!"#$#% &$'(#%)#*+,-#*#$+%./$0121%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%31*45678%9:5;%<=+*5%;>6?@8%2A%6B;6%

!"#$%&&'$$(%)#*$#'%+!,'#*-#. '#/)!01)#2"1+#(!+#.1)'-.34#

56789#:;<;=#/>?>@

%

Abstract

This paper deals with the success of Europe in the global war for talent. While the first part of the paper explores the global structural changes that influence the

war for talent and the limitations of EU policy in attracting talent, looking at the European Union as a whole as well as examining immigration policies in individual

regions and countries, the second part explores EU policy that has been introduced

to ‘fight’ the war for talent, such as the Blue Card and Scientific Visa. Finally, the paper tries to find an answer to the question how Europe fares against its main

competitors: Australia, Canada and the US. Much of this discussion will be focused

on the ability of the European Union to attract highly skilled migrants.

Keywords: Skilled migration, EU policies, Blue Card, Scientific Visa%%

Nitelikli !gücünü Çekme Sava!õnda Avrupa Ne Kadar Ba!arõlõ?

Özet

Bu makale nitelikli i gücünü çekme sava õnda Avrupa'nõn ba arõlõ olup

olmadõ!õnõ incelemektedir. Makalenin ilk bölümü nitelikli i gücü sava õnõ etkileyen

yapõsal faktörler yanõnda birlik üyesi ülkelerin ve AB'nin göç politikalarõnõ inceleyerek AB'nin nitelikli göçmen çekmede ya adõ!õ sõkõntõlarõn nedenlerini

incelerken, ikinci bölüm ise AB'nin nitelikli göçmen çekebilmek için uygulamaya

koydu!u 'Bilimsel Vize' ve "Mavi Kart' gibi uygulamalarõ incelemektedir. Son kõsõmda ise, Avrupa'nõn ana rakipleri olan ABD, Avustralya, Kanada gibi ülkelerle

nasõl ba a çõktõ!õ sorusuna cevap aranmaktadõr. Makalenin temel tartõ ma konusu

AB'nin nitelikli i gücü çekmedeki becerisi olacaktõr. %

Anahtar kelimeler: Nitelikli göçmen, AB Politikalarõ, Mavi Kart, Bilimsel Vize

=$CA%.:DA%.$8%E#"#$F#%G!1&/$214/21%H,*/4-/%I#"J*4/21%K*'2*#$#$#2+%L1M#$/4%NO*J-JA%** Makalenin Gönderilme Tarihi: 17 "ubat 2016, Kabul Edilme Tarihi: 27 Eylül 2016

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%;

*9A<BCDEA8B9##

LV/%0*:W#*%XY#$%Z:$%4#*/!4[%W/0#!%#4%4V/%4'$!%:Z%4V/%;624%M/!4'$F8%#2%W'21!/22%*/#C/$2%W/M#-/%1!M$/#21!0*F%M:!M/$!/C%Y14V%#44$#M41!0%4#*/!4%4:%*/#C%#!C%C/&/*:(%4V/1$%W'21!/22/26A%LV12%0*:W#*%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4%12%&/$F%-'MV%#%($:C'M4%:Z% 4V/%-:C/$!%/M:!:-1M%M*1-#4/5% 14% 12%#%$/2'*4%:Z% 4V/%/&/$B1!M$/#21!0% 0*:W#*12#41:!% :Z% ($:M/22/2% #!C% ($:C'M41:!8% #0/1!0%(:('*#41:!2% #!C% 1!4/$!#41:!#*% -:W1*14F8% YV1MV% M$/#4/2% 1!4/!2/%M:-(/4141:!% Z:$%V'-#!%M#(14#*%#!C%2"1**2A% 2%2'MV8% 4V/%#44$#M41:!%#!C%$/4/!41:!% :Z% 4V/% V10V/24% #MV1/&/$2% 12% :Z% Z'!C#-/!4#*% 1-(:$4#!M/% 4:%M:'!4$1/2%#M$:22%4V/%Y:$*C;A%LV/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4%V#2%$/-#1!/C%(/$&#21&/%C/2(14/% 4V/% /M:!:-1M% M$#2V% #!C% 2'W2/\'/!4% C:Y!4'$!A% % 2'$&/F%M:!C'M4/C% WF% ]/Y144^8% Z:$% /_#-(*/8% 2V:Y2% 4V#4% C/2(14/% C1ZZ1M'*4%/M:!:-1M% M:!C141:!28% #% *#$0/% ($:(:$41:!% :Z% 4V/% M:-(#!1/2% 2'$&/F/C%$/-#1!/C%Z:M'2/C%:!%4V/%4:(%4#*/!4%#!C%V#C%2'24#1!/C%4V/1$%1!&/24-/!4%1!%$/M$'14-/!48%*/#$!1!0%#!C%C/&/*:(-/!4A%%%

`!% 4V12% (#(/$8% Y/% Y1**% /_#-1!/% 4V/% 214'#41:!% :Z% Q'$:(/% 1!% 4V/%0*:W#*% Y#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4A% L:% C:% 4V128% Y/% Y1**% Z1$24% M:!21C/$% 4V/% 0*:W#*%24$'M4'$#*%MV#!0/2%1!%/M:!:-1M%#!C%C/-:0$#(V1M%4$/!C2%4V#4%1!Z*'/!M/%4V/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4A%a/%Y1**%4V/!%*::"%#4%4V/%Q'$:(/#!%K!1:!8%1!M*'C1!0%4V/% *1-14#41:!2% :Z% QK% (:*1MF% 1!% #44$#M41!0% 4#*/!4b% 4V/% 1--10$#41:!%(:*1M1/2%1!%1!C1&1C'#*%$/01:!2%#!C%M:'!4$1/2b%#!C%4V/%(:*1M1/2%4V#4%V#&/%W//!%1!4$:C'M/C%4:%XZ10V4[%4V/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!48%2'MV%#2%4V/%N*'/%3#$C%#!C%EM1/!41Z1M%c12#A%I1!#**F8%Y/%Y1**%/&#*'#4/%V:Y%Q'$:(/%Z#$/2%#0#1!24%142%-#1!% M:-(/414:$25% '24$#*1#8% 3#!#C#% #!C% 4V/% KEA% S'MV% :Z% 4V12%C12M'221:!% Y1**% W/% Z:M'2/C% :!% 4V/% #W1*14F% :Z% 4V/% Q'$:(/#!% K!1:!% 4:%#44$#M4%V10V*F% 2"1**/C%-10$#!42A%LV12% 12%W/M#'2/% 1!M$/#21!0% 4V/% 2'((*F%:Z% 2"1**/C% 1--10$#!42% 1!4:% 4V/% *#W:'$%-#$"/42% M#!% #CC$/22% ($:W*/-2%M#'2/C% WF% 24$'M4'$#*% #0/1!0% #!C% 1!4/$!#41:!#*% M:-(/4141:!A%`!4/$!#41:!#*% :$0#!12#41:!28% 2'MV% #2% 4V/% d$0#!12#41:!% Z:$% QM:!:-1M%3:B:(/$#41:!%#!C%./&/*:(-/!4%<dQ3.@%/-(V#212/%4V/%1-(:$4#!M/%:Z%

6% EMV:!% N//MV*/$% #!C% `#!A% 3A% a::CY#$C8% eLV/% 0*:W#*% fY#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4ge8% FBD<96G# BH#*9A;<96A8B96G#?696I;=;9AJ%31*4%678%;>>h8%2A;i^B;j7A%%

;%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

^%]/Y1448% f]/Y144%L#*/!4%E'$&/F%;>>j5%N'1*C1!0% 4V/%L#*/!4/C%d$0#!12#41:!3#*9#177BE86A8B9#N8AO#.6G;9A#?696I;=;9A#+;P8;N8%;>>jA##

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn ^%

2"1**/C% 1--10$#41:!% 1!4/$!#41:!#**FoA% 2% 2'MV8% /ZZ/M41&/% -#!#0/-/!4%:Z%V10VB2"1**/C%1--10$#41:!%12%:Z%Z'!C#-/!4#*%1-(:$4#!M/%4:%Q'$:(/A %

(6EAB<7#*=M6EA89I#AO;#"6<#HB<#.6G;9A##

Definition of the Term "War for Talent" #

`!%:$C/$% 4:%/&#*'#4/%Q'$:(/[2%2'MM/22% 1!% 4V/%0*:W#*%Y#$%Z:$% 4#*/!48% 14% 12%!/M/22#$F%4:%W$1/Z*F%/_(*#1!%4V/%-/#!1!0%#!C%0/!/212%:Z%4V12%4/$-A%`4%-'24%W/%2#1C%4V#4%4V/$/%12%!:%:!/%/_#M4%C/Z1!141:!%YV1MV%12%M:--:!*F%#MM/(4/CA%`4% 12%W/M#'2/% 4V/% 4/$-% C/(/!C2% :!% 4V/% *:M#*% /M:!:-1M8% 2:M1#*% #!C% C/-:0$#(V1M%M:!4/_42% #!C% 4V/% *:M#*% M:!M/$!% #!C% 4V/% (:*1M1/2% 1!% (*#M/7A% LV/% Xa#$% Z:$%L#*/!4[%Y#2% *#'!MV/C%WF% -/$1M#!%-#!#0/-/!4%M:!2'*4#!4% Z1$-%SMP1!2/F%p% 3:-(#!F% 1!% 6hhjA% `4% Y#2% *#'!MV/C% WF% 4V/% ('W*1M#41:!% :Z% #% $/(:$4% 4V#4%M:!M*'C/C%4V#4%XW/44/$% 4#*/!4% 12%Y:$4V%Z10V41!0%Z:$[?A%LV12%Y#2%W/M#'2/8% 4V/F%#$0'/C8% 4V/% -:24% &#*'#W*/% $/2:'$M/% Z:$% M:$(:$#4/% 2'MM/22% :&/$% 4V/% !/_4%4Y/!4F%F/#$2%Y:'*C%W/%1!4/**10/!4%#!C%/$'C14/%W'21!/22%(/:(*/A%SMP1!2/F%p%3:-(#!F% '2/C% 4V/% C/Z1!141:!% 1!% 4V/1$% $/(:$4% #2% X4V/% 2'-% :Z% #% (/$2:![2%#W1*141/2q% V12% :$% V/$% 1!4$1!21M% 01Z428% 2"1**28% "!:Y*/C0/8% /_(/$1/!M/8%1!4/**10/!M/8% r'C0/-/!48% #4414'C/8% MV#$#M4/$% #!C% C$1&/[iA% E:-/% V#&/% 2V#$/C%4V12%C/Z1!141:!8%2//1!0%4V/%4#*/!4/C%#2%X %(*#F/$2%s4V#4t%#$/%1!%4V/%4:(%6>u%:Z%4#*/!4%#&#1*#W*/%#4%#**% 2#*#$F% */&/*2% B%W/24%:Z%M*#22[jA%SMP1!2/F%p%3:-(#!F%#$0'/2%4V#4%4V12%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4%Y:'*C%W/M:-/%1!M$/#21!0*F%M:-(/4141&/%#2%4V/%C/-#!C%Z:$%4#*/!4%$:2/%#!C%4V/%2'((*F%:Z%4#*/!4/C%1!C1&1C'#*2%C/M$/#2/CA% 2%2'MV8%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%4V/%XW/24%#!C%W$10V4/24[%Y:'*C%W/M:-/%#%XM:!24#!4%#!C%M:24*F%W#44*/[hA%%%

International Economic and Demographic Trends #

SMP1!2/F%p%3:-(#!F[2%($/C1M41:!2% $/0#$C1!0% 4V/%Y#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4%V#&/%($:&/C%4$'/A%`!% 4V12%2/M41:!8%Y/%Y1**%/_#-1!/%4V/%$#!0/%:Z%Z#M4:$2% 4V#4%V#&/%1!Z*'/!M/C%4V/%0*:W#*%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4A%LV12%12%!/M/22#$F%1!%:$C/$%4:%1!Z:$-%:'$%

o% m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%%

7%% A9AP'&1"8%fE"1**/C%-10$#41:!%#!C%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%4#*/!4B%R/M/!4%C/&/*:(-/!42%#!C%4V/:$/41M#*%M:!21C/$#41:!2g8%1*$$+8%;>678%2A%;;A%%

?%% Q*1w#W/4V%3V#-W/$2%/4%#*A8%eLV/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4e8%.O;#?E:897;Q#RD6<A;<GQ, 31*4%^8%6hhj8%2Ao7A%

i%% QC%S1MV#/*2%/4%#*A%LV/%a#$%Z:$%L#*/!48%]#$Y#$C%N'21!/22%R/&1/Y%l$/228%;>>68%2A6;%j%% N$#C%E-#$4%#!C%T/:ZZ%E-#$48%.BMI<6C89I#S BN#.B# 8<;J#&B6EO#69C#:;;M#1#,G6Q;<7J#l$14MV/44%l$/228%;>>78%2A6jA%%

h%% Q*1w#W/4V%3V#-W/$2%/4%#*A8%eLV/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4e8%.O;#?E:897;Q#RD6<A;<GQ, 31*4%^8%6hhj8%2A76A%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%o

