of 80
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
1/80
Keeping Electrical Switchgear Safe
Staff responsible for care, operation
maintenance of switchgear should receivetraining (or refresher courses) relevant to theduties that are required of them
This is particularly relevant to staff called upon to
operate switchgear and such staff should havecompetency at the authorised person level
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
2/80
Keeping Electrical Switchgear Safe
Even where all operational and
maintenance work is contracted out, it ispreferable that there is sufficienttechnical knowledge within the companyto audit the practices of the contractors
and to handle abnormal situations thatwill inevitably arise on the premises.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
3/80
Nestle And MonotronicFined 245,000
Following Electrocution.
HSE Press Release - 03 June2003
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
4/80
Nestle And Monotronic
Nestle were fined 220,000 on 30th May
2003 following a fatal accident in 1999 A contractor was electrocuted whilst
pulling redundant cables from trunking
in Nestles coffee factory in Hayes,Middlesex
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
5/80
Nestle The HSE Inspector said that the
persons death could have beenavoided if Nestle had ensured itscontractors either followed or had inplace a safe system of work, similar to
the system Nestle managed for its ownemployees
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
6/80
Monotronic
Monotronic were fined 25,000 for
breaching the H&S@WA by failing toensure the safety of its own employees
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
7/80
HSE figures 2006/7
11 fatalities & 465 serious injuries as aresult of contact with electricity orelectrical discharge.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
8/80
HSE - Electricity at Work
Most electrical accidents occur because
people are working on or nearequipment that is:
Thought to be dead
Known to be live but those involved donthave adequate training or appropriateequipment, or they havent taken adequate
precautions
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
9/80
Legislation
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
10/80
Objectives Statute Law
Health and Safety at
Work, Etc. Act 1974 The Electricity at Work
Regs 1989
Management of H&S
@ Work Regs 1999 LOLER
Manual Handling Regs1992
Safety Signs & SignalsRegs 1996
COSHH The PPE at Work Regs
1992
The Confined Spaces
Regs 1997 Working at Heights
2005
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
11/80
Statute Law
The written law of the land and consistsof: Acts of Parliament - Primary Legislation
HS@WA 1974
Regulations - Secondary Legislation Electricity at Work Regulations 1989
Approved Codes of Practice Application of CDM ACOP
Guidance Notes Keeping Electrical Switchgear Safe
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
12/80
Levels of Duty
There are three levels or types of dutyimposed by the statute, only two of
these are relevant to our work: Absolute
Where the requirements must be metregardless of cost or any other consideration
Reasonably Practicable
Which means balancing the risks againstphysical difficulty, time, trouble and expense
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
13/80
The Health and Safety at
Work Act 1974
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
14/80
General Duties
There is an overriding duty on
employers to ensure so far asreasonably practicable, the health,safety and welfare of all their
employees.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
15/80
General Duties Additionally, the employer has to
ensure, as far as is reasonably
practicable: The provision and maintenance of Plant
and Systems of Work that are safe and
without risk to health The provision of information, instruction,
Training and Supervision as is necessaryto ensure health and safety at work
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
16/80
General Duties Employees have the following duties:
To take reasonable care for their ownhealth and safety and that of otherpersons who may be effected by their actsand omissions at work.
To co-operate with their employer so faras is necessary to enable the employer tocomply with his legal duties.
