275
AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL РУКОВОДСТВО ПО СПРАВЕДЛИВОМУ СУДОПРОИЗВОДСТВУ ВТОРОЕ ИЗДАНИЕ
| Date post: | 02-Apr-2016 |
| Category: |
Documents |
| Upload: | amnesty-ukraine |
| View: | 244 times |
| Download: | 5 times |
amnesty international
. , , , , .
, , . , , , , .
Amnesty International . .
, . , . , , , ; ; . , .
amnesty.org
Index: POL 30/002/2014
amnesty international
9 780862 104849
ISBN 978-0-86210-484-9
AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL
AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL
Amnesty International Publications
1 Easton Street
London WC1X 0DW
United Kingdom
amnesty.org
Amnesty International 2014 .
: POL 30/002/2014
:
. ,
, ,
.
,
.
, ,
.
Amnesty International ,
3,2 , 150
,
.
,
,
.
, ,
.
amnesty.org/fairtrials
Printed in the UK
ISBN: 978-0-86210-484-9
AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL
, , , , .
vi vi
Amnesty International ,
, , , Amnesty International
.
; ,
,
.
.
.
.
; ,
; .
.
.
Amnesty International ,
: , , , , ,
, , , .
Amnesty
International: , , , ,
, , , , , ,
.
,
: , - , ,
, , , , , ,
- , , , , ,
, , , , ,
;
Advocates for International Development (
): , , ;
, : Clifford Chance (
); Dechert LLP ( );
Herbert Smith Freehills LLP ( , , ,
); Linklaters LLP ( , ,
, ); Reed Smith LLP (
); 20072008
BPP
( , ).
.
.
viivii
xv 1 13 16 21
A. 1. 31
1.1 31
1.2 ? 31
1.3 ? 33
1.4 ? 35
2. , , 372.1 37
2.1.1 ? 38
2.2 39
2.2.1 40
2.2.2 40
2.3 40
2.4 41
2.5 41
3. 433.1 43
3.2 ? 44
3.3 46
3.4 46
3.5 47
3.6 48
3.6.1 48
3.7 49
4. 514.1 51
4.2 52
4.3 53
4.4 54
4.5
55
4.6 56
viii
5. 575.1 57
5.1.1 , 58
5.1.2 ? 59
5.2 60
5.3 61
5.4 61
5.4.1 62
6. 646.1 64
6.2 , 66
6.3 67
6.4 ,
68
7. - 70
7.1
70
7.2 ? 71
7.2.1 ? 73
8. 748.1 74
8.2 ? 75
8.3 , 76
8.3.1 ? 76
8.3.2 77
8.4 78
9 809.1 80
9.2 81
9.3 82
9.4 83
9.5 84
9.6 84
9.7 85
10. 86
10.1 86
10.2 87
10.2.1 88
10.3 88
10.4 89
10.5 91
10.6 92
10.7 , 93
10.8 94
10.9 95
ixix
10.10 96
10.10.1 96
10.10.2 97
10.10.3 98
10.10.4 99
10.11 ,
99
B. 11 103
11.1 103
11.2 104
11.2.1 105
11.3 106
12 , , 108
12.1 ,
108
12.2 , 109
12.3 110
12.4 110
12.4.1 111
12.4.2 113
12.4.3 114
12.5 114
12.5.1 115
13 11813.1 118
13.2 119
14 12114.1 121
14.2 122
14.3 122
15 12515.1 125
15.2 125
15.3 127
15.4 128
16 12916.1 129
16.2 130
16.2.1 130
16.3 131
x
17 , 132
17.1 , ,
132
17.1.1 134
17.2 ,
135
17.2.1 135
17.3 , 136
18 138
18.1 ,
138
18.1.1 139
18.2 140
18.3 142
19 14319.1 143
19.2 ? 144
19.2.1 145
19.2.2 145
19.2.3 146
20 14720.1 147
20.2 148
20.3 148
20.3.1 149
20.3.2 , ;
150
20.4 152
20.5 154
20.6 155
21 15621.1 156
21.2 in absentia 157
21.3 158
22 16022.1 160
22.2 161
22.2.1 162
22.2.2 162
22.2.3 164
22.3 165
22.4 166
22.4.1 - 167
xixi
23 16923.1 169
23.2 169
23.3 171
24 17224.1 172
24.2 173
25 17525.1 175
25.2 175
25.3 177
25.4 177
25.5 178
25.6 -
178
25.7 179
25.8 179
26 18226.1 182
26.2 183
26.3 183
26.4 184
26.5
185
26.6 186
26.7
187
C. 27 191
27.1 192
27.1.1 192
27.1.2 192
27.1.3 193
27.2 193
27.3 194
27.4 195
27.4.1 195
27.4.2 196
27.4.3 196
27.5 196
27.6 196
27.6.1 197
27.6.2 198
27.6.3 198
27.6.4 199
27.6.5 200
xii
27.6.6 200
27.6.7 200
27.6.8 201
27.6.9 201
27.6.10 202
27.6.11 202
27.7 202
27.7.1 203
27.7.2 203
27.7.3 204
27.8 205
28 20628.1 206
28.2 208
28.3 , 208
28.4 , 209
28.5 , 209
28.5.1 , 18 209
28.5.2 210
28.5.3 210
28.5.4 210
28.6 210
28.6.1 212
28.6.2 213
28.6.3 213
28.6.4 214
28.6.5 214
28.7 215
28.8
216
28.9 216
28.10 216
28.11 , 217
29 , 21829.1
218
29.2 220
29.3 221
29.4 221
29.4.1 , 222
29.4.2 223
29.4.3 ,
, 223
29.4.4 224
30 22730.1 227
30.2 ? 227
xiii
31 229
31.1
229
31.2 230
31.2.1 231
31.2.2 232
31.3 ? 232
31.4 234
31.5 ,
235
31.5.1 ,
237
31.5.2 238
32 239
32.1 239
32.1.1 240
32.1.2 242
32.1.3 242
32.1.4 242
32.1.5 243
32.1.6 244
32.1.7 244
32.2 245
32.2.1 245
32.2.2 246
32.2.3 246
32.3 246
32.3.1 247
32.3.2 247
32.4 247
32.4.1 , 247
32.4.2 248
32.4.3 249
32.4.4 251
32.4.5 251
32.5 , 251
32.5.1 252
32.6 , 252
xiii
xiv
.
.
, , ,
, .
,
.
, .
; , ,
, ,
, .
,
.
, ,
, , .
, ,
, .
,
, , ,
, , .
.
. ,
1948
.
,
.
, .
xv
xvi
1948 ,
(),
1966 . ()
,
.
,
. ,
, ,
.
, , , ,
, .
,
,
.
.
.
, ,
:
, , ,
. ,
, , , .
.
.
,
, ,
.
, ,
, . ,
, .
- ,
.
. :
,
. ,
. , ,
, ,
, .
, ,
. ,
xvii
, .
.
, ,
.
( ) ,
() , ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
.
Amnesty International.
1998 , ,
, 1998 ,
.
2010 ; , ,
2011, 2012 2013 .
, :
n , ( , ) ;
n , , 11 2001 ;
n , ;
n , , ;
n , ;
n ;
n , ( , );
n ;
n , , ;
n , - .
, .
xviii
, , , , .
1. 1.1 1.2
2. 2.1 2.2 2.3 ,
3. 3.1 ,
4. 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4
5. 6. 7.
1. , , . , -. ( ), , , , . , , , . , .
, Amnesty International , . , . , , . . Amnesty International , .
, ,
.
1
1.1 , , , ,
, -
. .
, .1
, .2 , . ,
.3 . , , ,
- .4 , -
(. 31 ).
, . , . , . , .
, ,
, , , ,
, .5 , . , , ; , , ; . , , , ,
.6
1.2 , , . , , , . . , , , , . . , , , , , , , . ; . , .
1 , , () .
2 , . . .
3 18 .4 . , , : ;
; . . , , 24 ILC Guide to Practice on Reservations to Treaties ( , ..), A/66/10/Add.1 (2011). 5 , , (2010) 66-68 ( . .).6 - , .
2
2. , -, .
2.1 () 1966 1976 . 26 2013 , 167 . , , Amnesty International: ; , , , , ; ; ; .
18 . . .
() , 1976 , , , , . 26 2013 , 114 .
, , 1991 . -
7 . 26 2013 , 76 .
2.2 , ( ) 1984 1987 .
26 2013 , 153 . -
,
.
. -
, ,
; ;
, ;
, . 10 ,
, .
- ,
.
,
.
, 2006 , -
. ,
. - ,
,
.
7 - , , , .
3
1989 1990 . 26 2013 , 193
. ,
.
18 ,
, ,
.
() 1979 1981 . 26 2013 , 187 . . 2 15 , . ( ) 23 . 2000 . - - , , .
( ) 1965 1969 . 26 2013 , 176 . - , . , 18 , , -, , , . , .
- ( -) 1990 2003 . 26 2013 , 46 . - , - , ; , , .
( ) 2008 . 26 2013 , 130 .
, -
.
( ) 2006 2010 . 26 2013 , 38 , 15 , ,
.8 , : ; , ; ;
8 , .
4
. , , .
2.3 , , , , , .
1949 , , , . 26 2013 , 195 . I (173 -), , II (167 -), ( ).
, .
3. , . , ,
.
( ), 1948 , , . . , , , .
, , 1985 , , , . .
1990 , , , , . , , .
1988 , ( ),
.
;
.
, (, ), 2012 ( 67/187).
, ,
5
, ,
,
.
( ) 1955 1957 .
.9 1971 -
.10 , ,
, .11 2013 , .
, ( ), 1990 . ,
, ,
.
, - -, ( ), 2010 . , , . , . , , , , ; .
, , ( ), 1984 . , . , , , , 14 . , ,
.12
, :
n ,
(
);
n ;
n , ;
n , , ( );
n , ( ).
3.1 , ,
9 67/188, 4.10 2858, 2; . 39/118, 3.
