4/20/2015
1
DOL Update
Michael E. Auerbach, CPA
Chief, Division of Accounting Services
Employee Benefits Security Administration
The views expressed are those of the speaker and do not necessarily represent the official position of the Department
MD Association of CPAsEmployee Benefit Plans ConferenceApril 27, 2015
Overview• EBSA Audit Quality Study
• New Initiatives
• Enforcement Initiatives
• On the Horizon – Emerging Issues
• DOL Resources
2
2
4/20/2015
2
3
Audit Quality Study
Statistical Sample of 400 Plan Audits• 2011 Form 5500 filings
• 6 strata based on size of EBP practice• 1-2 plans
• 3-5 plans
• 6-24 plans
• 25-99 plans
• 100-749 plans
• 750 + plans
• 1 audit in lowest 2 strata, 5 in all others
4
4
4/20/2015
3
Our Sample• Type of Audit
• 80% = Limited Scope• 19% = Full Scope• 1% = Other
• Plan Type• 89% = DC Pension Plan• 6% = DB Pension Plan• 5% = Welfare Plan
• Sponsor Type• 95% = Single Employer• 3% = Multi-Employer• 2% = Multiple Employer
• EBPAQC Member• 55% = Yes• 45% = No
5
5
Maryland CPAs
6
Number ofPlan Audits
CPAFirms
Numberof Audits
PlanAssets
PlanParticipants
1-2 66 85 $495.6M 22,497
3-5 40 92 $1.00B 37,456
6-24 89 425 $15.88B 367,573
25-99 53 468 $42.38B 1,303,127
100-749 23 309 $73.12B 1,099,719
750+ 11 254 $13.43B 434,576
4/20/2015
4
7
Findings
8
Audit Quality Continues to Decline
4/20/2015
5
Size of EBP Practice Matters
• Correlation between a firm’s EBP practice and deficient work
• Nearly 75% of plan audits were deficient in firms who audit 1-2 plans annually
• Deficient audits in this strata also had multiple deficiencies
• Less EBP specific training by firms in this strata
9
9
Practice Monitoring/Peer Review are not Useful Identifiers of Quality EBP Audits
• Firms had clean peer review reports where we identified deficient EBP audit work• 70% in 1-2 strata
• 85% in the 3-5 strata
• 90% in 6-99 stratum
• In 4 of 6 strata, audits with 5+ GAAS deficiencies were performed by firms with clean peer review reports
10
10
4/20/2015
6
Other Useful Findings
• EBPAQC member firms had a lower deficiency rate than non member firms
• Audit work is often of lesser quality in engagements where firms have less expertise
11
11
12
Other Useful Findings
• Problematic audit areas continue to be the same EBP-specific areas as previously identified
• No meaningful correlation between audit fees and the quality of audit work
4/20/2015
7
1313
Referrals of Deficient Audit Work
• 131 referrals made to the AICPA’s Professional Ethics Division
• 13 referrals made to state boards of public accountancy
What Is Our Current Focus?
• High Risk Audit Engagements
• Health and Welfare Plans
• ESOPs
• Plans with hard-to-value assets
• Re-inspections of CPA firms
• Continued Outreach to EBP Stakeholders
14
14
4/20/2015
8
15
New Initiatives
Peer Review
• Compliance with state peer review licensing requirements?
• Provide evidence that an acceptable peer review was performed
• CPAs performing audits (in the Form 5500 database) –that are not in the AICPA’s peer review records
• AICPA has found numerous CPAs performing attest engagements that have not been enrolled in the peer review program
16
16
4/20/2015
9
Licensure
• Is the CPA performing the audit – licensed?
• Are CPA firms properly licensed where they practice?• Rules vary by state
• NASBA website – auditor mobility
• NASBA provided list of plan auditors to states• States reviewing to see if CPAs are properly licensed
17
17
18
Enforcement Initiatives
4/20/2015
10
Reporting Compliance Enforcement
• Reporting of fidelity bonding status
• Missing audit reports
• Compliance with Small Pension Plan Audit Waiver requirements
• DFVC program compliance
• Plan asset accountability
• Health & welfare plan non-filers
• Stop filers (cooperative initiative with IRS)
19
19
Health & Welfare Benefit Plans• Benefit claims adjudication/payments:
• very complex • inherently a high risk of errors, misstatements or fraud.
