rFD-302 (Rev. 10-6-95)
DATE: 09-08-2010
^CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
REASON: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY ON: 09-08-2035
FEDERAL BUREAU OE INVESTIGATION
ALL INTOHEREIN IS
WHE!
09/11/2001, SAsI
NTAINEDIRED EXCEPT
On 09/17/2001. six
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOTOI OTHERWISE
d^ys afterand
[
TllOO Manhattan Avenue,
Date of transcription 09/16/2002
the terrorist events of[interviewed
Union City, New
J had previously telephoned the Newark FBI andJersey,i i
indicated that he had photographs prior to the explosions at theWorld Trade Center,
beb7C
The above-referenced agents retrieved the photographsat his residence, however, upon review, the photosfrom
i
appeared to be taken around the time of the collapse of the firsttower, not prior to the attack.
While in the apartment building, the interviewing agentswere advised by security to speak to another tenant who might haveknowledge of the event. Neither agent is able to recall the nameof the woman at present
.
The interviewing agents spoke with the referenced womanwho provided no additional information. After determining that thewoman could provide no relevant information, the agents thanked herfor her time and proceeded to leave. The woman accompanied theagents to the elevator on her floor.
While waiting for the elevator, the agents noticed adrawing, approximately eye level, on the wall near the elevatorcall buttons. The drawing appeared to depict the World TradeCenter towers. This was evident "by the shape of the buildingsdepicted, with one tower bearing a large antenna at the top. Therewas no evidence indicating how long the drawing had been there.
DAr
classifbe:
REASON^BECfcAS§IFYON:
Investigation on
File#
09/16/2002 at Newark, New Jersey
by SA
rf *
This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of
and its contents are not to be distributed outside your agency.
Date dictated 09/16/2002
•operty of the FBI and is loaned to your agency;
fD-448 (Rsv. 6-2-97)
FBI FACSIMILE
COVER SHEETfli INFORMATION CONTAINEDHERHN IS UNCLASSIFIED / / # A
PRECEDENCE
Immediate
Priority
IS Routine
To:
CLASSIFICATION
Top Secret
Secret
Confidential
Sensitive
IS Unclassified
S VfrC/CAT- P-Name of Officei
Special Handling Instructions: ifcurttcA
Time Transmitted: lSO% (^—w*V
Sender's Initials: £-*tkj>
Number of Pages: 4*u3Q
(including cover sheet)
4S
Date: -03/05/2002-
Facsimile Number: ^OA- Z2.Z~ X/>^,^/
Attn: —Name Room
From: ^ e.uo> <xy C_
Telephone
Name of Office
Subject: P V - SD?_
^A^ \*<x^ lAAcbV*!^
b6b7C
ulaov^ r^^ctprp4"
Originator's Name: Telephone:
T=Originator's Facsimile Number: <X\jJr¥H2-'r± I 03
Approved: ^A/JlMf7
Brief Description of Communication Faxed: jTO 3Q?~ gMr<sV ^ ^ IU - O"
WARNINGInformation attached to the cover sheet is U.S. Government Property. If you are not the intended recipient of this
information, disclosure, reproduction, distribution, or use of this information is prohibited (18.USC, § 641). Please notify the
originator or the local FBI Office immediately to arrange for proper disposition.
FD-542 (Rev. 11-02-1999)
DATE: 09-08-2010
CLASSIFIES! UC60322LP/PLJ/CCREASON: (^ (
C)
DECLASSIFY 01: 09-08-2035
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HERE IN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTT.JHEEE SHOOT OTHERWISE
SEt^T/ORCON/NOFORN
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 09/30/2002
To : Newark Attn
:
From: NewarkC-9 b6Contact: SA
| I b?c
Approved By:/
Drafted By: i
( S ) caSe ID %£^&S/OC/NFt
(S
) Ti tle™bs/Oe/NF^
(S)
Synopsis: (U) Statistical accomplishment report for captionedinvestigation
.
bl
(j'W 3&ea?A^ei3r?F'rom- -G«,3-
Reference: E 3 CObl
Details: (U) The purpose of this communication is to claimstatistical accomplishments from the referenced serial now apartof the above captioned substantive case file.
«/
GS/OC/NF) Transfer $f evidence to FBIHQ for review.
DATE:CLASSREASON: 1.4(
DECLAS!
!Ep&EseqSet/orcon/noforn^
(*>
bl
To : Newark Fr,om.
( S
)
Re-: fS-/0C/NFh
SJ&^ET/ORGON/NOFORN
MoTATarV
09/30/2002 bl
Accomplishment Information:
Number : 8
Type: FIS/TERRORIST ACTIVITY OBSERVED/DETECTEDITU: CONSENSUAL SEARCHITU: LIAISON WITH OTHER AGENCYITU: LIAISON WITHIN FBIITU: SEARCH (NON- CONSENSUAL)Claimed By
SSN:Name:Squad "C9"
bob7C
S^SJ^T/ORCON/NOFDRN"
c f 4
,(kev. 0^-28-2000)
DATE:*<09-08-2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
REASON: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY 01: 09-08-2035
^BgR^T/ORCON/NOFORN
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
277/&T3o(,£C-
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOWN OTHERWISE
(S)
Date: 10/04/2002
rAttn: C-9, SA
beb7C
Approved
Drafted By:
Case ID t:
Title:
(Pending) — vJ^J(Pending) -—//>?
Synopsis \j/ 0P//OC,. NF-K-To document the return of evidence toNewark and translation results, Hebrew to English, of certain pocket litter collected from the
High Fivers on 09/11/2001.
U t^//oc, NF)' BeCT^ved^Egem g O J"
Deci'ari'ri'i'tyeu . X3r(U) Full Field Investigation Instituted:
Reference: (S//OC, NF) f
06/26/2002
=3bl
*(S>
j£#OC,NF) ^requested FBI Newark to
laetransfer the collected pocket utter to me I latJf'BUbiy. IHe evidence was received by theon 09/13/2002, at FBIHQ. The itfenSHEfcluded personal notebooks/journals, address
books, personal organizers, personal letters, business cards, and assorted documents such as
passports, phone cards, maps and other documents associated with the five and the movingbusiness, seized from the "High Fivers",
bl
and!"
(SJ
W/OC,NF) Copies of the personal notebooks/journals, address books,personal orgamzere/personal letters, documents, and books in Hebrew were made for thepurpose oftraiisMdn imo Etipsh. On 091/7/2002, SA
|
--1 1 I provided the first oftwo
groups of documents to be transited bv Contract Linguist (CL)]j , | with the
approval ofLinguist Supervisor and Unit Chie:
FieldOffice (WFO), The first group of documents was translated, and subsequently retrieved bySA
. Washington
beb7C
heb7C
bl
CLASSIFBE;
REASON:SSIFYON:
]at WFO, on 09/19/2002. The second group was provided to CL
SI^ET/ORCON/NOFORN
that day
bl
-an 3©
ITx
^ SEJSK^T/ORCON/NOFORN
To : Newark E2^mj__CDimterint;ellJgerifeeRe: (S)
arjs ^nm- count
f > 0/04/20:027
'. >Vbl
.b6
b7C
CL l Itranslated the documents, which were retrieved by SA at WFO, on09/20/2002.
™-----l^//OC,NF)' The translated documents indicate the notebooks, journals, and
address books were of a personal nature. The translations include travel accounts, friends andassociates phone numbers, and family letters. CL opined there was nothing ofForeignIntelligence nature in the documents.
' '
( g
)
i^The following evidence is being returned to Newark: 1B25 BC E01 889034,and 1B25 BC £01889039, from eas^T ~JB4 E01889578 > 1B30 > 1B1LK?
W* |!S^ For Newark, copies ofthe translated documents, from Hebrew to English,
are attached hereto.
bl
"SSIZ^ET/ORCON/NOPORN
-08-2010
SIFIEB BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CCEEASOH: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY OH: 09-08-2035
REQUESTING OFFICE: FBI Headquarters
REQUESTING OFFICIAL: SSA
CASE TITLE: National Security
CASED)
sfeg^ET
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED. ^^ HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT
^P IMEm SHOOT OTHERWISE
CL
adquarters
Washington Field
September 17, 2002
b7C
(?)bl
LANGUAGE: Hebrew
WFO JOB#: 6643
Document Name: as02260f.nsd
ALLlNFeRMfiTION CONTMHEREIN isUSnassBarpccEPTWHB^HOWM OTHERWR
DATE:CLASSIFIEDREASON: 1.4
BE
SE ET[LS note: All foreign names and names of obscure towns in India and Nepal are
approximated]
Page 29
s wytR E T
'ALL IHF8RHATIQH- COHTAIHED
'HEREIN IS UUCliASSIFIED
DATE 09-08-2010 BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
. /
V
•
").
b7A
%*> .*
V
Sfea&'tuuj',.^.-
SECPT
Jo 7A
V
f ^
b7A
3ft3 4M(4B0
m®k f4%^ 7%*#t Sum*
UKNdU 6LLlL-e
niuq ^ud <m gogim u.qn^u ^cuu;
lsniuu uuatN^ mcuua k^nm cdiw.'«•
u 424101 - lia.w <aai m $n ^-.o^M,uada^a' luxial uiuiati' uauu moaci a<taia&u;
nii uLuiil -fluiM' nu aci^cu urawr 'm
WW - una Niucii^ia im«U<;c uqaurt ^ii
diaciia ucQ^a1
duwriLuhatfuiL au ciarti a<;-
KiibL ixial uc&n rtu udiLN ^ ci^auiiio;. <a£.
dlLNiQ cluc< uc^ uin tawGiidu lc.u^niu
u,,ijiwi„ acca nu ^auiua ^ aim a^iu
04 Mi u«| lniul mcuua cmcf im*
ciuum cidUJLu wtucia
v«jn«* .*%?*>
- i
ipf*'
»A«fe^'
flife
r>wy<r
#, -r siBftf ,,..:.,a4
- w
1^
n
Hi
ppton.™
v*ata
nfflnwimawirtwrairrnn
nsan wa rnnam imnn bmw to
1973- 1970 ,?TONh
t/J
11K1
? DWSIfl .praTTTUOT-
in nna
art arm fttoo tow fan in to jmm nap ,"pran"n
aifya mKD ,1936 mm ana ma ,mw wnpi nrainn nra?
maw iw "pran"n m raiwi? Jibwim mmto nt rm nap omn .(win nwa to iainna) raw nap
wt» mm mh tmwn owmn ban raw "ran"!!
Nto ,mfa w ,nwpa naina N7 i? nwiw .na ij) ib
raw nman ra?3 fow 'ton iwtoiw to man
.1973-1970 own pa Tnja» jwan n?33
n nwiai namp nfowptow npnam to nnwin^ran wbmm nam xm ma .nnpa uraa nmn
w tinw ,wwa wn iwtoi p»p "rap ,rata
to to wimp wv ra nai nana lap mnsnmirm
wm yppro nmm maw n»m nfonnro ,3am ma
ito nbiv'ivnb nantai wimara niNpnain? imrtw
,nN?am irefai nnra ,na>ppan riWvn .w prm
ra? /anan to nrtnjm niNxam pr rijKnwn njwiran
ns .ra im nta napn tin wipp awn to nab nK
,13 to wtom fa ib>nnn matf iapn mrm naNpa
m^aparapa wan? m nbd? nw ra»nn .nym-np>na
irmK .ppto? to ntopnwfo nrtrni n>pab nmia
apyiw trcnn? ianw mna -m nmnman nK uwn
nnnam own tow own twin iwn .ito iapn to
npnmn rmm .nwnn to ,m m» ,nw nw naa ,m>nvn
n»wn p to jrara anb nmw ,npapi npna rrnwn
rmwa im jma# m?fra ranmn iapn p ?ipa wip ran
n»W w rtm nmmn tons .wu>pi pp to irown
nmbnn ,nw ,nana pip nwman to rapana wi
napn nnaja wma iapn ara raiwin nwpna .mww
,w npii mm td nw?naa naa im invi maioni
raw ran iaP3i? nam mm .ton njrr to taipn ram>
to nNpa nnnnaja nnayb ipnn nnin .mrm? nnai
J.R.R. Tolkien
THEHOBBIT
O by George Allen and Unwin Ltd.
London
Hebrew Rights Reserved 1977 by
Zmora-Bitan, Publishers
P.O.B. 22383, Tel-Aviv
Printed in Israel, 2000
Translated into Hebrew by
the P.O.W. of the Israeli Air-Force Pilots
and their comrades
in Abasya Prison, Cairo, 1970-1973
wix wk ,msjfnmm tao ik in tea
.ni iDoaip TsinjiB nnv pto to - inn ix
nt isoa Wan imna mnv no ten nnoa mw.V'lana anaa mmw nwo x^s oVnna im
ppto/vwsiB'iurnra
1J77 ram man nroirtTwnin
nmw man imam to©
tikV onwnD .jncTmiBrt
^»aa Hpjnm mnr* ,ttpo
20oo/b"mWaoDi3
u^ju^Ojivr^iV ^^^ ttapSw^JSaUi^p^^^ "7?
J
* 1
b7A
s
3
s
£
U
ianm.ul' amu-wL
jm
i/t
cinu UILG.D
a^z, ffl/,i
Michal Shalev
ONE HUNDRED WINTERS
© Hebrew Rights Reserved by
Zmora-Bitan, Publishers
P.O.B. 4020 Ganei-Aviv— Lod, 71110
Printed in Israel, 2001
.m twjcw T»mn» wn» p^n Va - thr w
nt isoa Wsi laim not no to) nnoa wro
>'iana aro^ iwtbd nrarn sto Btom tidr
.IW '9 IW *nW UK j7ffl)l |IP 7W OTID Ml 195 TODM
jm 'n no 'to to rar tto ik to nnVw to mmm)m 278 to orai
2001 raw nnrorft to nn ison
nnw warn nran ©
lift mraia .praTrnaft
o"ia D^n .o -mi) man
•w6 dto .praTrnw "hm tupsi irro
71293 ,n'?,3isxn"K ,n nosaVm
2001 / K"0OT1 VlTO OSTJ
12 3 4 5 6 7 8
J
FD-542 (Rev. 11-02-1999)• ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEBE IN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE
DATE; 09-08™2010
classified by uc60322LP/PLj/cc FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATIONREASON; 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY ON: 09-08-2035
(S)
Precedence : ROUTINE
To : Newark
From: NewarkC-9Contact:
Date: 10/04/2002
-itApproved By-
Drafted By: fl
Case ID #: (.fff
Title: (S)
(S)
Synopsis
jL
I (Pending)
sTWIN TOWERS
vsWu
Statistical accomplihment
.
