+ All Categories
Home > Documents > 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by...

1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by...

Date post: 31-Mar-2015
Category:
Upload: edwin-covey
View: 214 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
Popular Tags:
93
1 The Grey P artridge Past, Present and Future
Transcript
Page 1: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

1

The Grey Partridge

Past, Present and FutureThe Grey Partridge

Past, Present and Future

Page 2: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

2

The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the

NGO Educational Trust

and the individuals and organisations who have provided the component

images.

It should not be reproduced in part or as a whole without

their permission.

© National Gamekeepers’ Organisation Educational Trust, April 2013

The Grey Partridge

Past, Present and FutureThe Grey Partridge

Past, Present and Future

Page 3: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

3

The NGO Educational Trust are particularly indebted to the Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust (G&WCT) for providing much of the material contained in this presentation and also Stephen Tapper and Dick Potts for their help and advice throughout this project.

The Trust also wish to thank:- Jacques Hicter for allowing us to use and include his DVD Perdreaux et Quintaux (Partridges and Yields).- The British Ecological Society for allowing us to reproduce three research papers published in the Journal of Applied Ecology

We also wish to thank David Mason for providingthe majority of the photographs used in thispresentation.

Acknowledgements

Page 4: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

4

The Grey Partridge has evolved in the temperate grassland ecosystems of the Asian Steppes in the Northern Hemisphere.

Man’s early development in agriculture, especially the clearing of woodland and early growth of cereal crops created even more and new favourable habitat and brought about a further increase in numbers

The Grey Partridge

Page 5: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

5

Farming between the Wars

Back to the 1930s, when corn was cut with a reaper

Page 6: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

6

...and sheaths of corn stacked in stooks to ripen before threshing

Farming between the Wars

Page 7: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

7

Throughout Europe, Asia and North America (where it was introduced) the Grey Partridge was a prolific species and was the most numerous bird on many arable farms.

In the 20th century it became an iconic image of rural Britain with ‘coveys’ of partridge to be seen in most fields.

Iconic Image

Page 8: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

8

In the years following the second world war there was a dramatic decline in Grey Partridge numbers, not only in Britain but across its full range.

This was due to:- a reduction in predator control due to the number of gamekeepers serving and killed during World War 2- the modernisation and development of intensive farming practice involving the extensive use of pesticides, particularly herbicides.

Modern Farming

Page 9: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

9

Fieldsport Feedback

This decline was first noticed, recorded and reported by the shooting organisations. The Grey Partridge was a prolific and popular game bird highly regarded as an exciting quarry species and much prized for its delectable flavour. Over 2 million were shot annually in the UK between the wars and some 25 million shot annually across Europe. At that time it was the most important lowland game bird.

Analysis of game bags on major shooting estates enabled a graphical representation of its decline in Britain.

Similar declines were recorded across Northern Europe.

Page 10: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

10

1900 1910 1920 1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000

2

4

6

8

10

Bag

per

100

hec

t are

s

WWI WWII

Game Bag Records Show Decline of the Species

Page 11: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

11

Population Decline

It is estimated that there were more than 1 million breeding pairs in Britain prior to the second World War and this population has now reduced to 65,000 pairs.

It is also estimated that in 1953 there were 110 million pairs in the world which had reduced to 25 million by 1985.

Page 12: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

12

The Grey Partridge decline is clearly a world phenomenon but nowhere is it more significant than in England.

Our focus is on Grey Partridge but it also poses the question as to the effect of the same factors on a wide range of other wildlife species, such as butterflies, sharing the same habitat.

Is this an indication that all is not well in the British countryside?

Meadow Brown Tortoiseshell Peacock

Global Decline

Page 13: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

13

Not surprisingly it was game biologists, most notably Dr. G.R. Potts, who were the first to scientifically investigate and demonstrate the reasons for this decline.

Much of this early research in Britain was carried out at:-• ICI Game Research Station at Fordingbridge• then the Game Conservancy Trust, now the Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust currently based at Burgate Manor, Fordingbridge

Population Decline

Page 14: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

14

Britain’s first steps in ecology

Game biologists were the first to show the consequences of herbicide use for farmland birds. Early work by Dr. D. Middleton, the first director of the Game Research Association funded by Eley, included studies on the % of birds surviving from hatching to adulthood.

