(:f...J..> 9 ~-

2001"" 3 ...

D*:It.R

2001 ~/t':;::;ffja<J.Ji~ (1994 - 1998) ~1I.#:Wf...tft.~RJj, Jt.1I_*:Wf.

.~'f¥~YIiiJt,.Jt"~*~"a<J ~M-.~o ~.UQ~~.( 1989 - 1993):4fi1t,_*

itiJt1):tI 1370 7f /t':;:t.m, _# t'1t 1.431-11;t g.; ;a#.Jt:l:1):fI 6 il.:}'r.1i*,_#.~~~...:kTmft..(A.~ E. ,2000)0 ~ffijftm*~JiYrIiiI~a<J~~~~"-_o~.::I?¥~}J;~:.#".::f..".,.{\'liif:e1..:e1.:8::i&:i&-flET1Itff.#~~~~~*.v.; *Jt!1..a~m.~t!:im~.B:k (IBJrI»JlBJ, ~ 281 7f/t':;:t.m*Jt!1..a~m~~fiE t!:i~~~::t~*-); ~miE:fi" 5704 7f /t':;:~x.#- (t!:iIl:f:iif:e1.a<J 6%), ;KI:JI~*

mili t!:i 82% 0 iX"'~m. iij" VJ.JI3tft:1i1:ft.m:ffilf~*~::f.."~.:ijf.~WP 0

*x~mM~~~~~a<J~~.it~~iX~~_~ooa<J..tt~.o .§~~

.?~, :i!:JI._*.t!liifJt .:e1..::f.."~ ~.:x.#Jt!1.IiiJtB :ka<J.~M~;I:.*:Ii:.::f.." Ji:.,

ffijB::Wf::f.." Ji:.X;i!m T.#B:Aa<J!lni&~ (~It~"J~)iioJiYr:ift;~~ 0 iX.mJjf&a<J#~a<J!lni&:U.(i&A.~.$.*).~.#~moffij#:t&.a~m~:!:~PA:¥~#~mT#~~~:1i1~~.~.*a<J_*ltmT;K~~~~~~~~.~.*a<J_@WPo

*x~.::I?.~~~ :~m ~ 1iJ:ff~:ff:Ji:.a<J, iij"V).mT#~~~~.*~~¥. 0#~~iti~~~_~Iii~mT.~..~~~::f.."~.,~ffij~*~~~a<J~i&~~,.1fmJlt§tjit!£.~.Xij"#~~:li:A(:jjR;~"'~~..::f.."8b:ffm~~)jfjj:i!:~~offij!£.~

.M#~:li:A::f.."Ji:.&~*~.~Xij"#~B:Aa<J.ffm.,~~~.:x.n~.:x.~m:k~

#~:li:Aa<J1t~ r, iX'" M1 itiit)g)g~'::f.."tIJaXl.o W1Jll~~~:ft. m#~ a<J:i!fIJI~~,