• Must be paid:• in the correct amount timely, in accordance with plan documents• Only to or on behalf of eligible, covered persons entitled to receive benefits
• Properly recorded and described in plan financial statements
• Type 2-SOC 1 reports may not include controls over whether the claim or benefit payment was appropriately calculated based on the provisions of the plan instrument.
20
20
4/20/2015
11
On the Horizon – Emerging Issues
• New Actuarial Study Longevity Improvements Considerations
• FASB Simplification Project
• Auditing Standards Board Project to Improve Plan Audit Reports
• EFAST 3 and Form 5500 Changes
• New AICPA Audit Quality Center Tools
21
21
DOL Resources
•www.dol.gov/ebsa• For DOL publications, FAQs, copies of the Form 5500,
instructions, and related schedules
22
22
4/20/2015
12
DOL Resources• Office of the Chief Accountant 202-693-8360
• Office of Regulations and Interpretations 202-693-8500• For questions about ERISA reporting, filing or other regulatory
requirements
• DOL EFAST Help Center 1-866-463-3278• For questions regarding the Form 5500 or related schedules
23
23
24
4/20/2015
13
25
Ian MacKay, CPADirector EBPAQC
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
(EBPAQC) Update
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
ERISA Plan Audits
26
67,533 audits (82%)
15,045audits
EBPAQC (2,364 firms)
Non‐EBPAQC (4,994 firms)
Source: DOL 2011 Form 5500
82,579 ERISA audits
4/20/2015
14
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBPAQC Website—aicpa.org/ebpaqc
27
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Sharing Access to the Center Website with Staff
When your firm joined the Center you received a welcome email that contained your firm’s unique activation link.
You will need this link both to activate your account and to share access with others.
If you no longer have that email, please contact the Center at [email protected] and request that the link, along with instructions to activate the link, be resent.
There is no limit to the number of individuals in your firm to whom you grant access
28
4/20/2015
15
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBPAQC Webinars
New membership requirement for 2015
DP must participate in one of these EBPAQC Designated Partner Audit Planning webinars :
- January 21, 2014 (live webinar)
- February 24, 2014 (rebroadcast)
- May 7, 2014 (rebroadcast)
- June 9, 2014 (rebroadcast)
- Or watch archive version on EBPAQC website (available 24/7)
29
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Upcoming EBPAQC WebinarsLook for future EBPAQC EAlerts for registration information.
30
May 1, 8,
15, 27
401(k) Basics‐ 4 Parts
May 5 Using SOC 1 Tool (Rebroadcast)
May 7 Designated Partner 2015 Audit Planning (Rebroadcast)
May 28 Managers and Supervisors 2015 Audit Planning
(Rebroadcast)
June 9 Designated Partner 2015 Audit Planning (Rebroadcast)
June 16 Investment Accounting and Reporting
June 23 Auditing Investments
4/20/2015
16
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Archived EBPAQC Webinars
31
Event Date
Defined Benefit Plan Audits
ESOP Audits
401(k) Basics
Health and Welfare Plans, Part 2 ‐ Audit Planning and Risk Assessment
July 16, 2014
June 13, 2014
May 9,22,30,June 6
July 17, 2013
Health and Welfare Plans, Part 1 – Introduction and Industry Update July 10, 2013
Multiemployer Plan Audits 2013 June 12, 2013
Using the Center's SOC 1SM Documentation Tool June 5, 2013
ASU 2011‐04 Fair Value Disclosures January 25, 2013
Understanding Insurance Products Offered to Employee Benefit Plans July 25, 2012
Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) June 13, 2012
EBPAQC Tools and Resources: Getting the Most From Your Membership November 30, 2011
401(k) Plan Tax and Compliance Issues for Auditors July 13, 2011
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Sampling June 8, 2011
Auditor Communications: Best Practices and Common Pitfalls November 10, 2010
Investment Products Offered by Insurance Companies July 21, 2010
Fraud Risks in Employee Benefit Plans February 17, 2010
Available on the on the EBPAQC website
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Documentation of review of nonattest services
New Tool- Auditor Independence
32
Do nonattest services impair independence?
Has any “prohibited” nonattest services been performed?
Has an understanding with the client has been established and documented in writing?
