+ All Categories
Home > Documents > mieaoi.irmieaoi.ir/article-1-731-fa.pdf · project finance:Theory and evidenc. Journal of Corporate...

mieaoi.irmieaoi.ir/article-1-731-fa.pdf · project finance:Theory and evidenc. Journal of Corporate...

Date post: 30-May-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
28
_ !" #$% &"’ 1397 - -./0 88 - 61 (!) #$ %& ’()) 7 (# ! 1 2 3 : 25 / 02 / 1397 : 07 / 06 / 1397 "% !"# $%& !& ’ (# & )*+, -". /+"# "+ &"012 / " / )*+, 3%# #+4 5’6 4 7+ / 89# /+ : / " 6"6 ; <’ !# != ># 02 7? /+# > +# 0@ !. 7A9B !9 4 A+C :D A> . 4 BF +# GHI& /" )*+, +# JB+K& 9 + / / & (# ’" LI"C " !"# M"1= N" ’ & )*+, / <1 <H 0 (+)/+ N != 7 )*+, QR 7 /+ +& # 1 A> +10 T -U2 )> - 5# +V= +# " /T1, # WX 7NV+B + (1 Y"2UZ /? !V R !;% ! 5+, G+Z 4 -4[ !+" 7’" +>" 7>" +>" 4 != B+;R # 7/JB "# Q;&+" /+ H " +" 7>"# 9"V -+" M"1= "# Expert Choice M"T& AHP 7 1"\ ]+ 12 BF 0C & +# +K )*+, ’ /^ 2 !# + / +K +# :1%& _/+B /" % /+# & (# )*+, / + N’ /># ("# 7W"V <" N’ &+& !# != >>+B <#H Buy Back ، BOT,LC 7 # - 7W4 7‘ +V !+ N 001’ "R :H /JB QR Q+ , .>> 7 <C a # +& /+ !". .N"V+B +" <0I& )>+B !H )> GHI& T1, +V= 7’ & !C+2 [^V 7+bcF, /+# >& EPC +" )d" .+B 345 :"7 N’ )*+, 7’ (# 7’ & 7/># +& + 70 89: JEL : C52, G32,G38,R51,R40 1 . > N#+& )bc 7NR )*+, N+> )+B f [email protected] 2 f> N#+& )bc 7NR )*+, N+> > f=. [email protected] 3 . - )bc 7)*+, N+> > f= [email protected] Downloaded from mieaoi.ir at 7:56 +0430 on Thursday June 4th 2020
Transcript

���� �����_� ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������ � !"�# �$% �&"��' 1397- -�./088- 61

������ � ��� �� ��������� �� ���� ����� ���� ��� ��

���� ��������� (��!�) ��#$ %& ����� ����� '(��)�)7

(���#� ��!�

������������� �1

������� ����2

������ �����3

�����:����25/02/1397 :����� �����07/06/1397

��"�%

������ ����� �!""���# $�%�& � !�& � �'�� (#��� ����&)*�+, -�"".�� /�+""# �""��+�� � �&�""�012 /���""� /

)*�+, 3�%�# ����#+�45'�6 4� 7�+�� /���� 89# /��+� :� /�� �""���� ��6�""6 ��;� <�'� !# != >��#

�02 7�? /�+#��>� +# � � ��0@� !.��� 7A�9B !��9� � ���4 A+C :DA>� . 4� ��� �BF�� ��+# G�HI& /�""�

)*�+, +# �JB+�K�&9�� � ���+�� /�� ������ �/�� ����& (#��� �'�""� L�I""C � ��""���� !""# M""1= N""�

�'�� ����& � )*�+,/�� <1�<H�� �0� ��� (�+��)/+� N�� != 7)*�+, QR 7 /�+�� ��+& �# ��1� A>� �

� �+10� ���T� -U2�)>� - 5�# ����+V�= � ��+# ��� " /�T��1�, �# WX� 7NV+B �+�(1� Y�""2UZ� /�?

!�V�� ��R�� !;��%� � !��� 5�+, G�+Z 4� -4[ !���+""� 7�'�""� ��+�>""� 7>""�� ��+�>""� 4� != ��B+;R �# 7/�JB

� �""# Q;&+""� /����+� � ���H��""� �+""� 7>""��#�9""V� -+""� M""1= �""# Expert ChoiceM""��T& �AHP 7�1""\

]�+����12 �BF���0C� ����& +# +K��)*�+, �'��/����^� ����2 !# �+�� /�� +K�� +# :�1%&_/+�B �/�""�

�%�� /�+# ����& (#��� �'�� )*�+,/�� ���+�� N��'��/>�# (""�# 7W��""���V <��""� N��'�� ��&+& !# != >�>��+B

<#�H��Buy Back، BOT,LC 7 ��# -�� 7W��4�� 7`��� �+V!���+� N��� � � �001'� ���""R :�H��� /�JB

QR Q��+� ����,� .>�>�7 <C�� a���� �# ��+& /�+�� !"".��� .N""V+B �+""� <�0I& ��� � )>��+B !���H� )>�

�� G�HI& ��� ���T��1�, � �����+V�= 7�'�� ����& !C+2 �[�^V 7��+bc��F, /�+# >���&EPC �+""� )��d�""�� ���

.�+�B

3�45��:��"�7 N��'��)*�+, 7�'�� (#��� 7�'�� ����& 7/>�# ��+& �+�� 7�0�

�89: ���JEL : C52, G32,G38,R51,R40

1 .>� N�#+& )�bc��� 7NR�� � )*�+, N�+�>� )�+B ������� [email protected]

2 f>� N�#+& )�bc��� 7NR�� � )*�+, N�+�>� >�� f����[email protected]

3. ���� -��� )�bc��� 7)*�+, N�+�>� >�� f����[email protected]

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

62 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

���8�

��.�� ��+�� >���� ���c= �0D� ��� -�.�� N'�� Q��& �? !^��& � NR��+�4 �'�""� ����& � ���

)*�+, ���)*�+"", �""�� �'�""� ����""& �""�� .N�� N'�� )>2 +# 9�� ��.N""��+#� <T""c� �""# �""0D� �""�

):�� 7)��41394N=+� 7 �� �c= � ( !""# N""�� �b��>""H� ��"";1= <T""c� �""# �0D� /�.& /��

)� ����= (@H� � .>���� ��;�+B/�� )� ��� -�1& � )��# ��>I� �b��>H� �J� /�+""# 9""�� � ��

N=+� 7/�""Hd'��i) .N��� !V+C !# ��+H� � �&��012 ��1396 >�""� A�>""�� G""HI& /��""�� � .(

:c6 4�>��20 N���� /�+�� � !'���0= /�� /�+""# 7�����""H� ��%��� � !^��& :c� !���+# !I�[ 7

l�� /��1399-1395 ��� �o�� !# 7 !���'�""� Q""���� /��%��� >� !# �#��8 ��+""\ � >""C�

����34 l�� � >C� �b�""�#�� (""@� ���q1� � N'�� />�? � -�o� rUC� 7!���+# �����, /��

R+# N��'�� 4� :c� !���+# �����, l�� !���# � 7/�d@%�).��# >����R ���1395(

)*�+, !# !^��& l�� � /���c= 4��� !# !��& �#���""�� ��"";1= +b�� A+Z 4� � NR��+�4 / (#

)*�+, ��� �b��>H� <;H& /�+# ��'�� �V�=��)*�+, ��� ���� >�� >��+B ���� 7 NR�""�+�4 /�""�

+#)+# � �""C�%R 5�# ���& 4� /+�B)+# � �'�""� ����""& � N�+�>""�r+Z /��+""# !^""��& /�""�

7���6�&�#)��+B 9=+1��2002(. � 4��s& ��� )>12 <�[:�""R� 79=+1& +� � �'�""� Q��+""� �>""� +""&

4� /���# >�=�& 7!^��& l�� � /���c=+# !^""��& l�""� � ���""c= ��9V�4��C�%R � /4�""�

7��b��4+V) N�� )��# �C�%R 5�# !# ��'�� Y���t� /�JB��1386 !""# !""��& f�""�� ���+""# .(

)*�+, !^��&)*�+, �& N�� )>��+B ���� �C�%R /�� � 89# /��)�b�# ��� N��1� �# )>�q�, �""�

!1�# � ����u& !v�� �M�� +#�+# � :�H��� /�� >""��+B �+""�� N""�HV�� �""# )*�+"", $�""c� /��

7W=�V)1999�# != ���� �& .( NR�""�+�4 !^""��& � �""C�%R 5""�# 7���� G#��� !# !��& 4� ��

7U���+,) N�� )��# +&��= ���# ��'�� 5�#1999�2 ��� w�1.� .( 5""�# �""& >""��+B ���� <��

)�+��B N=�c� N�� )��# ��'�� 5�# ���R� � ���+# G#�� != �����4�# � �C�%R !�""��� /�

7���T��)>��#2002 .(

)*�+, �'�� ����& N�1�� !# N���2 �# w��""�� 4� )��d��� ��T�� 9�� � �+�� 3�%�# NR��+�4 /��

�)*�+, ��� � �'�� ����& /���# 7�� !��& !# w�� )*�+, ����+� Q""R 7 )�+""�� EPCT+F !""= (

����+� � 9�� �'�� ����& �T��1�,/�+""\ 7)*�+"", x""0��� ��=� Y���>�� � !#+.& � )>� )>�� !""#

+o� ��>� != �1\ <�[� ���# � 5'�6/�� ����& (#��� �'�""� /�+""# �""�� r+""Z ���""�# �?�""� �

N��'��/>�# �� G�V�& !# N;�� ���1� Y��u� )*�+, ��� � �'�� ����& G�V�& ->2 �& � )*�+,/�""�

)*�+,) !#�c�(/+� ��� �0� /�� -�B �����+# � +��� ����""& (#�""�� �'�""� �""# -�""#� � +""�1=

+�c�# �c�#+K� � !# � >��#. )>""� -�"".�� Y�H�HI& � /+o� ���;� �+� �# �>�#� 5��F, ��� � �J'

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 63

�BF�� ]�+���� �1\)*�+, /���? 7�'�� ����& )�b� 4� ���+�� /�� )��d��� �# � ��B+;R := �# � ��

M��T& 4�AHP -+� � �9V�Expert Choice N��'�� Y��#+.& �# � !0C�� a���� WX� 7)�+= />�#

QR7 �� �+� 5.�� ��� ��+& /�+��.:���

H"8.� ��I� ���9�

M��T& N�1�� !# !��& �# � 7�� ����""& 4� �""0= +��%& M� �>�#� 75��F, ��� � �'�� ����& /��

�'�� �� !v��.:��� �� +�4 ���1� G;Z !CUR �Z !#�0C� N0T�� ���&- �0� (#��� ����& ���12

)*�+,<T� � � ��1 .>�c= +��%& !#

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

64 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

>�KKKKKK�1L"KKKKKK!8� :?� ��<KKKKKK�� ����=�KKKKKK� A"��KKKKKK� ��KKKKKKB

�����

����

���� �����

��

�����

����

ppp

�����

����

���

�� �����

���� �����

�'�� ����& M��T&/� )*�+,

��� ����� ����� �

�����

��� ����� ����� �

����� ����

���� ����� �����

������

����� ����

������ ���!�

�������

���� �����

"��#

$%&� '���� "(�

)�*�

������� ���+

�,%-

�./� �,%-

�0�� �,%-

�1�2 3����

4(�/

$��5� )��

�����%�� )��

����� �����

����

$��5� $�*���-

!���+� �4�#

��"�/ ���61 3�%�/

���.� %�7 �8�(�

$��9: ������ 3�%�/

"��# $�*2�%�/

�����

����

�����

���� �����

�����

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 65

�"N"' H"8.�

5��F,)*�+, �'�� ����& !���4 � /���4 /��!CUR 7N�� !�V+B -�.�� �� �? 4� /��>^& �""# !""= �""�

+��� G�HI& w�\��N�� )>� !v�� !���� � >��� y� :

) )�T�� !^'�@� �1388 ����� /���+T�� (�z&�� � �'��)*�+,�� )>""� ��+# ���B�+�� /

������+&�� )*�+, N=+� M�� 4� �c= M�� ��+= �>� � �T��!�""���� 7""�q1��� rU""C�

� ���+�>� ��R���z&�� �'������ .N""�� )��� ���""c�, 9�� � /4� )+�Ri 0��""0� )1389 � (

!# ��R 5��F,!;&>�#/ ""��)���/ �z""&�� ��+""� /�+""# ���""R �'�""��!�JB/ N""d� N^�""C �

��+�� ��U�� /�1� ��&+& !# � !�R��+, 7<""#�H�� (""�#BOT7 FDI �"";�2� {�""@R/7 -���""�/

��1u&�7 W�����V ���4�� .N�� )��� ���c�, � W �z""& ���""� -�""o� �#�""�4��� /�J""B�� � �'�""�

)*�+,��/ N'�� ��R��+�4��+""�� /�+# �b'� !v�� � �C�%R 5�# !# �� G""�HI& ���""�;�)1391(

)/+�� .N�� )>� !^'�@�1392!���+""� �J� Y���9'� ( ���""R /�J""B � N""�� )�+""= �""�+# �

)��� ���c�, )*�+, != 5""�# N=�""c� /�+""# �""uV � >�� ��= N'�� ���+12 !���# 4� ���+12 /��

!���+� �J� N� � ��+�� �C�%R5'�6 .��� :��+V ���R /�JBJ� /��!���+""� � /�J""B

���H� +o�� 4� ��+�� �c= � ���R ) �""u�V Q""��&1394 �����""� )>""� ���""c�, � �""�+# (

A�d� Q;&+�!���+� /�+# �&U��& � `�H� � >��+B +&�� �c= ��� != ���� .��""� :��+""V >���

���d0�)1395+# :�+I& Y�+K� ��+# �1\ (!���+� 7��+�� ���R /�JB3 :N""�� )��� !v�� �T��

1-7����� M�� 5��=2- !���+� >���, 7�""C�%R 5""�# �""# ���R /�JB3- N""'�R� ��+""=

)���? � N'��.���R !���+� �J� N� Q��+� /4��

Y�^'�@� �� ) M��2012�� ��c� ��6 /F&�+��� ��� � (!= >�� N""�� )�+= U& ��6

�+#� /��""%��� >""� |""d� / i�""d� ���? N""�� !""# 7!""H@�� "";�=+&� ��+""� 4��!�JB/ *+""��/ �

U&�� /4����/ 5&� .>�� -�.�� � � 7����+�N�1=� ��M� '�� ��� � �c=� )*�+, Q""��& 7

) ���#2014.N�� )>� !^'�@� ( 5��F, ��c��� ��c��>�� ���� Y�+@R� '�""� �� �""c= M""�

<#�� Y�+K� ��&� �z& � ����+� Q��+� � w�� ������ ��� '��� ��� )*�+, <�'� ��1� !# 7C�&�!

