+ All Categories
Home > Documents > 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

Date post: 07-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: justinplus
View: 235 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend

of 45

Transcript
  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    1/45

    2011 BrandFinanceBanking 500Summary brand valuation report

    Prepared for: -

    Brand Finance plc, January 2011

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    2/45

    1. Introduction to BrandFinance and Methodology The Banker Magazine and the Global Banking 500

    IVSCRecognised Valuation Approaches

    IVSCRecognised Valuation Methods

    Summary of Royalty Relief Method

    ISO 10668

    2. Global results Executive Summary

    Top 10 most valuable global banking brands

    Top 10 most valuable banking brands in [relevant

    geographic region]

    Top 10 most valuable banking brands in [country x]

    Most valuable banking brand by business segment

    3. [name of bank] results

    Valuation Results Valuation Schedule & Assumptions

    Brand valuation by region

    Brand valuation by business segment

    Brand valuation reconciliation

    Change in BSI

    Competitor review

    Competitor reviewhistorical brand values

    Portfolio value

    Market cap composition

    Table Of Contents

    2011 BrandFinance Banking 500 Summary Brand Valuation Report

    4. Comparison of brand valuation approaches

    5. About Brand Finance

    Appendix IA detailed overview of the BrandFinance Methodology

    Appendix II2011 BrandFinance Global Intangibles Financial Tracker (GIFT)

    Contents 2

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    3/45

    sectionone

    sectionone

    Introduction and valuation methodology

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    4/45

    Brand Finance is the worlds leading independent brand valuation

    consultancy.

    The BrandFinance Banking 500, now in its fifth year, directly

    compares the values of the worlds leading banking brands. It is

    the only direct comparison of brand value within the banking

    industry.

    The BrandFinance Banking 500 provides an opinion on the point-in-time value of the worlds leading banking brands. This report

    illustrates how our methodology, findings and value-based

    marketing techniques can be used for decision-making and to

    determine the impact of brand equity on business performance.

    Brand Finance has teamed up with The Banker, the monthly

    international financial affairs magazine, for the fifth year running

    to publish the results.

    The BrandFinance Banking 500

    4Introduction

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    5/45

    The Royalty Relief approach is based on the assumption that if a company did not own any trademarks it would

    need to license them from a third party trademark owner instead. Ownership therefore relieves the company

    from paying a license fee (the royalty) for the use of the third party trademarks

    The royalty relief method involves estimating likely future sales, applying an appropriate royalty rate to them and

    then discounting estimated future, post-tax royalties, to arrive at a Net Present Value (NPV). This is held to

    represent the brand value.

    Brand Finance uses the Royalty Relief methodology for three reasons:

    Firstly, it is the approach that is most recognised by technical authorities worldwide and favoured by

    accounting, tax and legal users because it calculates brand values by reference to comparable, third-partytransactions.

    Secondly, it ties back to the commercial reality of brands - their ability to command a premium in an arms

    length transaction.

    Finally, because it can be performed on the basis of publicly available financial information.

    5Valuation methodology

    Introduction to Royalty Relief methodology

    X RR tax1

    2

    3

    45

    Revenue Forecast -X

    Discount Rate

    NPV

    =

    Brand

    Value

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    6/45

    Full Methodology section intentionally summarised

    in this version of the report

    Additional sections included in the full report :

    IVSCRecognised Valuation Approaches

    IVSCRecognised Valuation Methods

    ISO 10668 Required Brand Valuation steps

    6Valuation methodology

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    7/45

    sectiononesectiontwo

    Global Results

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    8/45

    Excluded from sample report

    Additional sections included in the full report :