C<*iiiMJv "n.'d|wFa,,unr,,
i'
beb7C
bl
Details: L&) ^Interview conducted per FBIHQ request on 9/10/02.
^
—
/ ~\
ALL INFOHEREIN l§
Wl
A1NEDv
EXCEPTBE.
DATEclass:
REASON:DECLASi
bl
•'* 1_9?^j£oL££~
s^ket-
To : Newark From; NewarkRe: (S)
1 10/04/2002 bl
Accomplishment Information:
Number: 1Type: INTERVIEW OF SUBJECT (CONTACT & ESPIONAGE)ITU: AGENT INTERVIEWClaimed By:
SSN:Name:Squad: C9
behlC
~Sj55KET
2
To : Newark Eroni: MeisaxkRe: (SJ ] 10/04/2002 bl
LEAD(s)
:
Set Lead 1: (Adm)
NEWARK
(jVAT NEWARK
Read/ clear
3
(Rev. 08-28-2000)
DATE: 09-08-2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
REASON: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY 01: 09-08-2035
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEPEII IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOWN OTHERWISE
(S]
(S)
(U)
(U)
(U)
Precedence : ROUTINE
To : Counterintelligence
Date:
Attn: SSA
10/29/2002
CD-2CRoom 4066
b6b7C
Front':if Newark "")
Approved BY\MDrafted By:
SA b6b7C
~~~t^endi
LVVliAl 1U^M&!
(S)
bl
Synopsis: VJo provide Countering! 1 n a<=>r\n& wj t-h copies of i-.hpj'
DOB atphotos found in the vehicle of ,_^^__^Mercer County Airport on^ 10/3 0/20Ol J T^^Enclosure (s) : (Enclosed for Counterintelligence are nine colorphotographs taken from the camera of
| ] during hisdetention at Mercer County Airport, Ewing Township, NJ on10/30/2001^ J^QDetails: [The photos developed at the FBI laboratory depicthighway shots of various locations in NJ. One photo shows theview from Route 1 traveling North crossing the Delaware Riverfrom Pennsylvania to New Jersey at Trenton, NJ. These photos arebe irig submitted for any action deemed appropriate7] jf&j
(on 10/30/2001 the Mercer County Sheriff's Officecontacted the Trenton RA and advised that they an Israelinational in custody, acting suspiciously. This individual wasdriving a vehicle , a white 1997 MITSUBISHI truck which waflregistered to the
•bo
b7C
Ca. had an Israeli passport #_ _i
and there werereceipts in the vehicle showing that he paid a toll near theFEDERALIZATION ADMINISTRATION CENTER at Pomona, NJ that same
1=511
bob7C
day.was doing that daywhich was a direct
could not nrovi'Hfi an adequate explanation as to what he
<u)
was making deliveries of framed art workviolation of his B1/B2 visa. U.S. Immigration
ancLNaturalization personnel on scene that day refused to take| |
into custody for this violation. I \wa& charged withdriving with an invalid'" drivers 1 icense , issued a summons and^j
CLASS"REASON;
SJIFYON:
bl
3o^)v\noi,^
i
, To : ^Counterint^lcrence From : Newark* fARf--n jlO/29/2002
To: ^eounterint^lcre r
^ReVl- J1
bl
released. No further* investigation has been conducted regarding(U ) this---.incideat!Tfe>Jr
,-To: ^ounterint^Bfe^ice From: ^Newark
fg)-f ^e: I tL0/29/2002fScS —" bl
SfGBfETLEAD(s) :
Set Lead 1:
COUNTERINTELLIGENCE
AT WASHINGTON, DC
Read and clear.
m..^ DATE: 09-08-2010(Rev. 01-31-2003) CLASSIFIED BY UC
1
REASON: 1.4 (c)
' DECLASSIFY 01: 09™08~2035
% LP/PW/CC 4ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
,
HERE II IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT
WHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence : ROUTINE
To : Newark
From: NewarkTRAContact:
Approved By-
Drafted By:
Case ID #--:--
Title:; ^£
Date: 04/23/2003
Attn: ^SSL^'7Wf/^
heb7C
bl
(U1T
Synopsis : C^^ To report on the update of the charges againstfour Israeli nationals arrested by the Mt. Holly PoliceDepartment on 08/14-15/2001.
(U)
Enclosure (s) : J^T Enclosed in a 1A envelope are fourphotographs deducting the four Israeli nationals arrested by theMt. Holly Police Department on 08/14-15/2001 and a floppy diskcontaining same. A 1A envelope containing an NCIC printout forthe individuals listed below.
(U) Details: >^^0n 04/18/20031
( (
|Mt.
Holly PoligeBepartment was contacted and interviewed regardingthe status of the prosecution against four Israeli nationalsarrested by his department and previously reported under thisfile.
| 1 provided arrest photos of these individuals andItai:a floppy aiSK containing the photos.
(U) According to all foursubjects were charged with possession of stolen property, overduerental trucks. The charges against
[and[ II DOB
i
dob[are stiJL± pending and bench
]
warrants have been issued Py Burlington County Superior Court fortheir arrest. The charges against the other two subjects,
bob7C
b6b7C
bl
l)3>CJ^no<i ,^Cu
3E^ET*
To : NewaRe: (S)'
2± Virrm\. Mm.ra t-V
04/23/2003
+bl
DOB andf ] DOB.
, Jwere1 explained that since they were
(U)
dismissed.arrested during two separate incidents the cases were assigned todifferent prosecutors. This would explain why all the cases werenot dismissed, A review of attached NCIC printouts for theseindividual s shows Jzhat there is an outstanding warrant for only
beb7C
This information is being submitted for any actiondeemed appropriate.
k
2
•
(S.rcrfliO
t
Jbl
7-1 (Rev.'5-13-99)
PATE: 09-08-2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CCREASON: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY 01: 09-08-2035
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATIONWASHINGTON, D. C. 20535
To: Counterintelligence
CD-?,C.Room40f)6SA b6
b7C
Reference: Communication dated September 24, 2002
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEPEII IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE
Date: September 26, 2002
Case ID N<
Lab No.1 020924003 LV
bl
sag
;£!
Your No.:
Title:
(SI
Date specimens received: September 24, 2002
Specimens:
The items listed below were examined in the Questioned Documents Unit:
'Ql Notebook (Your JRJ13Y)
( O^V^Q 1 ' 1 "^ 1 '6 Lined sheets bearin§ handwriting (Your JRJ13Y)
~ Thei
Enclosures (9)
Pagel of 2
This Report is Furnished for Official Use Only
§E€«fI•
This report contains the results of the questioned document examinations.
Resulte of Examinations:
V_/ j#J The presence of overwriting, the limited nature of the text, and the limited amountof comparable writing prevents a definite reading of the beginning of the text on the bottomof Q 1.3 (_ooM NY). Nor could it be determined whether the same writer(s) prepared the text
throughout the Ql notebook. However, it should be.noted that one "B" letter formation wasfound on Q1.5 that appears similar to the indecipherable text on Q1.3. Five (5) printed
enlargements of this portion of writing are enclosed for your investigative assistance.
\AyJp)
Indented writing was observed on Q1.2. Two (2) copies of this text are enclosedfor your investigative assistance. No indented writing was observed on Q 1.3.
Remarks:
irougn 01throug!
Digital images of Q1.3 through Q1.6 have been recorded. Specimens Ql.lQ1.6 are enclosed herewith.
[ ]Questioned Documents Unit
b6b7C
BoR-voeMFrffiTrr@*3*»
Page 2 of 2
020924003 LV
DATE: 09-10-2010
FBI*ICTF0.
CLARIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
IJPASOH: 1-4 (b,c,d) *,
'
DECLASSIFY OH: 09-10-2035' *
• ET
ALL IIFOEEATIOI COHTAIHED
HERE II IS DECLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOWN OTHERWISE
U.S. Department of Justice
^LLTWTORMATION CQIHAtWE^ Federal Bureau of Investigation
hekin13S^si»exceptVifHERP^nWM OTHER!
In Reolv Please Refer to
File No.f
y 3(5>bl
Newark, New Jersey 07101
July 10, 2003
(S) £- TWIN TOWERSWERS / bl
This document is classified "siSp6^T/ORCON/NOFORN" .£»*-
^ +.„. „„*-a ^^4-y unless otherwise marked. (U)
Closing investigative memorandum relative to theFederal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Newark Division, Full b
^Field investigation initiated September 14, 2001, surrounding b7c
circumstances indicating that five (5) Israeli Nationalsidentified a s I
and I |detained in conjunction with the
PENTTBOMB, MAJOR CASE 182, investigation, had videotaped the9/11/01, terrorist attack on the Twin Towers and may havepossessed foreknowledge of the same. (Note: Newark's initialinvestigation of the five Israeli Nationals was conducted under ^the authority of the PENTTBOM investigation. Captioned ^jLinvestigation was initiated after the criminal investigation N
^2;indicated a possible/undefined intelligence affiliation with an ^Oj/
Israeli Intelligence Service. )(J^)
circumstantial information to corroborate eyewitness accounts thefive (5) Israeli Nationals "videotaped" the attacks on the TwinTowers of the World Trade Center. Investigation did find thatstill photographs were taken of the attack by these individualswith a 35 mm camera found in their possession, f UJ\
Newark investigation found no factual or substantivecircumstantial information to indicate the five (5) IsraeliNationals were on top of a parking garage "videotaping" prior to
first hijacked aircraft striking tower #2 of the World TradeCenter. Numerous circumstantial facts strongly support the five
(5) individuals statements they traveled to the roof of theparking garage after learning of the attacks from radiobroadcasts and Intern^_npsi*Ssa8££gs - None of the picturesfr^N
This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI.
FBI and is loanecj^o your agency; it and its
It is the property of thebl
ontents &
iUMUu*_^auM
(S)
(S)
(U)
(S)
(S)
•V
SE^lT/ORCON/NOFORN_
h TWIN TOWERS If%»
\bl
developed from the film found inside the 35 mm camera depictedthe twin towers prior to the attack.(LO
Physical evidence found in the possession of the five
(5) Israeli Nationals in conjunction with statements made by themduring numerous interviews over several months indicates that
lis'
being employed by theSpecifically,
h&bl
admitted to
1 and further admitted attending a
ne was selected jdv tTTe"T
I advised during an additional interview
] to attend a
He advised hisfor employees working outside
bob7C
thefor thecountry of Israel
1 was in|Statements by
t
associates corroborated this fact but also revealed thatfhave also been stationed in other countries as well. ^Newark'sinvestigation found no factual evidence to suggest that
|I
may
]was operating in an overt or covert capacity inside theUnited States for theno basis to even remo :ely suggestpossession of prior knowledgo_£e]World Trade Center of 9/11/01.
Furthermore, Newark foundwas in the
ting to the attacks on the
bl
However , Newark T s investigation found nothing to sugge_st
acted in such a capacity whi le in the United States .ji^QPhysical evidence as well as
| Statements to Special Agentsof the FBI corroborated Newark's belief that I I
wasworking for the Israeli Government through his employment at the
loffered no information to
hehlC
suggest that of or
tasked to perform any overt or covert clandestine function in theUntied States,, Newark found no basis to suggestwas in possession of or had any prior knowledge^relating to theattacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01. (J&X^J
physical evidence along with statements by I
revealed an association between
b7C
bl
•
(S)
SEQRlpT/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS
fte)
bl
(S)
(S)
(S)
More specifically, never fully revealed to thesatisfaction of interviewing agents , how hand written telephonenumbers found in his personal notebook just happened to be
]
bl.ho
b7C
In lite of theseriousness of Newark 1 3 investigation, and considering thetotality of mounting circumstantial evidence indicating eitherdirect or indirect links between the Five (5) Israeli Nationals
Newark found no basis to suggest|
]was in possession of or had any prior knowledge relatingto the attacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01.
was at firstindividuals, butcooperative of the Five (5) individuals, but later gave a full
accounting of his travel and activities while in the United
the leastlater gave be
b7C
corroborated statementstrengtn£ning the position there
States. Information provided bymade by his associates, further s
was no video camera used on the roof top of parking garage tomake recordings just prior or during the attacks on the twintowers of the trade center. 1(a)
ofjjTnoi
(S)
,A note pad belonging to|
|contained two sets
numbers . Investigation revealed the overseas telephone number|was coincidentally subscribed to by an individual
South America with authentic ties to Islamic militants in theThis number
b6b7C
inmiddle eastlater identiriea asfriend of
inwas
bl
a legitimate oanK account belonging to ^Awho lent him two hundred dollars ($200)71 The
^second telephone number once authenticated was according to TBINew York , associated with an
individuals
[advised this phone numner oeiongea to an individual naiAed
hashish dealer in the New York metro area. Physicalwell as statements by
[
confirmed
a
as and therecreational drug
other four (4) .
use of mostly [M\(%/
•
<S)
Slip^T/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS% bl
>
marijuana. Newar k believes
[
individuals foundaffiliation with
was for the purchase of smallquantities of illegal drugs. Newark's investigation ruled out a
b6b7C
nexus between|
|and the individual in South America, along
with circumstantial ties to the individuals connected to FBI NewNo articulate factsYork f s
_
were found to demonstrate that \_ ] was inpossession of or had any prior knowledge relating to the attackson the World Trade Center of 9/11/01. {Ud
Newark 1 s inquiry into concentrated on his
b6b7C
travel in the United States, along with his use of a Germanpassport he legally acquired from the German Embassy in Israel.Statements by corroborated information provided by hisassociates, and further strengthened the facts supporting theposition there was no video camera used on the roof top ofparking garage to make recordings just prior or during theattacks on the World Trade Center. Newark found no basis tosuggest
| |
was in possession of or had any priorknowledge relating to the attacks on the World Trade Center of
9/11/01. (a)
Background to the investigation: (*/OC/NF) \Uj
On September 11, 2001, numerous complaints received byFBI-NK revealed that several individuals had been observedcelebrating following the initial crash of an aircraft into theTwin Towers. T-l, a resident of Union City, NJ, advised that at
-apprnadmataly. SjLllQ_aj^.JL=^^ _.T^l_on the. ., _
.