Doug Middleton

The Grey Partridge is now one of the most intensively studied birds in Britain.

A summary of partridge research projects is included on the disk & the NGO ET website

Three of the most important research papers are also included on the disk & the NGO ET website

Page 15: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

15

G.R.Potts’ book ‘The Partridge’, Pesticides, Predation and Conservation published by Collins in 1986 was, and still is, regarded as the complete, authoritative gospel

An Authoritative Guide

Page 16: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

16

Professor Jon Hutton is a member of the monitoring group of the United Nations Environment Programme based at Cambridge and he is also Chair of the Sustainable Use Specialist Group. Their role is to evaluate the values of Biodiversity and put authoritative biodiversity knowledge at the centre of decision making.He has pointed out that:-

22 million recreational hunters spend £16 billion per annum (shooting, falconry, angling, etc) gives economical value to land and habitats

favourable to wild species which would otherwise be converted to crop lands. Recreational hunting achieves conservation in situations where there are

few alternatives. Where it is practiced responsibly in context with good governance

recreational hunting is an important tool for conservation. Those linking hunting with conservation need to demonstrate what they are

doing and why.

Conservation and the Recreational Shooter

Page 17: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

17

Fieldsport Feedback

The appearance of much of the British countryside as we know it today has been largely shaped by hunting, shooting and farming.

It was the ‘recreational shooter’ who first alerted the government to the demise of the grey partridge and they are the body/group most prepared and determined to actively seek a solution.

One of the problems in the UK is that few of the government, scientific and wildlife bodies have as much experience or background knowledge as the ‘hunter’ based organisations. Liaison between both camps is now, thankfully, beginning to improve.

It is now generally recognised that the future of the Grey Partridge is closely linked to recreational shooting.

If it was made a protected species or game shooting was banned, then most of the finance and conservation management linked to field sports, which is bringing about it’s current recovery, could disappear overnight.

Page 18: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

18

Biodiversity Action Plan (BAP)

In 1996 the Grey Partridge was identified in Britain as a Biodiversity Action Plan Species and it was the Game Conservancy Trust (now the Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust) who were made the ‘lead partner’ by the UK government.

They are responsible for delivering targets by deadlines

Their role is to carry out research, advise, monitor, advocate and demonstrate, best practice and get the research into Government’s agri-environment policy.

Page 19: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

19

Factors involved in Grey

Partridge decline in Britain

The annual National Game Census, which was initiated by the GCT in 1956, monitors a number of species including the Grey Partridge.

Studies in Grey Partridge mortality rate initiated by the GCT looked at deaths recorded at various stages in life cycle/ year :-

1 Egg mortality2 Nesting Hen mortality3 Chick mortality4 Shooting mortality5 Winter mortality

These studies led to insect monitoringin farmland starting in 1969

Page 20: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

20

National grey partridge

Spring pair monitoring

1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 20100

10

20

30

Sp

ring

pa

irs/k

m2

Long-term members

New members

The significant peaks in early 50’s, 1960 and mid 70’s are thought to be due to particularly good weather in Spring and early Summer.

There is an old saying that “a wet Ascot week means a bad year for partridges”

Page 21: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

21

A Sussex monitoring site

Sussex autumn partridge count - 1970

Shows a family covey(pair + offspring)

Page 22: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

22

Sussex autumn partridge count - 1994

A Sussex monitoring site

Shows a family covey(pair + offspring)

Page 23: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

23

Sussex autumn partridge count - 2008

Shows a family covey(pair + offspring)

A Sussex monitoring site

Page 24: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

24

Sussex site conclusion

The monitoring of Grey Partridge in this Sussex site is a typical example showing a progressive decline from 1970 to 1994 and then on to 2008.

However, this site includes a discrete recovery in the east of this region centred on the Norfolk Estate, Arundel. This recovery demonstrates what can be achieved and is testament to the hard work and commitment of the Duke of Norfolk and his team. A summary of this project is included on the disk.