    Executive summary

    Top 10 most valuable banking brands

    Top 10 most valuable banking brands in relevant geographic region

    Top 10 most valuable banking brands in relevant country

    Most valuable banking brand by service line

    8Global results

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    9/45

    sectiononesectionthree

    [name of bank] results

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    10/45

    Market Capitalisation Brand Value

    Brand Strength Index

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    XXXX Valuation Results

    10Valuation results

    0

    2,000

    4,000

    6,000

    8,000

    10,000

    12,000

    14,000

    2009 2010 2011

    XXXXX XXXXX

    XXXXX

    BrandValu

    e$millions

    0

    50,000

    100,000

    150,000

    200,000

    250,000

    300,000

    2009 2010 2011

    XXXXX

    XXXXX

    XXXXX

    MarketC

    ap$millions

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    2009 2010 2011

    XX XX

    XX

    BrandStrengthIndex

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    11/45

    TOTAL BRAND VALUE

    XXXX

    VALUE IN EXPLICIT

    PERIOD

    VALUE IN

    PERPETUITY

    CORPORATE

    VALUE

    XXXX XXXX XXXXX

    DISCOUNT RATE XXXX XXXX REVENUE FORECAST CAGR

    TAX RATE XXXX XXXX ROYALTY RATE

    PERPETUITY RATE XXXX XXXX BRAND SPLIT

    2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

    BRAND SPLIT %REVENUE

    growth %

    ROYALTY RATE

    BRAND

    CONTRIBUTION

    TAX

    DISCOUNT FACTOR

    NPV

    11Valuation results

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: XXXX

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Brand X Valuation Schedule & Assumptions

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    12/45

    TOTAL CORPORATE

    BRAND VALUE

    XXXX

    VALUE IN EXPLICIT

    PERIOD

    VALUE IN

    PERPETUITY

    XXXX XXXX

    DISCOUNT RATE XXXX XXXX REVENUE FORECAST CAGR

    TAX RATE XXXX XXXX ROYALTY RATE

    PERPETUITY RATE XXXX XXXX BRAND SPLIT

    2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

    BRAND SPLIT %REVENUE

    growth %

    ROYALTY RATE

    BRAND

    CONTRIBUTION

    TAX

    DISCOUNT FACTOR

    NPV

    12Valuation results

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: XXXX

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Brand X Valuation Schedule & Assumptions

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    13/45

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Brand X regional brand value segmentation

    13Valuation results

    - 2,000 4 ,000 6 ,000 8 ,000 10,000 12,000

    Europe

    South America

    North America

    Rest of the World

    / Other

    Pacific

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    Brand value $ millions

    X%

    X%

    X%

    X% X%Europe

    South America

    North America

    Rest of the World / Other

    PacificBrand X

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    14/45

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Brand X product brand value segmentation

    14Valuation results

    X%

    X%

    X%X%

    Wholesale - Banking /

    Investment - Banking

    Retail - Banking

    Asset Management -

    Banking

    Other - Banking

    - 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000

    Wholesale - Banking /

    Investment - Banking

    Retail - Banking

    Asset Management -

    Banking

    Other - Banking

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    Brand value $ millions

    Brand X

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    15/45

    Valuation Comparison with Last YearLast Historical

    Revenue

    Last

    Forecasted

    Revenue

    Brand

    Split

    Royalty

    Rate

    Perpetuity

    Rate

    Discount

    RateTax Rate

    Corporate

    Value

    Brand

    Value

    Effective

    Change% Change

    2010 Brand Finance Valuation X X X X X X X X X X X

    Change in Revenue X X X X X X X X X X X

    Change in Brand Split X X X X X X X X X X X

    Change in Royalty Rate X X X X X X X X X X X

    Change in Perpetuity Rate X X X X X X X X X X X

    Change in DiscountRate

    X X X X X X X X X X X

    Change in Tax Rate X X X X X X X X X X X

    Change in Corporate Value X X X X X X X X X X X

    2011 Brand Finance Valuation X X X X X X X X X X X

    15Valuation results

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Brand X value reconciliation (2010 to 2011)

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    16/45

    Financial Measures Security/ Risk Measures Brand Equity Measures Brand Rating

    Net Revenue Visual Identity Function

    AAA+

    Tier 1 Capital

    Forecasted Growth % Assets Rank Emotion

    Capital Asset

    Ratio

    Net Income Real ProfitGrowth

    Conduct

    Performance on

    Average Capital

    Margin %Return on Assets

    Loyalty

    Credit Rating

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Change in randeta Index

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    17/45

    Brand Value X X X X X X X

    Market Cap X X X X X X X

    Global Rank X X X X X X X

    BV/MC X% X% X% X% X% X% X%

    17Valuation results

    XXX XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX XXX

    0

    50,000

    100,000

    150,000

    200,000

    250,000

    300,000

    350,000

    400,000

    Brandvalue$

    millions

    Enterprise Value Brand Value

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Your Brand Comp 1 Comp 5Comp 4Comp 3Comp 2 Comp 6

    Brand X competitor review

    Market Cap

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    18/45

    18Valuation results

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Brand X competitor review historical brand values