)>� �4 9=+� N'�� N'�R� / � )>� !���= /+�c�# Y����R�0I� Y���� !#� .��� )��� A�T��B

)2016 ��+# � (��T��:� �z&�� '��� )4����/ 4��4+:� � M�� <��2 7��� !����� <��2 ��+&

�)*�+, M�� ��9�� ���+#�+# � :��H& )�+B !� !# � ��/ ""�+# � w�""\�� !""��B�>� M""� +��

N�� )�+=!���+� 4� ����� N��1� ��9�� .) �&�""� ��""c�+= Q��& �JB2016 ���""c�, � �""�+# (

Z 4� 7N""'�� +""# )�U""2 7>���� x�^\ ������ ��R�� +o� 4� != /���c= � )>� 9""�� )*�+"", G""�+

!���+""� !""# �����""u&) ���""�=�+�6 N""��� � � .��""� )��� �J""B2016 !""= N""�� !""�V+B !"".��� (

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

66 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

�����)*�+, �'�� ����& /�+# � ��+& !�""��;�� !���+""� !""= N""�� ���""� 4� )��d��� ���+12 /��

.f�# � �T��# :���� <}� ��� ���� �����)�+1""� +""# Y�""H�HI& !""= N�� +=i +� )>""� 4� M""�

� � Y��d�� )�B>��scope )��1� ��+# � �'�� (#��� ����& w�\�� 3�R5��F, .>�� 4� != ����

)��1� ��+# � �'�� ����& )*�+, N�+�>� +o��)*�+, �'�""� ����""& +""# +�c�# >�� 4�""B � N""d� /�""�

)*�+, �'�� ����& 3�%R � � )��# 9=+1��!= /+� /�� �? � �""C�%R N=�""c� �2�""� !# ��

�� r+@� ���12� ��+B)�+T� )��� � /�T� !# .>�� � w�""\�� N""�1�� !""# !""��& �""# 7<�'� ��1�

!^'�@� ���6 �>c� -�.�� -�"".�� N2+""� � N""�d�= ��+""# [�# !# M1= A>� �# 5��F, ��� � 7/�

)*�+, � 7�+�� /���� �+� ��+# ��� 7+�� ��B+;R M1= �# �'�� ����& /��� � �+�B �# N���

� 7a���� !# !��&N��'��� !v�� �? /�+# />�#.��+B

���� �=�� A"���

�& r+Z )�4��� ��+= �&��012 Y��#+.& ��+# �# )*�+, /�+# �'�� ���!'�� �Z �+�� /�� /�1374

�&1384 >� �=J� )�� �Z 7 4��� ��� ���4 <��495 �? +}=�>""� � 4�1080 N""�� )��""# 4� _

� Y�""�012 (�+""�& �""o�� !""# N'��=J""� l�""� � 71385!���+""� ���4�""� G""�+Z 4� 7/�JB � ��

M1=!���""c�# ����� � ��%��� Y�4� ��V � /��%��� /�� >""���+V �? �""Z !""= �+""= +""c��� /��

r+Z ���R �'�� ����& /�+# />�>� ���"";� �""��+�� <""�'� !""# �T�""' ��+""B ��9b��� �c= /��

~��� Q��+� � �=J� !���c�# ��# )>�001'���+�� /�+# �!v�� >�� 7 �&�""�012 >�""� �? �""Z )>�

� .>� x���� 9�� �0;� >���+V � >c� )*�+,��� �0� /��)+# :���� !# !��& �# /+� � /��+""#

)*�+, ��� 4� <C�� /��>�?��� #��� ����& ���12 /�b'� <T� G#�@� �'�� (2 �� N�^;&>�=:

>��2 �5��' � �=�� @��� A"��� �<O=� :3� � ��� ��B��$�

��$�

#������ +

>0�E �<�

P�

�������Q4

= ����7

��R���'

S�<�

��� ��

��R���'

S�<�

+

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 67

)*�+, w�� N� !#)*�+, ��� ���# ��R��+�4) �+�� /��)*�+, �""�� � !��9� � >�?� ��V+Z (�� �""�

l��^�� )*�+, ��� /�+�� /�+# �'�� (#��� ����& w�\�� ��� � )��;� ��>���""�� � ��""^� +�""�� 4� ��

�� �&Uu^� � <Tc� �6�.>��1�

H"8.� ?�

H"8.� ��� � ��O��G

A>� !# �#�����!�+o� ��^�) G�HI& /�� /�.�""�� !""= ���""�4 +""b� ��""# >""����� +""��� (/4��

� �# G�HI& � �� NR��������1 N��) �+�J, Y�C 7/����1389 �""�� G""�HI& >""�� .(

<T� � !^'�@�3 .N�� )>��+B !v��

�HI& ���!^��& �H�HI& A>� ��I' 4� G /��""�� � �+�� � ��I' 4� � )��# /�+#�=! />�#

Y�H�HI&"�d�C�&2"�� /��>��# .�+�B !H;Z N��� !��&+# Y�""H�HI& />�# ��""cV>� w�""� f�""��

!# ��&�+\/��^� Y��d& � 3�R /���9#� ���� /���c�N""��� Y�""H�HI& w��""�� ��""# G��� � $ _

�+� ��>��� M� � Y�H�HI& ��� +}=� !T0# ���""d� �b�""�#�� :""� �""# � >""��� l�""}� /�+""# _>""���

�#+�4 ��&>12 /����# Y�H�HI&)>���� /�+#�= Y�H�HI& /�+# ��� 7/����1389.(

!""^��� /�""�? !^���<T""c�� /� 7>""�� ��+�>""� 4� !���+""� 7�'�""� ��+�>""� � ���""H� 7/�JB

�� �+�� �# Q;&+� /����+�N=+� ������ ��>^& � !��1� )�+B :.� .>��# G""�HI& ��� � ��B>��=

�""# !""# !""��&�d�""C�&) G""�HI& �- ��� G""�HI& Y[�t""� �""# :�H�""�� {�"";&� (�""d�=

) 7�02>��1389.(

1.Methodology

2.Descriptive research

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

68 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

>��3��� : #���� ����H"8.�

!��1� ��V+B /�+#�� (�'�� ����& w�\�� ��B+;R) /��? !^��� 4� /�!H;Z � !# ���& 4� /�

QR )*�+, �T��1�, � (�+�� N=+�) ��+V�= !^��� 7 :"".� ��""�^& /�+""# .�+""= ������ � ��B+;R

5�+, �9#� �# != !��1��� ��+# � G�HI& w�\�� !���4� >��1� l��+V G�+Z(!""@#�)" ��+=�""=3"

.>� >���R )��d���

��+=�= l��+V :� �����.

�����.

�+V 5�, ���1� ��I' !# !��& �# �;�+H& :.� ��V+B +o�� � ��+=�= l��+V /��50 /�+""#

!""# !""@#� � !;""��I� G;Z " l��+V � �? �����+� � !^'�@� ��� /��? !^��� !""��1� ��>""^&44

��. :��

44 �50�1.96�� ∗ 0.25

�50 ∗ 0.05�� � 0.05� ∗ .025

��>^& G@�� ��1� �#50 �""= x""0��� Y�""H;Z � w�\�� )�B+;R 4� +d� �""�� 4� � ���""���� /

��>^&40 5�+,� !��� (1� � <�1T& +o� ��� ���4 �+""� <12 yU� <�0I& � !�9.& /�+# � /�?

.>��V+B

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 69

5�+, �� /��� G�HI& ����� !��� >��#!""= 5""�+, � )�1""� !""���1 �""BF�� �+""�� )*�+"", /�""�

N��'��5�+, � � >�>� />�#5�+, a���� �# -�� !��� � 7M""� )�1""� !""��� �'�""� ����""& /�""�

!���>�>� />�#. � G�HI& ��� )��� <""�0I& � !�9.& �o�� !#�""�N��'�� /�+""# 7 M""��T& 4� />""�#

AHP >� >���R )��d���)��� _� � �""� Y�""2UZ(""1�-+""V G""�+Z 4� )>""� /�?5""�+, � �""� _!""���

-+� 4� )��d��� �# �9V�Expert Choice .N""V+B >����R �+� <�0I& � !�9.& ��� M""��T& � l>""�

AHP L@""� � N""�� ���""R+# L@""� !""� 4� !""= N""�� �"";&�+� !0""�0� N""R�1 A>""� �?1

N��'�� � �#��4�) � />�#)*�+, �'�""� ����& /�� /�""� L@""�7(���+��2 � �0""C� /�""���^� �?

!;& /�+# != N�� �1��? 4� �'�� ����& Y��d�� /���+T�� ��# />�# � >""� >""���R )��d��� ��

L@�3 )*�+, �'�� ����& � �%�� /���+T�� �?�� ��+�� � ���+�� /��.>���#

5�+, ������� �B+;R ���4? G�+Z 4� G�HI& ��� ! !# !v��10 +d� G�HI& w�\�� ��B+;R 4�

� 3�%R ��� � >� >���R -�.�� " +��� ��� 4� Y[�t� ���� !# �>�� � )��d�""�� !""�[ !@#� 4

.��1� :���R �0.6 ({(n-m/2)/(m/2}

: l�t� +� /�+# !@#� ��� � !=m 5�+, ��>^&!���

n ��>^&)��� N;}� ���� l�t� !# != N�� /��+V�>�� .

