Teaching Vocabulary to ALL Your K-3 Students

Teaching Vocabulary to ALL Your K-3 Students

Kristin Nelson, Ph.D. andNaomi Watkins

IRA Annual Conference, Atlanta 2008

Kristin Nelson, Ph.D. andNaomi Watkins

IRA Annual Conference, Atlanta 2008

Today’s ScheduleToday’s Schedule Vocabulary Instruction Self-Inventory

Why K-3 Vocabulary? What do mean by ALL Students?

What Research Says About K-3 Instruction

Comprehensive Vocabulary Curriculum Specific-Word Instruction Word-Learning Strategies Word Consciousness

Vocabulary Instruction Self-Inventory

Why K-3 Vocabulary? What do mean by ALL Students?

What Research Says About K-3 Instruction

Comprehensive Vocabulary Curriculum Specific-Word Instruction Word-Learning Strategies Word Consciousness

Vocabulary Instruction Self-Inventory

Vocabulary Instruction Self-Inventory

Take a few minutes to reflect on the vocabulary instruction in your classroom. What do you do? What are your feelings?

Then, discuss your responses with a neighbor.

Then, we’ll discuss as a group.

Take a few minutes to reflect on the vocabulary instruction in your classroom. What do you do? What are your feelings?

Then, discuss your responses with a neighbor.

Then, we’ll discuss as a group.

Why K-3 Vocabulary?Why K-3 Vocabulary?• Word knowledge gap begins before school Hart and Risely (1995) found that 3-year-olds

from advantaged homes had oral vocabularies 5x larger than those from high-poverty homes

Without intervention, vocabulary gap gets bigger

To catch up, low-vocabulary students would need to learn 10 words a week.

Biemiller (2005) believes the bottom 25% begin kindergarten with 1,000 fewer root word meanings.

• Word knowledge gap begins before school Hart and Risely (1995) found that 3-year-olds

from advantaged homes had oral vocabularies 5x larger than those from high-poverty homes

Without intervention, vocabulary gap gets bigger

To catch up, low-vocabulary students would need to learn 10 words a week.

Biemiller (2005) believes the bottom 25% begin kindergarten with 1,000 fewer root word meanings.

Why K-3 Vocabulary?Why K-3 Vocabulary?Grade Average Student (at 2.4 root

words per day) Bottom 25% (at 1.6 root

words per day) End of Pre-K 3,440 2, 440

End of K 4,300 3, 016 End of Grade 1 5,160 3, 592 End of Grade 2 6,020 4, 168

Table from Vocabulary Handbook, p.9

What We Mean By ALL Students

What We Mean By ALL Students

Gifted students Average students English Language Learners Struggling Readers SPED students

Gifted students Average students English Language Learners Struggling Readers SPED students

Related ResearchRelated Research

Repeated Reading Rich Instruction ELLs SPED Students Observations

Repeated Reading Rich Instruction ELLs SPED Students Observations

Repeated ReadingsRepeated Readings Research shows that encouraging vocabulary

acquisition in the primary grades using repeated reading combined with word meaning explanation works.

In recent studies, Biemiller and Boote (2006) showed, in K-2 settings with 50% English-language learners, that repeated reading with repeated word explanations, students acquired up to 41% of words taught.

Research shows that encouraging vocabulary acquisition in the primary grades using repeated reading combined with word meaning explanation works.

In recent studies, Biemiller and Boote (2006) showed, in K-2 settings with 50% English-language learners, that repeated reading with repeated word explanations, students acquired up to 41% of words taught.

Repeated Readings cont.Repeated Readings cont. In these Biemiller studies, instruction was in the

form of providing simple explanations.

At the 41% rate of acquisition, 1,000 word meanings, 25 per week, would have to be taught to learn 400 words a year.

Kindergarteners benefited from more than two readings with word explanation--1st and 2nd graders, twice was sufficient.

In these Biemiller studies, instruction was in the form of providing simple explanations.

At the 41% rate of acquisition, 1,000 word meanings, 25 per week, would have to be taught to learn 400 words a year.

