+ All Categories
Home > Documents > ' C · Brecht's Joan Dark, messianic member of the Salvation Army in early-twentieth-century...

' C · Brecht's Joan Dark, messianic member of the Salvation Army in early-twentieth-century...

Date post: 27-Mar-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
2
notes 1. Generally, the titles of these metal sculptures are selected, almost casually, from mainstream films, as Trockel seeks to separate a work from its name-that is, to indicate the structure of narrative without recourse to the specifics of its story. 2. A related visual-verbal pun transformed Jeanne d'Arc into Brecht's Joan Dark, messianic member of the Salvation Army in early-twentieth-century Chicago, in Saint Joan of the Stockyards (1928), his radically revisionist life of the medieval martyr. 3. This collaged soundtrack is composed of some twenty extracts. For a fuller discussion, refer to Lynne Cooke, "In Medias Res," in Rosemarie Trockel (Munich: Sammlung Goetz, 2002), pp. 23-29. Born in 1952 in Schwerte, Germany, Rosemarie Trockel studied painting with Werner Schriefers at the Werkkunstschule in Cologne from 1974 to 1978. Since her debut show at Galerie Philomene Magers (later Monika Spruth, Cologne) in Bonn in 1983, she has exhibited widely in Europe and North America and was included in such major shows as the Venice Biennial (1999, 1996), Istanbul Biennial (1999, 1995), and Documenta X (with Carsten Holler, 1997). Recent one-person exhibitions were presented at the Sammlung Goetz, Munich (2002), De Pont Foundation for Contemporary Art, Tilburg (2001), Moderna Museet, Stockholm (2001), the German pavilion in the Venice Biennial (1999), and the Kunsthalle, Hamburg (traveling throughout Europe, 1998). She lives and works in Cologne. selected bibliography Pro Test: Rosemarie Trockel Manus Spleen 2. Cologne: Walther Konig, 2002. Text by Rosemarie Trockel. Rosemarie Trockel. Munich: Sammlung Goetz, 2002. Texts by Josefina Ayerza, Lynne Cooke, lngvild Goetz, Reinald Schumacher, and Stephan Urbaschek. Ross, Christina. "Vision and Insufficiency at the Turn of the Millennium: Rosemarie Trockel's Distracted Eye," October, no. 96 (Spring 2001 ), pp. 86-11 0. Rosemarie Trockel: La Biennale di Venezia 1999. 2 vols. New York: Nabe Press, 1999. Texts by Wilfried Dickhoff, Gudrun lnboden, Ralph Melcher, Joan Simon, Jeannette Stoschek, and Lisa Zeiger. Rosemarie Trockel: Bodies of Work 1986-1998. Hamburger Kunsthalle, in association with Oktagon Verlag, Cologne, 1998. Texts by Simone de Beauvoir, Wilfried Dickhoff, Marguerite Duras, Yilmaz Dziewior, Sebastian Egenhofer, Birte Frenssen, Gudrun lnboden, Melitta Kliege, Catherine Lampert, Holger Liebs, and Uwe M. Schneede. Parkett, no. 33 (September 1992). Collaboration with Rosemarie Trockel. Texts by Veronique Bacchetta, Anne M. Wagner, and Barrett Watten. Rebecca Comay will lecture on Rosemarie Trockel at Dia on Thursday, December 12, 2002, 6:30 pm. Support for this exhibition has been provided by The Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Ake Skeppner, and the members of the Dia Art Council. site map and checklist --> I 13 0 12 /2 11 3\10 4f 1. Phobia , 2002 5 aluminum plates black cotton trimming installation size: 8 1 '2 x 6 1 /2 feet courtesy Monika Spri.ith Galerie, Cologne, and Barbara Gladstone Gallery, New York 2. Beyond the Valley of the Dolls , 2000 50 aluminum plates installation size: 10 x 19 1 '2 feet courtesy Monika Spri.ith Galerie, Cologne, and Barbara Gladstone Gallery, New York 3. No Woman No Cry, 2000 50 aluminum plates installation size: 11 x 1 6 3 /4 feet courtesy Monika Spri.ith Galerie, Cologne, and Barbara Gladstone Gallery, New York 4. Rancho Deluxe , 2001 15 aluminum plates installation size: 9 x 10 1 '2 feet courtesy Monika Spri.ith Galerie, Cologne, and Barbara Gladstone Gallery, New York 5. Blackboard Jungle, 2002 72 aluminum plates installation size: 11 3 /4 x 6 3 /4 feet courtesy Monika Spri.ith Galerie, Cologne, and Barbara Gladstone Gallery, New York 6. Treasure 77 aluminu installation courtesy M Cologne, a Gallery, Ne 7. Manu's S video proje black and courtesy M Cologne, Gallery, N 8. Manu's Sp video proje color, 7 :42 courtesy M Cologne, a Gallery, Ne 9. Manu's Sp video proje color, 1 :50 co urtesy M Cologne, a Gallery, Ne 10. Manu's Sp video proje color, 7:20 courtesy M Cologne, a Gallery, Ne 11. Manu's Sp video, silen color, 1 :30 courtesy M Cologne, a Gallery, Ne 12. Leaving La video proje color, 5:12 courtesy M Cologne, a Gallery, Ne 13. Maquettes and catalo Private Co
Transcript
Page 1: ' C · Brecht's Joan Dark, messianic member of the Salvation Army in early-twentieth-century Chicago, in Saint Joan of the Stockyards (1928), his radically revisionist life of the