~~...~~~..~,~~,iij".,MIfij.~~~*11fIa<J*..I!r.~~a.o.~:ff

~~~~~.iij" VJ.1t~~~~jIJ~::f~/t':;:-:ff~~~1*:bn~~*~ (~jfJ~~ Ifb#)~:Ii:

A,~Ifij1f!jj:JMre§B~*..I!r.:li:A~.tg.1B:~_~.-Ilf:~,~~~:U.:ka<J_J8:a<Jt$1t

IfJ:(~~~*a<J:m~)o~~,~m;lf*Jt!1.a<JitifJ1..~}}".~.ilI~~m.1&.ilI~~1-

jjl:ljt'-~,.#..1tl.~..,Jt.m#~~itillQia<Jf11-_!NJiifit~.J!~_a.o

*x.~M#~m~a<J.~.ilI~~ti.1&.ilI~~~,~.;t~:ft.~iij"mT*~~

F~~~~~..~~Nox.~~=.~~m~~~~~~-~~*.~,~fi~~:*x..dJ._,'J1".,..~,~tt1f,~.~..#.tI$.'i:"..l.oxrp",~z.~dJ~.m.o

- 141 -

MANAGEMENT WORLD

2001No.3

~ #~..~~J.~tt..~.~~~~ ~ #~~. ~ ~~&#_~.#..~~~~~~*o~.~.~~lli~~*.tlI-~..f£~.~o

. ,** ~.m i'lt! ~:;I; t<J J'tl ~ ~ m1R J'tl ~

~T.#_~.#..~~it.~J:A:Stfi.:f:_~m.A.::f.o A1f1X1j".:f:~~:fIJmil#:m:VJ.JB:>J<:.:f:~fft{i (~~m)

.xit~~~~o.~~~~m.:f:_m~mfft{i~~m.

~~fflfft~.~m.~~~~~~o~#~~~,.:f:~~mfft~~.~m..,*,:m:~~~.~.-R (..ilf:n~m)o Bi

VJ.#~(£.;tz:~.~~IW;##~~~~jJjt.§."ti:.~~.~o#~(£.;tz:~@.~~.#~~.~;tz:(£.~~~~~(£.~~~¥ ~~.:f:_m ~~~m .P~;tz:(£. ~~~~~.-

~o#~~;tz:~.~~IW;-.~~_~~~M,~.~n§~~no#~~;tz:~m~~~~#~~~.~~~,~~~~n1t"~_no

.:f:~Bi.~(£.~~~~~nh*~~~~~.,§M.:f:.r.h ,.m:JIJ~.(:«~.n1!~~) ,.~~iiJ:fIJmfilf~~o*~~.~~liiJm.~~m-&~lPJo.:f:~~~.:iI.~n~~~~~~~Wh~.#~~fl~~~.:«.:f:_~tiE~m~o

II 1.m~':x;~~tiE~~, -&1!..mrf:l1t,m.:iX-

.:f:_~~~~.~r~#~(£.~~.~~~~@.~~om~~~~tiE~~,.:f:~~~n;tz:(£.~_ti~._~mrf:l,t,m.~!t*ifIj.~o :(£..mrf:l,t,jfi~_n (AB It),.:f:jfp,~1i1.)jt~ ~m ~fft{i.jtj 0 ~_~m rf:I.t'~~~_1I(CE St), .:f:..mT#~(£.~~~~.~o ~~"J1t-T~.ZI'B](BC St)o ~Jtt. C h,.:1::#~(£.~~.~.it1~o

ff~-~~~.:f:_~tiE.iiJVJ.m~ml~~~mm.~o Bi~~~*tiE~m~~~T~~~.:f:~:fIJm~~~~~om 1 ~iiJVJ.ml1J~1f1m..:f:_~m~~ito ~:e~.:f:-fft..xit (:«~~~h), .~*~~*~ .:f:":fIJffl~.~1&.t.ifn$.*o~~,~#~~~~"I&~(_m)J::j~~(£.~~~~~~~¥.JJ;f,~.:iX;;@:m~*Ufft.L.,tt~XIj"::ft:*Ufftfi «(£.~~~) _**1Jn, #~~(£.~$.*~.~,:«~~~fft.~~.r.,~~~~~m_.~.~it~#~ffl~o~~eoo*.#~~~m~~~ffl~~~~~~:iX~#_~fi#~(£.~Bi~*~~~.~~~m.Bi

- - -..1tJItI.t'~.

111 *"~m~tlJ.liJit~~.~it$

.*~~~m¥~~o .~~~~~~

.#~:fl"#~itiJl.:$:!P~-_o

#ji~F;tf~~Il~~~o-gf]A/fiJ~~ 7 .#~:fl"#- iti:81.:;;:,J\ atJ ¥J

-_o~~-~I1~~~~~7~n*ft~*".~JN.~1OAI:i!:#a<J1f~

~fi~.tt*~~Fo¥J-~~~~:fl".**~.~JN.~.*fto~~~~~~..~#~~.~.a<J@~~~~M~.#tl<Jll~~~o

:RI1.~~1-Il~~~~.'ft(~a<J

$.mtI<J~..~,~~~~~~~~JI.*;f:fi.*~~, 'E1(];".f'":;;:~.;f:fi-

~o~~~~¥~~M.#~~FJI.*~I~, *~~~.#~ ~~~J, @~*~~"..AI~#.;".f'"-~~~~J:.~.oPJT~it.~.a<J@1Ji:~~ttJJ:

~.#~I1~~~¥'J\o~ml~,it~~.~It:M.#RCJ

1l~~~jj-:B4IiJDh.~Eh..7i\oKr

~,~CDm:a<J#~-.t~fi*~~AI.#~ft~~J, ~ D h.*~~~fi A

I:i&:*;".f'"~;".f'"'5lZ>o

~1r-TDEz.I'BJ~*~J:.~:fi'*

~ft~*J, @~ 10 AI.#.~~ J:.~

;tt-,PJT~*'ft~¥~.*~:!:.oirD'

E ,~z.*~#"J:.~.#.~X*~o~.~~~~1'PJ. ,~~1-~~h.a<JItiJ~~

r.~OO~~.~m~~~F~X~~Fm~a<Jtt~~~~.*~~~o

- 142-

<* w..)~JJ of!!2001~. 3~

~~J:I..*.*,I999~m:J:I#j*=&lr~.m~-fttlliiti ,:1;5 861l:*.:7f.o i4'if#j*=IflI~lfi J:I".'&:I:~~JI*~(II 2), 1999 ~:I;5:t1J 591l~.:7f.o ..¥

