal FairAmount NotVeryMuch Notatall
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
15
4
13
4
21
11
31
11
42
15
37
7
50
12
42
14
32
24
42
45
23
36
22
32
10
57
8
45
6
41
5
44
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Iraqicou
rtsinMosulIra
qiCou
rtsO
utsid
eMosul
IraqiCrim
inalCou
rts
ingen
eral
Iraqi
coun
terterror
ismcou
rts
Ins*tu*onalTrustandtheRuleofLaw(II)Q:Howmuchdoyoutrustthefollowingwhenitcomestofollowingtherule
oflaw?(%)
GreatDeal FairAmount NotVeryMuch Notatall
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
22
16
41
32
31
15
25
50
12
18
5
12
29
21
9
3
3
31
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Democracyispreferableto
anyothe
rformofp
olibcal
system
Und
erso
mecircum
stances,a
non-de
mocrabcgovernm
ent
maybepreferableto
a
democrabcone
Thede
athpe
nalty
is
ajustpun
ishmen
tforcertaincrim
es
Democracy,TheRuleofLaw,andApplica*onoftheDeathPenalty(I)Q:Towhatextentdoyouagree/disagreewiththefollowingstatements?
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
42
17
38
23
38
25
16
20
23
24
12
45
8
4
14
16
4
15
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Itissomeb
mesnecessary
touseviolencetosu
pport
ajustcause
Thewillofthe
peo
pleis
moreim
portantthanthe
ruleoflaw
Theruleoflaw
mustb
efollowed
,even
ifitre
sults
inunp
opular
decisio
ns
Democracy,TheRuleofLaw,andApplica*onoftheDeathPenalty(II)Q:Towhatextentdoyouagree/disagreewiththefollowingstatements?
(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
7
44
25
35
30
19
38
2
Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies Civilians ISISfamilies
Veryooen Somebmes Rarely Never
FollowingNewsaboutISISTrialsQ:Howo@endoyoufollownewsandinformaBonabouttrialsinvolvingISIS
members?(%)
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
24
28
21
38
28
28
11
13
5
12
25
19
3
6
2
15
22
10
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Trialswou
ldbemorefair
theywereop
ento
the
publicto
see
Thepu
blichasarightto
know
whatish
appe
ning
inISIStrials
Publictrialswillonly
maketheprocesso
fpu
nishingISISm
embe
rs
slowerand
moredifficult
ViewsonPublicityofTrialProceedingsQ:Towhatextentdoyouagreeordisagreewiththefollowingstatements:(%)
StronglyAgree SomewhatAgree SomewhatDisagree StronglyDisagree
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
SurveyExperiments
Ineachofthefollowing,respondentswererandomlyassignedtoreceiveeither[opbon1oropbon2]asindicatedinthequesbonwording.Theywouldthenchoosethepunishmenttheyfeltwasappropriateforthegivenoffense.
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
33
27
46
22
30
27
19
2
12
2
11
2
18
16
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
VolunteraryJoined
Joined
tofe
edfamily
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years
PunishmentforISISWorkers(SurveyExperiment)Q:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnessesclaimedthatNasimhadworkedforISIS,butneverfought.Witnessesalsoclaimthathehad[1.volunteeredtojoinISIS,2.onlyworkedforISIStosupporthisfamily].WhatshouldbedonewithNasim?
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
3
66
5
50
14
22
7
31
13
8
16
6
68
71
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
VolunteraryJoined
Joined
tofe
edfamily
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison DeathSentence
PunishmentforISISFighters(SurveyExperiment)Q:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnessesclaimedthatAkramwaswithISIS.Witnessesalsoclaimthathehad[1.volunteeredtojoinISIS,2.only
foughtforISIStosupporthisfamily].WhatshouldbedonewithAkram?
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
29
24
25
25
27
24
19
20
20
20
2
17
32
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Marria
geto
afighter
WorkedforISIS
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison DeathSentence
Punishment:FemaleWivesvs.WorkersinISIS(SurveyExperiment)
Q:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnessesclaimedthatSara[1.wasmarriedtoanISISfighter;2.workingforISIS].
WhatshouldbedonewithSara?
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
31
18
25
10
21
4
26
9
25
24
14
9
13
29
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
wife
ofalowlevelISIS
wife
ofahighlevelISIS
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison DeathSentence
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
Punishment:Lowvs.HighlevelISISWives(SurveyExperiment)
Q:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnessesclaimedthatLinawasmarriedtoa[1.low-levelISISfighter,2.high-levelISIScommander].
WhatshouldbedonewithLina?