no

tes

1. G

ener

ally

, the

titl

es o

f th

ese

met

al s

culp

ture

s ar

e se

lect

ed,

alm

ost

casu

ally

, fro

m m

ains

trea

m

film

s, a

s T

rock

el s

eeks

to

sepa

rate

a w

ork

from

its

nam

e-th

at

is, t

o in

dica

te t

he s

truc

ture

of

narr

ativ

e w

ithou

t re

cour

se t

o th

e sp

ecifi

cs o

f its

sto

ry.

2.

A r

elat

ed v

isua

l-ver

bal

pun

tran

sfor

med

Jea

nne

d'A

rc in

to B

rech

t's J

oan

Dar

k, m

essi

anic

mem

ber

of t

he S

alva

tion

Arm

y in

ear

ly-t

wen

tieth

-cen

tury

C

hica

go,

in S

aint

Joa

n of

the

Sto

ckya

rds

(192

8),

his

radi

cally

rev

isio

nist

life

of

the

med

ieva

l mar

tyr.

3.

Thi

s co

llage

d so

undt

rack

is

com

pose

d of

som

e tw

enty

ext

ract

s. F

or a

ful

ler

disc

ussi

on,

refe

r

to L

ynne

Coo

ke,

"In

Med

ias

Res

," in

Ros

emar

ie T

rock

el (M

unic

h: S

amm

lung

Goe

tz, 2

002)

, pp

.

23-2

9.

Bor

n in

195

2 in

Sch

wer

te,

Ger

man

y, R

ose

mar

ie T

rock

el s

tudi

ed p

aint

ing

with

Wer

ner

Sch

riefe

rs a

t th

e W

erkk

unst

schu

le

in C

olog

ne f

rom

19

74 t

o 19

78.

Sin

ce h

er

debu

t sh

ow a

t G

aler

ie P

hilo

men

e M

ager

s (la

ter

Mon

ika

Spr

uth,

Col

ogne

) in

Bon

n

in 1

983,

she

has

exh

ibite

d w

idel

y in

Eur

ope

and

Nor

th A

mer

ica

and

was

inc

lude

d

in s

uch

maj

or s

how

s as

the

Ven

ice

Bie

nnia

l (1

999,

19

96),

Ist

anbu

l B

ienn

ial

(199

9,

1995

), a

nd D

ocum

enta

X (

with

Car

sten

Hol

ler,

199

7).

Rec

ent

one-

pers

on e

xhib

ition

s

wer

e pr

esen

ted

at t

he S

amm

lung

Goe

tz, M

unic

h (2

002)

, D

e P

ont

Fou

ndat

ion

for

Con

tem

pora

ry A

rt,

Tilb

urg

(200

1),

Mod

erna

Mus

eet,

Sto

ckho

lm (

2001

),

the

Ger

man

pavi

lion

in t

he V

enic

e B

ienn

ial

(199

9),

and

the

Kun

stha

lle,

Ham

burg

(tr

avel

ing

thro

ugho

ut

Eur

ope,

199

8).

She

liv

es a

nd w

orks

in

Col

ogne

.

sele

cted

b

iblio

gra

ph

y

Pro

Tes

t: R

osem

arie

Tro

ckel

Man

us S

plee

n 2.

