TAIHO 1 Recent Development of Plain Bearings for Combustion Engines 2013 . Nov . 19 Taiho Kogyo...

Post on 27-Dec-2015

219 views 0 download

transcript

TAIHO

1

Recent Development of Plain Bearings for Combustion Engines

2013 . Nov . 19

Taiho Kogyo Co., Ltd.TTRF Yoshio KUMADA

MITC2013

TAIHO

2

Contents

1 What is “Plain Bearing for Internal Combustion Engine”? 1.1 Short History 1.2 Needs & Direction of Development

2 Higher Performance, Lead Free 2.1 Al-Sn-Si(-Pb) Alloy Bearing 2.2 Microgrooved Bearing 2.3 Lead Free Overlay

3 Lower Fuel Consumption for Future 3.1 Bearing with Eccentric Oil Groove 3.2 Bearing with Surface Texture 3.3 Friction loss reduced by Fullerene/Graphene coating

4 Conclusion

TAIHO

3

1 Plain Bearings for Internal Combustion Engine

Camshaft bearing

Con-Rod small-end bearing

Con-Rod big-end bearing

Crankshaft bearing

Crankshaft bearing

Con-Rod big-end bearing

Crankshaft

Con-RodSmall-end

Big-end

TAIHO

4

Scientific Research – Modern age Scientific Research – Modern age

1687    I. Newton “Principia” Newtonian fluid, viscosity law 1883 B. Tower       experimental work    

   - discovery of oil film pressure1886 O. Reynolds theoretical work        - Reynolds’ equation1902 R. Stribeck Stribeck curve       

1904 A. J. W. Sommerfeld analytic solution of Reynolds’

equation1904 A. G. M. Michell tilting pad bearing (patent)

1910 A. Kingsbury          

1.1 Short History

TAIHO

5

1839   ~      

     1908                

J.Babbitt invention of White metal (1839, USA Patent)Babbitt metal (Sn-9Sb-2Cu)

T-type Ford, from 1908

White Metal・ Tin base (Sn-Sb-Cu-Pb) Lead base (Pb-Sb-Cu-Sn)

Soft, Low melting point Good : conformability, Anti-

seizurePoor : heat resistance, Anti-

Fatigue

Modern age – Modern age – White MetalWhite Metal

TAIHO

6

1920s Higher Load Carrying Capacity & Fatigue Resistance         Soft lead phase dispersed in hard metallic matrix           ⇒  Basic concept of recent bearing materials        thick-walled cast Cu alloy with 20-50%Pb        afterward,

centrifugal casting or direct casting on back-steel1939     Powder metallurgy : continuous sintering on back-steelAround Widely Expanded 1940 – quality, productivity, economic efficiency afterward, Cu-Pb with Overlay (electroplated, 20μm)     

Copper-Lead, OverlayCopper-Lead, OverlayModern age – Modern age –

Higher conformability & Anti-seizurearound    Pb-Sn-Cu, Pb-Sn, Pb-Sn-In, Pb-In         1970 Ni intermediate layer        

20μm

TAIHO

7

World War I Lack of Heavy Metals

1920s Rolls-Royce(GB) thick-walled cast duralumin with

Overlay, C/R, P/P1930s    USA Al-6Sn with Sn Overlay   VW(DE) Al-5Zn-SiCuPbMg1950s    USA Bimetal          GB Al-20Sn without Overlay   

    1970s USA, JPN Al-Pb Casting, Powder sintering

Aluminum AlloyAluminum AlloyModern age – Modern age –

Al-20Sn

As Cast Bimetal

TAIHO

8

Pb-6In-7Sn/Cu-23PbBack Steel

Bearing alloy(Lining)

Cu-Pb alloy bearingwith overlay

Al-12Sn-2.7Si-1Cu(-2Pb)

20μm

OverlayNi barrier

Cu-Pb alloy

Structure of Engine Bearing and Cross-Sectional View

20μm

back steel

Al alloy bearing

back steel

Bearing lining Bearing lining

TAIHO

9

1.2 Needs and Direction of Development1.2.1 Bearing Pattern

Prof. Norimune Soda said, “There is an effective method of using bearings, which is called the bearing law, that is the Bearing pattern”.軸受には軸受法という法則があり,当たりこそ軸受法である.(曽田先生)