AICPA Ethics rules to state that financial statement preparation and cash-to-accrual conversions performed by the member for a client should be considered nonattest services
4/20/2015
17
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Documentation of review of actuarial report in audit
New Tool- Actuary Report
33
Actuary's competence, capabilities, and objectivity
Benefit information date Objectives, scope of work,
and assumptions used Census data Auditor's conclusion
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
New Primer- Health and Welfare Plans
Overview of health and welfare plans
Defining the plan Unique aspects of health and
welfare plan contributions Funding of benefits Key roles and responsibilities Annual health care process Unique aspects of health and
welfare plan benefit obligations, benefits administration
Additional resources
34
H&W Plan Primer
4/20/2015
18
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
New Plan Advisory
35
Why a Financial Statement Audit Is Important
Risks to Plan Sponsors if a Quality Audit Is Not Performed
Evaluating Auditor Qualifications The Proposal Process Documenting the Agreement Additional Resources
Hiring a Quality Auditor
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBPAQC Resources- On the Horizon
Coming soon!
• EBP audit best practices tool
• ESOP appraisal documentation evaluation tool
In the future...
• Plan document evaluation tool
36
4/20/2015
19
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBP Audit Report Project
AICPA Auditing Standards Task Force considering modifications to the auditor’s report (full and limited scope)
Describe what the auditor did and found
Improve transparency and user understanding
37
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBP Reporting and Assurance Models Project
Explore and recommend alternative reporting and assurance models for EBPs
Better serve the various EBP stakeholder needs, including plan participants, plan sponsors and administrators, and the DOL
Models may either replace or supplement the current GAAP/GAAS financial statement model required by ERISA and DOL regulations.
May relate to financial reporting (i.e., GAAP or a special purpose reporting framework), compliance with laws and regulations, and/or internal control
Consistent with GAAS or the statements on standards for attestation standards (examination, review, agreed-upon procedures
38
4/20/2015
20
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
FASB Advocacy on EBP Accounting and Reporting
EBPAQC and Expert Panel engaged in substantial advocacy efforts
Goal: Raise FASB awareness about the uniqueness of employee benefit plan financial statements, including their purpose, users and preparers.
Observations about difficulties encountered in practice
• 26 page discussion memorandum (“Bucket List”) that identifies areas in current accounting affecting EBPs that are
- conflicting, redundant, irrelevant, or
- incomplete due to the specialized characteristics of plans.
Result: FASB has agreed to take on a research project on EBP financial reporting issues.
39
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EITF Agenda- EBP Simplifications
EITF Issue No. 15-C, "Employee Benefit Plan Simplifications“
Issue paper was prepared by a working group from the AICPA EBP Expert Panel, plan sponsors, service providers, and the DOL as a result of ongoing AICPA advocacy efforts
Discussed at the March 19th EITF meeting
Considering disclosure simplification for employee benefit plans related to: • fully benefit-responsive investment contracts,
• disaggregation of plan assets, and
• measurement date practical expedient.
4/20/2015
21
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
AICPA Suggestions to Tax Reform Working Group on Savings and Investments
March 26, 2015 AICPA Tax Executive Committee letter to Senate Committee on Finance Tax Reform Working Group on Savings and Investments
Recommendations to simplify employer-sponsored retirement plans and individual retirement accounts (IRAs):
1. Create a Uniform Employee Contributory Deferral Plan;
2. Eliminate Certain Nondiscrimination Tests on Employee Pre-tax and Roth Deferrals for 401(k) Plans, Matching Contributions;
3. Eliminate the Top-Heavy Rules;
4. Create a Uniform Rule Regarding the Determination of Basis in Distributions;
5. Create a Uniform Attribution Rule;
6. Create a Uniform Definition of Owners;
7. Change the Required Minimum Distribution Rules During Life and Remove Half-Year Age References; and
8. Create Uniform Rules for Early Withdrawal Penalties
41
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
AICPA Audit Quality Initiatives
and EBP Audits
42
4/20/2015
22
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
ERISA Audit Quality “Ingredients”
Qualifications
• Licensed and independent (ERISA requirements)
• Code of Professional Conduct (AICPA)
Standards
• AICPA Firm Quality Control Standards
• GAAS/AICPA EBP Audit and Accounting Guide
Monitoring
• Peer review (ERISA audits are “must select”)
Enforcement
• AICPA Professional Ethics investigations
• State Boards of Accountancy (license)
Commitment
• EBPAQC
43
Journey to maintain excellence
4/20/2015
23
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
AICPA Enhanced Audit Quality Initiativeand EBP Audits
EAQ initiative will enhance the quality of audits of private entities, including EBP audits.