Col

ogne

: W

alth

er K

onig

, 20

02.

Tex

t by

Ros

emar

ie T

rock

el.

Ros

emar

ie T

rock

el. M

unic

h: S

amm

lung

Goe

tz, 2

002.

Tex

ts b

y Jo

sefin

a A

yerz

a, L

ynne

Coo

ke,

lngv

ild G

oetz

, Rei

nald

Sch

umac

her,

and

Ste

phan

Urb

asch

ek.

Ros

s, C

hris

tina.

"V

isio

n an

d In

suffi

cien

cy a

t th

e T

urn

of t

he M

illen

nium

: R

osem

arie

Tro

ckel

's

Dis

trac

ted

Eye

," O

ctob

er,

no. 9

6 (S

prin

g 20

01 )

, pp.

86-

11

0.

Ros

emar

ie T

rock

el: L

a B

ienn

ale

di V

enez

ia 1

999.

2 v

ols.

New

Yor

k: N

abe

Pre

ss,

1999

. T

exts

by W

ilfrie

d D

ickh

off,

Gud

run

lnbo

den,

Ral

ph M

elch

er, J

oan

Sim

on, J

eann

ette

Sto

sche

k,

and

Lisa

Zei

ger.

Ros

emar

ie T

rock

el: B

odie

s of

Wor

k 19

86-1

998.

H

ambu

rger

Kun

stha

lle,

in a

ssoc

iatio

n w

ith

Okt

agon

Ver

lag,

Col

ogne

, 19

98.

Tex

ts b

y S

imon

e de

Bea

uvoi

r, W

ilfrie

d D

ickh

off,

Mar

guer

ite

Dur

as, Y

ilmaz

Dzi

ewio

r, S

ebas

tian

Ege

nhof

er,

Birt

e F

rens

sen,

Gud

run

lnbo

den,

Mel

itta

Klie

ge,

Cat

herin

e La

mpe

rt,

Hol

ger

Lieb

s, a

nd U

we

M. S

chne

ede.

Par

kett,

no.

33

(Sep

tem

ber

1992

). C

olla

bora

tion

with

Ros

emar

ie T

rock

el. T

exts

by

Ver

oniq

ue

Bac

chet

ta,

Ann

e M

. Wag

ner,

and

Bar

rett

Wat

ten.

Reb

ecca

Com

ay w

ill le

ctur

e on

Ros

emar

ie T

rock

el a

t D

ia o

n T

hurs

day,

Dec

embe

r 12

,

2002

, 6:

30 p

m.

Sup

port

for

thi

s ex

hibi

tion

has

been

pro

vide

d by

The

And

y W

arho

l F

ound

atio

n fo

r th

e

Vis

ual A

rts,

Ake

Ske

ppne

r, a

nd t

he m

embe

rs o

f th

e D

ia A

rt C

ounc

il.

site

map

an

d c

hec

klis

t

-->

I 13

0 12

/2 11

~ 3\

10

4f

1.

Ph

ob

ia,

2002

5

alum

inum

pla

tes

blac

k co

tton

trim

min

g in

stal

latio

n si

ze:

81 '2

x 6

1 /2 f

eet

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne G

alle

ry,

New

Yor

k

2.

Bey

on

d t

he

Val

ley

of

the

Do

lls, 2

000

50 a

lum

inum

pla

tes

inst

alla

tion

size

: 10

x 1

91 '2

feet

co

urte

sy M

onik

a S

pri.i

th G

aler

ie,

Col

ogne

, an

d B

arba

ra G

lads

tone

G

alle

ry,

New

Yor

k

3.

No

Wo

man

No

Cry

, 20

00

50 a

lum

inum

pla

tes

inst

alla

tion

size

: 11

x 1

63 /4

fe

et

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne G

alle

ry,

New

Yor

k

4.

Ran

cho

Del

uxe

, 20

01

15 a

lum

inum

pla

tes

inst

alla

tion

size

: 9

x 10

1 '2 f

eet

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne

Gal

lery

, N

ew Y

ork

5.

Bla

ckb

oar

d J

un

gle

, 20

02

72 a

lum

inum

pla

tes

inst

alla

tion

size

: 11

3 /4 x

63 /4

fe

et

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne

Gal

lery

, N

ew Y

ork

6.

