University of Durham Institute for Computational Cosmology Carlos S. Frenk Institute for...

Post on 17-Jan-2016

212 views 0 download

transcript

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Carlos S. Frenk Institute for Computational Cosmology,

Durham

Galaxy clusters

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Galaxy clusters - TiajinCarlos Frenk

Institute of Computational Cosmology University of Durham

• Introduction to the large-scale structure of the Universe

• The formation of dark matter halos

• The structure of dark matter halos

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

What is the Universe made of?

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

What is the universe made of?

critical density = density that makes univ. flat: = 1 for a flat univ.

(of which stars, Cole etal ‘02) s = 0.0023 ± 0.0003 • Baryons b = 0.044 ± 0.004

density critical density

• Radiation (CMB, T=2.726±0.005 oK) r = 4.7 x 10-5

• Dark matter (cold dark matter) dm =0.20 ± 0.04

• Dark energy (cosm. const. =0.75 ±

0.04 bdm(assuming Hubble parameter h=0.7)

• Neutrinos = 3 x 10-5 if m 6 x 10-2 (<mev)

mass+rel

+vac

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

m=0.24±0.04 >>

b=0.044±0.004

all matter baryons

Dark matter must be non-baryonic

The nature of the dark matter

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Non-baryonic dark matter candidates

hot neutrino a few eV

warm ? a few keV

cold axion

neutralino10-5eV->100 GeV

Type candidate mass

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

What is the Universe made of?

Dark energy

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Evidence for from high-z supernovae

SN type Ia (standard candles) at z~0.5 are fainter than

expected even if the Universe were empty

The cosmic expansion must have been

accelerating since the light was emitted

a/a0=1/(1+z)

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

a.

+ kc 2 =8π

3Gρa2

H 2 1− Ωm − Ωγ − ΩΛ( ) = −kc 2

a2

Friedmann equations

For a homogeneous & isotropic Universe

a = expansion factor, k= curvature

mass+rel

+vacπ

GH 23

8=Ω

G

cvac π

8

2=

a

aH

.

=

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Evidence for from high-z supernovae

Distant SN are fainter than expected if expansion were decelerating

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

a.

+ kc 2 =8π

3Gρa2

H 2 1− Ωm − Ωγ − ΩΛ( ) = −kc 2

a2

)(3 22 cpda

dac

+−=

)13(3

4..

+−= waGa π

Friedmann equations

For a homogeneous & isotropic Universe

a = expansion factor, k= curvature

2nd law of thermodynamics:

2cwp =

p= pressure

Equation of state:

mass+rel

+vacπ

GH 23

8=Ω

G

cvac π

8

2=

a

aH

.

=

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Friedmann equations

p = wρc 2where totmass+rel

+VAC a-3 a-4 const?

..

a = −4π

3Gρa(3w + 1)

c 2adρ

da= −3( p + ρc 2)

If VAC = VAC (z,x) and 3

1−<w quintessence

If vacconst ,dda

0 p c 2 w 1

Accelerated expansion

⇒ 3w + 1< 0 ⇒ ˙ ̇ a > 0 ⇒ Expansion accelerates

In general,

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

2cwp =

)13(3

4..

+−= waGa π

Friedmann equations

013 >+w

where

At early times the universe is always decelerating

totmass+rel

+ a-3 a-4 const?

For matter or radiation:

There must be a transition between decelerating and accelerating expansion

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Supernovae Ia and dark energy

Reiss etal ‘04Redshift z

(m

-M)

(ma

g)

Transition from decelerated to accelerated expansion at z~0.5

16 new Sn Ia -- 6 @ z>1.25

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The large-structure of the Universe

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Results from the “2-degree field” galaxy survey

250 nights at 4m AAT 1997-2002

Anglo-Australian team

221,000 redshifts to bj<19.45

Median z=0.11

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

100

0 m

illion lig

ht yea

rs

QuickTime™ and aYUV420 codec decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The origin of the large-structure of the Universe

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The beginning of the Universe

In 1980, a revolutionary idea was proposed: our universe started off in an unstable state (vacuum energy) and as a result expanded very fast in a short period of time cosmic inflation

Inflation

Initially, Universe is trapped in false vacuum

Scalar field

Universe decays to true vacuum keeping v~ const

Universe oscillates converting energy into particles

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Inflation for beginners

At early times k=0. So, Vacconst.