11 , , CCPR/C/79/D/1096/2002 (2003) 7.8 ( . .).
12 ., , 65/206, 3a.
6
. , , , 55/89 ( ),
,
.13
,
, :
n ( );
n ;n ;
n ( , );
n . , ;
n - ;
n . , .
4.
. , ,
, .
, ,
: ,
, 14.
4.1 ( ) 1981 1986 . 2001 . . 26 2013 , 53 .
( ), , , . , , . 11 . -, . .
1992 ( ). 2001 ,
13 2002/38, 8, E/CN.4/2002/200, . 196; 57/200, 3.
14 , 10 , - (), 2012 ,
, , , Amnesty International, , , .
7
( , ). , , 1992 .
2006 2012 . , , .
4.2 ( ) 1948 .
,
() .
( ) 1978 . 30 2013 , 23 35
.15
,
-.
,
- . 26 2013
, 21 .
, 1990 , -
.16 26 2013 , 13
.
( ) 1987 . 26 2013 , 18 .
( --) ( ) 1995 .
26 2013 , 32
, - .
( ) 1996 .
, ,
, .
26 2013 , 14 .
( ) - ,
,
15 , 11 2013 .
16 - , , ,
.
8
, , .
,
,
( -). ,
.
( )
, , .
. ,
- , ,
- .
. , ,
.
, 17
.
4.3 ( ) 2004 2008 . 2013 , 13 22 , .
,
-.17
4.4 () ( ) 1953 . .
26 2013 , 47 ()
.18
7 , : , , ; ; . 26 2013 , 43 .
, . 6 . 26 2013 , 46 47 , . 13 - . 26 2013 , 43 .
( ) . (47 23 2013 ). , , . , , 17 . , , . , -, .
17 2012 . , .
18 , 2013 , 59 , 14, .
9
, 47 , ( , ). , , .
2006 . , , ( ).
, , .
5. , , ( , , ), . , . , . . , , , . , , :
n , 1991 , ,
. ()
.
n , 1980 , ,
.
n , 1982 . ,
.
n , 1985 . ,
,
, .
n 1994 . ,
.
n 2005 ,
.
10
6. , , , . ( ), ( ) .
( ), 1998 . 1 2002 . 26 2013 , 122 . , , : , . . , ( ) , .
, : -
.
.
7.
: , , ,
, ,
, .
.
, , .
:
( ), ( )
.
: (3394/03),
(2010) 79-80.
, ,
,
.
, , ( ).
:
, , ( )
.
: , , , CCPR/
C/59/D/560/1993 (1997) 9.5.
11
, ,
, . :
: . . (40156/07), (2010) 53-68,
(22695/03), (2008) 38-47, - (54789/00), (2005) 64-74.
, : ,
( ) .
: , : , CCPR/C/ETH/CO/1
(2011) 15.
, -,
: , 32, 1.
, , .
65/205, 20.
12
, , -. , . , .
,
,
.19
.20 ,
, , ,
, .
,
( ) ,
.
, , ,
.
,
.
, .
, ,
.
(jus cogens) ( 53)
,
, ,
,
. jus cogens.
.21
19 . , OC-8/87, 32
20 , , E.94.XIV.6 (1994).
:
-
- .
21 12 , 12 , 22 2 4 .
13
, , , ( ). , , . , , , . : ,
.22 , , .
- , , . , .
, .23 .
, , , , . , ,
.24
habeas corpus habeas corpus , ,
, , - . 25 , .
, , ,
, -
, ,
, ,
,
, , ,
, , ,
. ,
,
.26 , , , . : ,
.27
22 . : 25965/04), (2011) 314, (7367/76), (1980) ( ), (4158/05), (2010) 56-57 ( 30 ), (30194/09), (2011) (, , 45 ), (3394/03), (2010) ( ), (39692/09; 40713/09; 41008/09), (2012) 57-59. . , 27, 7.
23 (8130/78), (1982) 73. 24 . M. Nowak, U.N. Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: CCPR Commentary (. , . , . .), 2- ., ., Engel, 2005 ., . 146. 25 . , OC-8/87, 33. 26 1 1 .27 2 1 .
14
, . .
, , , , , , , , , , ,
, , , . 28
, . 29
, .
, , ,
.
, ,
.30
,
.
,
. 31
,
,
. ,
.32
, ,
.
,
.
28 6 .29 . M. Nowak, U.N. Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: CCPR Commentary (. , . , . .), 2- ., ., Engel, 2005 ., . 146.
30 : . (8790/79), (1984) 36, , (688/75; 7238/75), (1981) 55.
31 , ; 2 4 ; (Rec (2006) 13), .
32 (5100/71; 5101/71; 5102/71; 5354/72; 5370/72), (1976) 80-85.
15
, .
Amnesty International, Combating Torture: a manual for action ( : , . .), (: ACT 40/001/2003).
M. Nowak, U.N. Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: CCPR Commentary, (. , . , . .), 2- ., ., Engel, 2005.
Steiner and Alston, International Human Rights in Context, ( , ), 2- ., Oxford University Press, 2000.
Clayton and Tomlinson, Fair Trial Rights, ( , , . .), Oxford University Press, 2001.
, Trial Observation Manual for Criminal Proceedings, ( , . .), 2009.
: , /, 2012.
, Legal Tools: International Standards on Criminal Defence Rights ( : , , . .). ( ): http://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/briefing-papers/legal-tools-international-standards-criminal-defence-rights
S. Trechsel, Human Rights in Criminal Proceedings (. , , . .), Oxford University Press, 2005.
, : ,
, 2007.
D. Weissbrodt, International Trial Observers (. ,
, . .), Stanford Journal of International Law, 18, 1982, . 27-122.
D. Weissbrodt, The Right to a Fair Trial under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (. , , . .), Martinus Nijhoff, 2001.
D. Weissbrodt, The Administration of Justice and Human Rights(. ,
, . .), City University of Hong Kong Law Review, 1, 2009, . 23-47.
Evans and Murray (eds), The African Charter on Human and Peoples Rights: The system in practice 1986-
2006, ( . , :
1986 2006 ., . .), 2- ., Cambridge University Press, 2008.
16
Starmer and Christou (eds), Human Rights Manual and Sourcebook for Africa ( . , , . .), British Institute of International and Comparative Law, 2005.
Buergenthal and Shelton, Protecting Human Rights in the Americas, Cases and Materials ( , : , . .), Engel, Norbert Paul, Verlag, 1995.
Burgorgue-Larsen, beda de Torres and Greenstein, The Inter-American Court of Human Rights: Case Law
and Commentary (-, , : , . .), Oxford University Press, 2011.
A. Dulitzky, Review of the Case Law of the Inter-American Human Rights System (. , , . .), Revue qubcoise de droit international, 19 2, 2006, . 331.
R. Wilson, Supporting or Thwarting the Revolution? The Inter-American Human Rights System and Criminal Procedure Reform in Latin America (. , ? , . .), Southwest Journal of Law and Trade in the Americas, 14, 2008, . 287.
M. Al-Midani, The Enforcement Mechanism of the Arab Charter on Human Rights and the need for an Arab Court of Human Rights (. -,
, . .). Journal of Human
Rights and Civil Society, 3, 2010, . 61-64.
M. Rishmawi, The Revised Arab Charter on Human Rights: A Step Forward? (. ,
: ?, . .), Human Rights Law Review, 5, 2, 2005, . 361-376.
M. Rishmawi, The Arab Charter on Human Rights and the League of Arab States: An Update (. , : , .
.), Human Rights Law Review, 10, 1, 2010, . 169-178.
, , : http://www.echr.coe.int/ECHR/Homepage_En ( . .).
, The Right to a Fair Trial, ( , . .), , 2000.
Harris, OBoyle and Warbrick, Law of the European Convention on Human Rights (, , ), 2- ., Oxford University Press, 2009.
Interights, Legal Manuals on the Case Law of the European Convention: Article 3: the Prohibition of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment; Article 5, the Right to Liberty and Security; Article 6: Fair Hearing ( . 3 , 5 , 6 ): http://www.interights.org/lawyers-manuals/index.html
P. Leach, Taking a Case to the European Court of Human Rights (. , , . .), 2- ., Oxford University Press, 2005.
17
Mole and Harby, The Right to a Fair Trial: A guide to the implementation of the European Convention on
Human Rights ( , .
, . .), , 2001.
Amnesty International, The International Criminal Court: Making the right choices Part I:
Defining the crimes and permissible defences and initiating a prosecution (
: . I. ,
, . .). (: IOR 40/001/1997) Part II: Organizing the
court and ensuring a fair trial ( II.
, . .). (: IOR 40/11/1997).
Amnesty International, The International Criminal Court: Ensuring justice for women (
: , . .). (: IOR 40/006/1998).
Amnesty International, Rape and Sexual Violence: Human Rights Law and Standards in the International
Criminal Court (, :
, . .). (: IOR 53/001/2011).
Cassese, Gaeta and Jones (eds), The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court:
A Commentary, ( . , ,
, . .), Oxford University Press, 2002.
Safferling, International Criminal Procedure, (,
, . .), Oxford University Press, 2012.
W. Schomburg, The Role of International Criminal Tribunals in Promoting Respect for Fair Trial Rights
(. ,
, . .), Northwestern Journal of International
Human Rights, 8, 1 ( 2009).
J. Temminck Tuinstra, Defence Counsel in International Criminal Law, (. ,
), Springer, 2009.
O. Triffterer (ed.), Commentary on the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court - Observers Notes,
Article by Article, ( . . ,
. , , . .), 2- ., ., Hart,
2008, 5556 5969.
Coyle, A Human Rights Approach to Prison Management: Handbook for prison staff (, . , . .), , 2000.
Report on the Human Rights of Persons Deprived of Liberty in the Americas ( , , , . .), , 2011.
Penal Reform International , Briefing on the Bangkok Rules ( , . .), PRI, 2011.
18
Rodley and Pollard, The Treatment of Prisoners under International Law ( , , . .), 3- ., Oxford University Press, 2009.