Tre

asu

re o

f th

e S

ierr

a M

adre

, 20

02

77 a

lum

inum

pla

tes

inst

alla

tion

size

: 9

x 1 2

1 '2 f

eet

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne

Gal

lery

, N

ew Y

ork

7.

Man

u's

Sp

leen

2,

2002

vi

deo

proj

ectio

n w

ith s

ound

bl

ack

and

whi

te,

10:3

0 m

inut

es

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne

Gal

lery

, N

ew Y

ork

8.

Man

u's

Sp

leen

4,

2002

vi

deo

proj

ectio

n w

ith s

ound

co

lor,

7 :4

2 m

inut

es

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne

Gal

lery

, N

ew Y

ork

9.

Man

u's

Sp

leen

3,

2001

vi

deo

proj

ectio

n w

ith s

ound

co

lor,

1 :5

0 m

inut

es

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne

Gal

lery

, N

ew Y

ork

10.

Man

u's

Sp

leen

1, 2

000,

vi

deo

proj

ectio

n w

ith s

ound

co

lor,

7:2

0 m

inut

es

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne

Gal

lery

, N

ew Y

ork

11.

Man

u's

Sp

leen

5,

2002

vi

deo,

sile

nt

colo

r, 1

:30

min

utes

co

urte

sy M

onik

a S

pri.i

th G

aler

ie,

Col

ogne

, an

d B

arba

ra G

lads

tone

G

alle

ry,

New

Yor

k

1 2.

Lea

vin

g L

as V

egas

, 200

2 vi

deo

proj

ectio

n si

lent

co

lor,

5:1

2 m

inut

e lo

op

cour

tesy

Mon

ika

Spr

i.ith

Gal

erie

, C

olog

ne,

and

Bar

bara

Gla

dsto

ne

Gal

lery

, N

ew Y

ork

13.

Maq

uet

tes

for

un

real

ized

bo

oks

an

d c

atal

og

ues

, 19

83-2

000

Priv

ate

Col

lect

ion

C

C<

0 0 C

< "' " " i -"'

~ " ~ E ,g

~

( .; -"

' )

u 0 ..=

!!' :. E

~ 0 "' 0 t §

C

I \.

/

Ro

sem

arie

Tro

ckel

S

ple

en

Oct

ob

er 1

6, 2

002-

Jun

e 15

, 20

03

Dia

cen

ter

for

the

arts

54

8 w

est

22n

d s

tree

t n

ew y

ork

Page 2: ' C · Brecht's Joan Dark, messianic member of the Salvation Army in early-twentieth-century Chicago, in Saint Joan of the Stockyards (1928), his radically revisionist life of the

Ro

sem

arie

T

rock

el

Spl

een

Whe

n yo

u ar

e yo

ung

you

thin

k of

bei

ng a

n ac

tivis

t, a

polit

ical

act

ivis

t. T

his

rais

es t

he

ques

tion

of w

heth

er y

ou r

eally

wan

t to

do

som

ethi

ng f

or o

ther

peo

ple

or t

o de

mon

stra

te

a ki

nd o

f se

lf-ad

mira

tion.

Whe

n I s

tart

ed t

o w

ork

on B

rigitt

e B

ardo

t th

at w

hole

dis

cuss

ion

cam

e ba

ck b

ecau

se s

he i

s su

ch a

con

trov

ersi

al f

igur

e-an

d sh

e re

calls

Mot

her

Cou

rage

.

It's

very

inte

rest

ing

that

she

has

this

qua

lity

of b

eing

a m

odel

for

eve

ryth

ing.

And

yet

she

is

alw

ays

deco

nstr

uctin

g he

r ow

n ro

le, e

ven

if no

t al

way

s in

a v

ery

refle

ctiv

e w

ay ...

. T

he f

act

of b

eing

a m

odel

doe

sn't

indi

cate

whe

ther

it's

a p

ositi

ve m

odel

, whe

ther

it's

goo

d or

bad

.

A m

odel

is n

ot s

trai

ghtfo

rwar

d, n

ot s

o cl

ear:

it's

mad

e ou

t of

circ

umst

ance

s, i

nclu

ding

you

r

own

pers

pect

ive.

The

re i

s no

mod

el f

or h

ow t

o de

al w

ith a

mod

el.