C12M'221:!%:Z% 4V/%Y#F2% 1!%YV1MV%Q'$:(/%V#2%Z:'0V4% 4V/%Y#$%Z:$% 4#*/!4b%V:Y%2'MM/22Z'*%14%V#2%W//!b%#!C%4V/%*1-14#41:!2%:Z%142%$/2(:!2/A% %V'0/%1!Z*'/!M/%:!% 4V/%Y#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4%V#2%W//!%:'$%#0/1!0%(:('*#41:!25% 1!M$/#2/C% *1Z/% 2(#!2%#!C% C/M*1!1!0% W1$4V% $#4/2% V#&/% */C% 4:% X#!% '!($/M/C/!4/C% 2V1Z4% 1!% 4V/% #0/%C124$1W'41:!% :Z% 4V/% 0/!/$#*% (:('*#41:![6>A% S:24% Q'$:(/#!% 24#4/2% M:!21C/$%*#W:'$%-10$#41:!% #2%-/#!2% 4:%-1410#4/% *#W:'$% 2V:$4#0/266A% 2%Y/**% #2% 4V/2/%C/-:0$#(V1M% MV#!0/28% 0*:W#*12#41:!% V#2% */C% 4:% 1!M$/#2/C% /M:!:-1M%1!4/0$#41:!%W/4Y//!%!#41:!28%Y14V%0:&/$!-/!42%$/C'M1!0%#!C%$/-:&1!0%*/0#*%#!C% $/0'*#4:$F% W#$$1/$2% 4:% 1!4/$!#41:!#*% 1!4/$#M41:!A% LV12% V#2% */C% 4:% *#$0/%M#(14#*%-#$"/42b%4V/%`!4/$!#41:!#*%m#W:'$%d$0#!1w#41:!%<`md@%<;>>j@%$/(:$42%4V#4% *#W:'$%-#$"/42%#M$:22% 4V/%Y:$*C%#$/%-:$/% 1!4/0$#4/C%#!C%24$:!0/$% 4V#!%/&/$%W/Z:$/6;A%R#(1C%C/&/*:(-/!42% 1!% 4/MV!:*:0F%-/#!%M:--'!1M#41!0%#!C%M:-('41!0% #$/% MV/#(/$% #!C% /#21/$% 4V#!% /&/$6^A% T*:W#*12#41:!% MV#!0/2% 4V/%-:&/-/!4% #!C% -:W1*14F% :Z% (/:(*/% #M$:22% W:4V% M'*4'$#*% #!C% 0/:0$#(V1M%W:'!C#$1/2A% LV12% 0$/#4/$% -:W1*14F% */#C2% 4:% 0*:W#*% *#W:'$% M:-(/4141:!8% #2%(/:(*/% #$/%-:$/%Y1**1!0% 4:% $/*:M#4/% :'421C/% 4V/1$% V:-/% M:'!4$1/26oA% LV12% 12%(#$41M'*#$*F%4$'/%Z:$%V10VB2"1**/C%Y:$"/$2%YV:%V#&/%/-10$#4/C%#4%#%*#$0/$%$#4/%4V#!%*:YB2"1**/C%:$%-/C1'-B2"1**/C%Y:$"/$267A%LV12%-/#!2%4V#4%Z'!C#-/!4#*%4:%#44$#M41!0%4V/%-:24%4#*/!4/C%Y:$"/$2%#$/%M:'!4$1/2[%(:*1M1/2%:!%1--10$#41:!%B%#!%122'/%Y/%Y1**%C12M'22%1!%C/(4V%1!%4V12%(#(/$A%%%

`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

6>% EMV:!% N//MV*/$% #!C% `#!A% 3A% a::CY#$C8% eLV/% 0*:W#*% fY#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4ge8% FBD<96G# BH#*9A;<96A8B96G#?696I;=;9AJ%31*4%678%;>>h8%2A;o;A%%

66% m'M1/% 3/$!#% #!C% %S#4V1#2% 3w#1"#8% fQ'$:(/#!% l:*1M1/2% 4:% 44$#M4% L#*/!45% LV/%3$1212% #!C%]10V*F%E"1**/C%S10$#41:!%l:*1MF%3V#!0/2g8%?8I<6A8B9J#L867MB<67#69C#&8A8T;97O8MJ#UVWXJ#2A%;;Bo^%

6;% `!4/$!#41:!#*% m#W:'$% d$0#!1w#41:!8% fT*:W#*% Q-(*:F-/!4% L$/!C2g8% dM#"8% `md% T/!/&#%EY14w/$*#!C8%;>>jA%

6^% EMV:!% N//MV*/$% #!C% `#!A% 3A% a::CY#$C8% eLV/% 0*:W#*% fY#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4ge8% FBD<96G# BH#*9A;<96A8B96G#?696I;=;9AJ%31*4%678%;>>h8%2A;i^B;j7A%

6o% R:2#*1/% mAL'!08% eLV/% V'-#!% $/2:'$M/% MV#**/!0/% 4:% :'4Y#$C% Z:$/10!% C1$/M4% 1!&/24-/!4%#2(1$#41:!2% Z$:-% /-/$01!0% M:'!4$1/25% 4V/% M#2/% :Z% 3V1!#e8% *9A;<96A8B96G# FBD<96G# BH# D=69#+;7BD<E;#?696I;=;9AJ Cilt 18, No 5,%;>>i8%2Aj?jvjjhA%%

67% EMV:!% N//MV*/$% #!C% `#!A% 3A% a::CY#$C8% eLV/% 0*:W#*% fY#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4ge8% FBD<96G# BH#*9A;<96A8B96G#?696I;=;9AJ%31*4%678%;>>h8%2A;i^B;j7A%

6?%%E#-1%S#V$:'-8% eQ'$:(/% #!C% 4V/% `--10$#41:!% :Z%]10V*F% E"1**/Ce8%Labour% International

Migration8%;>>68%31*4%^h8%9:%78%2A%;iBo^A%

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn 7%

/_(/$1/!M/% *#W:'$%2V:$4#0/2%#2% 4V#4%(::*% 12%C124$1W'4/C%#M$:22% 4V/% $/01:!8%#2%Y/**% #2% 2V1Z42% Z$:-% (*#M/% 4:% (*#M/A% % $/*#4/C% 122'/% M:!M/$!2% 4V#4% :Z% 2"1**%-12-#4MV6iA%I#M4:$2%2'MV%#2%C1ZZ/$/!41#*2%1!%Y#0/28%/-(*:F-/!4%W/!/Z142%#!C%*1&1!0% 24#!C#$C2% #M$:22% 4V/%QK%-/#!% 4V#4%Y:$"/$2%-#F%Y1**1!0*F% fC/-:4/g%4V/-2/*&/2%:$%Y:$"% 1!%#!:4V/$8% *:Y/$B2"1**/C% Z1/*C%v% 4V'2%!:4%'41*121!0% 4V/1$%"/F%2"1**2%v%1!%:$C/$%4:%:W4#1!%W/44/$%Y#0/2%#!C%Y:$"1!0%M:!C141:!2A%LV12%V#2%V#C% #!% 1!Z*'/!M/% 1!% M:'!4$1/2% 2'MV% #2% l:*#!C8% YV/$/% 2"1**/C%Y:$"/$2% V#&/%fC:Y!B4$#C/Cg% 4V/1$% ($1-#$F% 2"1**B2/4% 1!% :$C/$% 4:% :W4#1!% W/44/$% Y#0/2% #4% #%*:Y/$%:$%C1ZZ/$/!4*F%2"1**/C% r:W% 1!%#!:4V/$%S/-W/$%E4#4/A%LV/% $:*/%:Z% 4V/2/%C1ZZ/$/!41#*2%1!%#44$#M41!0%#!C%($:-:41!0%2"1**2%2V:$4#0/2%V#2%W//!%!:4/C%WF%#%!'-W/$%:Z%M:--/!4#4:$28%YV:%(:1!4%:'4%4V#4%4V/%(::*%:Z%2"1**2%12%/ZZ/M41&/*F%1!%fV1W/$!#41:!g%#!C%!:4%W/1!0%/ZZ1M1/!4*F%'41*12/CA%LV12%V#2%W//!%#%(#$41M'*#$%122'/%Z:$%Q#24Ba/24%*#W:'$%-:W1*14F8%YV/$/%4V/%C1ZZ/$/!M/2%1!%*#W:'$%-#$"/4%:((:$4'!141/2%#$/%f24$1"1!0g6jA%%

!% 1!C1$/M4*F% $/*#4/C% 122'/% 4:% 4V#4% :Z% Y#0/% C1ZZ/$/!41#*2% #!C% *#W:'$%-:W1*14F% 12% 4V#4% :Z% Q'$:(/x2% 1!M$/#21!0*F% #0/1!0% (:('*#41:!A% `!M$/#2/C%*:!0/&14F%V#2%('4%24$#1!2%:!%#%M#$/%1!C'24$F%4V#4%12%!/14V/$%2'ZZ1M1/!4*F%2"1**/C%!:$% 24#ZZ/C8% !:$% ($:&1C/C%Y14V% #!% #(($:($1#4/% M#$/% 1!Z$#24$'M4'$/A%LV12%Y1**%:!*F% M:!41!'/% 4:% 1!M$/#2/% #2% #% ($/22'$/% (:1!4% :&/$% 41-/8% F/4% Z/Y% (:*1MF%1!141#41&/28%#M$:22%4V/%QK8%V#&/%#44/-(4/C%4:%4#M"*/%4V12%($:W*/-A%%%

K*41-#4/*F8%4V/%-:&/-/!4%:Z%*#W:'$%12%1!Z*'/!M/C%WF%4V/%/M:!:-1M%#!C%C/-:0$#(V1M% C1ZZ/$/!M/2% :Z% $/01:!25% 2'MV% #2% C1ZZ/$/!4% */&/*2% :Z% $/#*% Y#0/%$#4/2% #!C% C1ZZ/$/!M/2% 1!% *#W:'$BZ:$M/% #0/% ($:Z1*/26hA% LV12% -/#!2% 4V#4% 1!%XY1!!1!0[%4V/%0*:W#*%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!48%4V/%#44$#M41&/!/22%:Z%#%!/Y%V:24%M:'!4$F%1!%4/$-2%:Z%Y#0/2%#!C%:((:$4'!141/2%:ZZ/$/C8%12%Z'!C#-/!4#*A%%%

Transformational Changes #

T*:W#**F8% 4V/$/% V#2% W//!% #% -:&/% Z$:-% ($:C'M4BW#2/C% 4:% "!:Y*/C0/BW#2/C% /M:!:-1/2% #!C% 4V12% Z'!C#-/!4#*% W'21!/22% 4$#!2Z:$-#41:!% V#2% V#C% #%(:Y/$Z'*% 1-(#M4% :!% 4V/% 0*:W#*% Y#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4;>ALV/% 2/$&1M/% 2/M4:$% !:Y%

6i%%N/*#% T#*0yMw1% /4% #*8% '%# )6YBD<# ?8I<6A8B9# 89# .<BDYG;C# .8=;7Z# $[8GG7# ?87=6AEOJ#+;AD<9#69C#,BG8EQ##

#####+;7MB97;78% 2V0#4/8%E'$$/F8%;>6;A%#6j%%S1""/*%N#$2*'!C%#!C%S#44V1#2%N'22/8%fS#"1!0% 4V/%-:24%:Z%QK%m#W:'$%S:W1*14Fg8%3QlE%L#2"%I:$M/%R/(:$428%;>6o8%2A;A%%

6h%%m#!4%l$14MV/448%);A#AO;8<#M;BMG;#EB=;Z#Y<;6[89I#AO;#I<8CGBE[#B9#G6YBD<#=BY8G8AQ8%3/!4/$%Z:$%T*:W#*%./&/*:(-/!48a#2V1!04:!8%.A3A%;>>?A%

;>% EMV:!% N//MV*/$% #!C% `#!A% 3A% a::CY#$C8% eLV/% 0*:W#*% fY#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4ge8% FBD<96G# BH#*9A;<96A8B96G#?696I;=;9AJ%31*4%678%;>>h8%2A;i^B;j7A%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%?

($:&1C/2%o;u%:Z%#**%r:W2b%1!%C/&/*:(/C%/M:!:-1/2%4V/%2/$&1M/%2/M4:$%12%/&/!%*#$0/$8% #MM:'!41!0% Z:$% i6A7u% :Z% #**% QK% r:W2;6A% 2% #% $/2'*48% M:-(#!1/2% #$/%1!M$/#21!0*F% C/(/!C/!4% :!% 4V/1$% (/:(*/% #!C8% 1!% (#$41M'*#$8% :!% 4V/1$% f4:(%4#*/!4g;;A% LV/% -:&/% 4:% #% "!:Y*/C0/BW#2/C% /M:!:-F% #*2:% -/#!2% 4V#4%:MM'(#41:!2%#!C%r:W%$/\'1$/-/!42%#$/%1!M$/#21!0*F%M:-(*/_8%$/\'1$1!0%V10V/$%*/&/*2%:Z%M:0!141&/%#W1*14FA%`4%12%4V/$/Z:$/%1-(:$4#!4%4V#4%M:-(#!1/2%#$/%#W*/%4:%/-(*:F8%"//(%#!C%1!M$/#2/%4V/%($:C'M41&14F%:Z%4V/1$%-:24%&#*'#W*/%"!:Y*/C0/%Y:$"/$2A%%

.O;#)8=8A6A8B97#BH#'%#,BG8EQ#89#1AA<6EA89I#.6G;9A#

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m12W:!%E4$#4/0F%Z:$%;>6>%#!C%4V/%Q'$:(/%;>;>%E4$#4/0F;oA%%LV/%Q'$:(/#!%3:--1221:!%V#2%#22/22/C%4V#4%Q'$:(/%Y:'*C%!//C%W/4Y//!% ^jo8>>>% #!C% i>>8>>>% Y:$"/$2% 1!% 4V/% 1!Z:$-#41:!% #!C% 4/MV!:*:0F%1!C'24$1/2%WF%;>678%#!C%:!/%-1**1:!%1!%4V/%V/#*4VM#$/%($:Z/221:!%WF%;>;>%1Z%14%12% 4:% $/-#1!% 1!4/$!#41:!#**F% M:-(/4141&/;7A% 2% 2'MV8% 4V/% Q'$:(/#!%3:--1221:!%:(/!/C%142%z'*F%;>6o%M:--'!1M#41:!%:!%V10V/$%/C'M#41:!%Y14V%4V/% 414*/% XQ'$:(/% #!C% 4V/% T*:W#*% R#M/% Z:$% L#*/!45% `2% Q'$:(/% #!% 44$#M41&/%./241!#41:!% Z:$% L#*/!4n;?A% LV/% /&1C/!M/% 2'00/242% 4V#4% 14% 12% !:4A% Q'$:(/% 12%'!C/$24::C% 4:% W/% *#001!0% W/V1!C% M:'!4$1/2% 2'MV% #2% '24$#*1#8% 3#!#C#8%EY14w/$*#!C% #!C% 4V/% KE% 1!% 142% !'-W/$% :Z% V10VB2"1**/C% -10$#!4% Y:$"/$2A%R/M/!4% $/(:$4% Z1!C2% 4V#4% 1--10$#!42% 4:% 4V/% QK% #$/% F:'!0/$% #!C% */22% Y/**%/C'M#4/C% 4V#!% 4V:2/% 1!% :4V/$% dQ3.% C/241!#41:!2;iALV/% Q'$:(/#!%