Page 25: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

25

Population Decline

• The recorded 80% decline in Grey Partridge is similar in both timing and rate in several Northern European countries. The modernisation of farming spread so quickly that many of the factors involved in the decline were synchronised across much of the Northern hemisphere.

• Conclusions from studies in Britain may well therefore be relevant elsewhere.

Page 26: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

26

Main Issues Identified

1. Habitat decline

2. Decline in Gamekeepers

Reduction in predator control

Habitat and conservation management

3. Increased use of pesticides and herbicide

Page 27: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

27

Main Issue 1: Habitat Decline

Habitat decline; more and more land has been taken into modern intensive farming with larger fields bringing about loss of hedgerows and hedge banks.

The introduction of new winter wheat varieties led to a prevalence of Autumn seed drilling. This resulted in a reduction of Winter stubbles and subsequent loss of Winter food for both partridges and songbirds.

However G&WCT still estimate that there is potential suitable general habitat for 511,000 pairs of Grey Partridge (8x more than we have actually got).

Page 28: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

28

Potential habitat within the UK

Optimum Land = 36,000 km2 (yellowyellow)

Sub-optimum land = 42,000 km2 (green)

Present UK population is 65,000 pairs

There is a habitat potential of 511,000 pairs.

Page 29: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

29

Potential Habitat

This poses the question why the current population is so low; the current population is 65,000 pairs whereas the estimated habitat potential is 511,000.

This shows that habitat may be important but is not the most significant factor.

Page 30: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

30

Necessary Habitat Improvement

• Providing “year round” food for grey partridge

• Late winter and spring cover

• Nesting cover

• Accessible, insect rich habitat for brood rearing

Page 31: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

31

Habitat Improvement

Nesting cover

Grey Partridge favour nest sites in grass margins adjacent to hedgerows on banks

Page 32: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

32

Habitat Improvement

Old dead tussocky grass

It is the previous year’s uncut dead grass that provides the best nesting sites

Page 33: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

33

Habitat Improvement

Page 34: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

34

Accessible, insect rich habitat next to nesting cover

This could be further improved by providing protection from aerial strikes.

Habitat Improvement

Page 35: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

35

The margin flora is unaffected by cropping rotation

The headland loss is of little economic significance because this is an area of traditionally poor crop yield and is better utilised for conservation.

A 6-metre strip all round a field provides territory for a greater number of partridge pairs than the same area in a single block

Habitat Improvement

Page 36: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

36

A colourful public relations brood rearing mix!

However, a 6-metre margin of unsprayed and unfertilised stubble is more important to the Grey Partridge chicks

Habitat Improvement

Page 37: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

37

Over winter food & cover-stubbles

Habitat Improvement

Page 38: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

38

Un-harvested Conservation Headlands

This looks good and in the absence of other cover can provide useful shelter from raptors immediately after harvest. However the large single flush of

food attracts vermin, particularly rats.

Habitat Improvement

Page 39: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

39

Biennial cover crops such as Kale

This can provide vital cover for pairs in Spring

Habitat Improvement

Page 40: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

40

Kale mixes

Kale provides good cover and when mixed with different varieties of quinoa, which ripen in sequence, achieves continuous natural food over a greater

period of time.

Habitat Improvement

Page 41: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

41

Post harvest auto-cast Kale

Gamekeepers continuously experiment to get the most beneficial margin habitat including annually renewing half and leaving half to provide cover. Kale provides good cover but another option is 3 metres of chicory, both reduce sparrow hawk strikes, and then a further 3 metres of wild flower mix sown amongst cereal as a

brood mixture providing seeds and insects. The food hopper provides over-winter and spring feeding.

The following June it looks like this

Habitat Improvement

Page 42: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

42

Habitat Improvement Summary

Provide round the year cover that offers:1. Protection from predators - especially in

late winter & spring2. Nesting areas3. Accessible, insect rich areas

For further information go to www.gwct.org.uk

Page 43: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

43

Main Issue 2: The Decline of Gamekeeping

1911 1981

Gamekeepers per 1000 hectares

>1.6

0.8 - 1.6

0.4 - 0.8

0.2 - 0.4

0.1 - 0.2

<0.1

The 25,000 employed in 1911 has shrunk by 80%Traditionally it was one keeper per thousand acres

Page 44: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

44

Days of Plenty

Page 45: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

45

Grey Partridge Predators

Fox

Stoat WeaselRat

The fox is the most serious predator, followed by the stoat, rat and weasel.

