SHYDRAULIC COMPONENT ACOUSTIC COMPATIBILITY ...I .w 'Ql U t f h l e d d d - K N xk I Q I bi V a l i...

Post on 16-Feb-2021

2 views 0 download

transcript

  • _ 62

    z Technical Report 483

    SHYDRAULIC COMPONENT ACOUSTICCOMPATIBILITY STUDY

    * ~ cMS ShimamotoFinl epot:October 1979

    ?-0 ina Reprt:1972-1975

    Lf 1

    Approved for public release; distribution unlimited

    NAVAL OCEAN SYSTEMS CENTER__ SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA 92152

    8__ _f 0-

  • BestAvai~lable

    Copy

  • NAVAL OCEAN SYSTEMS CENTER, SAN DIEGO. CA 92152

    AN ACTIVITY OF THE NAVAL MATERIAL CO MMAND

    SL GUILLE, CAPT, USN HL BLOODCommander Technical Director

    ADMINISTRATIVE INFORMATION

    The work reported here- was conducted tinder tile NAVORI) 6.2 )eepReco"' ry Systeln (i)RS) program. task number 00000-3-65025. Testingl wasperlormed dhuring the period 19' ,-,.7,

    Released by Under Authority ofJ K Katayala, I lea(I JD I lightower, I leadIOcean Systems Division lEnvi'olmelntal Sciences l)epartnment

    WI|U

    NI

    _I_ ?I

    I

    II I5

  • ___ UNCLASSPIE1)i"

    ___ ECUAITV CLASSIFICATION %F THIS PAGE 14hen Dotes Kn!erqed

    REPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE READ INSTRUCTIONSIREPORT NUM83ER OVT ACCESSION NO. 3. RECIPIENT'S CATALOG NUMBERt

    ___ NOSC Technical Report 483 (TR 483)

    ____________________________5. TYPE OF REPORT A PERIOD COVERED__ HY)RAUIC CMPONNT ACOUSTIC COMPATIBILITYHYRUI ClPOE'in.i 17-1975

    6. PERFORMING ORG. REPORT NUMSER

    7. . TNOR() a. CONTRACT OR GRANT NUMBER(&)

    9- PERFORMING ORGANIZATIO~N NAME AND ADDRESS 10. PROGRAM ELEMENT. PROJECT, TASK INaval Ocean Systems Ceniter, hlawaii Laoati I AREA A WORK UNIT NUMBERSPO Blox 997 ~)~l)>NAVORI) 6.2 DRS Task NumberKailtna, flziwali 967341 00000-3-65025

    ___ II. CON TROLLING OFFICE NAME AND ADDRESS .. 12RLj!0RT-QAI-

    ijOcfM7

    ~22~~j' \~. 13.I NUMBER OF PAGES__14 MONITORING AGENC'I NAMEt i ADORESSfif different from, Controlling Office) 15. SECURiTY CLASS. (of this report)

    Unclassified

    t~a DV.CL ASSI FICATIONitDOWNGRADINGS*tNEDULE

    16. DISTRIBUTION STATEMENT (of this Report)

    Approved for public release. dlistrtibution unilimited.

    17. DiSTRiBUTIONWSTATEmENT lof thofabst~sct entered In Black 20. ifdifrn Rpbt

    IS SUPPLEMENTARY NOTES

    19. KEY WORDS (Continue on reverse side if necessary and Identify by block number) -Acoustic PumlpsCompatibility Relief valves

    Ilydraullic Scivo Valves

    ;2 A~ TRACT (Co,1tinue an reverse aide If necesary and identify by black number) pr- 1wi Remote IJllillatilttd Work Sy~stem i(RUWNS~ is acablle-tetieled, unIIIIIIII~d %olvehicle Capable oftir

    formling deep ocean se'arclh, inspection zitid work l asks ito depths" of 20,000 feet. The vehicle and ptrIiiN %,abletermunation are open frame structures, thins. hII draullic Components ale Io';ated directly InI sealuatei. Since thesu'limersibles generally require sirrnultus us otf their propulsive C.pblt n cutcSnossiia oatime acoustic noise of the equipmienit mus1t bie low so that pier forluan e f the acoulstic; senlsors is not dlegladed.Tills docunnelu reports the invest igationl of acoustic nloise outputs of off-time-shelf hiN dratihct coumponents for use

    DbD r JAN S 7314 D\;ITIONj OF I NOV 65 IS OBSOLETE UNCLASSIFllDN

    S/N 012-LF-oA.66o1SKCURITY CLASSPICATION OF TNIS PAGE (Whien Dlata Sniffede)

  • CONTENTS

    INTRODUCTION ... page 3

    BACKGROUND... 3 9

    SYSTEM OPERATING REQUIREMENTS... 5

    ACOUSTIC COMPATIBILITY CRITERIA ... 7

    COMPONENT SELECTION ... 8

    COMPONENT EVALUATION ... 9

    Test Facilities... 9Sound Measurement Equipment... 11

    COMPONENT TESTS AND RESULTS... 15

    Relief Valves ... 15Motors... 19Pumps... 21Servo Valves. . 23

    COMPONENTS SELECTED FOR USE ON RUWS... 24

    CONCLUSIONS ... 27

    REFERENCES ... 28

    APPENDIX A: TEST DATA OF FIRST TEST SERIES.. 29

    APPENDIX B: TEST DATA OF SECOND TEST SERIES ... 75

    APPENDIX C: TEST DATA OF THIRD TEST SERIES... 89

    APPENDIX D: NOSC ROLAMITE VALVE DESIGN ... 97

    ,a i " e!,d,/ ? Spec~a,

    Zt

  • I LLUSiTRNTIONS

    -I ThI et.oti 1111,1il' W~or k SYsteil (RUWS) .. page 4- 2. The RUWS vehicle -

    3. RUWS. acouistic freqieticy spetroa ... 7 *4. R'JWS simplitied hyd:rtulic schenuttieS. Kit Tree Reservoir test Niyout .. . 106i. Doughboy swiniming pool test Iiiyou t 1 I07. Actustic tests oni NIL g 74 servt 2 ~ ptigsimigpo eutwt

    Ku Tree Reservoir result .. IS. NOSC saltwater test pool1 hyout . .. 1.49. yrpiue zuve simeitisceotic . . .14

    It0. Test sechezmitic. eifvdvs...tIL1 Rohuuite vatlve test a nu~tigeten it 1 .I12I Test schenlat ic. mo1tors; . . Q113. D~isk th tu (rpm vs torqlue) -.. 014. D~isk daita (rpmn vs lhp) . 01 5. Test selia -utic: pumpls. .'16o. Test sceui:servo v.i Ives (initialI configuration) . . .2

    17 Test schematic. sev oo (ie otiurtoi 2IS. Elctroldrairljic icuitl slietiuui tor RUWS ..

    D- 1, NOSC Rolaiite v;v ~D)-2 INOSC RoIlunite valve parts .. .

    TABLE

    - 1L Ind"- oC compionenits ald test sitcs ... 1 2

  • INI'IOI)1CT ION

    I~~it~i~hvthelv m dx~ t'ncut tovtI -ho \i'A'iiv' Ph'11w ~u\dI"i~ ~ i

    I i i 3 ( M ' ~ 1 1 I 'Ql . .w U f l d d d t h e xk - bi K N I Q I V a l i t ; 1 0 0 1 A t ' t s t i Ivdi p C W ) I u ~ i lxIom I' mme UC I'llm mpod thor S\A011 1AVSh oly'Ct~ iidIZItt~~h Ii :o tP

    W Alli n comm ImIx tover1ill kill Vth thc il th and~' V111a iSAIbk tvollnao IXOIUtdIVIiMI " of ~ r the k\'USIc .1li' -"'-lct ,d'dl~

    t~~r t~~' i~U'S -M, IIIw~o K'n vovm xim~ i~iIngiIi 1.k \;t~itledu vmo1-L tov o i'1

    IVtII,- OV vlIitrk leil x' i 1,0 m ll,n11I 1%1% Mau~ 111 clt lleni 1011-v Of~ d thw~~dI n hQ11\11 m!,t

    vo' sited N hC W 'tT 11w 01uItxv t\''u ~tohct madalto cou-n awl~ :t Mc':( o.rtow wth' aiIC

    1cisleiiI 101a"I \\ilIt Wi,1w R'IV$Stilm A' vilI'lihl- . I l k 11 10psla VI tta

    11t;SNAlk cnnlls m 1110 1\'Con\oll FCour1~ S~tIIki VOP,4 k\ mv tesIhO ;

    nl'o tile etlpisht of 't d I .... o isnt Ismou- k .i..th -M!"I~ 01 mptm:- ottn c-l\~uwetil\it-tvdtOt tod tio" ".4w a'vkmMdph wauN in I'\h I-,'

    \w'asulI the~i IV lu 11no\ vo~k q ih \1d Illil fl~m~ lI toI ~ itl ti It0 I' fool' -Fnowls.. otIvIll ma\~ 'l~ \1p iiu A lI 'i 1sined. I%s t.e 11 c oo in ll u' aN1\ t SOh '- N.oItli ;tc ho plxhttv lttimu aVles~li mu I\ Oj'Clt.mall I t ,ilf 1101,114 01ANM S

  • us

    0.0

    I--

    dcI cc t-v

    IL 0ca

    C.3

    Iz 'La'U

    00z z cc

    ca

    z z ccZ wi 4

    _ _ _ _

  • Tie electromechanical tether cable for RUWS employs a Kevlar strength member andsingle coaxial electrical member. Power and comnand/control signals to the vehicle and the

    ____wide bandwidth video and sensor data from the vehicle are simultaneouslv transmitted oi thetether cable through use of time and frequency multiplexing techniques.

    Hydraulically-powered systems wer- selected to perform the RUWS mechanical func-tions because of their tolerance to high ambient pressures and their inherent versatility throughsimple variable-speed controls. Hydraulic systems are compact and offer a low weight-to- Apower ratio. Weight is significant because of the high cost of syntactic foam that is needed toprovide vehicle buoyancy at deptls to 6.100 metres (9,000 psi).

    Another lmiajoi factor for selecting electrohydraulic propulsion systems over electricpropulsion systems was that controllable electric drive motors would cause a varying electricalload which would produce large line voltage variations at the vehicle due to the IR (current

    X cable resistance) loss in the cable. The RUWS system uses a 8.315-metre (24,000-foot)coaxial electromechanical cable that transmits up to 45 kVA of 60-Hz. 3000-volt power tothe PCT and vehicle. Tie electrical control and inforniation signals ,re time-division multi-plexed onto the coaxiai power cable. Tie sensitivity of the multiplexing circuitry requires afairly constant voltage level. Large voltage regulators with their attendant high heat loadwould be required for large line voltage variations. By operating a fixed-displacement hydrau-lic pump at a constant speed and throttling excess oil flow through a relief valve the electricpump-drive motor is under constant load. thereby minimizing the electrical current variation.

    Hydraulic propulsion systems. howvever. tend to produce more noise than electric pra-pulsion systems. Components in a hydraulic system considered to be major noise producersare pumps. motors and valves.

    Tie objective of this program was to select several commercially available hydraulicpumps, motors and valves as condidate components for the RUWS electrohydraulic propul-sion system, perform acoustic tests on the components, and select the quietest componentsthat would fit the requirements for the RUWS hydraulic system.

    SYSTEM OPERATING REQUIREMENTS

    = The components in RUWS sulbmersibles requiring electrohydraulic power consist ofthe thruster drives, vehicle tether winch and traction drives, and the vehicle's work suit (mani-pulators. camera gimbal. and special tool drives). Figure 2 depicts the RUWS vehicle, itsthrusters and work suit. The thruster arrangement provides four degrees of propulsive control:vertical, transverse, fore and aft, and yaw.