, Juvenile Justice and Human Rights in the Americas ( , . .), , 2011.
, Implementation Handbook for the Convention on the Rights of the Child ( , . .), 3- ., ., 2007.
Amnesty International, International Standards on the Death Penalty ( , . .). (: ACT 50/001/2006).
Hood and Hoyle, The Death Penalty: A Worldwide Perspective ( , : , . .), 4- ., Oxford University Press, 2008.
, The Death Penalty in the Inter-American Human Rights System: From Restrictions to Abolition ( : , . .), , 2011.
Schabas, The Abolition of the Death Penalty in International Law (, , . .), 3- ., Cambridge University Press, 2002.
, Protecting Witnesses and Victims of Crime ( , . .), 2006.
, Access to Justice for Women Victims of Violence in the Americas ( , , , . .), , 2007.
, Handbook on Justice for Victims (
, . .), -, 1999.
Andreu-Guzmn, Military Jurisdiction and international law: Military courts and gross human rights violations (-, : , . .), , 2003.
Amnesty International, Rights at Risk: Amnesty Internationals concerns regarding security legislation and law enforcement measures ( : Amnesty International , , . .). (: ACT 30/001/2002).
H. Duffy, The War on Terror and the Framework of International Law (. , , . .), Cambridge University Press, 2005.
I , Report on Terrorism and Human Rights, ( , . .), , 2002.
, Assessing Damage, Urging Action: Report of the Eminent Jurists Panel on Terrorism, Counterterrorism and Human Rights ( , . , ), 2009.
, . www.icj.org ( . .).
International Council on Human Rights Policy, Human Rights After September 11, Versoix, Switzerland, 2002.
P. Sands, Lawless World: Making and Breaking Global Rules (. , : , . .), Allen Lane, 2005.
19
2020
Coomans and Kamminga (eds), Extraterritorial Application of Human Rights Treaties ( . , , . .), Intersentia, 2004.
ASIL Guide to Electronic Resources for International Law (
): http://www.asil.org/erg/ ( . .).
Columbia Human Rights Research Guide (
):
http://library.law.columbia.edu/guides/Human_Rights ( . .).
Columbia University, Human Rights and Humanitarian Affairs: Information Resources (
, : ):
http://library.columbia.edu/indiv/lehman/guides/human.html ( . .).
Georgetown University Law Center, Human Rights Law Research Guide, (
,
):
http://www.law.georgetown.edu/library/research/guides/humanrightslaw.cfm ( . .).
United Nations Documentation, Research Guide: Human Rights ( ,
: ): https://www.un.org/Depts/dhl/resguide/spechr.htm
( . .).
University of California, Berkeley, Researching International Human Rights Law (
, , ):
http://www1.umn.edu/humanrts/bibliog/biblios.htm ( . .).
University of Minnesota Human Rights Library: List of Research Guides, (
. ):
http://www1.umn.edu/humanrts/bibliog/biblios.htm ( . .).
University of Texas Human Rights Protection: A concise guide to researching the international
protection of human rights, ( . .
):
http://tarltonguides.law.utexas.edu/human-rights ( . .).
21
, 2008 .
(2002
),
,
-
-,
,
, ,
,
, ,
(1984 ).
,
,
,
21
22
,
-
()
-
-
( )
12 1949 .
.
,
( )
( )
169 169 ,
22
23
( 182 )
-
-
,
, ,
,
-
-
( )
( )
( )
( ) ,
23
24
,
( )
( )
( )
XXXI (2005)
11
11.
,
,
,
,
, ,
,
,
,
24
25
,
( )
,
, ,
, ,
,
,
,
, ,
,
,
, ,
, , , ,
,
, ,
,
, ,
,
,
,
I
12 1949 ,
II
12 1949 ,
6 6
25
26
7 7
12 12
( )
( )
, ,
,
, ,
,
,
17
26
27
,
,
,
.
,
,
-
,
, ,
,
,
-
27
28
29
A
1
2 , ,
3
4
5
6
7 -
8
9
10
30
1
. , . , .
1.1 1.2 ?1.3 ?1.4 ?
1.1 Y .a
,
.
,
, .
, ,
, ,
. ,
, , ,
.
, ,
. (. 5.3 ).
1.2 ?
.b
,
, .c 33
a . [ 3 , 9(1) , 16(1) -, 6 , 7(1) , 14(1) , 5(1) , M(1) , , 1 ; . 37(b) ]
b . [ 9(1) , 17(2)() , 37(b) , 16(4) -, 6 , 2 3 7 , 14(2) , 5(1) , 2 , 1(b) M , , XXV , IV , , , ]c IV , , ,
33 , , CCPR/C/59/D/560/1993 (1997) 9.5; : (9990/82), (1986) 54, (21915/93), (1997) 41, (28358/95), (2000) 50-52,
(3394/03), (2010) 79-80; - , (1994) 46-47; (12.228, 117/90), (2009) 22 ( .).
31
, 3 , .
, 9, 1 . . , , .
(. 18.1.1 11 ).
, ,
: ,
34, ,
35,
, .36
.
, ,
, .37
, , , . , 1 5,
.38
, , .a
, , , , ,
, .39 , ,
.40 (. 18 ).
, , , ,
.41
34 , , CCPR/C/98/D/1312/2004 (2010) 8.2.
35 , (2004) 103 ( . .).36 10/2009 (), A/HRC/13/30/Add.1 (2009) . 200-209 52(b)-53; (12.228, 117/90), (2009) 22-25 ( . .). 37 XXXI, III(A)(20) (23); (1493/2006) , (2009) 7.2-8 ( . ); 11 ; , , (2011) 143-162 ( . ); . (4158/05), (2010) 85 ( . ).
38 . : (18580/91), (1995) 42, (26772/95), (2000) 170, (3394/03), (2010) 78 ( . .). 39 : , (12244/86, 12245/86, 12383/86), (1990) 32, (14310/88) , (1994) 50-63 ( . .). . 1 VII ( . .); 11, (2007) 3.40 : (27785/95), (2000) 108-109, (68294/01), (2008) 52-62 ( . .). 41 (34578/97), (2000) 47-52 ( . .).
: 132
a 5(1)()
, 5(1) . , :() , ;(b) () , , , ;(c) , , ;(d) , ;(e) , , , ;(f) , .
(. 27 ).
1.3 ? ,
.a
.
, .
, .42 (
.
).
, , , ,
43: , . , , , . ,
, 44 ,
, 45
.46 , ,
.47
b 48 (. 4.3 , 3.1, 4.1, 5.1, 6.1 10.2 ).
,
,
. , ,
.49
,
(
11 2001 ).
, ,
, ;
. (
).50
42 , 8, 1, , , CCPR/C/96/D/1460/2006 (2009) 7.2 ( . .).
43 , 26, A B IV. 44 . , : , CCPR/C/ETH/CO/1 (2011) 15.45 , 25/2004 (- . ) E/CN.4/2006/7/Add.1 . 2729, 13-20, , E/CN.4/2001/14 (2000) 93-94; Article 19 (275/03), , 22- (2007) 93-108 ( . .); , : , CCPR/C/CAN/CO/5(2005) 2 ( . .), , CCPR/CO/83/UZB (2005) 22 ( . .); . . , , CCPR/C/98/D/1593-1603/2007 (2010) 7.4.
46 . (3455/05), (2009) 161-190 () ( . .); . , : , A/56/18 (Supp) (2001) 373, , CERD/C/ETH/CO/15 (2007) 19, , CERD/C/60/CO/15 (2002) 5 (), , CERD/C/IND/CO/19 (2007) 14 (), XXXI, 20.
47 , 9, A/HRC/22/44 (2012) 38(c), , 14/2006, A/HRC/4/40/Add.1 (2006) 9-15 (
. .); Article 19 (275/03) ,
22- (2007) 93-108 ( . .).
48 , A/HRC/13/42 (2010) 18-21;
, 14/2009 (), A/HRC/13/30/Add.1
(2010) pp187-191 19-22;
, , CCPR/C/100/D/1776/2008
(2010) 7.6; :
(59334/00), (2007) 172-173 ( . .),
- ,
(39630/09) (2012) 230-241 ( . .).
49 63/185, 8 13-14 .
50 , 29/2006 (), A/HRC/4/40/Add.1 (2006) . 101-108 12, 21-22.
33
a 9 , 9(1) , 37(b) , 16(4) -, 6 , 7(3) , 14(2) , 5(1) , 55(1)(d) ; M(1)(b) , ; III(1) , , , ; . XXV
b . 2 17(1)
, , ,
, ,
, .a 51
,
, ,
.
.52
(. 11 ).
, , 1 9 , ,
, .53
, , , , , ,
, .54
,
, .55
, . , . , []
.56
, ,
, .57
58
.59
, ,
. , ,
.60
51 , A/66/289 (2001) 27; , E/CN.4/1998/54 (1998) 122-123 E/CN.4/2001/73/Add.2 (2001) 27; , E/CN.4/2003/8 (2002) 65-66; , : , CEDAW/C/JOR/CO/4 (2007) 26; . , , A/HRC/4/33/Add.3 (2007) 39.
52 , 7/2002 (), E/CN.4/2003/8/Add.1 (2002) . 8592, 22/2006 (), A/HRC/4/40/Add.1 (2007) . 8992.
53 , , CCPR/C/51/D/458/1991 (1994) 9.8 ( . .), - , CCPR/C/83/D/1134/2002 (2005) 5.1 ( . .), , CCPR/C/99/D/1502/2006 (2010) 10.4; Article 19 (275/03), , 22- (2007) 93 ( . .).
54 (11.430, 43/96), , (1997) 64-71, 115 ( . .).
55 : (70276/01), (2004) 70-78, (35615/06), (2007) 46-53 ( . .).