;6%% `!4/$!#41:!#*% m#W:'$% d$0#!1w#41:!8% fT*:W#*% Q-(*:F-/!4% L$/!C2g8% dM#"8% `md% T/!/&#%EY14w/$*#!C8%;>>jA%

;;%%.#!1/*%l1!"8%(<;;#6I;9A#96A8B9Z#AO;#HDAD<;#BH#NB<[89I#HB<#QBD<7;GHJ%a#$!/$%N::"28%9/Y%=:$"8%;>>6A%

;^%%3#$-/!%T:!w{*/w%/4%#*8%eLV/%QK%(/$Z:$-#!M/%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%V10V*FB2"1**/C%-10$#!42e8%-BA<;#'D<BM;#\#F6E]D;7#L;GB<7#*97A8ADA;#,BG8EQ#M6M;<8%;>6^A%

;o%% `W1CA%;7%%m'MF%3/$!#%#!C%3V:'%S/!0%]2'#!8%e`2%Q'$:(/%-1221!0%:'4%:!%Z:$/10!%4#*/!4ne%%98P;<78AQ#"B<GC#-;N7J%31*4%;j?8%;>6^8%2A6B7A%%%

;?%% `W1C%6A%;i%%dQ3.%#!C%QK8%eR/M$'141!0%`--10$#!4%a:$"/$25%Q'$:(/%;>6?e8%dQ3.%l'W*12V1!08%;>6?8%l#$12%

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn i%

3:--1221:!%M#*M'*#4/C%4V#4%4V/%QK8%Y14V%6Aiu%V10VB2"1**/C%-10$#!4%Y:$"/$2%:Z% 4V/% 4:4#*% /-(*:F/C% (:('*#41:!8% 12% W/V1!C% M:'!4$1/2% 2'MV% #2% '24$#*1#%<hAh7u@8%3#!#C#%<iA^u@8%EY14w/$*#!C%<7A^u@%#!C%4V/%KE%<^A;7u@;jA%%

d!/%:Z%Q'$:(/[2%-:24%Z'!C#-/!4#*%:W24#M*/2%4:%#44$#M41!0%0*:W#*%4#*/!4%#!C%V10V*F%2"1**/C%-10$#!42%12%4V/%!:!B/_124/!M/%:Z%#!%1!4$#BQ'$:(/#!%*#W:'$%-#$"/4A%`!%/ZZ/M48%4V12%-/#!2%4V#4%1--10$#!42%YV:%M:-/%4:%:!/%M:'!4$F%1!%4V/%QK%-'24%-#"/%#%Z$/2V%#((*1M#41:!%1Z%4V/F%Y12V%4:%$/*:M#4/%4:%#!:4V/$%S/-W/$%E4#4/;hA% LV12% -/#!2% 4V#4% 1!4/$!#*% -:W1*14F% 12% &/$F% *:Y8% /2(/M1#**F% YV/!%M:-(#$/C%Y14V%M:'!4$1/2%2'MV%#2%4V/%KE8%3#!#C#%:$% '24$#*1#A% MM:$C1!0%4:%4V/%dQ3.8%:!*F%^u%:Z%Y:$"1!0%#0/%QK%M141w/!2%*1&/%1!%#%S/-W/$%E4#4/%:4V/$%4V#!% 4V/% :!/% 4V/F% Y/$/% :$101!#**F% W:$!% 1!A% LV/% *#M"% :Z% #% M:--:!% *#W:'$%-#$"/4%-#F% #*2:% W/% #% C/4/$$/!4% Z:$% V10V*F% 2"1**/C% 1--10$#!428% #2% 4V/$/% #$/%1!M:-/% C12(#$141/2% W/4Y//!% C1ZZ/$/!4% QK% S/-W/$% E4#4/2A% T:!w{*/w% #!C%M:**/#0'/2%#$0'/% 4V#4% 1!%:$C/$% 4:%#44$#M4%-:$/% 1--10$#!42% 14% 12%!/M/22#$F% 4:%($:-:4/% 1!4$#BQK% -:W1*14F^>A% LV12% Y:'*C% #*2:% */#C% 4:% -:$/% /ZZ1M1/!4%C124$1W'41:!% :Z% *#W:'$% W/4Y//!% QK% M:'!4$1/28% #2% $/21C/!4% -10$#!42% Y:'*C%V#&/%4V/%Z$//C:-%4:%-:&/%4:%M:'!4$1/2%YV/$/%4V/1$%2"1**2%Y:'*C%W/%4V/%-:24%($:C'M41&/A%%%

2%.#!w/$%#!C%.1/4w%V#&/%(:1!4/C%:'48%4V/%QK%#4%#%W$:#C/$%*/&/*%f*#M"2%#44$#M41&/!/22% #2% #%C/241!#41:!g% Z:$% *#W:'$%-10$#!428%Y14V%R'221#% #!C%9:$4V% -/$1M#% :Z4/!% W/1!0% 4V/% ($/Z/$$/C% :(41:!2^6A% *4V:'0V% M:'!4$1/2% 4V#4%(#$41M1(#4/%1!%4V/%QKx2%Q#24/$!%l#$4!/$2V1(%<Q#l@8%2'MV%#2% $-/!1#8%N/*#$'2%#!C%S:*C:&#%#*$/#CF%V#&/%Y/**% /C'M#4/C%#!C%2"1**/C%Y:$"/$28% 4V/%-#r:$14F%<7ju@%:Z%Q#l%*#W:'$%-10$#!42%MV::2/%4:%-:&/%4:%R'221#%$#4V/$%4V#!%4V/%QKA%LV/% /#2F% 4$#!2Z/$#W1*14F% :Z% 2"1**28% R'221#!% *#!0'#0/% ($:Z1M1/!MF% #!C%M:-(#$#W*/%/C'M#41:!#*%2F24/-2%-/#!%4V#4%R'221#%$/-#1!2%#%-:$/%#44$#M41&/%($:2(/M4% 4V#!% 4V/%QK8%/&/!% 1Z%-10$#!42%V#&/% 4:%C:Y!0$#C/% 4V/1$% 2"1**2%#2%#%M:!2/\'/!M/A% LV12% $/($/2/!42% #% (:*1MF% Z#1*'$/8% 1!% 2:% Z#$% #2% 4V/% QK% V#2% !:4%#C/\'#4/*F%2V#(/C%-10$#41:!%#!C%/-(*:F-/!4%(:*1MF%4:%4#"/%#MM:'!4%:Z%4V12A%`4%V#2%Z#1*/C%4:%-#"/%14%/#21/$%Z:$%-10$#!42%4:%:W4#1!%2"1**2|*#!0'#0/%4$#1!1!0%:$% 4:% 4$#!2Z/$% 4V/1$% 2"1**2% #!C%/C'M#41:!% 1!4:% 4V/%QKA%l:4/!41#*%-10$#!42% #$/%#Y#$/%:Z% 4V/%W#$$1/$2% #!C% 4V/%!//C% Z:$%:Z4/!%M:-(/4141&/%:$% /_(/!21&/% 2"1**%

;j%%m'MF%3/$!#%#!C%3V:'%S/!0%]2'#!8%eLV/%$/01:!#*%C1-/!21:!%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%4#*/!45% m/22:!2% Z$:-% Z$#-1!0% 4V/% Q'$:(/#!% EM1/!41Z1M% c12#% #!C%N*'/% 3#$Ce8% FBD<96G# BH#'D<BM;69#,DYG8E#,BG8EQ8%31*4%;68%9:%h68%;>6o8%2Ai?Bh7A%%%

;h%%3#$-/!%T:!w{*/w%/4%#*8%eLV/%QK%(/$Z:$-#!M/%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%V10V*FB2"1**/C%-10$#!42e8%-BA<;#'D<BM;#\#F6E]D;7#L;GB<7#*97A8ADA;#,BG8EQ#M6M;<8%;>6^A%

^>%% `W1CA%^6%% */_#!C/$% .#!w/$% #!C% N#$W#$#% .1/4w8% eLV/% QKx2% Z#1*'$/% 4:% #44$#M4% 4V/% -:24% 4#*/!4/C%4/-(:$#$F%-10$#!42e8%mEQ%N*:08%;>6o8%2A6A%%%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%j

4$#1!1!0|/\'1&#*/!M/% \'#*1Z1M#41:!2% 1!% 4V/% QK8% #!C% 2:% #$/% ('4% :ZZ5%\'#*1Z1M#41:!% M:'$2/2% 4:% 1-($:&/% 4/MV!1M#*% :$% Y:$"1!0% 2"1**2% 4:% #*10!% 4V/-%Y14V% C1ZZ/$/!4%QK% $/\'1$/-/!42% #$/% '!C/$4#"/!%WF%:!*F% #% 2-#**% Z$#M41:!%:Z%-10$#!42%Z$:-%4V/%Q#l%#!C%:4V/$%#$/#2A%%LV/%QK%12%1!%#%(:2141:!%4:%-#"/%4V12%4$#!2Z/$%/#21/$%#!C%-:$/%#44$#M41&/%W'4%V#2%!:4%F/4% 1C/!41Z1/C%#!%#(($:($1#4/%1!24$'-/!4%4:%#MV1/&/%4V12A%%%

The Approaches of the EU Member States to Highly Skilled Migration##

Divergence in Attitudes: Scandinavian Welfare States

LV/%*#M"%:Z%-:W1*14F%12%#%M:!2/\'/!M/%:Z%C1&/$0/!4%(:*1M1/2%#!C%#4414'C/2%4:Y#$C2%4V/%-10$#41:!%:Z%V10V*F%2"1**/C%Y:$"/$2%1!%C1ZZ/$/!4%S/-W/$%E4#4/2A%LV/%EM#!C1!#&1#!%Y/*Z#$/%24#4/28%Z:$%/_#-(*/8%#$/%M#4/0:$12/C%WF%M:!2124/!4%1!Z*:Y2% #!C% :'4Z*:Y2% :Z% -10$#!428% /M:!:-1M% ($:2(/$14F% #!C% #% *#$0/% #!C%0/!/$:'2%Y/*Z#$/%24#4/A%`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oA% 2% 2'MV8%(:*1MF% 1!% 4V/2/%24#4/2% 12% !:Y% -:$/% :(/!% 4:% V10V*F% 2"1**/C% 1--10$#!42A% `!% I1!*#!C8% Z:$%/_#-(*/8% 4V/% S10$#41:!% l:*1MF% l$:0$#--/% Y#2% 1-(*/-/!4/C% 1!% ;>>i% 4:%W/44/$% -#!#0/% *#W:'$% -10$#41:!% #!C% ($/C1M4% *#W:'$% -#$"/4% !//C2% -:$/%#MM'$#4/*F%WF%*1!"1!0%4V/%$10V4%4:%Y:$"%4:%$/21C/!M/%(/$-142A%%%%%

Divergence in Attitudes: Western European Core States %

LV/%a/24/$!%Q'$:(/#!%M:$/%24#4/2%< '24$1#8%N/*01'-8%I$#!M/8%T/$-#!F8%m'_/-W:'$08% 4V/% 9/4V/$*#!C2% #!C% 4V/% KP@% V#&/% #*2:% 24$'00*/C% 4:% Z1!C% #%W#*#!M/% Y14V1!% 4V/1$% 1--10$#41:!% (:*1MFA% m1"/% 4V/% EM#!C1!#&1#!% Y/*Z#$/%24#4/28% 4V/2/% M:'!4$1/2% #$/%Y/#*4VF%#!C%V#&/%W//!%($1!M1(#*%C/241!#41:!2% Z:$%

^;%%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

^^% m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%%

^o%%3#$-/!%T:!w{*/w%/4%#*8%eLV/%QK%(/$Z:$-#!M/%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%V10V*FB2"1**/C%-10$#!42e8%-BA<;#'D<BM;#\#F6E]D;7#L;GB<7#*97A8ADA;#,BG8EQ#M6M;<8%;>6^A%

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn h%

1--10$#!42% 4:%Q'$:(/^7A%S#!F%:Z% 4V/2/% 24#4/2% V#&/% $/M/!4*F% $/Z:$-/C% 4V/1$%1--10$#41:!%(:*1M1/2% 1!% :$C/$% 4:% $/24$1M4% 1--10$#41:!b% W'4% V#&/% #*2:% 2:'0V4%Y#F2% 4:% #44$#M4% #!C% #**:Y% /-(*:F/$2% 4:% V1$/% V10V*F% 2"1**/C% -10$#!42^?A%T/$-#!F% #!C% 4V/% 9/4V/$*#!C28% Z:$% /_#-(*/8% 2/4% V10V% 4V$/2V:*C2% Z:$%/*101W1*14F8%YV1*24% #**:Y1!0% 1!4/$!#41:!#*% $/M$'14-/!4% 4:%W/% /_/-(4% Z$:-% 4V/%($:V1W141&/% M:!C141:!2% (*#M/C% :!% :$C1!#$F% *#W:'$% -#$"/42^iA% E1-1*#$*F8% 4V/%KP%V#2%-:&/C%4:Y#$C%#%f(:1!42BW#2/Cg%2F24/-%4V#4%C12M:'$#0/2%*:YB2"1**/C%W'4% ($:Z1M1/!4% /-(*:F//28% Y14V% *144*/% $/Z/$/!M/% 4:% 4V/% Z*'M4'#41:!% :Z% *#W:'$%C/-#!C2%1!%(#$41M'*#$%1!C'24$1/2A%LV/%(:*1MF%:W24#M*/%1!%4V12%/_#-(*/%12%4V#4%4V/%f(:1!42%2F24/-g%12%\'14/%$101C8%0$#!41!0%V10V/$%(:1!42%4:%f4$#C141:!#*g%#!C%($:Z/221:!#*% Z1/*C2% <C:M4:$28% *#YF/$28% /4MA@8% F/4% !:4% #MM:--:C#41!0% 4V/% Z#M4%4V#4% *:Y/$% 2"1**2% C:% !:4% /\'#4/% 4:% *:Y/$% ($:Z1M1/!MFA% I:$% 4V12% $/#2:!8% !:!B($:Z/221:!#*% W'4% V10V*F% 2"1**/C|2:'0V4% #Z4/$%Y:$"/$2% 1!% (#$41M'*#$% Z1/*C2% #$/%!:4% W/1!0% -#C/% /*101W*/% Z:$% 1--10$#41:!8% C/2(14/% 4V/% Z#M4% 4V#4% 2(/M1Z1M%1!C'24$1/2% -#F% $/\'1$/% 4V/2/% 2"1**2% 1!% :$C/$% 4:% -//4% 4#$0/42% #!C% 2'24#1!%M:-(/4141:!A%d4V/$%($:W*/-2%$/*#4/%4:%4V/%Z#M4%4V#4%YV1*/%4V/%M:$/%24#4/2%Y1**%2//"%#!C%#MM/(4%V10V*F%2"1**/C%#!C%($:Z/221:!#*%-10$#!4%Y:$"/$28%4V/$/%12%!:%2F24/-#41M% ($:M/C'$/% Z:$% \'#*1Z1M#41:!2% #!C% C/0$//2% 4:% W/% $/M:0!12/CA% LV12%($/2/!42% #% 210!1Z1M#!4% :W24#M*/% 1!% #44$#M41!0% \'#*1Z1/C% -10$#!42% 4:% 2(/M1Z1M%Z1/*C2^jA%E1-1*#$*F8%:4V/$%W'$/#'M$#41M%122'/2%v%2'MV%#2%&12#%(:*1MF%v%M:!41!'/%4:%24/-%4V/%-:&/-/!4%:Z%-10$#!42A% CC/C%4:%4V12%12%4V/%!//C2BC$1&/!%$#4V/$%4V#!%1!!:&#41:!BC$1&/!%!#4'$/%:Z%4V/%QK%24#4/x2%-10$#41:!%(:*1M1/28%1!%M:!4$#24%4:% 4V:2/% :Z% 4V/% KEA% 3'$$/!4*F8% 14% 12% !:4% (:221W*/% Z:$% Z:$/10!BW:$!%/!4$/($/!/'$2% 4:% 24#$4% 4V/1$% :Y!% W'21!/22/2% 1!% 4V/% QK% v% 4V12% $/($/2/!42% #%-#r:$%($:W*/-8%#2%4V/%KE%#!C%:4V/$%$/01:!2%#$/%-:$/%$/2(:!21&/%4:%4V12A%%%