-Ros

emar

ie

Tro

ckel

Def

ined

as

'the

seat

of

emot

ions

and

pas

sion

s," s

plee

n is

the

sem

inal

con

cept

inf

orm

ing

a

cycl

e of

sho

rt v

ideo

pro

ject

ions

, ba

sed

on a

you

ng w

oman

nam

ed M

anu,

whi

ch R

osem

arie

Tro

ckel

has

bee

n in

volv

ed w

ith f

or s

ome

time.

For

thei

r pr

esen

tatio

n at

Dia

she

has

orch

estr

ated

an

inst

alla

tion

arou

nd a

seq

uenc

e of

arc

hite

ctur

al i

nter

vent

ions

. F

ive

free

­

stan

ding

wal

ls, w

hose

out

er s

urfa

ces

are

arm

ored

in

an i

nter

lock

ing

patte

rn o

f m

obile

met

al p

late

s, c

ut a

pat

h th

roug

h th

e re

furb

ishe

d w

areh

ouse

gal

lery

. On

the

obve

rse

of

each

is

a pr

ojec

tion,

sca

led

to s

ite.

In th

e re

cess

es o

f th

e sp

ace,

two

vitr

ines

con

tain

maq

uette

s fo

r un

real

ized

boo

ks a

nd c

atal

ogue

s. A

djac

ent

is a

brie

f am

bien

t lo

opin

g vi

deo,

Leav

ing

Las

Veg

as (2

002)

, sh

ot b

y a

cam

era

crui

sing

slo

wly

thr

ough

a s

ilent

sto

rage

site

whe

re a

band

oned

ref

riger

ator

s aw

ait

recy

clin

g. T

his

ghos

tly f

oota

ge i

s su

gges

tivel

y,

if in

defin

ably

, con

nect

ed w

ith t

he s

heat

hed

scul

ptur

al w

alls

.'

Man

u's

Spl

een

1 (2

000)

is

set

in

a ce

met

ery.

Afte

r tw

o co

nsor

ts h

ave

shift

ed a

cor

pse

in a

n op

en g

rave

to

one

side

, m

akin

g ro

om f

or a

sec

ond

incu

mbe

nt,

Man

u ju

mps

in

and

falls

bac

k, p

rone

, as

if sh

e to

o w

ere

dead

. Jus

t as

abr

uptly

, she

cla

mbe

rs o

ut,

and

the

trio

lea

ves

as c

asua

lly a

s it

had

arriv

ed. T

houg

h th

e co

nver

satio

n is

nev

er h

eard

, a h

eart

­

stop

ping

ly p

lang

ent

mel

ody

acco

mpa

nies

the

epi

sode

, its

hau

ntin

g re

frai

n lin

gerin

g in

the

view

er's

min

d lo

ng a

fter

the

cred

its h

ave

rolle

d. A

ttrac

tive,

rel

axed

, Tro

ckel

's p

rota

goni

sts

are

blith

ely

imm

une

to a

ny s

ugge

stio

n of

the

mac

abre

or

goth

ic h

orro

r: e

mot

iona

l cu

es

are

inst

ead

trig

gere

d by

the

unfo

rget

tabl

e so

undt

rack

.

The

whi

msi

calit

y pe

rmea

ting

Man

u's

Spl

een

1 is

mat

ched

by

a di

sorie

ntin

g ca

pric

ious

ness

in M

anu'

s S

plee

n 3

(200

1 ),

whi

ch a

ddre

sses

birt

h, a

lbei

t ob

lique

ly, a

nd a

esth

etic

cre

ativ

ity,

by im

plic

atio

n. A

t a

baby

sho

wer

, a

preg

nant

wom

an,

agai

n M

anu,

blo

ws

out

the

cand

les

on a

cak

e am

id m

uch

hila

rity

and

exci

tem

ent.

As

she

puffs

, th

e bu

rst

of a

bal

loon

is

hear

d,

and

her

stom

ach

sim

ulta

neou

sly

defla

tes.

Usu

ally

con

side

red

a co

nditi

on o

f hy

ster

ia,

here

fal

se p

regn

ancy

thr

eate

ns t

o be

com

e a

colle

ctiv

e m

ania

, in

that

its

unm

aski

ng f

ails

to i

nter

rupt

thi

s ef

ferv

esce

nt c

eleb

ratio

n. I

ndee

d th

e br

ief

epis

ode

repe

ats

twic

e m

ore,

to

the

allu

ring

stra

ins

of M

adon

na's

rec

ordi

ng o

f "D

on't

Tel

l Me"

pla

yed

back

war

ds,

in r

ewin

d.