telephone to tell T-l that T-2 saw smoke coming from the WTC. In
order to see the WTC more closely, T-l used 7x33mm (likely7x35mm) power binoculars to view the scene from the rear windowof T-l's apartment. While looking in the direction of the WorldTrade Center (WTC), T-l observed three (3) males kneeling on theroof of a white van located in the rear parking lot of T-l'sapartment complex. It appeared as though they noticed T-l as
well. fS^OC/NF) fmT-l described the males as white, mid-twenties, no
facial hair, no glasses, "clean-cut," no hats, all wearing shortsleeves, with lean builds. Other identifying data was alsoprovided. T-l described the white van as a nbox"-style van which [JX^
•
(S)
T/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS
D ft>bl
had no windows on the sicte; it reminded T-l of a telephonecompany van. <*/OC/-N-F)fvA
j
According to T-l, one of the males appeared to betaking still photographs and video of the other males with theWTC in the background. All of the males appeared to be jovial in
that they smiled, hugged one another, and gave "high fives."(See attached photos) . As the vehicle later left that area, T-lrecorded the license plate as JRJ-13Y. Later that day when T-l f s
spouse returned home, T-l provided the police with theinformation pertaining to the males. tS/OC/NF) ( \j\
Another complaint received by FBI-NK revealed a secondeyewitness who reported having observed a white van in the sameparking lot as described by T-l. This eyewitness, however,observed the van in the parking lot as early as 8:00am on themorning of the explosions at WTC. (&/OC/-N"F)^U^)
A third complainant later reported having seen, onSeptember 11, 2001 (time not noted), a "big, white, model 2000Chevrolet van, or possibly panel truck or U-Haul truck, bearingthe words "Urban Movers" in black lettering along the side. Thevehicle was observed in the Liberty State Park's Marine Terminalin Jersey Cit^, NJ, located across the Hudson River from WTC.(•S^OC/NF) (\i \
Pursuant to this information, East Rutherford, NJpolice authorities stopped an Urban Moving Systems van at a pre-positioned roadblock. The van, occupied by males similar tothose described by witnesses, was traveling eastbound along StateRoute 3 in New Jersey. Following the stop, the police detainedfive (5) individuals, all believed to be Israeli Nationals, on
the grounds that they may have possessed information pertainingto the WTC explosions. The matter was later forwarded to FBI-NKfor further investigation. The individuals were detained forquestioning and later held for violations of their immigrationstatus. fW-OC/NF) f l\
)
A search of the van and individuals was conducted atthe time of the vehicle stop. The vehicle was also searched by a
trained bomb-sniffing dog which yielded a positive result for thepresence of explosive traces. Swabs of the vehicle's interior /(£\
i
(S) cS^K^T/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS:3&> bl
were taken, and those samples were sent to the crime laboratoryfor further analysis. (i/OC/RF)/^
J
Seizure of the individuals' property yielded thefollowing: a 35mm camera, several personal telephone-stylenotebooks, back packs, airline tickets with immediate traveldates for destinations world-wide, Israeli passports (in somecase, expired), a German passport, and thousands of dollars of
cash. Student identification cards later believed to be falsewere also found. Oddly, equipment typically used in a movingcompany's daily duties was not found, including work gloves,
blankets, straps, ropes, boxes, dollies, rollers, etc. Also notfound was the video camera that T-l observed at least one of the
males using to film the explosion at WTC. f&/OC/NF) (\\\
The five (5) detained Israeli Nationals^and|_
bob7C
were interviewed subject to tne nmn:ea scope of determiningwhether a video camera had been used, and, if so, where the videocamera was to be located now. The results of the individualinterviews yielded a wide array of discrepancies with respect to
the whereabouts of each of the individuals as it applied to timeperiod of the attack on the WTC. 4*/0C/NF)l U )
advised interviewing agents that afterhaving arrived at his workplace, Urban Moving Systems, located at
3 18th Street, Weehawken, NJ, around 8:00 am, September 11, 2001,
he received a telephone call informing him that the first^expd.asJjpn ha.d~cugcn rre.cL XKLotBJ^tixe_^xjELt. explo^ion, _actua 1 1y .
occurred at 8:45am that morning.] I l and his.| K NFI)
got into a company van and departed the workplace for a Gulfgasoline service station. Then,
[
friends, traveled to another location inphotographs of the WTC. f&/<)C/NF)f \X)
in the company of hisorder to take
also stated that he(Urban Moving Systems) around 8:00am . Later,
arrived at workafter l I
toldabout the explosion at WTC,
Internet and went to the roo f of the buildingand take photographs. Then, and
looked on theto observe the WTC
friends (NFI) left theSometime between 10:00office and were caught in heavy traffic,
am and Noon and while attempting to return to their office, (pj)
bob7C
hehlC
wHMiHf^^WBiiHw
(S)
tA *
C
SEpK^T/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS3®bl
to anand his friends (NFI) stopped at a parking lot (adjacent.
apartment building) to take more photographs. fS^OC/NFiU, Jb7C
stated to one of the police officers after
his arrest that tne initial explosion occurred while he and the
others were on the West Side Highway (Route 9A in New York City)
traveling northbound toward the entrance of the Lincoln Tunnel,
later informed FBI-NK that he had arrived at work around8:20 am, and only learned of the crash into the WTC from a co-
got into aworker. andcompany van ( the one they had used to travel from theirresidences in I I NY to Weehawken, NJ) and traveled to a
nearby parking lot to observe the WTC and take photographs.
|and
| |were at the parking lot for
approximately 10 minutes, sometime between 8:30 am and 9:00 artu \
but returned to Urban Moving Systems before 9:00 am. 4*^OC/NF>)(A\y
Film obtained from the 35mm camera of one of
detainees was later developed and processed by FBI-NKphotos depict
[and[
theThe
] located at an
observation point later determined to be the parking lot adjacent
to the Doric Tower apartments located at 100 Manhattan Avenue in
Union City, NJ. The three (3) Israelis, sitting together on top
of a white van, are visiblv smiling on at least three (3) of the
photographs . 4&A)C/NF)/ \J^J
The photographs also revealed that all five (5)
Israelis later observed the WTC burning from a location on top of
. the roof of an Urban Moving Systems warehouse located adj acent to
the Urban Moving Systems office location described herein.4^0C/NF>f^^
At this point, more interviews were conducted to verify
the accuracy of their statements, as well as obtain anyadditional information concerning the video camera that was
allegedly used by the Israelis. One such interviewee, T-3,
beb7C
claimed to have seenafternoon prior to September II, 2UU1. According to T-3,
lin the Doric Towers on thebeb7C
rode the elevator with T-3 and another, unidentified,Spanish-speaking male whom T-3 observed exiting the elevator on
T-3 observed I lexitinq the elevator on Floor 9.
had identified himself, to the Spanish-speaking (jJ^pUfi/fFloor 3
Oddly,
•
(S)
(U)
(S)
(S)
cse>*£t/orcon/noforn
twin towers
3cobl
male, as a "construction worker" working in the building until7:00 pm that night. [Note: T-3 identified from a photolineup comprised only of the photographs of the five detainedDmpIsraelis-. ]ftt)
T-l, the source of the original information pertainingto the Israeli males, was re-interviewed at a later date. T-lconfirmed for interviewing agents that it was a video recordingdevice, rather than a still camera, that the Israelis had used in
filming the WTC from atop the van. In fact, T-l recalled quiteclearly that the camera was a small, hand-held unit, with a
Liquid Crystal Display (LCD) screen which folded out and could beused in "panning." WOC/NF)Mjl \
In the early phases of the investigation, several othercomplaints surfaced concerning trucks and/or vans belonging toUrban Moving Systems that had been sighted in locations ofsignificance with respect to the overall investigation of thehijacked flights on September 11, 2001. For instance, two (2)
complaints were received which indicated that Urban MovingSystems vehicles had been spotted in the greater Boston, MAmetropolitan area, one in Plymouth, MA and one in Nashua, NH.
Additionally, an Urban Moving Systems truck (traveling westbound)had been stopped on September 10, 2001, near Montoursville, PA.
At the time of the vehicle stop , the driver and passenger,
Nationals,and were identified as Israeli
Later, the same truck was stopped on September2001 while traveling eastbound toward New Jersey. ^L/OC/NF
On 09/17/01,
f
1 was interviewed and given
FBI Philadelphia noted that
I]
On OS/21/01,upon Newark 1 s seizure of documents obtained from the Penske true!
in whichconducted.
\_
1 was driving, a second interview of]statements to Philadelphia agents in
was
conjunction with evidence taken from the Penske truck lead agentsto believe that he most likely was truthful. Philadelphia^concluded that he most likely was not direeted|_
beb7C
b6b7C
blb6b7C
*#)
•
(S)
(S)
(S)
(S)
"S^^RET/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS
aii3^
bl
and did not have any priorknowledge of the attacks that occurred on 09/11/01.fbL^
On 09/17/01, a polygraph examination of|
A follow-up interview of I H on 09/21/01 was
bl
was
conducted along with a second polygraph which indicated he showedAgain, the Philadelphia agents opined that l I
blb6b7C
]and did not have any prior knowledge of the terrorist attacksthat occurred on 09/11/01 tyty(&)
Based primarily on the inconsistencies found in thestatements of the five (5) detained Israelis, and the interviewsconducted of.T-1 and other tenants of the Doric Towers|2J23-£tin£n±
|
s,QrBI-NK conducted polygraphs of \
Ion the issue of|
"land
[ Bothf
mTocIWJTW
arKT
blb6b7C
(S)
Based upon the aforementioneS facts, FBI-NK thenobtained a search warrant for a search of the offices of UrbanMoving Systems in Weehawken, NJ. The search, conducted onSeptember 13, 2001, rr)et with negative results concerning a videocamera . f^OC/NF)MA )
At this point in the PENTTBOM investigation, Agents ofFBI-NK' s Foreign Counterintelligence (FCI) squad were consulted
.^jLoj^JAe^jflrsJ:- . tijiLe_ci).ac„e.m ^__Based upon the _odd_ „circumstances surrounding
|
and I I denials anddeception over the alleged usage of a video camera the Israelis,
blheb7C
(S)
and the noticeably positive reaction de
detainees to the explosiom^at WTC, the70C/NF)
Qonatratftri bv tha Israeli
"T"
(U)-
1. Did the Israeli nationals have foreknowledge of theevents at WTC and were they filming the events prior toand in anticipation of the exploslon-?-------]^y0C/NF)
bl
(S)
tU)
iU)
(S)
IS)
•^5^T/0RC0N/N0F0RN
L- TWIN TOWERS3&>
bl
revealed two references to aTnrh-irh further identified
^^OC/NF)
bornas an
Based on information provided by the Miami Division,Newark initially detained and interviewed four (4) employees ofClassic International Movers, a New Jersey-based moving companywhich was believed by Miami to have been utilized as a mover byone of the nineteen (19) alleged hijackers involved in theterrorist attacks. All four detained employees, were identifiedas Israeli nationals, who had andrecently entered the U.S. from various locations in SouthAmerica
«
MOC/NF)
One of themvisibly disturbed by thi
born wase Agents questioning regarding his
personal e-mail account.
I
Of note is that the telephone number torMovers also appeared in one of the
(5) IsraelisClassic internationalaforementioned notebooks seized from the fivealready held in detention by FBI-NK. #/OC/NF)
[
FBI-NK then conducted polygraphs of
] to determine whether either possessed priorknowledge of the attack on the WTC. Not surprisingly, [~~
and
who was not even present when the initial photographs were takenfrom the apartment parking lot,was present in the parking lot,
K/OC/NF)*:
who
then attempted to determine,\$Q;iess interview statements, the statements made/r>y\
The!
based upon wit
the detainees themselves, and by other independent investigation,
bob7C
blb6b7C
bob7C
blb6b7C
whetherapartmerlt parking I6t V&fl.
at the WTC. *&ADC/NF)"Tarred
and could have been at thegs pAint prior to the first explosion
FBI-NK obtained witness statements and a gasolinereceipt from the Gulf service station where the Israelis hadpurchased gasoline on September 11. Investigation determinedthat the Israelis purchased gasoline at approximately 2:14 pm, (y^\
12
(S)
(U)
tSEJ^T/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS
D$}"
which was subsequently corroborated by reviewing the photographstaken by the Israelis (themselves) that day. One such photograph b6
depicts|
|using a squeegee to clean the windows of an UrbanMoving Systems vehicle. Because the picture is chronologicallyone of the last taken that day, the gasoline had to have beenpurchased after the attack on the WTC. (-S^oe/NfHtl 1
A review of EZ-Pass records provided little by way ofdetermining the exact location of the Israeli's vehicle (whitevan) during the actual time of the attack. According to EZ-Pass
,
the Urban Moving Systems van used by the Israelis to travel fromBrooklyn, NY (location of their residences) to Weehawken, NJ onthe morning of September 11, 2001 passed through the Brooklyn, NYentrance to the Brooklyn-Battery Tunnel at 7:48 am. ffttoC/NF/(^\
FBI-NK obtained the videotape of a local newshelicopter crew which provided footage of the explosion beginningjust minutes after the initial impact of the aircraft into theNorth Tower (Tower #1) of the WTC. A comparison of thisvideotape with the still photographs taken by the Israelisimplied that the Israelis photographs were taken closer in timeto the explosion of Tower #2 (South Tower) than to the initialimpact into Tower #1. This comparison, albeit non-scientific,corroborated the three Israelis 1 claim that they departed UrbanMoving Systems for the parking lot observation point afterhearing of the initial explosion. (lA)
Liaison with the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA)
.resulted^.in FBI-NK obtaining a duplicate record of the __„_„_metropolitan New York Air Traffic Control radar traffic recordsfor the morning of September 11, 2001. By way of background, oneof the earliest photographs taken by the Israelis from theparking lot observation point shows what is believed to be a
local news helicopter hovering over the Hudson River between theparking lot and the WTC (this helicopter appeared in theforeground of the third photograph" taken) . The FAA ! s radartraffic records identify a helicopter, belonging to a local radiostation AM 880, slowly traveling in a southerly direction downthe Hudson River and then hovering from 8:50 am until 9:03 am,
(the time of the crash into Tower #2), between Union City and theWTC on the morning of September 11. Although the results of^ thisanalysis verified that the Israelis were at the parking lot
13
b7C
(S)
i« M * •»<* *
rS50RPT/ORCON/NOFOEN
- TWIN TOWERS
:te>bl
(U>
observation point between^ 8 ^5a precise time.* 4S^QC/NE<
9:03 am, it did not provide
According to T-l, it was the call from T-2, who is T-l ! s neighbor and close friend, which initially prompted T-l tolook out of the window towards the WTC. It was at that time thatT-l had also observed the Israelis atop the white van. Since T-lbelieved that T-2 !