Not to interfere with or misuse anythingprovided in the interests of health safetyand welfare.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
17/80
The Electricity at WorkRegulations 1989
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
18/80
Regulation 3 Duty Holders
Employees are to co-operate withtheir employer so far as is necessaryto enable any duty placed upon thatemployer by the provisions of these
Regulations to be complied with. To comply with the provisions of the
Regulations so far as they relate to
matters which are within their control.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
19/80
Regulation 3 Duty Holders Directors and Managers
Designers of Systems and Components Designers of Systems of Work, Tools,
Safety Procedures
Designers of Organisation of Work Planners
Constructors
Operators, Maintainers, Supervisors
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
20/80
Regulation 4
Systems and Work Activities
All electrical systems must be constructed andmaintained at all times to prevent danger, so faras is reasonably practicable
Every work activity, including operation, use and
maintenance of a system and work near a system,shall be carried out in such a manner as not togive rise, so far as is reasonably practicable, todanger
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
21/80
Operation of Network
Training Network
ManagementProcedures
Operations
ManualSafetyRules
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
22/80
Management Instructions
Local ManagementInstructions
Operation ofEA Ratcliffe
TrainingNetwork
AvoidingDanger fromUnderground
Services
Access ofHigh
Vehiclesand
Equipment
SafeSystems of
Work
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
23/80
Safety Rules
High Voltage SafetyRules
GeneralProvisions
GeneralSafety
Definitions
SafetyPrecautionsfor Work onor Near HV
Systems
Proceduresfor Work onParticularApparatus
SafetyPrecautionsfor Live LineWork on HV
OHL
SafetyPrecautions
andProcedures
for Work onLV Systems
SafetyPrecautionsfor Testing
on HV
Apparatus
Responsibilitiesof Persons
Interpretationof Rules
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
24/80
Electricity at Work Safe WorkingPractices
Safety rules Should set out principles and general practices
clearly and in a format that is compact enough forthe people involved to carry around with them
Detailed procedures for safe working on particularitems of equipment, or under particular
circumstances, should be the subject of separatedocuments, which should be readily availablewhen required
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
25/80
Operations Manual
Network OperatingManual
SystemControl
AuthorisationProcedures
OperatingProcedures
Maintenance Administration
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
26/80
Regulation 5
Strength and Capability of ElectricalEquipment
This Regulation does not allow anyelectrical equipment to be put into use
where its strength and capability may beexceeded and must not give rise to danger
The requirement is Absolute
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
27/80
Fault Level The maximum amount of energy that
can flow into a fault. Influencing factorsinclude:
Circuit Impedance
Rotating Plant or Machines
The nature of supply from the DNO
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
28/80
Fault Levels
Typical 1MVA, 11kV/440V Transformer
has a full load current of 52A Typical fault level on an 11kV system is
250MVA giving a prospective short
circuit value of 13,121A (13.1kA)
(18.4kA @ 350MVA on an 11kV system)
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
29/80
What do the numbers mean?
A F1 Car produces 800HP at20,000rpm
1 HP = 746W therefore at 20,000
Revs an F1 car produces 597kW On an 11kV network with a fault level
of 250MVA this is equivalent to
(250MVA / 597kW) = 419 F1 Cars
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
30/80
Fault Levels Fault level increases as system
impedance decreases 33kV Networks - 1000MVA
1675 F1 cars
132kV Networks - 3500MVA -5000 MVA
Between 5860 and 8375 F1 cars
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
31/80
The PPE at Work Regulations 1992
PPE means all equipment
designed to be worn or heldby a person at work toprotect against one or more
risks, and any addition oraccessory designed to meetthis objective.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
32/80
Regulation 11 Means for Protecting From Excess of
Current
Efficient means, suitably located, shall beprovided for protecting from excess ofcurrent in every part of a system as may benecessary to prevent danger.
There is a need to anticipate excesscurrent; a fault or overload.