    The vehicle work suit (reference 1) consists of a seven-function manipulator, a four-function grabber. a TV-camera pan and tilt gimbal, and various work tools. Tie work suit iselectronically controlled and hydraulically powered. To meet the design pefornance goalsfor the work suit. 1000 psi was needed for the hydraulic supply pressure. and therefore 1000psi was selected for the RUWS vehicle system pressure. Candidate hydraulic componentsselected for use on the vehicle were tested at 1000-psi differential pressure for the acousticcompatibility evaluation.

    1. Marrone. R. A.. J. Held, and R. W. Uhrich. "Manipulator. Grabber and Tools for theROWS Work Subsystem", NUC TN SIS, Volume 2. November 1972.

    @T-m-

  • Al

    t A

    __lock,

    tS___ _ _FM

  • AC( ISTIC COMPATIBILITY CRITERIA

    Prior toc.tu oi pountt for the~ pow'r ssicii it 12% ssir to etatbhi- Illu-

    awhive~~w ac oinp -111itihdity . the ac~oustic uutput of thc hyddlk~ omponlents mu11- liemiiiiil in~ the. operikting tv-i- of thw various RUWS - t usticSI~

    TALT ALT AM IVE

    10:N

    Kt

    ISL

    FR.EQUEN'CY IIMH0

    _v ISwfAus \Oi xl \-)U~pMC1. A RIAIAcod-KN , DN-al~t 1, I______ I

    V-Llvm I W "~wiwatumforLo RaoTr. kig iatt I-RS1 am AlimtetFuutpmo

  • f__ __ I N~t t ~ = V-r IN UI _ FLPCT )N

    MENOI

    BOL U

    AOPN~N Sv-EATIONvflic h\-rnittw owrr andp~xlpulton svstflt ustu "MA\ishoncextcalI

    = ~ ~ ~~~E jn 4VhAce~awt iiLVhdt hw n4oeIr 'u\i.oo nd-etpct

    il~~tnator The Atfii yia 1u'!I rtl vll' lw~t$o un i't.Bn'irelva~v pq'flQI~ici'nrv1 -at~ aotrs I diu MOWhdcS itahatQ lttr

    a*A A-

    11SIO l5ls l tao. auNCI hl it", vlk -w n

    l'hb e ot11W- 'u r ~h\ s> - i'11nc'u hasa p n wc a\ctuato that

    orp'UCati (I VOI atunteui row PtficotVShn due audca !p. lir 311-wsuwt~

  • V Electric Motors General Electric. Model 4K254A K205Louis Allis Pacemaker Motor

    Pumps Born Warner. Model P4-213BeLaval. Model IMO A12-DR-137

    Vickems. Model V30-IF I5F-ICL

    Racine Supen'aneIlydrastar. Model 5-lil-20G

    Motors WSL Model 35 Mark VI*Nutron. Model NF AV-2.5Char-Lynn. Orbit Model AAS*Lamina Model A-62F* [Planet. Model MV-.93-A lA2BlAl 1

    Servo Valves Olsen. Moddel S-5CMoo. Model 74-104Moog. Model 35-A-76-1 5-E-05-6-A 4Sanders. Mode! SV-438-10P

    -- Relief Valves Republic. Model RG7O -2-3;4 521.4Vickers. Mo I CT-I O-C-20 4Fuid Controls. Model IAR4 -FiL 0-30SlFluid Controls. Model I A32-R6-30S Circle Seal. Model PI0-776p Rolamite. desinlA and fabricated at NOSC

    *Tested at Ku Tree Reservoir _

    The electric motors were necessar, for test purposes to drive the pumps. Their noise outputswere very low and did not significantly ctntribute to the results of the piump tests (graphsA-101 and A-102 in appendix A).

    COMPONENT EVALUATION

    The facilities and procedures used in evaluating the candidate components are des-cribed in the following paragraphs.

    TEST FACILITIES

    The initial tests were conducted at Ku Tree Reservoir (figure 5) in central Oahu. Th@issite was desirable because- of its large water volume and its bottom profile. which minimizedreverberation at the hydrophone. Because of logistics problems encountered at remotelest site, however, the tests were continued in a Doughboy swimming pool. 28 feet in diameterby 4 feet deep (figure 6). The reverberation off the walls and bottom of the pool produced an

    12I

  • ~- ~ ___ - 7

    VALVETOWER

    SUSPENSION BRIDGE50'

    HYDROPHONE

    TES GENPORATOR

    Fiur 5.E KuTreSesrvirtetOayut

    YDALCTS TN

    WEI

    =1 ~ Figure .ouboy seroirpo test layout.

    1 10

  • Increl-se inthe fie mui -mioud pivsstwo levels; bi tile Slalpes Of -tile noise stped r1u11 appnoxi-111ated 1110W o~etded ul to'ttie comipotielit tests at thle teswti'u ii Igure 7). t Was ullscmvd

    thatI til soun Sre ure cune ~hi Wasi iplorWIti to the ab.,olute 1noise level. i.e., tile in-ceaise iM sounld pressnie11 level was largest I'M lte noisiest coimponents and less 1"or thekqieiterOMMs I all cases; pool wreadigs wve~ higher thanl oplen watet' tvadings. so thle use of' pool no0iserea'iigS tir compitonent sclectionl is felt to be onl thle conlservative side.

    110

    tfl 90'RUrnr IISWIMMING PLrESULTS

    100

    0 40 60 120 160 200

    111d mvimmilig poo wMiII withi Kki five Re~et'Nir lvslllt.

    InI I 07t a salhi'ater lost pool was btlilt at thle NOSC' I lawaii Laboratory anld was thenlkused lor, t,1niherf acoutmic testinig. Flgin'e'S illustrat-s tile layout of, thle saltwater test pool.T'able I shiows i wlecmpnet wereo tested atWhich thcilty Only those C11ompoentls-lested !in the \;ttl mW Iility- simol i bo conipareil.

    Tihe coipon1wel ti ad lhdophlone were suspendved tImil cantileveved bealums anld sub-mulelrged l'adl'"a' tokte hot toi ofithe 110A. NO hoses or brackets touched thle sides or, bottom

    A h\aill- lom tst stand \xs use61 to SupJply i1vssure anld flow to tile muot1ors andt v'alvest1or testing I The test Stanld was equipped with pressure "ages to 1muonlitom' output allki return-liessims. a flowmnleti o m1onlitor, fow ito thle aliopoeln and valve," it Control Ou~tp~ut andrettun preswltui\ m 'nitmhw I hdalc i.Nl A[6y was used i the tests.

    SOUIJNIV lASURE~N I 11 UQ1llNtUNT

    Aeouistic imeasurunemx\ wure niado using a ('levite I lyvolhono. Model ('S-33 1 AAG(01YV), iihmi co'n'msts ot a_ IlA seisot' mnd -i ('A-A&A preamnjlifler assembly. Th'lis systemwos ca-libratedl b1V clevite -and hald a flat reponse of' -ff dB 2 Fi o rl nce I voliiwba'. Tlhehlydrim~lone system IN-p owred by a I 2-volt battery,

    __A

  • -M-

    \~~e I v ----

    HIM

    1-11 __ MA WR I

    MIN

    MbI'4l SV4 AO

    Irm"ilihv k V4 ~l~ _______

    wI~ _______

    F 1 wholI

  • To Convert from thIe scop~e readJing tot the taunardi unIi ts of' (13//'11icrollascaI/I Iz/yd(.thec following, relationship was used: di131 1 pl'a/ I I1141 yd =scope reading + 148.2. This rela-tionshap is deri Nd ams follows: the scoperedjgiin(l uliwtdtm)whhisefeds10 logS 100 V. .1he1 following equation is ulsed to convert scope reading to 113 v'olts (A llv):

    (1l311 10 log 1000 Where R SO0 ohm11s

    ME 10 og 1- \1

    -10 (Iog 20 +f 2 lot, \')

    -13 20 log,

    -13 + d113v whler'e d11v =20 log- V

    thefore: dl11v (1i111 - ISI

    scope on'd ilg I 1

    A scain bandwidth (11W) of 300 IN was used. To convert to a I-li1z 13W, 10 log 13W mu11st be

    -~ subtracted f rom thie scope readings. Therefore:

    di/1 It? (Illm - 13 - 10 lo- l3W~

    (I ll - IS 10 to,, 300

    (Iill) - 1- 24.8

    Th20 spectril anlve hs Soisut -eimr an - -l the hydrophone amuiphflier. is -

    it ~ dllmu --31.8

    -113m - '7.

    d~n-3.

  • --A-

    [ 95 IT14YDROPHONE

    ki -5 YARDS

    COMPONENT

    TEST POOL 10 FT

    DEPTH - 15 FT

    PiicS. NQSC saltwater test pool b~ytit.

    The hydropholue Output is fed initoa Hiewlett-Paickard 141ITSpectrum Analtyzer. ASimplified Schema~tic is ShIowil ill figm- 9.

    HYDROP14ONE SPECTRIUM ANALYZER~

    14

  • Ilydrophlle sensitivity miust be subtracted to get thle act sound plitur levels at thehydrophone. Thercio-re:

    Mini + 34.1

    To determine the sound pressuire levels at onle vard spacingi, a1 Correction fm:o. 0lg )mutst be added to accounit for thle spreading loss. Thle absorption loss for five yrspaincinge isne~gligible and was not considered. Th'lerefore. wihere lydrophione "pacing 1) 5 Yards.

    it1Il mierobar/q llz~l vd = dlti 34,-2 + -20 log 5

    =dlim 34.' + 14

    _____ = ll + 48:2

    A ieola al is MqlaettoIO microbar. So. inl H1. the .Cro ref'erence onl the miicrobar

    scae is equivalent to 100 -B onl thle microllaslscaeTeeoe

    dB" 1 iiroacl I 11 ard ill +48.2 + 100

    (dBm+ 148.2

    Whlen tranlsposing thle acoustic Curves f'rom thle polaroid pictures to thle graphis 148.2 was_____added to the till scale.I

    COMPON ENTITESTS AND1 RIESU LTS

    The methods that wvere employed inl acoulstic testing of thle different componlents areI described in thle following paragraphis.___ RELIEF VALVES

    'fhe relietf valves tested were set to opeli at 1000-psi differential pressure.1The valves_____were installed as sliown inl figure 10 and tested at Various flow rates. To deterinle thle effects,

    of higher ambienit pressures onl thle noise Output of hlydraullic Components, simullated lbighlamibienit pressure tests were run by inicreasing return tiine pressures wile mahnan al 1000-Psi differential pressure, across thle valves. Th~ree pressure relief valves were tested at variouls

    ____return linle pressures to determine the effects of thle hiigher pressures on ncise outpu11t.

    XEZ

    ______

  • HiYDR~AULICI E-, 7I AND

    FRELIEF VALVE~

    iliver 10. Test sceematic: relidlef is.

    Relief'vlv test results areC Shlown in graphs 13-lu Il rough U-5 10. B-001 I hroughB-604. G.-201I through G-208. and G-301 through G-304 in tile appicesfJi.