��������� � �B H"8.� ��B

T"���4<�� -���:�

!��1� Y�2UZ� �>�#� ���1� ) :��T�� !o�U� �T�V�+B /�����1� Y�C !# � /��? /��1 �&3(

��<�1U��' A� �� V<��� ������� @�P<� ��<�� :3�4�B�

1.Goal

0%

35%

52%

13% P� ���730 X��

A"�30 ��40 X��

A"�40 ��50 X��

P� ��Y��50 X��

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

70 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

��<��2 ��<�� :U��' ����� �� V<��� ������� @�P<�3�4�B�

��<��3 U��' ����Z 3�&"� �� V<��� ������� @�P<� ��<�� :?� �� 3�4�B�� ��B A"��

�=�� @���

�4[�� >"�.� � ��&���5��' � �B>�E ��B��$� ��� >8��

5�+, � ]>�� Y[�t� )�1� !���1 )4�� �� �1 r+Z)*�+, w�� ��� � )>� �+""� +""o� >""� � �""�

:N�� )��� 5""�+, Y[��""� � ]>""�� �""BF�� )>"".� +�4 l�>� r+� !# :)*�+, $��� )4�� !���

)�1�1 )*�+, $������ �0� /���BF�� � )��""# /+""�)*�+, 4� �""�� /�""� 5'�""6 !""# � /�""�

��F�� ��� 4� �R+# != N�� L�\�& !# -4[ .>��JB�B)>""�>, 3�%R � -�2 Y�C !# ��")*�+"","

���, )�b� �T�' >��� `�>%� �""�� /�+""# �""BF�� �""�� ���� �+""� `�>%� +�c�# ��� ��� � )>���

)*�+,�� �""�.>""��# !;��""%� 7Y+""T�' x""�Z �""# !""= ��""�^& � �""BF�� +""� N""�1�� ��B>��""�

��l�>�).>��+=1( $��� )4�� :)*�+, ��=� 4� N1�� ��� �5�+, )�1� !���1 �""# l�t""� )�

�BF�� N�1�� !�� ]�+���� /�+# Y+T�' x�Z G@��)*�+, /���=� )4�� � ���+�� /�� +K�""� �

N�� )>� )��d��� )*�+, �. l�>� )2(

2.Scope

0% 8%

45%43%

5% L7 ��"RL7 S�<�����P���P ��"R

22%

27%48%

3%

P� ���73 X��

A"�3 ��5 X��

A"�5 ��10 X��

P� ��Y��10 X��

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 71

5�+, ���� )�1� !���1: l�>""� � ]>""�� a��""�� !CUR !# !��& �# � !�[(l��+V) !@#� G;Z

� � Y[��� +�4 �1.� )�1� !���c�+, w1 �� �'�"";� <#�� ���� /��� 4� �""R+# � �T�""' >""��#

Y[���13715718 +�D != ��� 5��= ���� L@� ��� <#�� l�>� ).N��� l�;�3 ���1� �4 (

X��G1�4[�� : \�]� ^_� �� S9��� ��B"�5��'" � �5��'��$� ��� ��B

`��

�4[�� 3�<� X�a� � ���

1 w�� ����+�" /�+�� )*�+, )Y�;�&+& /����+� /�+�� )*�+, ( M�

2 :� � w�� Y�9�.& ��

3 l�Z )�� NR�� !�

4 �0R�� )�4�# �+� �6

5 ���^& !��9�/�� NC+V 4� N�� !�V a�,

6 ��T�� �C�%R/4�� )*�+,/�� ���+�� 5�

7 :.� � w�� ����u& Nd�

8 ��9�� �= <���� Nc�

9 /��V�+s� <I� /�+�� )*�+, !�

10 :.� +V��� �.#�� )>� � +� NV � NcB+# �@� )�

11 Y�%�c� �0C� {�@R �+�� )l�Z QR 7 G12 QR ��>^&7 )�b���� � (... )�4��

12 ��9�� /+�J,+�Kz& 4� :�+I&�� )�4���

13 l�H��� 5��� ��V )/*�'��T&( )�9��

14 4� �0^V $'�R )*�+, )��6

15 ������& � ���# ��+= � �+�� � )*�+,/�� �+�� )�9��,

16 ��9�� ���� !��9�/�� <= )*�+, )�9���

17 M��/+�J, � )*�+,/�� �0� ���/+� )>d�

18 ������& � N�+�>� M��/�� )*�+,�� )>.�

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

72 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

�����

�� � �!��"38363836373639383536344032393337383439373938333439353437

��� �����0.90.80.90.80.90.810.90.80.80.710.610.70.90.90.710.910.90.70.710.80.70.9

25

���

���

26

���

���

27

���

���

28

���

���

20

���

���

21

���

���

22

���

���

23

���

���

24

���

���

15

���

���

16

���

���

17

���

���

18

���

���

19

���

���

�����

1 �

����

2 �

����

3 �

����

4 �

����

5 �

����

6 �

����

7 �

����

8 �

����

9 �

����

10

���

���

11

���

���

12

���

���

13

���

���

14

���

���

X��G2 �4[�� : \�]� ^_� �� S9��� ��B"�5��' 3�7 �" � �5��' ��� ��B

3� ���$�

X��G3 3�"�) ��Y X<��� c���� :d��' ���� ��7 � ��� ����1(

��1�� Nd� x�Z G;Z ()*�+, ��=� � )*�+,))4�� �� � !��# l�t� 28 71 )�1� !���5�+, �

l�t� +� !# )>�)��� ���, /�>2 ��b���� 4 ���1� �Z != )>� )>��+, ��B>������, 4� 1Y+T�'

5�+, � != L�\�& ��� �# .N�� )>� )��? ��&+& !#!����� != ���� � )��� ���, �'� N�� )>c

)>2 �? /�+#� != ��� � >��# )��# <�R� ��b���� ���^& N�� )>c� !�V+B +o�

1.likert

`��

�4[�� 3�<� X�a� � ���

1 �;�2� ��+V�= M� 2 !#+.& ��+V�= /�+�� � ��� )�+B 4� )*�+,�� ��

3 �;�2� �T��1�, �0C� )*�+, !�

4 !#+.& �T��1�, �0C� � /�+�� ��� )�+B 4� )*�+,�� �6

5 !#+.& N=+� )+#��+# � )+#/��+# 4� />��2/�� )*�+, a�,

6 L@� /�JB+�Kz& ��^d��i )*�+,/�� ���+�� +# ��=� ��� )*�+,�� 5�

7 5H�/+�J, )N=�c� (N'�� Nd�

8 ��9�� N=�c� � 5H�/+�J, 5�# �C�%R Nc�

9 N�#�0@� )*�+,/�� �0� ���/+� /�+# Y���t� �'�� !�

10 ��9�� N=�c� � 5H�/+�J, N=+�/�� !@��� �'�� )�

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 73

��<��4X�a� �B �� U��' ���� A"O��"� ��<�� :

#�� #�4 >"�.� � ��&���f� � g<% �% ���

N��'�� ��6�6 -�� -�B !# ��� /�+#)��� />�#)*�+, � �'�""� (#�""�� ����& /�� -4[ �+""�� /�""�

�BF�� !# ���� 5H� �1\ N��N��'�� � +K�� /����^�) /���BF�� $��0& !# (/>�# :""� /�""�

�+� <12 yU� �# � !0�+� ��� � .��� !�R��+, !�9.& ���� � <�0I&5""�+, 4� <""C�� a���� !""���

)�1�1 w�1.� 4� _28 �""�� !""# Y�+""��s& !""���� ��V+B +o� � �# �9.� )4�� �� � +o� >� �BF��

�� !.���::��

!�9.& � 5�+, 4� <C�� a���� <�0I&�1� !��� )1 w�1.� 4� _28 )4�""� �� � +o� >� �BF��

� �# � �>2 [�# Y�;��I� !# !��& �# Y�+��s& !���� ��V+B +o� � �# �9.� �>2 ��V+B +o�84 !""#

�BF�� ��>^& _!���� ����2�� �%�� != �����? >��� N""�� ��+""\ �""# ���""�# != )��;� >� ���""1�

0.00

1.00

2.00

3.00

4.00

5.00

6.00

,�-

1

,�-

4

,�-

19

,�-

3

,�-

12

,�-

21

,�-

22

,�-

25

,�-

16

,�-

10

,�-

7

,�-

24

,�-

17

,�-2 ,�-

14

,�-

20

,�-

23

,�-

6

,�-

18

,�-

8

,�-

26

,�-

5

,�-

28

,�-

9

,�-

11

,�-

15

,�-

13

,�-

27

Average 5.75.65.55.55.55.45.45.35.25.15.15.15.05.05.04.94.94.94.94.84.84.74.64.54.54.54.44.3

���� ������ � ��� ������ �

1: 196=28*7

��� !" �����: 168=28-196

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

74 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

-�B !���� ��[�#<�1T& /���6 )>��= � <""�R� /�""���^� �""1= ��"";# /�+# �J' N���+# � ��6

:�1%& �>2 /+�B84 !#74 ��>^& Jb� ��� 4� � <�>^&12 5�+, 4� �BF�� !""# M""� )�1""� !���

�� N�� l�>�) >�?4.(

�4[���5��' ��B� h"��� �� �=�� A"��� ����� g�]��� �� �i<� j������ ��B �<=�

`��

�4[�� 3�<� X��k� A"�Y ��&4 �7 � ���

X�a�

1 w�� ����+�" /�+�� )*�+, )Y�;�&+& /����+� /�+�� )*�+, ( Type of Contract

TOC 1

2 �0R�� )�4�# �+� Internal Rate of

Return IRR 4

3 �;�2� ��+V�= Employer Credit EC 19

4 l�Z )�� NR�� Construction

Duration CD 3

5 /+�J,+�Kz& 4� :�+I&�� Sanction'

Influence SI 12

6 �;�2� �T��1�, �0C� )*�+, Contractor's

credit CC 21

7 !#+.& �T��1�, �0C� � /�+�� ��� )�+B 4� )*�+,��

Contractor's

Relevant

Experience CRE 22

8 5H�/+�J, )N=�c� (N'�� Government

Involvement GI 25

9 ��9�� ���� !��9�/�� <= )*�+, Total Project

coast TPC 16

10 :.� +V��� �.#�� )>� � +� NV � NcB+# �@� Total commuted

Passenger TCP 10

11 :.� � w�� ����u& Amount &type of

Guarantee TOG 7

12 L@� /�JB+�Kz& ��^d��i Stakeholder's

Role SR 24

13 ��9�� M��/+�J, Riske Taking RT 17

14 :� � w�� Y�9�.& Amount &type of

procurement TOP 2

15 4� �0^V $'�R )*�+, Net Present Value NPV 14

16 !#+.& ��+V�= � /�+�� ��� )�+B 4� )*�+,�� Employer's

Relevant

Reputation ERR 20

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 75

X��G5��&4 : A�� � h]�� ��B?� ) H"8.�� A"��� ���� <�� ��B����� / �B �=�

�5��'(������ ��B

`�� ����� / ?� 3�<� A"�Y X��k� �7

��&4 1 W�����V Finance F

2 W��4�� Usance U

3 /�;�2� {�@R Line of Credit LC

4 !\+� `��� Bonds B

5 -����# Y���t� /���001'� International loan IL

6 <#�H�� (�# Buy Back BB

7 !���+����R :�H��� /�JB Foreign Direct Investment FDI

8 )+#7NR��l�H��� � /��+# Build Operation Transfer BOT

��<��5 �4[�� L$� �0 � ��<�� :�5��' ��B�� ����� g�]��� �� �i<� j������ ��B

h"��� �� �=�� A"�

-�� !0�+�5�+, (�4�&!# !��& �# !0�+� ��� � :!��� ���^&12 l�>""�) �0""C� �""BF��4 � (

������ !# !��& �# ���q1�8 )*�+, �'�� ����& �+T��) ���+�� /�� l�>�5 !;��""%� G�+Z 4� 7 (

��R�� !1�� �BF�� ��# ���4 !���H� 7!�V�� .>��+B -�.�� ��B+;R Q��& ���+�� )*�+, /��

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

76 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

#�� �G��R �&��

l�>� G;Z4 ]�+���� ���1� � �=J� l�>� 4� )>� ���1�)5-�"".�� �""��4 Y����H� !# !��& �# (

5�+, 4� != �BF�� )�4��� /�+# ��B+;R ��# ���1�� !�� )>� !���1 N���2 �# 7��# )>��+B a���

-+� ���+R )>���.�� /��%��� :vU2 !# <T� � �9V�

>��4 #�� �G��R : �&��EXPERT CHOICE

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 77

>�� �����4 �&�� #�� �G��R :EXPERT CHOICE

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

78 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

@�G�4[�� A"� ��0�E c���� l����� �����&4 � �B �B

�? +�K�""& 3�""%R� <;� Y�IdC � != )>�? N�># �BF�� )�4��� <R�>& 4�N""��'�� � �""� />""�#

� �;'�@� �'�� ����& /������2 !��9B �# >��+B� >� /��)*�+, ��� � �'�� ����& /�+# +o !# ��

W�+&��8*12 <T�)5( ��.:��

>��5 ��&4 � �B �"k� l����� :L"�� � �i<� ��B��"4

���6�� !o�U� !6�""BF�� W�+&�� /��12 ���� � ��� � ��""���� +""# +K�""� /�""� /�""�

+K�� ��4�� )�+1� !# �'�� ����& � � ���""� +""� �4� W�+&�""� �""�� �""HV� /�""� N;""�� !""# �""BF��

� !# /�JB+�K�&� )>� ��+# �'�� ����& /�� !""��1� !���� � .N�� )>� )��? G�HI& ��� /�

!��9B ��# ���4 !���H� l>� 4�:�1%& � <R�>�� /��-+� � /+�B <T""�) �9V�6!""��1� � ( 4� /�

-+� � )>� :� A�+B �9V��� � <T�).>���#7(

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 79

>��6��<�� : �&�� #�� � �G�P �!��8� X�� P� ��

>��7��<�� : �&�� #�� � ��� L� m��4 P� ��

SR �5��' � �=�� A"���) H"8.� �� <� �k=�_�7 (3��$� ����

� !q���6 QR )*�+, N�� )>��+B ����2 9�� Y��\+V � � )>�+=i G�HI& ����27 �+�� !# ��+&

� .N""V+B >""���R �+""� /��=�� ��� �'�� (#��� ����& >���+V !;�� 4� /��� !^'�@� ����2 ��""1�

<""%V � � <�0I& � !#+.& )*�+, � �'�� ����& w�\�� WX� � �V+^� )*�+, �%�R� !# �>�#� !@#�

!.��� :.�, .>� >���R /+�B

SR �5��' � �=�� @��� A"���7 3��$� ����

+#/��� � ��+& +� ��U�� /��� Y�#�%� f��� Q""R )*�+, ����+� �c= /+� M�V�+& �'�2

7 ���& � ��+& �+��29/01/1385 )� N=+""� ��#�� �V+""��) !""��� � ��+""& /+""� �""�? � (�

>�� ��u�� !#�T��1�, N=+���# !""%���� )>�+# N1�� ����+� ��� � N1�� ���^& /��;� . �""001'�

� QR )*�+, 4 !# )*�+, ��� >��+B +H� Y�HV��& �+�, � N�� )��# ��+& �+�� Y�""CEPC -�"".��

Priorities with respect to:

Goal: best finance methode

TOC .147

IIR .088

EC .125

CD .122

SI .142

CC .077

CRE .067

GI .066

TPC .060

TCP .041

TOG .032

SR .032

Inconsistency = 0.05

with 0 missing judgments.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

80 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

Y��� !#�%� ��;��^�� _���3 )��� (�) >�# w�\�� )+d�28 QR ���+�� Y��012 /�JB�� �����7 !#

!���+# N���^� Q��& �T��1�, N=+�.>��+B ��C /�1� N��� /�+;�� Y�o� � /9�

SR �5��' ���k�7

�5��' 3�7 �

��+V�=!��� � ��+& /+� �@� N=+� : (�+��) )��c�<1� ��c� ��>�� N=+� : �""0� <H��

)+# ��+& /�

��c��T��1�, (!���+V) �+���� N=+� 75��F, ��c� ���>�� :�T��1�, ��� �T��1�, N=+� :

�7 ��]� n��

QR7 l�Z !# ��+& /�+�� 27 +# <1�c� +���0�=25 (""��� (w) �����1'� +��� y+� 4� )�b����

)�+""B9# (Z�""H& 4� �"";2 4� W"", � w�+""� (�""#+D " ��+�) ��>��� � ��+& `+� ���� !H@�� �

7�&UI�17 �'�1""� ��>""��� � �? +�""�� /�d""C ���� )�+B9# (Z�H& � !�>1I� ��>�� � ��+�

JB �# � !�V��+��s& �#��� ��>""�� � �U�""� ]+""# �""�= 4� �"";2 � >���& <��& ��= � ����, 4�+& 4�

Y��^� !H@�� �����#�� ��""��, ��+""& �+""D l�1� � ��#? Y�""C !""# +�""�� Y�""�012 <""= .>""#��

�>�#� � )�B+�1^& M� � )>��+B �+�� ����4+�4 /�""��� � �""��=�, M""� � (����t1'�+��� y+�)

Y��^�)QR +o� � (��#?!�V+B <T�) N�� )>�8# -4[ .( )*�+, NR�� ����+� N�� L�\�& !QR

7 !# ��+& �+�� Y�CEpc-Turn key ��""R w�""� � != )>��+B �JB�� ��� �T��1�, N=+� !#

�# �c= �N�� +�o�

>��8: ��O�!�� "k�<� SR ��B7 3��$� ����

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 81

SR �5��' �=�� A"��� H"9_�7 �I� P���4[��BH"8.� �

���6 w�1.� 4� >� !o�U� !628 )*�+, �'�� ����& +# +K�� �BF��� �� � ���>�� G�HI& l�� 4�V

A>� !^��� 4� ����R+o�12 l�>""� � !""= >�>� +�Kz& ��9�� ��+&[�# 9v�� �BF��6 �""�� +�Kz""&

�BF��� �� l�>�) .N�� )>� ���# !^'�@� ��� )*�+,6(

X��G6 ^��N� :�4[�� SR �5��' �=�� A"��� � h]�� ��B7

`�� �4[�� 3�<� SR �5��' �=�� A"��� �� H"9_�7 3��$� ����

1

w�� ����+�" /�+�� )*�+,

)Y�;�&+& /����+� /�+��

)*�+, (

�+� ��;� <�'� !# QR ����+� ����4 � ��1�� /��;� � /����+� Y�;�&+& ���� !# )*�+, ���

!���JB!���� �d�� +�Kz& 9�� �'�� (#��� ����& >���+V � �J' )>c�.>��

2 �0R�� )�4�# �+�

� � � )>��+b� ���^& �+� �c= !^��& ��R��+�4 )*�+, -�12 !#�c� 9�� )*�+, ��� Y�C

<T� :!'��^� � �4��& ->2 <�'� !# 9�� ���^&5 ����& /�+# � ������� � N�#�0@� ��^� ���

N�� !���>� )�+1� !# ��B>��=

3 �;�2� ��+V�=

)*�+, /�+�� � �'�� ����& r+Z )�4��� /�+�� !# !��& �#��� �0� /��� /+� {�@R �'��

5�� �+�� N^�C ��� ��[�Z ��>�6 !� !H#�� � ��+& !��B �;�� Y�C !# �BF�� ��� ��+��

(#��� ����& >���+V /��4��� )>��= ����&N�� )��# �'��

4 l�Z )�� NR�� �BF�� � ]>�� r+� <�'� !#2 .N�� )��;� G;@�� � +K��

5 /+�J,+�Kz& 4� :�+I&��

QR )*�+, �'�� ����& >���+V � �BF�� ���7 � � N�� )��# +K�� ���# �+C� ���� ��1�

4� 5�# +# >� 4� /���4 ���4 /�;�2� {�@R +��� 4� �'�� ����& !.��� JR� ��># � )*�+,

.N�� !���� A�+%� ��R !# f�10�

6 �;�2� �T��1�, �0C� )*�+,

)*�+, /�+�� ��� 4� �T��1�, 4� ���� �d�� Y�+K� �T�' )��# /+K�� �;�2� /��� ����#+�4 /��

�BF��x�� /�� /��1 75 �8 !��9B 4� �R+# N�HV�� � l�;�� ->2 �2�# �'�� ����& /���

.>�>� )*�+, ���

7 !#+.& �T��1�, �0C� �

/�+�� ��� )�+B 4� )*�+,�� QR )*�+,7 ��� �0� )*�+, ��'��N�� ��# �T��1�, /+�

8 5H�/+�J, )N=�c� (

N'��

� l�� ����4 )4�# /��86 �&91 )>��= >�= +�Kz& �BF�� ���� /� )*�+, �'�� ����& >���+V

.N�� !����

9 ��9�� ���� !��9�/�� <=

)*�+, �BF�� � ]>�� r+� <�'� !#2 .N�� )��;� G;@�� � +K��

10 :.� +V��� �.#�� )>� �

+� NV � NcB+# �@�

NR��+�4 ���� ->2 <�'� !#� �C�%R 5�# N=�c� /�� )*�+, ��� � �BF�� ��� ��

.N�� )��# +�Kz& �# � G;@�� �'�� ����& w�\��

11 :.� � w�� ����u& .��# >����R � )��# +K�� �'�� ����& /������+� ��d� � Q��+� +# ��#

12 L@� /�JB+�Kz& ��^d��i

)*�+, � )*�+, ��� />�0= � �0C� ��^d��i ����2 !# �T��1�, � ��+V�= 5H� 4� ��V �0� /��

���M��9� � y+�c� /��4+� ���� N� !# /+���B� ��# /�� ��� � /+� Y��>R

+K�� � ���4 �;�� Y�C !# ��^d��i +�Kz& � 5H� (-�+�) Y��>R ��� 4� ��B>��= )��d���

��.>��#

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

82 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

��"����"4

4� w�1.� 28 �BF�� )*�+,!= �'�� ����& )�b� 4� ���+�� /�� !# 5�+, )��JB >�712 �BF�� !""#

����2 /��� +#�/ 4�V -�� ������ >�>� �����N�� +=i �""BF�� )�4��� ��� w�1.� 4�5 !""= �>""2

x�� <��� /��3767778712 �BF��� +K�� /�� )4��")*�+, ��=�" )4�� � +b�� �BF�� Nd� �

" )*�+," �� +�Kz& /��� ���q1� .>���#8 � ���""�2 !# �'�� ����& � N""� �""���� /�""�

N��'��;R 4� �.��+o� 4� W, != >�>� ������� />�#�B+ M""��T& �# �AHP -+""� �""��+R 7 �9""V�

Expert Choice <T� �4 .>��+B !v��

���6 !6Sam of prty <T""�)4-+� �""��+R � ( �9""V�Expert choice N""�� )>""� )��?