The requirement is Absolute.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
33/80
Regulation 12 Where necessary to prevent danger,
suitable means shall be available for cutting off the supply of electrical energy toany electrical equipment
the isolation of any electrical equipment
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
34/80
Regulation 12
Isolation means the disconnection and
separation of the electrical equipmentfrom every source of electrical energy insuch a way that this disconnection and
separation is secure
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
35/80
Regulation 13 Precautions for Work on Equipment
Made Dead
Covers the preferred system of work, thatis based upon equipment that has beenmade dead in order to prevent dangerwhilst work is carried out
Protection from equipment becomingcharged through Electro-magneticinduction or the accumulation of electricalcharge is necessary. The discharge oflatent energy is another requirement
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
36/80
Regulation 13 Precautions for Work on Equipment Made Dead
It MAY be appropriate for safety isolation proceduresto be formalised in written instructions or house rules.Permits to work may form part of the written
procedures and their use is considered essential toensure a safe system of work where this involveswork on the conductors or equipment of high voltagepower distribution systems (typically where the
working voltage exceeds 1000 volts) or where thesystem is VERY complex. The duty holder must ensure that adequate safety
rules operate The rules are effectively owned by the duty
holder on behalf of the company
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
37/80
Regulation 14
Work on or Near Live Conductors
This imposes an absolute duty
not to carry out work on or near
live electrical equipment unless itcan be properly justified by a
defined risk assessment
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
38/80
Regulation 14
Risk Assessment must consider if:
i. It is unreasonable in thecircumstances for it to be dead
ii. It is reasonable to work live
iii. Suitable precautions are taken toprevent injury
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
39/80
Regulation 16
Persons to Be Competent to Prevent
Danger and Injury
The object of the regulation is to ensurethat persons are not placed at risk due
to lack of skills on the part ofthemselves or others when dealing withelectrical equipment
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
40/80
Regulation 16
Are persons competent to avoid
danger and injury? Do they have: Sufficient technical knowledge
Adequate training and awareness
Adequate experience Ability to recognise at all times whether it
is safe for work to continue Supervision where necessary
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
41/80
Competent
Assessed and authorised in writing by
the company as having sufficienttechnical knowledge and or experienceto avoid Danger for the duties
authorised.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
42/80
Competency Assessmentand Authorisation
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
43/80
Set Up Identify the duties and appropriate
authorisation levels
Determine the skills required to performthe duties
Develop an assessment criteria tomeasure the level of understanding forthe predetermined standard
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
44/80
The MatrixA B C D E
5 SAP 2 ControlEngineer ForTrainingNetwork
4 SAP 1 IssuePTW IssueSFT UseofSpiking Gun
Use of TestEquipment
3 AP 2 11kVOperationsThroughControl Eng
ReceiveSFT IssueLOA
SuperviseLive LineTapping
SuperviseLive LineHot Stick
2 AP 1 L.V.OperationsSupervise
Long Objectin Proximity
to OHL
ConnectGenerator for
Alternativesupply
Live LineTapping Live LineHot Stick
1 CP Entry intoLVSwitchrooms
Entry into11kV
SubstationsSupervision
of aWorking Party
ReceiveLOAPTW
Entry into33/132kV
Substations
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
45/80
The MatrixA B C D E
5 SAP 2 ControlEngineer ForTrainingNetwork
4 SAP 1 IssuePTW IssueSFT UseofSpiking Gun
Use of TestEquipment
3 AP 2 11kVOperationsThroughControl Eng
ReceiveSFT IssueLOA
SuperviseLive Line
TappingSuperviseLive Line
Hot Stick
2 AP 1 L.V.OperationsSupervise
Long Objectin Proximity
to OHL
ConnectGenerator for
Alternativesupply
Live LineTapping Live LineHot Stick
1 CP Entry intoLVSwitchrooms
Entry into11kV
SubstationsSupervision
of a
Working PartyReceive
LOA
PTWEntry into33/132kV
Substations
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
46/80
Dependencies
A1 Entry into LV Switchrooms
B1 Entry into 11kV Substations D1 Receive LOA and PTW
A2 LV Operations
A3 11kV Operations through Control
B3 Receive SFT
C3 Issue LOA
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
47/80
DependenciesA B C D E
5 SAP 2 ControlEngineer ForTrainingNetwork
4 SAP 1 IssuePTW IssueSFT UseofSpiking Gun
Use of TestEquipment
3
AP 2 11kVOperations
ThroughControl Eng
Receive
SFTIssue
LOASuperviseLive LineTapping
SuperviseLive LineHot Stick
2 AP 1 L.V.OperationsSupervise
Long Objectin Proximity
to OHL
ConnectGenerator for
Alternativesupply
Live LineTapping Live LineHot Stick
