Date post: | 29-Dec-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | audra-davis |
View: | 219 times |
Download: | 3 times |
1
Berkshire Hathaway Asset Study
Winter 2011 Fin / Invest / Business Law Cluster
Kevin C. Kaufhold
1
2
Description of Berkshire Hathaway
• Holding company owning insurance and other firms • 70 domestic and foreign insurance subsidiaries• Largest are GEICO, General Re, Swiss RE, WESCO• Also owns $ Billion + positions in Coca-Cola, Wells-Fargo, Zales
Jewelers, BN RR, utilities, many others
• $ 112.024 Billion market cap• $35 Billion in cash reserves (plus equity positions)• 2009 revenues were $112.493 Billion• 2009 earnings were $5.192 Billion• TTM EPS is $7,234 EPS
2
3
Description of Berkshire Hathaway, continued
Ownership and management structure Publicly tradedCEO Warren Buffett; Charlie Munger active in WESCO16% institutional ownership.
Class A shares never split: $127,000 per share value
Class B shares developed in 1996 at 1 / 30 of Class A Class B split 2-2011 when BN was acquired 50:1 Class B is therefore now at 1 / 1500 of Class A ($80 / share)
3
4
Impact from National Economy
VL macro growth 2% 2011
Consensus has been revised upward --- 2% to 3.5% 2011
P&C insurance industry is pro-cyclical
Slowness of economic recovery is a large factor in current industry and company pricing performance
5
• Industry Considerations
• Slow macro recovery putting pressure on P&C insurance industry
• Firms reluctant to pay higher insurance premiums
• New insurance clients harder to develop
• Investment returns from portfolios also under pressure• Laddered bond positions expiring • New bonds having lower returns
5
6
• Industry Considerations, continued
• S&P and VL have neutral outlook on industry• Excess underwriting capacity or supply• S&P estimates excess at $335 Billion• Net premiums may increase modestly 2 to 4% in 2011• But P&C storm and catastrophic damages 2009 decreased
• Going forward 3+ years, industry may expand with economy
• Many firms planning for eventual share repurchases
6
7
• Company Considerations
• BRK holding up well in industry• Good investment returns• Better than expected profit from insurance operations• Poised to use cash to increase equity positions and acquisitions
• Safety ranking (VL) = 1 (highest)• Only other safety ranking of 1 in industry is Chubb
7
8
Company Considerations, Continued
Premium growth last 9 years 5.39% (ind 5.00%)LT debt to capital 9 years 13.30% (ind up to 40%)ROE 9 years 8.00%Beta = 0.14 (ind is 0.38 to 1.49; Chubb at 0.47). PE range 13 to 21 in 2009
YTD share pricing 6.0% (ind 5.6%; 6.9% S&P)5 year share pricing 7.8% (ind 3.5%; 1.3% S&P)
9
Company Portfolio
Focused portfolio of cash reserves or insurance “float”
Concentrated in insurance and consumer staples
Top 10 positions comprise 93.5% of BRK portfolio Top 4 positions 67%; KO, Wells Fargo, American Express, P&G BRK is now Wells Fargo biggest shareholder at $9.7 Billion
10
11
12
Company Valuations
VL projects NT pricing consistent with capital markets
But, 3 to 5 year pricing at 5% to 11% annualized returns
Thomson Reuters LT growth forecast at 5.0%
Technical indicators neutral to negative (VL to Thomson)
But forecast revenue growth 18.4% 2010 to 22.0% 2011
Relative value is negative (Thomson)
13
Company Valuation, continued
Biggest factor may be SuccessionSuccessors named, but likely Buffett will remain in charge
indefinitely Question as to growth post-Buffett
My recommendation ---- NT hold --- primarily based on relative value LT accumulation --- based on superior industry position
Current and future Management is inherently oriented toward shareholder interests
History heavily favors BRK’s superiority of pricing performance ---
14
15
References
MSN Money, financial information and worksheets
S&P company and industry report, 2-19-2011; Significant events 2-7-2011 (Wesco)
San Francisco Business Times, 2-21-2011 article on Wells Fargo
Seeking Alpha commentary on company, 2-2011
Thomson Reuters company report, 2-18-2011.
Value-Line, 12-7-2010 company and industry reports
Yahoo Finance, financial information and worksheets, pricing graph