Post on 30-Oct-2014
description
transcript
© 2014 IBM Corporation
Smarter Care
Paul Grundy MD, MPH - IBM Director, Healthcare Transformation August, 2014
Utah Hospitals Better Care, Reducing Costs, Improving service
Population Health Patient Centered Medical Home
© 2014 IBM Corporation 2
Smarter Care
Paul Grundy MD MPH Bio
• “Godfather” of the Patient Centered Medical Home• IBM Global Director Healthcare Transformation • President of PCPCC • Member Institute of Medicine• Member Board ACGME • Professor Univ. of Utah Department Family Medicine
• Winner NCQA national Quality Award • A Leader of MOH level taskforce primary care transformation 8
nations: USA, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, Holland, Denmark, UK, Belgium,
• Univ. of California MD, John Hopkins Trained
© 2014 IBM Corporation 3
Smarter Care
PopulationHealth
System Integrator
PatientExperience
The System Integrator
Creates a partnership across the medical neighborhood
Drives PCMH primary care redesign
Offers a utility for population health and financial
management
Per Capita Cost
Public Health
Away from Episode of Care to Management of Population
Hospital Hospital
Community Health Community Health
© 2014 IBM Corporation 4
Smarter Care
4
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001 2004
United StatesGermanyCanadaFranceAustraliaUnited Kingdom
Average health spend per capita ($US PPP)
How do you start to fix the foundational issue around why our healthcare system is so expensive and yet so broken??
Source: K. Davis, C. Schoen, S. Guterman, T. Shih, S. C. Schoenbaum, and I. Weinbaum, Slowing the Growth of U.S. Health Care Expenditures: What Are the Options?, The Commonwealth Fund, January 2007, updated with 2007 OECD data
© 2014 IBM Corporation 5
Smarter Care
Current Payment Systems Penalize Primary care Prevention Quality and Reward Volume We have discover the enemy --- we buy garbage!!!! IBM other large Buyers are demanding change in that (BIG TIME)
PreventableCondition
ContinuedHealth
HealthyConsumer
NoHospitalization
Acute Care Episode
Efficient, Successful Outcome
Complications,Infections,
Readmissions
High-CostSuccessfulOutcome
$Fee-for-Service PaymentPays More for Bad Outcomesand Less When People Stay Healthy
IBM paying first $$ primary care!!
© 2014 IBM Corporation 6
Smarter Care
© 2014 IBM Corporation 7
Smarter Care
7
Reason IBM pays 1st dollar primary care
“Not surprisingly, those patients with the strongest relationships to specific primary care physicians were more likely to receive recommended tests, medication adherence and preventive care.
In fact, this sense of connection with a single doctor had a greater influence on the kind of preventive care received than the patient’s age, sex, race or ethnicity.”
Patient–Physician Connectedness and Quality of Primary Care Steven J. Atlas, MD, MPH; Richard W. Grant, MD, MPH; Timothy G. Ferris, MD; Yuchiao Chang, PhD; and Michael J. Barry, MD 3 March 2009 | Volume 150 Issue 5 | Pages 325-335
© 2014 IBM Corporation 8
Smarter Care
“We do heart surgery more often than anyone, but we need to, because patients are not given the kind of coordinated primary care that would prevent chronic heart disease from becoming acute.” -- George Halverson’s (CEO Kaiser) from “Healthcare Reform Now
© 2014 IBM Corporation 9
Smarter Care
36.3% Drop in hospital days32.2% Drop in ER use12.8% Increase Chronic Medication use -15.6% Total cost 10.5% Drop Inpatient specialty care costs 18.9% Ancillary costs down 15.0% Outpatient specialty down
Outcomes of Implementing Patient Centered Medical Home Interventions: A Review of the Evidence from Prospective Evaluation Studies in the US - PCPCC Oct 2012
Smarter Healthcare
© 2014 IBM Corporation 10
Smarter Care
10
Creating Value Through Patient Centered Medical Homes
October 22, 2009
Bob Kocher, MDNational Economic CouncilSpecial Assistant to the President
© 2014 IBM Corporation 11
Smarter Care
11
MOVING TOWARDS A MORE COORDINATED SYSTEM
11
Cooperating in new efforts to better coordinate care
• Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs)
• Community health teams
• HIT
Working with innovative reimbursement structures
• Bundled payments
• Expanded pay-for-Quality
• Readmission incentives
• Outlier reductions
Improving health outcomes
• Prevention (primary and secondary)
• Chronic disease management
• Patient engagement and education
• Data transparency
Patient Centered
Medical Homes quality
improving/value creating systems
© 2014 IBM Corporation 12
Smarter Care
12
HEALTH INSURANCE REFORM WILL IMPROVE THE WAY CARE IS DELIVERED FOR ALL AMERICANS
12
•Primary care has a critical role to play in reform
•Health insurance reform will facilitate adoption of advanced primary care models (PCMH)
Changes to the delivery system
•Incentives quality not quantity of medical care
•No cost sharing for preventive care
•Better coordinate care for patients with chronic diseases
•Ensure patients receive clinically recommended treatments and follow-up
•Reduce duplicative testing and rehospitalizations
•Integrate with community health resources to provide more holistic patient care
•Expand coverage and access
© 2014 IBM Corporation 13
Smarter Care
Maryland July 2014 -- CareFirst saved $267 million with its medical home
• 11 percent fewer days in the hospital • 8 percent fewer hospital readmissions.