56 , A/HRC/7/4 (2008) 46, 53; . , A/HRC/20/24 (2012) 13-14, 70. 57 , : , CCPR/C/CAN/CO/5 (2005) 20 ( . .).58 2/11 -, , MC 259-02; - (27021/08), (2011) 97-110 ( . .).59 , : , CAT/C/YEM/CO/2/Rev.1 (2010) 14; , A/64/211 (2009) 31, 53(g).60 , 27/2008 (), A/HRC/13/30/Add.1 78 (2009) 81-83 ( . .), , 26, B IV, IV, 8(a); (71503/01), (2004) 173 ( . .).
: 134
a . 59
,
.61
, ,
, , ,
.62
, , , ,
,
45 ,
, .63
.
,
.
, .64
(. 31 ).
1.4 ? ,
, .a
,
,
.65
,
,
.66 ,
,
, .b
,
, .67
, ,
, .
.c
(. 5 6).
a 17(2)(b) , 2 , 12 , M(1)(c-d)(g) ,
b . 88
c 9
61 : (148/96), 13- (1999) 12-16 ( . .), ( ) (39/90), 10- (1997) ( . .); , : , CAT/C/CR/31/4 (2004) 6(h); 26, B IV, IV, . 42, 8(a).
62 : (13229/03), (2008) 67-70, (11036/03), (2008) 54-55; - . , (2006) 86-96 ( 90); ( 86/09), (2009) 93-100 ( . .).
63 (30194/09), (2011) 56-57 ( . .).
64 , 24, 8 ( . .), HRC
29, 11 ( . .); , 9, A/HRC/22/44 (2012) 37-75. 65 , A/HRC/14/46 (2010) . 29, 27; . , : , CAT/C/YEM/CO/2/Rev.1 (2010) 13, , : , CAT/C/CR/34/UGA, (2005) 6(d), 10(h).66 . , UNODC/CCPCJ/EG.5/2011/CPR.1 (2011) 8(c), 16, 18.
67 , , CCPR/C/78/D/1020/2001 (2003) 7.2 ( . .); 5 7 - , (2001), ( . .) ( 65/19); , 2, 15.
35
, , , , , . . , ,
.68
, , , ,
.a 69
68 , A/HRC/14/46, (2010) . 29, 28.
69 (42697/05), (2011) 92-93 ( . .).
: 136
a IV(4)
, 17(2) -, , - :(a) , ;(b) , ; []
, 9 , , , , , , .
2 , ,
, , . , , , . , , .
2.1 2.1.1 ?
2.2 2.2.1 2.2.2
2.3 2.4 2.5
2.1 .a
. (. 31 ).
,
, . (. 6 ). .
,
.70
, ,
, ,
.71
, , ,
,
.
a 9(2) , 7(4) , 14(3) , 5(2) , 10 ; M(2)() , ; V , , , ; . 2 55 1 60 , 117(1) , 53- , B 59-
70 : (36378/02), (2005) 413, (60593/10), (2012) 58-62, (42310/04), (2011) 209-211; (253/1987), , CCPR/C/41/D/253/1987 (1991) 5.8 ( . .).
71 (43/1979), , A/38/40, 40, . 239 (1983) 13.2; . , : , CCPR/C/79/Add.85 (1997) 13; (42310/04), (2011) 209-211 ( . .).
37
, 9(2) .
,
9 . ,
, ,
.72
, , ,
, .73
. ,
, , .
,
, , . ,
, .74
,
,
.75 (. 27.6 ).
,
,
, ,
,
.76
,
.77
2.1.1 ? .a
2 5 V ,
, , ,
.
. (,
), , ,
, .
,
, , ,
, .
,
.78
a 9(2) , 14(3) , 10 , M(2)() , ; 25 .
72 , , A/HRC/6/17/Add.4 (2007) 22 ( . .).
73 , (2004) 109 ( . .).74 : , v United Kingdom (12244/86, 12245/86, 12383/86), (1990) 40-41, (20869/92), (2000) 53-57, . . (26899/95), (2001) 47-50, (36378/02), (2005) 413-428 ( . .).
75 (6492/11), (2012) 77 ( . .).76 (23541/94), (2001) 42.77 .: , : , CCPR/C/79/Add.85 (1997) 13, (55434/00), (2008) 38 ( . .).78 : , CCPR/C/59/D/526/1993 (1997) 12.2; . , CCPR/C/53/D/493/1992 (1995) 9.2 ( . .).
: 238
, ,
,
,
, ,
,
5(2).79
, 9(2)
, 50 ,
.80
,
,
, .81
2.2 , .
,
, .a 82
- , :
n ; n ;n ; n ; n , ;n .
, ,
.
, ,
, , .83
(. 9 ).
,
.84
. . , ,
a 13 14 ; 2, 42(c) 3, 43(i) , ; 20(d) ; M(2)(b) , ; . 55(2) 60(1)
79 , (12244/86, 12245/86, 12383/86), (1990) 40-42 ( . .).
80 , , CCPR/C/31/D/188/1984 (1987) 9.2, 11 ( . .).
81 Media Rights Agenda (224/98), , 14- (2000) 42-44 ( . .).
82 , 2, 13; , CPT/Inf (96) 21 (1996) 16, CPT/Inf(92)3 (1992) 36-37 ( . .); .
, , (ICC-01/09-01/11-16), II , (30 2011 .), 5 ( . .).
83 , (2004) 112. 84 , : , CCPR/C/DZA/CO/3 (2007) 18; : , CAT/OP/MDV/1 (2009) 97.
, , 39
, 13 , , , , , .
, , . , , . , ,
.a , , , ,
, .85
,
, , .86
2.2.1 :
, .b 87
,
, .c 88 17(1)
, .
, 17- ,
, (
) .89
.d
(. 3 , 9 20 ).
2.2.2
, .90
.e
(. 9.4 16.2 ).
2.3
, .f
85 . : , CAT/OP.SWE/1 (2008) 44-49; , : , A/53/44 () (1998) . 31, 195, , CAT/C/AUT/CO/3 (2002) 4(b).
86 : , CAT/OP/MDV/1 (2009) 95-98; , 6- CPT/Inf (96) 21 16 ( . .).
87 , 2, 13; Rec(2012)12, 21.1 ( . .).
88 , : ,
CCPR/C/NLD/CO/4 (2009) 11; : , CAT/C/75 (2003) 220(e).
89 : (4268/04), (2008) 73( . .), . (32432/96), (2007) 61 ( . .) ( ).
90 , : , CCPR/C/FRA/CO/4 (2008) 14 ( . .), , CCPR/C/NLD/CO/4 (2009) 11; : , CAT/C/75 (2003) 220 (e).
: a 240
a 2, 42(d) , b 5 , ; 17(1) ; 3, 42(a) 2, 43(c)(d) , ; 20() ; M(2)(b) , ; 55(2)() ; . 98.1 ( , ), 60 , 42 c 5 , ; 8 , ; 55(2)() ; 42 ; 42 d 8 3, 43(a) , ; 55(2) ; 42 ; 42 e 3, 43(a) , ; 55(2) ; 42()(iii) ; 42()(iii) f 9(2) , 16(5) -, 7(4) , 14(3) , 5(2) , 10 ; M(2)() , ; V , , , ; 60(1) , 117(1) , 20(4)() , 20(2)
, , 5 , .
. ,
.
,
, ,
.91 ,
, 8. , , . (.
8.4 , ).
2.4 , ,
.a
,
( ) .b
(. 9.5 23 ).
:c
n ; n ; n , ; n , ; n .
. ,
.
(. 9.6 10.2.1 ).
2.5 (
92)
.
,
,
.d 93
,94 -;
, ; , ,
, ,
, ,
.
a 2, 42(d) , ; 14 , 20(d) ; V , , , b 16(5) -, 5(2) , 14 , M(2)() , ; V , , , ; . 14(3) c 1819 , 12 , M(6) , ; . XI , 30 , IX , , , d 36(1)(b) , 16(7) -, 16(2) , 3, 43(c) , ; M(2)(b) , ; V , , , ; 27
91 , , CCPR/C/41/D/253/1987 (1991) 5.8 ( . .).
92 65/212, 4(g); 12/6, 4(b) ( . .).
93 . Rec(2012)12, 15.115.2, 25.125.2 ( . .).
94 : ( ), (2001) 77, 89 ( 1 36 ), ( ) (2010) 95 ( . .).
, , 41
, ( M(2)(d)), ,
.
,
,
.95
V , , ,
.
, , ,
, , ,
, , , .96
, ,
, .a
, .
, .b
, Amnesty
International ,
.
(. 4.6, 25.8).
a . 27(2)
b 36(1)(b) , 16(7)() -
95 : , (2007) 164, - , (2005) 125, , (2004) 112, 195, OC-16/99, (1999) 106; . ( ), (2004) 87 ( . .).
96 ( ), (2004) 88 ( . .).
: a 242
3
, , . , , , . , . , , . .
3.1 3.2 ?3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6
3.6.1 3.7
3.1 (
) (
), .97 (. 20 ).
.a
, ,
,
, , ,
,
.98
b .
.
. ,
, ,
.99
a , , : * 17(2)(d) , * 37(d) , 16(4) , 1 , ; * 17 ; 3 * 4 , ; * 20() ; A(2)(f) * M(2)(f) , ; * V , , , ; * 1 IV , * 25 , * 98.2 ; 55(2)() 67(1)(d) ; 117(2) 121(2)() ; 17(3) , 42 , 18(3) , 42 b 14(3)(d) , 7 , 8(2)(d) , 6(3)()
97 . , 32, 34.98 , , : , CCPR/C/79/Add.74 (1997) 28 ( . .), , CCPR/C/NLD/CO/4 (2009) 11; (250/2002), , 17- (2003) 55 ( . .); ,
(2009) 62 ( . .); , (36391/02), (2008) 54-55 ( . .).
99 , 20, 11; , E/CN.4/1992/17 (1991) 284; (36391/02), (2008) 54 ( . .).
43
:
n ; n ; n .
, ,
, ,
.a
,
,
,
.b 100
,
,
.c
,
( ,
) .101
(. 20 ).
3.2 ? , , ,
.