# 1     # 2     # 3     # 4

Severity of engine bearings

Maximum unit load : Pmax = 50 -100 MPa

Minimum oil film thickness : hmin = 0.4 - 0.8 μm

TAIHO

10

Ref. : Y. Kumada, Journal of Japanese Society of Tribologist , 41, 1 (1996) 28

1.2.2 Conformability, Running-inDevelopment of Bearings ・・・ the challenging theme how to make running-in of the bearing materials with higher strength

1  Thin Overlay

2  Hard Particle in the Lining

3  Softer Middle Layer

4  Micro Regular Shape in the Surface

Pb base Overlay

Pb Free

2.3 Pb free Overlay

2.1 Al-Sn-Si Alloy

2.2 Microgrooved Bearing

Al-Sn-Si Alloy + Underlay

TAIHO

11

2.1 Al-Sn-Si alloy, 2.2 Microgrooved Bearing(2.3 Lead Free Materials)

(2.2 Microgrooved Bearing)(2.3 Lead Free Overlay)3.1 Eccentric grooved Bearing3.2 Surface texture

・ Higher Oil Temp.・ Higher Unit Load

2.2 Microgrooved Bearing

・ Higher Durability・ Lower cost

High performance

Improve of Fuel Consumption

Clean Exhaust Gas

Reduction of Noise & Vibration

Otherslonger life, cost reduction

Reduction of Environmental Substances of Concerns

2.3 Lead Free Materials

1.2.3 Trends of Engines & Influences on Bearing

Trend of Engines Influences on Bearing → Solution

・ Higher Unit Load

・ Lower Rigidity of Housing・ Narrow Width → Higher Unit Load・ Lower Viscosity Oils・ Excessive wear

・ Smaller Diametral Clearance

TAIHO

12

2.1 Al-Sn-Si Alloy Bearing

2.1.1 Seizure by Nodular Cast Iron Shaft

Ref. : T. Fukuoka, H. Kato, S. Kamiya, N. Soda, SAE Technical Paper, 830308 (1983)

TAIHO

2.1.2 Lapping shaft surface by hard particles, Si

Ref. : T. Fukuoka, H. Kato, S. Kamiya, N. Soda, SAE Technical Paper, 830308 (1983)

13

Fig. seizure property of two kinds of Al-alloy bearings

Fig. seizure process of Al-alloy bearings and new concept

TAIHO

14

Al-12Sn-2.8Si

normal

Larger Si

GO-STOP 50kcycles2.2MPa120C ATFSCM420H carburizing & quench

0

20

40

60

80

100

1 2 3 4 5

Wear

am

ount

,m

m

Si Mean particle size, mm

2.1.3 larger Si particle Size ( 2→ 5μm )

Ref. : T . Desaki et al., JSAE Review, 21, 3 (2000) 321.

20μm

20μm

TAIHO

15

0.1 ~ 0.4 mm

3 ~ 6 μm

2.2 Microgrooved Bearing ( MGB)

Ref. : Y. Kumada, Dissertation in The University of Tokyo ( 1996 )

TAIHO

16

2.2.1 Al alloy bearings (after engine endurance test)      Look at the bearing pattern !

Microgrooved Bearing Normal Plain Bearing

# 1     # 2     # 3     # 4 # 1     # 2     # 3     # 4

Blo

ck sid

eC

ap

side

Engine: V6,3.0L 6,300r/min×WOT ×100h

Bearing:Crankshaft bearing Al-Sn-Si alloy

TAIHO

2.2.2 Bearing temperature rise

Test condition

Engine : I-6, 2000cc, gasoline#4 crankshaft bearing was measuredLoad : W.O.T.Lubricant : 7.5W-30   SEOil temperature : 130℃

140

160

180

Rotational speed, r/min

Beari

ng

back

sid

e t

em

p.,

5000 6000 7000 8000

MGB G24 MGB G23 NPB

Seizure

Al-Sn-Si alloy NPB

Al-Sn-Si alloy MGB G24

Lead Bronze with Overlay

NPB

ΔT = kQ/G Oil flowHeat generation

17

Ref. : Y. Kumada et al., Tribology Trans., 39, 1 (1996) 81

TAIHO

■Contribution to improving fuel consumption, lower cost et al.