s call came immediately after the firstexplosion at the WTC, FBI-NK attempted to obtain the toll recordsof T-2's residential telphone with a view toward determining theexact time of T-2 ' s call. Unfortunately, electronic records oflocal calls such as that are not maintained by the localtelephone service provider; thus, no electronic "time stamp"verifying T-A !
s observation of the Israelis could be obtained.(A*0C/N-F)/a)
at Urban MovingAn interview of T-5,Systems, revealed that upon "clocking in" at work at 8:58 am onthe morning of September 11, 2001, T-5 had observed
and
beb7C
in the local dispatch area of thewas alsocompany. I was 6ft the Internet,
present. unrortunately, a second interview of T-5 was notconducted with the intent of verifying T-5's earlier statements,Instead, the interview produced only additional background onUrban Moving Systems. feoC/NF)f\Aj
to 3
*b6
b7C
Ihad advisedled I
FBI-NK in a
while travelingfrom the office location to the parking lot ' observation point(100 Manhattan Avenue, Doric Towers), to inform him of their
and the others) having left the office. Q ] authorizedtheir departure and noted that he himself was' on his way to theoffice and expected to arrive there within a minute
thus,may, corroborate statements with respectto the approximate time when they were at the parking lot4£/OC/1*F)'/Li *
Q»14
(S)
(S)
(S)
** V f f •I). 4
z
SEfc&T/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS•]&;
bl
On Wednesday, September 21, 2001, all five (5) of theIsraelis were re-interviewed by FBI-NK and FBI-NYO agents with
I
Two (2) of the five (5) Israelis were polygraphed withrespect to prior knowledge of the
-
attack on the WTC. Both I I
land| |
who had
(excluding were give2fc'our^jja) or tne rive p) Israelis
blb6b7C
C/NF)
advised that in past conversation with[
|had informed him of having been the
actvisecTT "Ithat f
naa aisob6b7C
up interrogation ofbroke-down and stated that
(Uy^ZocTNF) During a "followolvaraph examiner,!
J
tc<
bv the polygraph examiner, \
<0
York ofFollow-up interviews by Special Agents from FBI New
revealed no new significant facts KAA
b6b7C
and
15
(S|
tf * ') t %EOTETSECjpET/ORCON/NOFORN
- TWIN TOWERS
3S)bl
relative to the issue s under investigation by Newark. Bothandl I statements were consistent with those maaein previous interviews. (Ct)
In a letter dated 9/25/P1, from Newark Special Agent inCharge to U.S.Immigration and Naturalization Service, 970 Broad Street, Newark,NJ, Newark advised the FBI no longer had any investigativeinterests in the five (5) detainees. Newark further advised inthis letter to INS to proceed with the appropriate immigrationproceedings, fti^
On or about 11/20/2001, all five (5) of the IsraeliNationals held in detention under authority of the United StatesImmigration and Naturalization Service (INS) were served a
deportation order, then discharged from the INS detentionfacility in Brooklyn, New York, and escorted by INS personnel to
J.F.K. International Airport for a flight to Tel Aviv, Israel, (cc)
On 07/10/2003 Newark investigation was completed andclosed, ((a)
heb7C
b6b7C
U*
(Rev. 01-31-2003) *>— -*>-
DATE: 09-10-2010 1
FBI INFO-
CLA5SIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
REASON: 1-4 (b,c,d)
DECLASSIFY 01: 09-10-2035
•S|^ffiCET/ORCON/NOFORN
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT
IfflEKE SHOOT OTHERWISE
Precedence : ROUTINE Date: 07/10/2003
:Ujc
»LU;
To : Counterintelligence
New York
Attn: CD-2C
is!JLU; New Haven
From: Newark/ C-9
*J0vContact:
Approved By :
J_
SA
Attn:
Attn:
>sed)osed)osed)osed)osed)osed)(Closed)
osed)nding)
SEKRET/ORCON/NOFORN
V-
ucTSSA"IOSISOI-2SSSA
)
1
SAlSASA
| |
1-2^SSAIRSSquc
1
id b
SSA
bob7C
bl
^ SfefZ^T/ORCON/NOFORN^v
% i
To: Counterintelligence From: NewarkI 07/10/2003Re: (S)
bl
:is: \Jfe).igation.
Synopsis : \JJf) To advise CD-2C of final results ofinvestigation.
(U) Full Field Investigation Instituted: 09/14/2001
Administrative: (U^ Upon dissemination of this communication,all outstanding leads set for CD-2C and the Laboratory Divisionshall be discontinued by Newark in ACS.
1\>W\^*W©e/NF> For purposes of the enclosed LetterheadMemorandmu (LHM) , the following symbols were utilized:
i V^S^OC/NF)' T-3
WOC/NF) *T-1
(Ǥ^OC/NF*PT-2
is
is
is
b6b7C
^T&&)C/NF) T-4 is
i vAw^eeZ-NF)- T-5 is
Referral /Consult
3hehlC
Details: (S/OC/NF) Newark provides the closing investigativememorandum relative to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
,
Newark Division, Full Field investigation initiated September 14,2001, surrounding circumstances indicating that five (5) IsraeliNationals identified as I I
2and detained in conjunction
hehie
with the PENTTBOMB, MAJOR CASE 182, investigation, had videotapedthe 9/11/01, terrorist attack on the Twin Towers and may havepossessed foreknowledge of the same.
vftsubs
(^OC/NF-) Newark investigation found no factual orsubstantive circumstantial information to corroborate eyewitnessaccounts the five (5) Israeli Nationals "videotaped" the attackson the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center. Investigation didfind that still photographs were taken of the attack by theseindividuals with a 35 mm camera found in their possession.
\yS J-^OC/NF) Newark investigation found no factual orsubstantive circumstantial information to indicate the five (5)
Israeli Nationals were on top of a parking garage "videotaping"prior to first hijacked aircraft striking tower #2 of the World
SEh^T/ORCON/NOFORN
•To:Re:
SEGMIT/ORCON/NOFORN
Counterintellj np.nr.p From: Newark(S)
3107/10/2003 bl
&
Trade Center. Numerous circumstantial facts strongly support thefive (5) individuals statements they traveled to the roof of theparking garage after learning of the attacks from radiobroadcasts and Internet news sites. None of the picturesdeveloped from the film found inside the 35 mm camera depictedthe twin towers prior to the attack.
(ji^)(/OC/NF') Physical evidence found in the possession of thefive (5) Israeli Nationals in conjunction with statements made by
^J;hem 'during numerous interviews indicates that|
(U)
(S)
(S)
IS
bv thei"111 SpeciiicallvTI 1 admitted to oemg employed"
by the|
advised during 'an additional interview he was selected
1 torT .graft I . Hp. artvi .gprt \
Iworkinq outside the country ot
[Statements bybut also revealed tha
associatesmay have also
been stationed in other countries as well. ^NewarTT'sinvestigation found no factual evidence to suggest that I I
was operating in an overt or covert capacity inside theUnited States for the "Jewish Agency" . Furthermore , Newark foundno basis to even remotely suggestpossession of prior knowledge.World Trade Center of 9/11/01
was in thelating to the attacks on the
However, Newark's investigation round normng suggestacted in such a capacity while in the United Statesevidence as well asfnysicai
of the FBI corroborated Newark's belief that [
1 statements to Special Ag^hts'
] was
suggest that f
loffered no information to"
1 was an I
:
l
(
Newark found no basis to suggestwas in possession of or had any prior knowledge relating to theattacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01.
3
J^OC/NF) Physical evidence along with statements byrevealed an a s sociation between
sfe^EGT/ORCON/NOFORN
blb6b7C
blbob7C
blb6b7C
• S^5«^T/0RC0N/N0F0RN
To : ConntftH n1-.<=>1 1 i ggnr-.p-
Re: (S)
(S)
^
(S)
(S)
htM_
From: Newark07/10/2003
bl
J More specifically, never fully revealed to thesatisfaction of interviewing agents, how hand written telephonenumber? found in hi? p?£?Qnal notebook just happened to be
In lite of the
blb6b7C
seriousness ot Newark's investigation, and considering thetotality of mounting circumstantial evidence indicating eitherdirect or indirect links between the Five (5) Israeli Nationals
Newark found no basis to suggest
to|was in possession 61 or had any prior knowledge relating
THe attacks on the World Trade Center of 9/11/01.
(i> (S/QCtoF) - [ 1 was atindividuals, but
first the leastlater gave a fullcooperative of the Five (5)
accounting of his travel and activities while in the UnitedStates. Information provided bv l [
corroborated statementsmade by his associates, further strengthening the position therewas no video camera used on the roof top of parking garage tomake recordings just prior or during the attacks on the TwinTowers of the World Trade Center.
bob7C
A note pad belonging to containedInvestigation revealed the overseas
telephone number [ |was coincidentally subscribed to
by an individual in South America with authentic ties to Islamicmilitants in the middle east
f~
This number was later identifybelonging to a_ friend of
|
The second telephone number once authenticateddollars ($20was accordin:
[ecf as a legitimate oanK accountwho lent him two hundred
blbob7C
FBI New York, associated with an
belonged to an individual named1 advised this phone number
a hashish dealer in theNew Yor Physical evidence as well as statements by
Hmetro areaand the other four (4) individuals confirmed
[
recreational drug use of mostly marijuana. Newark believesaffiliation with individuals found
the purchase of small quantities of illegal drugs. Newarkinvestigation ruled out a nexus between |
land the
wass
for
SEOraiT/ORCON/NOFORN
• SEjQKET/ORCON/NOFORN
ToRe,
Counterintelligence From: Newark'(S) I
[07/10/2003 bl
&1
(S)
(U)
dividual in South America, along with circumstantial ties tothe individuals connected to FBI New York T s
No articulate facts were found to demonstraternar
||was in possession of or had any prior
knowledge relating to the attacks on 'the World Trade Center of9/11/01.
(vrt(«Sr/0C/NF) Newark 1 s inquiry into[ ] concentratedon ifis travel in the United States, along with his use of a
German passport he legally acquired from the German Embassy inIsrael. Statements by
| [corroborated information providedby his associates, and further strengthened the facts supportingthe position there was no video camera used on the roof top ofparking garage to make recordings just prior or during theattacks on the World Trade Center. Newark found no basis tosuggest
| |was in possession of or had any prior
knowledge relating to the attacks on the World Trade Center of9/11/01.
JA^/fS^OC/NF)Squad 1-21 of
Follow-up interviews by SA's from FBI New York's]revealed no new significant
issues unaer investigation by Newark. Bothand
facts relative to theI I and [statements were consistent with thosethey made in previous interviews.
fWWOC/NF) In a letter dated 9/25/ 01, from Newark SAC to||
I IU.S. Immigration and
Naturalization Service, 970 Broad Street, Newark, NJ, Newarkadvised the' FBI no longer had any investigative interests in thefive (5) detainees. Newark further advised in this letter- to INSt-n nmpppH wi j-h j-h^ pp^-rnpri ^t-^ immigration proceedings.
\
7\.iVjlf-gyoc/NF) On or about: 11/20/2001, all five (5) of theIsraeli Nationals held in detention under authority of the UnitedStates Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) were served a
deportation order, then discharged from the INS detentionfacility in Brooklyn, New York, and escorted by INS personnel toJ.F.K^ International Airport for a flight to Tel Aviv, Israel.
(pC/NF) In April of 2002 an in-depth analytical inquiryw^s initiated by personnel from FBIHQ and other members of theU.S. Intelligence Community who physically traveled to Newark toreview this case file. Newark was advised the purpose of theinquiry was to determine if a nexus, if any existed between thefive (5) Israeli Nationals under investigation by Newark to other
S^e^BT/ORCON/NOFOKN
5
heb7C
blbob7C
8 m• ' ^ ^g^T/ORCON/NOFOEN ^
To: Counterintelligence— From: NewarkRe : _(S) 07/10/2003 bl
»0Israeli Nationals fitting a similar "profile" some of whom werealso held in INS detention around the time of 9/11/01, Theanalytical inquiry further attempted to determine if these five(5) individuals were possibly part of clandestine humanintelligence collection network. Newark notes that the findingsof FBIHQ's analytical inquiry are not complete at the, time of blof FBIHQ's analytical inquiry are not complete at tne. time orthis writing. Newark suggests FBIHQ f s investigating x [
(5)[fee the repository for any futtner QgKj
investigative iinamas'relative to suspicious activities oP^^investigative nnaings^relative to suspicious activitiesIsraeli Nationals not specifically related to Newark's inquiry.
(U) Investigation at the Newark is complete.
SBdRET/ORCON/NOFORN
6
• ^T/ORCON/NOFORN wTo: Con nt-fiH ntp.1 1 i ^n^^u Ev™n» NewarkRe: (Sf
I07/10/2003
hi
LEAD(s) :
Set Lead 1: (Info)
ALL RECEIVING OFFICES
(U) Disseminate information contained herein toappropriate individuals within your office.