New Member States %

9/Y%S/-W/$%E4#4/2%:Z%4V/%Q'$:(/#!%K!1:!%#*2:%Z#M/%#%M:-(*/_%(1M4'$/%YV/!%14%M:-/2%4:%1--10$#41:!A%9/Y%S/-W/$%E4#4/2%4V#4%r:1!/C%4V/%Q'$:(/#!%K!1:!% 1!% ;>>o% #!C% ;>>i% V#&/% 4F(1M#**F% /_(/$1/!M/C% -10$#!4% :'4Z*:Y28% #2%-10$#!42% 2//"% W/44/$% Y:$"1!0% M:!C141:!2% #!C% -:$/% 24#W*/% #!C% C/&/*:(/C%/M:!:-1/2% 1!% YV1MV% 4:% Y:$"^hA% ]:Y/&/$8% 21!M/% r:1!1!0% 4V/% QK% 4V/2/%

^7%%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%%

^?%% z:!#4V#!%3V#*:ZZ% #!C%T/:$0/%m/-#}4$/8% eS#!#01!0%]10V*FBE"1**/C%m#W:'$%S10$#41:!5% %3:-(#$#41&/% !#*F212%:Z%S10$#41:!%l:*1M1/2%#!C%3V#**/!0/2%1!%dQ3.%3:'!4$1/2e8%!'&L#$BE86G#'=MGBQ=;9A#69C#?8I<6A8B9#"B<[89I#,6M;<7#^_8%;>>hA%%

^i%% `W1CA%^j%%R'WF%T$:(#28% eS10$#41:!% #!C% `!!:&#41:!5% YVF% 12% Q'$:(/% Z#1*1!0% 4:% #44$#M4% 4V/% W/24% #!C%W$10V4/24ne8% 'D<BM;69# %98P;<78AQ# *97A8ADA;`/GBY6G# /BP;<969E;# ,<BI<6==;# M6M;<, ;>6^A%%%

^h%%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%6>

M:'!4$1/2% V#&/% 2//!% #% 24$/!04V/!1!0% #!C% '(0$#C1!0% :Z% 4V/1$% /M:!:-1/28%-/#!1!0%4V/F%#$/%W/01!!1!0%4:%2//%(#44/$!2%:Z%1--10$#41:!%4:%4V/1$%M:'!4$1/2A% 2%#%$/2'*48%2:-/%$/24$1M41&/%(:*1M1/2%V#&/%W//!%('4%1!%(*#M/8%2'MV%#2%4V/%!//C%Z:$%Y:$"%(/$-142%1!%N'*0#$1#%#!C%Q24:!1#o>A%%

d&/$#**8%Q'$:(/[2%*#M"%:Z%2'MM/22%1!%#44$#M41!0%0*:W#*% 4#*/!4%#!C%V10V*F%2"1**/C% 1--10$#41:!% 12% #44$1W'4#W*/% 4:% !/0#41&/% #4414'C/2% 4:% 1--10$#41:!%4V$:'0V:'4%Q'$:(/A%P#V#!/M%#!C%k1--/$-#!!%#$0'/%4V#4%Q'$:(/%M:!41!'/2%4:%2//%142/*Z%#2%#%Z:$4$/22o6%4V#4%&1/Y2%1--10$#!42%#2%#!%'!C/2/$&1!0%C$#1!%:!%$/2:'$M/28%C/($1&1!0%!#41&/%(:('*#41:!2%:Z%Y:$"%#!C%$/2:'$M/2A%LV12%/_4/$!#*%#!C% 1!4/$!#*%($:r/M41:!%V#2%#%C/4$1-/!4#*%/ZZ/M4%:!% */&/*2%:Z% 1--10$#41:!% 4:%Q'$:(/8% -/#!1!0% 4V#4% V10V*F% 2"1**/C% -10$#!42% #$/% -:$/% *1"/*F% 4:% 0:% 4:%M:'!4$1/2%2'MV%#2%4V/%KE8%3#!#C#%#!C% '24$#*1#A%%%%%

What is the EU Doing to Attract Highly Skilled Workers?#%

The EU Blue Card %

`!% :$C/$% 4:% M:-(/4/% 1!% 4V/% 0*:W#*% Y#$% Z:$% 4#*/!48% #CC$/22% *#W:'$%2V:$4#0/2% #!C% W/M:-/% -:$/% 1!!:&#41&/8% (:*1MF% -#"/$2% 1!% 4V/% QK% V#&/%24$/22/C% 4V/% 1-(:$4#!M/% :Z% $/01:!#*% M::(/$#41:!% #!C% M:**#W:$#41:!o;A% LV12%/-(V#212%:!%M::(/$#41:!%#!C%M:**#W:$#41:!%Y#2%2//!%4:%V#&/%4V/%(:4/!41#*%4:%#CC$/22%($:W*/-2%Y/%V#&/%#*$/#CF%1C/!41Z1/C8%2'MV%#2%4V/%*#M"%:Z%#%Q'$:(/#!%*#W:'$%-#$"/4% #!C% 1!4$#BQ'$:(/#!%-:W1*14FA%L:% #44$#M4% 0*:W#*% 4#*/!48% 14%Y#2%Z/*4% 4V#4% #% $/01:!#*% #(($:#MV% Y:'*C% 1!M$/#2/% */&/$#0/8% /_(#!C% 4V/% *#W:'$%-#$"/4%#!C%2/!C%#%M*/#$%-/22#0/%#W:'4%4V/%QK[2%:(/!!/22%4:%V10V*F%2"1**/C%1--10$#!42o^A% 2%2'MV8%1!%;>>6%#%M:--:!%*/0#*%Z$#-/Y:$"%Y#2%($:(:2/C%Z:$%-10$#41:!% 4:% 4V/% QKA% LV12% Y#28% V:Y/&/$8% $/r/M4/C% WF%S/-W/$% E4#4/2% YV:%2#Y%4V12%#2%C/&:*&1!0%4::%-'MV%(:Y/$%:!%#%M$141M#*%122'/ooA%E'W2/\'/!4*F8%#%X2/0-/!4/C[% #(($:#MV% Y#2% 1!4$:C'M/C8% YV1MV% 2#Y% C1ZZ/$/!4% -/#2'$/2% Z:$%C1ZZ/$/!4%4F(/2%:Z%-10$#41:!o7A%%

d!/% :Z% 4V/2/% 1!C1&1C'#*% -/#2'$/2% Y#2% 4V/% 3:'!M1*% .1$/M41&/%;>>h|7>|Q3%:Z%;7%S#F%;>>h%<V/!M/Z:$4V%"!:Y!%#2%4V/%N*'/%3#$C%.1$/M41&/@8%YV1MV%2:'0V4%4:%/24#W*12V%-:$/%#44$#M41&/%QK%/!4$F%#!C%$/21C/!M/%M:!C141:!2% o>%% `W1CA%o6%% `W1C%;6A%o;%%m'MF%3/$!#%#!C%3V:'%S/!0%]2'#!8%eLV/%$/01:!#*%C1-/!21:!%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%4#*/!45% m/22:!2% Z$:-% Z$#-1!0% 4V/% Q'$:(/#!% EM1/!41Z1M% c12#% #!C%N*'/% 3#$Ce8% FBD<96G# BH#'D<BM;69#,DYG8E#,BG8EQ8%31*4%;68%9:%h68%;>6o8%2Ai?Bh7A%%%

o^% m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%%

oo%%3#$-/!%T:!w{*/w%/4%#*8%eLV/%QK%(/$Z:$-#!M/%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%V10V*FB2"1**/C%-10$#!42e8%-BA<;#'D<BM;#\#F6E]D;7#L;GB<7#*97A8ADA;#,BG8EQ#M6M;<8%;>6^A%

o7%% `W1C%6iA%

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn 66

Z:$%($:Z/221:!#*2o?A% `4%Y#2%($:(:2/C% 4V12%Y:'*C%V/*(%Q'$:(/% 2'MM//C% 1!% 4V/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4%WF%#CC$/221!0%4V/%$/#2:!2%YVF%V10V*F%2"1**/C%1--10$#!42%Y/$/%*/22% 1!M*1!/C% 4:% Q'$:(/8% 2'MV% #2% #% *#M"% :Z%-:W1*14F% #!C% #C-1!124$#41&/% #!C%W'$/#'M$#41M% C1ZZ1M'*41/2oiA% LV/% N*'/% 3#$C% 12% W#2/C% :!% M:--:!% M$14/$1#5% #%Y:$"%M:!4$#M4b%#%-1!1-'-%2#*#$F%*/&/*%/\'1&#*/!4%4:%#%-1!1-'-%:Z%67>u%:Z%4V/% #!!'#*% #&/$#0/%Y#0/% :Z% 4V/% M:'!4$Fb% #!C% /C'M#41:!#*% #!C% ($:Z/221:!#*%\'#*1Z1M#41:!2A% `4% 12% #*2:% 1!4/!C/C% 4:% Z#M1*14#4/% -:W1*14F% Y14V1!% 4V/% QKA% !:4V/$% 1!C1&1C'#*% -/#2'$/8% 4V/% EM1/!41Z1M% c12#8% Y#2% #*2:% 1!4$:C'M/C% 4:%#44$#M4%4:(%2M1/!41242%#!C%$/2/#$MV/$2%B%1--10$#!42%YV:%#$/%V10V*F%\'#*1Z1/C%B%1!4:%Q'$:(/ojA%%%

Limits of the Blue Card %

LV/%:$101!#*%2M:(/%:Z%4V/%N*'/%3#$C%.1$/M41&/%Y#2%#-W141:'25%14%#**:Y/C%Z$//C:-%:Z%-:&/-/!48%#2%1--10$#!42%Y/$/%#**:Y/C%4:%-:&/%<#Z4/$%/10V4//!%-:!4V2@% Z$:-%:!/%QK%S/-W/$%E4#4/% 4:%#!:4V/$ohA%LV/%N*'/%3#$C%Y#2%#*2:%1!4/!C/C%4:%1-($:&/%4V/%4$/#4-/!4%:Z%V10V*F%2"1**/C%-10$#!42%Y14V1!%4V/%KP%4V$:'0V% Z$//C:-% :Z% #22:M1#41:!b% 4V/% $/M:0!141:!% :Z% 1!4/$!#41:!#*%\'#*1Z1M#41:!2b%#!C% 4V/%/\'#*% 4$/#4-/!4%:Z% 1--10$#!42%#!C%!#41&/%M141w/!2% 1!%4/$-2%:Z%Y:$"1!0%M:!C141:!28%2'MV%#2%(#F%#!C%C12-122#*7>A%]:Y/&/$8%4V/%N*'/%3#$C%.1$/M41&/%12%0/!/$#**F%$/0#$C/C%4:%V#&/%Z#**/!%2V:$4%:Z%142%M/!4$#*%0:#*76A%`4% C:/2% !:4% 01&/% V10V*F% 2"1**/C% -10$#!42% #MM/22% #!C% -:W1*14F% #M$:22% 4V/%Q'$:(/#!% *#W:'$% -#$"/48% #2% 4V/F% M#!% :!*F% -:&/% 4:% #% 2/M:!C% Q'$:(/#!%M:'!4$F% '!C/$% 24$1M4% M:!C141:!2A% aV1*24% 4V/% (:*1MF% Y#2% 1!4/!C/C% 4:% M$/#4/%V#$-:!F%#!C%'!14F% 1!% 1--10$#41:!%(:*1MF8% 1!C1&1C'#*%S/-W/$%E4#4/2% $/4#1!%4V/% $10V4% 4:% C/4/$-1!/% 4V/% /!4$F% :Z% 4V1$CBM:'!4$F% !#41:!#*2A% LV/% EM1/!41Z1M%c12#%V#2%#*2:%V#C%*1-14/C%2'MM/22A%d!*F%i8>>>%EM1/!41Z1M%c12#2%Y/$/%122'/C%1!%;>668%#%!'-W/$%4V#4%Z#**2%2V:$4%:Z%4V/%-1**1:!%$/2/#$MV/$2%!//C/C%Z:$%4V/%QK%4:%W/M:-/%X4V/%-:24%CF!#-1M%#!C%M:-(/4141&/%"!:Y*/C0/BW#2/C%/M:!:-F%1!%4V/%Y:$*C[%WF%;>;>7;A%%%%