,
.d 102 ,
, ,
.e 103
a 16(4) ; 17(2) , 3 3, 43(b) , ; V , , , b 16 , ; 2, 16 12 , ; b I iii e H , ; V , , , sc 9 , d 37(d) , 17 ; 3, 3, 43(b) (d) 4, 44(a) , ; 20() ; V , , , e 3, 43(b) , ; V , , , ; 55(2)(c-d) ; 42()(i) ; 42()(i)
100 , 32, 34.101 - ( ) (2007) 101, (2012) 259 ( . .).
102 13/19, A/HRC/RES/13/19 (2010) 6, , : , CCPR/C/79/Add.75 (1997) 27, , CCPR/C/JOR/CO/4 (2010) 9; , : , CAT/C/CR/31/3 (2004) 6(h), 7(c); (7377/03), (2009) 30-33 ( . .); ,12- , CPT/Inf (2002) 15, 40-41 ( . .).
103 13/19, 6; , : , CCPR/C/JPN/CO/5 (2008) 18 ( . .), , CCPR/C/NLD/CO/4 (2009) 11; : CAT/OP/MDV/1(2009) 105-107; : (7377/03), (2009) 30-33( . .), (71407/10), ( ) (2012) 31 ( . .), (33086/04), (2008) 42 ( . .), (2008) 54-55 ( . .), (18731/91), (1996) 66 ( . .).
: a 344
, , 1 .
, 17(1) . , .
, ,
- ,
24 .104
,
, .105
, ,
,
, ,
.106 ,
,
. ,
,
, ,
.107
.108 ,
,
, , ,
(),
.109
, , , . , ,
, .110
,
,
,
.111
,
, , .
,
.
.
48
.a
,
, 24 .112
a 7 , ; 18(3) ; . 15
104 , : , CAT/C/KHM/CO/2 (2010) 14.
105 , (2009) 62 ( . .).
106 : (7377/03), (2009) 30-32; . (2008) 54 ( . .).
107 : (36391/02), (2008) 55, (42310/04), (2011) 262-263, (18731/91), (1996) 66 ( . .).
108 (71407/10), ( ) (2012) 31 ( . .); . (12744/87), (1991) 32-38 ( . .).
109 (7377/03), (2009) 32-33; . (18731/91), (1996) 66 ( . .).
110 : 21- , CPT/Inf (2011)28 19, 12- , CPT/Inf (2002)12 41 ( . .).
111 , (ICC-01/04-01/07-2635), II, (17 2010 .) 62-65; . , , (2 1997 .) 38-55 ( . .).
112 , E/CN.4/1990/17 (1989) 272(c); . (1989) 272(c); . : E/CN.4/1995/34 (1995) 926(d), A/56/156 (2010) 39(f).
45
, , , , , , e.113
. ( ), . , .114 (. 9 ).
, .115 , , 24 , .116 , , , .117
, , , , 48 .118
, , , (. 5.2).
3.3 , , , .119 .a 3.1, , , , . (. 20.3.1 28.6.1 , ).
, .
3.4 , , , . , .120 , (. 20).c
, , 13 , .d
a 1 5 , ; G(b), H(d) M(2)(e-f) , ; 55(2)() ; . 17 b 14(3)(d) , 7 , 8(2)(d) , 6(3)() c 13(1) 16(4) , 6 , ; 17(2) ; 3, 4 11, 55(a) , ; 55(2)() ; 42()(i) ; 42()(i) ; . H() , d 4(2)
113 , A/56/156 2010) 39(f); , 12- , CPT/Inf (2002) 15 41 ( . .).
114 , 21- , CPT/Inf (2011)28 21; (36391/02), (2008) 54 ( . .).
115 , : , CCPR/C/GBR/CO/6 (2008) 19 ( . .), , CCPR/C/AUS/CO/5 (2009) 11; : , A/HRC/10/3/Add.2 (2008) 15, 22 ( ) ( . .); . , : , CAT/C/ISR/
CO/4 (2009) 15, CAT/C/JOR/CO/2 (2010) 12, , CAT/C/CHN/CO/4 (2008) 16(d). 116 , : , CAT/C/TUR/CO/3 (2010) 11. 117 , : , CCPR/C/GBR/CO/6 (2008) 19 ( . .).118 (28135/95), (2000) 42-46 ( . .).119 , :, CCPR/C/ESP/CO/5 (2008) 14 ( . .).120 , :, CCPR/CO/84/TJK (2005) 11, , CCPR/CO/84/SVN (2005) 9; , 12- , CPT/Inf (2002) 15 41 ( . .).
: a 346
, . (. 31 32 ).
, ,
, .a 121 , ,
, .b
,
,
,
, .122
, , , , ,
.c 123 , , ,
.124 , , ,
.d (. 20.3.2 ).
, ,
, .125
(. 2.4, 8.3.2, 9.5 23 ).
3.5 ,
, .e
, , , . , . , . ,
, .f
a 3 , ; H(b-c) , b 3, 23 10 ,
121 , 32, 38; (12744/87), (1991) 32-34 ( . .).
122 : : , CAT/C/JPN/CO/1 (2007) 15(g), : , CAT/C/TUR/CO/3 (2010) 11.
123 XXXI (2005) 30; , 32, 7-10; , A/66/289 (2011) 78; . , : , CCPR/C/RWA/CO/3 (2009) 18; . , : , CAT/C/BDI/CO/1 (2006) 9, : Bulgaria, CAT/C/CR/32/6 (2004) 5(d), 6(d); ,
: , CERD/C/USA/CO/6 (2008) 22; , , (2002), D 236 ( . .); , OC-11/90 (1990), 22-27 ( . .).
124 , : , CCPR/C/AZE/CO/3 (2009) 8, -, CCPR/C/SMR/CO/2 (2008) 12 ( . .), , CCPR/C/AUT/CO/4 (2007) 15, , CCPR/C/PAN/CO/3 (2008) 13 ( . .).
125 (13205/07), ( ) (2010) 24-25; Rec(2012)12, 21.3 ( . .).
47
c 3 , ; 10, 33 11 12 , d 1,41(c) ,
, 17(2) , , , , , , .
, , 6 , , [, ] , , , , , .
e 6 , ; 13 5, 45(c), 13, 64 15, 69 , ; . 9, 52(b) 11, 58(a) , f 1314 , ; I(i) ,
, , , (
) . (. 20.5 20.6 ).
3.6
(. 8), , .a 126 , .
3.6.1 ,
.b
,
.c
,
, .d 127
, ,
( ).128 ,
.129
, .e
, , , , . ,
.130
,
,
.131
,
,
.132
a 8 , ; 18 ; 7, 3, 43(d), 4, 44(g), 5, 45(b) , ; 93 ; M(2)() N(3)(i-ii)() , ; 98.2 23.4 ; . 14(3)(b) , 18(3)(b) -, 8(2)(c-d) , 16(3) , 67(1)(b) , 20(4)(b) , 21(4)(b) ; . 7(1)() 6(3)() b 22 , ; I() , c 8(d)(2) , 16(3) , 8 , ; 18 ; 7 12, 3, 43(d), 4, 44(g), 5, 45(b) , ; e (i-ii) 3 N , ; 23.4 ; 67(1)(b) ; 97(2) ; . b d 3 14 , 6(3)(b-c) d 8 , ; 18(3) ; 7 12, 3, 43(d), 4, 44(g), 5, 45(b) , ; 93 ; N(3)() , ; V , , , ; . 98.2 23.4 ; 67(1)(b) e . 7, 28 ,
126 , 32, 32-34; 15/18, 4(f); . . , (1999) 139 ( . .)
127 . , 32, 34.128 . , : , CAT/C/LVA/CO/2 (2008) 7.
129 , : , CAT/C/JOR/CO/2 (2010) 12; . (14437/05), (2007) 84-99 ( . .).
130 (14437/05), (2007) 84-99 ( . .).
131 , : , CAT/C/AUT/CO/4-5 (2010) 9; . , 33/2006 ( ) , A/HRC/7/4/Add.1 (2008) . 512 19; (62936/00), (2008) 210 ( . .); . , : , CCPR/C/NLD/CO/4 (2009) 14. 132 , : , CCPR/C/POL/CO/ 6 (2010) 20; . , CCPR/C/AUT/CO/4 (2007) 16, , CCPR/C/69/D/770/1997 (2000) 8.5 ( . .).
: a 348
, 14(3)(b) , , : []b) .
, 18(1) .
,
,
.133
,
, ,
,
, .a 134
,
. , , ,
. , ,
(,
, )
(. 20.4).135 ,
.b
/
, ,
.c (. 17.3 ).
3.7 ,d ,
, .e
, ,
.f
, , ,
, - .g
,
.136
133 , , A/HRC/13/37/Add.2 (2009) 36 ( . .); . A/63/223 (2008) 39; . - , (2000) 127-128 ( . .).
134 : , (46221/99) (2005) 132-133, (39846/98), (2001) 58-63; . (52479/99), (2009) 53-62 ( . .).
135 (38321/97), (2001) 65-69, (24430/94), (2002) 46-53; . 3(i) 4 IX .
136 : (7025/04), (2009) 80, (26986/03), (2007) 90-92; . (56581/00), (2006) 86-87 ( . .).
49
, , 8 , , , , . , .
a 8 , ; 18(4) ; 93 b 23.5 c 18(5)
d 14(3)(d) , 7 , 8(2)(d) , 16(3) , 6(3)() e . 55(2)(d) f . 8, 29 3 43(b) , g 112(1)(b)
, ,
,
.137
, , .
, ,
.a (. 20.2 ).
a 45
137 , : , CAT/C/CR/30/1 (2003) 6(c).
: a 350
4
, , , . , , , , , .
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
4.1
, ,
.
,
.
,
,
.a
,
,
, , .138
, ,
,
.139
a 17(2)(d) , 26 , 19 , 20 31 ; . 38 , 99 24
138 , : - , CCPR/C/CAF/CO/2 (2006) 14 ( . .), , CCPR/C/SWE/CO/6 (2009) 13.