●Received the first JAST award                   (1996. 5)

Main stream of Engine Bearings( around 75% of worldwide Taiho engine bearings )

It is common that a plain bearing hasplane surface in order to carry the load by oil film pressure.

An engineer of Taiho Kogyo in which I have taught Tribology for forty years, proposed the idea in a confident attitude. “The idea, whichSurface has many grooves, is not common. That is very interesting.”

2004.2.24 Asahi Newspaper

Prof. Kimura says,

18

TAIHO

19

2.3 Lead Free Materials2.3.1 Lead Amount of Typical Plain Bearings

Pb amount in a piece of bearing (mass%)

White Metal

Overlay

Al alloy

Cu alloy

Sn basePb base

Pb baseSn base

Al-SnAl-Sn-Si-PbAl-Pb-SiAl-Zn-Si-PbAl-Cd

Cu-Pb-SnCu-SnCu-Graphite

Category Composition 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

OverlayLining

Back steel

Ref. : S. Kamiya, Document of 47th Contingence-Composite session meeting, JSTP (2001)

TAIHO

20

2.3.2 Pb Free Bearing Materials

Taiho Kogyo other companies

Aluminum Alloy

Overlay

Copper Alloy

Overlay

Al-20Sn-1Cu Al-(12-15)Sn-3Si-1Cu-Cr,Zr,V,Mn Al-(6-7)Sn-3Si-(1-1.5)Cu-Cr,Zr,V,Mn

Al-(4-5)Zn-Si-Cu

PAI-72MoS2 (Solid PAI-(18-20)MoS2-(10-18)Gr,WS2

Lubricant Overlay) PTFE-MoS2-Gr

Cu-4Sn-7Bi Cu-(4-10)Sn-(4-8)Bi-Mo2C,Zn,NiCu-6Sn-Ag Cu-(5-8)Sn-Ni,P Cu-20Zn-Ni,Al,Mn,Fe

PAI-72MoS2 (S.L.O) Sputter (Al–20Sn)Bi Bi/Ag, BiSn Sn-(2-8)Cu

TAIHO

2.3.3 Solid Lubricant Overlay PAI+MoS2

Good conformability for initial running-in Low friction by solid lubricant, MoS2 PAI(thermosetting resin) for binder + MoS2 (solid lubricant) 40vol% Thickness 6μm

Good conformability for initial running-in Low friction by solid lubricant, MoS2 PAI(thermosetting resin) for binder + MoS2 (solid lubricant) 40vol% Thickness 6μm

Cross-section of Overlay

Overlay

“Pb free bearings”JSME “Technology Award” in 2003

21

TAIHO

22

Al-7Sn-2.7Si-1.5Cu-Cr-Zr/PAI-72MoS2

better

Fatigue resistance of Al-Sn-Si alloy bearing with solid lubricant overlay

Ref. : Y. Kumada et al., VDI-Berichte Nr. 1906 ( 2006 ) 113

TAIHO

23/58

TAIHO

Touareg

Adopted for VW W12 crankshaft bearings

Ref. : R.Szengel, F.T.Metzner & M.Dehmke, Aachener Kolloquium. “Fahrzeug und Motorentechnik” (2003)

23

TAIHO

Ref. : Nikkei Monodukuri , 8 (2012) 92.

24

Taiho Kogyo developed Crankshaft bearings having super low frictional property for Mini-vehicle -- Bearings with solid lubricant overlay --

TAIHO

25

•Al-Sn sputter (GB, DE, Austria)

  Higher Load Carrying Capacity

Slightly Lower Conformability

High production Cost (PVD)sputteredAl-20Snoverlay

Cu-Sn alloySputter (SEM Image)

2.3.4 Al-Sn Sputter

TAIHO

3.1 Eccentric oil-grooved bearing for low fuel assumption

Conventional Eccentric

Oil flow in oil groove

parti

ng e

nd

26

Ref. : Y. Hikita et al., ITC KOBE 2005, Book of Synopses (2005) 24.