Different predators tend to be more destructive at different times of the year

It was always said that to avoid foxes coveys fly out into the middle of fields to ‘jug up’ for the night – thus leaving no scent trail leading to them

Page 46: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

46

Grey Partridge Predators

The Grey Partridge has a number of winged predators. Amongst these two the carrion crow is the most serious

followed by the magpie.

MagpieCarrion Crow

Page 47: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

47

Intra-guild effects on fox

Intra-guild predation on the red fox

Top predator Numbers reduction/interference on fox Authority

Gamekeeper 83% Tapper et al. (1996)

Coyote 86% Sovada et al. (1995)

Lynx 41% Helldin et al. (2006)

Wolf 36% coyote Berger & Gese (2007)

Golden eagle Ξ13% diet Korpimaki & Nordström (2004)

Intra-guild predation, in which higher level predators control middle or lower level predators within a food web, is a factor which is reducing in many countries. Historically the red fox population would have been held in check by a number of natural predators.

However the wolf, lynx, coyote and golden eagles are no longer present in many countries. It is now a crucial role of the gamekeeper to attempt to restore and keep the balance particularly in the British countryside.

Page 48: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

48

Predator Control

1. Rifle and scope

2. Shotgun

3. Larsen trap

4. Spring traps used in a tunnel

5. Approved snares

4

32

1

5

Tools of the trade

Page 49: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

49

A rolling landscape of arable, sheep grazing and military training

Salisbury Plain Predator Control Experiment

Page 50: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

50

Salisbury Plain study areas

M ilston

C ollingbourne

Tidworth

Bulford

N orth1 Km

Arable

G rass

Page 51: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

51

Decline in Game Keepers

The 25,000 keepers employed in 1911 have reduced by 80% leading to a reduction in predator control

In the Salisbury Plain Experiment Grey Partridge numbers on large plots of land were monitored over a 3 year test period. A plot of keepered land with good predator control was compared to a plot with no predator control.

At the end of 3 years the predator control variable for the 2 plots was reversed for a further 3 year period.

Page 52: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

52

Adult malesTotal birdsBag

53233

22

32213

65

Partridge brood counts

1984 The Baseline Year

Covey – size related

Single male (hen killed?)

Adult pair with no offspring(eggs eaten or no chicks survived)

Page 53: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

53

Adult malesTotal birdsBag

3079

1

57318 27

No control 1987 Predation control

Covey – size related

Single male (hen killed?)

Adult pair with no offspring(eggs eaten or no chicks survived)

Partridge brood counts

Page 54: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

54

Adult males

Total birds

Bag

49

399

105

29

128

25

Predation control 1990 No control

Covey – size related

Single male (hen killed?)

Adult pair with no offspring(eggs eaten or no chicks survived)

Partridge brood counts

Page 55: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

55

Conclusions• Predation control

– Increased the production of young grey partridge

– August numbers improved 75% annually– Over 3 years this resulted in a 3.5 fold change

– Breeding stocks, measured in spring, increased by 35% p.a.– Over 3 years resulted in a 2.6 fold change

Salisbury Plain Predator Control Experiment

Page 56: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

56

Gamekeepers and Conservation

Gamekeepers would also be involved in reducing disturbance to breeding partridge, the maintenance of favourable habitat, particularly game crops.

Also provision of supplementary feeding particularly in Winter.In Spring many pairs nest close to these feed sites. This may reduce the size of territory resulting in pairs nesting closer together.

These activities also benefit a wide range of other species

The G&WCT and the NGO believe that wise use of the British countryside rather than protectionism is the most constructive route forward.

Page 57: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

57

Main Issue 3: Increased use of

pesticides and herbicides

The development and increased use of Pesticides in an attempt to increase human food production following World War II seems to have been the main trigger that started the Grey Partridge decline.