139 , : , CAT/C/CR/28/4 (2002) 8(b), , CAT/C/CR/28/7 (2002) 6(f), , CAT/C/CR/31/2 (2004) 6(c); . , CPT/Inf/(92)3 36, CPT/Inf (2002)15 40; ( . .); 65/205, 20.
51
, 17(2)(d) 2. [] - :(d) , , , , , , []
(. 3 , 5 6 ).
4.2 , -
, .140 (. 10 ).
.a (. 27.6.2 ).
.
.141 ,
.b , , ,
. .142 , ,
, 143 .
, . , ( ) ,
.144
,
.145 , , , ,
.146
, ,
. ,
, , .147 (. 10.2.1, ).
a 14(3) , 2(1) , 16(1) , 3, 43(e) , ; 20() ; 92 ; M(2)() , ; V , , , ; 24.9 ; . 17(2)(d) 18 , 2 10 b 15, 1 4 16 , 3, 43(e) ,
140 , 2, 13; Rec(2012)12, 15.2 ( . .).
141 , : , CCPR/CO/84/THA (2005) 15 ( . .).
142 , A/HRC/13/39/Add.5 (2010) 82 ( . .).
143 , 12- , CPT/Inf (2002) 15 43 ( . .).
144 : , CCPR/C/90/D/1327/2004 (2007) 7.8-7.9 ( . .), , CCPR/C/103/D/1871/2008 (2012) 8.9; . , 11 42 ( . .).145 (24276/94), (1998) 124 ( . .).146 (42596/98 and 42603/98), (2006) 32-37 ( . .).147 . , : , CCPR/C/DZA/CO/3 (2007) 11.
: a 452
, 16, 1 , , , .
4.3
, .
,
.
, . ,
, .148
, 48- ,
.149 (. 5 ).
,
.a 150
, ,
. (., , 4.2 4.4).
,
.
.151
.152
,
,
,
, .153
, , ,
, ,
, ,
, .154
, , ,
, ,
.b (. 17, , ).
a 24 , III , , ,
148 : - (2000) 83; (2007) 166-172 ( . .).149 , : , CAT/C/CR/31/7 (2003) 6(j). 150 , 20 11; , A/56/156 (2001) 39(f); , : , CAT/C/YEM/CO.2/Rev.1 (2010) 12 ( . .), , CAT/C/SLV/CO/2 (2009) 20; : , A/HRC/10/3/Add.2 (2008) 32, 62; , : , CCPR/CO/84/SYR (2005) 9 ( . .), , CCPR/C/ESP/CO/5 (2009) 14 ( . .). 151 : (2007) 171 ( . .), (2003) 87 ( . .), - (2000) 83-
84 ( . .); . : : , CCPR/C/CHL/CO/5 (2007) 11, , CCPR/C/51/D/458/1991 (1994) 9.4 ( . .), - , CCPR/C/50/D/440/1990 (1994) 5.4( . .), - , CCPR/C/61/D/577/1994 (1997) 8.4 ( . .); . 65/205, 21; 8/8 7(c) ( . .); (1997) 20 ( . .).152 : , CCPR/C/100/D/1776/2008 (2010) 7.4-7.5, : , CCPR/C/USA/CO/3/Rev.1 (2006) 12 ( . .).153 Amnesty International (48/90, 50/91, 52/91 89/93), , 13- Annual Report (1999) 54 ( . .).154 - , I (2004) 125-136 ( . .).
53
b N(6)(d)(i) ,
4.4 , ,
,
, .a 155
, ,
.b
, ,
.156
.157 ,
, 158 159 , , , , .
, , , . . , , , ,
, , .160
, , , , . ,
, , .161
,
.162 , ,
.163
,
, , ,
, , .c ,
-
, -
. (. 10.6 ).
,
.d
,
,
.
, , , ,
.e
a 17(2)(d) , 17(5) -, 16(2) , 2628 , 31 ; 92 ; M(2)() , ; V , , , ; 24 99 ; 100(1) b 19 , 92 , M(2)(g) , ; 24 ; 100(3)
155 , 2- , CPT/Inf (92) 3, 51; (15672/08 .), (2011) 59 ( . .).
156 . ( 1992), (1977) ( . .).
157 (151/96), , 13- (1999) 27 ( . .).
158 (54/91, 61/91, 98/93, 164/97 196/97 210/98), , 13- (2000) 123-124 ( . .).
159 X Y (10.506), (1996) 98-99 ( . .).
160 : (39631/06), (2010) 45-48, (24407/04), (2010) 91-97, (48666/99), (2007) 125-134, (37444/97), (2005) 86-99 ( . .).
161 : (62936/00), (2009) 246-247, 252-259, Cp: ( .2) (25498/94), (2000) 61-74 ( . .).
162 - , (2004) 135-136 ( . .).
163 - , (2006) 330 ( . .).
: a 454
c 26
d 92
e 28 21
4.5 , , ,
, .a 164
.165
,
.166
.167
, , .b
.168
, ,
,
, .169
, -,
, . ,
, - ,
.c
,
.d 170
, ,
.
, ,
, .
.171
,
, ,
.e
, ,
, 24
, . ,
.172
.f
e 6
164 , : , CAT/C/CR/31/6 (2004) 4(b), 8(d).
165 . (11.427), (1998) 47-48, 63-68 ( . .).
166 , 20, 11.167 , 65/205, 20; 13/19 (2010) 5.
168 : , CAT/OP/SWE/1(2008) 64.169 : 2, 13, : , CAT/C/HUN/CO/4 (2006) 8, : , CAT/C/CR/33/1 (2004) 6(m)
7(m), 20: , CAT/C/75 (2003) 219(i) 220(j); . , CAT/C/42/2 (2009) 24. 170 , A/56/156 (2001) 39(l).
171 : : , CAT/C/AUT/CO/3 (2005) 13, : , CAT/C/TUR/CO/3 (2010) 11; : , CAT/OP/MDV/1 (2009) 111; , 12- , CPT/Inf/(2002) 15 42 ( . .), , CPT/Inf (2009) 22 19-20 ( . .).
172 (45744/08) (2010) 67 ( . .).
55
a 14(4) ; 24 , 24 , 20(d) 31 , IX(3) X , , , ; 42 b M(2)(b) , ; 20 ; . 13 24
c . 10(2) d . 4
f 25 26
, , , ,
.173 (. 10.4 10.11 , ).
4.6 , ,
.
,
,
.a 174
.b
. (. 2.5).
, :
, ;
; ,
.175
, ,
,
() , .c
, Amnesty International
,
.
,
. , ,
.176
(. 25.8 ).
173 , : , CCPR/C/HUN/CO/5 (2010) 14; , 20: , CAT/C/75 (2003) 220(k).
174 : ( ) (2001), 77, ( ) (2004) 50 ( . .).
175 OC-16/99, (1999) 86 ( . .).
176 OC-16/99, (1999) 137, (11.331), (2003) 37, 40 ( . .).
: a 456
a 36 , 17(2)(d) , 16(7) -, 10 , 38 , 2(1) , M(2)() , ; V , , , ; 37 ( )b , 6(3) , 10(3) , 15(3) c . 27(2)
5
, . , , . . , ( ) .
5.1 5.1.1 , 5.1.2 ?
5.2 5.3 5.4
5.4.1
5.1
.a 177
, . ,
, ,
, .
, , .178
,
.b 179
, , :c
n , , , ;
n ;n ;
a 4 , V , , , b : 9(3) , 16(6) -, 14(5) , 5(3) , M(3) , ; 59(2) . , : 7(2) , XI , 4 11(1) , 10(1) ; 27 c M(3) , ; 14(1)
177 65/205, 20; 15/18, 4(c); 2005/27, 4(c) ( . .); . : : (543/03), (2006) 30-32 ( . .), (3394/03), (2010) 117-118 ( . .); : , (2004) 114-115 ( . .), , (2007) 81 ( . .), , (2008) 63 ( . .).
178 - . (9903) , 51/01 (2001) 232; : , (37388/97) (1999), 11036/03) (2008) 72 ( . .).
179 21/4 (2012) 18(a).
57
, 9(3) , , [].
n :n - ;n .
.
, , ,
, ,
, 7(5)
.180
,
,
. ,
,
. ,
,
, .181
,
, ,
. ,
(, habeas corpus ),
.182
(. 6). habeas corpus ,
.183
, -
, , -
. ,
,
.184
,
.185
.
, ,
, ,
.186 (. 10).
180 , Inter-American Court (2008) 67; . (37104/06), European Court (2010) 47-51. 181 (543/03), (2006) 47 ( . .).182 : (543/03), (2006) 34, , (8805/79 8806/79 9242/81), (1984) 51, 57, (34578/1997), (2000) 84 ( . .). 183 , (8805/79, 8806/79, 9242/81), (1984) 51, 57; . , , CCPR/C/50/D/330/1988 (1994) 11.1 ( . .).184 , 63/185, 13, 14; , : , CCPR/C/
UZB/CO/3 (2010) 15; . VII(2) ( . .); (3394/03), (2010) 126 ( . .).
185 , (2010) 102; , : (), CCPR/C/UNK/CO/1 (2006) 17 ( . .).
186 , : , CCPR/C/AZE/CO/3 (2009) 8, , CCPR/C/SLV/CO/6 (2010) 14; , E/CN.4/2003/68 (2002) 26(g), A/65/273 ((2010) 75; , 12- , CPT/Inf (2002) 15, 46 ( . .); . , : , CAT/C/JPN/CO/1 (2007) 15.
: a 558
5.1.1 , , , , .
(. 12.4 ). () ,
, .187
. , ,
.188
, , , , , , , ,
.189
, , 36 , , , , 3 5 , ,
.190
5.1.2 ?
.
, , ,
, ,
, .191
48
.a 192 ( . 27.6.1 ).
