+ All Categories
Home > Documents > 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What...

17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What...

Date post: 10-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: trinhminh
View: 216 times
Download: 2 times
Share this document with a friend
43
1 Melinda Welton, Gulf Coast Bird Observatory David Anderson, Louisiana State University Edgar Selvin Pérez, Defensores de la Naturaleza Gabriel Colorado, Univ Nacional de Colombia David Mehlman, The Nature Conservancy Cerulean Warbler In search of critical migratory habitat 1) All of you are aware of the plight of the CERW and that a technical group formed in 2001 to discuss and prioritize CERW research and conservation needs. One of the highest highest research needs id by the group was basic natural history info about the sp during the non-breeding season. Paul Hamel immediately assembled a
Transcript
Page 1: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

1

Melinda Welton, Gulf Coast Bird Observatory

David Anderson, Louisiana State University

Edgar Selvin Pérez, Defensores de la Naturaleza

Gabriel Colorado, Univ Nacional de Colombia

David Mehlman, The Nature Conservancy

Cerulean WarblerIn search of critical migratory habitat

1) All of you are aware of the plight of the CERW and that a technical group formed in 2001 to discuss and prioritize CERW research and conservation needs.

One of the highest highest research needs id by the group was basic natural history info about the sp during the non-breeding season.

Paul Hamel immediately assembled a

Page 2: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

2

El Grupo

Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Bolivia, U.S., Canada

Page 3: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

3

?

Page 4: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

4

Union Camp

Page 5: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

5

Ted Parker1953 - 1993

Parker speculated that

In mid-March, most CERW move along the eastern slopes of the Andes to n. Columbia

Fly >1,500 km across the W Caribbean Ocean

Moving NW until reaching land somewhere over the coast from Nicaragua to Belize

They continue inland to suitable lower montane forest in low mountains facing the Caribbean coast

Where they spend the next three weeks (late-March - mid-April)

Page 6: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

6

Potential staging area

Page 7: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

7

Significant habitat degradation in a geographically small area could imperil the Cerulean Warbler

Conservation Implications

Page 8: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

8

2004Belize Expedition

Page 9: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

9

Hurricane Iris, October 8, 2001

Page 10: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

10

Tallest trees Union

Union Camp, April 2004

Forest to the south of the camp was badly damages

Remarkably, little damage to N,E,& W

Page 11: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

11

16 Cerulean Warblers (13 males, 3 females)

April 2 – 4, 2004

Most common migrant recorded

2004 Results

Page 12: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

12

2004 Survey Locations

2004 Survey Locations

Page 13: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

13

2005 Survey Locations

2005 Survey Locations

Page 14: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

14

Goals for 2005

• Survey locations of historic records

• Survey sites consistent with Parker’s criteria: lower montane forest, in low mountains facing the Caribbean coast

• Build capacity among local biologists

Page 15: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

15

Workshop

With the assistance of David Anderson, PhD candidate at LSU, and Selvin Perez, and several Honduran and Guatemala biologists

Page 16: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

16

Methods

• Teams of 2 - 3 biologists

• Line transect length 2 to 3.5 km

• Timing 0630 - 1100 and

1430 - 1630

• Composition of all flocks recorded

• Additional data collected for CERW

Page 17: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

17

2005 Results

2005 Results

32 Surveys conducted(4 Guatemala, 28 Honduras)

29 Ceruleans observed(11 Guatemala, 18 Honduras)

April 1 - 14

Page 18: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

18

2005 Results

2005 Results

32 Surveys conducted(4 Guatemala, 28 Honduras)

29 Ceruleans observed(11 Guatemala, 18 Honduras)

25 CERW at 3 sites

April 1 - 14

Page 19: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

19

Goals for 2006

• Resurvey 2005 sites with Ceruleans

• Increase geographic range

• Increase elevation range

• Will playback increase detections?