Kindergarteners benefited from more than two readings with word explanation--1st and 2nd graders, twice was sufficient.

Rich InstructionRich Instruction In recent studies, Beck and McKeown (2007)

showed that kindergarten and first-grade children from a low-achieving school learned more sophisticated words with 6 days of rich vocabulary instruction versus 3 days--with a mean gain of 8.17 words for the verbal task (vs. 2.50) and 8.03 (vs. 2.97) for the picture task.

In recent studies, Beck and McKeown (2007) showed that kindergarten and first-grade children from a low-achieving school learned more sophisticated words with 6 days of rich vocabulary instruction versus 3 days--with a mean gain of 8.17 words for the verbal task (vs. 2.50) and 8.03 (vs. 2.97) for the picture task.

ObservationsObservations Nelson, Dole, Hosp & Hosp (2008)

showed that over a three-year period, K-3 teachers in a reading reform project, taught vocabulary on average about 8 minutes a day. Is this enough?

Nelson, Dole, Hosp & Hosp (2008) showed that over a three-year period, K-3 teachers in a reading reform project, taught vocabulary on average about 8 minutes a day. Is this enough?

English Language LearnersEnglish Language Learners From the research we have, the

same research-based strategies also are effective with ELLs, but should be modified (Calderon et al. 2005).

From the research we have, the same research-based strategies also are effective with ELLs, but should be modified (Calderon et al. 2005).

Vocabulary Instruction for ELLsVocabulary Instruction for ELLs Considerations:

Need to teach Tier I words (basic) August et al. (2005)

Place words in context Provide additional scaffolding and exposures Tie words to students’ cultural background Build background knowledge vs. merely

activating BK Use cognates Incorporate pictures, objects, gestures, etc.

Considerations: Need to teach Tier I words (basic) August et

al. (2005) Place words in context Provide additional scaffolding and exposures Tie words to students’ cultural background Build background knowledge vs. merely

activating BK Use cognates Incorporate pictures, objects, gestures, etc.

SPED StudentsSPED Students Studies show that the same research-

based strategies also are effective with students with disabilities--but may need to be taught with more intensity and repetition

Studies show that the same research-based strategies also are effective with students with disabilities--but may need to be taught with more intensity and repetition

Research Suggests A Comprehensive Vocabulary Curriculum Includes:

Research Suggests A Comprehensive Vocabulary Curriculum Includes:

Specific-Word Instruction Word-Learning Strategies Fostering Word Consciousness

Specific-Word Instruction Word-Learning Strategies Fostering Word Consciousness

What is Specific-Word Instruction?What is Specific-Word Instruction?

Step 1: Selecting Words to Teach Step 2: Deciding to what depth you

want students to know these words Step 3: Determining methods to

teach words at determined depth

Step 1: Selecting Words to Teach Step 2: Deciding to what depth you

want students to know these words Step 3: Determining methods to

teach words at determined depth

Rationale for Selecting WordsRationale for Selecting Words

Text may contain too many unknown words for direct instruction

Word meanings may be given within the text as they occur

Excellent instruction would be difficult to provide for a long list of words

Text may contain too many unknown words for direct instruction

Word meanings may be given within the text as they occur

Excellent instruction would be difficult to provide for a long list of words

Issues Related to Choosing Words

Issues Related to Choosing Words

There is no agreed upon list of best individual words to teach

No definitive method for approaching the issue how to choose words

Choices may vary depending on grade level, reading ability, English proficiency

There is no agreed upon list of best individual words to teach

No definitive method for approaching the issue how to choose words

Choices may vary depending on grade level, reading ability, English proficiency

Choosing Specific Words: Possible Approaches

Choosing Specific Words: Possible Approaches

Biemiller (2001) argues for teaching 4,000 root words by the end of grade 2 followed by 500 to 750 roots per year in elementary schools. He and his colleagues are working on a sequential list for teachers.

Relying on recommendations from basals (but some such as Hiebert (2004) argue these words are often too rare to spend valuable time teaching) They sometimes may be too easy as well.