o?%%m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%

oi%% z:/*%L$#MV4-#!%/4%#*A%eLV/%T*:W#*%3:-(/4141:!%Z:$%L#*/!4g8%.O;#(G;AEO;<#$EOBBG#BH#)6N#69C#L8MGB=6EQ#,6M;<, L'Z42%K!1&/$214F,%;>6>8% 2A6o8%6hB;>A%#

oj%%m'MF%3/$!#%#!C%3V:'%S/!0%]2'#!8%e`2%Q'$:(/%-1221!0%:'4%:!%Z:$/10!%4#*/!4ne%%98P;<78AQ#"B<GC#-;N7J%31*4%;j?8%;>6^8%2A6B7A%%%

oh%%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

7>%% `W1CA%76%%m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%%

7;%%m'MF%3/$!#%#!C%3V:'%S/!0%]2'#!8%e`2%Q'$:(/%-1221!0%:'4%:!%Z:$/10!%4#*/!4ne%%98P;<78AQ#"B<GC#-;N7J%31*4%;j?8%;>6^8%2A6B7A%%%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%6;

aV#4%Y#2%4V/%$/#2:!%Z:$%4V/%*1-14/C%2M:(/%:Z%4V/%N*'/%3#$Cn%LV12%M#!8%($1-#$1*F8%W/%#44$1W'4/C%4:%#%C1&/$0/!M/%1!%4V/%#4414'C/2%:Z%S/-W/$%E4#4/2%4:%4V/%N*'/%3#$C%.1$/M41&/7^A%a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oA% LV/%KP% #!C% `$/*#!C8% YV:% V#C% #*$/#CF% #C-144/C% *#$0/%!'-W/$2% :Z%Y:$"/$2% Z$:-%QK%S/-W/$% E4#4/28% :((:2/C% 4V/% (:*1MF% #!C% 4V/%:(/!1!0% :Z% 4V/1$% -#$"/42% 4:% 4V1$CBM:'!4$F% !#41:!#*2A% % !'-W/$% :Z% M:$/%a/24/$!% Q'$:(/#!% 24#4/28% 2'MV% #2% '24$1#8% ./!-#$"8% T/$-#!F% #!C% 4V/%9/4V/$*#!C28%:((:2/C% 4V/%.1$/M41&/%:!% 4V/%0$:'!C2%:Z% 4V/1$% X2:&/$/10!4F[77A%LV/2/%24#4/2%C1C%!:4%Y#!4%4:%01&/%'(%4V/1$%2:&/$/10!4F%#!C%M:!4$:*%:!%#!%122'/%4V#4%Y#2%2:%1-(:$4#!4%4:%4V/1$%:Y!%/M:!:-1/2%#!C%/*/M4:$#4/7?A%%%%

!:4V/$%($:W*/-%12%4V/%'!C/$/241-#41:!%:Z%4V/%C1&/$01!0%*#W:'$%-#$"/4%!//C2A%TJ-J2%24#4/2%4V#4%21!M/%M:'!4$1/2%#**%V#&/%C1ZZ/$/!4%!//C28%:!/%V10VB%2"1**/C% 1--10$#41:!% ($:0$#--/%Y1**% W/% '!#W*/% 4:% M#4/$% /ZZ/M41&/*F% Z:$% 4V/%YV:*/% :Z% 4V/% M:--:!% -#$"/47iA% TJ-J2% #*2:% #CC2% 4V#4% 21!M/% 4V/% !//C% Z:$%2"1**/C% *#W:'$% 12% 2($/#C% /&/!*F% W/4Y//!% S/-W/$% E4#4/2% #!C% 1!C'24$1/28% #%M/!4$#*1w/C% (:*1MF% Z:$% 4V/% YV:*/% :Z% 4V/% QK% :!% #% 4:(1M% #2% 2/!2141&/% #2%1--10$#41:!%12%'!*1"/*F%4:%W/%2//!%#2%4V/%X$10V4[%C1$/M41:!%WF%-#!F%S/-W/$%E4#4/27jA%%

LV/% /M:!:-1M% M:!4/_4% #*2:% *1-14/C% 4V/% 1-(#M4% #!C% 2M:(/% :Z% 4V/% N*'/%3#$C% .1$/M41&/A% .'$1!0% !/0:41#41:!2% Z:$% 4V/% .1$/M41&/8% 4V/% /M:!:-1M% M$1212%24#$4/C7hA%LV/%/M:!:-1M%M$#2V%-#C/%14%V#$C/$%Z:$%S/-W/$%E4#4/2%4:%1!4$:C'M/%

7^%%m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%

7o%%%̀ W1CA%77%%R:C/$1M"% l#$"/2% #!C% E4/ZZ/!% !0/!/!C48% f Z4/$% 4V/% N*'/% 3#$C% QK% l:*1MF% :!% ]10V*F%~'#*1Z1/C%S10$#41:!5%LV$//%a#F2%d'4%:Z%4V/%`-(#22/”8 ;89<8EO#0aGG#$A8HAD9I#L87ED778B9#,6M;<8%N/$*1!5%]/1!$1MV%NO**%E41Z4'!08 ;>6>A%

7?%% !4V:!F% S/221!#8% .O;# )BI8E7# 69C# ,BG8A8E7# BH# ,B7A\""**# ?8I<6A8B9# AB# ";7A;<9#'D<BM;, 3#-W$1C0/5%3#-W$1C0/%K!1&/$214F%l$/228%;>>iA%

7i%%=#21!%P/$/-%TJ-J28% eQK%N*'/%3#$C%EMV/-/5%LV/%R10V4%E4/(% 1!% 4V/%R10V4%.1$/M41:!ne%'D<BM;69#FBD<96G#BH#?8I<6A8B9#69C#)6NJ%31*4%6;8%9:%o8%;>6>8%2AoohA%%

7j%%%̀ W1CA%o7>A%7h% m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%%

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn 6^

(:*1M1/2%4V#4%/!M:'$#0/C%1--10$#41:!A%`!%41-/2%:Z%V10V%'!/-(*:F-/!48%(#FBZ$//w/2% #!C% M'428% 14% Y#2% V#$C% Z:$% 0:&/$!-/!42% 4:% r'241ZF% #C-1441!0% V10V/$%*/&/*2%:Z% 1--10$#!42A%LV12% 12% #%W$:#C/$% 4V/-/% 1!%(:*141M28% #2%(:*141M1#!2%#$/%V/#&1*F% 1!Z*'/!M/C% WF% ('W*1M% :(1!1:!% :!% M:!4$:&/$21#*% 122'/2% *1"/%1--10$#41:!?>A% `4% 12%#*2:%4V/%M#2/%4V#4%!#41:!#*%($/Z/$/!M/2%#$/%#*2:%*1"/*F%4:%2V1Z4%#Z4/$%($:Z:'!C%MV#!0/2%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%/M:!:-1M%*#!C2M#(/?6A%%%

I'$4V/$-:$/8% 4V:2/% M:'!4$1/2% 4V#4% #*$/#CF% V#C% :(/!% #!C% 2'MM/22Z'*%(:*1M1/2% 1!% #44$#M41!0% V10V*F% 2"1**/C% 1--10$#!428% 2'MV% #2% 4V/%KP8%Y/$/% !:4%1!4/$/24/C%1!%4V/%N*'/%3#$C%#2%4V/%W/!/Z142%Y/$/%!:4%M:!21C/$/C%4:%:'4Y/10V%4V/% M:242?;A% d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

% % Z'$4V/$% #2(/M4% 4V/% (:*1M1/2% C1C% !:4% #CC$/22% 12% 4V/% 1!4/$!#*% #!C%/_4/$!#*% ($:r/M41:!% :Z% 1--10$#41:!% 1!%Q'$:(/A% LV/% (/$M/(41:!% :Z% Q'$:(/#!%#4414'C/2% #2% !/0#41&/% #!C% 1!2'*#$% Y#2% (/$(/4'#4/C% 4V$:'0V% 4V/% /&/!4'#*%Z$#-1!0%:Z%4V/%N*'/%3#$C%.1$/M41&/?o%M:!M/(4'#*12/2%Z$#-1!0%#2%X#%($:M/22%:Z%2/*/M41!0% #!C% /-(V#2121!0% #2(/M42% :Z% #!% 122'/% #MM:$C1!0% 4:% #!% :&/$$1C1!0%/&#*'#41&/%:$%#!#*F41M#*%M$14/$1:![A%LV/%Z1!#*%#C:(4/C%*/012*#41:!%Z:$%4V/%N*'/%3#$C% .1$/M41&/% ($:r/M4/C% YV#4% 3/$!#% #!C% 3V:'% 4/$-% #% 24$:!0% X-10$#41:!%Z$#-/[A%`!%*1!/%Y14V%XZ:$4$/22[%Q'$:(/8%4V12%-10$#41:!%Z$#-/%/-(V#212/C%2#Z/%#!C%2/M'$/%W:$C/$2?78%#2%Y/**%#2%4V/%1-(:$4#!M/%:Z%$:W'24%M:!4$:*%:Z%!#41:!#*%W:$C/$2%1!%:$C/$%4:%C/4/$%'!Y#!4/C%-10$#41:!??A%LV12%Y#2%#%MV#!0/%Z$:-%4V/% ?>%%L/$$F% T1&/!2% #!C% C#-% m'/C4"/8% eQ'$:(/#!% `--10$#41:!% l:*1M1/2% 1!% 3:-(#$#41&/%l/$2(/M41&/e8%&B=M6<6A8P;#'D<BM;69#,BG8A8E78%c:*%^8%9:%68%;>>78%2A6v;;A%%

?6%%% !C$/Y%S:$#&M21"8%.O;#&OB8E;#HB<#'D<BM;J#3:$!/**%K!1&/$214F%l$/228%9/Y%=:$"8%6hhjA%?;% m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%%

?^%%%̀ W1CA%?o%%I#*"%.#&14/$8%eI$#-1!0%W1:4/MV!:*:0F%(:*1MF%1!%4V/%Q'$:(/#!%K!1:!e8%1+'-1#"B<[89I#,6M;<8%9:%78%

%%%%;>6;8%2A6A%?7%%m'MF%3/$!#%#!C%3V:'%S/!0%]2'#!8%eLV/%$/01:!#*%C1-/!21:!%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%4#*/!45% m/22:!2% Z$:-% Z$#-1!0% 4V/% Q'$:(/#!% EM1/!41Z1M% c12#% #!C%N*'/% 3#$Ce8% FBD<96G# BH#'D<BM;69#,DYG8E#,BG8EQ8%31*4%;68%9:%h68%;>6o8%2Ai?Bh7A%%%

??%%m'MF% 3/$!#8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/% C1&/$214F% :Z% QK% -10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% ($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!%:Z% 4V/%N*'/%3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8%,BG8EQ#$ADC8;7, 31*4%^o8%9:%;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%6o

1!141#*% Z$#-1!0% :Z% 4V/% N*'/% 3#$C% #!C% EM1/!41Z1M% c12#% .1$/M41&/28% :!%M:-(/4141&/!/22% #!C% /_M/**/!M/A% LV12% V#C% /-(V#212/C% 4V/% 1-(:$4#!M/% :Z%1!M$/#21!0% V10VB2"1**/C% 1--10$#41:!8% #2% Q'$:(/% Y#2% Z#**1!0% W/V1!C% 1!% 4V/%0*:W#*%/M:!:-1M%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%4#*/!4?iA%%

2% EM1/!41Z1M% c12#2% Y/$/% :!*F% 1!4$:C'M/C% 1!% ;>>7% #!C% N*'/% 3#$C2% 1!%;>>i8%4V/1$%:&/$#**%/ZZ/M42%#$/%C1ZZ1M'*4%4:%/&#*'#4/%#!C%#2M/$4#1!%#4%4V12%(:1!4%1!%41-/A%aV#4%12%M*/#$8%V:Y/&/$8%12%4V#4%4V/%(:*1M1/2%V#&/%!:4%0:!/%Z#$%/!:'0V%1!%#CC$/221!0%4V/%#C-1!124$#41&/%#!C%W'$/#'M$#41M%W#$$1/$2%4:%1--10$#41:!?jA%%

.O;#'%#1I6897A#&B=M;A8AB<7Z# BN#$DEE;77HDG#87#.O;#'%4#%

*4V:'0V% 1!C1&1C'#*% S/-W/$% E4#4/2% #!C% 4V/% QK% V#&/% 1!4$:C'M/C%(:*1M1/2% 4:% #44$#M4% 0*:W#*% 4#*/!48% 4V/F% 241**% *#0% W/V1!C% M:'!4$1/2% 2'MV% #2%3#!#C#8% 4V/%KE%#!C% '24$#*1#A% 2%Y/%V#&/%C12M'22/C8% 4V12% 12% 1!%(#$4%C'/% 4:%4V/% $/24$1M41&/% #4414'C/2% #!C% (:*1M1/2% 4:Y#$C2% 1--10$#41:!% 1!% XZ:$4$/22[%Q'$:(/?hA%LV12%12%#*2:%C'/%4:%4V/%#44$#M41&/!/22%:Z%M:-(/414:$%M:'!4$1/2A%LV12%#44$#M41&/!/22%M#!%W/%#44$1W'4/C%4:%#%$#!0/%:Z%Z/#4'$/2%:Z% *1Z/% 1!%3#!#C#8%KE%#!C% '24$#*1#8% 2'MV% #2% #0/% */&/*28% 4V/% \'#*14F% :Z% *1Z/8% /_1241!0% 1--10$#!4%M:--'!141/2%#!C%4V/%Z#M4%4V#4%4V/F%#$/%Q!0*12V%2(/#"1!0i>A%LV/2/%Z/#4'$/2%:Z%*1Z/%V#&/%-/#!4%4V/$/%#$/%V10V%*/&/*2%:Z%C/-#!C%Z$:-%V10V*F%2"1**/C%-10$#!42A%`4%#*2:%/_(*#1!2%YVF%4V/%KP%12%2:%XZ#$%#V/#C%:Z%4V/%QK%#&/$#0/%1!%#44$#M41!0%4V/%W$10V4/24%#!C%W/24[i6A%%%

