Why use Bayesian Networks for poverty analysis

Post on 05-Dec-2014

746 views 2 download

description

Presented at the Basin Focal Project Poverty Mapping Workshop, November 2007, Chiang Mai, Thailand

transcript

BN, BBN, CPN, ‘Bayesian Networks’

Why use BN• To estimate quantities which are unobservableq• Modelling – building models, ‘elicitation’• Mixed data, probabilistic relationships

– medical diagnosis– inference, risk, decision support– estimation of physical statep y– ‘data integration’

Example : Dryland Salinity WA ………….[ land condition, forest changes]

SALINITY : Information Gap, Policy & Management Problem :– where is it, where changed, where will it.. MAP, MONITOR, PREDICT

BIG AREA~230,000 sq km

Knowledge about SALINITY PROCESS – rising saline groundwater as the result of clearingrising saline groundwater as the result of clearing

Sample ‘truth’Observationaldata – spatial Y/N (date?)

Knowledge about PROCESS

Knowledge ??Landscape position importantLandscape position important- more likely in valleys

Salinity affects vegetation- Visible effects ? – images

G d t l l S il tGroundwater levels Soil type, Vegetation type, etc ???

Network diagram – dryland salinity – FIRST VERSION

Is each location (likely to be) saline or not ? - Not observable directly

Meaning of network, then

- A. How do we observe (get data) on ‘Landform Position’ ? everywhere- B. How do we observe ‘vegetation condition’ ?

(A from processing DEM; B [surrogate] classification from Landsat)

Network – dryland salinity – FIRST VERSION - getting the data

DEM IMAGE

processing task

classification task

DEM

‘Raw data’

IMAGE

‘Raw data’?arrows??what happens?

H d l i t t di NOT BNHydrologists concept diagram - NOT a BN

SalinityGround water depth and rate of rise

?

XHydrological model- deterministic Data

Model Parameters

XModel Parameters

Water Poverty ‘Network’

limitations for agriculturevolume, critical supply gap,uncertainty supply

?

uncertainty supply

Opportunity

??

WPPoverty measureor surrogate

Opportunity cost labour

g

Water-related health costs

?

Education/Investment constraints

Land Monitor – Information Gap

• The three highest priority environmental issues- Land salinisation, - Salinisation of inland waters, and

Maintaining biodiversity- Maintaining biodiversity (Western Australian State of the Environment Report, 1998)

• About 1.8 million ha in WA are already salt-affected, and this area could double in the next 15 to 25 yearsand this area could double in the next 15 to 25 years.

• Effects on Vegetation

• No Accurate map, No spatially explicit information on change, or prediction

Salinity Problem & ImpactResource Problem affects peopleEconomic & Social ProblemEconomic & Social Problem

Prediction 25% - 35% land lost

$$ - 40% Australia’s grain

Farming is not subsidised in AustgBusiness, Land value, Banks $

Built infrastucture : road networkMaintenance;Town Buildings ‘Rescue Towns’

Land Monitor ComponentsLand Monitor - Components

I Institutional support (agencies)I. Institutional support (agencies).

2. Demonstrated Technical Capacity (CMIS) Define necessary data (Landsat TM 1988-2000 DEM)Define necessary data (Landsat TM 1988-2000, DEM)and methods

3 Funding Support (National Govt)3. Funding Support (National Govt)------------------------4. Public Interest

LANDSAT TM – Complete Australian Archive since 1988

CMIS Methods and technical developments

• Rectification & Registration, Calibration (robust regression)

(C )• Discriminant Analysis (CVA etc)

• Enhanced ML classification (PP – uncertainty)

• DEM (pre)Processing – derived variables

• Data Integration - CPN, Decision Trees

• Trend summary and representation (vegetation condition)

( th NN LD D i i T )(others e.g. NN, LD, Decision Trees …)

Salinity Mapping & Monitoring Ground DataSalinity Mapping & Monitoring Ground Data