Biemiller (2001) argues for teaching 4,000 root words by the end of grade 2 followed by 500 to 750 roots per year in elementary schools. He and his colleagues are working on a sequential list for teachers.

Relying on recommendations from basals (but some such as Hiebert (2004) argue these words are often too rare to spend valuable time teaching) They sometimes may be too easy as well.

Possible Approaches cont.Possible Approaches cont. Teach a group of words that have related meanings or

related to a single topic

Teach words that are important to the understanding of selection or because of their general usefulness

Teach words that are “conceptually difficult” (i.e., not part of everyday experiences) such as superconductor as opposed to superfluous Nagy (1988)

Teach a group of words that have related meanings or related to a single topic

Teach words that are important to the understanding of selection or because of their general usefulness

Teach words that are “conceptually difficult” (i.e., not part of everyday experiences) such as superconductor as opposed to superfluous Nagy (1988)

Possible Approaches cont. Possible Approaches cont. Teach words teachers want to be

incorporated into their writing or speaking Duin and Graves (1987)

Teach words based on a three-tiered approach Beck, McKeown, & Kucan (2002) Developed through their research

Teach words teachers want to be incorporated into their writing or speaking Duin and Graves (1987)

Teach words based on a three-tiered approach Beck, McKeown, & Kucan (2002) Developed through their research

Three-Tiered ApproachThree-Tiered Approach Tier One words: Most basic words, rarely requiring

instruction in school. Baby, clock, glue, sad

Tier Three words: Words whose frequency of use is quite low, often being limited to specific domains, and probably best learned when needed in a content area. Isotope, lathe, peninsula

Tier Two words: High-frequency words for mature language users; instruction in these words can add productively to an individual’s language ability. Coincidence, absurd, industrious

Tier One words: Most basic words, rarely requiring instruction in school. Baby, clock, glue, sad

Tier Three words: Words whose frequency of use is quite low, often being limited to specific domains, and probably best learned when needed in a content area. Isotope, lathe, peninsula

Tier Two words: High-frequency words for mature language users; instruction in these words can add productively to an individual’s language ability. Coincidence, absurd, industrious

Beck, McKeown, & Kucan, 2002

Criteria for Identifying Tier Two Words

Criteria for Identifying Tier Two Words

Importance and Utility: Words that are characteristic of mature language users and appear frequently across a variety of domains.

Instructional Potential: Words that can be worked with in a variety of ways so that students can build rich representation of them and of their connections to other words and concepts.

Conceptual Understanding: Words for which students understand the general concept but provide precision and specificity in describing the concept.

Importance and Utility: Words that are characteristic of mature language users and appear frequently across a variety of domains.

Instructional Potential: Words that can be worked with in a variety of ways so that students can build rich representation of them and of their connections to other words and concepts.

Conceptual Understanding: Words for which students understand the general concept but provide precision and specificity in describing the concept. Beck, McKeown, & Kucan, 2002

How to Choose Tier Two Words

How to Choose Tier Two Words

List all the words that are likely to be unfamiliar to your students

Analyze your list: Which are Tier Two words? Which are most necessary for comprehension? Which will you teach? In-brief or in-depth?

List all the words that are likely to be unfamiliar to your students

Analyze your list: Which are Tier Two words? Which are most necessary for comprehension? Which will you teach? In-brief or in-depth?

Beck, McKeown, & Kucan, 2002Chapter Two, Bringing Words to Life

Choosing Tier Two Words Group Activity

Choosing Tier Two Words Group Activity

Choosing Tier Two Words: A Model

Choosing Tier Two Words: A Model

Read Owen and Mzee

Go through the process just described and then

Make a list of 4-5 words from the text that you would teach.

Compare/discuss lists as a group

Read Owen and Mzee

Go through the process just described and then

Make a list of 4-5 words from the text that you would teach.

Compare/discuss lists as a group

Some Good ChoicesSome Good Choices

From Owen & Mzee: wallowed, grazing, surging, sanctuary, nuzzles, commotion, affection, resilience, extraordinary

What additional words might you select for ELL, Struggling and SPED students?