EAQ is a holistic approach with major changes being proposed to peer review, standards, enforcement and other areas.
The EAQ will affect how your firm approaches your EBP audits even if your firm performs just one or a few.
45
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
AICPA Enhanced Audit Quality Initiative
Peer ReviewPerform more extensive peer review procedures on high-riskand complex areas and engagements.
Address the risks posed by low-volume auditors of high-risk and complex engagements by requiring the firm, in all cases where material non-conformity with applicable professional standards is noted, to engage a third party to perform pre- or post-issuance reviews of those engagements in the future with periodic reporting to a peer review Report Acceptance Body (RAB).
Evaluate firms’ engagements in “new” industries promptly, rather than waiting for their next peer review.
46
4/20/2015
24
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
AICPA Enhanced Audit Quality Initiative
Peer Review (continued)Enhance the quality of peer reviewers by introducing a streamlined process for barring reviewers who do not meet required performance criteria.
Establish systems to facilitate the identification of the firm and engagement populations subject to peer review.
Explore ways in which peer review reporting can better articulate information users find meaningful.
Facilitate the prevention of audit quality issues before they start by developing a next generation of peer review that provides firms with near real-time feedback on their accounting and auditing practice, enabling them to quickly leverage and implement prescriptive measures, in some instances even before an engagement is completed.
47
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
AICPA Enhanced Audit Quality Initiative
Ethics Enforcement
• Use publicly available information to proactively identify deficient audits and require members to correct the deficiencies.
• Consider sanctions, including admonishment, suspension or expulsion from AICPA membership, when a firm has failed to provide the AICPA Peer Review Program with a complete list of engagements that should be subject to review. The AICPA’s action would be reported to the appropriate regulators.
48
4/20/2015
25
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
AICPA Enhanced Audit Quality Initiative
Auditing and Quality Control Standards
• Monitor the use of the Auditing Standards Board’s new clarified auditing standards to ensure they are being consistently understood and implemented to achieve high-quality audits. Revise standards, issue supplemental guidance or provide additional education and tools as necessary.
• Identify and better understand where and how audit deficiencies occur and their root causes so revisions can be made to the appropriate standards and/or guidance.
• Consider whether more specificity is needed in the quality control standards to drive quality performance.
49
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Peer Review and Ethics EBP Audits
50
4/20/2015
26
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Peer Review Findings- ERISA Audits
51
Non-EBPAQC firms are 3X more likely to have a nonconforming ERISA audit engagement
EBPAQC firms have a peer review pass rate of 94% compared to 78% for non-members
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Themes of Deficient Audit Work
Overreliance
• SOC 1 reports
• Work performed by actuaries
• Work performed by appraisers
• Predecessor auditor work
Lack of skepticism
Checklist mentality/complacency
Lack of audit experience – EBP or otherwise
52
52
4/20/2015
27
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
AICPA Ethics Investigations of EBP Audits
DOL and state societies continue to refer deficient audits to the AICPA Professional Ethics Division
Over 900 referrals to AICPA Ethics Division since early 1990s
- expect 130+ referrals in 2014-2015
An independent review is performed on all cases
AICPA Ethics Division findings typically are consistent with DOL findings
AICPA’s focus is on rehabilitating the practitioner
53
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBPAQC Resources
54
4/20/2015
28
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBPAQC Resources
EAlerts
Webinars
Website
Member‐to‐member Forum
Resource Centers
Tools
Primers
Plan Advisories
55
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
24 EAlerts issued in the past year
Are you sharing EAlerts with your staff?