TAIHO

Ratio of friction loss

Piston & Con-rod

Accessory

Valve train Crankshaft

Oil pump 16%

Water pump

27

3.1.1 Background

TAIHO

28

Engine : L4 1.5LOil temperature : 100ºC

0

10

20

2000 4000 6000Rotational speed , rpm

Oil

flow

, L

/min

Crankshaft bearing

Connecting rod bearing

Valve train

Crankshaftbearing (Upper)

Connecting rod bearing Upper Lower

Crank pinjournal

Crank main journal

Crankshaftbearing (Lower)

Crushrelief

TAIHO

Conventional Eccentric

Oil flow in oil groove

largeSide flow is

parti

ng e

nd

reduced

Crush relief area(Clearance is large)

29

3.1.2 Eccentric oil-grooved bearing

TAIHO

-0.2

-0.1

0

0.1

2 4 6 8 10Oil flow , L/min

Fric

tion t

orq

ue d

iffere

nce

,

Nm

Conventio

nal

No. 1

No. 2

No. 3

Eccentri

c

q0º

90º

Partin

g

end

Oil groove end

Cen

ter

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

0 30 60 90 θ , º

Depth

, m

m

Conventional

No. 1

No. 2

No. 3

(Center) (Parting end)

30

3.1.3 Relationship of oil groove end and friction torque

TAIHO

4 Conclusion & Future Issues

1 Al-Sn-Si alloy, Microgrooved Bearings were adopted in almost all automotive engines, and have become standard ones.

2 Regarding Lead free bearings, we have to develop high performance engine bearings, that is, the bearings satisfying both of running-in property and material hardness.

3 It is desired that mechanical loss caused by bearing friction will be near zero, so near zero friction bearings have to be developed near future.

31

TAIHO

32

TAIHO

33

TAIHO

34 表4 同一排気量(1500cc)エンジンの年代毎の軸受負荷容量の変化

年代 エンシ ン゙型式 出力 重量 適用車種 軸受寸法 軸受材質 内部構成部品 備考

1960 R型 PS60 166Kg コロナ

:Φ × ×M/N(1) 61.6 30 1.79:Φ × ×M/N(2) 61.6 34 1.79:Φ × ×M/N(3) 61.6 40 1.79

Φ × ×C/R: 53 27 1.50/ 4× ×P=60 5 2.6

/=1.15PS cm2

M/ N,C/ R,C/ Mホワイトメタル

5MPa負荷容量1

4気筒3点支持鍛造軸カム軸歯車駆動スラスト軸受はリア側で支持

1970 T-U型 78PS 141Kgセリカ

カローラカリーナ

:Φ × ×M/N 62 20.8 2.0Φ × ×C/R: 51 19 1.5/ × ×P=78 4 4.8 1.8

/=2.26PS cm2

M/N,C/R- -Pb Sn Cu付

銅・鉛合金MPa負荷容量30

C/Mホワイトメタル

4気筒5点支持DCI軸カム軸チエン駆動スラスト軸受はセンターで支持

1980 5APS85

6000RPM

116Kgカリーナカローラコロナ

Φ × ×M/N: 52 20 2.0Φ × ×C/R: 43 17.1 1.5/ × ×P=85 4 4 1.74

/=3.05PS cm2

M/N,C/R- -AL Sn Si

MPa負荷容量30

4気筒5点支持FCD70軸DOHC軸タイミングベルト駆動スラスト軸受はセンターで支持

1990 5EPS105

6400RPM

107Kgターセル

Ⅱカローラコルサ

Φ × ×M/N: 54 16 2.0/ Φ × ×C R: 46 16 1.5

/ 4× ×P=105 4.3 1.4 =4.36PS/cm2

M/N,C/R- -AL Sn Si

5MPa負荷容量3

4気筒5点支持FCD軸DOHC軸タイミングベルト駆動スラスト軸受はセンターで支持

50

100

150

200

1960 70 80 90 2000 年度

重量

kg

0

50

100

150

PS出

重量PS

0

2

4

6

1960 70 80 90 2000 年度

PS/c

m2

軸受

負荷

PS/ cm2

by K. Niwa

TAIHO

35

Trends of Automotive Engines & Influences on Bearing

Needs Trend of Engines Influences on Bearing

・ Direct ignition & higher cylinder pressure (Gasoline)・ High pressure fuel jet & higher cylinder pressure (Diesel)

No.