I'$4V/$-:$/8% M:-(/414:$% M:'!4$1/2% V#&/%C/&/*:(/C%(:*1M1/2% 4V#4% #44$#M4%Y/**B4$#1!/C% #!C% Z*/_1W*/% 1!C1&1C'#*2% YV:% V#&/% ($#M41M#*% /_(/$1/!M/i;A% `!%3#!#C#8%Z:$%/_#-(*/8%4V/$/%12%#%XV'-#!%M#(14#*%-:C/*[%YV/$/%2"1**/C%Y:$"/$2%#$/% 2/*/M4/C% Z:$% $/21C/!M/%W#2/C%:!%#%(:1!4% 2F24/-% 4V#4% #**:M#4/2%(:1!42% Z:$%/M:!:-1M#**F% #44$#M41&/% \'#*141/28% 2'MV% #2% /C'M#41:!% #!C% "!:Y*/C0/% :Z%I$/!MV% #!C% Q!0*12Vi^A% % 21-1*#$% (:1!42BW#2/C% -:C/*% /_1242% 1!% '24$#*1#8%

?i%%m'MF%3/$!#%#!C%3V:'%S/!0%]2'#!8%eLV/%$/01:!#*%C1-/!21:!%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%4#*/!45% m/22:!2% Z$:-% Z$#-1!0% 4V/% Q'$:(/#!% EM1/!41Z1M% c12#% #!C%N*'/% 3#$Ce8% FBD<96G# BH#'D<BM;69#,DYG8E#,BG8EQ8%31*4%;68%9:%h68%;>6o8%2Ai?Bh7A%%%

?j%%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

?h%% `W1C%;6A%i>%% z:!#4V#!%3V#*:ZZ% #!C%T/:$0/%m/-#}4$/8% eS#!#01!0%]10V*FBE"1**/C%m#W:'$%S10$#41:!5% %3:-(#$#41&/% !#*F212%:Z%S10$#41:!%l:*1M1/2%#!C%3V#**/!0/2%1!%dQ3.%3:'!4$1/2e8%!'&L#$BE86G#'=MGBQ=;9A#69C#?8I<6A8B9#"B<[89I#,6M;<7#^_8%;>>hA%%

i6%%Q*1w#W/4V%3:**/448%eLV/%l$:(:2/C%Q'$:(/#!%N*'/%3#$C%EF24/-5% $-1!0%Z:$%4V/%T*:W#*%a#$%:!%L#*/!4ne%?8I<6A8B9#,BG8EQ#*97A8ADA;#L87ED778B9#M6M;<,%;>>j8%2A7oA%

i;%% z:/*%L$#MV4-#!%/4%#*A%eLV/%T*:W#*%3:-(/4141:!%Z:$%L#*/!4g8%.O;#(G;AEO;<#$EOBBG#BH#)6N#69C#L8MGB=6EQ#,6M;<, L'Z42%K!1&/$214F,%;>6>8% 2A6o8%6hB;>A%%

i^%% `W1CA%

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn 67

YV1MV%#**:M#4/2%(:1!42%W#2/C%:!%\'#*141/2%2'MV%#2%*#!0'#0/8%Y:$"%/_(/$1/!M/%#!C% '24$#*1#!%/C'M#41:!#*%\'#*1Z1M#41:!2ioA%`!%4V/%KE8%4V/$/%12%#*2:%#%0$/#4/$%*/&/*% :Z% :(/!!/22% 4:% 1--10$#41:!% M:-(#$/C% 4:% Q'$:(/i7A% LV12% 12% W#2/C% :!%C/-#!C%Z$:-%4V/%*#W:'$%-#$"/4%#!C%4V/%!//C2%:Z%/-(*:F/$2A%aV1*/%3#!#C#%#!C% '24$#*1#% #C-14% #% 2'W24#!41#*% ($:(:$41:!% 4V$:'0V% 4V/1$% l:1!42% E/*/M41:!%2F24/-28%/-(*:F/$%2(:!2:$2V1(%12%:Z%0$/#4/$%1-(:$4#!M/%1!%4V/%KEA% 2%2'MV8%4V/% -/$1M#!%2F24/-%Y:$"2%*1"/%#%X&#*&/[%YV/$/%!'-W/$2%#$/%*::2/!/C%#!C%410V4/!/C% W#2/C% :!% *#W:'$% C/-#!C2b% #!C% W'$/#'M$#41M% #!C% #C-1!124$#41&/%($:M/C'$/2%#$/%-:$/%$/2(:!21&/%#!C%f:(/!g%4:%122'/2%2'MV%#2%4V/%$/M:0!141:!%:Z%C/0$//2%#!C%\'#*1Z1M#41:!2A%%%

4% 4V/% 2#-/% 41-/8% 4V/% 1!M$/#21!0*F% (:('*124|$10V4BY1!0% -:&/-/!4% 1!%!#41:!#*%(:*141M2%#M$:22%4V/%M:$/%24#4/2%:Z%4V/%QK%V#28%1!%$/M/!4%F/#$28%(*#M/C%#%0$/#4/$%24$#1!%#!C%W#$$1/$%:!%4V/%#&#1*#W1*14F%#!C%-:W1*14F%:Z%V10V*F%2"1**/C%Y:$"/$2A% S10$#41:!% (:*1M1/2% 1!8% Z:$% /_#-(*/8% I$#!M/8% 4V/% KP% #!C% 4V/%9/4V/$*#!C2% V#&/% W/M:-/% 1!M$/#21!0*F% $/24$1M41&/% 4:% -10$#41:!% per se8%(*#M1!0% Z'$4V/$% :W24#M*/2% 1!% 4V/% (#4V% :Z% 4V/% QK% -//41!0% 142% &#$F1!0% #!C%CF!#-1M%*#W:'$%#!C%2"1**%!//C2A% %$/&1/Y%M:!C'M4/C%WF%4V/%T/$-#!%`!2414'4/%Z:$% QM:!:-1M% R/2/#$MV% <.`a% N/$*1!@8% W#2/C% :!% #% 2'$&/F% :Z% (:*1M1/2% #!C%/_(/$4% :(1!1:!8% V10V*10V4/C% f4V#4% C/2(14/% #% !'-W/$% :Z% (:2141&/% $/M/!4%C/&/*:(-/!428% Q'$:(/% *#M"2% #% M:!2124/!4% 24$#4/0F% 4:% #CC$/22% 4V12% MV#**/!0/%/ZZ/M41&/*Fgi?A% aV1*24% 4V/% KE% <#!C% :4V/$% M:'!4$1/2@% V#&/% #% 21!0*/% (:*1MF%2F24/-% 4:% 1!4$:C'M/% MV#!0/2% 4:%-10$#41:!8% 4V/%QK% 12% Z:$M/C% 4:% W#*#!M/%QK%(:*1MF% #0#1!24% 4V/% (:Y/$% CF!#-1M2% #!C% ($/22'$/2% :Z% (#$41M'*#$% S/-W/$%E4#4/2A% 9/Y% (:*1MF% 1!141#41&/2% 4:% #CC$/22% 4V12% ($:W*/-% V#&/% :!*F% W//!%1!4$:C'M/C% 1!% 4V/% *#44/$% (#$4% :Z% 4V/% ;>>>2A% 2% 2'MV8% 4V/% /&1C/!M/% W#2/% 4:%#22/22%4V/%/ZZ/M41&/!/22%:Z%QK%(:*1M1/2%<2'MV%#2%4V/%N*'/%3#$C8%/4MA@%C:/2%!:4%F/4%/_124A%%

S:$/:&/$8%!'-/$:'2%24'C1/2%2V:Y%4V#4%#C-1!124$#41&/%:W24#M*/2%/-/$0/%#2% #-:!0% 4V/% ($1-#$F% W#$$1/$2% 4:% #44$#M41!0% V10V*F% 2"1**/C%-10$#!425% 122'/2%2'MV%#2%2V:$4%(/$-142%-/#!%4V#4%-10$#!42%C:%!:4%V#&/%#%fM*/#$%:'4*::"g%#2%4:%4V/1$% Z'4'$/8% 1!M*'C1!0%$/*#41!0% 4:%Y/*Z#$/% $10V42%#!C%Z'4'$/%M141w/!2V1(A%d!/%:Z%4V/%($:W*/-2%24/--1!0%Z$:-%4V12%-#F%W/%(/$M/(4'#*%#2%Y/**%#2%f#M4'#*g%B%#%(/$M/(41:!%#-:!0%-10$#!42%4V#4%4V/%W#$$1/$2%/_(/$1/!M/C%1!%4V/%QK8%$/*#41&/%4:%4V/%W/!/Z142%#!C%:((:$4'!141/2%4V#4%M#!%W/%Z:'!C%1!%:4V/$%$/01:!28%#$/%!:4%

io%% `W1CA%i7%%m'MF% 3/$!#8% eLV/% &#$1/41/2% :Z% V10VB2"1**/C% 1--10$#41:!% (:*1M1/25% M:#*141:!2% #!C% (:*1MF%:'4('42% 1!% #C&#!M/C% 1!C'24$1#*% M:'!4$1/2e8%FBD<96G# BH#'D<BM;69#,DYG8E#,BG8EQ, 31*4% 6?8%9:%68%;>>h8%2A6ooB6?6A%%%

i?%%.`a% N/$*1!8% f]10V*FB2"1**/C% 1--10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% Q'$:(/g8% L87ED778B9# ,6M;<# WV_XJ%;>668%2A;A%%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%6?

fY:$4V%14gA%]:Y/&/$8%*/22%$/2/#$MV%V#2%W//!%M:!C'M4/C%:!%4V/%Y#F%1!%YV1MV%(/$M/(41:!2%1!Z*'/!M/%2"1**2%2V:$4#0/2A%%

Bureaucratic Advantage %

d!/%:Z% 4V/%$/#2:!2%YVF%Q'$:(/% *#02%W/V1!C% 142%M:-(/414:$2% 1!% 4V/%Y#$%Z:$% 4#*/!4% *1/2% 1!% 4V/% W'$/#'M$#41M% #!C% #C-1!124$#41&/% MV#**/!0/2% 4V#4% V10V*F%2"1**/C%1--10$#!42%Z#M/A%3/$!#%#!C%3V:'%#$0'/%4V#4%YV/!%/-10$#41!08%V10V*F%2"1**/C% Y:$"/$2% *::"% Z:$% *:Y% 4#_% $#4/2% #!C% W$/#"2% Z:$% Z:$/10!% Y:$"/$2b% #%2(//CF%($:M/221!0% 41-/%Z:$%#((*1M#41:!2b%#%M*/#$%($:M/22% Z:$% 4V/%$/M:0!141:!%:Z% 1!4/$!#41:!#*% \'#*1Z1M#41:!2b% #!C% M*/#$% $10V42% Z:$% Z#-1*F% $/'!1Z1M#41:!A% `!%M:!4$#24% 4:% 4V128% Q'$:(/#!% 1--10$#!42% Z#M/% -#!F% #C-1!124$#41&/% #!C%W'$/#'M$#41M% MV#**/!0/2A% L#_% 2F24/-28% Z:$% /_#-(*/8% #$/% :Z4/!% /_M/221&/*F%M:-(*/_% #!C% C:% !:4% #**:Y% Z:$8% :$% *1-148% 4#_% C/C'M41W*/2iiA% `!% M:!4$#248%L$#MV4-#!% #!C% M:**/#0'/2% #$0'/% 4V#4% 1--10$#41:!% 2F24/-2% Y14V1!% 3#!#C#8% '24$#*1#%#!C%4V/%KE%#$/%-:$/%CF!#-1M%#!C%*/22%W'$/#'M$#41M#**F%MV#**/!01!0%Z:$%1--10$#!42ijA%LV12%V#2%W//!%#%($:W*/-%Y14V%24$1M4*F%(:1!42BW#2/C%<$#4V/$%4V#!%!//C2|2"1**2%C$1&/!@%1--10$#41:!%(:*1M1/28%#2%4V/%(:1!42%2F24/-2%#$/%!:4%2'ZZ1M1/!4*F% CF!#-1M% 4:% $/2(:!C% 4:% Z*'M4'#41:!2% #!C% MV#!0/2% 1!% *#W:'$%C/-#!C28%1!%M:!4$#24%4:%M:'!4$1/2%2'MV%#2%4V/%KE%#!C%3#!#C#A%%

4% 4V/% 2#-/% 41-/8% /ZZ:$42% #$/% W/1!0%-#C/% 4:% #CC$/22% 4V/2/% MV#**/!0/2A%E:-/%S/-W/$%E4#4/2%V#&/%/!#M4/C%*/0#*%($:&121:!2%4:%Z#M1*14#4/%4V/%2/*/M41:!%#!C% /!4$F% :Z% -10$#!428% YV1*/% :4V/$2% V#&/% C/Z1!/C% 2(/M1Z1M% V10VB2"1**/C%M#4/0:$1/2% :Z% -10$#!4% Y:$"/$2% YV:% Y1**% V#&/% #% 21-(*1Z1/C|24$/#-*1!/C%#C-1!124$#41&/% ($:M/C'$/% 4:% !/0:41#4/A% N'4% M:'!4$1/2% Y14V% :!*F% #% $/M/!4%V124:$F%:Z%2"1**/C%-10$#41:!%#$/%*/22%*1"/*F%4:%V#&/%#(($:($1#4/%#$$#!0/-/!428%/&/!%1Z%4V/F%C:%V#&/%2"1**2%2V:$4#0/2A%a14V%4V/%-:&/-/!4%:Z%M:$/%M:'!4$1/2%4:Y#$C2% !/Y% (:*1M1/28% 4V12% 214'#41:!% -#F% 0$#C'#**F% MV#!0/A% LV/% 122'/8%V:Y/&/$8%12%YV/4V/$%14%M#!%MV#!0/%fast enough 4:%-//4%C/-#!CA%LV/2/%!/Y%S/-W/$%E4#4/28% #21C/% Z$:-%]'!0#$F% <YV:%V#&/% 4V/%-:24% /ZZ/M41&/%(:*1M1/2%#-:!0% 4V/% !/Y% 24#4/2@8% #$/% */22% *1"/*F% 4:% :ZZ/$% 4#_% /_/-(41:!2b% 4:% V#&/% #%2"1**2%2F24/-%#!C%($/Z/$$/C%*1242%:Z%2"1**2|($:Z/221:!2b%:$%4:%V#&/%2/4%2(/M1Z1M%2"1**2|/#$!1!0% 4V$/2V:*C2% 1!% :$C/$% 4:%define fV10V*F% 2"1**/C%Y:$"/$2g%Y14V1!%4V:2/% 2(/M1Z1M%M:'!4$1/2% <1!%M:!4$#248% Z:$%/_#-(*/8% 4:%T/$-#!F8% '24$1#%#!C%4V/%KP@A%%%

ii%%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

ij%% z:/*%L$#MV4-#!%/4%#*A%eLV/%T*:W#*%3:-(/4141:!%Z:$%L#*/!4g8%.O;#(G;AEO;<#$EOBBG#BH#)6N#69C#L8MGB=6EQ#,6M;<, L'Z42%K!1&/$214F,%;>6>8% 2A6o8%6hB;>A#

