20
1
1
2
Municipal Complex: Administration
Issues Electric panels do not meet current standards Lighting is deficient in several areas of the
building Interior finishes have come to an end of their
useful life causing paint to peel and carpet to fray
3
4
Municipal Complex: Library
Issues Electric system do not meet current standards HVAC in need of major overhaul. Current
system leaks in many places causing damage to collection and structure
Finishes are worn and frayed
5
6
Parks & Playgrounds Improvements
Issues Fields use far exceeds the capabilities of the
grass playing surface causing deterioration of playing surface and subsurface
7
8
TablesTable 1. Expected field condition based on hours of field use per year. University of Florida Athletic Field Use Capacity
Field Condition Hours per Year
Sustain good field conditions200 hours or less
Fair to good field conditions, some thinning turf and localized wear areas
400 to 600 hours
Significant turf loss, field surface damage, increased potential for athlete injury
Over 800 hours
Barrows Field at Carteret Park 916 hours per year
Hurrell Field 800 hours per year
9
Parks & Playgrounds Improvements
Options Keep fields “as is” Reduce activities held on the field Re-sod fields on an annual / biannual basis Install synthetic playing surface
10
Parks & Playgrounds Improvements
Synthetic Surface Concerns Heat Gain Increased Injury Rate Visual Impact Formation of Bacteria on Playing Surface Environmental Impact from Synthetic Materials Product Life Security, Vandalism and Access Light pollution
11
Synthetic Surface Concerns
Heat Gain Synthetic surfaces are hotter than natural grass. It is planned to install
sprinklers at Carteret Park to allow for summer usage of the field on extremely hot days. “Surface temperature of RIF fields can be reduced by 33 percent with proper use of irrigation cycling…. The heat load problem on RIF fields is manageable with irrigation, the problem is that most fields have been constructed without irrigation.” If you can't take the heat...Dr. Dave Minner, Ph.D., Associate Professor, Iowa State University
Increased Injury Rate Studies have shown that there is no increased injury rate on synthetic
playing surfaces and that the rate of injury is comparable to natural grass. The type of injuries differ. “For example, the researchers found there was a greater incidence of surface to skin injuries and muscle strains and spasm on FieldTurf. However, on the natural grass fields they documented a great incidence of head concussions and ligament tears.” American Journal of Sports Medicine, Oct 2004
12
Synthetic Surface Concerns
Environmental Impact from Synthetic Materials There is no data to suggest that crumb rubber is toxic.
The type of rubber used in athletic fields is cryogenic rubber that does not contain metal or dust.
The use of fertilizers and pesticides will be eliminated on the synthetic playing surface
Product Life Expected life for the playing surface is 10 years. An 8
year guarantee will be specified. All subgrade work has an expected life of 20 years or more. Much of the initial cost involved is in the subsurface construction.
13
Synthetic Surface Concerns
Formation of Bacteria on Playing Surface There is no increase in the type or formation of harmful
bacteria on the synthetic fields. Spot solutions are available if requested. "The microbe population of natural turfgrass far exceeds anything we've found in the infill systems. In fact, a number of the infill systems had zero living microbes in the sample at the time of testing."
Andy McNitt
Associate Professor of Soil Science at Penn State
14
Synthetic Surface Concerns Visual impact of permanent striping
Striping does not have to be permanently stitched into the synthetic material. At Carteret Park, temporary striping may be utilized.
Security, Vandalism and Access Access will remain the same to pedestrians.
Measures will be installed to ensure no motor vehicle access onto the playing surfaces. The fields will not be closed. Additional video cameras may be installed to further enhance security.
Light pollution Customized lighting that will minimize light pollution
has been recommended. These lights can be remotely controlled as well. If installed, a strict curfew will be enforced.
15
Grass vs. Synthetic Surface Grass
Cut twice a week
Striped twice a week
Fertilized 6 times a year
Core aerated and over seeded twice a year
Major top soil and leveling twice a year
Irrigated playing area once a day
Fields must be closed for routine maintenance
Necessitates closure for annual / biannual resodding from three to six months
Synthetic Only surrounding grass areas
to be cut Striped every two weeks for
activities that are not permanently stitched into the material
Treatment only for shrubs and perimeter grass areas, not on fields
No core aeration or over seeding required
Fields brushed four times a year
Irrigate for cooling on “heat” days only
Playable all year round regardless of weather
Elimination of gas powered lights at Palmer Field at Forest Avenue School
16
20 Year Life Cycle AnalysisSOD EVERY YEAR
Hurrell Field Synthetic Turf Natural Grass
Installation Cost Per Field $2,306,430 $1,529,496
Annual maintenance $169,994 $1,637,268
Total Cost per Field $2,476,424 $3,166,764
SOD EVERY TWO YEARS
Hurrell Field Synthetic Turf Natural Grass
Installation Cost Per Field $2,306,430 $764,748
Annual maintenance $169,994 $1,637,268
Total Cost per Field $2,476,424 $2,402,016
SOD EVERY THREE YEARS
Hurrell Field Synthetic Turf Natural Grass
Installation Cost Per Field $2,306,430 $509,832
Annual maintenance $169,994 $1,637,268
Total Cost per Field $2,476,424 $2,147,100
17
20 Year Life Cycle Analysis
SOD EVERY YEAR
Carteret Synthetic Turf Natural Grass
Installation Cost Per Field $2,565,630 $1,699,440
Annual maintenance $169,994 $1,774,555
Total Cost per Field $2,735,624 $3,473,995
SOD EVERY TWO YEARS
Carteret Synthetic Turf Natural Grass
Installation Cost Per Field $2,565,630 $849,720
Annual maintenance $169,994 $1,774,555
Total Cost per Field $2,735,624 $2,624,275
SOD EVERY THREE YEARS
Carteret Synthetic Turf Natural Grass
Installation Cost Per Field $2,565,630 $566,480
Annual maintenance $169,994 $1,774,555
Total Cost per Field $2,735,624 $2,341,035
18
Please Remember to Vote
The Special Election Day for the Capital Bonds Referendum is Tuesday, February 6, 2007.
Polling Hours are from 6:00a.m. to 8:00 p.m.
If you are a registered voter and are uncertain about where to vote check your sample ballot or call the Clerk's office (973-748-8400, ext.220). Polling place information and current voters registration lists are also available in Room 102 of the Municipal Building.
19
Absentee Ballots
As an Essex County resident you may apply for an absentee ballot if you are a qualified and registered voter by written application to the County Clerk's Office. The deadline for such requests are seven (7) days prior to any and all elections (Primary, General, School, Special, etc.). Any absentee voter who fails to apply by the deadline may apply in person to the County Clerk's office, or by authorized messenger, on any day up to 3:00 P.M. the day before an election.
20
Thank you!
For more information please visit our website at www.glenridgenj.org