34
66
47
64
18
18
27
17
6
4
5
3
2
2
1
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Localciviliankilled
anISIS
mem
ber
Iraqim
ilkilledanISISm
embe
r
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison DeathSentence
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
Punishment:ExtrajudicialKillings,Iden*ty(SurveyExperiment)
Q:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnessesclaimedthat[1.alocalcivilian,2.anIraqiArmyfighter]namedSamerwasseenexecuBngsuspectedISISmembers.
WhatshouldbedonewithSamer?
36
10
11
20
28
36
46
10
26
1
16
2
24
13
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Revenge
Preven
tISISfrom
returning
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison DeathSentence
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
Punishment:ExtrajudicialKillings,Mo*ve(SurveyExperiment)Q:WitnessesclaimedthatalocalciviliannamedAlikilledanISISsupporterinhisneighborhood.WitnessesclaimhewasmoBvated[1.byrevenge2.to
preventfutureaTacks]WhatshouldbedonewithAli?
SurveyExperimentsonDueProcess
•Ineachofthefollowing,respondentswererandomlyassignedtoreceiveeither[opbon1oropbon2]asindicatedinthequesbonwording.Theywouldthendecidewhetherbasedontheinformabon,howlikely/unlikelywerethefollowingstatements:•1.Theaccusedafairtrial•2.Theaccusedwasguilty•3.Witnesswereprobablytellingthetruth•4.Thejudgemadetherightdecision•5.Thesentencewasproporbonaltothecrime•6.Thesentencewasaboutgesngrevenge
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
8
14
33
11
21
24
5
33
46
50
6
48
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Didno
thaveaninde
pend
ent
lawyer
Hadaninde
pend
entLaw
yer
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImportanceofDueProcessQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthatMustafawasworkingforISISasaninformant.
Mustafadeniesthis.Athistrial,Mustafa[1.hadnolawyerandwasnotabletospeakinhisdefense,2.hadalawyerandwasableto
speakinhisdefense]Doyouthinkhehadatrialfair?
34
24
42
31
34
54
6
49
16
18
3
16
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Didno
thaveaninde
pend
ent
lawyer
Hadaninde
pend
entLaw
yer
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImportanceofDueProcessQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MustafawasworkingforISISasaninformant.Mustafadeniesthis.Athistrial,Mustafa[1.hadnolawyerandwasnotabletospeakinhisdefense,2.hadalawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense]Doyouthinkhewasguilty?
27
28
44
19
43
58
7
57
10
14
2
20
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Didno
thavean
inde
pend
entlaw
yer
Hadaninde
pend
ent
Lawyer
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImportanceofDueProcessQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MustafawasworkingforISISasaninformant.Mustafadeniesthis.Athistrial,Mustafa[1.hadnolawyerandwasnotabletospeakinhisdefense,2.hada
lawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense]Doyouthinkwitnessesweretellingthetruth?
11
9
36
16
31
22
7
30
38
61
6
46
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Didno
thavean
inde
pend
entlaw
yer
Hadaninde
pend
ent
Lawyer
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImportanceofDueProcessQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthatMustafawasworkingforISISasaninformant.Mustafadeniesthis.Athistrial,Mustafa[1.hadnolawyerandwasnotabletospeakinhisdefense,2.hadalawyerandwasableto
speakinhisdefense]Doyouthinkthejudgemadetherightdecision?
18
18
49
10
19
48
38
61
25
32
8
20
37
2
5
10
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Didno
thavean
inde
pend
entlaw
yer
Hadaninde
pend
ent
Lawyer
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImportanceofDueProcessQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MustafawasworkingforISISasaninformant.Mustafadeniesthis.Athistrial,Mustafa[1.hadnolawyerandwasnotabletospeakinhisdefense,2.hadalawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense]Doyouthinkthesentencewas
proporBonaltothecrime?
7
34
3
38
35
66
12
49
36
50
5
21
34
8
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Didno
thavean
inde
pend
entlaw
yer
Hadaninde
pend
ent
Lawyer
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImportanceofDueProcessQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MustafawasworkingforISISasaninformant.Mustafadeniesthis.Athistrial,Mustafa[1.hadnolawyerandwasnotabletospeakinhisdefense,2.hadalawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense]Doyouthinkthesentencewas
aboutgeVngrevenge?
11
10
21
16
9
13
11
8
34
15
25
28
45
61
43
48
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Judgefrom
Basra
Judgefrom
Mosul
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImpactofPerceivedJudicialBiasQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MohammedwasfighBngforISIS.Mohammeddeniesthis.Athistrialajudge[1.fromMosul2.fromBasra]sentencedhimtodeath.
Doyouthinkhehadafairtrial?