1 CP Entry intoLVSwitchrooms
Entry into11kV
SubstationsSupervision
of a
Working PartyReceive
LOA
PTWEntry into33/132kV
Substations
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
48/80
Audit
Periodic safety audits of all Authorised
Persons Retention and audit of completed safety
documents
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
49/80
Review Procedure
Authorisations should be reviewed
periodically and amended as necessary No set time period for refresher training
Dependent on frequency of skill
utilisation and experience HSE advise that it should be as
necessary to maintain competence
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
50/80
Powers of Inspectors The right to enter premises, inspect,
investigate, examine, take measurements,
photographs, samples, articles or substances To have articles or substances dismantled or
subjected to test Require persons to give evidence
Require the production of, inspect or takecopies of any book, documents or registersrelevant to his authority
Issue Improvement Notices
Issue Prohibition Notices
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
51/80
Penalties For an offence brought before a
Magistrates Court the maximum fine is
20,000 plus six months imprisonment+ 5,000 for each regulation breached
For an offence brought before a Crown
Court the fine can be unlimited and, forcertain offences, imprisonment up totwo years can be imposed
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
52/80
Regulation 29 Defence
Regulation 29 only applies in
criminal proceedings. It provides adefence for a duty holder who canestablish that he took all reasonable
steps and exercised all duediligence to avoid committing anoffence under the absolute
regulations
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
53/80
The Management of Health andSafety at Work Regulations 1999
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
54/80
Regulation 3 Risk Assessment
Every employer shall make suitable and
sufficient assessment of the risks to the health and safety of his
employees to which they are exposedwhile they are at work; and
to persons not in his employment arisingout of or in connection with the conductby him of his undertaking,
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
55/80
Method Statement A method statement should provide adequate
levels of information across all the elements
of the work, with regard to the hazardsidentified and the related risks, and howthese will be controlled through an agreedmethod and sequence of work activities by
identified personnel and plant/equipment
The detail given must be proportionate to thelevel of risk, and give or reference related risk
assessment
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
56/80
Regulation 8 Procedures for serious and imminent
danger and for danger areas Every employer shall establish and where
necessary give effect to appropriateprocedures to be followed in the event ofserious and imminent danger to persons at
work in his undertaking Nominate sufficient employees to
implement those procedures
Restrict access to danger areas
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
57/80
Regulation 13
Capabilities and Training
Employers should provide H&S training: Upon Recruitment
Change of employee responsibilities
New equipment or change in use of that
equipment New technology
New systems of work
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
58/80
Regulation 13
Training should be repeated
Periodically where appropriate
Employers should review their employees
capabilities to carry out their work, as
necessary. If additional training, includingrefresher training, is needed it should beprovided.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
59/80
CompetencyStages of the
Individual
UnconsciousIncompetence
(Unaware ofLimitations)
Conscious
Incompetence(During training
anddevelopment)
ConsciousCompetence
(Trained andassessed ascompetent)
IndividualPresented withNew Task
(Not assessed ascompetent)
UnconsciousIncompetence
(Develops badhabits)
UnconsciousCompetence
(Develops goodhabits)
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
60/80
General Regulations
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
61/80
Control of Substances Hazardous toHealth Regulations 2002 (Revised
2005)
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
62/80
COSHH
Prevent workplace disease from exposure tohazardous substances
Hazardous material is any material, mixtureor compound harmful to peoples health
There must be an assessment of health risks
and a selection of suitable control measures Suppliers material safety data sheet is not a
risk assessment. It is part of the informationrequired to make an assessment
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
63/80
The Confined Spaces Regulations 1997
What is a confined space?
A confined space has two definingfeatures:
Such a space is substantially closed
There is a foreseeable risk from hazardoussubstances or conditions within the space ornearby
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
64/80
The Confined Spaces Regulations 1997
The regulations require:
Identification of a confined space.