Onc

e ag

ain,

wha

t sh

ould

hav

e be

en a

dis

turb

ing,

eve

n un

cann

y, e

vent

ref

utes

str

aigh

tforw

ard

inte

rpre

tatio

n. S

lyly

and

gla

ncin

gly,

Man

u's

Spl

een

3 in

timat

es t

hat

even

thos

e cu

ltura

lly

\ co

nstr

ucte

d no

tions

tha

t in

scrib

e th

e m

ost

fund

amen

tal

form

s of

fem

ale

crea

tivity

int

o

the

soci

al c

an b

e fr

eed

of t

heir

debi

litat

ing

path

olog

ical

, m

enta

l, an

d em

otio

nal

attr

ibut

es.

Sim

ilarly

, as

evid

ence

d in

the

inau

gura

l vi

deo

in th

e se

ries,

that

sel

f-ob

sess

ed

mor

bid

mel

anch

olia

rom

antic

ally

cre

dite

d to

mal

e ge

nius

may

pro

ve b

ut a

gui

se t

o be

ado

pted

at

will

.

For

mul

ated

with

the

ter

se c

onci

sion

of

a te

levi

sion

inf

omer

cial

or

an M

TV

clip

, the

se w

orks

posi

tion

the

view

er a

s a

disp

assi

onat

e w

itnes

s to

con

stru

ctio

ns o

f id

entit

y pr

emis

ed o

n a

labi

le r

ole-

play

ing.

In M

anu'

s S

plee

n 2

(200

2),

the

epon

ymou

s fig

ure

beco

mes

the

adj

unct

to

a sp

eake

r at

a de

mon

stra

tion

prot

estin

g th

e pr

opos

ed d

emol

ition

of

two

key

cultu

ral

icon

s, th

e C

olog

ne

Kun

stve

rein

, an

d K

unst

halle

whi

ch f

or d

ecad

es h

ave

been

the

site

of

vang

uard

exh

ibiti

ons

and

rela

ted

prog

ram

min

g. S

hot

in b

lack

and

whi

te i

n a

docu

men

tary

mod

e, th

is w

ork

feat

ures

the

ren

owne

d ac

tor

Udo

Kie

r, a

nat

ive

of t

he c

ity, w

hom

Tro

ckel

inv

ited

to r

ead

a sp

eech

she

wro

te f

or b

oth

this

vid

eo a

nd a

s he

r ow

n co

ntrib

utio

n to

the

ong

oing

cam

paig

n, t

o w

hich

she

is

pass

iona

tely

com

mitt

ed.

Con

flatin

g in

vent

ion

and

actu

ality

,

fictio

n an

d hi

stor

y, M

anu'

s S

plee

n 2

elud

es e

asy

clas

sific

atio

n; f

or, w

hile

fol

low

ing

Tro

ckel

's

dire

ctiv

es,

the

acto

r, in

his

ow

n rig

ht a

s a

loca

l citi

zen,

sim

ulta

neou

sly

cont

ests

the

pol

itica

l

deci

sion

. T

heir

dres

s, m

ien,

and

man

ner

add

a fu

rthe

r tw

ist:

he a

nd M

anu

infu

se i

nto

this

deba

te a

cou

nte

Q:

ultu

ral

aura

red

olen

t of

the

six

ties,

the

era

in w

hich

the

Kun

stve

rein

and

Kun

stha

lle w

ere

esta

blis

hed.

In c

ontr

ast,

Man

u's

Spl

een

5 (2

002)

tr

eats

the

med

ium

of

vide

o as

a c

onve

nien

t de

vice

for

reco

rdin

g a

quix

otic

ges

te,

an a

gile

im

prov

isat

ion

redo

lent

of

a F

luxu

s pe

rfor

man

ce

or a

ctio

n. H

ere,

as

else

whe

re i

n th

e se

ries,

the

unas

sum

ing

mod

esty

of

the

ende

avor

, the

disa

rmin

g lig

htne

ss o

f to

uch,

and

the

com

ic t

ende

rnes

s be

tray

Tro

ckel

's s

igna

ture

sen

sibi

lity.

Beg

uilin

g ye

t cr

yptic

, M

anu

is a

key

rol

e m

odel

in

Tro

ckel

's c

urre

nt p

anth

eon,

am

ong

the

mos

t po

tent

and

per

sist

ent

of w

hom

is

Brig

itte

Bar

do!.