~~~.ffl~*X~.~~~*~~~e~~~

#m, jJr~*~~~.#I~~F,~~~~M.",~~#j*=&lr~.ffl~-@.*77%~#f/t~12% ~~*~.o t1T~.$.A~m/fi, ttall#»*1I#~~F.~#f/t-J.J{.~~~f1i:tf#.1It"*.ii~.~ 6O%tr."ti<M 3)0 ~~lJJaIlA;;(f

-~~.~'fiJmT(~~.mT)#j'f.~~rz:~~*N~~o ~~.~§.~.ffl:tlJ#~~~ k*~!.1;'~RJJ T:ett:!d~mf*M"F~.*E*J~f=II.1fr ~J ~ ~ .If:fl::k 0

:t£.M73!31-,'t1.~~s,~m~I:);*!JJ-fT#~~~.~.W ~~!JJ-jlj~.~#~~fi.,~~"0:6: CD 8:,.#*-ftJfi~fi.#~1f#~I:);.:Il

"j,:a: ~:*f(J<Jij:.~rnJ1Jr#~~~#:.ft":ii;#~"#~~.f! ,1ifrI:);~~~.#~.I£.r:., 1:);-1&10~#~~.:Jg.::F.~.Ii:#~o:6: DE l\l:,.-#*=its

.#.#~..:Il"j,:6: -.1t~r#ji'..I£.~;f'fi:.ft".#'".#~~.tt,~I:);~~~..J(.JX;J"#~~"(~J(f"'.!t:Jf:d::iIt#ji.l£.~:;-g.~:ii:#~.#m~:i!filt.~~I!i):1g :F.:I:.#~ 0 MrJlJ::I::t£

.~!:F.~.::a:It.~.W(J<J-Jg:o:6: E ,~Z*~.*##{\'lT~Ji"Jg:,:6:-"1f~~~~.ifijl'.f!*it,1ifrV)._J(f~.f£~~:I:'f¥~~~.#,1!'Ein*,:'=!k~ ,*'m_- ~ ~'" .£*:7r.

A:Jg~.(J<JiI:.o

=,**~~.;o:a"J~.