    1'Vickes rlict'valveo was lested at meurn line jIR ssues o01 '-M .0300. -400. 4M~and 500 psi. Acoustic data kgraphs 11-01 tlirout~ 13- 1 otapnd'\ A) show that bM in-evasing thle return1 tiine presmure fromi 0 to 215) psi. the low t'requency (0-40 ki lz) noise output

    wvas reducved considerably but thczi. was little etTect on thle higher T:AunLs lhiere W.1s notfurther reduction in lowv Imiequencv nioie output wvidh inlcivasing I~lvssure-s- however, (lhe niild=tange (40-kIlWz noise otpuit kleci-ae w~ %LIith inicivasing pressure uip to 400 psi. The h~igh fvcviCucy (I140-200 kliz) noise ouitpult dcrevscd whenl the 'mesillrC Was illneaed f'ronm ISO to450 p~si. There wvas no chiange in noise outplut with anl inicivase in pressure trii 450 to 500

    The Republic relief valve was tested with return line pressures Oo . 25S0. 500, anld 750psi. as seenl ill graphs, 134C thogh 13-4018 oftru -t' appendix A. The lowv fre-luency noise ouitpultdecreased With ineicasing pressure up to S00 psi: however. there was\ little Or no0 significanitChange inl noise outpult With anl illceiae it' return line ressure froim 500 to SO0 psi.

    to

  • The zteolustic datitn dicate t hat eavit~atioul n1oie wats prollblv nmdu e d or 0chin m1ated atpssures above 450 pisi. NI would also appewar that opcrat ionls at depthis below 1000 feet

    wvhetv amibient prevsxlsures preneter thau 4350 psi, WONt have much towevr noise levels thI tutu-per.16ons nearer. the sulrftee. All reiel' valves were tested at both 0- land W0-psi return precssuesto determuine their no0ise outpult at the surfitee and at delth.

    The results shlow inconlsislcies inl sonic of, th1elut es f'tI te--11(s[till under alapne lvid

    to dissolved gase-Sinl the hydraiuhie oil coming out sl ~ tio u nestite. 'With lesdissolved

    iases ttteiv Would be less gaseius Cavitation.- Foami \v.I" observed in the oji reset you' dut tugtesting evenl tltoiigd thle reset or oil level was sit iticiently hligh andk thle reset you. was iiouutedabove thle puulipl.

    The amtiount Oair dissolved inl thle (lil was, liko! 11msrd during thle tests, 'otuponeutlstested with sa;turated Oil may.1 appearl noisier thlt those tested Witli low gas con teut . *Tewe-t'ore, thle best Comparisons are Imade bierteen coipoteuls tini1 Wvere tested wiil 1500-psi ret0(untite pr~essure.,

    A Sanders frictiotial-hr-ottling Servo valve. nIodi'a lunber SVA 38-lOP., was ;ioustiveall- tested inl a rtief Valve Imode: ixe. it was. used to regulate pressurev by throttling ttile hydratulic

    oil flow Wilit i1o em r-euze load. 1t was eoupre ith (lie Vickens relief valve, model numberCT-i 0-C-.20 (trlenillt-thro")t lingV!) A comppaat ive c ahuit ion was conducted using dticeoit atnd oit tfrom Zil opn1 reservoir.

    The Sanlders servo valve anid file \icke-s relief vamtve test results are shiowvn ill graphlsS13-11( through W-3Qiid V3-101 through F 4 l 0 lin ap~petdix B, The test rsults show that-

    thle Satidersm frict iomaliirot t igvalve is much -puliett tOwn tile Viekmr turbilletit-thro tl tinl)vaive. The results, also suggqest flhtt degassed oi limKes litleI. if anyi,. ditferenice inl tle noise Ott-put Of thle Viekers V.-Ilve alt ile lower tiow nates, but reduces thle noise output b 1 approxi-nIately to kill at 20SZgptn.

    Tlhe 8Saniters seivo valve and tile Vickers relief, valve wet'e tesied at i-e111tuit le pressure1-sot'0 atid S00 psi. Acoustic data- tgutph11S t- 101 through (-i 0S o'appendNii Msho'v Owtl there

    us l~ri dcreseinl noise- oup t le Viekevs valve when back-pressuird to 500 I'm, *Ilhedata al.,o showv 1iti1 there is no decease ill noise out put oft tile Sanders \zalve wlvhimeck-

    prssreL The Viekers, Valve. whleni bick-piressured 1o 500 psi. is as inc ;1s file Sanlders valveat 5 gpim: howevero. tile Samders valve is v. pp31rox Ituatctv 10 kiI quieter -i tile higher flowv rates,

    With desigil ;ssistallu fromt lieluaid A. Mhilroy Of tby NSRDlC -\nnzpolis I-aboratorva loatite piesstiv relief vatve wa~s designed. fabricated. Muid aIcoustically ttd. Illetri:

    NSRDC tests. lRolimite valves hiad proved to bec Comtparatively quliet: tisl- Csl'erienee led toNOSC*s, interest inl thle 'tVeh for p otential usew inl sulimnribles. :\eeorditng to Mitroy (reice4). thre Rotamuite valve achieves quiet frict ional t irlot t hug with tiei of tile trobtle ils of :on-venilional des imls. suich as Close lllachilillig_ lcikarne. e'nteule fIll gn etc.

    4.~ ~ ~ ~~T 1ziliw -t , RI.Alf~Rlit aGte\~lvs". Naval Shill aes ik n De' topmlciit CCeitte:

    Report Nunibel .40IP Septembewr 10

    PA

  • IWT he fltti tona ii litottling Rohniu11tv Vailve NOS draw ~i ing iumhi DRlS-1000 ka ppentdix

    I' 11ises Collima te d I tole Structure tClIIS). nunut t1facured by. 111iii- tk Co( rztlttio as thle

    ll Rokuniite 'lve wa~s de-sigied .1", la pi to topeutled ilxalte e The p-lot Xsuige \%-I\Ieindit leRlnievle 1vvr the pilot st~ge kiltmilleii into tile Rl'thiiute housIngwi ot 0 used inl thle aieoust0i tests hekduse tit p'ool T~itrune he pressire w'ould (Wilhtt

    crew o ptie pressrre Cycled oThe jdtMg \-Ild lnA t:t11Ab dtsig iel~li

    the Control port atnd used ats .1 reilote pilot steI'ture II I. thle Kolaz;iii ah- 1 'il ethn peucdsteadily. The remloteo rveevalve was nlot sublmerged dnrnreli thle anstctest,\ ud it id nlotcontributte to tile acolltIe outplut otf fihe Rohmnulte valve-

    REFMOTE ~ I----

    HYDRAULICL..... ITEST

    STAN'D

    ROI AMITE~ VA\LVE

    -E-

    Pjili Il RA.1umute V1hVV test M i-mauzeiltieil

    GrapliI-(,O thIlough11 B-(104 in appentdix ll, show that the Rolamillte vaht, hNd itshlighest acoustic output at 10 gpi an11d was quieter at the lugli1er flow rates, This charactm istivmlay be title to thle arranlgemenlt ot' the Cl 15 tluotthing elements (appenidil 1)), As shownl inappendix 1). thl. two throttling elent ale separated IN\ .1 plenumi ring forminlga plenumilchamlrber Flow thr1ough tile eilments is regultd th-iotthbndsirceednti

    firt eemet. ot, flil~ me~te flow alva Of thle Wie 'id e0lement relmiuns "&thetsle I bcre-tore, thle plvssut'e drop, aeixls the seconld element Varnes prilportlolnallh with thle tlow, til

    4 ~highler thle flow, the greater thle l'ressuix' drop, lhe weonld ~'emn set'eetive at the lugherflto-w rates :iud not at tile low 1ritesz, I lim-ever. at Iigpn rthe eCenlent mlay not Ilm',enough ot'ect over the iucrc tubl ee to Keep the nloise level as low as it Is at 5 gpmt,

    119

  • C~rtph' i 111holigh G-204 tapelldix. ('Ocleati, sIhm 1that "he 1tolin~w valvC is1110 qw e -ea the --stir'acte than "tie NIICkers I'elierval 1 t nomnaI oper~ting vollltR'fS.

    is rw t\d III iheIJ \ ccNhdv.teut iet timls.I-ever. tile Rolamite \hv still

    1~ttfIt ~ 01th~x'i~t ~04 onviltdi\ C)~ Alow thatu the lRohmmne is poeid~1Xpliet111.111i Owe Sa'tkivsN \ ew vahi eaepitrt'vq%%eIIIe-s abo'wC 30 kdll (or the I 0-glpni flow

    nm,.111 aud th-v I A30 K1 4; al thle flow'i ravei's

    l'It livi=lt -. ilic 11,R)WIN \\V.", tc'tcd ait 'iriow\t po1mei- lewus to tmiubte the loadittigwractlofli\ et v WC subiom ettile INpilx11 11s't 10it\s To mnltct prolviic' loaditig \\111hout

    vilmItii thlo urSuati Pwr ettr 11111111e'c. I loil iiu~ tk ~A11111..11.1 dik ev I lid to' tile-- uo'v tt ti.iu-V 1 )- A tiietkoinetvi wolkh-ii" Imit \\ais dtw~ aiitla chd tio tile shaft t") III )tit,~

    \1,1 till,,p Semeuti i'sks twm iIivi diam etku \\ere ai'atialle. tI ch disk WZIN ewpenm-110-___ itt thh~itd to detet1i iw the tonjuee teqiiid to vt'mie it al t 1 -ien Ipnt whtile NzIIIered

    Mi Wavter th11 -pe t v \I Jimi cmv' ol 111 aMte'tiois %11-.k\ e -d it) select zi rl-olseler ini-____ tot' ttt~~ht \Vwutii wnt therw io-wkt tic toakiiit for ; ie wtr

    =k A N3A' 0

  • -~-~- -~ - ___i_

    -I/ I'400-

    0 AIDlA AM' 400'~ 'N otvi

    Tt MQUFjn kltl Ntd W

    AC 2'V ~A 01l;!

    4 MI

    hzu 1-1. 4- awk

  • 532iiliAR

    -ON<

    A\1; ilit Y''

    tU l Owl" ~ltu 111fl101N \\A,; -Nih Wl~.-'" M "1 'R 4 'l llw .' gv w

    ''' 4t- C _-- k

    0 '' Ii''t.. \lI1 Q l u vt ital M ..- Mill " n~ ~ ~ru' .

    M-ItO _ 't k! ho otlii --noM kI

  • GAGE RELIEF VALVE

    II

    ELEC

    SERVO VALVES

    111e 'Wno vaits. iv ivitially testvu 10- colilncing (lthi tn rol 'iS, toitv.aawon II illtvr 16. and connecting the 1UOM -ii '1tvupe acos tlis '~ih&lrlx fo

    thmmich tile rib" -' a i licd by vaivtc the electiCal sulpply vmlacIli. loOf test-(141di M0 . silui lt ' '111v :elia use Condit'lon' ii nlllntWsiR vi 'r tpe

    aIcross p1orts Ci and C, - 00pi at ea-ch port. II thle acuall system wlltile I WX '- s i tv dropiwould bec divided beten tile lw-draulic movtor alld the svo Val;dv tiht pmreu Irons ars

    catiwuld depend- onl the aniolult otr hlow '1-rough the valve to the llitor. I inc'nl -%\kiitest (tigure 1 1) te ontrol p'orts were "onucted tos a1 lidraiiC molktor Part of tilt

    fiw valve. Te mleasured- nloiNe outna i' iakenl as the comhtnied noist uitiut (it th' mnotorto load thle mlotor Withiout Creating the trb.1ince and thruts! idtt'rtiit inl .i rotiti :'ro-Cllcr.

  • __ HYDRAULIC

    STAND

    ~PWVALL

    I igutre I b. Tcs* s henuatz: w i 't'.11 cuii ~ pvzi~itt).