BB

: th

ose

ubiq

uito

us i

nitia

ls

inev

itabl

y co

njur

e th

e F

renc

h ac

tres

s w

ho h

as lo

ng t

ease

d an

d ta

xed

adm

irers

as

wel

l as

detr

acto

rs,

prov

okin

g w

ildly

div

erse

res

pons

es f

rom

suc

h di

sput

atio

us f

emin

ists

as

Sim

one

de B

eauv

oir

and

Mar

guer

ite D

uras

. The

y al

so b

elon

g to

the

Ger

man

pla

ywrig

ht B

erto

lt

Bre

cht,

who

se M

othe

r C

oura

ge i

s si

mila

rly c

onte

sted

. W

ar p

rofit

eer

or m

isgu

ided

mat

erna

l

prot

ecto

r? E

xplo

iter

or h

isto

ry's

vic

tim?

Or

...

Man

u's

Spl

een

4 (2

002)

di

still

s an

d co

nden

ses

Bre

cht's

pla

y in

to a

six

-and

-a-h

alf-

min

ute

vide

o pr

ojec

tion.

Its

cas

t of

hyb

rid c

hara

cter

s ce

nter

on

Cou

rage

(pl

ayed

by

Man

u) w

ho,

dres

sed

in a

Cou

rreg

es o

utfit

, pr

imps

and

pre

ens

in f

ront

of

a fr

ying

pan

/mirr

or.

Kat

trin

,

her

ill-s

tarr

ed m

ute

daug

hter

, is

mel

ded

into

tha

t qu

inte

ssen

tial

fem

ale

mar

tyr

Joan

of

Arc

,

who

se m

ost

here

tical

act

s, in

the

judg

men

t of

the

pro

secu

ting

eccl

esia

stic

al a

utho

ritie

s,

incl

uded

her

ref

usal

to

rem

ove

men

's a

ttire

and

res

ume

clot

hes

appr

opria

te t

o he

r st

atus

(and

gen

der)

.' T

he p

rost

itute

Yve

tte, w

ho a

lone

pro

fited

fro

m t

he w

ar b

y fin

ally

mar

ryin

g a

colo

nel,

is c

onfla

ted

with

Jac

kie

O; f

ittin

gly,

she

spe

nds

her

time

polis

hing

and

ser

vici

ng a

gian

t ca

non.

Like

Bre

cht,

Tro

ckel

lam

inat

es m

ultip

le r

efer

ence

s an

d na

rrat

ives

.' F

or e

xam

ple,

Frie

dric

h vo

n S

chill

er, C

arl

Dre

yer,

Rob

ert

Bre

sson

, an

d P

eter

Tch

aiko

vsky

(am

ong

the

num

erou

s ot

hers

who

tac

kled

the

sub

ject

of

Joan

of

Arc

) w

ere

criti

cal

to h

er c

ompo

site

cre

atio

n. E

qual

ly d

eter

min

ing

wer

e ce

rtai

n co

nsta

nts

in

her

own

prac

tice,

fro

m t

he s

ymbo

lic a

nd a

ssoc

iativ

e ro

le s

he h

as lo

ng a

ccor

ded

dres

s, c

ostu

me,

and

cou

ture

, to

her

abi

ding

fas

cina

tion

with

a p

anop

ly o

f in

stan

­

tiatio

ns o

f th

e id

ol, c

ult

figur

e, a

nd s

tar

in th

e co

ntem

pora

ry c

ultu

ral

imag

inar

y.

Mem

orab

le, t

oo, i

s ho

w b

oth

Bre

cht

and

Tro

ckel

use

mus

ical

int

erlu

des

to

punc

tuat

e th

e un

fold

ing

of a

tale

, as

com

men

tary

or

coun

terp

art.

A c

onst

antly

inte

rrup

ted

radi

o tr

ansm

issi

on,

mad

e by

Kat

trin

sw

itchi

ng t

he d

ial f

rom

sta

tion

to

stat

ion

in a

fran

tic a

ttem

pt t

o un

ders

tand

the

inf

amy

unra

velin

g ac

ross

the

wor

ld,

is th

e ve

hicl

e fo

r T

rock

el's

bril

liant

ly c

ompa

cted

sou

ndtr

ack.

