Date post: | 24-Jan-2015 |
Category: |
Business |
Upload: | environmentalconflicts |
View: | 466 times |
Download: | 1 times |
Capital Accumulation as Time-Space Appropriation
Presentation at International Conference on Environmental Conflicts and Justice
Barcelona, July 2, 2010
Alf Hornborg, Human Ecology Division, Lund University
Capital accumulation =
• A recursive relationship between some kind of technological infrastructure and a symbolic capacity to make claims on other people’s resources
• Presupposes rates of unequal exchange that ultimately rest on human evaluations and that guarantee a minimum net transfer of resources from one social sector to another
Landesque capital in ancient Peru
Toward a cross-cultural definition of capital accumulation
A formal comparison of the accumulation of productive infrastructure in 15th century Peru and 19th century England:
Productive infrastructure accumulated
Cultural mystification of unequal exchange
15th century Peru Agricultural terraces
Ceremonial redistribution of maize beer
18th century England
Textile factories Wages and market prices
Cross-cultural comparison as subversive science:
• Are ”wages” and ”market prices” cultural mystifications of unequal exchange in the modern world, just like the concept of minka and the ceremonial redistribution of maize beer were in the Inca empire?
Capital accumulation as appropriation
How do we quantify unequal exchange?
• In terms of ”exchange value” (price), all market transactions are by definition equal
• In order to establish the occurrence of unequal exchange, we need a different metric than money (but not to be confused with ”value”)
• Some options: embodied materials, energy, environmental damage, land requirements, labour time, etc.
The Industrial Revolution as time-space appropriation
Commodity Volume for £1000 in 1850
Embodied labor
Embodied land
Raw cotton
11.84 tons 32,619 h 58.6 ha
Cotton cloth
3.41 tons 4,092 h - 1 ha