    = STANDI

    _ II

  • ResutlIts of thec servo Valve tests are shown inl graphis, 1-101 thirough E'-3 10 ol' appenidixA. Test results of servo valves and motors inl the final test configuration are shown inl graphisF- 10 1 I hrotigh F-41I3 of appendix A. In iIthis con figuration, the hIighest noise levels were pro-duced at low mlotor rpmII where tile Ilrgest pressure (11rop occurredl across thle ser-vo Valve. Whlenthle mlotor's were r-tin at thle ig~her speeds. mlore precssure was dropped across thle motors.reCsult61 il nIO~l nlornise oult pitts. The Olsen-WS I com bina tion u.

  • STe ivpv s ofI vivl'. tv t"I il-wuilild (lie I ,Iio\Vitt'-

    lW1P TYPlI' DISK~ A(lTNO X I WFIiGi

    00 1 crsv\ 10 u' 1110011 pi

    0 1111c pT1Av'i' I % k )AIsl

    I tlitwto II ~ Geav fi d- '0 oviu

    Volroi 'li ;uv "Ikl II mag ;jlts D1I01 flttx'ugh 114 04 oh~tl'~'ttdi\ A\ 1 ho 1) 1~ avaI pump\V;~IN !IV~ '11iiil't\1 plt " Ix'd I Iowx 'T it ha~d high fillema ulekagltv Mid It Wits am 1it10 hcdvi-

    SO'1 v tpitle! I'tvb livs hich Iv.' ;t txwh illhi ioifica I;idmi \wkn 'IdIiltik otsl.lkoe.fl

    Fine Ratcuto pwl'l wav, otigtwtlkv hWmok "III\ to ow'ltimtte I htype ol PItIl. a pI'tVNittV~~tt.ttiI.\ ~t tt I-diq'hcc'~tt d~gti I t'ik i~ ucii WWO ;W01 ui pt il am' h\l'j

    Illo l'l M I ti011 vak n tj.~ ile itii tV no tisle 1tile 11111111'lvuillot ofi lieg~ Iwict i~

    Atxis 1 lvdvo'tav Itt tltt. mutdei -I 11 -20k Illtium tactiltvd h~ I tat tImun (1 oip01at txlli ako~ wt'Ntic;11v I'~sikI. *flti\ plumpl \VayS dilV~xM-koui'iid Uo a 1-50- p1110 a cititti d mli

    illt ile oitI1-1il Ilolx vm1tttt oClitaie.IdU hi tes \wdiX kolndu\ieWI int 11 Q '- 5 ot I "le NO)sk\dIliwhk tes vol. Graix~i 1)-SIl ith volt I D-51 'loiv I IlaI thie lholdiastpuntp 11111 IS ntdtd101

    *at a 50 Ofsi Ioakd. andI tl'isie\(Ilk loa~d W JIM

    -~~ I. t api (, -401 shoiv\ tha~t t'e \.i iN ~i'lt is qtidtdt t liallti lel It 111111 mm 1'1 toI20 k~t;. ah~w 0ki o 17 tile Hv mmdatl, i.111n i'- 111idor

    ~ v~ip-it 1 =5t) i that thei tRacinl '1uz'1'i all' vultntp is "iuldtmi' t hanl th lI 1 tvt iamai

    w-s

  • Afte h.instalat ion mid cheockouit. thie Vehicle was a1coust icallv tested with i he hydrllo-photl. mon ted Oltile I'r-ont o1 tile foaml pack wvhere hle Vehicle Search sonlar (VSS) ltit nlate- -l'y Would Ile moun11ted. T'estinug wsdone i Kaneoihe 13ay Yandli sea level mea suremen ts wvei'eI-eeoI'(ld. Tlo simullate, I000\-f',ot depth1 oporat ions, thie hlydraulic systeml W.I. pzIVNssriedl toi00 psi, CTe Ivsuilts arel shown i figuire 18.

    Since I)7,whel thie hydraulic contponentls wvere selected. Comiponent acoustic testshave eonfi t ted. Betcause ol' thie lie\\- 0SIA regutla lions onl noise in (lhe working envfiionmenihd muilic colipoticn~itttt tatiiti have beeni expe.nding greatler' e thrt s ill desin g quitie terhy'dratilte. conipoticti ts. Qute t hlydraulfics developmniet has also been cont iki tug at Navylabora tories,

    (Conmponenit acoulstic tests have conit jutted oniull and vaves which wvere tile uIkor.nloise produtcers. C'ommercial pumpils adivertlised by thie mlann lt rersvI to be quiet Ww teted.as were valves inlcorporating quiet throltlin techniques. As aI tesult of' these continuinig tesaI nlew\ SUIlen I taeModel Racdie j'tttn has been selected to ieplace thle Vic kors van1e pumpill

    -= VS3 PASSIVE

    A ~ ~ ~ ~ E LTAL'V CIIC

    00

    .::0

    Z1.1

  • CONCLUSIONS

    There are sever.l m.Jnisms ol noise g~eneration in hb draulic si'stems. The malormechanisnis are cavitation, machinery and Iflid f'low.

    In hydraulic compo cuts and systems of' which noise was not a design consideration.cavitation could be thle most serious noise source. Cavitation occurs when, at sOlle point illthe system, the local pressure is less than tile vapor pressure or the hydrauilic fluid and bubbles-ire formed. This can occur in areas of high~ velocity flow and intese turbulence. Then, at a1

    - point downstream, thle pressure rises above the vapor pressure and thie bubble collapses(implodes) producing broad banld noise extendig from the audible into the inaudible fre-

    By maintaining thle pressure throuighout thle s'ysteml at a level hgh enlough that even inareas of' intense turbulence the local preisure dtoes not drop below the vapor pressure of thlefluid, cavit'ation would be eliminated, The components tested1 showed a reduction in noiseoutput when return line pressuires were maintained above 450 psi. This is the condition of'suibmersible, hydraulic systems that have reservoirs compensated to amibient pressure in thedeep ocean. It may also be accomplished with a closed system with a sualed reservoir pressur-ized to 450 psi.

    Hydraulic components are being dlesigned and produiced without a tendency for cavi-zt tation. Sharp-edged orifice valves are highly susceptible to cavitation because of the high fluid

    velocities and turbulence onl the exit side of' the orifice. Several throttling techniquesusing" small-cross-sectionl multiple path~s are presently employed by manufacturers makingquiet throttling valves. These techiniques keep flow velocities and turbulence at levels Which(d0 not produce cavit Jion.

    A

    --

  • -- Hi

    REFERENCES

    1. Marrone, R. A., J. Held, and R. W. Uhrich. "Manipulator. Grabber and Tools for theRUWS Work Subsysten', NUC TN 818, Volume 2. November 1972.*

    2. Volberg, H. W., "Specifications for Vehicle Search Sonar (VSS) Equipment", NUCHawaii Laboratory, Code 653 1, De.ember 197 1.

    3. Volberg, H. W., "Specification for -ong Range Tracking Sonar (LRTS) and Altimeter *Equipment for the Remote Unmanned Work System", NUC Hawaii Laboratory, Code

    6531, February 1972.

    4. Milroy, R.A., "ROLAMITE Rolling-Gate Valves", Naval Ship Research and DevelopmentCenter Report Number 4407, September 1974.

    *TNs ire informal documents intended chiefly for internal use.

    S-

  • APPENDIX A

    TEST DATA OF FIRST TEST SERIES

    GRAPHS

    This appendix presents the results of the first series of acoustic tests, depicted byno0ise profile graphs for each of the componients and specitfied test conditions. The decibelScales for all graphis have a reerence of I microllascal per hiertz per yard (dl3/hd'af!ll;,vd).

    1-1

  • -TT80 -- -- - -

    dB 70 - - - - - -

    - 50-

    40- F30 - - - -- -- - -- - -0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (k~z) Frequency (kHz)

    ELECTRIC MOTOR - GENERAL ELECTRIC ELECTRIC MOTOR - PACEMAKERMOTOR SPEED - 1750 RPM MOTOR SPEED - 3450 RPM

    A-101 A-102

    'oi

  • 1201130 i -s100-

    70--

    60 -i i0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz) I

    RELIEF VALVE - FLUID CONTROLS 1A-32 RELIEF VALVE - FLUID CONTROLS IA-32INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSIRETUR3N PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSIFLOW TOVAL.VE- 5 GPM FLOW TO VALVE ~ 10GPM

    6-101 B-102

    110

    dB 90

    -_ -- - _ _ _ U50 I_ - .i-j I i i - I

    0 40 80 120 160 200o 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RELIEF .'ALVE - FLUID CONTROLS A-32 RELIEF VALVE FLUID CONTROLS I A-32 - °

    INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE 1 000 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 15 GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 20 GPM

    8-103 B-I14ZI

    31

  • 130-

    120 --

    110

    100 =I=*1= i

    -~-4

    70-4---I- --- h-

    60-----_ LH zz50 ~----

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RELIEF VALVE -FLUID CONTROLS IAR-41 RELIEF VALVE - FLUID CONTROLS IAR-41INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PsiRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 5 GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 10 GPM

    U-201 B-202

    408110 1600

    INE1RESR0100S

    REUB PRSUE0 S

    FLWTOVLE05P

    I7

    60_

  • _ _ _ -1308. 90 - - _ t - j

    __0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200__Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RELIEF VALVE -FLUID CONTROLS 1AR-41 RELIEF VALVE -FLUID CONTROLS 1AR-41INLET PRESSURE~ 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURE- 1500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 5 GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 10 GPM

    8-204 B-205

    130- ~ -- -- -

    110-- - -e-I IN I j __ I F.-__

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 480 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RELIEF VALVE -FLUID CONTROLS 1AR-41 RELIEF VALVE -FLUID CONTROLS 1AR-41INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI -

    -- FLOW TO VALVE- 15 GPM F LOW TO VALVE- 20OGPMh3-206 8-207

    Im33=

  • 12042 iiiiiii4- 110 1

    100 jIdB 90 --4

    I i I

    50 I rim0 40 80 120 160 2000 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RELIEF VALVE - VICKERS RELIEF VALVE - VICKERSINLET PRESSURE 100 PSi INLET PRESSURE 1250 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 250 PSI

    FLOW TO VALVE - G0 PM FLOW TO VALVE - 20 GPM8=301 8-302

    130 11 iTh T I1

    44A1 444-I110 i -

    804

    60 i !t - _0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RELIEF VALVE - VICKERS RELIEF VALVE - VICKEPSINLET PRESSURE - 1300 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1350 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 300 PSi RETURN PRESSURE 350 PSIPLuW TO VALVE 20 GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 2GPMB-8304 i

    14

  • I

    !11 ~ il ,°I I I I i l !- i I 1 1i20 .. .. . Ii i I i ' I

    o , o Ii ___ - 1 I - - -I

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    = RELIEF VALVE - VICKERS RELIEF VALVE ViCKEIRSINLET PRESSURE - 1400 PSI INLET PRESSURE 1 450 PSiRE'uRN PRESSUiRE = 400 PSI REITULRN PRESSURE - 450 PSI-. 0W 10 VALVE 20 OPN' F LOW TO VALVE=- 200 PM

    i8.,205 82 00

    i20 --iF .. J - IL I_

    1004- -

    idB 90 f-

    80-60 - . .so ,i.