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn 6i

Temporary Versus Permanent Migration %

%"/F%W'$/#'M$#41M%#!C%#C-1!124$#41&/%MV#**/!0/%4V#4%4'$!2%0*:W#*%4#*/!4%#Y#F% Z$:-% Q'$:(/% 12% 4V/% C1ZZ1M'*4F% 1!% -:&1!0% Z$:-% #% 4/-(:$#$F% 4:% #%(/$-#!/!4% &12#A% `!% 4V/%KE8%3#!#C#% #!C% '24$#*1#8% 4V/$/% 12% M*/#$% (:$4#W1*14F%W/4Y//!% 4/-(:$#$F% #!C% (/$-#!/!4% &12#2% Z:$% V10V*F% 2"1**/C% -10$#!42ihA% 2%N:FC8%m:Y/**%#!C% &#4#%#$0'/8%M*#$14F%1!%(:*1MF%#!C%(:$4#W1*14F%1!%&12#2%V#&/%W//!%#%Z'!C#-/!4#*%C/&/*:(-/!4%1!%1--10$#41:!%(:*1MF%1!%3#!#C#8% '24$#*1#%#!C% 4V/% KEj>A% 3:-(#$#41&/*F8% 4V/% #W1*14F% :Z% 1--10$#!42% 4:% -:&/% Z$:-% #%4/-(:$#$F%4:%#%(/$-#!/!4%&12#%1!%Q'$:(/%12%M:-(*/_%#!C%C1ZZ1M'*4A%S:24%&12#2%1!%Q'$:(/% #$/% 4/-(:$#$F%#!C% 4V/$/% 12% M:!21C/$#W*/%0:&/$!-/!4#*% C12M$/41:!%1!&:*&/C%1!%$/!/Y1!0%&12#2j6A%LV12%-/#!2%4V#4%1--10$#!42%Z#M/%M:!21C/$#W*/%'!M/$4#1!4F% $/0#$C1!0% 4V/1$% Z'4'$/% 1!% #% Q'$:(/#!% M:'!4$F8% 1!M*'C1!0% :!%YV/4V/$% 4V/F% #!C% 4V/1$% Z#-1*F% Y1**% W/% #W*/% 4:% 24#F8% Y:$"% #!C% 0#1!%M141w/!2V1(j;A% LV12% '!M/$4#1!4F% v% $/*#41&/% 4:% 4V/% /_(/!C14'$/2% #!C% /ZZ:$42%$/\'1$/C% 4:% 0#1!% /&/!% 4/-(:$#$F% (/$-142% v% -/#!2% 4V#4% 4V/% ($:(:2141:!% :Z%/-(*:F-/!4% Y14V1!% 4V/% QK% 12% !:4% #2% #((/#*1!0% #2% 4V/% :ZZ/$% :Z% 0$/#4/$%24#W1*14F8%*:Y/$%2"1**%$/\'1$/-/!428%#!C%/#21/$%f$/M:0!141:!g%1!%:4V/$%$/01:!2A%R/24$1M41&/% 1!C1&1C'#*% (:*1M1/2% 2'MV% #2% 4V/% *1-14#41:!% :Z% Y:$"% (/$-142% 1!%N'*0#$1#% 4:% 2(/M1Z1M8% 2V:$4B4/$-% ($:r/M428% /!4#1*% ($:W*/-2% Z:$% V10VB2"1**/C%-10$#!42%YV:%2//"%24#W1*14F%:&/$%'!M/$4#1!%Z'4'$/%($:2(/M42A%%%

Global Challenges %

N:4V%Q'$:(/%#!C%142%M:-(/414:$2%Z#M/%MV#**/!0/28%#2%-#!F%V10V*F%2"1**/C%-10$#!42%2//"%4:%$/4'$!%#!C%Y:$"%1!%4V/1$%!#41&/%M:'!4$1/2j^A%aV/$/#2%1!%4V/%(#24%4V/%-:&/-/!4%:Z%2"1**/C%Y:$"/$2%#!C%X4V/%W/24%#!C%W$10V4/24[%#Y#F%Z$:-%C/&/*:(1!0% M:'!4$1/2% V#2% W//!% C/2M$1W/C% #2% #% XW$#1!% C$#1![8% 4V12% 4$/!C% 12%W/M:-1!0%$/&/$2/CA% MM:$C1!0%4:% !!#%m//%E#_/!1#!%1!%V/$%W::"%XLV/%9/Y% $0:!#'42[8% 4V/$/% V#&/% W//!% 24$:!0% 0$:Y4V% $#4/2% #!C% #% 0$:Y1!0% 2'((*F% :Z%2"1**/C% *#W:'$% 1!% C/&/*:(1!0% /M:!:-1/2% 2'MV% #2% `!C1#% #!C%3V1!#joA% LV12% 12%C'/%4:%4V/%$/4'$!%-10$#41:!%:Z%2"1**/C%#!C%/C'M#4/C%Y:$"/$2A%`!%#%;>>h%24'CF%Z$:-% K3% N/$"/*/F% #!C% .'"/% K!1&/$214F% /!414*/C% X -/$1M#[2% m:22% 12% 4V/%a:$*C[2%T#1![8%$/2/#$MV/$2%Z:'!C%4V#4%:Z%4V:2/%2'$&/F/C8%j?Aju%:Z%3V1!/2/%

ih%% !!#%N:'MV/$%#!C%m'MF%3/$!#A8% e3'$$/!4%l:*1MF%L$/!C2% 1!%E"1**/C% `--10$#41:!%l:*1MFbJ#*9A;<96A8B96G#?8I<6A8B9J 31*4%7;8%9:%^8%;>6o8%2A;;B;7A%%%

j>%% `W1CA%j6%%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

j;%% `W1CA%j^%%EMV:!% N//MV*/$% #!C% `#!A% 3A% a::CY#$C8% eLV/% 0*:W#*% fY#$% Z:$% 4#*/!4ge8% FBD<96G# BH#*9A;<96A8B96G#?696I;=;9AJ%31*4%678%;>>h8%2A;i^B;j7A%%

jo%% !!#%m//%E#_/!1#!8%.O;#-;N#1<IB96DA7.%3#-W$1C0/8%]#$&#$C%K!1&/$214F%l$/228%;>>?A%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%6j

$/4'$!1!0%-10$#!42%#!C%ihu%:Z%`!C1#!%$/4'$!//2%24#4/C%4V#4%0$:Y1!0%C/-#!C2%Z:$%4V/1$%2"1**2%1!%4V/1$%V:-/%M:'!4$1/2%Y#2%4V/%-#1!%$/#2:!%Z:$%4V/1$%$/4'$!A%I'$4V/$-:$/8% jiA^u% :Z% 4V:2/% $/4'$!1!0% 4:% 3V1!#% #!C% ?;A^u% :Z% 4V:2/%$/4'$!1!0% 4:% `!C1#% W/*1/&/C% 4V#4% 4V/1$% M#$//$% ($:2(/M42% Y/$/% W/44/$% 1!% 4V/1$%!#41&/%M:'!4$1/2%4V#!%1!%4V/%KEj7A%%

aV1*24% 4V12% 24'CF%Y#2%W#2/C%:!%(/$M/(41:!2%:Z% 4V/%KE8% 14% 2'00/242% 4V#4%Q'$:(/%Y1**%M:!41!'/%4:%Z#M/%M:!21C/$#W*/%MV#**/!0/2%1!%Z10V41!0%4V/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4A% 3:-(/414:$% M:'!4$1/2% 2'MV% #2% 3#!#C#8% '24$#*1#% #!C% 4V/% KE% #$/%(/$M/1&/C%#2%-:$/%#44$#M41&/%C'/%4:%4V/1$%\'#*14F%:Z%*1Z/8%C/&/*:(/C%/M:!:-1/2%#!C%/_1241!0%1--10$#!4%M:--'!141/28%#2%Y/**%#2%V#&1!0%($:M/22/2%Z:$%4'$!1!0%4/-(:$#$F%&12#2%1!4:%(/$-#!/!4%:!/2j?A%l/$V#(2%#%-:$/%210!1Z1M#!4%MV#**/!0/8%V:Y/&/$8% M:-/2% Z$:-% 4V/% C/&/*:(1!0% /M:!:-1/2% :Z% -#!F% 4V1$CBM:'!4$F%!#41:!#*2[%V:-/%M:'!4$1/2A% 2%M#$//$%:((:$4'!141/2%#!C%C/-#!C%Z:$%2"1**2%1!%4V/2/%M:'!4$1/2%1-($:&/8%!#41:!#*%1!241!M42%#!C%C/21$/%4:%Y:$"%1!%:!/[2%V:-/%M:'!4$F%-#F%($:&/%#%(:Y/$Z'*%Z:$M/%1!%4V/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4jiA%%

&B9EGD78B9###

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r/M428%W:4V%1!4/$!#**F%#!C%/_4/$!#**F8%4V/%1-#0/%:Z%142/*Z%#2%#%XZ:$4$/22[8%MV#$#M4/$12/C%WF%#4414'C/2%4V#4%2//%:(/!%1--10$#41:!%(:*1MF%#2%#%C$#1!%:!%$/2:'$M/2%#!C%4:%4V/%C/4$1-/!4%:Z%4V/%!#41&/%(:('*#41:!A%%%%

Q'$:(/#!%(:*1MF%-#"/$2%V#&/%($/2/!4/C%!/Y%M/!4$#*12/C%2MV/C'*/2%2'MV%#2%EM1/!41Z1M%c12#%#!C%N*'/%3#$C%Z:$%#44$#M41!0%V10V*FB2"1**/C%-10$#!42A%LV/2/%(:*1M1/2%#$/%*1-14/C8%V:Y/&/$8%WF%4V/%C1&/$0/!4%#4414'C/2%:Z%S/-W/$%E4#4/2%4:%QK% (:*1MF8% YV/$/% (:*1MF% 1!24$'-/!42% #!C% C1ZZ/$/!41#*2% 1!% W'$/#'M$#41M%4$/#4-/!4% C1ZZ/$% 210!1Z1M#!4*FA% aV1*24% 2:-/% S/-W/$% E4#4/2% #*$/#CF% V#&/%(:*1M1/2% V/*(1!0% 4:% /!2'$/% 4V/F% #$/% 2'MM/22Z'*% 1!% #44$#M41!0% 0*:W#*% 4#*/!48%:4V/$2% V#&/% -:$/% $/24$1M41&/% (:*1M1/2% W'4% Z#&:'$% QK% (:*1MF% C1$/M41&/2% 4V#4%

j7%% z:/*%L$#MV4-#!%/4%#*A%eLV/%T*:W#*%3:-(/4141:!%Z:$%L#*/!4g8%.O;#(G;AEO;<#$EOBBG#BH#)6N#69C#L8MGB=6EQ#,6M;<, L'Z42%K!1&/$214F,%;>6>8% 2A6o8%6hB;>A%

j?%%S#$41!%P#V#!/M%#!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8%f]10VBE"1**/C%`--10$#41:!%l:*1MF%1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

ji%% z:/*%L$#MV4-#!%/4%#*A%eLV/%T*:W#*%3:-(/4141:!%Z:$%L#*/!4g8%.O;#(G;AEO;<#$EOBBG#BH#)6N#69C#L8MGB=6EQ#,6M;<, L'Z42%K!1&/$214F,%;>6>8% 2A6o8%6hB;>A%

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn 6h

#44$#M4%V10V*FB2"1**/C%1--10$#!42A%LV/%C1&1C/C%#(($:#MV/2%:Z%S/-W/$%E4#4/2%V#&/8%V:Y/&/$8%-/#!4%4V#4%/ZZ/M42%:Z%4V/2/%(:*1M1/2%#$/%&/$F%*1-14/C%#!C%Z#1*%4:%2#412ZF%4V/%!//C2%:Z%(:4/!41#*%-10$#!42A%d4V/$%($:W*/-2%1C/!41Z1/C%$/*#4/%4:%V:Y% 2"1**2% #$/% W/1!0% used <C:Y!0$#C1!0% C'/% 4:% Y#0/|*1&1!0% 24#!C#$C%C1ZZ/$/!41#*2@8% #!C% 4:% V:Y% 2"1**2% #!C% \'#*1Z1M#41:!2% #$/% 2(/M1Z1M#**F%$/M:0!12/CA%QK%(:*1M1/2%#!C%S/-W/$%E4#4/%($:&121:!2%V#&/%!:4% 2'ZZ1M1/!4*F%4#"/!% 1!4:% #MM:'!4% 4V/% f-#$"/4g% :Z% #*4/$!#41&/% :((:$4'!141/2% 4V#4% 2"1**/C%-10$#!42%V#&/%YV/!%M:!21C/$1!0%*#W:'$%-10$#41:!A%QK%(:*1M1/2%2//-2%-:$/%$/24$1M41&/%#!C%!#$$:Y*F%M#4/0:$12/C%&12%#%&12%CF!#-1M%2F24/-%:Z%KEA%LV/2/%#$/% ($:W*/-2% /!M:'!4/$/C% 1!4/$!#**F% #2% Y/**% #2% /_4/$!#**F8% 4V:'0V% v% #2%-/!41:!/C% #W:&/% v% -#!F% ($:W*/-2% M:-/% C:Y!% 4:% 4V/% C1ZZ/$/!41#*% #!C%'!/&/!%(:*1MF%/!&1$:!-/!42%:Z%C1ZZ/$/!4%S/-W/$%E4#4/2A%%