    0

    5,000

    10,000

    15,000

    20,000

    25,000

    30,000

    35,000

    2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

    Brandvalue$millions

    Year

    Your Brand

    Comp 1

    Comp 2

    Comp 3

    Comp 4

    Comp 5

    Comp 6

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    19/45

    19Valuation results

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Brand X portfolio value

    0

    20,000

    40,000

    60,000

    80,000

    100,000

    Brand 1 Brand 2 Brand 3 Brand 4 Totalportfolio

    XXX XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    Brandvalue$million

    s

    X%

    X%

    X%

    X%

    0%

    20%

    40%

    60%

    80%

    100%

    Brand Value Contribution

    Brand 4

    Brand 3

    Brand 2

    Brand 1

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    20/45

    20Valuation results

    Parent Company: XXXXDomicile: xxxxx

    Brand Value $XXXXMarket Capitalisation Value $XXXXX

    Brand Value/Market Capitalisation XX%Brand Rating XX

    Brand X: composition of market cap

    XXXXXX

    XXX

    XXX XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    XXX

    -

    20,000

    40,000

    60,000

    80,000

    100,000

    120,000

    MC Analyst Mcap Asset Break Down Intangible Asset

    Value

    Brand Value

    $millions

    Undisclosed Value

    Disclosed Intangibles

    (less GW)

    Disclosed Goodwill

    Tangible NAV

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    21/45

    sectiononesectionthree

    Brand valuation analysis

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    22/45

    22Brand valuation analysis

    How can brand valuation enhance shareholder value?

    Better understand the value of key customer segments (bygeography, product, channel and customer type)

    Understand the relationship between brand equity and key value drivers in

    the business model

    Understand the strengths and weaknesses of the brand compared with key

    competitors

    Provide a planning framework for long term strategic marketing investment

    Create a framework for marketing mix modelling

    Create the framework for better reporting and managing brand performance

    (brand scorecard or dashboard)

    Create a body of information about brand performance for use in investor

    and banking presentations

    Why conduct a more detailed brand valuation study

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    23/45

    23Brand valuation analysis

    Marketing Mix

    Optimisation

    Brand

    Scorecard

    Dynamic

    Valuation

    Model

    Brand Equity

    MeasurementStrategic

    Brand

    Valuation

    Market

    Research

    Business Data

    Value Mapping

    Continuous feedback

    Brand

    Discovery

    Brand Finances approach has been designed to allow clients to manage their brands more intelligently and deliver

    improved business results

    Each step in the process is tailored to the clients specific needs and the level of sophistication required, from highlevel to highly granular

    Brand Finance approach to marketing-oriented projects

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    24/45

    24Brand valuation analysis

    Brand Discovery& Value Mapping

    Brand EquityMeasurement

    Strategic BrandValuation

    Marketing MixOptimisation

    Brand Scorecard DynamicValuation Model

    What is legal &

    economic status of

    the brand?

    What financial,

    competitor & marketdata is available?

    What data gaps

    must be addressed?

    What are key value

    drivers (and linkages

    between drivers)

    within the business?

    What are key drivers

    of brand equity?

    What is the relative

    importance of each

    driver to mycustomers (by

    segment)?

    How do I perform

    versus mycompetitors on key

    drivers?

    How strong is my

    brand relative to its

    competitors?

    What is the value of

    my brand and what

    does it contribute to

    business value?

    Which segments ofmy business are

    generating most

    value?

    How should Iallocate my

    resources?

    How does brand

    equity link to

    business results andbranded business

    value?

    What is the optimal

    marketing mix to

    maximise short term

    sales?

    What is the return onmy promotional

    marketing spend?

    Can we connect

    marketing

    investments, drivers,

    & health indicators to

    financial KPIs and

    shareholder value?

    How can we track

    performance over

    time and capture

    data systematically

    for improved

    decision-making and

    in-depth

    understanding of

    value drivers?

    Which markets,

    customers, brands

    and channels will

    generate the highest

    return and maximiseshareholder value?

    How much should

    we invest and where

    to maximise that

    return?

    What value is at risk

    if we fail to

    adequately support

    the brand?

    Market research

    review

    Data gap analysis

    Value map (via

    interviews or

    workshops)

    Brand Equity Driver

    analysis

    Brand Equity

    analysis

    Brandetaanalysis

    Business and brand

    valuation framework

    Brand Valued

    Added

    Brand Evaluation

    Matrix

    Profit pool analysis

    Demand Driver

    analysis

    Econometric

    modelling

    Marketing ROI

    Brand Dashboard

    (high level snapshotfor management)

    Brand Scorecard (in

    depth diagnostic tool

    for marketers)

    Strategy selection

    Portfolio

    management

    Brand architecture

    Resource allocation

    Value at risk

    analysisServices

    Qu

    estions

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    25/45

    sectiononesectionfour

    Comparison of brand valuation approaches

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    26/45

    The Royalty Relief approach is based on the assumption that if a company did not own any trademarks it would

    need to license them from a third party trademark owner instead. Ownership therefore relieves the company

    from paying a license fee (the royalty) for the use of the third party trademarks

    The royalty relief method involves estimating likely future sales, applying an appropriate royalty rate to them and

    then discounting estimated future, post-tax royalties, to arrive at a Net Present Value (NPV). This is held to

    represent the brand value.