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0Frequency (kHz) F (kz

    - RELIEF VALVE = ViCKERSINLET PRESSURE = 1400 PSI I- P -RETURN PRESSURE- 4GO PSI 45-FS-FLOW TO VALVE 20GPMO F L T

    130

    120I

    110=1003

    dB 90 tTh

  • 130

    120

    110 'I

    '

    60

    i fso

    0 40 ~ ~ 120 160 200 o 408 2 6 0

    Fre ue cy (k~ )Frequency kliz)20

    RELIEF VALVE VICCEjqSINLET PR-ESsURERETURN PRESSIRE 100LIPs

    VALVE VCKE- SF Lo-W TO VALVE S 0 PsiR

    RETUN PR~uns1000 ps ILOVTOVAL0 PIsiP

    0o%"__ 130

    120

    110-100

    80

    70

    0 40~ 8 120 1602 0 041 0 2 0

    Frequency (kizt;0 4Frequency (kiz)RELIEF VALV, E- ICKERSV

    C

    E r U- R N P R E 5 . . 1 0 0 0 P S IP R ~ j 0 0

    F I-o y O VALVE ~ 5 GPILO~ V L E -RS-

    L 0 V-A0 Psi

    -16

  • 130-riIII--- 1 __ 1

    110III I-

    80 I II

    50 LLIIL0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Freuency (kHz)

    =RELIEF VALVE - VICKERS RELIEF VALVE - VICKERSINLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 15C00 PS IRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIF FLOWTO0 VALVE - 5 GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 106PM.j

    - ~~130 ~z r '-----dBi--- -3

    Iw IY I

    dB 01.-~ ~*---

    0 40 80- 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) F reqta-jcy (kHz) -

    R fELEF.Ln .-AC -KERS R EL'Et VA LVE -VZ C KE ..INILET PRESSURE - 1500o PSI 'INLET PRESSURE - 15003 v15RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIFLOWTOVALVV- 156GPM- FLOWVTO VALVE - 20GPM

    B-314 8-315

    IM1!

  • W i ,

    1 3 0 .. . ... .....120 -I- --

    100

    dB 90 _--

    50 L-__0 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz|

    -hLIUF VALV6 REPUBLIC RG70 RELIEF VALVE - RIPUBLIC RGi0ILiPRESSURE 1000 flni INLLT PRESSURE - 1000 PSIRETURN PRFESSURE -= 0 p RETURN P'RESSURE - 0 PSI

    FLOW TO VALVE - GPM i LOW TO VALVE - 10 p1'_i401 0 (; 111vt

    12: -T

    100 'i _~~~dB 90EI _- E

    80, TU E R P

    70 -- -----50 -

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200j ~~~Frequency (kHz)Frqec(kz

    RELIEF VALVE -REPUBLIC RG7O EIrVLE- E0LCR7INLT RESUR 100 SIINLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI

    RETURN PRESS, qc- 0 PSI '1ETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSIf FLOW TO VALVE - 15 GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 20 GPM13,403 -11404

    IM

    38

  • 120 m ...... - ..... .

    in

    ~i;I

    A; 70 ~-

    120 10 10 0

    707L50 I--0 80 120 160 200 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)E Q RELIEF VALVE REPUBLIC tG010 RELIEF VALVE - REPUBLIC RG70INLET PRESSU.RE 1 (0 PSI INLET PRESSURE- - 1250 PSIRETURN PRESSURE 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 250 PSI

    FLOW TO VALVE - 10 GPM FLOW TO VAI.VE - 10 GPMB-406 1-406

    130 'I:~120 -I - - j

    -i ~110. .. ',100 - -- - - - - _--'--

    d l 90- _- 80 fi_i Ii I ,.i

    60 1 =- F-- - -= - - 2 _50 . .- -

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RELIEF VALVE -REPUBLIC RG70 REL!EF VALVE - REPUBLIC RG7OINLET PRESSURE - 1500PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1750 PSIRETURN PRESSURE 6 00 PSI RETURN PRESSURE 750 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 10 G'PM FLOW TO VALVE - 10 GPM

    1.-407 0.408

    -- -i _-- = --~ I -

  • 501dB 70

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kd-z)

    A~E -r- VALVE - CIRCLE SEALPI10-17I3 RELIEF VALVE CIRCGLE SEAL 140,776INLET PIIES$SUIIEC - 10001,81 INLET PRESSURtE - iO t 00'sIRETUIAN PREISSMlE - il ItUNiIES~P~j SrLOW TO VALVE 9 GP0IM F LOW TO VALVE - GlPM

    110

    100

    90 i j80-

    dB 70- -t_ -

    60j

    40

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200-~Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RIELIEF VALVE CIRC~LE SEAL 111-0-7 i llrELIEF VALVE- G11OLE SEALPI'0-776INL" t SU~E - 100 ISIINLE7 I'llUSSUIM. 1-500 1181

    nt-TUIIN PF L'sSurl - 1100 P'SI RETURtN IESSUJE- W-0 s

    F LOW TO VA\LV~E - 9) GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 9 PM

    40

  • 110

    dB 70TV L z60 -

    50 -- =-=j--40 L30 ~I~-L-

    0 40 80 120 160 2000o 40 s0 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) F-requency (kHz)

    HILLIEF VALVE - CIRCLE SEAL Pt0-776 RELIEF VALVE - CIRCLE SEAL P10.776INLET PPESSURE 500 P'SI INLET PnESSURE 500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 9 GPlm FLOW TO VALVE 13I GPM

    f 11.000 01-0"

    1001

    90

    80

    dB 701

    50 j -40 Ij~30 v1 IIILiLi

    *0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 16^0 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    RELIEF VALVE - CIRCLE SEAL P10-776 RELIEF VALVL - CRCLE SEAL P101-776( AINLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET I'RI!SURE 1 0 I aiS

    RETURN PRESSURE- 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE -000 P~SIFLOW 10 VALVE - 1I GIPM FLOW 10 VALVE I 18PM

    41J

  • 1-10 - - - - -1r

    100-

    80_

    dB 70-----

    60-

    40----- - --

    1 ~30--8 LL l -0 RE0E 80qunc 120z 160 200 0 40 80 10 60 200

    REL VALVE -l CRCLE SEAL P 10.776 RELIEF VALVE - CIRCLE SEAL Pi0.776INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE -500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE -1000 PSIFLOW '10 VALVE 18 OpM FLOW TO VALVE - 18 GPM

    B-509 .1

    42

  • 130 -I tI

    120-- -_

    110- --

    90

    80-

    60

    50 - -- - - - -- - --0- 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200 4

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)t

    MOTOR CHAR-LYNN MOTOR -CHAR-LYNNIMOTOR RPM - 300 RPM MO0TOR RPM -600 RPM1DISK DIAMETER - 22.625 IN DISK DIAMETER - 22.6215 IN

    TESTED AT KU TnRE RESERVOIR TESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOIRC401 C-102

    En,

  • 120 ....

    I z -k 'T ,= -100 *~*

    80 - ___ _ __ _

    070160 ,

    500 40 go 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200A

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR - LAMINA MOTOR LAMINA

    MOTOR RPM - 300 RPM MOTOR RPM - 450 RPM

    DISK DIAMETER - 22,625 IN DISK DIAMETER - 22.625 INTESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOIR TESTE0 AT KU TREE RESERVOIRC201 C-202

    130 TfT .

    1101

    100 4 9

    d8 90

    80

    70

    I I70 -[-- -

    0 40 80 20 160 200Frequency (kIz)

    MOTOR - LAMINAMOTOR RPM - 600 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 22.625 INTESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOIR t

    C-20__

  • 130 -j~~-----

    120 -,- F I__ i i . ___ i

    _,_- I_ _ i100 J 1 _ ...50

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR -PLANET MOTOR -PLANETMOTOR RPM 300 RPM MOTOIl RPM - 450 RPMDISK DIAME fER 2 .625 IN DISK DIAMETER -- 21625 INTESTED AT LI TREE RESERVIIOR TESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOIR

    C-301 C302

    I J I . i _ -

    Jj i50 I

    110

    dB 90 LY+95Xfzz~~i~~+

    60 4

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency ,KHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR - PLANET MOTOR - PLANETMOTOR RPM - 600 RPM MOTOR RPM - 900 RPMDISK DIAMETER 224265 IN DISK DIAMETER 2-. 5 INTESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOIR TESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOIR

    C-303 C-304

    45 ---

    =m

  • 10

    dB 90 I _I

    70 1 1_

    60150szzo. z .-

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR -WSI MOTOR - WSIMOTOR RPM - 300 RPM MOTOR -45-0 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 21625 IN DISK DIAMETER - 11615 INTESTED AT kU TREE RESERVOIR TESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOtiR

    C-401 CA02

    130 -

    120111

    - dB 90 1I-~~ 80 1 t

    70_

    60

    50 _ -___ - -- -

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR -WSI MOTOR V-SMOTOR RPM -600 RPM MOTOR RPM -90w RpmDISK DIAMETER - 2225I DISK DIAMETER - 22625 INTESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOIR TESTED AT KU TREE RESERVOIS

    C-403 C-404

    46

  • 100 --- al1

    60 - - - 4 --50

    'Nair:-------

    30- iLi0 40 80 120~ 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR - WSI MOTOR - WS IINLET PRESSURE~ - 100PSI INLET PRESSURE - 300 PSIRETURN PRESSURE 0 S RETURN PRESSURE - 100 PSIF LOW TO MOTOR - 1 GPM FLOW TO MOTOR - 5 GPMSHAFT RPM - 200 RPM SHAFT RPM - 30RPMTORQUE PRODUCED - 0INL TORQUE PRODUCED 10INLDISK DIAMETER - 24 IN DISK DIAMETER - 24 IN

    C-105 C406

    110I 1 1 1

    10011 1 -- '- I ' ' I --80 11_ _I

    d8 70

    60- i -

    50 -

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz'

    MOTOR -WSI MOTOR - WSIINLET PRESSURE - 500 PSI INLET PRESSURE - Boo PSIRETURN PRESSURE -150 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 150 PSIFLOWTO MOTOR - 7,1 GPM FLOW TO MOTOR IOGPMSHAFT RPM - 450 RPM SHAFT RPM -600 RPMTORQUE PRODUCED- 220 IN-LB TORQUE PRODUCED- 400 IN-LBDISK DIAMETER - 24 IN DISK. DIAMETER - 24 IN

    C-407 C-408

    ____ 711 7

  • I1 7"

    EE

    A

    dB 70

    0 0- 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR -WSIINLET PRESSURE - S00 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - I50 PsiFLOW TO MOTOR - 5 GPMSHAFT RPM - 300 RPMTORQUE PRODUCED - 200 IN.LBDISK DIAMETER - 28 IN

    CA09

    wi

    48 W

  • ____ 110 - - - - I -r

    I ! I

    - dJB 70 1-_

    60

    50--

    40-j-jl i z0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR - WS1 MOTOR %%'31IN'LET PRESSURE - ZSo PSI INLET PRESSURE - 7950 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 12-5 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 175 PSIFLOW TO MOTOR - 2.5 GPM F Low TO MOTOR - 5 GPMSHAFT RPM - I50 RPM SHAFT RM-0 RPTORQUE PRODUCED- 100 iN LB TORQUE PRODUCED- 4~IN-BDISK DIAMETER 37,875 IN DISK DIA16ETER - 32$7 IN

    C-41 0 C.411

    - ~~110 - -i 1 I I- - i 1 1- ~~100--==--1---' _I __ _

    90 ~

    80 - =I_

    dB8 70___

    If L _04

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (ki-z)

    t.;~OTOR -WSI MOTOR - WSIINLET PRESSURE - Soo PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1 owlPSIRETURN PRESSURE - 125 PS I RETURN PRESSURE - 125 PSIFLOW TO MOTOR - 5A6 GPM FLOW TO MOTOR - 6-5GSHAFT r-PM - 324 RPM SHAFT RPM - 342RPTORQUE PRODUCED - 420 I N-LB TORQUE PRODUCED - 510 IN-LB _DISK DIAMETER - 32875 IN DISK DIAMETER -- 32 vs5 IN