From Owen & Mzee: wallowed, grazing, surging, sanctuary, nuzzles, commotion, affection, resilience, extraordinary

What additional words might you select for ELL, Struggling and SPED students?

Step Two: Deciding to What Depth You Want Students to Know Words

Step Two: Deciding to What Depth You Want Students to Know Words

Do you want students to: Simply be able to recognize the word? Know the multiple meanings of the word? Understand the word while reading within the

context of the text? Use the word in a different context? Use the word in oral conversation? Incorporate the word in their writing?

Do you want students to: Simply be able to recognize the word? Know the multiple meanings of the word? Understand the word while reading within the

context of the text? Use the word in a different context? Use the word in oral conversation? Incorporate the word in their writing?

If you want students to understand words at a deeper level, then…

If you want students to understand words at a deeper level, then…

Provide lots of examples Relate words to students’ prior knowledge Elaborate on the meanings of the words Present contrasting words

It’s like this, it’s not like that Provide lots of repetition of the words Use gestures, pictures, visuals, etc. to help convey the

meanings of words Teach the word conceptually Relate the word to other related words that students already

know Repeatedly expose students to the words in different

contexts

Provide lots of examples Relate words to students’ prior knowledge Elaborate on the meanings of the words Present contrasting words

It’s like this, it’s not like that Provide lots of repetition of the words Use gestures, pictures, visuals, etc. to help convey the

meanings of words Teach the word conceptually Relate the word to other related words that students already

know Repeatedly expose students to the words in different

contexts

A Few Methods for Teaching Specific Words at a Deep Level

A Few Methods for Teaching Specific Words at a Deep Level Use conceptual approaches to

teaching vocabulary such as:1. Text Talk2. Concept Picture Sort3. Semantic feature analysis4. Vocabulary Pictures5. Vocabulary Boxes6. Word Squares

Use conceptual approaches to teaching vocabulary such as:

1. Text Talk2. Concept Picture Sort3. Semantic feature analysis4. Vocabulary Pictures5. Vocabulary Boxes6. Word Squares

Demonstration of Text TalkWith Make Way for Ducklings

Beck et al’s Basic Text Talk Instructions

Beck et al’s Basic Text Talk Instructions

1. Read the story.2. Conceptualize the word within the

story.3. Have children say the word.4. Provide a student-friendly definition.5. Engage them in activities using the

word.6. Have children say the word.

1. Read the story.2. Conceptualize the word within the

story.3. Have children say the word.4. Provide a student-friendly definition.5. Engage them in activities using the

word.6. Have children say the word.

Specific Word Centers

Center Reflection: Think-Pair-ShareCenter Reflection: Think-Pair-ShareConsider the following questions individually:

1. With what activities were you already familiar? Unfamiliar?2. How did the activities enrich your understanding of specific

words?3. What aspects of these activities do you think your students

may find challenging? How can you help your students overcome these challenges? What adaptations might you have to make?

4. How can you incorporate these activities into your classroom?

Then, turn to a neighbor and share your responses.

Consider the following questions individually:1. With what activities were you already familiar? Unfamiliar?2. How did the activities enrich your understanding of specific

words?3. What aspects of these activities do you think your students

may find challenging? How can you help your students overcome these challenges? What adaptations might you have to make?

4. How can you incorporate these activities into your classroom?

Then, turn to a neighbor and share your responses.

Word-Learning StrategiesWord-Learning Strategies Word-part clues:

Prefixes, Suffixes, & Affixes Context clues

K: Model using context clues through think-alouds

1-2: Instruct students how to use context clues

3+: Teach the different types of context clues

Word-part clues: Prefixes, Suffixes, & Affixes

Context clues K: Model using context clues through

think-alouds 1-2: Instruct students how to use context

clues 3+: Teach the different types of context

clues

Some Methods for Teaching Students Word-Learning Strategies

Some Methods for Teaching Students Word-Learning Strategies

Concept-Definition Map Word-Part Clue Evaluation Word Part Web Memory Word Families Prefix Crossword

Concept-Definition Map Word-Part Clue Evaluation Word Part Web Memory Word Families Prefix Crossword

Word-Learning Strategies CentersWord-Learning Strategies Centers

Word-Learning Strategies Center Reflection: Think-Pair-Share

Word-Learning Strategies Center Reflection: Think-Pair-Share

Consider the following questions individually:1. With what activities were you already familiar?