31
34
41
30
29
22
26
18
25
35
19
36
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Judgefrom
Basra
Judgefrom
Mosul
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImpactofPerceivedJudicialBiasQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MohammedwasfighBngforISIS.Mohammeddeniesthis.Athistrialajudge[1.fromMosul2.fromBasra]sentencedhimtodeath.
Doyouthinkhewasguilty?
21
11
24
10
39
48
40
40
32
37
25
42
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Judgefrom
Basra
Judgefrom
Mosul
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImpactofPerceivedJudicialBiasQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MohammedwasfighBngforISIS.Mohammeddeniesthis.Athistrialajudge[1.fromMosul2.fromBasra]sentencedhimtodeath.
Doyouthinkwitnessesweretellingthetruth?
14
13
16
27
33
26
28
43
51
37
54
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Judgefrom
Basra
Judgefrom
Mosul
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImpactofPerceivedJudicialBiasQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthatMohammedwasfighBngforISIS.Mohammeddeniesthis.Athistrialajudge[1.fromMosul2.fromBasra]sentencedhimtodeath.
Doyouthinkthejudgemadetherightdecision?
12
56
16
72
35
19
30
10
43
16
33
2
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Judgefrom
Basra
Judgefrom
Mosul
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImpactofPerceivedJudicialBiasQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MohammedwasfighBngforISIS.Mohammeddeniesthis.Athistrialajudge[1.fromMosul2.fromBasra]sentencedhimtodeath.
DoyouthinkthesentencewasproporBonaltothecrime?
13
74
8
74
62
15
48
26
14
7
26
11
3
18
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Judgefrom
Basra
Judgefrom
Mosul
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImpactofPerceivedJudicialBiasQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MohammedwasfighBngforISIS.Mohammeddeniesthis.Athistrialajudge[1.fromMosul2.fromBasra]sentencedhimtodeath.
DoyouthinkthesentencewasaboutgeVngrevenge?
27
55
39
60
11
27
21
31
13
7
27
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
JudgeFrom
Basra
JudgeFrom
Mosul
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:ImpactofPerceivedJudicialBiasQ:A@ertheliberaBonofMosul,witnesseshavecomeforwardclaimingthat
MohammedwasfighBngforISIS.Mohammeddeniesthis.Athistrialajudge[1.fromMosul2.fromBasra]sentencedhimtodeath.
Ifyoudisagreewiththedecision,whatdoyouthinkshouldbedone?
5
10
12
9
6
12
31
16
3
58
18
57
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Captured
Surren
dered
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:RightsofPOWsQ:DuringtheliberaBonofMosul,FadhilwasanISISfighterwhowas[1.capturedduringafirefight2.voluntarilysurrendered].Athistrial,hehadalawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense.Thejudgesentencedhimtodeath.Doyouthinkhehad
afairtrial?
87
8
40
10
4
19
13
17
4
21
30
17
4
52
17
54
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Captured
Surren
dered
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:RightsofPOWsQ:DuringtheliberaBonofMosul,FadhilwasanISISfighterwhowas[1.
capturedduringafirefight2.voluntarilysurrendered].Athistrial,hehadalawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense.Thejudgesentencedhimto
death.Doyouthinkthejudgemadetherightdecision?
83
40
33
32
6
44
14
43
5
12
31
14
6
4
22
11
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Captured
Surren
dered
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:RightsofPOWsQ:DuringtheliberaBonofMosul,FadhilwasanISISfighterwhowas[1.capturedduringafirefight2.voluntarilysurrendered].Athistrial,hehadalawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense.Thejudgesentencedhimtodeath.Doyouthinkthe
sentencewasproporBonaltothecrime?
7
85
9
61
5
11
42
31
16
4
18
7
71
29
1
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Captured
Surren
dered
DefinitlyYes ProbablyYes ProbablyNot Definitlynot
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:RightsofPOWsQ:DuringtheliberaBonofMosul,FadhilwasanISISfighterwhowas[1.capturedduringafirefight2.voluntarilysurrendered].Athistrial,he
hadalawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense.Thejudgesentencedhimtodeath.DoyouthinkthesentencewasaboutgeVngrevenge?
4
10
9
30
13
70
32
52
79
2
54
4
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Civilians
ISISfamilies
Captured
Surren
dered
Amnesty 6-15years 15-40years LifeinPrison
MironovaV.andWhi.S."RuleofLawinPostISISIraq"
PunishmentforISIS:RightsofPOWsQ:DuringtheliberaBonofMosul,FadhilwasanISISfighterwhowas[1.
capturedduringafirefight2.voluntarilysurrendered].Athistrial,hehadalawyerandwasabletospeakinhisdefense.Thejudgesentencedhimto
death.Ifyoudisagreewiththesentence,whatdoyouthinkshouldbedone?