    C-412 C413

    49

  • F ~110 __IIII 711ih'i90- 4-t

    dB 70 ___

    50 N-:

    30 L jill Ii~I0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)IMOTOR - WSI MOTOR -WSI

    INLET PRESSURE - 400 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 600 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 125 PSI RETUIAV PRESSURE =125 PSIFLOW TO MOTOR - 2.5 GPM FLOW TO MOTOR - 3R. GPMSHAFT RPM - ISO RPIM SHAFT RPM - 210 RPMTORQUE PRODUCED - 220 IN-LB TORQUE PRODUCED - 20 IN-LBDISK DIAMETER - -55 IN DISK DIAMETER - 25.75 IN

    C-414 C-415

    110- 11 I - 1100 ---90 1

    dB 70

    -60-1 _ _I

    iI J

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR - WSI MOTOR W VSIINLET PRESSURE - 850 PSI INLET PRES SURE - 110OPSIRETURN PRESSURE - 125 PSI RETURt.PRESSURE - 125 PSI-iFLOW 1O MOTOR - 4S6MFLOW TO MOTOR - SGPMSHAFT RPM - 260 RPM SHAFT nPM - 300 RPMTORSQUE PRODUCED -510 IN-LB TRU RDCD-60I-lDISK DIAMETER - -355IN DISK DIAMETER - 35175 IN

    C-416 C417:

    -So

  • I ,___,j --r-i--iiij,-1101

    i ~~90i i i I

    80 i1 i1

    dB 70

    60-- '

    i I j Ii i ' - 'I '''S] I t i ,

    ISO

    40iIl ii i I A30 , i•-300 40 80 120 Wi A&20 6 AO B 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequewy ikHz)

    MOTOR - NUTRON MtOTOR - NUTRONINLET PRESSURE - i CaST PRESSURE - soc ni

    r c-501 -0

    'i V II ! I i , Ii~~~ I, -

    - ,i i+, --" PS I

    RETURN ~ ~ ~ !RSSR -i 7, i I- Tv -U R_'%.SUR :-l S

    80 12010 0 0 0 8 2 10 20I

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    MOTOR -NUITRON_ MOTOR -NUTRON -INLET ?PRESSURE - 850 PSI INLET PRE-SSURE - 1160 PSi -_RETURN PRESSURE - 150 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 150 PSI---FLOW TO MOTOR- 430PM FLOW TO MOTOR - 3 GFM

    SH AFT R1PM - 492 RPM SHAFT RPM - 52 RPML

    Jfl2* EPRODUCED - 200 IN-1B TORQUE PRODUCED- 390 iN-LBDISK DIAMETER - 24 IN DISK DIAMETER - 24 IN

    C-503 VC50

    ALI55I

    40.

    0 40 8 2 6 0 0 s 2 6 0

  • - ~100 - _ _

    90r80 1

    d B 70

    60 - -50

    40 _

    30-I___0 40 80 120 160 200

    Freq~uency (kHz)

    MOTOi: NUTRONINLET PRESSURE - 1300 PSI

    ___ RETURN PRESSURE - 150 PSI-~FLOW TO MOTOR - 6k GPlM

    SHAFT RPM - 600 RPMTORQUE PRODUCED - 400 IN-LBDISK DIAMETER - 24 IN

    C-505

  • 110 - - - -- __

    no frn

    I -

    40_1I

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    PUMP -VIK~l Vth O 113brml icugv-01-OUP ti'UT P~I1 oLi E 00vs PU T Ptl#KWffilODUTPUT FI.O o - AKAM lN Lt VPPF - -S

    DAV COvoPL - t MAUNI Mi I-P 1u -- IS -\ 1

    UAWIf _ IV 1'.LNU- L UN fitl tdB71 707_

    _

    50 1__ ~40 ___

    30 -- _ _ t I I_0 40 80 120 M6 200 0 4- 0 120 160 .00

    PI M 3 hr A-EI 1 j P U M Pi 0U F U W L IM 01oi ilr ftO 24 u is& Or~u ~~WI)0

    U431V de ~ MOMOr3 SOO to I1p Il~vI \lij t-of, '-U imn tj 0~I U1',\01rSIVE %IJPI IA ul - UAN Ouitc I- -WV umt PI~ rN ~ 0ij Oll 11tiiv-jUIr. AIECOP E N fm

    W! -0 IT:r n

  • 10

    I 0

    __~ ~~1 L-- - = 4 ---- f

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    OUPT )ts4sh- -01 P - 1~ - OUPU PhlS.cn I- __w80 lvi MOI I OORO 130n I I IVE"mop emlr

    0

    40 1 110 40 s0 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Ftequoncy (kHt) -

    PUMP -AN SM PUMANE PUM NGI t~ \i.E UIVAOUTPUT PntC-S!,Ufit- Io 1PS011I3 OWUll '~~~: ~)I~OUTPUT F LOW 10 GPM ol IT 1 r=LOW -I a G im

    11IV Moroit ItTII: mo'o a wbo iti'm 0111I:t &IMroVl -Gt m'titi OpW -1 '6 AbiVE COU0UUM, -- DRIN OfiltuCr 0m UVEiv 0 OUPI INut 01Lt~IN uliil.T DitiV

    0-401

  • 820

    610

    0

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kt-z)

    =SERVO VALVE -MOOG 74 SERVO VALVE - MOOG 74INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI

    -- CllC12 PRSUE= 50PICI/C2 PRESSURE - 500 PSI-RETURN PRESSURE 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI

    FLOW TO VALVE 1 V8 GPM FLOW TO VALVE- 410 PM- -E-101 E-102

    110 -- _4_100- -

    dB 90

    50 z~ j0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200 - -

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE - MOOG 74 SERVO VALVE - MOOG 74INLET PRESSURE 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSICl1C2 PRESSURE So50 PSI Cl1C2 PRESSURE = 500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE = 0 P.11FLOW TO VALVE - 7.2 GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 7.4GPM

    E-103 E-104

  • 130-

    -120 _ _ 1 ' '110 .

    70 - ... .....

    60

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE - MOOG 74 SERVO 'ALVE - MOOG 74INLET PRESSURE 1250 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSICtIC 2 PRESSURE- 750 PSI CItC2 PRESSURE - 1000 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 250 PSI RETURN PRESSURE 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 4 GPM FLOW TO VALVE- oGPM

    E.105 E,406

    ~~130 - l- -- -

    : 120

    I I1 1 0 0 16

    IEV P -V OG7 EV AV MOO 74

    IlC RSUE 10 S I1C HRSURi 00 S

    0ET40 80E 120R160 00 0 40 TUR 120SUR 10 200 I

    SERV O VLVE = 3,OG 74 SERVO VLVE OO 7 GM--=--

    INLE 1-RSSUR- 100 ISI ILET RESURE 160all

    5016

    SEV VAV =OG7 EV AV OG7INLE PRESUR - -60S INLE PRESUR -Isoo-=- -

  • Ii110-

    i00 - i n -100 _ ___p

    9 0 - __--80 __l~ I __ I If' _,.-_..dB 70- ~H~i°oI i__ -

    * ~60- ~--I I '= I

    50I I I -

    40 ~ I ~ 44==-

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE -MOOG 74 SERVO VALVE - MOOG 74INLET PRESSURE 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSICl.lC2 PRESSURE - 1000 PSI CliC 2 PRESSURE 1000 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 7.5 GPh FLOW TO VALVE - 76 GPM

    .109 E-1 10

    A_

    4

    A

    7 1

    ZI

  • 130----~

    io -I /

    dB -90 -

    80-70 ' j

    50

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 2VC

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE - MOOG 35 SERVO VALVE - MOOG 35INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSIC1lC2 PRESSURE - 500 PSI C11C2 PRESSURE - 500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 4 GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 6 GPM

    E-201 E-202

    --110

    80 _jI-

    -- , 70 . . .,

    -_N 60

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE - MOOG 35 SERVO VALVE - MOOG 35INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSIC/C 2 PRESSURE - 500 PSI C/C 2 PRESSURE - 1000 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - P GPM FLOW TO VALVE - 4 GPM

    E-203 E-204

    58=-- - _t =_ 8_ --- . ....

  • d7- - - - - -- - -

    0 40 8M2 6 0 0 8 2 6 0

    Fr8ec0k~)Feunc k-z

    0 0 0 20 16E000 40 8 20 1060

    IN00 PRSSR - 50PIILTRES - 10 SC110z -RSUE- 10 S lC HSUE- 10 SRETUR PRESURE- 50 PIREUNP SUE- 50PI

    80 40 8 12 16 20 1Frdunc 70~

    60gSEV5A0E-MOG3

    FLO TO VALV 12 10 20

    euenc (kiz

    SERVOVALV - MOG-3INLETPRESURE 1 So PS

    59 3

  • 90- F~-_dB 70 - - --

    60 --- ~.A- ~50 ----- i~

    40- - ~ -- f- i- e-=0- 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE - OLSEN SERVO VALVE =OLSENINLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE 1000 PSICI1C2 PRESSURE - S00 PSI C11C2 PRESSURE 500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSUR 0PiFLOW TO VALVE - 0OGPM FLWOVL E 0 4PI

    E-301 E-302

    1101

    1001

    dB 70-- ~ f--

    40 -L0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE - OLSEN SERVO VALVE OLSEN=INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1000l PSi I_Cl' 2 PRESSURE - 500 PSI c11c2 PFE-SSURE Soo PS_:

    =RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSIFL.OW TO VALVE - I GPM FLOW TO VALVE- 4 GPNE-303 E-004

    60

  • 120 -- _-fil i_ 5 0 - - ---- -_ _

    .o 40 8 10 10 00 0 8 120.16 200

    110 -_

    FF n

    SROLVE- LSE SRV VLV - OLSEN1NE0E0R-ZOOS NEPESUE 00S

    °NJ a l' ~

    C11C2 PRESSURE - 500 PSI C11C2 PRESSURE - 500 PSiRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSi RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSi--:

    FLOW TO VALVE - 6 GPM FLOW TO VALVE- 7 GPM 7'-13 -- E.305 E-306-@

    S12 -- ] H--110-

    8070

    :- 50

    0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE - OLSENINLET PRESSURE 1500 PSiCl1C2 PRESSURE - 1000 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - S00 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 6S GPM

    E-307

    63

  • 130 -~~~ ~

    110- - - I - - - - -dB 100-17

    ----

    A& 90 - - -80- t-- -

    70-

    60-"=0- 40 -80 120 160 200 40- 80 120 160 200

    F Ftqency (kHz) Fre-quency (kiz)

    SERVO VALVF -OLSEN SEV -AVE - OLSEN

    INLET PRL SUE- 1500 Psi INLET PRESSURE IS1O0 Psi

    CjpC2 PRESSURE - 1000 PSI C1 C RSUE 0- SRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE- 4 GPM FLOW TO VALV- GPM

    130 -

    120--

    1dB 9 0---

    70 - - - - --

    60

    SoI~~-0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE -OLSEN_INLET PRESSURE - 15001 31CIC2 PRESSURE - 1000 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE - 9 GPM

    E-310

    ___________62 __

  • 13

    dB 90 -- t==1t- ~-80 - - - -. - -

    = ~70 ._

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -OLSEN & NUTRON SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -OLSEN & NUTRONINLET PRESSURE - 100a PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSIC1 PRESSURE= C1 PRESSURE - ~ 700 PSIC2 PRESSURE C2 PRESSURE -300 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSIFLOW TO VALVE-JMOTOR 1.8 GPM FLOW TO VALVEIMOTOR - 3.8 GPMMO0TOR RPM -150 RPM MOTOR RPM -300 RPMDISK DIAMETER 24 IN DISK DIAMETER -24 IN

    F-101 F-102I ~~~130 --- iii 'F Fr zz--1101

    1004- -1dB 90Lni\..