��!.��� ���6 ���&N��'�� � �+= /+�B � ��# />�#<�0I& /��-+� � )>� ����""& /�+""# �9""V�

)*�+, �'��N��'�� �""�� ���B>""�� !""6 4� !""= �""�� 4� ��""V �0� /�� 7>""� >""���R !""�R��+, />""�#

!.����� /+�B �# W�����V � != ���7/18% � +��� 4�N��'�� /��� �� )��""# /+&[�# ������

<""#�H�� ��# �+T�� />^# !;&+� � �Buy Back �""#8/14 % �""�&+& ��""1� !""# � -�� !"";&+� �

� /��BOT,LC �+""V 7��# -�� 7W��4�""� `���!���+""� N""��� � � �""001'� :�H�""�� /�JB

�� �+� ������ !;& � ���R.�+�B

���6 ��B+;R !^��� <�0I& � !�9.& !6� � )*�+, � 7:�+b�# y+�c� )�b� M� �""# �""0� /��

>""�?� ����""& <""^d'�# � )�H'�""# /�""� N""�V+� 9�� � �c= /��%��� � ����� Q��+� ��V+B +o� �

�� <C�� !.��� ��� 7!^'�@� ��� r+Z �� )*�+, 3�%R��""���� !""= ��+""B�+""& ����""& � �

)*�+, � �'�� (#��� �0� /������V /+� ����� �I� )*�+, W���� �� � >��# ��� �'�� ����& !=

)*�+, � 4� �H�d0& �+T�� M� �# �� {�""@R �""� ���""R W��""���V WX� � )*�+, ���T&���R ����

+# /�;�2�)*�+, ��� Y�=>& 4�V !# ��� /�.>��1� )��d��� ��

+�K�& +b�� w�\���B9�� /�JB��+V +# )>��%�� /�� ����& /��>�)*�+"", � �'�""� (#�""�� /�""�

�� /+� ��� �0���� _>��#+�K�& !=+�K�""& � /+�J,�""BF�� ��#�""� �""V /�J""BM""� 4� �""� � �""�

>���+VM� Y�C !# �^@� �'�� (#��� ����& /���1� )4�>�� M� !# � !#�c� 7��� l�""1��� �T�' >��#

����BF�� 4� /��>^& �� M� !=+V 4� /��>^& �� M� +# �� ��""�� 7>�+�JX# +�K�& �� !���JB +�K�& ��>���

.���

!;& ��� 4� != /+b�� !.����� />�# �+""T�� +""��s& <""�'� !""# !""= N""�� ��� ��1� �%�� ���&

;�2�!���# � Y��M� 4� !���'�� /�� ����� N�^\� � �" ��# (""���� � /��%��� /�""� 4� �""001'�

+b��7 )*�+,)*�+, � ����#+�4 ���� /���4 �;�2� >��4��� �2�� !# != ���� � !# <��1�� >���# /��

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 83

)*�+, �'�� ����&�� �I� )*�+, �� /�)*�+, �0= �Z !#.>���#��T�� ������ +&+�J, w�""� != >���1�

�? �'�� (#��� ����& �1u�� 7�? /�+�� /����+� Y�;�&+& � )*�+,.>��# ��

� SR �� c���� o�9_�7 3��$� �����

��^@�" :�+I& 4� �""��� /�""���b�& � �""c= ��>""� ����� N�^\���# /�""� 4� �""R+# /� �""001'�

� ��>���+V �+B /���=1 !��9B ���1& )>""� �""2�# (���� ��� � N�� )>�TV� !��� �'�� ����& /��

�02 != N��-�B �����+# :D QR )*�+, �'�� ����& w�\�� � ���>�#� /��7 4� )*�+"", �""�� 7�+��

>H^�� ���� N� ��+V�= �# ����+� � )>� - ���R �'�� ����&- �� � � � )��"";� G""V ���""�

����& !=)>��= !���+� ����^@� N�� )>� /+�c�# M�� <1I�� �? �Z �JB" )>��? A+Z N;D

!���+� �� �;�2�!;& � N�� )��# +�1= �JB�� w�\�� ��� ��;� /��>� �& 9�� />�# ����4 �& .>��#

)*�+, �'�� ����& Y���9'� !=)*�+, � (�I� )*�+,) /���� �0� /��<�>"";& � !�cb� )���? /+�

�+� Y�HV��& � x��^& !#+# ��& � ��+b� A�^�� /��� ��+H�""�� �""� W��""���V G""�+Z 4� �'�� ����&

�""c= �""0^V Q��+""� � .��>""� �HV�""� �'�""� ����""& �""0^V Q��+""� � >�""��# �""T�� ���""R

:�+I& +�Kz& � ����� Q��+�)��# YU��^& � Q#�� +# ����+# /�+# (�001'� � N""�HV�� ->""2 4� N""V

)*�+, �'�� ����& x��&+�4 /���� -+�[ ����#+# �""T&� �# N���# �)*�+, ���+B��""R /�""� !""# �""�

+, ������ (���� (V � N��H& ��.��:�1""%& ��""=� � w�""\�� �""�� � NR�� � N""'�� �""��+�� � +""�B

N���� ������� � !���+� �4�# �T��# � �'�, :����!���+""� � +K�""� ��^d��i � �� /�JB �""�� �

)*�+, 4� )�+B:� ���� �&���>�� ��+&�+�b# Y�C N�� -4[ != >��#

���.�� �B H"8.� #���� �

�""�� !# !��& �# G�HI& ��� � � �'�""� (#�""�� ����""& /�""��+T�� ��""# /��""�4 ���""�;� Y��""d& !""=

)*�+, � �'�� (#��� ����& -�.�� �^��� /��>���+V ��""�� �� �c= � �+�� /�� � -�"".�� +�""�� ���

.N�� )��# �+#� �^���� � <Tc� �# ���>�� �= -�.�� �T�N���>I� 4� +b�� � <;H& G�HI& ��� /��

5�+, ���>�� �= ���# ��b��5�+, �? /��;� != �+6 N�� )��# -�� !��� � �""��4 !""���H� !���

-+� � ����^� ]� /�+# ������%�R� 4� )��d��� N�� )��# �9V� ���4 ���# !=.��# +#

1.Works Flow

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

84 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

���� ��$N"'8.�"H�B���Z �

1( ��T�� � ��+#)*�+, �'�� ����& �.��G""�+Z 4� ���+�� /�� ��U""�� �'�""� ����""& /�""��9#�

>���� y�TC `��� �+V.

2( ���?)*�+, � �""I� )*�+"", �'�� ����& � /����+� Y�;�&+& <��& � ����� ���""�#+�4 /�""�

.�+�� ��q1�

3( )*�+, � �""I� )*�+, �'�� ����& ��0��^�� � ��V+Z ��# M�� !��# :��& � $�%�& /�""�

.���+��

٤( )*�+, �'�� ����& � )*�+, ��^d��i N�+�>� ��^d��i N�+�>� )4�� +# !�T& �# ���+�� /��PM

Book.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 85

@���

1. 7��U�� ���+, � �,�� �0�^1��"/�+""� )��""�+#/�""� ���""� ����""& �'�""� )*�+"",�""�"7 ��""'��

W��+d�= !�[�� !^��& -�o� ����& �'�� � 7��+�� Nc;��� 1388.

2. 7)�T�� ���� )1388(" �""�+#)*�+"", � �'�""� ����""& �""���� �+""T�� � ���""B�+�� /�""�

N=+��� >�'�& <H���`+# )>��=)IPP(7 )*�+"", /��= ��� �""�X� ���""B�+�� /�""�" ��""��,!""���

������= >�� N�+�>� )*�+, � NR�� )�bc��� N�#+& f>� .

3. -7����? )1379(" ���+Z � �c��� `��� !���+�/�JB �T�� �# Y�>��2 �V��%& � ��6�""6

�4�# !���+� )G;@�� �# ��4��� �HV (����,!��� ������= N�+�>� >�� �'�� )>Tc��� Y+�>�

)�bc��� -��� `��C)w.(

4. �0�0� >1I�. W1� rUV 7_���V +�� l�""��4 �""���d@""%� 7 & >""1I�/)>�^""� 7��1389 7(

!;&� />�#)��/�� �z&�� !���+� /�+# ���R �'�� ��U""�� /�""1� Nd� N^�C � /�JB

�;&�+� !0�0� <�0I& � 4� )��d��� �# ��+��. 0%VN�+�>""� � �""1= Y�^'�@� !���. Y�""^'�@�

N�+�>� � �1=. )�1� 2 7 $C79-53

5. 7��� ��>�7�,1381">""���+V <""�0I& !0""�0� �"";&�+� AHP " Y��""c��� )�b""c��� ��^�""C

+�;=+���.