Also archived on EBPAQC website
EAlerts
56
4/20/2015
29
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
The Importance of Hiring a Quality EBP Auditor (New) EBP Financial Statement Audits Plan Investments Internal Controls Monitoring Outsourced Recordkeeping and Reporting Understanding Auditor Communications
Plan Advisories
57
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBP Fraud ToolDOL Criminal Enforcement Cases
Updated—Summary of over 185 EBP fraud cases
58
4/20/2015
30
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Internal Control Communications Examples Tool
59
• Oversight of the Financial Reporting Process
• Investments• Selecting,
Monitoring, and Valuing Plan Investments
• Securities Lending • Participant Loans • Bank Reconciliations• Claims Processing• Forfeitures
• Participant Accounts • Monitoring • Contributions • Employee
Contributions • Employer
Contributions • Eligibility
Distributions • Benefit Payments • Vesting Matters • Third Party Service
Providers • Multiemployer Plans
• Monitoring and Review
• Payroll/Personnel Records and Census Data
• Maintaining Records • Demographic Data • Census Data • Other • Plan Fees • Parties‐in‐Interest • Uncashed Checks• Plan Amendments
Updated—Over 135 example comments
Send us additional examples! Email to Center mailbox at [email protected]
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
SOC 1 Review Documentation Tool
Use to help document review of SOC 1 reports issued in accordance with SSAE No. 116• Summarize procedures and findings related to controls at a
service organization relevant to plan audits
60
4/20/2015
31
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Other Tools and Aids
61
Firm Preparedness Checklist for Employee Benefit Plans
Internal Inspection Tool
Responding to Requests for Proposals
Marketing Toolkit
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
8 forums
3,700 participants
2,500 topics posted
Valuable resource
Member-to-Member Discussion Forum
62
4/20/2015
32
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Accounting and Audit Resource Centers
63
Upd
403(b) Plans Auditor Communications Auditor Independence Defined Benefit Pension Plans SOC 1(SM) Reports and Service Organizations Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOP) Form 11-K Audits Fraud in Employee Benefit Plans Health and Welfare Benefit Plans Internal Control Limited Scope Audits Multiemployer Employee Benefit Plan Audits Pension Protection Act of 2006 Plan Investments Parties in Interest and Prohibited Transactions
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBPAQC “Topix” Primers
64
Limited Scope Audits Tax and Compliance Issues for 401(k) Plans Parties in Interest and Prohibited Transactions Insurance Company Products Offered to
Employee Benefit Plans Alternative Investments in Employee Benefit
Plans Plan Investments in Bank Collective Investment
Funds Stable Value Funds and Investment Contracts Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) Multiemployer Employee Benefit Plans 403(b) Plans Cash Balance Plans Plan Sponsor Subsidies Under the Medicare
Prescription Drug, Improvement and Modernization Act of 2003
4/20/2015
33
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Limited Scope Audit Primer
Discusses:• Statutory and regulatory exemption
• Proper certifications from qualified institutions
• Plan administrator’s responsibilities
• Current environment
• Scope of testing
• Reporting
65
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
401(k) Tax and Compliance Primer
Discusses:
• Tax advantages of plan qualification
• Plan qualification requirements
• Plan design
• IRS determination letters
• Non-discrimination tests
• Other operating tests
• Safe harbor plans
• Plan document failures
• Operational errors
• IRS correction programs
• UBIT considerations
66
4/20/2015
34
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Parties in Interest and Prohibited Transactions Primer
Discusses:
• Party in interest under ERISA vs. related party under GAAP
• Prohibited party in interest transactions
• Administrative and statutory exemptions
• Reporting requirements for party in interest and non-exempt transactions
• ERISA or IRC penalties
• Voluntary Fiduciary Correction (VFC) Program
67
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Common EBP Audit Deficiencies
68
4/20/2015
35
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
SOC 1 Review Documentation Tool
Use to help document review of SOC 1 reports issued in accordance with SSAE No. 116
• Summarize procedures and findings related to controls at a service organization relevant to plan audits
69
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Other Tools and Aids
70
Firm Preparedness Checklist for Employee Benefit Plans
Internal Inspection Tool
Responding to Requests for Proposals
Marketing Toolkit
4/20/2015
36
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Find an EBPAQC Member Firm
Firms by Name
Firms By State
Search on EBPAQC website under Membership
71
71
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
EBPAQC Marketing Toolkit
Sample General Announcement to All
Firm Staff
Sample Announcement to Employee Benefit Plan
Audit Staff (granting access to website)
EPBAQC Press Release and Press Relations
Guidelines EBPAQC Logo Usage and Guidelines
Client Communication
Client Talking Points
Newsletter Sample
Sample Web site Text
Networking Strategies Marketing Strategies
72
72
4/20/2015
37
Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center
Questions
73