    Brand Finance uses the Royalty Relief methodology for three reasons:

    Firstly, it is the approach that is most recognised by technical authorities worldwide and favoured by

    accounting, tax and legal users because it calculates brand values by reference to comparable, third-party

    transactions.

    Secondly, it ties back to the commercial reality of brands - their ability to command a premium in an arms

    length transaction.

    Finally, because it can be performed on the basis of publicly available financial information.

    26Valuation methodology

    Introduction to Royalty Relief methodology

    X RR tax1

    2

    3

    45

    Revenue Forecast

    - XDiscount Rate

    NPV = Brand

    Value

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    27/45

    27Valuation methodology

    ROYALTY RELIEF: Determine sales forecast, multiply sales forecast by royalty rate, deduct tax. Net Present Value (NPV) of brand contribution = Brand Value

    (Favouredby BrandFinance plc)

    EARNINGS SPLIT (Role of branding): Determine forecast earnings, deduct charge for capital employed to give intangible earnings (EVA), apply

    role of brand to determinebrand contribution.NPV of brand contribution= Brand Value

    3

    Forecast Earnings Brand Contribution (%)Role of Branding

    Deduct

    Charge for Capital

    Employed

    1

    2 4

    5 RoBX = % NPV =Brand

    Value1

    2

    3

    45

    Discount Rate

    X RR tax1

    2

    3

    45

    Revenue Forecast -X

    Discount Rate

    NPV

    =

    Brand

    Value

    Visual representation of the three leading methodologies

    X

    $

    $

    $

    Corporate

    Earnings

    Intangible

    Earnings

    Allocated

    Intangible

    Earnings

    % BX =Brand

    Value

    Intangible Earnings ($M) Brand Contribution (%) Brand Multiple (x)

    EARNINGS SPLIT : Determine current year earnings, deduct charge for capital employed to give intangible earnings (EVA), determine brandcontribution.Apply brandmultiple = BrandValue

    Earnings split method 1

    Earnings split method 2

    Royalty Relief approach

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    28/45

    28Valuation methodology

    Definition of Brand ValueBrand Value is the Net Present Valueof the estimated future cash flows

    attributable to the brand

    The dollar value of a brand iscalculated as Net Present Value or

    todays value of the earnings the

    brand is expected to generate in the

    future

    The financial value of a brand is

    defined as the sum of all earnings that

    a brand is expected to generate

    Valuation based on which key financial

    metric?Net Sales Intangible Earnings Intangible Earnings

    Forecast of future Economic Value

    Added

    Royalty Rate study based on third

    party arms length comparables, brandstrength and margin analysis

    Based on drivers of demand analysis

    (Role of Brand Index)

    Based on % of committed consumers

    base

    Time scale (modeling)DCF of five year explicit forecast and

    perpetuity

    DCF of five year explicit forecast and

    perpetuity

    Not explicitly taken into account; Uses

    current Intangible Earnings

    How is risk accounted for?

    Discount rate calculated from first

    principles using Capital Asset Pricing

    Model (CAPM) producing Weighted

    Average Cost of Capital (WACC) that

    takes into account brand specific risk

    Discount rate determined by

    estimating brand risk using a Brand

    Strength Index (BSI) and applying the

    answer to an S curve of possible

    rates.

    Multiple (short term growth indicator)

    BV Calculation

    BV = (Si * RR*(1-tax))/(1+r)i

    Where S = Sales Forecasts; RR =

    Royalty Rate; r = Discount Rate; i =

    number of years

    BV = (EVAi * RBI)/(1+r)i

    Where EVA = Intangible Earnings; RBI

    = Role of brand Index; r = Discount

    Rate (S curve); i = number of years

    BV = EVA * (%) * M

    Where EVA = intangible Earnings; % =

    Brand Contribution);

    M = Brand Momentum

    Methodology summary

    Earnings split method 1 Earnings split method 2Royalty Relief method

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    29/45

    29Valuation methodology

    Pros & cons

    Pros This is an accepted methodology for valuing brands, that iswidely used and based in commercial reality. It is commonly used

    in legal cases and tax disputes;

    It ties back to the commercial reality of brands - their ability to

    command a premium in an arms length transaction.