SECJ^T/ORCON/NOFORN
7
"X
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
jDATE: 09-09-2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
REASON: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY 01: 09-09-2035
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HIKE IN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT
WHERE SHOWN OTHERWISE
T
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence : ROUTINE
To: Newark
From: NewarkSquad C-9Contact : S
A
**
Date: 02/10/2004
bob7C
(S)
Approved By,
Drafted By:
Case ID #: (S)
Title
:
(S)
4L fyl p^A .^4(Closed)
TMTN TOWF.RS
bl U(S)
Synopsis:\%^ To reopen and reassign subject case
U> 4!
(U) Full Field Investigation Instituted: 09/14/2001
Detait (U) ranH nnfiri case needs to be reopened and reassignedJ:o facilitate evidence tracking. Sa[
the previous case agent, has been reassigned to HQ.
b6b7C
ALITIfffORMATIOMCOPHEREIN ISUSC^eSlElED EXCEPTWUERE#fCWi\I OTHOT
f/O
® bl
To: Newa,Re: (S)
j± From; Newa
aSECRET
02/10/2004
fbl
LEAD(s) :
Set Lead 1: (Action)
NEWARK
AT NEWARK, NJ
(U) Reopen subject case.Close subject case.
Reassign case to SA bob7C
(Rev. 01-3 1-2003)
DATE: 09-03-20
CLASSIFIED BYREASON: 1.4 (c
DECLASSIFY 01»|322LP/PLJ/CC
09-09-2035 *ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOWN OTHERWISE
Sg^RET/NOFORN
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
(S)
(S)
(S)
(S)
(S)
ROUTINE
NewarkSquad CContac
Approved By
Drafted By:
Case ID #:>£fff
Date: 04/14/2004
Attn: Evidence Control Center
beb7C
>n of e
bl
Synopsis :\J^ \^f) To provide semi-anual justification forretention of evidence when case is closed.
»»-
Details: l&f The evidence related to the above-listedinvestigation was determined to be of no value to thePENTTBOMB investigation, but was found to be worthy of a CIinvestigation . Newark ' s^CI inquiry TWIN TOWERS was closed inJuly of 03, however F-B-I-HQ--1 s \
is st ill pending. Newark is awaiting a summary of]
I I to assist us in determining the final disposition or ^Tevidence retained by Newark.
bl
ALL INFOHEREIN IS UNWHERE S
INEDEXCEPTBE.
SE&RET/NOFORN
F/6bl
fe)
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
DATE: 09-10-2010
FBI ICTF0-
CLASSIFIED BY UC6"
REASOCT: 1-4 [b,c,d
DEC LASS IFY 01:
ffiLP/PLJ/CC
ALL INFORMATION COHTAIHED
HEBE IN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE
,ET
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence : ROUTINE
To : Counterterrorism
New York
PhiladelphiaSt. LouisSan Francisco
Date: 04/30/2004
Attn: ITOS 1/ CONUS 1/ Team 3
SSAosT
1
1
be
Attn: ECAU, Room 4944 hlC
Attn: SSAAttn: SSA
SSAAttn: SSAAttn: SSA IT Pakistan SquadAttn: SSA IT Pakistan
g: From: NewarkGMRA2Contact: IA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
beb7C
Case ID #: [II)
(»)
(S) («)
03)
315B-NK-C86934315N-NK-C98832
(U) Title*
(UJ lEDA I
(Pending)(Pending)ending)
315B-NK-102595-EL6J
IT-PAKISTAN
IT UBL/AL QAEDA
(Pending)
(U) Synopsis:1 SS"1 SSAN:
Threat assessment:unknown and f
w www . ant iwar .com.] DOB:
iasad==Fa?©:B
Be^3?a^^^fF^Srr
<u * Administrative: Yg^ This document contains information obtainedunder the authority of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act(FISA) , 50 U.S.C., Section 1801. Such FISA derived informationshall not be used in any criminal proceeding, including grand
SECRET
%^^ \REASON: 1.4
BE
DATE:.
bl
Sfe^ET
To: Counj^erterrorism From: Newark(U)---Re-: ^^ 315B-BK-CS6934:7
m^^/^0/2004:
jury proceedings and warrant affidavits, without the expresswritten approval of the Attorney General of the United States.FISA derived information concerning any U.S. Person may not bedisseminated to a foreign government without prior AttorneyGeneral approval.
(U) Enclosure (s): ""jftQ There are eleven enclosures attached to thisassessment. They are as follows: (1) an untitled Excelspreadsheet, 22 pages, dated 10/03/2001; (2) a copy of adocument written in Italian with the 22 page FBI Suspect List,dated 05/22/2 002; (3) a Lexis Nexis business summary onantiwar.com; (4) five news articles downloaded from Lexis Nexis;(5) three Internet postings.
(U) Details: J^S^An electronic communication from theCounterterrorism, NTCS/TWWU to all field offices, dated03/24/2004, advised that the post-9/11 "watch list," "ProjectLookout," was posted on the Internet and may contain the names ofindividuals of active" investigative interest. Different versionsof these lists may be found on the Internet. This assessment wasconducted on the findings discovered on www. antiwar. com.
(U) ^Sk^ While conducting research on the Internet, anuntitled spreadsheet, dated 10/03/2001, was discovered on websitewww . antiwar . com under antiwar.com/justin/finnlist.pdf. Thisspreadsheet contained names, DOBs, SSANs, addresses and othercolumns. The last column labeled as ID contained numbers which
1On 10/03/2001, information was disseminated to all field officesby the Counterterrorism Unit as Priority on Information ControlForms (ICF) The names contained on this untitled Excelspreadsheet!
r(U)-~ "H&KT?he antiwar.com website describes itself as a
sounding Koam of interest to all who are concerned about U.S.foreign policy and its implications. It also states thatantiwar.com has become the Internet newspaper of records for agrowing international movement, the central locus of oppositionto a new imperialism that masks its ambitions in the rhetoric ofhuman rights, humanitarianism, freedom from terror and globaldemocracy. It also describes itself as a non-profit group thatsurvives on generous contributions from its readers. TheManaging Editor is listed as Eric Garris, and the EditorialDirector is listed as Justin Raimondo.
heb7Cb7E
ET
§fee^iiT
(U)To:Re-
counterterrorism From: Newark
^ajT^A search of the Universal Index (UNI) revealed
b6b7C
tr
(U)
(U)
x A search of UNI for www.antiwar.com was negative,
A scan ofnumerous documents forantiwar.com.
the Electronic Case File (ECF) revealedand
b7A
>^J File 65T-HQ-1427774 serial 26, dated 04/14/2004,from the Counterintelligence Unit CD-4E/11869 to the WashingtonField Office furnished Waslii.nqt-.on Fiftlci with information receivedby the| I
S^ftRET
3
Referral /Consult
(U)
To:Re ;
Counterterrorism F:
.--J^V315B-NK-C86934?£pm : Newarkl7] 04/30/2004
Referral/Consult
(S)
(U)
(S)
(S)
(S)
(U)
(U)
(U)
bl
fef File 315M-SL-188252 serial 152 , dated 11/17/2003 ,
that he was in possession of adocument which was written in Italian. This document specifiedthat
|Iwas a suspect on an FBI list. The
document containedand two previous arjflrfiflRfiss'.j
social security number , date of birth]was listed as
This document canon a list dated 05/22/2002be round at www.antiwar.com/iustin/CI--08-02.pdf.
File 315N-SL-188252 serial 176, dated 12/27/2003,is a LHM for
i
This serial also restated theinformation contained in serial 152 regarding the document foundon www . ant iwar . com
.
X Filewrote a pagedated 05/21/2002, indicated that
length article reporting on the magnitude and"^alue of Americanmilitary and economic assistance to Israel.
| |reported in
detail^ on all types of assistance to Israel citing one of hissources" of information as www . antiwar . com
.
File dated11/13/2002^, regarded a peaceful protest at the main gate of RAFFairford, UK, on 11/09/2002. The protesters handed out severalarticles during the protest. One article referred to suspectedIsraeli spies being held by U.S. authorities since the terroristattacks in the U.S. The article was from an Internet web page,dated 12/12/2001, entitled "Suspected Israeli Spies Held by U.S."An insert at the bottom of the page provided a website,www . ant iwar . com
,
where more information could be obtained on thesuspected Israeli spies.
----{)^File 100A-PG-67150-302 serial 970, dated10/03/2002, indicated that during a Western Regional Conferenceof the National Alliance Sacramento Unit (NASU) , a member
ET
bl
bl
bob7Ab7C
b7A
ssefREa
To: Counterterrorism From: Newark(U) -------—^^
;xnju
discussed a website, antiwar.com. This individual told NASUmembers to educate themselves about the Middle East conflict.
W ^>S^ File 174A-LA-234485 serial 55, dated 11/10/2003,indicated that on 10/27/2003, a special agent reviewed thecomputer hard drives seized during the investigation of I"
_
Thereview of two hard drives revealed visits to many websitesbetween 07/25/2002 and 06/15/2003. One of the websites listedwas antiwar.com.
b6b7C
1 dated 02/05/2003.
(U)~~-^yS) There are four FISA derived references located at
Newark. They are 315B-NK-102595-EL6 serials 65, 71, 72 and 80.
b6b7Ab7C
Jo 7A
to 6
b7Cb7E
b6b7C
b6b7C
(U)
To:Re;
Counterterrorism From: Newark-"^T315B-NK-C869347704/30/2004
beb7C
(U)
(U)
mi-
4KT
j^n
**$&$' A search of Dun and Bradstreet (D&B) revealed that
hehieb7E
hehlCb7E
b6b7C
(U)
(U)
iU)
(U)
One business summary was located on D&B listed toAntiwww Co"". , ^0 Box 575, Big Sur, CA 93920, with no furtherinformation available.
^<^A search of Lexis Nexis for antiwar.com revealed aCalifornia fictitious business name for 'antiwar.com, 851 BurlwayRd., #202, Burlingame, CA 94010. The filing date was 10/23/2000The business HpffpHnhinn was 1-i.cihf=>rj ag ^r]^^T-1--i sina-r.nmnnfftr witha contact name of
contact YMOepfrojsearch of telephone number the
listed to
negative on
I
ipJlone number posted on www.antiwar.com, isat I I This telephone number was
negative.^SJ^ A search of
.bo
b7C
b6b7Cb7E
for was .bo
b7Cb7E
SEpKET
6
To: Counterterrorism From: Newark(U) Re: ------
,
^^[315B-NK-C869347l04/3 0/2004
(U) y&f A search of Lexis Nexis forrevealed \_
(U) -&.
(U)
S)/ A DMV (CA) search for
A CCH search for
($) A D&B search for
(/S\) A|
S\ A
in Lexi
was negative,
search for
search for
was negative,
was negative.
was negative.
was negative.
A search of the News and Business Section locateds revealed numerous articles regarding
and www . ant iwar . com
.
Six articles were selectedtor inclusion in this assessment.
beb7C
b6b7Cb7E
b6b7C
Jo 6
b7Cb7E
.b6
b7C
b6b7C
(U)
To:Re:
j>fe^IJET
Newark.counterterrorism Egopi: JMewarK>g< r315B-NK-C869347jD4/30/2004
heb7C
I W J&f There are numerous websites that comment on theposting found on www . ant iwar .com. Many individuals harshlycritize Eric Garris and Justin Raimondo for their views. Threepostings were selected to be included in this assessment.
$.$j#f On the Pravada website was posted an article byJustin Raimondo, "Did Al Qaeda shoot recently released footage of9/11 WTC attack or was it someone else?"
\^T' i^f On www . i dl -ny . org , a harsh critizism ofwww.anti.com was posted that included photographs of Eric Garrisand Justin Raimondo.
(&7 On www . chroniclesmagazine . org
,
an article by JustinRaimondo, ^Chronicles Intelligence Assessment - The TerrorEnigma: Israel and the September 11 Connection," outlined theactivities of the Mossad. It also included information obtainedfrom a story in the Bergen Record dated 09/12/2 002 regarding agroup of Israelis detained by FBI, Ifewfirk, for possibleinvolvement in the events of 9/11. Y(An active investigation wasconducted on the five Israeli Nationals. For a deta;L!).ed reportof this investigation see
bl
(ANALYST COMMENTS: The rights of individuals to post informationand to express personal views on the Internet should be honoredand protected; however, some material that is circulated on theInternet can compromise current active FBI investigations. Thediscovery of two detailed Excel spreadsheets posted onwww . ant iwar . com may not be significant by itself sincedistribution of the information on such lists are wide spread.Many agencies outside of law enforcement have been utilizing thisinformation to screen their employees. Still, it is unclearwhether www . ant iwar . com may only be posting research materialcompiled from mutiple sources or if there is material posted thatis singular in nature and not suitable for public release. There
SP^RET
Counterterrorism From: Newark315B-NK-C869347) 04/30/2004
are several unanswered questions regarding www . ant iwar . com
.
Itdescribes itself as a non-profit group that survives on generouscontributions from its readers. Who are these contributors andwhat are the funds utilized for? I I
Ic
~~1on www.antiwar.com7 If this
is so, then what is his true name? Two facts have beenestablished by this assessment. Many individuals worldwide doview this website including individuals who are currently underinvestigation and|
beb7C
L
"l * I
sJjS^ET
(U)
To: Coujitgrterrorism From: NewarkRe: C^f V315B-NK-C869347n04/3 0/2 004
Set Lead 1: (Discretionary)
COUNTERTERRORISM
<u>
AT AT WASHINGTON, DC
"'''''"'"''"
>J*V It: ^ s recommended that ECAU further monitor thepostinqs on website www.antiwar.com.
Set Lead 2: (Action)
SAN FRANCISCO
AT AT SAN FRANCISCO, CA. b6Jo7C
(U)--------v-;--- ^§X It is recommended that a PI be opened to determine
\u
i
if are engaging m, orhave engaged in, activities which constitute a threat to NationalSecurity on behalf of a foreign power.
Set Lead 3: (Info)
ALL RECEIVING OFFICES
^410
DATE: 09-10-2010"* FBI INFO.