, 72
.193
, , , , , 24 ,
.194
.195
a 14(2)
187 : (7710/76), (1979) 25-38, (24760/94), (1998) 146-150, (543/03), (2006) 40, ((3394/03), (2010) 124-125 ( . .); . , -, E/CN.4/2006/120 (2006) 28; , (2008) 63 ( . .).188 : , CCPR/C/50/D/521/1992 (1996) 11.3 ( . .), , CCPR/C/95/D/1278/2004 (2009) 8.2, , CCPR/C/75/D/726/1996 (2002) 8.3 ( . .), , : , CCPR/CO/84/TJK (2005) 12 ( . .); . , , E/CN.4/2005/6/Add.4 (2004) 32(c), 78(a); : - , (2005) 79-81, , (2007) 84-86.189 : (13867/88), (1992) 20-22, (24760/94), (1998) 146-150, (31195/96) (1999) 49-53, , (8805/79, 8806/79,
9242/81), (1984) 49, (27267/95), (1999) 57-58, (12794/87), (1990) 42-43, . . (26899/95), (2001) 62-64 ( . .).190 (543/03), (2006) 41-51 ( . .).191 (25642/94), (1999) 48-51 ( . .); , 8, 2. 192 , : , CCPR/C/SLV/CO/6 (2010) 14; , E/CN.4/2003/68 (2002) 26(g) A/65/273 (2010) 75; . , : , CAT/C/CR/29/2 (2002) 6(f); (68294/01), (2008) 66-67 ( . .). 193 , : , CCPR/CO/83/UZB (2005) 14 ( . .), , CCPR/C/UKR/CO/6 (2006) 8 ( . .), , CCPR/C/MDA/CO/2 (2009) 19. 194 , 20: , CAT/C/75 (2003) 220(b). 195 . (12843/87), (1991) 24, 25 ( . .).
59
, , .
, ,
.196
, (, ),
.197 1988 4 6 , , ,
.198 , 48
.199
,
.200 , , . , , , ,
, habeas corpus.201 (. 31 ).
5.2 , ( ) , , ,
, .202 ,
, .a 203
:b
n 204 n , c (. 3) n , 205 n , , , d;
n , 206;n 207;n ;
n , (. 2.5)
a 78 b 28, 25 ( 24), 26, 29, 21, 18, 27 32 c 3 4, 44(c) , ; 27 ; 25 d 3, 43(f) , ; N(4)() ,
196 : (3394/03), (2010) 127-134, . , (62736/09), (2013) 55-62 ( . .). 197 ., , , : , CCPR/C/FRA/CO/4 (2008) 14; , (2002) 121-122 ( . .).198 : (11209/84, 11234/84, 11266/84, 11386/85), (1988) 55-62, (17019/02, 300070/02), (2009) 32-38 ( . .).199 , A/63/223(2008) 45(a).200 , A/49/40, I, XI, . 123, 2 ( 9 29); ); . , : , CCPR/C/ISR/CO/3, (2010) 7(c); . , : , CCPR/CO/84/THA, (2005) 13 15 ( . .).201 : (14553/89, 14554/89), (1993) 61-66, (21987/93), (1996) 83-84; . , (1999) 104-112, 184-88 ( . .). 202 (33977/96), (2001) 84-85 ( . .); , , A/HRC/4/26/Add.3 (2006) 34 ( . .); . , , E/CN.4/2006/7/Add.3 (2005) 65.203 (30779/04), (2007) 73-77 ( . .).
204 : (3710/406), (2010) 118 ( . .), (46221/99), (2005) 103, ( . .)3, (3394/03), (2010) 118 ( . .); : (2008) 65 ( . .), - (2005) 78 ( . .); , , E/CN.4/2005/6/Add.4 (2004) 32(b). 28 , , , , , . CPT/Inf(2008) 27 8-10, CPT/Inf(2009) 30 9 ( . .). 205 (493/04), (2007) 77 ( . .)206 : (24760/94), (1998) 146 ( . .), (543/03), (2006) 35 ( . .); , , E/CN.4/2005/6/Add.4 (2004) 32(b); : , (2008) 65-68 ( . .), , (2007) 85 ( . .).207 , 9, A/HRC/22/44 (2012) 67; : (543/03), (2006) 43 ( . .), (30779/04), (2007) 62 ( . .), (30748/04), (2009) 76 ( . .); . , (2007) 102-107, 116-119 ( . .).
: a 560
n ( , ).
()
.
, ,
(. 6 7).
5.3 (. 15) ,
.208
, , , ,
, .a
, ,
, , :b
n , , , ;
n , , .
, , ,
, (. 5.2). ,
,
, ,
.c 209 (. 6 7 - ).
5.4 ,
:d
n , , 210;
n , , 211;
n , 212:n 213,n ,
a 9(3) , 37(b) , 16(6) -, 14(5) , 39 , 6 , M(1)() , ; III(2) , , , ; 3 b 7(2) , 5 , III(2) , , , ; 6 7 ; . 9(3) , 16(6) -c 8(2) d 6 7
208 (12.533), (2009) 69 ( . .).
209 , , CCPR/C/99/D/1502/2006 (2010) 10.4, (12.533) , 86/09 (2009) 68-81 ( . .).
210 , (2009) 122; (12.553) (2009) 110 ( . .).
211 (19382/92), (1995) 55 ( . .); (11.506), (2002) 65-66 ( . .); , 32, 30. 212 . (11.205 .), , (1997) 25-37 ( . .). 213 (12.553), (2009) 81, 85; : (12369/86), (1991) 43, (30779/04), (2007) 69 ( . .).
61
n ,214; n 215;n .216
.217
, ,
218, . ,
219 , , , , , , . , ,
, 220, ,
.a 221 ,
.b 222
. c (. 27).
,
, .d 223
.224 , , .
.225
, ( ,
, ,
)226
.e 227
, .228
,
.229 (. 11 ).
, , , . , , , , .
, .f 230 (. 22.4 ).
5.4.1 ,
, ,
. , ,
a 16(6) -, 12 9 b 58 , 10 ; M(1)(f) , c 37(b) , 65 d II(2) , , , e 3(2)
f bf 7 , 5152
214 (30779/04), (2007) 71; (12.553), (2009) 131 ( . .).215 (12369/86), (1991) 51 ( . .).216 (30779/04), (2007) 75-76 ( . .). 217 (3394/03), (2010) 117, 120 ( . .).218 ., , , (2001) VII, 4, 28-29, 33-34.219 (30779/04), (2007) 72; (12.553), (2009) 84, 89-90 ( . .).220 , , CCPR/C/59/D/526/1993 (1997) 12.3; Rec (2012)12, 13.2(b), 5 ( . .). 221 (55939/00), (2005) 64 ( . .).222 65/229, 9. 223 - , (2006) 69; (12.553) (2009) 84, 141-145; (ICC-01/05-01/08-475), II , - - (14 2009 .) 38 ( . .).
224 (70276/01), (2004) 71-78 ( . .). 225 : (2122/64), (1968) A.10, (543/03), (2006) 42, 43 ( . .). 226 : (32819/96/98), (2000) 14-15, 18-21, (62936/00), (2009) 154 ( . .).227 , : , CCPR/CO/83/MUS (2005) 12, 15 ( . .).228 , : , CCPR/C0/70/ARG (2000) 10 ( . .), , CCPR/C/MDA/CO/2 (2009) 19, , CCPR/C/ITA/CO/5 (2005) 14 ( . .); - , (2006) 69 ( . .).229 , XXXI 26(b); , E/CN.4/2006/7 (2005) 65-66. . , : , CAT/C/KEN/CO/1 (2008) 12; : , CAT/OP/MEX/1 (2010) 208.230 : (23452/94), (1998) 115, 116, (33401/02146), (2009) 192-202 ( . .); . : , CEDAW/C/39/D/6/2005 (2007) 12.1.5, A. T. (2/2003), A/60/38 ( I), III (2005) 8.4, 9.2-9.4, (5/2005) CEDAW/C/39/D/5/2005 (2007) 12.1.5; (12.626) (2011) 211-213 ( . .).
: a 562
, .a 231 : , , , , , ,
.b ,
.232
233 (. 5.4).
, ,
, , , ,
.c 234
a . 9(3) ; 7(5) ; 14(5) ; 5(3) ; ( 2.3 6.2); M(1)() , ; III(4) , , , ; 4 b 57, 58 62 c 5760 62 , M(1)(f) , ; 10
231 . (59526/00), (2007) 57 ( . .); 65/229, 5.
232 , (2004) 113-135 ( . .).
233 : (12050/04), (2010) 78-93 ( . .), (60859/00), (2006) 111 ( . .).
234 65/229, 9; 63/241, 47; , A/HRC/7/3 (2008) 41.
63
6
, , . , , , .
6.1 6.2 , 6.3 6.4 ,
6.1 , , . ,
.a
, , 1 7
.235
, , ,
.236 , ,
, .237
, 238 239
( ).
. ,
.b 240
(. 5) , , .
, , ,
.c
habeas corpus.
, ,
.241
a 9(4) , 17(2)(f) , 37(d) , 16(8) -, 7(6) , 14(6) , 5(4) , 32 , 32 , M(4-5) , ; XXV , VII(3) ; . 8 b 17(2)(f) , 7(6) , M(5)(b) , ; . 32 c 9 , X , M(5)(b) , 235 (153/96),
, 13- (1999) 17 ( . .).
236 : Habeas corpus , OC-8/87, (1987) 35, , (2003) 111; (24276/94), (1998) 123 ( . .).
237 , 2, 13; ., , : 2947/06), (2008) 145-152 ( ) ( . .), (31365/96), (2000) 58-61 ( ) ( . .); . (28212/95), (2002) 33-38 (
) ( . .); . , , CCPR/C/59/D/560 /1993 (1997) 9.4-9.5 ( ), , , A/37/40 (Supp. 40) (1982) 13 ( ) ( . .).238 , , CCPR/C/89/D/1172/2003 (2007) 8.5 ( . .). 239 15/18, 4(d)-(e).240 - , (1997) 59-60 ( . .).241 65/221 6(b)-(c) 64/168 6(b)-(c); . 13/26, 9.