http://www.fiercehealthpayer.com/story/medicaid-can-reap-rewards-medical-homes/2014-07-15
© 2014 IBM Corporation 14
Smarter Care
Rural New York July 2014
Costs for Medicaid patients dropped from $334 to $266, according to a recent “risk
adjusted” analysis.
http://poststar.com/news/local/medical-home-program-gains-traction/article_5811380c-2ee9-11e3-8548-001a4bcf887a.html
© 2014 IBM Corporation 15
Smarter Care
•9.9 percent lower rate of adult ER visits•27.5 percent lower rate of adult ambulatory care sensitive inpatient stays•11.8 percent lower rate of adult primary care sensitive ER visits•8.7 percent lower rate of adult high-tech radiology usage•14.9 percent lower rate of pediatric ER visits•21.3 percent lower rate of pediatric primary-care sensitive ER visits
24 July 2014 Michigan Blues’ patient-centered medical home program shows statewide transformation of care YEAR 6
4,022 primary care doctors at 1,422 practices around the state in its sixth year of operation. These practices care for more than 1.2 million BCBSM members
© 2014 IBM Corporation 16
Smarter Care
© 2014 IBM Corporation 17
Smarter Care
44% reduction in hospital costs
21% reduction in overall medical costs.
160 PCMH practices Pennsylvania from 2009 to 12
Number of patients with poorly controlled diabetes declined by 45%
44% reduction in hospital costs
21% reduction in overall medical costs.
160 PCMH practices Pennsylvania from 2009 to 12
Number of patients with poorly controlled diabetes declined by 45%
http://www.ajmc.com/publications/issue/2014/2014-vol20-n3/Medical-Homes-and-Cost-and-Utilization-Among-High-Risk-Patients#sthash.qR8uWb4t.dpuf
http://www.ajmc.com/publications/issue/2014/2014-vol20-n3/Medical-Homes-and-Cost-and-Utilization-Among-High-Risk-Patients#sthash.qR8uWb4t.dpuf
PCMH Pennsylvania June, 2014
Conclusions: PCMH practices had significantly reduced costs and utilization for the highest risk patients, particularly with respect to inpatient care.
© 2014 IBM Corporation 18
Smarter Care
Ogden UT ,
USA 2012
© 2014 IBM Corporation 19
Smarter Care
© 2014 IBM Corporation 20
Smarter CareMobileFirst Patient Consumer
© 2014 IBM Corporation 21
Smarter Care
PreventiveMedicine
MedicationRefills Acute Care
Nursing
Test Results
Master Builder
DOCTOR
Source: Southcentral Foundation, Anchorage AK
BehavioralHealth
CaseManager
MedicalAssistants
Chronic DiseaseMonitoring
Practice transformation away from episode of care
© 2014 IBM Corporation 22
Smarter Care
MedicationRefills
ChronicDisease
MonitoringTest
Results
AcuteCare
PreventiveMedicine
Point of Care Testing
Acute Mental Health
Complaint
ChronicDisease
ComplianceBarriers
HealthcareSupport
Team Behavioral Health
MedicalAssistants
CaseManager Provider
Source: Southcentral Foundation, Anchorage AK
PCMH Parallel Team Flow Design: the glue is real data, not a doctor’s brain
© 2014 IBM Corporation 23
Smarter Care
Today’s Care PCMH Care
My patients are those who make appointments to see meMy patients are those who make appointments to see me
Our patients are the population community Our patients are the population community
Care is determined by today’s problem and time available todayCare is determined by today’s problem and time available today
Care is determined by a proactive plan to meet patient needs with or without visits
Care is determined by a proactive plan to meet patient needs with or without visits
Care varies by scheduled time and memory or skill of the doctorCare varies by scheduled time and memory or skill of the doctor Care is standardized according to
evidence-based guidelinesCare is standardized according to evidence-based guidelines
Patients are responsible for coordinating their own carePatients are responsible for coordinating their own care
A prepared team of professionals coordinates all patients’ careA prepared team of professionals coordinates all patients’ care
I know I deliver high quality care because I’m well trainedI know I deliver high quality care because I’m well trained We measure our quality and make
rapid changes to improve itWe measure our quality and make rapid changes to improve it