˙ a

a= const Universe expands exponentially

Inflation ends when Vac decay and Universe reheats

a.

kc 2 8π3

Ga22

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Conventionalinflation

Chaoticinflation

Cosmic Inflation

t=10-35 s

Inflation theory predicts:

1. Flat geometry (=1)

(eternal expansion)

2. Small ripples in mass distribution

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Quantum fluctuations are blown up to macroscopic scales during inflation

Generation of primordial fluctuations

Because of quantum fluctuations, different parts of the Universe finish inflating at slightly different times

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Spectrum of inhomogeneities

x

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Standard inflation predicts:

1. FLAT GEOMETRY:

2. 2~ k

3

k

2

k2

kn

n = 1

Gaussian amplitudes

123=

+

Hm

Cosmic Inflation

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Evolution of an adiabatic perturbation in CDM universe

M=1015 Mo=1, h=0.5

Dak matter baryons

radiationFlu

ctu

atio

n a

mpl

itud

e

Log a(t)/a0

Horizon entry

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The origin of cosmic structureQUANTUM FLUCTUATIONS:

k2

kn

n = 1

Gaussian amplitudes

Inflation (t~10-35 s)

P(k)=Akn T2(k,t)

Damping (nature of dark matter)+

n=1

Mezaros damping

Free streaming

P(k)

Transfer functionRh(teq)

• Hot DM (eg ~30 ev neutrino)

- Top-down formation

• Cold DM (eg ~neutralino)

- Bottom-up (hierachical)

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The microwave background radiation

z =1000

The microwave background radiation

Plasma

z =

T=2.73 K

380 000 years after the big Bang

inflation

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Temperature anisotropies in the CMBIntrinsic anisotropies at last scattering:• Gravitational redshift: Sachs-Wolfe effect• Doppler effect• Adiabatic perturbationsLine of sight effects:

• Time varying potentials: ISW effect• Compton scattering: SZ effect

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The origin of cosmic structure

n=1

Mezaros damping

Free streaming

Large scales

P(k)

Rh(teq)

Small scales

• Hot DM (eg ~30 ev neutrino)

- Top-down formation

• Cold DM (eg ~neutralino)

- Bottom-up (hierachical)

QUANTUM FLUCTUATIONS:

k2

kn

n = 1

Gaussian amplitudes

Inflation (t~10-35 s)

P(k)=Akn T2(k,t)

Damping (nature of dark matter)+

Transfer function

• Hot DM (eg ~30 ev neutrino)

- Top-down formation

• Cold DM (eg ~neutralino)

- Bottom-up (hierachical)

CMB

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

QuickTime™ and aGIF decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

The acoustic peaks in the CMB

Wayne hu

http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/

If M<Mjeans the photon-baryon fluid oscillates

of CMB acoustic peak sound horizon at trec

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The cosmic microwave background radiation (CMB) provides a window to the universe at t~3x105 yrs

In 1992 COBE discovered temperature fluctuations (T/T~10-5) consistent with inflation predictions

The CMB

1992

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The CMB

1992

2003

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

WMAP temperature anisotropies in the CMB

Bennett etal ‘03

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The Emergence of the Cosmic Initial Conditions

curvature

total density

baryons

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

The Emergence of the Cosmic Initial Conditions

• > 105 independent ~ 5 measurements of T are fit by an a priori model with 6 (physical) parameters

• Best CDM model has: t

o= 13.7±0.2 Gyr

h=0.71±0.03 8=0.84±0.04

t=1.02±0.02

m=0.27±0.04

b=0.044±0.004

e=0.17±0.07 (Bennett etal 03)

• Parameters in excellent agreement with other data T-P x-corr Adiabatic fluctns

curvature

total density

baryons

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

123=

+

H1. FLAT GEOMETRY:

2. QUANTUM FLUCTUATIONS: k2

kn

n = 1

Gaussian amplitudes

Inflation (t~10-35 s)

adiabatic

Dark matter

CMB (t~3x105 yrs)Structure

(t~13x109yrs)

The origin of cosmic structure

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

Evolution of spherical perturbations

University of Durham

Institute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational CosmologyInstitute for Computational Cosmology

n=1

damping

Free streaming

Calculating the evolution of cosmic structure

N-body simulation

“Cosmology machine”