・ Down-size, Thin wall, Light weight Materials (Al alloy)・ Reduction of Friction Loss・ Increase of Start–Stop Operation

・ Lower volume of Oil Pump・ EGR・ Direct ignition & higher cylinder pressure

・ Reduction of bearing slap noise

・ Higher Reliability・ Commoditizing

・ Higher Unit Load →① Al-Sn-Si alloy,    ② Microgrooved Bearing

・ Lower Rigidity of Housing

・ Narrow Width → Higher Unit Load・ Lower Viscosity Oils・ Excessive Wear④Eccentric grooved Bearing・ Higher Oil Temp.・ Higher Unit Load

・ Smaller Diametral Clearance②Microgrooved Bearing

・ Higher Durability・ Commoditizing, Lower cost

1

2

3

4

5

High performance

Improve of Fuel Consumption

Clean Exhaust Gas

Reduction of Noise & Vibration

Others longer life, cost reduction6

Reduction of Environmental Substances of Concerns

・ Less or Free of lead ・③ Lead Free Materials

TAIHO

36

4 今後の課題と方向Influence on Bearings   年頃

・ higher unit load →鉛青銅系ライニング、   鉛系オーバレイ

1970 年~   2000 年

1995 年~  現在

1975 年~   2005 年

1995 年~  現在

1990 年~   2000 年

・ マイクログルーブ軸受( MGB )

High performance

Improve of Fuel Consumption

Clean Exhaust Gas

Reduction of Noise & Vibration

Reduction of Environmental Substances of Concerns

Others -- longer life, cost reduction

Needs Trend of Engines

1

2

3

4

5

6

・ Direct ignition & higher cylinder pressure (Gasoline)・ High pressure fuel jet & higher cylinder pressure (Diesel)

・ EGR・ Direct ignition & higher cylinder pressure

・ Reduction of bearing slap noise

・ Higher Reliability・ Commoditizing

・ Less or Free of lead

・ Down-size, Thin wall, Light weight Materials (Al alloy)・ Reduction of Friction Loss・ Increase of Start–Stop Operation

・ Lower volume of oil pump

No.

・ Higher Durability, Commoditizing, Lower cost

・ Lower Rigidity of Housing

・ Narrow Width → Higher Unit Load・ Lower Viscosity Oils・ Excessive Wear

・ Higher Oil Temp.・ Higher Unit Load

・ Smaller Diametral Clearance

・ Lead Free Materials

TAIHO

37

TAIHO

38

3.3.1  従来( Pb 含有)軸受の性能位置付け 

スポーツタイプガソリンエンジン

ディーゼルエンジン

一般ガソリン エンジン

SA161SA151

LN750/HD150LN760/HD240

LN762

8 12 16

20

40

60

80

20周速 , m/s

100

最大

軸受

面圧

 ,

MP

a

24

120

今後の開発エンジンの領域(予測)

コンロッド軸受最高出力時

【材料記号説明】 オーバレイ材/ライニング材

3.3  鉛フリー軸受

Al-Sn-Si-Pb 合金

Pb 基オーバレイ付き銅鉛合金or 鉛青銅

TAIHO

39

・ Addition of Solid lubricantsGraphite(Gr)MoS2, WS2

PTFE Sulfide : Cu2S , AgS ・・・

・ Addition of Ag 〔 HS100 , HS210 〕

・ Addition of Low Melting Point MetalBi , Sn , In

Conformability

・ Lower hardness    addition of Soft components Gr , MoS2 , PTFE ・・

・ Surface Modification   Sn electroplating ① Solid Lubricant Coating 〔 RA500 〕 ② Microgrooved Bearing