    __ ~~70- ~ I - -

    _ ~~50-_ 111 ±0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -OLSEN & NUTRON SERVO VALVE & MOTOR OLSEN &NL'TRONIINLET PRESSURE 1000 Psi INLET PRESSURE - 1450 PSI

    =C 1 PRESSURE- 900 PSI CI PRESSURE- 1350) PSIC2 PRESSURE -Z1O PSI C2 PRESSURE -100 Psi

    =RETURN PRESSURE - 0 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - to PSI-:FLOW TO VALOVE-1MOTOR 5,2 GPM FLOW TO VALVEIMOTOR -7.4 GPMI

    MOTOR RPM - 450 RPM MOTOR RPM 000 RPMDISK DIAMETER -24 IN DISK DIAMETER - 24 IN

    L=F-1 03 F4~04J

    63

  • " - -r %-7! "F=r - - - '

    * I i =, 1-° , - , ,-jii i - I

    dB 70 !==-j i-.-. 1 -60- " ,

    S0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency- (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    INLETPRESS - 5O0 PSI IN"ET PRESSURE - 1500 PSI

    C 1 PRESSURE - 506 Psi Cl PRESSURE - 110D0 PSIC I PRESURE - 5m C PRESSUR -- 00 PSI

    RETURN PRESSURE -- 300 PSI RETURN PRESSURE Soo50 PS!FLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR - 0 GPM FLOW TO VALVE .MOTOR - 0.5 Gp%I

    MOTOR RPM U 0 RPM MOTOR RPM - 60 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35.75 1NF-201 -0

    110 - 1...T

    ° IIi f Ii i iI

    dB 70 - A 12

    60 i

    50 I I : j,40

    300 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - MOOG 74 & SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - MOOG 74 & WSIINLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSIC1 PRESSURE - 1100 PSI C1 PRESSURE - II I% PSiC2 PRESSURE - 900 PSi C2 PRESSURE - 8530 PSIRETURN PRE.aSURE - 500 PSI RETURN -RESSURE - 5 PSiFLOW TO VAINEIMOTOR - 2 GPM FLOW-TO VALVEMOTOR - 2G GPMMOTOR RPM - 120 RPM MOTOR RPM- 150 RPMDISK DiAME-i ER - 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35i5 IN

    F203 5=204

    64

  • -110 ------l-=-....- i-i- ---- i !_ = --- -n - • ______; _

    _ I , , ° ),I , °110 T TT T10

    1)! i -'t

    -dB- 70 11 3

    50- 1-'

    40 1:0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - MOO3 74 & WSI SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - MOO 74 & 1WS61

    INLET PRESSURE 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURE - i500 PSIC1 PRESSURE 1150 PSI Cj PRESSURE- no PSI

    C2 PRESSURE Soo PSI Ci PRESSURE - 750 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PI RETURN PRESSURE - SOO PSiFLOW TO VALV=EIMOTOR - 32 GPM FLOWT VALVEIMOTOR 36GPMMOTOR RPM -180 RPM MOTOR RPM 2I RPMDISK DIAMETER - 3535 iN DISK IiAMETER - 3.51N

    F-205 F-206

    110 - tloo]

    -L ! i1- I7I

    dB 70 _

    60 s V \_ , I

    50

    40

    30;=-aL-0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    *SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - MOOG 74 & %'SI SERVO VAL-VE &, MOTOR -MOOG 74 & WSiINLET PRESSURE 1500 Psi INLET- PRESSURE- 1500 PSiCj PRESSURE - 135PSI Cj PRESSURE - 1450 PSI

    2 PRESSURE -00 P3 C2 PRESSURE - 700 PS

    K C2

    RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE 0 50 PSI

    FLOW TO VALVEIMOTOR- 4.6 GPM FLO W VALVEJMOTO -A 5.!GPMMOTOR RPM = 246 RPM MOTOR RPM - 270 rPM

    DISK DIAMETE 35151I DISK DIAMETER - 6 IN

    Fr--07 =

  • 60

    OnZiF'0- 40 -80- 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - MOOG-74 & WSIINLEST P!NSSRE - 1500 PSIC1 POESSURE 1500 PS1C2 PRESSRURE 500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 00 PSIFLOW-TO VALVEIIMOTORI = 5GPMMOTOR:RPM =2612 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 36.75 IN

    66 [

  • 110 - - -I

    dB 70-~= ~ = ~-

    60 - --- -

    50 - __

    30 - -- L-

    0 40 80~ 120 160 .200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)SERVO VALVE &MOTOR -MOOG 35 & WSI SETRVO VE &MOTOR MOOD 35 & S

    INLET PRESSURE 1500BO PSI INLET PRESSURE 1500o PSICl PRESSURE= 11G sI PRESSURE - I1100 PSIC2 1SSUREl - goo PSI C2- PRESSURE 950 PSIFIE! -N PRESSURE - 500 Psi RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIF-LOW TO VALVEIMOTOR 0.5 GPM PLO w-TO VALVGIMOTOR -I GP MMOTOR RPM - 31) RP~M- MOTOR Rpm - 0 RPMADISK DIAMETER - 35 IN DISK DIAMECTER 35,75 IN

    90

    -dB 70

    60-_ _

    50- ;3-- _ V40--

    30 A ----'-- -- I-0 40 80 120 -160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kliz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -MOOG 35 &WSI SERVO VALVE &MOTOR MOOG -5 S. W-91INLET PRESSURE 1500Bo PSI INLET PRESSURE - 16~00 Psi iCl PRESSUREC - ISO PSI G1I PRESSURE 1200 PsiCv, PRESSURE - Boo PSI CI PRESSURE 800 PSI -RETURN PRESSURAE 5 00 Psi RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI

    FLWT ALVEIMOTO R I B GPM FLOW TO VALVEIMjOOR 1 ,8 GPM

    MOTOR RPM -90 RPM MOTOR RPM 120I RPMDISK OIAMETZR - 35.75 ilm DISK OIAMETER - 36.5, INV

    "03O F-304 I IwO

  • 1001_ _90 ~_

    80

    dB 70

    60 N

    40 -_

    30 - - -0- 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -MOOG 36 & WSI SERVO VALVE &MOTOR MOOG 35 Si WSI

    INLET PRESSURE - 1500 Psi INLUT~PRESSURE 1500 psi=C 1 PRESSURE - 1225 PSI Gl PRESSURE -1250 PSI=02 PRESSURE 775 PSI 02 PRESSURE -700 Psi

    RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR 20PMFLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR -3,2 GPMMOTOR RPM 1S0 RPM MOTOR RPM - 18RPMDISK DIAMETER 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35175 IN

    "Os0 P-306

    -z dB 70-

    30 - -0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200a

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR MOOG 35 & WSI SERVO VALVE & MOTOR MOOG 35 &wSiINLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSIC I PRESSURE -1200 PSI Cl PRESSURE 1350 PIC2 PRESSURE- 500 PSI C,- PRIESSURE 0 00 PSI

    __RETURN PRESSURE - 5000PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PsiFLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR -3.8 GPM FLOW TO VALVC/MOTOR -4.1 GPIMMOTOR RPM - 210 RPM MrOORi P 240 RPM--'NiSK DIAMETER 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN

    ".07 F.30s

    68 ____

  • INLE 1RSU00 50 S

    80 PR SUR; 45 S

    50PESUE50 S

    3030

    0 0 80 10 1610

    Frequeny (k6z

  • 100 AH--~

    90 - - - - -

    80 - - - - -

    dB 70 -40 - - - - - - -

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - OLSEN & WSI SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -OLSEN & WSIINLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET HitSUR 100SC1 PRESSURE - 580 PSI Cl PRESSURE -700 PSIC2 PRESSURE - 450 PSI C2 PRESSURE - 500 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 100 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 125 PSI

    FLWT AVIMTR-0GMFLOW TO VALVEIMOTOR - 2 GPMMOTOR RPM - 0 RPM MOTOR RPM -144 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 35,75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN

    F.401 F-402

    110----------------

    100----------------

    80------------- -

    40 80 120 160 20 0 480 10 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)1

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - OLSEN & WSI SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -OLSEN & WSIINLET PRESSURE - 1000 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1125 PSICl PRESSURE - 950 PSI C1 PRESSURE - 1000 PSIC2 PRESSURE 15 ISPSI C2 PRESSURE - 125 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 125 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 126 PSIFLOW TO VALVEIMOTOR - 4.8 GPM FLOW TO VALVEIMOTOR - 4.9 GPMMOTOR RPM - 252 RPM MOTOR RPM -276 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN

    F A 03 F-404

    70

  • -0 -31-

    dB 70 -- -

    60- i - --

    30 - tT__-

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -OLSEN & WSI SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - OLSEN & WSIINLET PRESSURE - 1250 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500O PSIC1 PRESSURE - I11S0 PSI C1 PRESSURE - 1200 PSIC2 PRESSURE - 150 PSI C2 PRESSURE - 850 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 100 PSI RETURN PRESSURE: 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR - 5 GPM FLOW TO VALVE/MO0TOR -2 GPMMOTOR RPM - 300 RPM MOTOR RPM - 108 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35.76 IN

    F=405 F =406

    110

    80- -

    dB 70 -- --- -j I

    60 -j-_

    50- -=4-

    30 L j0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - OLSEN & WSI SERVO VALVE & MOTOR -OLSEN & WSIININLET PRESSURE - I1So0 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSIC1 PRESSURE - 1200 PSI C1 PRESSURE -1100 PSI -C2 PRESSURE - 800 PSI Cq PRESSURE - 900 PstRETURN PRESSURE 500o PSI RE TURN PRESSURE = 500o PSIFLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR -2.5 6PM FLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR -2,6 GPM _MOTOR RPM - IS0 RPM MOTOR RPM - 156 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN

    F-407 F-408

    71

  • 100 - 1111

    dB 70 --

    60- _ _ - -- - -

    30 I ii 1 ,0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - OLSEN & WSI SERVO VALVE & MOTOR OLSEN & WSI

    INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURe - 1500 PSIC1 PRESSURE - 1150 PSI C1 PRESSURE - 1200 PSIC2 PRESSURE - 800 PSI C2 PRESSURE - 800 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR - 3 GPM FLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR - 4 GPMMOTOR RPM - 180 RPM MOTOR RPM - 216 RPM

    -- DISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN= 110

    90 1-el I: ,oo ' J III ,80- dB 70; i

    40:- 30 al ,

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz) i

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - OLSEN & WSI SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - OLSEN & WSIINLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSI INLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSIC1 PRESSURE - 1250 PSI CI PRESSURE - 1350 PSIC2 PRESSURE - 750 PSI C2 PRESSURE - 550 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSI RETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR - 4.5 GPM FLOW TO VALVE/MOTOR -5 GPMMOTOR RPM - 252 RPM MOTOR RPM - 264 RPMDISK DIAMETER 35.75 IN DISK DIAMETER - 35.75 I N

    FAll F412

    E"-

  • LI I1 - - --

    100 - -

    LB 7050-- 4

    40 j- ___111130FT I -

    0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz)

    SERVO VALVE & MOTOR - OLSEN & WSIINLET PRESSURE - 1500 PSIC1 PRESSURE - 1400 PSIC2 PRESSURE - 750 PSIRETURN PRESSURE - 500 PSIFLOW TO VALVE/1MOTOR -S GPMiMOTOR RPM - 276 RPMDISK DIAMETER - 35.75 IN

    F-413

    m1

    al

    wlU

  • APPENDIX B

    TEST DATA OF SECOND TEST SERIES

    GRAPHS

    This appendix presents the results of the second series of acoustic tests, depictedby noise profile graphs for each of the components and specified test conditions. The decibel-_ scales for all graphs have a reference of I -microPascal per hertz per yard (dB//gPa/Hz/yd).