(Rev. 01-31-2003) CLASSIFIED BY UC^
REASON: 1.4 (b,c,c
DECLASSIFY 01: 09-10-2035:,^T
2LP/PLJ /tc!uii
secret
ALL IIFOEEATIOI COHTAIHED
HERE II IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence : ROUTINE
To : Counterterrorism
Mew York
PhiladelphiaSt. LouisSan Francisco
Attn:
AttnAttnAttn
AttnAttnAttn
Date: 04/30/2004
ITOS 1/ CONUS 1/ Teapi 3SSA
SSA IT Pakistan SquadSSA IT Pakistan
From: NewarkGMRA2Contact: IA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: (is)
. 00(S) -~-M^>
(UK.. (£;)
315B-NK-C86934315N-NK-C98832
31bB-l\IK-lU2byh
.58!
(U)
Title:
(U)
•^ \ IT-PAKISTAN
(><( | IT UBL/AL QAEDA
b6b7C
(Pending) ~<2~?0
(Pending) r U(H~
(S)
Pending) -T
(Pending) -x
$05
bl
Synopsis: L Threat assessment:[
I SSAN: unknown andI
SSAN:
\>
I DOB;DOB:
www. antiwar. com.b6b7C
(U) Administrative: j^f This document contains information obtainedunder the authorixy^of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act(PISA), 50 TJ.S.C, Section 1801. Such FISA derived informationshall not be used in any criminal proceeding, including grand
$Bp%&T
3-': >WLA. ' " DSlEJBjiclassifie:
REASgSCLASSIFYON:
b6b7C
AForums - Shock Video: Who Shot Ne^9/1 1 Tapes? http ://engfomm.ij||/da.ru/showthread.php3?s=&tlireadi
.
\
PRflUDflLogin with username and password:
Login! |
9
All times are GMT. The time now Is 06:57 PM. ^MP5**3^ Iggsgg&l lr'ggfftBSm.1 WEfflflar l InTTgrTpTfrn^ fcggKjy ;l Utes&M fcffinrmsg
gfl Forums > News section > Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11 Tapes?
4 Last Thread Next Thread
ThreadAuthor
NewsLynkReporter
Registered: Dec 2003Location: The matrixPosts: 819
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINSHEREIN^NCLASSIFJEO
WP
Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11 Tapes?
SHOCK VIDEO: WHO SHOT NEW 9/11 TAPES?Did Al Qaeda shoot recently released footage of 9/11 WTC attackv or was it someone else?
by Justin Raimondo
I shivered, a little, as I watched Lisa Meyers' report on NBC theother night:
http://www, msnbc.com/news/1001433.asp?0cv=CB10
"New and threatening messages have been received from Al
Qaeda. There's a videotape aimed at American and Saudi Arabianrulers and another that includes what appears to bewell-produced footage of the 9/11 attacks v raising still otherquestions."
This new 9/11 footage sure does raise a lot of other questions,first and foremost: who shot the video? It was posted on what is
described as "a known Al-Qaeda website" last Wednesday,although it was taken down after a few days. Aside from theusual militaristic gymnastics by jihadi commandos, Meyersreports:
"The tape also contains what U.S. counterterror experts say maybe never-before-broadcast video of the Sept. 11, 2001, attackson New York's World Trade Center shot from across the EastRiver in Brooklyn. The FBI says it is familiar with the video, whichwas provided by a friendly bystander. But that raises the questionv how did a tape that was not widely circulated end up on aknown Al Qaeda site?"
It's sinister to contemplate. Video believed to have been in U.S.government hands somehow pops up on a website alleged to bean Al Qaeda mouthpiece, and U.S. government officials hold it upas a reason to cower in fear before the threat of another majorterrorist attack on American soil. Meanwhile, the President aversthat Iraq is the central arena in his "war on terrorism," and his
supporters claim that we're battling them in the streets ofBaghdad so we don't have to fight them in the streets of Boise vor whatever alliterative cliche first comes to mind.http: //www,weeklvstandard.com/Conte... 03/425kcolb.asp
The idea that Al Qaeda had additional agents in the area, whoknew the attack was coming, would certainly explain the
lof74/26/2004 2:03 PM
Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot Ne^9/1 1 Tapes? http://engforum^vda.ru/showthread.phP3?s=&threadi..
unflinching steadiness of the camera's eye as it recorded theterror of that moment. But instead of inventing additionalelements and players, it's always best to stick with what wealready know. So who else just happened to be videotaping theWorld Trade Center attack that day?
Hours after the terrorists struck, five people were arrested in NewJersey as they taped the WTC from their vantage point across theHudson River in New Jersey. A witness identified only as "Maria"by ABC News said she saw:http://www.haaretzdaily.com/hasen/p. )tsID=0&listSrc=Yhttp://abcnews.qo.com/sections/2Q20. ..van 020621.html
"Three young men kneeling on the roof of a white van in theparking lot of her apartment building. 'They seemed to be takinga movie/ Maria said. The men were taking video or photos ofthemselves with the World Trade Center burning in thebackground, she said.
"What struck Maria were the expressions on the men's faces.'They were like happy, you know - They didn't look shocked tome, I thought it was very strange,' she said."
Even stranger v it turned out the five were Israelis. When lawenforcement swooped down on this crew, they found them in
possession of $4,700 in cash, box cutters, and multiple foreignpassports. Police dogs reacted as if the presence of explosiveswas indicated, and, as the Bergen County Record reported:http://www.forward.com/issues/2002/02.03.15/news2.html
"Sources close to the investigation said they found other evidencelinking the men to the bombing plot. 'There are maps of the cityin the car with certain places highlighted/ the source said. 'It
looked like they're hooked in with this. It looked like they knewwhat was going to happen when they were at Liberty StatePark.'"
These guys were held for three months, much of the time in
solitary confinement, and extensively interrogated. One refusedto take a lie detector test for weeks, and then failed it All fivehad been in the employ of Urban Moving Systems, ofWeehawken, New Jersey, the company name on their van'sregistration.
Police raided the Urban Moving Systems warehouse 48 hourslater, and carted away a lot of computer hard drives and othermaterials. The owner, one Dominik Suter, fled to Israel the nextday. A few months later, Suter's name turned up on a list ofterrorist suspects circulated by the FBI to European financialinstitutions.
http://www.antiwar.com/iustin/CI-Q8-02.pdf
The apprehended Israelis claimed that they were merely"documenting" the day's events: police confiscated theirphotographic equipment, and whatever film they had taken. The
2 of 74/26/2004 2:03 PM
Forums - Shock Video: Who ShotNj|9/l 1 Tapes? http://e^^
new film shows the World Trade Center burning from theBrooklyn side of the East River, while the Urban Movers werefilming from the vantage point of Liberty State Park, across theHudson River in New Jersey. But whomever had foreknowledge ofthe attack on the World Trade Center could have taken that film vand Al Qaeda operatives are not the only possible suspects.
I have written at length about the five arrested Israelis in my newbook, The Terror Enigma: 9/11 and the Israeli Connection, and I
commend the attention of my readers to this modest little volumeif they want to know more. I bring this up, not merely to plug mybook, but to point out that we can't begin to understand thestrange expropriation of this previously unknown footage outsidethe context provided by The Terror Enigma.http://www .iuniverse.com/bookstore/.. .suadz b6J9qGKNA
As I prove in my book, Al Qaeda did not carry out its plans for amajor terrorist attack entirely undetected. The Israelis were hoton the trail of the 9/11 hijackers, and must have had someforeknowledge of what happened that fateful day.http://irag-info.laccesshost.com/schrom.html
Did they shoot the footage we are just now seeing, or was an AlQaeda film team at the ready the moment the twin towers werehit? Readers of The Terror Enigma will understand how and whythe former scenario is just as likely the latter.
As to how, in that case, the video passed into the hands of AlQaeda's propagandists v it wouldn't be the first time the fruits ofIsraeli spying operations in the U.S. fell into the hands ofAmerica's enemies.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/fr/576453/Dosts
In any case, how this new 9/11 footage, previously known only tothe FBI and a "friendly bystander," wound up in Al Qaeda'spossession v or in the hands of a website claiming to representthem v is a mystery that the U.S. government seems quiteuninterested in unraveling.
NOTES IN THE MARGIN
The U.S. is how completely enclosing Iraqi villages in barbedwire. A more appropriate metaphor for the occupation of Iraqcouldn't be created by any novelist. Like the Israelis, theAmerican occupiers are requiring an internal passport of all
travelers coming into and going out of these villages. And,speaking of Israel, we are now doing to the Iraqis what ArielSharon and his ultra-rightist Likud party bloc have been dishingout to the Palestinians: arresting and detaining the relatives of"suspected guerrillas."
http://www. nytimes.eom/2003/12/07/i., .&partner=GQOGLEhttp://www. amnestv.nl/persberichten/NK-PB0090.shtml
I can hear all the weeping and wailing on the part of the "liberal"wing of the War Party, crying out that this is hardly going to win
3 of 74/26/2004 2:03 PM
Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/1 1 Tapes? http ://engforun^ivda.ru/showthread.phpS?s=&threadi.
"hearts and minds." The point is that it isn't meant to: turningIraq's villages into concentration camps is designed to humiliatedemean, and ultimately subjugate a proud people who refuse to'be conquered. That's the real face of the American "liberation" vflat out ugly.
vjustin Raimondo
Find this article at:
http://www.antiwar.com/1ustln/1120803.html
El 12-08-2003 07:31 PM
JohnathanRGaltCoalition Forces Member
Registered: Dec 2003Location: Cambridge, UKPosts: 821 .
Main English News site URL:http://enqforum.Dravda.ru/forumdisplav.phD3?forumid=7Main Discussion Forum URL: "
http://enqforum.pravda.ru/forumdisplav.phD3?forumid=2
vr&mi |St'<n3saai
Report this post to a moderator| IP: Logged
gj fej^mi \M3Mi £§jgsM fl^MMB
Bzzzzzt. Error in story.
Compare this statement:
The tape also contains what U.S. counterterror experts say maybe never-before-broadcast video of the Sept. 11, 2001 attackson New York's World Trade Center shot from across the EastRiver in Brooklyn.
With this statement:
Hours after the terrorists struck, five people were arrested inNew Jersey as they taped the WTC from their vantage pointacross the Hudson River in New Jersey".
We need to understand basic geography. Study a map of NewYork.
Brooklyn is to the EAST of Manhatten.
New Jersey is to the WEST of Manhatten.
Justin Raimondo is to the SOUTH of the planet Uranus.
4 of 74/26/2004 2:03 PM
s
Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/1 1 Tapes? http://engfonimj^vda.ru/showthread.php3?s=&threadi.
13 12-08-2003 07:52 PM
NickShowJunior Member
Registered: Dec 2003Location:
Posts: 4
Last edited by JohnathanRGait on 12-08-2003 at 07:59 PM
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
gj [fejg^&j fe^mmi IftLgEml
m 2nd error
(^^Miffi^S)
And I've been spreading this word around but no one seems to listeiThat video wasn't never before broadcast stuff. The professionalquality angle has been seen before. I own a copy of it. Why, you astBecause it's on a dvd....put out by PBS of a Nova special.This one in fact:
http://imaqes.amazon.eom/imaqes/P/B00006ADG4.01.LZZZZZZZ.-jf:
It's from the first ten seconds of the damned program! NBC and CNrand the FBI can't get it right!
Yes, it must be a conspiracy! PBS is funded by the US Governmentvia grants!
All this means is that Al Queda has access to Best Buy! Dear godsomeone stop this garbage!
Report this post to a moderator| IP: Loqgi
Q 12-09-2003 08:11 AM gg i&m-mi Iftoaal fc^j^S] fesSlft)fe*~<gfflfl &^m
NickShow(
Junior Member
Registered: Dec 2003Location:
Posts: 4
S 12-09-2003 04:38 PM
The Beatresident beatnik
Registered: May 2003Location: BetweenMickey's ears
Posts: 8774
They also have access to Circuit City, too.
Report this post to a moderator| IP: Logged
gg giamy IMj^j SBS) (gfigig)
Jonathan
my-'eml tiSf&^l
It's my understanding that this "new" film was taken in Brooklyn.Why they would also mention A TOTALLY SEPARATE ACCOUNTthat occurred in New Jersey, is puzzling, but the have NOTHINGTO DO WITH EACH OTHER.
Nick-
So, what do they say is the reason it fell???
Report this post to a moderator[ IP: Logged
Q 12-09-2003 05:33 pm gj Ifengsaferi fg&wraml i&eMsai li^mrr^i
JohnathanRGaitCoalition Forces Member The al-Qaeda videos are available here:
5 of 74/26/2004 2:03 PM
Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/11 Tapes? http://engforun-1avda.ru/sh wthread.php3?S=&threadiruiMca
Registered: Dec 2003Location: Cambridge/ UKPosts: 821
http://intellnet.orq/media/
Anyone with a video camera in West Brooklyn, East NJ, or SouthManhattan would have started recording that event once thenews of the first plane hitting the tower became publicknowledge.
Justin Raimondo is hawking his book "The Terror Enigma: 9/11and the Israeli Connection". As to the reason why antiwar comignores all evidence to the contrary while truth and reality take aback seat -- anti-semitism is an ugly thing.
It's from the first ten seconds of the damned program! NBC andCNN and the FBI can't get it right!
B 12-09-2003 07:21PM
NickShowJunior Member
Registered: Dec 2003Location:
Posts: 4
Neither can the AntiWar.com
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
gj tiks^m) \fgLjmi (ISSiii) iSag^al iliiig
Re: Jonathan
Originally posted by The Beat
Nick-
^1051 lH-^aisasJ
So, what do they say is the reason it fell???
Q 12-10-2003 02:32 AM
NickShow -
Junior Member
Registered: Dec 2003Location:
Posts: 4
D 12-16-2003 08:19 PM
JohnathanRGaltCoalition Forces Member
Supports couldn't take the strain as the columns were damaged.The dvd itself is more if you want to know the physical aspects asto why they collapsed more than the social/political.
Last edited by NickShow on 12-10-2003 at 02:34 AM
Report this post to a moderator| IP: Logged
Eg ^j^m i&i^ffgBi s^^3 m^mI
Ife-vana fgRjjjjjga
Finally the info get somewhere that is read often:
http://www.thememorvhole.org/911/new-footaqe/index.htm
m^<smt Igtg^Sj
Report this post to a moderator | IP: Logged
gg ifeRSSgBDl flfelw:-fiSDl Sggjgj) gggrggg
NickShow
Good find!