Jml~983~I~-l98? 1989- 1~1 1993 -"--' - 1m.&}

1!2~~#.?-&4t!:u~.II 2 w.~: ... e <ef:1 ~.~ait~..)o #f"ir-mMi!:ttI Q ~... 44(*»-*-

B),4S( .*»-~tfir),47(*.),48(.~~.~A).o

,~ 1997

£~70

60

50

40

30

~

10

0 -1981 1983 1985 \987 1989 1991 1993 1995 --- ~&

IJ 3 tlJ #. jk. tlJ £. '*'" It it 4t .. +- .t. # It-,~ . .'l" :t tlJ ~ 1/t113~~:#.*..*..tt; ft(IfI.#*.tt".)o.x#.M-.~i*'.~#*

.#i*'~Iti!.I:t.(-*jC)x7"xA~~~-*jCft::.o

1991

;;fn;Jt-ft!!~~~Fm;fJ-~,*~~F...:t._,lJ11,.::&::,~~.~.*I-atJ..(Bi.*(I(J~Jf) ~i.lo ftll;ff ~1I.:t.1ti:eJ.

6%(J"J~#j1:L1!.¥.!t;:ff~JIJ.{t,

B5.;ffitt:$a*:*;;fn8*#_o ..ili(J"Jif~B5..~, ~lIIili 1/3 atJ

tJ,-M;;P;~~R-.(I(J*7t,iiJVlm*

"'."'.(~~~~I@.~tt,

1999) 0 :It~.&I!ij#~~F.!J;'

atJ~..:t.Jlko ~ 1I:;ij'1ltlf..t. 21 %

(I(J}..O," 24%(l(JlJ~11o ¥J~~,

ilf$:/{nlJ11.~;fiJL1-Ji~~

~~, W1iilf$~~.~m:tE:i!

~x.#_,"#_,.*~JIk~~*~.~jffo.~'ftkf(]a<J~~*:v-~jt;,.m~-(If.,~m~~a.JR.JjJ(J"J~~~l!ijftin~~~:;I:.~ a<J -* ~ 11, 'ftk in ~ Iii] ilf ~ A. :fi"

::1t:~#.~o~.*1tVl*,~~#j*=.§=t.

143-

MANAGEMENT WORLD

No.3 2001

*.#~~~~Q~&~~~~~~~~~~&tifl1;N;~II~~j*'n<J#j*'~:t£Jjj~(jJfj\rtr:J1JfI1

fft~.f1:r;f:n~"ola]D;j',#_iiif{j'"*i!w.1t,

~~~.~,.~~.*~~~~~m.~W.

.1i:..A.~~.~o

~~~~ ~~Jft ~A~#~~~~~*~.(~@f1:)-:t._,~j] ,~~.fI1..~-m~

W~~mIlJirtr:l1J.t.~~$j]~#~6tJ*IiJD;j"f¥

~ ~ B~~~D;j',~1Il~ft~~~ili~(jJ.~.

.~ , x f§~ f1'~ Jj; f§ Iii ~ . ~ ::u:f. ft ~:bIt 1-'J. - ~

~,iiJ1-'J.f/J\liJ~#n<J~~~.-.~,~~~#.Jir..oWl:-tiJili-&,* ~... ~Mn<J#}]t~_,~JlJ:;I;t:~.. ,1I:;KfJf.*~ ~M.#:N.J;t:J:io

T 1:.f"#~il..fj:: (3)0

ftll::A~Ji:.~.?3'jJ,*.~::f.#fp.#~o

~m~.X~.T~$~tl~.~o~~.~~

1:.f"~*~~#~1:.f"~M~~.o~a.*~

:;;t1tA.ff1X1j":i1f;fi#.ft1:.j.!t:mifij1:..,~.;;tR:Ao

$ifi..&Jr~~~fl1:.j.!t:~#f"i.~.~;Jt~II.1:.

j.!t:~#f"~~~-M~m5, ~-~..~~~~.~~MT~1n~#~~~~**., ~~~

~YJ~**.oIII 11:J:1#~.4:f"~_mdif~ (IE):f:~.~#

~~a~*~.~~~~..&Jrj.!t:1:.~ojn.#~1:.j.!t:~..&Jr.m~~YJ~*~#...&Jr.~~~-@~1t~,.~EI!~~,,~::.&:~~.#~;ti~~..&Jr.*~.~a~*~#~~~~~m8~T~1II1~IE tJ.r4'fi~ HE ~,ftP~#]k1:.f"Jifr~*~.1&~~r40~1n"iiJ I:J)}..~ 1-lfifiJfI)! -fFm._A"*7t~o.M-,#.ft~f=~.~:Jl:zJij';ItiJ*.~()}..c s.#~JlJ G s.) ,RP#-..a~m.~ r!i m o.=,it~~'#~m:Mc:Jl:z~ItiJI:1'J#~(~Dh-#~jlJ F h-)o)!*f;,1:.~.JfI FD 8:~#:Ii.~~:pj:J11