It’s up to the patient to tell us what happened to themIt’s up to the patient to tell us what happened to them
We track tests & consultations, and follow-up after ED & hospitalWe track tests & consultations, and follow-up after ED & hospital
Clinic operations center on meeting the doctor’s needsClinic operations center on meeting the doctor’s needs
A multidisciplinary team works at the top of our licenses to serve patientsA multidisciplinary team works at the top of our licenses to serve patients
Slide from Daniel Duffy MD School of Community Medicine Tulsa Oklahoma
© 2014 IBM Corporation 24
Smarter Care
Superb Access to Care
Patient Engagement in Care
Clinical Information Systems, Registry
Care Coordination
Team Care
Communication Patient Feedback
Mobile easy to use and Available Information
Defining the Care Centered on Patient
© 2014 IBM Corporation 25
Smarter Care
Trajectory to Value Based Purchasing: Achieving Real Care Coordination and Outcome Measurement
Source: Hudson Valley Initiative
© 2014 IBM Corporation 26
Smarter CarePayment reform requires more than one method, you have dials, adjust them!!!
“fee for health” fee for value “fee for outcome”“fee for process” “fee for belonging“fee for service” “fee for satisfaction”
“fee for health” fee for value “fee for outcome”“fee for process” “fee for belonging“fee for service” “fee for satisfaction”
© 2014 IBM Corporation 27
Smarter Care
Give me enough medals and I'll win you any war' Napoleon Bonaparte – not just the $Green$ that brings JOY
The Science of Rewards, incentives
© 2014 IBM Corporation 28
Smarter Care
% Total Healthcare
Spend
% of Members
Those who are well or think they are well
Those with chronic illness
Those with severe, acute illness or injuries
Benefit Redesign - Patient Engagement Different Strategies forDifferent Healthcare Spend Segments
© 2014 IBM Corporation 29
Smarter Care
29
IBM’s Strategy Moves Costs From Below Market to Market Leader
Best in market purchasing strategy Redesigned plan mix to use PPO
model Employee-centric allocation of IBM
investment with dependent subsidy reduced
Investments in prevention, primary care and chronic disease management
Employee cost sharing keeps pace with inflation
Award-winning wellness strategy providing support for healthy living; onsite screenings and immunizations
Source for benchmarks: Average of survey results from Kaiser Family Foundation, Hewitt Associates and Towers Perrin
4.8%
9.7%
4.5%
6.6%
10.6%
6.4%7.0%
4.9%
2.2%
5.6% 4.6%
3.7%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
8.0%
9.0%
10.0%
11.0%
12.0%
20042005 2006 2007 2008
2020099
Net
IBM
Med
ical
Tre
nd
Benchmark Net IBM Trend
$1B Saved in 6 Years
© 2014 IBM Corporation 30
Smarter Care
30 © 2009 IBM Corporation6
IBM Population Risk Has Moved Toward Improved Health
Wellness programs have had a dramatic impact on the health of our employees
– Percentage of employees with high health risks reduced by 55%
– Percentage at low risk increased by double digits
Reduction in health risks translates into health claims cost reduction
– Represents an almost $300 reduction in per employee costs or a $29M savings
2004 – 2007 Health Risk Assessment Participation
*$392M = 2007 dollars applied to 2004 health risk profile.**Total costs based on 103K total self-insured population and represent employee costs only (not including dependents)
Projected 2007 spend with no health risk improvement
Actual spend
$7,555
$4,638
$2,660
$392M* $363M**$29M (7%) difference
55.4%68.3%
31.8%
26.0%
12.8%5.7%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
2004 Profile 2007 Profile
% o
f A
ll H
RA
Par
tic
ipan
ts
High Risk (4+ risks)
Medium Risk (2-3risks)
Low Risk (0-1 risk)
Shift in Health Risk Profile = Savings in Healthcare Claims Costs
Note: Includes ALL participants each year, NOT MATCHED SAMPLES
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
% o
f A
ll H
RA
Pa
rtic
ipan
ts
High Risk (4+ risks)
Medium Risk (2-3 risks)
55.4%59.2%
64.8% 68.3%
31.8% 30.2%28.7% 26.0%
12.8% 5.7%10.6% 6.5%
2004 2005 2006 2007(N=54K) (N=70K) (N=73K) (N=75K)
Low Risk (0-1 risk)
$363M$369M
$383M
$401M$398M$395M
$392M
$340
$360
$380
$400
$420
2004 2005 2006 2007
IBM
Med
& R
x Pa
id C
laim
s Co
sts