Page 20: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

20

Playback

Page 21: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

21

2006 Survey Locations

2006 Survey Locations

Page 22: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

22

2006 results

2006 Results

47 Surveys conducted(11 Guatemala, 36 Honduras)

48 Ceruleans observed(27 Guatemala, 21 Honduras)

April 1 - 15

Page 23: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

23

Encounter Frequency

Page 24: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

24

Encounter FrequencyEncounter Frequency

Page 25: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

25

What have we learned?

• Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years

• They use a broad elevation range

• Found in both primary and mature secondary

• Erratic in their response to playback

• Geographic range conforms to Parker

Page 26: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

26

What have we learned?

• Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years

• They use a broad elevation range

• Found in both primary and mature secondary

• Erratic in their response to playback

• Geographic range conforms to Parker

Page 27: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

27

Ceruleans by Elevation

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

0 - 199 200 - 399 400 - 599 600 - 799 800 - 999 > 1,000

Elevation (m)

Belize

Guatemala

Honduras

Page 28: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

28

What have we learned?

• Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years

• They use a broad elevation range

• Found in both primary and mature secondary

• Erratic in their response to playback

• Geographic range conforms to Parker

Page 29: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

29

Ceruleans by Habitat Type

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Primaryforest

Maturesecondary

Shadeplantation

Other

Habitat

Belize

Guatemala

Honduras

Page 30: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

30

What have we learned?

• Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years

• They use a broad elevation range

• Found in both primary and mature secondary

• Erratic in their response to playback

• Geographic range conforms to Parker

Page 31: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

31

Playback

• 2004 two positive responses

• 2005 two positive responses

• 2006 no responses to playback

• 2006 9 Ceruleans singing(8 Guatemala, 1 Honduras)

Page 32: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

32

What have we learned?

• Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years

• They use a broad elevation range

• Found in both primary and mature secondary

• Erratic in their response to playback

• Geographic range conforms to Parker

Page 33: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

33

Encounter FrequencyEncounter Frequency

Page 34: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

34

Goals for 2007

• Expand the geographic range of surveys

• Extend survey dates to the 3rd week in April

• Ground truth a predictive habitat model

Page 35: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

35

2007 Mahalanobis Model

Legend

Rio Plátano Biosphere Reserve

MayaMountains

Bosawás BiosphereReserve

Page 36: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

36

2007 Survey locations

Page 37: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

37

Winds aloft

April

1,525 meters

From Gauthreaux(2005)

Do all Ceruleans need to stop?

Page 38: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

38

Winds aloft

April

1,525 meters

From Gauthreaux(2005)

Do all Ceruleans need to stop?

Page 39: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

39

AcknowledgementsField & Technical AssistanceKelvin Bodden, Daniel Boone, Francisco Cabanas, Eloise Canfield, Barbara Dowell, Roberto Downing, David Medina Gámez, Pablo Herrera, Johana Mejia, David Shoch, Elizabeth Shoch, Luis Soto, Juan Carlos Sorto, Ricardo Steiner, Jaime Talavera, Francisco Urbina, Lemuel Valle, Wilson Miguel Vasquez, Mark Bonta, Paul Hamel, David Pashley, Sherry “Pilar” Thorn.

Logistical SupportJorge Betancourt, Nicolas Leiva, Teodoro Argueta, Kelvin Bodden, Carlos Alvarenga , Louis Alicea, Angel Boesch, USAID Project MIRA fielded staff, staff of AMITIGRA, Wilfredo Chavez, Ing. Enid Adonis Hernandez Amaya, the staff of Las Cabanas de Aventura, staff of FUNDAECO.

Additional FundingLyndhurst Foundation, Percy Sladen Award of the Linnean Society of London, Patagonia, Recreational Equipment Incorporated.

Page 40: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

40

Questions?

Page 41: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

41

Habitat model

Page 42: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

42

Questions?

Page 43: 17 Welton CERW Migration - U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Frequency Encounter Frequency. 25 What have we learned? • Ceruleans use the same sites in subsequent years ... 17 Welton

43

Ceruleans forage in mixed-species foraging flocks in mid-canopy

AverageForaging height 15.0 m

Tree height 20.6 m

Canopy height 23.5 m

Emergent trees 29.3 m


Recommended