・ Hard Particle   Enlarged Si , Fe-P , AlN ・・・

Boundary Lubricity

Concept of Pb Free BearingConcept of Pb Free Bearing

TAIHO

40

摺動メカニズム: 油中の S,O の存在と摩擦熱とによって、極表面に約 0.1~ 0.2μm の厚さで次の物質が形成される. (ESCA , AES , EPMA 分析結果 )         

③-1 トライボケミカル反応の利用 -Ag の添加

SnAg

Cu

応力や摩擦熱

オイル中の   S , O

表面への Sn,Ag の富化

Sn,Agを固溶した非平衡 Cu マトリックス

Cu2O , SnO2

の薄い層

CuSO4

Sn リッチAg3Sn-Sn共晶

( AgS,SnS等)部分的に数 μm 厚さの Cu2O ,CuSO4

表面

軸受

合金

Fig.3Smaller and stable friction coefficient ofSn-Agthin layer

Coefficient

of friction

00.2

0.4

0.6

Sliding distance (time) →30mm(91sec)

Sn-Agbulk

0.1mSn-Agon Cu-5Sn Cu-5Sn bulk

Fig.3Smaller and stable friction coefficient ofSn-Agthin layer

Coefficient

of friction

00.2

0.4

0.6

00.2

0.4

0.6

Sliding distance (time) →30mm(91sec)

Sn-Agbulk

0.1mSn-Agon Cu-5Sn Cu-5Sn bulk

出典:神谷荘司,名古屋大学学位論文    ( 1999 )

5Sn-1Ag thin layer

TAIHO

41

TAIHO

【試験方法】試験機 : 高面圧軸受試験機

軸受材質 : SA162, RA530/SA250軸受寸法 : 内径 φ42×幅 17mm給油温度 : 140℃試験軸 : S55C 焼入れ      表面粗さ RzJIS 0.5μm 硬さ 500 - 600HV10

回転数[r/min]

軸受面圧   [MPa] 20

105

0 45   90 135 175 220 〔 min 〕

1300

45min 毎に10MPa ステップアップ

3040

50

0 45   90 135 175 220 〔 min 〕

混合潤滑領域の摩擦係数,焼付き面圧を確認

供試軸受オイルバス

油圧ピストン

モーター

ひずみゲージ

荷重パターン試験機

42

TAIHO

43

1750    Half bearing (← Leonardo da Vinci at the Renaissance)  ~       :replaceable in case of excessive wear            1850    Bearing Materials               : cast iron, bronze, brass, pewter (Alloy of tin, lead and zinc)          

Industry RevolutionIndustry Revolution

Brass half bearing

Ref. : D . Dowson, History of Tribology 2nd edition, Professional Engineering Pub. (1998) 201.  

1.1 Short History

TAIHO

44

Sn/Cu-6Sn-1Ag

Bi/Ag/Cu-10Sn-4Bi-Mo2C

Size : - 1 μm

Size :1 - 5 μm

Dendrite

Granule

22HV

12HV

Bi:5μm

Ag:5μm

基材

Cross Overlay Overlay Crystal size Hardness -section surface fracture s.

5μm 5μm5μm

Fine

Bi

Ag

基材

基材

BP100X

CX4

裏金

PK1

2.3.5 Sn,Bi electroplating

TAIHO

45

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Conventional No.1 No.2Em

bedded

Rate

Engine : L4, 1.5LRotational Speed : 6400rpmOil Temp. : 120ºC

[ Test conditions ]

A : Crank pin lower side

B : Crankshaft bearing back side

125

130

135

140

145

150

Conventi

onal

No.

1

No.

2

No.

3

Tem

pera

ture

, º

C +0.8ºC +1.5ºC +1.4ºC

+2.1ºC +2.5ºC+1.2ºC

Eccentric

3.1.4 temperature increase and embeddability of Eccentric oil-grooved bearing

Embedded rate of foreign particleson connecting rod bearings