fi;;tR:A,)Aifij~.mXlt#.ftW:A~.fflll*(J.OC

"EI!.I1lW:Jt~*-.~ DE t'"*~ FE)o:&:fcJR

::f.jJ~x~:Im*JfI*.\IlBA~.re~,J!.7t*/

_.~~~&~~~o~M1-:Jl:z~.~~~..

"ifiil../J'o.'::::, El!T*~1:.f"PJf~.~:lft1&

.:U:. ~ Iff , .4: j.!t: ::1- JfI # .\Il ~ B A -!;P , )AIM 1t ( G F

8:~).#Ns;.~., ftP-.iP:iIiil.'I'il...1l{;o~~a.*~VJ., *~j.!t:~~.~A,,*,,*

~:(£.3-5~.;{i-~*~..~~0~.*:Mc~M (1980- 1983)#~~fiT ".::::~" (ftP.~llJ

;ti~#;ti, ~~ a illlJ, .~#~~~.ff.) 0

~-.m~~7#.\Il~;ti~*~~~,~.~~"MM ,1&.;ti:k/J' ":l(~:ft~,, AI~iJ:ft~ ,...~.o 1985 ~~II.,,*#Jg:J11fiT*;ftm:WI*;Mc, 1987~X~~".~., 1993~X..*:Mco )!~jJl:.L~&.:I:.~ T~;ti r:p1&:~;ti*/J'

~-*~ooo~ft~mX~ffT.~~~~.~M~~1lJ~_01998~Ri.7t_Jg:X~.T~tli

'=:,"f'=fJl, ~~P.t*,I:1~,*:ti.~

.#..~JiYr.,~Jti,.JI.'"Itk~~.#.!/l

.. ~ . 'L- 0 ~ ~ ~ "J:i:: Eb .;# j1'i: ~ $Ij It JiYr t:R: ~

~o.#j1'i:~t:R:~Tj1'i:~JiYr~~~~JiYr~~Mj1'i:~~*Itk~~ft~off1iiJj1'i:~.-:If~"'~:fiE,:!In~,*tt ,$Jm: ,1tk:6i.~*/J',~~:&If, RJ$til:ft.J.f.,It'fmfi~.o.#j1'i:~$tJ J.f.~~ T #.!/l.."JJti

~~.~Itk~~~oR~~.#j1'i:~.~RJ~~.iB:*fIII.J!.j1'i:~.~-:lfmm-ft,1JDit#.!/l~Mo

~.~*~AmJti~~~,.~~~~j1'i:~~..mo~a$.*~j1'i:~~w.~:*=~~::(£*$J,"~,~~,RJ.~f=~_1f'f,~a1£*it1l{;o&Z,:(£$~~ ,~MiJCJ ,~~:f:t~Pfr/[}i.I..~ ,~~~X;fft~-ftkA~~:fT-Jg.JJ:.~j]~f=~$JIf'f,~aJB;*it.o:Wl:'fijifi&,~a.$.*~f=~.lf~~-.~~~~~W:~-~~j1'i:~~~'f.:fi"-~~~a~*o ¥J-~W, j1'i:~ftilJJ.f.~:&:.J!.:i1J~-ft.-tf!.:§::~aJR.*(J(J.~ (Demsetz, 1967) 0

~a~*~.J!.j1'i:1£*~:*=~~~.~JR.(J(Jo~1I{;~~a~*~Am~_~..J!.j1'i:~~.,".all 0 :Wl:'fijili-m, ~...~~~s.*ItiJJ:. T AfflX;f.J!.