($M
's)
(Cal
cula
ted
base
d on
200
7 do
llars
)
2005 2006 20073 Year Total
Est. savings between IBM health risk improvement &
expected risk increase$12M $29M $38M $79M Total
Wellness programs have had a dramatic impact on the health of our employees ‘04 to ’07
High health risk population reduced 55%Low health risk population increased 23%
Reduction in health risks translates into savings in health claims costs compared to expected trends with no wellness interventions
$279M estimated savings for 2004 to 2013 period
Expected cost increase with no IBM population
health risk improvement*
With actual IBM population health risk
improvement**
© 2014 IBM Corporation 31
Smarter Care
Public Health Prevention
Specialists
PCMH 2.0 in Action
Community Care Team
Nurse CoordinatorSocial Workers
DieticiansCommunity Health Workers
Care Coordinators
Public Health Prevention HEALTH WELLNESS
Hospitals
PCMH
PCMH
Health IT Framework
Global Information Framework
Evaluation Framework
Operations
A Coordinated Health System
35
© 2014 IBM Corporation 32
Smarter Care
2009 2010 2011 2013 2014Percentage of Vermont population participating 6.7% 9.8% 13.0% 42.0% 86.0%
Participating population 42,179 61,880 82,332227,04
5654,852 # Community Care Teams 2 3 4 6 11
© 2014 IBM Corporation 33
Smarter Care
33
The New Yorker: The Cost Conundrum June 1st 2009
• When you look across the spectrum from Grand Junction to McAllen you see A threefold difference in the costs of care—
• you come to realize that we are witnessing a battle for the soul of American medicine. Somewhere in the United States at this moment, a patient with chest pain, or a tumor, or a cough is seeing a doctor. And the damning question we have to ask is whether the doctor is set up to meet the needs of the patient, first and foremost, or to maximize revenue.
• The lesson of the high-quality, low-cost communities is that someone has to be accountable for the totality of care. Otherwise, you get a system that has no brakes. You get McAllen.
• The foundation of this is at the Micro level someone has to be Accountable for your care -- that is the PCMH in most of the civilized world !!!
• primary care doctors per 100,000 Grand Junction, 106, McAllen has just 45
• OR WHERE is the ADULT supervision!!!
© 2014 IBM Corporation 34
Smarter Care
Healthcare Will Transform
Data Driven
Every person has a plan
Team based
Managing a population down to the person
.
© 2014 IBM Corporation 35
Smarter Care
Hospital
Payer
EmployerCommunity
Government
Primary Care
Provider
Other Caregivers
Pharmaceutical Manufacturers
Nurse
Specialists
Social Worker
PCMH
Patient
The PCMH model impacts stakeholders across the continuum of care
Pharma: Improved communication platforms and relationships with healthcare providers, patients and payers; increased sales through improved patient identification, diagnosis, and treatment; recognized as a key player in the patient health delivery value chain
Payer: Improved member and employer satisfaction, lower costs, opportunity for new business models
Employer: Lower healthcare costs, more productive workforce, improved employee satisfaction
Government: Lower healthcare costs, healthier population
Patient: Better, safer, less costly, more convenient care and better overall health, productive long-term relationship with a PCP
Primary Care Provider: Increased focus on the patient and their health, greater access to health information; higher reimbursement; more PCPs
Specialists: Better referrals, more integrated into whole patient care, better follow up less re- hospitalizations
Hospital: Lower number of admissions and re-admissions for chronic disease patients; able to focus on acute care issues
© 2014 IBM Corporation 36
Smarter Care
© 2014 IBM Corporation 37
Smarter Care
1. Pursue Electronic Patient Management and engagement rather than Electronic Patient Records 2. Bring to bear upon every patient encounter what is known rather than what a particular provider knows. 3. Make it easier to do it right than not to do it at all. 4. Continuous performance improvement. 5. Infuse new knowledge and decision-making tools throughout an organization instantly.