Unfamiliar?2. How did the activities enrich your understanding of how

to learn words on your own?3. What aspects of these activities do you think your

students may find challenging? How can you help your students overcome these challenges? What adaptations might you have to make?

4. How can you incorporate these activities into your classroom?

Then, turn to a neighbor and share your responses.

Consider the following questions individually:1. With what activities were you already familiar?

Unfamiliar?2. How did the activities enrich your understanding of how

to learn words on your own?3. What aspects of these activities do you think your

students may find challenging? How can you help your students overcome these challenges? What adaptations might you have to make?

4. How can you incorporate these activities into your classroom?

Then, turn to a neighbor and share your responses.

Teaching Word-ConsciousnessTeaching Word-Consciousness

Word Play -riddles, rhymes and games

Word Histories and Origins - Latin, French, Spanish connections

Idioms, Similes and Metaphors

Word Play -riddles, rhymes and games

Word Histories and Origins - Latin, French, Spanish connections

Idioms, Similes and Metaphors

Example of Word-Consciousness“Teacher hands out little books called, Dinosaur Riddles. T has students read the riddles to themselves and then asks for students to guess the answers. Teacher explains to students why the riddles are funny. Example: What do you call a dinosaur that smashes everything in its path? Tyrannosaurus Wrecks.”

Other Ideas for Fostering Word Consciousness

Other Ideas for Fostering Word Consciousness

Word Wizard: bringing in examples from home of words taught at school

Use sophisticated words in the classroom - “It was magnanimous of your mom to send in these cupcakes”

Share favorite words with each other - “My favorite word is epiphany, or serendipity…because…it means…and it sounds so pretty…”

Word Wizard: bringing in examples from home of words taught at school

Use sophisticated words in the classroom - “It was magnanimous of your mom to send in these cupcakes”

Share favorite words with each other - “My favorite word is epiphany, or serendipity…because…it means…and it sounds so pretty…”

Point out interesting language in stories students write - “Those were great words…”Or in stories you read to them - ”It was fun to read the words …the author included in her story.”Play games such as Scrabble and crossword puzzlesRead and write riddles (maybe with themes such as

dinosaurs, Halloween, pets)Explain and use figures of speech -

“She’s as happy as a clam” “Tough as nails” Read and write poetry

Ideas for Fostering Word Consciousness?

What do you already do in your classrooms? Let’s brainstorm ideas.

A Review of What a Vocabulary Classroom Includes:

A Review of What a Vocabulary Classroom Includes:

Student-friendly definition Compare and contrast Elaboration Gestures Real, concrete objects/hands-on experiences Teacher examples Student examples Repetition Connections to students’ experiences Fun with words

Student-friendly definition Compare and contrast Elaboration Gestures Real, concrete objects/hands-on experiences Teacher examples Student examples Repetition Connections to students’ experiences Fun with words

ConclusionsConclusions

What will you try to incorporate/implement in your practice?

What challenges do you foresee regarding this implementation?

About what do you still have questions?

What will you try to incorporate/implement in your practice?

What challenges do you foresee regarding this implementation?

About what do you still have questions?

Contact InformationContact Information Kristin Nelson: kristinnelson4@comcast.net Naomi Watkins: naomiwatkins@gmail.com

University of Utah1705 E. Central Campus Dr.

Room 142Salt Lake City, UT 84112

Kristin Nelson: kristinnelson4@comcast.net Naomi Watkins: naomiwatkins@gmail.com

University of Utah1705 E. Central Campus Dr.

Room 142Salt Lake City, UT 84112

If you don’t mind, we would greatly appreciate if you left us with your completed self-inventories.