j*'(J(J:N:Ao ~J'J'~.J!.j1'i: ~*.!Ji~Af(]~!y_~.II

~a~*o~~~~~~7~~~~.¥~.J!.j1'i:

i!~~~.$.*o ~1-,;'~*(:i1JItk~)X"'..~

144-

<of...w..}_A ~2001 .,... 3 '*

#~~..~o ~oo~~..m~~T#~~~~~fIJI~fiEo

~M,~.~~..~~~.~~£.~-St:~raJ.PJ~~::ft"~.4fJCJorPJ.~~~~~(PJ

~&.~ii::ft"if~~,~~;fiiAiJJ.M.~)jj:.~

~.;I;:sr.~#~~~#(~~f(I~~)XIj"aJ{fjj:.

.~ftlf~~~Titf:;$;:::f'"~1:f:.o ~?X, ap.*~

W#~..:::f'".~, ~~¥~_n.~flm~~j

m ..~~~" :i&.ft.~~~~ J:fJCJ~tim~o ~~,j:NJJ:**&t:f2.~_n.Niffjt.I&,~#~~r:

BCJPJ~*Jfj:**.~o ..=:, ap.*jj:~jj:.:::f'".

~~~~~J:XIj"#~~r:.~r:~~~~~~:::f'"

.,ffr~~""~~"tt.ft"f(I~it;#~.~P~

.1lf:o~~.~.~BI~*!t1m,.~~~.XIj"

#~~~~~mmM,n*~r:~XIj".#~A~

8t.tto

~oo.~J, #~~r:.XIj".#~~~.tt:::f'"

.ff:.1ffXlj"#~~A('@.~~~'JtJ#~fJCJ~A,RP

1'"Amf).:~:x.*.¥It)fJCJ.ff1m*o~f}iI(1999) ~if~~1IJj ,ftlE~.:Jf1ii:v)'* ,~J(if1;;f.

#i9:.~iI*~~~T.1'"~~~~~:tI*(j!J

v)':::f'"~1ft;ffiit.)o ~m ~1iJ*.fJCJ~#.m1lJ,".#_fJCJ~~~&oo&~T~~~~~~fi#~~r:fJCJ8t.~~..~g*,.~XX~'JtJ#~:i&.fi*.~.o

.#r:~.~&~1;;f#~~r:fJCJ.~:::f'"~~~aplE,"~~~.aplE~~OO~~..,~~#~~~II~JiJr.Wif~Mtk:fJCJfiiJ.o Zhang f(I

Pearse{ 1996, 1997) An~iiE/jJ-~~JI.::;f'"Jajr:~

.~~1m.*.#~.~.#~*::ft".*~~o

~fi~JI.~~~~~..~f(I.#~~r,~ft

T ~fIJI~m~~~~*fl#_JiJr~~J~.#~..Rfl~::ft"#_JiJr~.tIJ~Jf~ SO% - 83%; *::ft"#

_fJCJ:i8:#.~~~:fi#1I, .#~.m~ 0 Zhang

(2000) , Zhang," Flick(forthcoming) XIj"~II.

ftfJCJ~~~~~roo~.#r:~&~~.*fJCJ#

~~*~~~~~~~~.~~,~~~~.~~*~~~¥~#_mfl#~fi~..f(I.~~

..~.itfnn.f¥.*ft.#,.(.P.#~.,bl..im".~1fi~~~J.f;~~(rCJ~noPJJA!.,rr-fXftpJIr;(:E-tlt~#~~.nft~.-~..(rCJ~.o

~ ,tait~i';j"it

*X~~~~~~~~~*~T.~~~#~.r5m,.#"{j'ziii$J,.~.1If.,*.~#:m;LlJ:ff~:WJ.{t~a.f£»:f8o ~~..~.~6r;1g~.~a~*~.#~~~~~~1If.,~~.'A#~Jf~Ji:.,~Wif.#iiii{:tt*.~1I,.-JJ£..,#~~~L~*o