© 2014 IBM Corporation 38
Smarter Care
6. Establish and promote continuity of care with patient education, information and plans of care.
7. Enlist patients as partners and collaborators in their own health improvement.
8. Evaluate the care of patients and populations of patients longitudinally.
9. Audit provider performance based on the Consortium for Physician Performance Improvement Data Sets.
10. Create multiple case-management tools which are integrated in an intuitive and interchangeable fashion giving patients the benefit of expert knowledge about specific conditions while they get the benefit of a global approach to their total health
© 2014 IBM Corporation 39
Smarter Care
Practices Features -- - Emphasis on care coordination and system navigation, System Integrator, PCMH role for family physician in integrated system - Big push on population health management - Care teams with PCP + a variety of other professions, e.g., nursing, pharmacy, public health and mental health.
Technology Use - Better population health data stemming from centralized data based EHR through integrated system. - Adoption of telemedicine, Establish Primary Care Technology Center (PCTC), a research and training entity, to fuel adoption of efficacious technology in practice, patient engagement tools. Modern, flexible, sophisticated system, developed in partnership with technology providers. -Multi-modal communication w/ patients .
© 2014 IBM Corporation 40
Smarter Care
Building a Workforce -- Training in the use of population health management, data management and public health tools - Dual degrees – MD + MBAs, MPHs - .Add’l training in interprofessional collaboration, EHR data usage, and integrated practice management.
Research Focus -- Conclusive evidence about system wide quality improvement and cost savings of robust primary care.- Rise of Continuum-Based Research Networks, applied research efforts to improve clinical pathways. - Research builds case for reductions in Total Cost of Care (at system level), research into technologies most inpactful on Triple Aim. - FM becomes trusted source of best practices to meet Triple Aim, .Focus on issues that relate to patients owning their own health through patient experience and engagement research
© 2014 IBM Corporation 41
Smarter Care
Collaboration -- - Family medicine’s partnership with payers and the integrated systems, to exchange ideas about how to best deploy family physicians and represent their colleagues’ interests to these systems - Subspecialists – to ensure great working relationships within systems. - Primary care professionals – to achieve the best possible outcomes in service of Triple Aim. Payers, particularly CMS – to ensure success of alternative payment pilots.- Primary Care Nurse Practitioners (to work together in pursuit of expanded role of Primary Care, Technology manufacturers) to provide advice on how to improve technology in use by FPs,
Key Investments -- Curricular overhaul and research effort to prepare residents for work in integrated systems, tools for data being made into actionable information in population management, advance clinical decision support
© 2014 IBM Corporation 42
Smarter Care
Thank you
© 2014 IBM Corporation 43
Smarter Care
A comprehensive approach helps reduce costs while improving care
Apply new insights from interactions and outcomes
to enable continuous transformation
LEARNING
Identify and influence individuals and populations, and recognize
intervention opportunities
INTERVENTION
COORDINATIONDeliver care and monitor progress
across clinical and social requirements
COLLABORATIONAssess and engage individuals and stakeholders to drive individualized care plans
Drive evidence-based andstandardized care planning
KNOWLEDGE
WELLNESS
43
© 2014 IBM Corporation 44
Smarter Care
© 2014 IBM Corporation 45
Smarter Care
45
© 2014 IBM Corporation 46
Smarter Care
Trademarks and notes
© IBM Corporation 2014• IBM, the IBM logo, ibm.com, and Cúram are trademarks or registered trademarks of International Business
Machines Corporation in the United States, other countries, or both. If these and other IBM trademarked terms are marked on their first occurrence in this information with the appropriate symbol (® or ™), these symbols indicate U.S. registered or common law trademarks owned by IBM at the time this information was published. Such trademarks may also be registered or common law trademarks in other countries. A current list of IBM trademarks is available on the Web at “Copyright and trademark information” at ibm.com/legal/copytrade.shtml.
• Other company, product, and service names may be trademarks or service marks of others.• References in this publication to IBM products or services do not imply that IBM intends to make them available in all
countries in which IBM operates.
© 2014 IBM Corporation 47
Smarter Care
Objectives
1) Participant will understand/be able to discuss the important trend of PCMH in health care 2) Participant will understand/be able to explore the rationale and supporting evidence for PCMH 3)Participant will understand/be able comprehend the impact on patients, providers and payers
Disclosure – I am a full time Employee of IBM –IBM and other PCPCC executive member companies have supported by talks on PCMH.