64
habeas corpus ,
.242 ,
.243
,
,
, , ,
.244
, , , ,
.245
, , , ,
.246
, . , ,
.a 247 (. 31 ).
,
habeas corpus ,
, :
,
, , ,
. ,
,
248
,
, ,
,
, ,
, .249
, , ,
, .b ,
habeas corpus.250
a 27(2) , X , 4(2) , M(5)() ,
242 A/HRC/10/21 (2009) 53, 54(e)-(f). 243 . , -, E/CN.4/2006/120 (2006) 17-29. 244 , : , CAT/C/AUS/CO/3 (2008) 10. 245 : - , 1997) 59-60 ( . .), - , (1999) 123 ( . .); . , : , CAT/C/CR/30/3 (2003) 5.246 ., , , , CCPR/C/90/D/1327/2004 (2007) 7.5, 7.8-7.9; 11 42 ( . .).
247 , 29, 16 ( . .); : OC-8/87 (1987) 42 ( . .), OC-9/87 (1987)41(1) ( . .); 1992/35, 2; , A/HRC/13/42 (2010), 46-47; , A/HRC/7/4 (2008) 67, 82(a); : , CAT/OP/HND/1 (2010), 282(a)-(b).248 (143/95 150/96), , 13- (1999) 33 ( . .). 249 : - (35865/03), ( ) (2007) 101 ( . .), (8139/09), (2012) 259 ( . .). 250 E/CN.4/2006/120 (2006) 292(b).
65
b 22
6.2 , ,
, .
.
251, , .a
, , , , ( , ). (. 6.1).
, , ,
.252
, .b 253
, , , ,
.254
, , , , , , . , ,
, .255
, habeas corpus, , , , , , , , , , ,
.256
, :
n ;
n ;
b 9(4) , 17(2)(f) , 16(8) -, 7(6) , 14(6) , 5(4)
251 , : , CCPR/C/PAN/CO/3 (2008) 13 ( . .). 252 : , CCPR/C/35/D/265/1987 (1989) 9.6-10 ( . .), , CCPR/C/100/D/1449/2006 (2010) 8.6; , CCPR/C/99/D/1369/2005 (2010) 8.5; (153/96), , 13- (1999) 11-18 ( . .); : (2007) 128 ( . .), Habeas corpus , OC-8/87 (1987) 42 ( . .); : , (1704/06), (2009) 128-136 ( . .); . (31365/96), (2000) 58-61 ( . .).
253 : . (3455/05), (2009) 202, (22414/93), (1996) 130 ( . .); . , , CCPR/C/59/D/560 /1993 (1997) 9.5.
254 (22414/93), (1996) 130 ( . .).
255 , A/HRC/13/42 (2010), 27-29; , : , CCPR/C/USA/CO/3/REV.1 (2006) 18 ( . .).
256 2/11.
: a 666
, 32 1. , .
2. 1 , , . , , , .
a 32(2)
n .257
.258
,
.259
, ,
(. 13.2).260 , ,
.a 261 , . , ( ). , , ,
.262 , , . , , ,
.263 (. 8.4 , , 14.2 ).
, , .
.264
, .265
, .
, , ,
.b 266 .
6.3 , , ,
.c
5(4) .267
a 3, 20 23 , ; . 4, 44(c-d) 5 ,
257 . (3455/05), (2009) 202 ( . .); : . , CCPR/C/59/D/560/1993 (1997) 9.5, . , CCPR/C/78/D/1014/2001 (2003) 7.2 ( . .). 258 . , (2007) 129 ( . .).259 : . (3455/05), (2009) 202-224 ( 202-204), (31195/1996), (1999) 58-64, (27785/95), (2000) 125-127, (23541/94), (2001) 39, 42-43; . . , , CCPR/C/78/D/1014/2001 (2003) 7.2 ( . .). 260 : . (3455/05), (2009) 202-224, (1704/06), (2009) 128-136, (17977/91), (1995) 47; - . (9903) , 51/01 (2001) 213 ( . .).
261 : (17977/91), (1995) 47-59; . (6301/73), (1979) 60 ( . .).262 : (27785/95), (2000) 125-131; . (3455/05) (2009) 202-204 ( . .).263 . (3455/05) (2009) 202-224 ( 205, 218-224) ( . .); . 1, 2 14 .264 - , (1997) 63-64; (27785/95), (2000) 133-136; . - ((9862/82), (1986) 55-61; (P-900-08), , (2012) 39 ( . .). 265 (13190/87), (1993) 28 ( . .).266 : (30779/04), (2007) 62, (46468/06), (2008) 179 ( . .). 267 : (24760/94), (1998) 162, (59334/00), (2007) 177 ( . .).
67
b IV , , ,
c 39 , 17 , VIII , 60(3)
, , .
,
,
.a ( ,
, ,
). (. 5.4).
.b , .
,
, .268 , .
. 269 (. 7 - ).
.
, c, , ,
, ,
.270
,
.
, ,
, .271
(. 25.7 ).
6.4 , , ,
, . (
,
,
).d , , , ,
, .e 272
.f
c 4, 44(c) ,
268 : (43376/06), (2009) 73-88 ( . .), ((26772/95), (2000) 152-153 ( . .); , (12.553, 86/09), (2009) 104-105 ( . .). 269 , (2007) 117-118; . (11.205 .), (1997) 19 ( . .).270 - . (99903), (2001) 213; :
(24760/94), (1998) 163-165, (7064/05), (2006) 89-93; . (18837/06), (2010) 38-48 ( . .).271 - ( 43/2006), , A/HRC/7/4/Add.1 (2008) . 3951, 36-37; . . , , CCPR/C/59/D/560 /1993 (1997) 9.4. 272 : (59334/00) (2007) 192, (27267/95), (1999) 69; . , I (1988) 166, 174 ( . .).
: a 668
, 39 , , , , , , . .
a . 6.2
b 6.2 , 60(4)
d 9(5) ; 24(4) ; 16(9) -; 14(7) ; 5(5) ; M(1)(h) , ; . 8 , 7 , 25 , 35 , 85(1) e 1823 , XVI f 19
,
,
, , .273
, , ,
.274
, ,
.a
(. 10.11 , , 30 ).
a 11, 55(b) ,
273 : (59334/00), (2007) 192-196, (30280/96), (2000) 33, (19365/02), (2004) 27 ( . .).
274 . . . , , CCPR/C/46/D/432/1990 (1992) 6.5; . (13126/87), (1993) 25 ( . .).
69
, 9(5), , , .
7 -
, , , . , , , - .
7.1 7.2 ?
7.2.1 ?
7.1 , , . , , , . 19, , , , . .
.a 275
, , . (. 5.3 6.3). , , , .276
.277 ,
.278
, , , ,
.279 (. 10.3).
, , , . ,
.280
a 9(3) ; 16(6) -; 7(5) ; 14(5) ; 3(5) ; 38 ; M(3)() , ; XXV ; . 60(4)
275 (12850/87), (1992) 84 ( . .); : 32, 61; . , , CCPR/C/73/D/788/1997 (2001) 7.4.
276 , (2009) 120-122; (2122/64) (1968) 4-5 ( . .).
277 - , (2006) 69; (12.553), (2009) 84, 141-147; (ICC-01/05-01/08-
475), , II, - - (14 2009 .) 38 ( . .).
278 , (2004) 229 ( . .).
279 ., , , : , A/56/44 (2001) 95(e) ( . .).
280 . (2122/64), (1968) 4-5 ( . .).
70
, (, ,
).a
7.2 ? , , , , ,
.281 (
282).
,
.283
, ,
, 284 ( 9(3) 5(3) )
.285 ( , , , , , , . . 19).
.b
n ; n , (. 7.2.1); n ;
n .286 . , , , ,
.287 , . , , . , , ,
.288 (. 5.3 15).
b V , , ,
281 : (47095/99), (2002) 114, (30210/96) (2000) 110, (26772/95), (2000) 152 ( . .).282 . Article 19 (275/2003), , 22- (2007) 97-99; , (1997), 77; (ICC-01/04-01/06-824), (13 2007 .) 124 ( . .).283 , , CCPR/C/54/D/473/1991 (1995) 8.5 ( . .). 284 , , CCPR/C/77/D/908/2000 (2003) 6.2 ( . .).
285 (27561/02), (2007) 23-26 ( . .).
286 : (47095/99), (2002) 114-120, (7390/07), (2010) 68-70 ( . .).
287 (62936/00), (2008) 150 ( . .).
288 , : , CCPR/C0/70/ARG (2000) 10 ( . .), , CCPR/C/MDA/CO/2 (2009) 19, , CCPR/C/ITA/CO/5 (2005) 14 ( . .).
- 71
a . 9(3) ; 7(5) ; 14(5) ; 5(3) ; 57, 58 62 ; ( 2.3 6,2); M(1)() , ; 4 2(1)
, 9(3) , , . , , , [].
, ,
(),
.289
, .290
, ,
, , .291
, ,
.292
,
22 , ,
,
, . ,
,
,
, , ,
. ,
,
.293
,
.
,
,
,
.294
,
7(1)(d) .295
, [
]
,
.296
, , ,
,
, . ,
,
( 14 ) 16 , .297
289 , , CCPR/C/ 72/D/818/1998 (2001) 7.2; (19382/92), (1995) 72-76; . , (13301/87), (1992) 14-17 ( . .).290 : (24760/94) (1998) 153-158; . (10527/83), (1987) 15-20; . (7759/77), (1981) 55; . , (2008) 156 ( . .). 291 (7064/05), (2006) 83 ( . .).292 (7412/76), (1977) 120; , (2009) 119 ( . .).
293 , , CCPR/C/ 72/D/818/1998 (2001) 7.2 ( . .).
294 , : , CCPR/C/FRA/CO/4 (2008) 15 ( . .).
295 ( ) (39/90), , 10- (1996-1997 .), . 52-56, c. 55 ( . .).
296 Article 19 (275/2003), , 22- (2007) 97-100 ( . .).
297 , (2009) 117-123 ( . .).
: a 772
7.2.1 ? , ,
, .298