~~~~~~#~~A~Ji:.~~~~~~~~~.,#~.~~~~~.~&..~~~*~~:¥o

#;St;,:(£it:tJ~~f*$lJr,#~~~~A~~Ej!;P',v)'.&II~~~:tt-:fj-~:jt:A(fCJ$Ej~,~.z.~xw.~~.,ffi:(£.1fl:.X+*~",J!f+1i.it;~~ T ~~".~1fJfi ,fJfi:Tfj:JIJ ,!M'jlJ~#~~1-:fj-~ ,.#..* -* m~JJ.Jt.~*, :e:.:WJ.#~..IIQi;fi!i~ 0 :ii:f+~A~\t&~!:iJ *i~:tt- f' ~

~~~..~*~~~A.~._~o~~,~~*:tJ~~~.~~~~-~~~

.~~.*--#~--:(£~m~.#~~.~

:fi"~fi,lP*fJ~~~~~*#~,jX~~TM1iiii~~Jfi: (1) v)';f!~.#~..1f:l:.~~~~,.~..#.m~8ti~~1I.*@J~,~..~JDt~J~, .#.m~1f~.~~.~tt~~*.~~,j!*,.#.~~8ti:fi"Ji:..a<J.~.w:,.,.#:jt:A.~~#~~~.~, W~~~.~~~~~Xif#~~:l:mftJ.fo (2)*fJfft~~Ji:.o ~~*#~~*M~~;fI~,-1iiii,'E..T.jf*Mm.~~~~t1f~~~~1I., ~$ljT*f}jftmlflJI~aeJ~.,¥J -1iiii, 'EJJ fi T #~~~.&#~~~;f-Jf.~~nj], .~T~JKGe:., fiiJn;f, ~it:tlj~~r,.*~~~~~~*f}j~.l:.~,V).~.~#~~~,~m.&#~.~6r..~~..*.*ft~#.I8f.*~~,W.§.,J!f+Xif.#.

.~.*ft~~m,~it~~~~.r~...

- J.4~-

MANAGEMENT WORLD

2001No.3

W-:fiTtiJJJ, ~jlJ..~. ~~#&~§.:f:-'-:fi'fl~it~~#:~Tti~o-:ffTm~,~~tt;i1JI:)...BB~~~~~M#*&*§~.:f:-'~fi-:ff'fl~it,.*~f1-M,..#_~.#.Jff=acJi1J$tittt 0 .1! *" 'fit ~...:tt ~ Xit * ~ ~ jD: jig JlJ tt:ff '*"

m, ~.A.~~ ,~~.Jf~]l'.~ti~m,,*tt!i1J I:). m JIt.~

A#jt$JJJ,M.#jt~f=oug.W.'fIiiM#]l'.~f=~&~,.~~~~~~~.~~~mm~oJi..¥*_..,m_J(if~ti~~j]..'fIii~f=#acJ~a~*(~~jD:.~.~#~~~~.m)o .1!§m"l:R:#~tq$t; 1JJI.ti~?tt~, tJffi.1t#*~fi~,~~*ft~]l'..PtftJ.'It-;I:).&~l:R:~,*Ia)~.,m~.~~jD::#~,*~tt~o

:.ft:t-.:¥--f:i: ~1J.,*"*.;"'-1:1::.. ::fJ-.:ff..)

...T~.o.=,#~~A~~&~~M~~~~~~

~.~m~~o~~~.*~ft~-~~~.EacJ:&:Jlrp~.,:&:~AacJJjj-E£,~PJ.::I:~#~

~~tFm",~~~~~~.,.lk:fi-fl.A.~~l'I

~,.::\'[.~~~mI~,,*.~~*z;O.,#~=*

~~acJ~iii~..:::f'"~j~ftl:.*o ifij..§., I~-ft

~M~;&.Jf.(§m.#.Jf.)(I(J*.m~:J::*~

~Ji:Mftrp~~zh.o

~=~~~,~~~ftacJ#~~.~;&.z~#acJm~m~,~...~~~Jjj-~#~~~~!Jjtt;f:ftFmo ~:;g.~~IiJ.~~m.Qo ,*ifij,.

~~ ~~#~~~g~tt;f:ftFm..~~iiJ.(I(J#~~«$IJ~tF13'f¥iiEoPJft:J.,.*:;.~

~4fl~.~ii~(I(J~«..0

.~~M~~~~~~~?#~~~~M*, .!A!.~ilo ~t:J., .(!~~~~~'$~-, '1::*1

~, ~~.~I~~~.*~t:J.*~fi~~#~~.acJ~5:~fJ:~", *~JI.~", .7f;#, ~fiJ!:*1~..0 A,,*_~,#~~~:;J;..Lt;K;""fi~(~~jl'.) J!*WJ",.~, PJ.~~.(I(J~«$tJ.rro ft~ ~ 1998 ~~fi~~~jJ;:§~1iiJ "-~ 30~:::f'"~":t£#~~~l:.acJ.r-iiJt:J.1t~~$~~Jj:ll,.!A!.~tk~.~,~~#~-~if.~:$.~#o;&ifij

.~ ~fn~~$ ~~.~~~~W ~.~fi*.~~A~.~1Jp'ft,.",~1m.~~~«..oft1n ~;&~-~W~~*J, ffi iiJ t:J.m*§(l(JJj~g*:ilJ 50-60~0 j*,:fI."'~:ili~*~~"iiE