Pesticides, especially herbicides which came into use 20 years earlier than insecticides, break the chick food chain

In fact both insecticides and herbicides inhibit insect populations and diversity

Page 58: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

58

Insect Dependency

Red-Leg Partridge and chicks Grey Partridge and chicks

The use of pesticides breaks the chick food chain. This is so crucial for the Grey Partridge because the chicks are solely dependant on a plentiful supply of suitable insect species for the first 10 days after hatching before they start to eat seeds. It is interesting that Red Leg partridge chicks start on seeds after only 3 days.

Page 59: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

59

Crop Spraying

Page 60: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

60

If you must Spray

Avena spp. (wild oats): tri-allatediclofop-methyldifenzoquatflamprop-m-isopropyl

Alopecurus mysuroides (black-grass):

tri-allatediclofop-methylHOE 7113-01H

Elymus repens (couch): glyphosate

Herbicides for selective control of grass weeds in cereal headlands?

• Farmers must make a profit• Spraying is linked to yield• Be selective with the insecticides and herbicides you choose

Page 61: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

61

Breaking the food chain

What is clear is that improvements made to chemicals used in modern farming over the past few decades have not brought about the dramatic recovery in Grey Partridge numbers seen in some other species.

This may seem surprising because the Grey Partridge’s potential to ‘bounce back’, with brood size numbering up to 14, is enormous. This is because the new chemicals used are not themselves mortally toxic to the Grey Partridge or its chicks but it is that their use in modern farming methodology still has the same significant effect of breaking the crucial early chick nutrition. It will also impact on interaction within the local food web.

What is now becoming clear is that other species, such as birds like skylarks and corn buntings, are affected by these same factors.

Page 62: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

62

Breaking the food chain

It would appear that we are not dealing with a contact toxin, a lethal dose for chicks or even an accumulative toxin. Whatever new chemicals are developed and used, if they are effective as herbicides and/or insecticides, they are still collectively likely to break the chick’s food chain.

Because the timing of their application is critical to the crop it may well also unfortunately be equally critically timed to the life cycle of the Grey Partridge i.e. the first 10 days after the chicks hatch.

Reduced and selective pesticide use in response to actual crop problems rather than their use as a blanket preventative safeguard may also be beneficial.

Selective timing of the reduced use of such agro-chemicals, if achievable, may yet be a critical long term deciding factor in ensuring the future of the Grey Partridge.

Page 63: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

63

Chick survival

Low input conservation headlands to increase insects Plant Wild Bird seed mixture Don’t use summer insecticides on headlands

The availability of insect food is crucial.It could be improved by use of one or other of the entry-level stewardship options :

Page 64: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

64

Chick’s Favourite Insects

Click here to view a short YouTube video

Page 65: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

65

Grey partridge chick nutrition

Chicks raised with and without insects

Animal proteins from insects needed for fledging

Page 66: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

66

Conservation Headland

One solution is to create spray free conservation headlands, by not spraying a 6-metre border around the crop

Page 67: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

67

Un-Sprayed Conservation Headland

It is difficult to get farmers to agree not to spray headlands due to the belief that there is re-infestation by both weeds and insect pests

Page 68: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

68

Grey Partridge chick survival

Conservation headland trials in Norfolk

Page 69: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

69

Chick survival with conservation headlands

Block A(no conservation headlands)

Block B(conservation headlands introduced after 2003)

1968-2003 29% 31%

2004-2008 27% 53%

The improvement in survival amounted to an additional 3.6 chicks per brood

Two similar adjacent blocks of land, with no conservation headlands, were chosen for a comparative study. The chick survival percentage was

established for the period 1968 – 2003 on both sites.

In the period 2004 – 2008 Block A was left without conservation headlands but on Block B conservation headlands were established and maintained.

Page 70: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

70

Research programme for Conservation Headlands

Does it work for another game species? Yes it does – and also for song birds

Pheasant Linnet

Page 71: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

71

Other benefits to wildlife Wildflowers Butterflies Small mammals Predatory beetles

Corn Marigold Field Mouse

Predatory BeetleHedge Brown

Prickly Poppy

Research programme for Conservation Headlands

Page 72: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

72

Other Factors

There are clearly a number of issues involved in the Grey Partridge decline and it may well be a quite complex interaction of factors.