The work to be done outside wherereasonably practicable
Formal risk assessment Safe systems of work
Rescue arrangements
Training
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
65/80
Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and
Dangerous Occurrences Regulations1995
Reporting of certain injuries, diseasesand dangerous occurrences so that themost serious injuries can be brought tothe attention of the enforcing authoritiesquickly.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
66/80
Reporting of Injuries, Diseases and Dangerous
Occurrences Regulations 1995
The Regulations require the following: When any person dies or suffers any major injury, or
where there is a dangerous occurrence as a result ofwork activities the responsible person must notify therelevant enforcing authority.
This must be done by the quickest practicable meansand a report must be sent within 10 days.
If the injury suffered is not classed as major but requiresan absence of more than three calendar days then onlya report alone is required
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
67/80
The Lifting Operations Lifting
Equipment Regulations 1998
Applies to any item of equipment used
for lifting including accessories such aslifting hooks and eyebolts.
Accessories for lifting must be
thoroughly examined at least every sixmonths.
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
68/80
The Lifting Operations Lifting Equipment
Regulations 1998
A written examination scheme shoulddevised.
Reports of thorough examinations andinspections should be kept available at
the place where the lifting equipment isto be used
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
69/80
Safety Signs & Signals
Regulations 1996
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
70/80
Prohibition Sign
Prohibition sign - a sign prohibiting
behaviour likely to increase or causedanger
POINT OFISOLATION
Do not interfere
Empower Training Services Limited
POINT OFISOLATION
Do not interfere
Empower Training Services Limited
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
71/80
PERICOLOApparecchiaturain Tensione
PERICOLOApparecchiaturain Tensione
Warning Sign Warning sign - a sign giving warning of
a hazard or danger
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
72/80
Mandatory Sign
Mandatory sign a sign prescribing
specific behaviour
Arc-protective
clothing must
be worn
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
73/80
Safe Condition Safe condition sign a sign giving
information about a safe condition
CMECME
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
74/80
The Work at HeightsRegulations 2005
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
75/80
The Work at Heights Regulations 2005
What is work at heights?
Work in any place from which a personcould fall a distance liable to causepersonal injury
Includes
access and egress work at or below ground level;
but not stairways or slips or trips on the
level
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
76/80
The Work at Heights Regulations 2005
53 deaths and 4000 major injuries fromfalls at work in 2004
Duty holders must: Avoid work at height whenever they can
Use work equipment or other measures to
prevent falls where they cannot avoid work Where they cannot eliminate the risk of a
fall, use work equipment or other measuresto minimise the distance and
consequences of a fall should one occur
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
77/80
The Work at Heights Regulations 2005 Ladders and steps are not banned
But they should only be used when all
other safer alternatives for work at heighthave been ruled out
A risk assessment must show that the taskis low risk and of short duration, or that
there are site features that mean otherequipment is not appropriate. If so, laddersand steps can be used
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
78/80
Common Law
Evolved over hundreds of years as a result
of decisions of courts and judges. Theaccumulation of common law cases hasresulted in a system of precedents ordecisions in previous cases which are
binding in future similar cases.
The burden of proof in common law casesrests with the claimant the injured party
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
79/80
Employer vs Employee Claimant must prove that he/she was owed a
duty by whoever he/she is suing, that there
was a breach of that duty and as a result ofthat breach he/she suffered damage.
Defences could be that there was no
negligence, there was no duty owed, theaccident was the sole fault of the employee,the accident did not result from a lack of care,contributory negligence or that the employee
knowingly accepted the risk
7/31/2019 1 Legislation
80/80
Damages Damages awarded depend upon:
Loss of a faculty
Permanent nature of an injury
Its effect on the ability to earn a living
The expenses incurred
The amount is decided by the judge and maybe reduced by a percentage if there is foundto be a contribution to the injury caused bythe claimants own negligence