~~~tF~~~~~A.~~~~#~~~~~A;I;~m*tFm~o :!zn.jJ;§M~~.(~ 30~),

jJ;:§~Jiijrp J1U.~:hnl:. "iiJ..*§"~..-

.~~.~§:;J;:t£ftW~.7f;~T~§~JiijrpPJf

.~~.i:I:.~:tI~,-fI!!;( fn)aPJt:J.M;.:pj:jJ;:§ W ~

(:hPl:..~~~§.~Q(J 10~, ;j1:: 50~, *g.~~)o ~#jJ;:§~IiiJ.:fi"T:i$..fi.o =~~::ft:#.'M:;l1J~~#(.)tJ.'.:i!fiM-*o ~~.*~~~

fit: *1] (in 99 :if:):!t.jj(!)..~~'S:«~{fmo=:i:

~.~~.~..#..om._~m...~.~~~,.~

~~~.~#_.om.a~m.~.~~.~o~.~~*xti...~~#*~~~.~..*~~o

~.~D~.~E~.#~~..~..~.#.#.*..0 ."J~.,~. D .e..~Ei.#,...ll.o

~~~~~~~~A=a~A(.~~.x..)-~~.* - ~a~*o A1n~~~~.~ A~~~..~~~a~*~.~&.1:.~0

@~.~~~~fi.#~.ft.8~.#.~..~~m. ~T.KI~~*~~.~...1!.ao-o ."...ftfto-1It".#.it~~..~8.#fi~~e~iiJ.'" ZhanS(2000) ~1l ZhanS ~ Flick (forthcominS) 0 '

...~.

(I) (~..~ ta..tt.'*'), <A~a.), 2CXX)

. 6]J. 14 a 0(2) rf'mrf'~..'&: (J1t&~. Jtf...), (rf'...),

1999.6]J.17130(3) ..tr.: (~ta.8#*~M'JI*),jt.#**~.:t

~X,I999lf:o(4) Demsetz, Harold. 1967. Toward a Theory of Property

RiShtl. Americo Eco/lomic Rel/i.w S7 (2): 347 - 59.

(S) ZhanS. D. and P. H. Pearse. 1996. Differences inSilviculturallnyeetment Under Varioua Type. of Foreet Tenurein Britiah Columbia. Fora' Sci.au 42 (4): 442-49.

(6) ZhanS. D. and P.R. Peane.. 1997. The influence ofthe Form of Tenure on Reforeatation in Briti.h Columbia.Fora' EoolOn and Manag&ment 98: 239 - SO.

(7) Zhans. D. 2CXX). Endan,ered Speciee and TimberHarveatinS: The Cae of Red - Cockeded WoodpeckeR.

WorkinS Paper. ScAool of Foratry and 'Wildlife Sci.-.A u6urn UnifJerli'y.

(8) ZhanS' D.. and W.Flick. forthc ominS. Sticks,

Cmotl, aDd Reforestation .In'estment. Land EcoMmia.

- 146-