6. :��).)+� 7)��4+�%� 9��+, 7)��41395 � ��U""�� !^""��& M��# �'�� ����& 4� ��+�� )��d��� (

)*�+,�102 !���0%V 7��R��+�4 /��- )�1""� 7��U""�� /�>""T��# � ��""%��� �.��+&14 �""# 7

13957 $C85-59

7. :���+#� .`��C>1I� 7+V��4? .>1I�+��� 7/�Hd'���).-�""�� 7>��1396 �""K? � ���""H� N""���� (

N=+� �'�� ����&�""102 !���0""%V 7)�""�� y�T""C G""�+Z 4� /�.& ���- � ��""%��� �"".��+&

)�1� 7��U�� /�>T��#21 �����4 71396 $C 7114-91

8. 7���;� >1I�)1386 ("�4�# /�� �'�� � �'�, ��#�""001'�"7 7��+""& ���4�""� !""^'�@� � ���>""&

��= -�02 ������ �bc���)�� )N1�.(

9. /+�� _�02 W1� _4�+# ���+2 :�B�+�) .1392���z& .( (#��� �'�� � !���+�/�J""B ���""R

7���;� 7Y���9'� ��>��Y� � .�������� N""����:""T� l�""� 7/��""%��� � �'�""� /�""�, )�1""�2,

$C84-43

10. 7/4�;V M��+V .7����0���� �""T��+V � 7/+""V <""T��� )1376(7"���"";� �""��4�# � /�""���� �'�""�"7

:�+�� :>�� )>;2 7����� 7l��>0� 7��+& Y��c��� )�B?.

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

86 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

11. 7�I�V >�^� � +��# ��F�+b�2 /��"N�+�>""� ����""& _�'�""� ���""B !""# /�""� <""C� 44 ����""�

�����" 7��dC� ��6 l�� +���V -��, /�02

12. ��b��4+V ����).1386 (��+# 5H� ���T��1�, ���12 � !""��#/4�""� ����""& (#�""�� �'�""�

)*�+,/�� ��d� 7��+�� ����,!��� ������= >�� N�+�>� )*�+, � NR�� )�bc��� ��+&.

13. 4�+�V 7w�4 �02 � !��%^� 7��+# )1390(7 "����& 7�'�� 7:���""d� �""��9#� � ��"".&"7 7��+""&

Y��c��� $�

14. �u�V ��T6 �H& _�;� -UD)��4 :���+#�._ �1�V �9�92 & /����>R M���.����>R )1394(

��+# (���� � ���=��� /�z""&�� �'�""� ���""R � `�""H� 7��+""�� !���0""%V 5��F"", `�""H�

)�1� .3�%R11 $C 7178-149

15. �'�� ����& ��.& ��+&+# )F�� ���=�b'� ���+Z _ � ���'�� /���9#� ����""& W��+""d�= ����� _

7��+��� �'��1388

16. �d�@' />� ./+=�� l�;��).1388 (7"l>� ������ )�� 4����� /�+# )*�+,/�� BOT، 7��+""&

��'�� W��+d�= ��>�� � N�+�>� NR�� )�bc��� ��^�C +�;=+���

17. >�� 7/�d@%�).��� >1I�1396!���+# +# /�+� ( �c= !^��& /�� :c� !���+# +# >�=�& �#

$R�� �R+# ��^� �# �? !���H� ��""102 !���0""%V 7��U""�� ��""%��� �# Q;&+� /��- �"".��+&

)�1� 7��U�� /�>T��# � ��%���18 �# 71396 $C 7103-83

18. 7/���� - .7- />1�� � 7 V/��""�+)1389("��""�?�""���� ����""& �'�""� !""# � N=�""c�

���12 �C�%R � )*�+,/�� /+� "����� 5��1� !���'�� !�'�� /��+�7�� ��+&.

19. 7���� >�� �02)1386.("NR��� � �102 � -�""02 /�""�V" 7��+""& ���4�""� !""^'�@� �

���>& ��= -�02 ������ )�bc����� )N1�.(

20. 7��;�� ���+V � )/����13887( >1��"N=�c� ���12 �C�%�&: -�o� ���""� ����""& �0'�""�

� /�JB�� )*�+,/�� +�4 ��R�� /9=+� � �0I� !# 5�# �C�%R" ��'�� W��+""d�= !^""��&

-�o� ����& 7�'�� Nc;��� 1388

21. ���d0� ,�1��= �\ _+��� ,`>%� _!1Z�V ,!1Z�V) .1395�""�+# .( Y�+""K� � /��>""���, :�+""I&

+# !���+�/�JB ���R � ��+�� � !@#� ��%��� �����H� �# 5��= Y�+K� �d�� :�+I&. y�;�

-�� l��, )�1�2, $C10-1

22. Akbiyiki, R. Eaton,D. & Turner, A . (2000) Project Finance and the Private

Finance Initiative (PFI) Journal of Structured Finances, vol. 12. pp.67,75.

23. Bhattacharaya, A. B. (2002), Project Finance Power Plant in Mexico,

master of Science Dissertation in law, Montreal, Canada

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

���� �����– � !"� � ��� ������ � ������ � ����� ������# �$% �&"��' 1397 87

24. Byoun, S., & Xu, Z. (2014). Contracts, governance, and country risk in

project finance:Theory and evidenc. Journal of Corporate Finance,No 26.

Pages 124-144

25. Chirkunova, E.K.,Kireeva, E. E., Kornilova, A. D., & Pschenichnikova , J. S.

(2016). Research of instruments for financing of innovation and investment

construction projects. Procedia Engineering,No 153. Pages 112-117

26. Eiris. (2006),Project Finance : A Sustainable Future, SEE Risk Briefing,

(Ethical Investment Research Services.)

27. Farrel,H and Beresfor , CH(2009) , Public private partnership understanding

monument, page, 547-561

28. Fight,A .(2006) Introduction To Project Financing ,Great Britannia .Elsevier

29. Fox,J &Tott,N.(1999) . The PFI hand book, Bristol, Herbert Smith Jordan

Publishing Ltd

30. Gorshkov, R., & Epifanov, V. (2016). The mechanism of the project

financing in the construction of underground structures. Procedia

Engineering, No165.pages 1211-1215

31. Hoffman, s.l.(2007). The Law Business of International Project Finance (3rd

ed) Cambridge University PRESS.

32. Kean,F. R.(1995), Corporate Finance , us, Blackwell

33. Krishnamurthy V. Subramanian, Frederick Tung,(2016). Law and Project

Finance, In Journal of Financial Intermediation, Volume 25, 2016, Pages

154-177.

34. Merton, C. Robert (2004)"The DESING OF Financial System: Towards a

Synthesis of Function and structure."

35. Nevitt,P. K. & Fabozzi, F.J.(2000), Project Financing(1st ed), England. Euro

money Books.

36. Priseilla , A.(1999). Project Finance In Developing countries, Washington

DC .IFC, NO. 23474, Number,7. Great Britannia .Elsevier.

37. William,C.(2007) Research Methods, Journal of Business & Economic

Research, March2007, Volume5.Number3

38. Wojtek M. Wolfe(2013), China's Strategic Hedging, In Orbis, Volume 57,

Issue 2, 2013, Pages 300-313

39. Yescombe, E. R. (2002) Principles of Project Finance, London. Academic

Press,

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020

88 �<=�� � >"�.�?� ���@��� A"��� ��B/... � 3�!E�3��� �$��� F� ����"G�E ��<� �A"��B� �����

Dow

nloa

ded

from

mie

aoi.i

r at

7:5

6 +

0430

on

Thu

rsda

y Ju

ne 4

th 2

020


Recommended