Previously present factors may well have become more significant as the decline reached critical thresholds.

Some think that factors such as predation by protected species inhibit any national recovery from the low population count that currently exist in many areas.

Page 73: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

73

Protected Predators

While everyone is pleased to see a recovery in the population of rare and protected species the decision makers need to recognise that if these

species are predators there is an ecological price to pay.

Red KiteHen HarrierMarsh Harrier

Page 74: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

74

While such species benefit from this protection and their populations increase beyond natural limits they start to impact on

the vulnerable prey species.

Buzzard Badger

Protected Predators

Page 75: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

75

It is possible that a national Grey Partridge recovery may be handicapped by current

increased populations of their natural predators.

Sparrowhawk

Goshawk Freshly Killed Grey Partridge

Goshawk on Pheasant

Protected Predators

Page 76: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

76

Population Dynamics Model

• Predation loss depends on

control of nest predators

• Chick survival depends on

herbicides and insecticides

• Winter loss depends on

hedgerows, spring cover and

feed hoppers

Start

PredatorControl

HerbicideUse

Spring Cover+

Feed Hoppers

BreedingStock

AutumnCount

NumberShot

WinterLoss

Increasedhen mortality

&egg loss

Decreasedhen mortality

&egg loss

Increasedchick survival

ReducedWinter loss

Reducedchick survival

IncreasedWinter loss

Shooting policydependant onAutumn countD

EC

RE

AS

ING

P

OP

UL

AT

ION

INC

RE

AS

ING

P

OP

UL

AT

ION

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

Page 77: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

77

The Royston Project

The Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust have put forward a protocol to save the Grey Partridge as a national species.

It is based on an improvement in the number of controllable factors and has been put into practice at its test site at Royston.

Page 78: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

78

Royston Protocol

1. Provide good Winter and Spring cover crops for shelter, hiding places and food.

2. Supplementary winter feeding strategically placed hoppers near cover crops and nesting sites. Also select and strategically plant insect rich habitat.

3. Good nesting sites –hedgerows and beetle banks- particularly those close to supplementary feeding sites.

4. Chick survival is increased by moderated use of selected herbicides and insecticides and provision of 6-metre unsprayed field margins

Page 79: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

79

5. Intensive Traditional Gamekeeping to provide: habitat maintenance- high level of liaison with landowners and/or tenant

farmers for the considerations listed in 14 are essential but expensive consequences of the decision making necessary to give Grey Partridge population numbers any chance of recovery

predator control- also expensive and time consuming requiring an experienced, skilled person to target identified species

The particularly well keepered Royston project loses 40% of sitting hens but without intensive game keeping it could be 80% or higher

6. Census numbers, at critical phases, help to monitor the status of the Grey Partridge within the Biodiversity Action Plan

Royston Protocol

Page 80: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

80

7. Control the practice of Grey Partridge shooting - limit to harvesting the surplus. Until stocks recover don’t shoot grey partridges

1. Only those conserving good stocks (more than 20 per 250 acres) should consider shooting

2. Never shoot greys after December

3. Never shoot partridges that are in pairs

4. Take precautions not to shoot greys when shooting redleg partridges

Royston Protocol

Page 81: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

81

Grey partridge pairs – Spring 2002

2.9 pairs / sq. km20 Pairs total

The Royston Project

Page 82: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

82

Grey partridge pairs – Spring 2007

18.4 pairs / sq.km184 pairs total

2007

The Royston Project

Page 83: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

83

Spring pairs at Royston

2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 TargetYear

0

5

10

15

20

Sprin

g pa

irs /

100

ha

Reference areaDemonstration area

01 07Predicted 31 185Actual 19

184

The Royston Project

Page 84: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

84

Number of game birds counted in autumn (Birds / sq.km)