6 of 74/26/2004 2:03 PM
Forums - Shock Video: Who Shot New 9/1 1 Tapes?
#http://engforux^|avda.ru/showthread.php3?s=&threadi.
ZrSj^ Report this post to a moderator 1 IP: jjnnrjpH
Registered: Dec 2003Location: Cambridge, UKPosts: 821
D 12-16-2003 08:36 PM gj fiB)Q^^^g^j^^ (EfiB IffifflAll times are GMT. The time now is 06:57 PM.
<l Last Thread Next Thread
j5) Show Printable Version|(B) Email this Paoe | |P Subscribe to thte Thr^H
Forum Jump:
News section
Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads HTML code is OFFYou may not post replies vB code is ONYou may not post attachments Smilies are ONYou may not edit your posts flMG] code is OFF
Mark Ail Forums Read|FpmmLea^ers
| ContacUis | Forums | How to improve prahxm p,,., „,^,.
Powered by: Pravda.Ru, vBulletinCopyright © 2003 Jelsoft Enterprises
Limited.
7 of 74/26/2004 2:03 PM
Justin Raimondo explores the Israelis'^jinection to 9/1
1
http://www.chrog^esmagazine.org/Chjoiiicles/August.,
* '
//From the August 2003 issue of Chronicles;'
CHRONICLES INTELLIGENCE ASSESSMENT
The Terror Enigma: Israel and the September 11 Connectionby Justin Raimondo
"Remember 9/11!" is the rallying cry of the War Party; what we are remembering, however, is
a half-truth. It is time to draw the curtain on the largely ignored prehistory of September 11.Although Bush-administration officials deny that they had even a hint of what was to come,government agencies were literally awash with warnings from the intelligence services ofother nations—including the British, the French, the Germans, the Russians, the Argentines,the Israelis, the Egyptians, the Moroccans, and the Jordanians,
The Israelis had warned us in August 2001, when they sent a delegation to Washington,handed over a list of 19 individuals in the United States whom they believed to be planningterrorist activities, and issued a nonspecific warning that a major terrorist attack was afoot.Yet there are indications that the Mossad knew about Muhammad Atta and his gang longbefore they let U.S. law enforcement in on the secret.
In the months before September 11, the Mossadhad launched a major covert operation in theUnited States, involving hundreds of agents who not only kept a close watch on the terroristsbut may have effectively blinded U.S. antiterrorism investigators to the activities of Al Qaedain the United States. The evidence can be found in the U.S. government's own documents,leaked by its own employees, and in its public pronouncements before the decision was madeto quash this story at any cost.
In March 2001, the National Counterintelligence Center—whose mandate empowers it toidentify and assess possible threats to U.S. national security—posted the following warning onits website :
In the past six weeks, employees in federal office buildings located throughout theUnited States have reported suspicious activities connected with individualsrepresenting themselves as foreign students selling or delivering artwork.Employees have observed both males and females attempting to bypass facility
security and enter federal buildings. If challenged, the individuals state that theyare delivering artwork from a studio in Miami, Florida, called Universal Art, Inc, orthat they are art students and are looking for opinions regarding their work. Theseindividuals have been described as aggressive. They attempt to engage employeesin conversation rather than giving a sales pitch.
The NCIC warned that "these individuals have also gone to the private residences of seniorfederal officials under the guise of selling art." How they discovered the home-addresses ofthese senior officials, the NCIC did not say. At that point, two of the "students" had beenarrested for immigration violations: The suspects possessed counterfeit immigration papersand identification. Later, many more would be picked up—nearly 200—and summarilydeported to their country of origin: Israel.
The NCIC alert was the earliest premonition, some six months before the event, of September11. It was the first known instance—and possibly the last—in which the "antiterrorism"apparatus set up by the U.S. government actually worked, to some extent. The NCIC endedits warning with what turned out to be an accurate assessment of the threat:
Other reporting indicates that there may be two groups involved, and they refer tothemselves as "Israeli art students." One group has an apparently legitimate
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINEDIERQN JS^UNCLASSIFIED A ,
lof5 ' ' 4/26/2004 2:23 PM
JustinRaimondoexplorestheIsraeligonnectionto9/llhttp://www.ch^iclesmaga2ine.org/Chronicles/August.
?0neJ~^ k
ing 9°al While the second
' Perha Ps a non-Israeli group, may have tiesto a Middle Eastern Islamic fundamentalist group. Federal employees observingany activity similar to that described above should report their observations toappropriate security officials.
frnl^nTth% did
-In?eed '
cS° many accounts of Israeli "art student" sightings poured in
HnSpr ThaWlde
,Van
^tY °f federal agendeS
'that they were com Piled in a secret governmentdosser. Their mode of operation was always the same: They would enter a U S federalfacihty even some that were unmarked, and make their pitch, aggressively seeking en rvhrough back doors and generally acting as if they were casing the joint. Since the nation'sfrontline fighters in the "War on Drugs" had, for some reason, attracted the partkfularattention of these "art students," this document, which only came to light afterSeptember 11
'
seems to have been compiled and written up by the internal security unit of the DruaEnforcement Agency (DEA), in cooperation with the Immigration and Natural zation Servicesometime in summer 2001. (See "Suspicious Activities Involving Tsra pli ZSn.Z:*™™'
^^nfoS6^^^ 1
!?3t Ti the
,be9inning °f 200°" and increased in November:After April 2001, the number of reported incidents . . . declined[;l however the aeooranhirspread of the incidents" was extended "to Wisconsin, Oklahoma, and Los Anqeles *
if?addiLto visiting DEA offices, these "art students" also descended on a nuler of otoerlaw-enforcement and Department of Defense facilities across the. continental. United StatesThe majority of recorded incidents, however, seem to have occurred in the southern half of
wiffi'toe DyEA^ Offi e n
e
f
pi
qCenter °f
DaCt,Vity ,0C*ted in S0Uthem Florida
- ItwiS^aSSadwith toe DEA s Office of Security Programs apparently became convinced that, as the report
hkt?fIU
|
ref°
f the!
ndividuals ' conduct, combined with intelligence information andhistorical information regarding past incidents involving Israeli Organized Crime
activity/incidents may well be an organized intelligence gathering
These were no ordinary Israeli "tourists," as they claimed when confronted. While all Israelis
11 7QTS t,mS
"V*6 military
'an Unusual|y hi9h Proportion of these "studen s" we e£S nT,,te Un,
?-Jn6 °EA rep° rt
"StS name 'rank
'and serial number: "ay SimonManna Glickman, and Dilka Borenstein are all described as former members of Israelimilitaryintelligence. Zeev Miller is identified as a "combat engineer," and Ofir Navron is a^ombdisposal expert." Aran Ofek, the son of a two-star Israeli general, was apprehended in DallasTaken toge her, their credentials are impressive: "intelligence officer," "electronic intercepoperator," "special forces," "demolition/explosive ordnance expert."
intercept
A group of Israelis was picked up by the FBI after being spotted in Liberty State Park in Jersey£?'^W Je
/S^'
I
aU9hmg and h,Sh-flvlng one another as the World Trade Center burned onhe other side of the river. A story by Paulo Lima in the Bergen, New Jersey RecordaSS^tSi2)
-deSa
?beS h°W
7? men-"Israeli tou9rists"-were picked up eight hoursafter the WTC attack, "carrying maps linking them to the blasts":
to toe'bomtin6
^ot^inVeStigation said they found otner evidence linking the men
Lh
Hre«?M ")*¥„**£ d
,
ty'u
the Car Witn certain P|aces highlighted," the sourcesaid. It looked like they're hooked in with this. It looked like they knew what wasgoing to happen when they were at Liberty State Park."
Lima reports that the five "tourists" had been picked up after local police received thefollowing alert from the FBI:
2 of 54/26/2004 2:23 PM
Justin Raimondo explores the Israelis^onnection to 9/1
1
httpyAvww.chr^lesmagazine.org/Chronicles/August.
Vehicle possibly related to New York terrorist attack. White, 2000 Chevrolet vanwith New Jersey registration with "Urban Moving Systems" sign on back seen atLiberty State Park, Jersey City, NJ, at the time of first impact of jetliner into Worldirade Center. Three individuals with van were seen celebrating after initial impactand subsequent explosion. FBI Newark Field Office requests that, if the van islocated, hold for prints and detain individuals.
These reports attracted little if any notice. Not long after, however, the whole operation began
m-S
„
Urf?C„
e'
n muJ° r m
?dia
-0n November 23, 2001, the Washington Post ran a story by JohnMmtz deta. ing how along with the 1,000 or so Muslim Middle Easterners jailed in the Ashcroftsweep 60 Israelis had been picked up and held, not just for routine visa violations, but in
connection with the September 11 investigation. The Post's subhead read: "Government callsSeveral Cases of Special Interest,' Meaning Related to Post-Attacks Investigation."
iScT?"9 fc
rM
'
mtZ\ af°Unt' INS officials in cleve|and and St. Louis testified in court thatthese Israelis were "of special interest to the government'-putting them in the samecategory as hundreds of mostly Arab men rounded up by the feds since the attacks.
Over the next eight or nine months, the rest of the story would come out, though it would beobscured by denials and submerged by an oddly indifferent media. "It is rather stranqe "
remarked Janes Defense Intelligence Digest (March 13, 2002), "that the US media seems tobe ignoring what may well be the most explosive story since the 11 September attacks-thealleged break-up of a major Israeli espionage operation in the USA." (The Post's story blandly
™,n£ T 'Hi*the
,!f
raeli detainees were "observing a time-honored tradition in their
SnU h-7 ?nl I «
W° rld after their mandatory sefvice in the Israeli military," althoughMmtz did note that a number of them had served in counterterrorist units in Israel.")
?h1DtCeHlber U
'2001
'Fox News ran the first in a series of investigative reports that blewthe whistle on a vast Israeli spy network operating on American soil-and openly posed the
question of whether the Israelis had foreknowledge of September 11. According to Jane'swhat is striking about Fox News reporter Carl Cameron's portrait of Israel's spy network in theU.S is the sheer vastness of his subject. The broad scope of the operation, with its manyfronts and activities conducted from coast to coast, had all the aspects of a major militarycampaign. In the months leading up to 9/11, Cameron claimed, Israel was waging a covertwar against its principal ally and benefactor, the United States.
Over four nights, Cameron reported the myriad details of Israel's far-flung underground armyin the United States. He noted that some of the 60 detainees arrested in the wake ofSeptember 11 were active Israeli military officers. Some had failed polygraph tests when theywere asked about surveillance activities against and in the United States."
Cameron showed how the Mossad had thoroughly penetrated top-secret communicationssystems. He cited veteran law-enforcement agents afraid for their jobs if they questionedIsrael s role. What really caught the attention of viewers, however, was the followingstatement from his first broadcast:
There is no indication that the Israelis were involved in the 9-11 attacks butinvestigators suspect that the Israelis may have gathered intelligence about theattacks in advance, and not shared it. A highly placed investigator said thereare-quote-"tie-ins." But when asked for details, he flatly refused to describethem, saying-quote-"evidence linking these Israelis to 9-11 is classified. I cannottell you about evidence that has been gathered. It's classified information."
Cameron's bombshell should have provoked a frenzy of media interest and calls for an officialinvestigation. That no such call was ever made is a story in itself.
3 of 54/26/2004 2:23 PM
Justin Raimondo explores the Israeli^onnection to 9/1
1
http://ww,vxh^clesmaga2ine.org/Cl1ronicleS/August.
inhSfJ^PaPt
°thiS r
!P°rt
'Cameron focuses on a single aspect of a multilayered Israeliintelligence operation that became increasingly visible in the months precedingSeptember 11:
Numerous classified documents obtained by Fox News indicate that even prior toSeptember 11, as many as 140 other Israelis had been detained or arrested in a
fin^Tc^sT
prawlin9 investigation into suspected espionage by Israelis in theUnited States. Investigators from numerous government agencies are part of a
IKS'?9?U
5thf'
S Sen COmpiling evidence since the mid"90s. These documentsdetail hundreds of incidents in cities and towns across the country that
Q0CUmentS
Sy/'t0rS say-°>uote-nmay we" be ^ organized intelligence gathering
IHevem^Ume?F
S ln^Uded a 6°"page report comP iled bv a numfaer of federal agencies In the
L?p°f
:ff bureaucratese so typical of a government document, the -braelUrtStudent Papers -leaked some months later-confirmed Cameron's contention that anationwide underground apparatus of Israeli agents, centered in Florida and TexasCarried out
DBA ^eT°N
Pc;
erX
,0npSin the
Dmonths leadin9 up to September 11. Their targets included he
JEfeJ ?f ;
, fal Protective Service;the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, andHreaL^^^^xsr^ 1 a host of state and federal cou;thouses and °th-
The leaked document describes in excruciating detail the doggedly-persistent efforts of Israelisclaiming to be "art students" to get into the offices and even the homes of federallaw-enforcement agents and government officials.
A March 5, 2002, article in Le Monde by Sylvain Cypel was more specific "More than a t-hirH nfhese,
'students' claimed residence in Florida," and "at least fiv^were nterceoted in Hnl.vwooH
SfflulC^^SS^^-1 poin,
ts out the p™ o^lTo s°Trd
town of some 25 000 sou , Jh' 1^°^ °f 9/11-
Were residing in Florida -" Hollywood, a
Smtrorisfce°r ™™ °f Israel'
s spv "«woric and the
nnmhl^f ^m™embe
[s of the 3 rouP that diverted American Airlines flightnumber 11-Mohammed Atta, Abdulaziz Al-Omari, Walid and Wall Al-Shehri aswe as one of the five terrorists of United flight 175, Marwan Al-Shehhi-resided allat various timesjn
. Hollywood, Florida. As for Ahmed Fayez, Ahmed and HamzaA -Ghamd. and Mohand Al-Shehri, who took over United flight 75, like Sakl
rtchf^c'' ? uAl-Haznawi and Ahmed Al-Nami, of United flight 93 whichcrashed September 11 in Pennsylvania, and Nawaq Al-Hamzi, of AA flight 77
noTh^Fort S^ST*' *"> °" *™ *"« «*" 3t°^^ in ^The most logical assumption is that the Israelis were engaged in a larqe-scaleintelligence-gathering operation on Islamic terrorist cells in the United States.