    I __--

    EV

    75-

    -I-

  • 130

    100

    dB 90j

    80 l

    70

    60i 1 E 150 ------------

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frpquency (kHz)

    FLOW - 5GPM FLOW - 10OGPMB-316 8-317

    130

    - 100

    =dB 90-IIL--- ---870 ---------------- -- -

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 2005Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW-5P FLOW - 20 GPM 0B-318 8-319

    VICKERS RELIEF VALVE --CT-10-C-20INLET - 1000 Psi

    RETURN- 0OPSI

    LOCATION - SALTWATER TEST POOL

    76

  • 130 sog-%f

    100 - ---I~dB 90- ------ I

    70 - L-=-=i-I-l--

    FLWI _~h IN - &0 ~ B 40 8320 6 0 0 0U-312 16 20

    iit120-

    I dB9

    60- IL1r50-

    10 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200 I-4Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    i4FLOW - IS5GPM FLOW -=20 GPM6-322 -2

    VICK.ERS RELIEF VALVE --CT-10 C 2041 DEGASSED OIL

    1INLET - 1000 PSIRETURN- 0PSILOCATION -NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    7-0

  • 130-

    dB 90 ij- -

    70tIlql

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 s0 120 160 200

    Freciuemiy (kHz) Frequency (kI-z)

    FLW-5 GPM FLOW - 106GPM8"24 B-325

    120--7I L -I I -'100 -- - - -

    80-- 11

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 156GPM FLOW -206GPM

    8"26 8327

    VICKERS RELIEF VALVE NqO. CT-1 0*C-20INLET - 1500 PSIRETURN - 500 PSII LOCATION -NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    I - pa

  • -130 __ 1 1-

    120 - _ _

    11 0 --

    80-il80-

    500 ii8 zz0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200 -

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 5 GPM F LOW- 0 GPIM__E-401 -402

    13T120-211 117"110 -

    100

    50 ''plA0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200_

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz) _

    FLOW- 15 GPM FLOW - 20GPMt-403 E-404

    SANDERS SERVO VALVE NO.SV41- lOPINLET - 1000 PSIRETURN - 0PSILOCATION - NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    79 ___W_

  • - 130-.T

    - 1zu t!- I

    - --80-

    :0 40 380 120 160 200Frequency '%kHz)

    I FLOW-f 22GPME-405

    SANDERS SERVO VALVE NO. SV4SS-1OP

    INLET-500 PSIRETURrJ - 0PS

    LOCTIO - ~tSALTWATER TEST POOL*

    sosgo t__

  • 130--r

    110

    100dB 90

    1

    80A-

    0 0 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200EFrequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    F~LOW - 5 G.PM FO- 10GPME-406 E407 IA

    1302-1

    I 100------ - __

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 2u7Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz) -2

    FLOW - 15 GPM FLOW -20GPME-408 E-409 I

    SANDERS SERVO VALVE NO. SV-438-10PINLET - 1500 P~SIRET URN - 500 PSI

    LOCATION - NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    A-9I

  • DEGASSED -DEGASSED

    80 - - - - -- -

    70

    601 _1 1 150__

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 5 GPM FLOW - 10OGPMB-328 0-329

    1201

    1 DEGASSED __EGASSED ---

    80

    70 1V _0 4C 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200 f

    Frequency (kt-z) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 15 GPM FLOW - 20 (GPMB-330 U-331I COMPARATIVE DATA (DEGASSING)

    VICKERS RELIEF VALVE 7DEGASSED OIL vs INLET - 1000 PSIRNETR-U0 PSI RTR PINE 00PIRETURN - 0 PSLOCATION - SAL-TWAI ER TEST POOL I

    82 -=~ME 7EMA2

  • 1300 I

    dB 90 --

    80-1 500 PSI Rl

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW-5GPM FLOW- 10 GPM332 6-333

    120 --

    100 -AOPI

    500 SIL 500 PSIR70 - - -- - - - -

    60-iii~~ -F0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 15 GPM FLOW - 20GPMB-334 B-335

    COMPARATIVE DATA (BACK-PRESSURING)

    VICKERS RELIEF VALVE

    I INLFT -10% PSI vs INLET - 1500PSI

    RETURN- PSI RETURN - 500 PSI

    LOCATION - NUC SALTWVATER TEST POOL

    83

  • 130

    DEGASSEDDGASE

    100 - ~ -

    dB 90---- j---80-

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 6 GPM FLOW - 10 GPMB-336 B-337

    120

    dB 90

    80 - PSj-

    60 - - i0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    fFrequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 15GPM FLOW -20 GPMB-338833 1

    VICKERS RELIEF VALVE (DEGASSING vs BACK-PRESSURING)

    DEGASSED OIL vs BACK-PRESSURED 'INLET - 000 PSI INLET - 150PSI A

    RETURN -0 PSI RETURN - 500 PSI

    LOCATION -NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    ____________- ~B

  • 120- ~~i

    dLOW -5GP9LO0-OP

    86t 0. I.1

    120 P1I R~ So-s

    110 - _

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - I5GPM FLOW 2 0 GPMEF412 E-41 3

    REUR -0PPRSUNI0 SLO0T0O + U ATAE ETPO

    ssR

  • 130

    120 - ---

    dB 90

    80

    70 SANDERS'- -

    0 0 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    EFFLOW-S5 GPM FLOW - 10 GPMG-101 G-102

    120 -~--}-----VCEVICKERS VCKR

    100

    50

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80~ 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 15 GPM FLOW - 20) GPMG-103 G-104

    COMPARATIVE DATA (VICKERS vs SANDERS VALVES) _

    VICKC-RS vs SANDERSINLET - 1500 PSI INLET - 1000 PSIRETURN - 500 PSI RETURN - 0 PSI

    LOCATION - NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    86 _

  • 50~-- ~ ± I12 40 8 10 10 00 0 8 10 16 0

    1106G.0

    10

    dB 90--

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200 -Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW-F1GPM FLOW -210 GPMG-105 G-1 06

    CO PA ATV DATAER VVICER vS N ERSV LVS

    I1E0-1000S

    LOCATION/ -NCSLWTRESNPOOL

    770

  • APPENDIX C

    TEST DATA OF THIRD TEST SERIES

    GRAPHS

    This appendix presents the results of the third series of acoustic tests, depicted bynoise profile graphs for each cf the components and specified test conditions. The decibelscales for all graphs have a reference of I microPascal per hertz per yard (dB//]Pa/Hz/yd).

    - PSED1ING PAGE KAM~U NOTj 7T1J6&

    89

  • 130-

    120 A

    110--

    80 --0-

    70--

    60 --0-

    50 ----0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 30 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (k~z)

    FLOW - 5GPM FLOW - 106GPMB-601 B-602

    130 - - - - - - - -

    -i 120--------------

    110-

    100---------------

    dB 90 - - - - -- -- - - - - -

    600~4 0 10 10 20

    0 0 8 2 10 200 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kI-z) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 156GPM FLOW - 20 GPM"-03 8.604

    ROLAMITE PRESSURE RELIEF VALVE (EXTERNAL PILOT VALVE)

    INLET - 1000 PSIRETURN - 0 PSI

    LOCATION - NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    90

  • 110 VICKERS __

    40 80 10 10 20A0 8 2 6 0

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - GPM". FLOW -10 GPMG-201 G-402

    130

    110 -

    I1 ]40 -0 - I9'~zzL

    0 0 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kI-z) _

    FLOW- 15 GPM FLOW- 20 GPING-203 4

    COMPARATIVE DATA (ROLAMITE v.VICKERS)

    INLET - 1000 PSIRETURN - 0PSI

    LOCATION - NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    91

  • 100-

    70 __ 1IT60 -1 I11E'

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 5 GPM FLOW - 10 GPMIG-205 G-206

    1 3 0 ~T 1i1-I ----- ~I

    * 110 - - -4 ICKERS\ ~ ~ tdB 90 - - -- I

    70

    60 RT, I4~I 4 I

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Freqdency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW - 15 GPM FLOW - 20 GPMG-207 G-208

    COMPARATIVE DATA (ROLAMITE vsVICKERS)

    ROLAMITE VICKErSINLET-1000 PSI I SooPSIRETURN - 0PSI 50 PSI

    LOCATION -NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

  • 130 13 i-- H ii . NI H'" I :i ~ ~120 '~~~~110

    ISANDERS

    I- -80

    70 Nic-T IL' lizzzL50 i

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200

    Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW- 5 GPM FLOW- 10GPMG.301 G-302

    i } ~ ~130 I-

    1110100 SANDERSi I I -i 'rDR

    dB 90

    ROLACIT MROLAMITE

    0 -Pr

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kHz)

    FLOW -15 GPM FLOW - 20 GPMG-303 G-304

    COMFARATIVE DATA (ROLAMITE vs SANDERS)

    INLET - 1000 PSIl -

    RETURN - 0 PSI

    LOCATION - NUC SALTWATER TEST POOL

    93I

  • 1301

    _ dB 90 - 1

    70'

    0 40 80 120 160 200 0 40 80 120 160 200Frequency (kHz) Frequency (kI-z)

    OUTPUT OUTPUTPRESSURE - 0 PSI PRESSURE - S00 PSIID-501 0.502

    10 40 8 12 16 20

    100UR 00 ~

    8050

    0 40 8 LOW120 16PM 0LOequTncy (kU SLWAEz)S PO

    L9

  • 130

    120

    __ ~110 j- -i100

    HYDRATAR ICKERS

    130

    I HYDRACWEA

    60R CIN OUTPUT50 PRESSURE - 1000 PSI

    G-5010 40 80 120 160 200

    Freqency (kHz)

    COMPARTIVE DATA HYDRASTAR s CINKUERVA PUMPS) MPUM PRESS - 1000 PSIHYDRASTAR VACERRPM 175 RPM- 1750FLOW -20 GPM FLOW - 20M

    _130

    dB 90

  • AP~PEND)IX D

    NOSC ROLAMITE VALVE IDESIGN

    ARoiaili te valhe was desi-ned and tested by thle Naval Ocean Systems (Center. H awaliiLaboratory. Ihe valve is shown ill fl'UreS D)-] and D)-2: design details arec contained inl thleNOSC (Irawlim l)RS-19000 (3 ,heets).I

    __ S4

    I-

    Fiur D-I. NOSC RoIlnnile valve

    97

  • 0k0 ' 11 wl Ik 111P IU o lu t,"N ,Iln ic 1 1 N II 1 1.o l )Ili" td 1 1iilA " 11 ,k W , 0 ! l, 11 11' l" JM ! :1h l 1I \I 'l

    Ol 11. 11oI'l'u 0. 11 1 , , ZII I,'1N\ 1" III N ,'0! d ' oI ."I I1 IN 11 'i

    Im 11".1 1, o 0 l I I,,, I I k I tN k t!1 i ' tI ,I,\ (h ,

    171

    'Ake

  • ___d -- lm-

    pItU~~~~-J --- - f

    i0

    II .

    .0.

    Fr

    1A a0 0~

    02 0~I

    I I99

  • M A-

    iii

    sVV"

    -----------,

    I-f

    L7 ------- ,,+-'U0 _-- - - -

    VI v

    Olt

    ,* ~ 'ED

    tooF

  • 1

    rill i J

    Rilll-il

    '- "

    sI

    @~

    0 ji~ ji

    i I o I Al

    * I Iaa, I-l -l <

    J , , ,, T, A

    ! 101

    ..A -A,