Q'$:(/[2% (:2141:!% 1!% 4V/% 0*:W#*12/C% /M:!:-F% -/#!2% 4V#4% 1!% 2(14/% :Z%($:W*/-2%Y/%V#&/%1C/!41Z1/C%V/$/%#!C%4V/%Z1!#!M1#*%#!C%/M:!:-1M%MV#**/!0/2%14% M:!41!'/2% 4:% Z#M/8% 14% Y1**% $/-#1!% #!% 1-(:$4#!4% C/241!#41:!% Z:$% -10$#!42A%]:Y/&/$8% 1Z% Q'$:(/% 12% 4:% 4$'*F% 2'MM//C% 1!% 4V/% Y#$% Z:$% 0*:W#*% 4#*/!48% -:$/%M:**/M41&/%#!C%M:**#W:$#41&/%(:*1M1/2%#$/%!/M/22#$F%1!%:$C/$%4:%24$/#-*1!/%4V/%($:M/22% :Z% 1--10$#41:!% #!C% 4:% #**:Y% Z$//% -:&/-/!4% W/4Y//!% Q'$:(/#!%S/-W/$%E4#4/2A%%

+;H;<;9E;7##

N#$2*'!C% S1""/*% /4% #*A8% em#W:'$% S:W1*14F% 1!% 4V/% QK5% .F!#-1M28% l#44/$!2% #!C%l:*1M1/2e8%*9A;<;EB9B=8E7J%31*4%oh8%9:%^8%;>6o8%2A66?%v%67jA%%

N#$2*'!C8%S1""/*%#!C%S#44V1#2%N'22/8%fS#"1!0%4V/%-:24%:Z%QK%m#W:'$%S:W1*14Fg8%3QlE%L#2"%I:$M/%R/(:$428%;>6o8%%

N//MV*/$8%EMV:!%#!C%`#!A%3A%a::CY#$C8%eLV/%0*:W#*%fY#$%Z:$% 4#*/!4ge8%FBD<96G#BH#*9A;<96A8B96G#?696I;=;9AJ%31*4%678%;>>h8%2A;i^B;j7A%%

N:'MV/$8% !!#% #!C% m'MF% 3/$!#A8% e3'$$/!4% l:*1MF% L$/!C2% 1!% E"1**/C% `--10$#41:!%l:*1MFbJ#*9A;<96A8B96G#?8I<6A8B9J 31*4%7;8%9:%^8%;>6o8%2A;;B;7A%%%

N#'/$8% LV:-#2% #!C% 24$1C% P'!w/% 8% eLV/% ./-#!C% Z:$% ]10VBE"1**/C%a:$"/$2% #!C%`--10$#41:!% l:*1MFe8%0<D77;G7# 'EB9B=8E#+;P8;N`&6O8;<7# 'EB9B=8]D;7# C;#0<Dc;GG;7, 31*4%oi8%;>>o8%9:%68%2A7ivi7A%%

3#&1/C/28% */_#!C/$8% ,<Q89I# !M;9# (B<A<;77# 'D<BM;Z# .O;# .D<9# AB# $;EAB<86G#)6YBD<#?8I<6A8B9d%9/Y%=:$"8%m/_1!04:!%N::"28%;>>hA%

3/$!#8% m'MF8% eLV/% &#$1/41/2% :Z% V10VB2"1**/C% 1--10$#41:!% (:*1M1/25% M:#*141:!2% #!C%(:*1MF%:'4('42%1!%#C&#!M/C%1!C'24$1#*%M:'!4$1/2e8%FBD<96G#BH#'D<BM;69#,DYG8E#,BG8EQ, 31*4%6?8%9:%68%;>>h8%2A6ooB6?6A%%%

3/$!#8% m'MF% #!C% 3V:'%S/!0% ]2'#!8% e`2% Q'$:(/% -1221!0% :'4% :!% Z:$/10!% 4#*/!4ne%%98P;<78AQ#"B<GC#-;N7J%31*4%;j?8%;>6^8%2A6B7A%%%

= EH9%PQRQS%TGSGU%

%;>

3/$!#8% m'MF% #!C% 3V:'% S/!0% ]2'#!8% eLV/% $/01:!#*% C1-/!21:!% 1!% 4V/% 0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%4#*/!45%m/22:!2%Z$:-%Z$#-1!0%4V/%Q'$:(/#!%EM1/!41Z1M%c12#%#!C%N*'/%3#$Ce8%FBD<96G#BH#'D<BM;69#,DYG8E#,BG8EQ8%31*4%;68%9:%h68%;>6o8%2Ai?Bh7A%%%

3/$!#8%m'MF8% eK!C/$24#!C1!0% 4V/%C1&/$214F%:Z%QK%-10$#41:!%(:*1MF% 1!%($#M41M/5% 4V/%1-(*/-/!4#41:!% :Z% 4V/% N*'/% 3#$C% 1!141#41&/e8% ,BG8EQ# $ADC8;7, 31*4% ^o8% 9:% ;8 ;>6^8%2A6j>v;>>A%%

3V12Y1M"8% N#$$F8% e]10V% E"1**/C% `--10$#41:!% 1!% 4V/% `!4/$!#41:!#*% $/!#e8% *K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<, 9:A6ij;8%;>>7A%

3V#-W/$28%Q*1w#W/4V%/4%#*A8%eLV/%Y#$%Z:$%4#*/!4e8%.O;#?E:897;Q#RD6<A;<GQ, 31*4%^8%6hhj8%2Aoov7iA%%

3:**/448% Q*1w#W/4V8% eLV/% l$:(:2/C% Q'$:(/#!% N*'/% 3#$C% EF24/-5% $-1!0% Z:$% 4V/%T*:W#*%a#$%:!%L#*/!4ne%?8I<6A8B9#,BG8EQ#*97A8ADA;#L87ED778B9#M6M;<,%;>>jA%

3V#*:ZZ8% z:!#4V#!% #!C% T/:$0/% m/-#}4$/8% eS#!#01!0% ]10V*FBE"1**/C% m#W:'$%S10$#41:!5% %3:-(#$#41&/% !#*F212% :Z%S10$#41:!% l:*1M1/2% #!C%3V#**/!0/2% 1!%dQ3.% 3:'!4$1/2e8% !'&L# $BE86G# '=MGBQ=;9A# 69C# ?8I<6A8B9# "B<[89I#,6M;<7#^_8%;>>hA%%

.#!w/$8% */_#!C/$%#!C%N#$W#$#%.1/4w8%eLV/%QKx2%Z#1*'$/%4:%#44$#M4%4V/%-:24%4#*/!4/C%4/-(:$#$F%-10$#!42e8%mEQ%N*:08%;>6oA%%%

.#&14/$8% I#*"8% eI$#-1!0% W1:4/MV!:*:0F% (:*1MF% 1!% 4V/% Q'$:(/#!% K!1:!e8%1+'-1#"B<[89I#,6M;<8%9:%78%;>6;A%

.`a% N/$*1!8% f]10V*FB2"1**/C% 1--10$#41:!% (:*1MF% 1!% Q'$:(/g8% L87ED778B9# ,6M;<#WV_XJ%;>66A%%%

QC%S1MV#/*2%/4%#*A%LV/%a#$%Z:$%L#*/!48%]#$Y#$C%N'21!/22%R/&1/Y%l$/228%;>>6A%

I$/!MV8%E4/&/8%eQK%m#W:'$%S10$#41:!%1!%4$:'W*/C%41-/25%2"1**2%-12-#4MV8%$/4'$!%#!C%(:*1MF%$/2(:!2/2e8%*9CD7A<86G#+;G6A8B97#FBD<96G, 31*4A%o78%9:%68%;>6o8%2A6>>v6>>6A%%

T#*0yMw18%N/*#%/4%#*8%'%#)6YBD<#?8I<6A8B9#89#.<BDYG;C#.8=;7Z#$[8GG7#?87=6AEOJ#+;AD<9#69C#,BG8EQ#+;7MB97;78% 2V0#4/8%E'$$/F8%;>6;A%#

T1&/!28%L/$$F%#!C% C#-%m'/C4"/8%eQ'$:(/#!%`--10$#41:!%l:*1M1/2%1!%3:-(#$#41&/%l/$2(/M41&/e8%&B=M6<6A8P;#'D<BM;69#,BG8A8E78%c:*%^8%9:%68%;>>78%2A6v;;A%%

T:!w{*/w8%3#$-/!%/4%#*8%eLV/%QK%(/$Z:$-#!M/%1!%4V/%0*:W#*%M:-(/4141:!%Z:$%V10V*FB2"1**/C% -10$#!42e8%-BA<;# 'D<BM;# \# F6E]D;7# L;GB<7# *97A8ADA;# ,BG8EQ# M6M;<8%;>6^A%

TJ-J28% =#21!% P/$/-8% eQK% N*'/% 3#$C% EMV/-/5% LV/% R10V4% E4/(% 1!% 4V/% R10V4%.1$/M41:!ne%'D<BM;69#FBD<96G#BH#?8I<6A8B9#69C#)6NJ%31*4%6;8%9:%o8%;>6>8%2Ao^7Bo7^A%%

T$:(#28%R'WF8%eS10$#41:!%#!C%`!!:&#41:!5%YVF%12%Q'$:(/%Z#1*1!0%4:%#44$#M4%4V/%W/24%#!C% W$10V4/24ne8% 'D<BM;69# %98P;<78AQ# *97A8ADA;`/GBY6G# /BP;<969E;#,<BI<6==;#M6M;<, ;>6^A%%%

]da%EK33QEEIKm%`E%QKRdlQ%`9%L]Q%TmdN m%fa R%IdR%L mQ9Lgn ;6

]/Y1448% f]/Y144% L#*/!4% E'$&/F% ;>>j5% N'1*C1!0% 4V/% L#*/!4/C% d$0#!12#41:!3# *9#177BE86A8B9#N8AO#.6G;9A#?696I;=;9A#+;P8;N8%;>>jA##

`!4/$!#41:!#*% m#W:'$% d$0#!1w#41:!8% fT*:W#*% Q-(*:F-/!4% L$/!C2g8% dM#"8% `md%T/!/&#%EY14w/$*#!C8%;>>jA%

P#V#!/M8%S#$41!% #!C%P*#'2%IA%k1--/$-#!!8% f]10VBE"1**/C% `--10$#41:!%l:*1MF% 1!%Q'$:(/g8%*K1#L87ED778B9#M6M;<8%9:%7^hh8%;>6>A%

m#"2V-#!8% 9#!C1!18% e`!C1#!% M:-(#!1/2% 24$'00*/% #2% Y#0/2% $12/e8%0D789;77#";;[J#;>>jA%%

S#V$:'-8% E#-18% eQ'$:(/% #!C% 4V/% `--10$#41:!% :Z% ]10V*F% E"1**/Ce8% Labour%International Migration8%;>>68%31*4%^h8%9:%78%2A%;iBo^A%

S/221!#8% !4V:!F8%.O;#)BI8E7#69C#,BG8A8E7#BH#,B7A\""**#?8I<6A8B9#AB#";7A;<9#'D<BM;, 3#-W$1C0/5%3#-W$1C0/%K!1&/$214F%l$/228%;>>iA%

S:$#&M21"8% !C$/Y8%.O;#&OB8E;#HB<#'D<BM;J#3:$!/**%K!1&/$214F%l$/228%9/Y%=:$"8%6hhjA%%%%

l1!"8% .#!1/*8% (<;;# 6I;9A# 96A8B9Z# AO;# HDAD<;# BH# NB<[89I# HB<# QBD<7;GHJ% a#$!/$%N::"28%9/Y%=:$"8%;>>6A%

l#$"/28%R:C/$1M"%#!C%E4/ZZ/!% !0/!/!C48%f Z4/$%4V/%N*'/%3#$C%QK%l:*1MF%:!%]10V*F%~'#*1Z1/C%S10$#41:!5%LV$//%a#F2%d'4%:Z%4V/%`-(#22/”8 ;89<8EO#0aGG#$A8HAD9I#L87ED778B9#,6M;<8%N/$*1!5%]/1!$1MV%NO**%E41Z4'!08 ;>6>A%

l$14MV/448%m#!48%);A#AO;8<#M;BMG;#EB=;Z#Y<;6[89I#AO;#I<8CGBE[#B9#G6YBD<#=BY8G8AQ8%3/!4/$%Z:$%T*:W#*%./&/*:(-/!48%a#2V1!04:!8%.A3A%;>>?A%

E#_/!1#!8% !!#%m//8%.O;#-;N#1<IB96DA7.%3#-W$1C0/8%]#$&#$C%K!1&/$214F%l$/228%;>>?A%

E-#$48% N$#C% #!C% T/:ZZ% E-#$48%.BMI<6C89I# S BN# .B# 8<;J# &B6EO# 69C#:;;M# 1#,G6Q;<7J#l$14MV/44%l$/228%;>>7A%

L$#MV4-#!8%z:/*%/4%#*A%eLV/%T*:W#*%3:-(/4141:!%Z:$%L#*/!4g8%.O;#(G;AEO;<#$EOBBG#BH#)6N#69C#L8MGB=6EQ#,6M;<, L'Z42%K!1&/$214F,%;>6>8% 2A6o8%6hB;>A%%

L'!08% R:2#*1/% mA8% eLV/% V'-#!% $/2:'$M/% MV#**/!0/% 4:% :'4Y#$C% Z:$/10!% C1$/M4%1!&/24-/!4% #2(1$#41:!2% Z$:-% /-/$01!0% M:'!4$1/25% 4V/% M#2/% :Z% 3V1!#e8%*9A;<96A8B96G# FBD<96G# BH# D=69# +;7BD<E;# ?696I;=;9AJ Cilt 18, No 5,%;>>i8%2Aj?jvjjhA%%

a#CVY#8% c1&/"% /4% #*A%1=;<8E6e7# )B77# 87# .O;#"B<GCe7# /689, K3% N/$"/*/F% #!C%.'"/%K!1&/$214F%l$/228%;>>h8%2A6^A

k#1M/&#8% !w/*1"#%#!C%P*#'2%k1--/$-#!!8%eEM#*/8%.1&/$214F8%#!C%./4/$-1!#!42%:Z%m#W:'$%S10$#41:!% 1!%Q'$:(/e8%!cHB<C#+;P8;N#BH#'EB9B=8E#,BG8EQ, c:*% ;o8%9:%^8%;>>j8%2Ao;iv76A%%

%