Another important piece of the puzzle is found in an October 14, 2002, article bv OliverSchrom in the German weekly Die Zeit. Schrom writes:
hp°lUmntil aft6r
?e attaClf
S°1
SePtember lj-d id the consequences of the spy ring
Sic £T Apparan,tly the a^nts were not interested in military or industrial
facilities but were shadow.ng a number of suspects, who were later involved in theterronst attacks against the U.S. According to a report of the French inte Mgenceagency that Die Zeit examined, "according to the FBI, Arab terrorists andsuspected terror cells lived in Phoenix, Arizona, as well as in Miami and Hollywood
4 of 54/26/2004 2:23 PM
Justin Raimondo explores the ^aelisU|nhection to 9/1
1
http://www.chrafclesmagazine.org/Chronicles/August..
Florida from December 2000 to April 2001 in direct proximity to the Israeli spycells."
The MossadI
was particularly interested in Muhammad Atta, the terrorist leader, and Marwanal-Shehi who lived in Hollywood, Florida. Die Zeit reports that the Mossad was watchinq theterrorist leader and his chief accomplices very closely:
Everything indicates that the terrorists were constantly observed by the IsraelisThe chief Israeli agent was staying right near the post office where the terroristshad a mailbox. The Mossad also had its sights on Atta's accomplice Khalidal-Midhar, with whom the CIA was also familiar, but allowed to run free.
The title of the Die Zeit piece-"Next Door to Mohammed Atta"-may be a bit of an -
overstatement, however. As Schrom writes:
[Muhammad Atta and Marwan al-Shehi] lived in Hamburg before they settled inHollywood, Florida[,] in order to plan the attacks. A Mossad team was alsooperating in the same town. The leader, Hanan Serfati, had rented severaldwellings. "One of Serfati's apartments was located on the corner of 701st St and21st Ave. [sic] in Hollywood, right near the apartment of Atta and al-Shehi
"
French intelligence reported later.'
There is just one problem: There is no 701st Street and 21stAvenue in Hollywood, FloridaSerfati s rental was at 701 South 21st Street, about a half-mile from Atta's 1818 Jackson
'
Street address. Serfati rented several apartments in the area, however, and one could easilyhave been next door to Mohammed Atta" and his confederates, who moved around quite abit. In addition, the geographical congruity of the Israeli "art students" and the hijackinqconspirators was not limited to South Florida, as John Sugg has pointed out in a March 202002, piece for the Weekly Planet :
'
r
Many of the apparent operatives had set up shop at addresses only stones' throwsfrom Arabs in San Diego, Little Rock, Irving, Texas, and in South Florida. ThePlanet also has obtained a watch list of mostly Arabs under scrutiny by the U.S.government. The addresses of many correspond to the specific areas where theIsraelis established bases.
While the Israelis were closely observing Atta and his friends, they did not inform the U Sgovernment what they were up to until August 2001: Der Spiegel reported (October 1 2002)that they handed over a list of 19 terrorist suspects, with at least four of the hijackers on it, "afew weeks before" September 11, but the federal government says that the warning was forattacks "outside the United States."
The warning was nonspecific, indicating only that these were potential terrorists And thereare other discrepancies thatcloud the picture of Israeli cooperation in this matter. If theIsraelis had decided in August to come clean with the information they had, why were federalagents still arresting and detaining our "partners" in the "War on Terrorism" in late Novemberand early December?
Copyright 2003, www. ChroniclesMagazine. org
BACK TO THE AUGUST 2003 ISSUE
5 of 5
k.4/26/2004 2:23 PM
DATE: 09-09^2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
REASON: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY 01: 09-09-2035
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HERE IN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Investigation
In Reply, Please Refer to
File No.11 Centre PlaceNewark, NJ 07102
January 19, 2005
Brooklyn, NY 11218
Dear
ALL INFOHEREINWHEI
"AIMED
EXCEPT
b6b7C
In September 2 001 you were detained by the UnitedStates Immigration and Naturalization Service. At the time ofyour arrest, items found in your possession were seized as partof an ongoing investigation. The Federal Bureau of Investigationno longer requires retention of these items and would like toreturn them to you. You have 30 days to make arrangements toretrieve the items or they will bft dttBftrovftri Your nqint ofcontact is Special Agentl
|Thank you
for your time and attention.
Sincerely,
Joseph Billy Jr.Special Agent in Charge
DA'
CLASSIFIED!?
REASON: 1.4(
m. 9(Sr
Acting supervisory Special Agent
Uo
te>
bl
DATE: 09-09-2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
REASON: 1.4 [cj
DECLASSIFY OH: 09-09-2035
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOWN OTHERWISE
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Investigation
In Reply, Please Refer to
File No.11 Centre PlaceNewark, NJ 07102
January 19, 2 005
Brooklyn, NY 11218
Dear
jfflONggj£0
W UErWNlSE.
@*hehie
In September 2 001 you were detained by the UnitedStates Immigration and Naturalization Service. At the time ofyour arrest, items found in your possession were seized as partof an ongoing investigation. The Federal Bureau of Investigationno longer requires retention of these items and would like toreturn them to you. You have 3 days to make arrangements toretrieve the items or they will be destroyed. Your point ofcontact is Special Agent
|Thank you
for your time and attention.
Sincerely,
Joseph Billy Jr.Special Agent in Charge
DACLASSIFIEDREASON: 1.4i
BECLASSB?¥0N:
[
By: -K3r]
Acting Supervisory Special Agent
\k
hi
Gt>
BATE: 09-09-2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
REASON: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY OH: 09-09-2035
ALL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEREIN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPTWHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Investigation
In Reply, Please Refer to
File No.11 Centre PlaceNewark, NJ 07102
January 19, 2 005
Brooklyn, NY 11218
ALL INFOHEREIN IS UWHER
NTAIWEDEXCEPTISE.
heb7C
Dear
In September 2 001 you were detained by the UnitedStates Immigration and Naturalization Service. At the time ofyour arrest, items found in your possession were seized as partof an ongoing investigation. The Federal Bureau of Investigationno longer requires retention of these items and would like toreturn them to you. You have 3 days to make arrangements toretrieve the items or.thev will be destroyed. Your point ofcontact is Special Agent Thank youfor your time and attention.
Sincerely,
Joseph Billy Jr.Special Agent in Charge
By: &5(r
CLASSIFIEDMASON: 1.4( 0/
BSCLASS]
Acting Supervisory Special Agent
\^
bl
G) 1
DATE; 09-09-2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC60322LP/PLJ/CC
PEAS OCT: 1.4 (c)
DECLASSIFY OCT: 09-09-2035
ALL INFORMATION COHTAIHED
HEREICT IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT
IfflEKE SHOWN OTHERWISE
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Investigation
In Reply, Please Refer to
File No.11 Centre PlaceNewark, NJ 07102
January 19, 2 005
Brooklyn, NY 11218
ALL1NF0RHEREIN IS
WHERE SHQ
NTAINEDSSIRED EXCEPT
ERW1SE. *
Dear
In September 2001 you were detained by the UnitedStates Immigration and Naturalization Service. At the time ofyour arrest, items found in your possession were seized as partof an ongoing investigation. The Federal Bureau of Investigationno longer requires retention of these items and would like toreturn them to you. You have 3 days to make arrangements toretrieve the items or they will be destroyed. Your point ofcontact is Special Agent
\ |
Thank youfor your time and attention.
heb7C
Sincerely,
Joseph Billy Jr.Special Agent in Charge
DATE:class:
REASON: 1
BE<
bili ffcS£r
Acting SUps^vieibry Special Agent
f/ Ubl
(Rev. 01-31-2003)
DATE: 09-03-2010
CLASSIFIED BY UC
PEAS OH: 1.4 [cj
DECLASSIFY 01: 099^
2LP/PLJ/CCILL INFORMATION CONTAINED
HERE IN IS UNCLASSIFIED EXCEPT
WHERE SHOOT OTHERWISE£035
^^Sg^ET
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
(S)
Precedence : ROUTINE
To : Newark
From: NewarkSquad CI-1Contact: SA
Date: 02/18/2005
heb7C
Approved By:
Drafted By: Q
193ST
Case ID #: ^Title:' ^fljr
(S)
(Closed)
TWIN TOWERS
a 3(S)
bl
SynopsisXirJ#f No response has been received from subjectsrg regarding property seized.
oM Qea?awie€t--®ass©u -CM^Efr'nmiXlwi
Reference:tee: (S)
Details KPpfi On 01/1 9/200^ Mip writer .gent- mit four Ipttprqreferenced above, toand regarding property that was seized as part ofthe Twin Towers investigation. The letters stated that theindividuals had 3 days, from the date on the letter, to respondto FBI Newark in order to retrieve their property or it will bedestroyed. The letters were sent to the last known address ofthe individuals. To date, no response has been made and FBINewark considers the items abandoned. The items will bedestroyed pursuant to FBI guidelines.
DAr
classme:REASON: 1
b6b7C
2U
\lo
I
bl
^&
FEDERAL- BUREAU OF INVESTIGATIONFOIPA
DELETED PAGE INFORMATION SHEET
No Duplication Fees are charged for Deleted Page Information Sheet(s).
Total Deleted Page(s)Page 12 --be, b7CPage 13 --be, b7CPage 14 --be, b7CPage 15 --be, b7CPage 16 --be, b7CPage 17--be, b7CPage 1S --be, b7CPage 19 --be, b7CPage 20 --be, b7CPage 21 --be, b7CPage 22 --be, b7CPage 23 --be, b7CPage 24 --be, b7CPage 25 -~bG, b7CPage 26 --be, b7CPage 27-~b6, b7CPage 2S --be, b7CPage 29 --be, b7CPage 30 --be, b7CPage 31 --b^ b7CPage 32 --b^ b7CPage 33 --be, b7CPage 34 --be, b7CPage 35 --be, b7CPage 36 --be, b7CPage 37--be, b7CPage 38 -~bG, b7CPage 39 --b^ b7CPage 42 --be, b7CPage 43 --be, b7CPage 44 --be, b7CPage 45 --be, b7CPage 46 --be, b7CPage 47--be, b7CPage 4S --be, b7CPage 49 --be, b7CPage 50 --be, b7CPage 51 --be, b7CPage 52 --be, b7CPage 53 --be, b7CPage 54 --be, b7CPage 55 --be, b7CPage 56 --be, b7CPage 57--be, b7C
201
PagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePagePage
5S ~59 ~60 ~61 ~62 --
63 ~64 ~65 --
66 ~67™63 ~69 ~71 ~72 ~73 ~74 --
75 ~76 ~77--7S --
79 --
50 -51 --
52 --
53 --
54 --
55 --
56 --
S7~SS --
89 --
90 --
91 --
92 --
93 --
94 --
95 --
96 --
97™9S --
99 ™100 -
101 -
103 -
104 -
105 -
106 -
107^10S -
109 -
110 -
b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6b6bebebebebebebebebebebebebebebebebebebebebebe
, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C, b7C
be, b7Cb6, b7Cbe, b7Cb6, b7Cbe, b7Cbe, b7Cbe, b7Cbe, b7Cbe, b7Cbe, b7C
Page ]L 1 1 --be b7CPage :L12 --be b7CPage ]L13 --be b7CPage ]L14 --be b7CPage ][15 --be b7CPage :[16 --be b7CPage : L IT --be b7CPage ]LIS --be b7CPage ][19 --be b7CPage :L20 --be b7CPage :L21 --be b7CPage ]L22 --be b7CPage ]L23 --be b7CPage :L24 --be b7CPage :[25 --be b7CPage ][26 --be b7CPage ]L27--be b7CPage ]L2S --be b7CPage :[29 --be b7CPage ]L30 --be b7CPage ]L31 --be b7CPage ]L32 --be b7CPage :L33 --be b7CPage :L34 --be b7CPage ][35 --be b7CPage ][36 --be b7CPage :L37--be b7CPage :L3S --be b7CPage ][39 --be b7CPage ]L40 --be b7CPage ]L41 --be b7CPage :L42 --be b7CPage ]L43 --be b7CPage ][45 --be b7CPage :[46 --be b7CPage :L47--be b7CPage :L4S --be b7CPage ][49 --be b7CPage ][50 --be b7CPage :[51 --be b7CPage ]L52 --be b7CPage ][53 --be b7CPage ][54 --be b7CPage :[55 --be b7CPage :[56 --be b7CPage ]L57 --be b7CPage ]L5S --be b7CPage :[59 --be b7CPage :[60 --be b7CPage ][61 --be b7CPage ][62 --be b7C
Page 163 --b6 b7CPage 164 --b6 b7CPage 165 --be b7CPage 166 --be b7CPage 167--be b7CPage 168 --be b7CPage 169 --be b7CPage 170 --be b7CPage 171 --be b7CPage 172 --be b7CPage 173 --be b7CPage 174 --be b7CPage 175 --be b7CPage 176 --be b7CPage 177--be b7CPage 17S --be b7CPage 179 --be b7CPage ISO --be b7CPage 181 --be b7CPage 183 --be b7CPage 184 --be b7CPage 186 --be b7CPage 187--be b7CPage 189 --be b7CPage 190 --be b7CPage 191 --be b7CPage 192 --be b7CPage 193 --be b7CPage 194 --be b7CPage 195 --be b7CPage 196 --be b7CPage 197--be b7CPage 198 --be b7CPage 199 --be b7CPage ;200 --be b7CPage ;201 --be b7CPage ;202 --be b7CPage ;203 --be b7CPage ;204 --be b7CPage ;206 --be b7CPage ;207--be b7CPage ;208 --be b7CPage ;209 --be b7CPage ;210 --be b7CPage ;211 --be b7CPage ;212 --be b7CPage ;213 --be b7CPage ;214 --be b7CPage ;215 --be b7CPage ;216 --be b7CPage ;249 -- Diiplicate
Page 250 ™ DuplicatePage 542 ~ bl 7 h6 r b7CPage 543 ™ b<5 7 b7CPage 544 ~ h6, b7C