Grey partridge Red-legged partridge Pheasant

Autumn Density Young: Old Ratio

Density Young: Old Ratio

Number

2001 7.6 0.6 15.7 0.3 66

2002 28.8 3.0 18.5 1.1 353

2003 39.1 2.9 43.9 2.2 432

2004 53.4 2.8 43.9 1.2 537

2005 60.8 1.9 58.4 0.9 612

2006 87.8 2.6 77.5 1.5 522

The Royston Project

Page 85: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

85

Number of brown hares counted in winter

YearHares

Demo Ref

Spring 2002 39 63

Winter 2002 94 83

Winter 2003 159 57

Winter 2004 179 75

Winter 2005 185 93

Winter 2006 216 137

The Royston Project

Page 86: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

86

Songbirds at Royston

Song Thrush

Chaffinch

GoldfinchGreenfinch

The Royston Project

Page 87: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

87

Jacques Hicter Project

Jacques Hicter, a shooting farmer from northern France, has also achieved remarkable results from a total commitment to the future of the Grey Partridge, the balance of natural ecology and modern farming methodology.

His activities feature in a DVD, sponsored by Syngenta, which is included on the

disk and can be viewed on the NGO ET YouTube Channel.

Click here to view now

Page 88: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

88

Jacques Hicter Project - Population Growth

The graph shows the population recorded at Jacques Hicter’s two farms, situated 20kms apart. He has achieved similar success at both sites.

1980 1990 2000 20100

20

40

60

80

100

pair

s p

er

10

0h

a

The sharp decline in 2007 and 2008 is

almost certainly due to adverse weather

conditions

Page 89: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

89

Grey Partridge - Conclusions

The overall impression in 2008 is that a Grey Partridge recovery will be hard earned. There is unlikely to be any short term spectacular bounce back. The G&WCT have identified a number of key factors in the original demise which may all need to be countered and they have produced recommendations in a recovery document. Even in the G&WCT project areas where a recovery is in progress it has not yet been demonstrated that a similar recovery is possible on a wide range of other soil types or that the population will standeven a controlled shooting strategy.

Page 90: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

90

What has been demonstrated by the G&WCT at Royston, Jacques Hicter in Northern France and more recently the “Norfolk Estate Project”, is that with passion and complete commitment to the future of the Grey Partridge a local/discrete recovery can be achieved.

Grey Partridge - Conclusions

Page 91: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

91

However those are very intensive and expensive projects and, at present, there seems little evidence that a general species recovery is possible without similar support. The government stewardship scheme, as far as the Grey Partridge is concerned, is probably no more than a small step in the right direction.

Dick Potts believes it will be impossible to achieve recovery targets without the crucial role of the gamekeeper.

Grey Partridge - Conclusions

Page 92: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

92

Further Documents on the CD & Website

• Jacques Hicter video – Perdreaux et Quintaux (Partridges and Yields)• G&WCT

– Conserving the Grey Partridge– Insect population graphs (1970 – 2005)– How to identify grey partridges– Chick food favourites– Environmental Stewardship: Making the most for grey partridges– Late winter and spring feeding of pheasants and partridges– Providing nesting cover for wild grey partridges– Providing brood-rearing cover for wild grey partridges– Providing winter cover and food for wild grey partridges– Restoring wild grey partridges to your farm– Using predation control to increase wild grey partridge numbers– Summary of research projects

• British Ecological Society published research papers– Pesticide Use on Cereals and the Survival of Grey Partridge Chicks: A Field Experiment

Author(s): M. R. W. Rands – Effect of Hedgerow Characteristics on Partridge Breeding Densities Author(s): M. R. W. Rands – The Effect of an Experimental Reduction in Predation Pressure on the Breeding Success and

Population Density of Grey Partridges Perdix perdix Author(s): S. C. Tapper, G. R. Potts, M. H. Brockless

• Dick Potts – Norfolk Estate Project review

Page 93: 1 The Grey Partridge Past, Present and Future. 2 The copyright of this presentation is reserved by the NGO Educational Trust and the individuals and organisations.

93

For further information regarding any aspects of this presentation please contact:

Brian HayesNGO Educational TrustPO Box 3360StourbridgeWest MidlandsDY7 5YG: 01384 [email protected]

NGO EDUCATIONAL TRUST

CONTACT DETAILS


Recommended