He

r m

ise-

en-s

cene

is m

odel

ed o

n th

e de

finin

g pe

rfor

man

ce b

y th

e B

erlin

er E

nsem

ble

in 1

949,

in

whi

ch t

he i

sola

ted

cart

is

turn

ed i

n on

e di

rect

ion

whi

le b

eing

hau

led

in a

noth

er.

War

's in

evita

ble

fodd

er,

the

sons

Eile

f an

d S

wis

s C

hees

e ar

e qu

ickl

y di

spat

ched

.

Gar

bed

in f

lesh

-col

ored

le

otar

ds t

o en

hanc

e th

eir

imm

atur

e in

noce

nce,

the

y

are

sedu

ced

by th

e ga

ping

thr

oat

of t

he c

anon

, sac

rific

ed t

o a

vora

ciou

s P

hallu

s.

Iden

tical

blo

nds

occu

py th

e pr

ompt

er's

box

, a c

horu

s co

mpr

ised

of

Bar

do!

and

her

doub

le.

(i;}

Man

u's

Spl

een

4, th

e os

mot

ic f

low

of

desi

re a

nd d

ashe

d ho

pes,

of

irony

and

earn

estn

ess,

aga

in p

erta

ins

to t

he w

ork'

s re

posi

tioni

ng i

n th

e 19

60s.

The

fai

led

utop

ian

drea

ms

of t

he C

old

War

-with

its

doo

med

offs

prin

g, l

iber

atio

n an

d re

sis­

tanc

e m

ovem

ents

-are

po

igna

ntly

con

jure

d in

Joh

n Le

nnon

's y

earn

ing

refr

ain

"imag

ine

all t

he p

eopl

e." S

ince

war

and

bus

ines

s ar

e, a

ccor

ding

to

Bre

cht,

but

two

side

s of

the

sam

e co

in, t

he p

ostw

ar w

orld

was

fac

ed w

ith a

his

toric

al p

re­

dica

men

t of

unp

rece

dent

ed g

ravi

ty. I

nitia

lly d

ecep

tivel

y ly

rical

, ulti

mat

ely

deep

ly

disq

uiet

ing

, Tro

ckel

's p

resc

ient

rew

orki

ng o

f B

rech

t's c

lass

ic is

unn

ervi

ngly

tim

ely.

Men

tors

at

once

fla

wed

and

ins

pira

tiona

l, de

Bea

uvoi

r, D

uras

, Bar

do!,

and

oth

ers

offe

r ex

empl

ary,

if n

ot p

resc

riptiv

e, e

xplo

ratio

ns o

f ge

nder

rol

es. B

ut,

in th

eir

mul

­

tiple

, al

mos

t co

ntra

ry, a

ppro

ache

s to

the

con

cept

of

the

role

mod

el, s

uch

anti­

thet

ical

fig

ures

ind

icat

e w

hy i

t is

so

diffi

cult

to i

dent

ify a

the

oret

ical

ly c

onsi

sten

t,

anal

ytic

ally

gro

unde

d fe

min

ist

agen

da w

ithin

Tro

ckel

's p

ract

ice.

In

her

art,

the

fem

inin

e an

d fe

min

ist

cons

tant

ly i

nter

twin

e an

d re

frac

t, pe

rsis

tent

ly c

onfo

undi

ng

dogm

atic

for

mul

atio

n. T

his

ceas

eles

s pr

obin

g of

rec

eive

d no

tions

, cl

iche

d

conv

entio

ns,

and

inst

itutio

naliz

ed v

alue

s is

effe

cted

by

sub

terf

uge,

beg

uile

men

t,

cont

radi

ctio

n, a

nd r

igor

ous

circ

umve

ntio

n of

the

por

tent

ous,

mon

umen

tal,

and

alle

gedl

y si

gnifi

cant

. F

orsw

earin

g a

foun

datio

n in

wha

t ar

e de

emed

ess

entia

list.

trut

hs,

the

Spl

een

serie

s is

pre

mis

ed o

n th

e be

lief

that

wha

t is

in c

onte

ntio

n ar

e

not

visi

ons

of r

ealit

y bu

t st

ereo

type

s an

d ar

chet

ypes

, tho

se p

erva

sive

and

top

ical

repr

esen

tatio

ns t

hat

only

mas

quer

ade

as u

npro

blem

atic

and

una

ssai

labl

e.

L.C

.


Recommended