    The methodology specifically recommended by the IVSC for use

    in IFRS reporting;

    It relies on verifiable third party data (licensing agreements) and

    therefore less judgment is involved;

    It recognises that brands can have a value even where the

    underlying business is unprofitable.

    It can be performed on the basis of publicly available financial

    information.

    Also a generally accepted methodology for valuing brands

    With sufficient market research, it can provide insight into impact of drivers of

    demand on the value of different intangible assets in the business

    Cons At times it is difficult to source comparable license agreements

    for a particular sector.

    Unless the Royalty Range is analysed carefully, it could lead to a

    conservative or even an aggressive brand valuation.

    Highly judgmental, particularly when done without specific, detailed market

    research into drivers of demand

    Calculations based on profit can lead to volatile results which do not reflect the

    underlying value of the brand; businesses that are loss-making will have zero ornegative brand value, which is inappropriate in many cases

    Approach to determining discount rate has been criticised as lacking

    transparency and not being applicable to all situations

    Generic approach for brand strength may lack cohesion with particular sectors

    Calculations of EVA are notoriously complex and hard to audit. E.g. Stern

    Stewart claim to make 167 adjustments between accounting profits and EVA

    (EVAs of many brands from time to time can be negative)

    Earnings SplitRoyalty Relief

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    30/45

    sectiononesectionfive

    About Brand Finance

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    31/45

    We perform valuations forfinancial reporting, taxplanning, M&Aactivities, jointventures, IPOs and othertransactions. We workclosely with auditors, taxauthorities and lawyers.

    Our analytical services helpclients to better understandthe drivers of business andbrand value. Understandinghow value is created, whereit is created and therelationship between brandvalue and business value isa vital input to strategicdecision making.

    Valuation Analytics

    We give marketers theframework to makeeffective economicdecisions. Our value-basedmarketing service enablescompanies to focus on thebest opportunities, allocatebudgets to activities thathave the mostimpact, measure the resultsand articulate the return onbrand investment.

    We help private equitycompanies, venturecapitalists and brandedbusinesses to identify andassess the valueopportunities throughbrand and market duediligence and brandlicensing.

    Strategy Transactions

    Our Services

    At Brand Finance, we are entirely focussed on quantifying and leveraging intangible assetvalue. Our services compliment and support each other, resulting in robust valuation

    methodologies, which are underpinned by an in-depth understanding of revenue drivers andlicensing practice.

    About Brand Finance 31

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    32/45

    Selection of financial services clients

    About Brand Finance 32

    http://www.barclaycard.co.uk/
  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    33/45

    Selection of other global clients

    33

    About Brand Finance 33

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    34/45

    Canada

    USA

    Brazil

    South Africa

    Spain

    Portugal

    Turkey

    Greece

    SwitzerlandCroatia

    Holland

    U.K. (HQ)

    France

    Finland

    Russia

    Dubai

    Sri Lanka

    India

    Singapore

    Hong Kong

    Australia

    About Brand Finance 34

    Our international network

    East Africa

    Belgium

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    35/45

    35Brand Finance

    Brand Finance plc is the leading independent

    intangible asset valuation and brand strategy

    firm, helping companies to manage their

    brands more intelligently for improved

    business results.

    For further enquiries relating to this report,

    please contact:

    David Haigh

    CEO

    [email protected]

    Mike Rocha

    Managing Director

    [email protected]

    Country Name of Contact Email address

    Australia Tim Heberden [email protected]

    Belgium Valerie Herdlicka [email protected]

    Brazil Gilson Nunes [email protected] Andrew Zimakas [email protected]

    Croatia Borut Zemljic [email protected]

    Dubai Gautam Sen Gupta [email protected]

    East Africa Jawad Jaffer [email protected]

    France Xander Bird [email protected]

    Holland Marc Cloosterman [email protected]

    Hong Kong Rupert Purser [email protected]

    India Unni Krishnan [email protected]

    Portugal Pedro Tavares [email protected]

    Russia Alexander Eremenko [email protected]

    Singapore Bernard Lee [email protected]

    South Africa Oliver Schmitz [email protected]

    Spain Pedro Tavares [email protected]

    Sri Lanka Ruchi Gunewardene [email protected]

    Switzerland Mike Rocha [email protected]

    Turkey Muhterem Ilguner [email protected]

    United Kingdom James Park [email protected]

    USA Bill Barker [email protected]

    For further information on Brand Finances services and

    valuation experience, please contact your local

    representative.

    Contact details

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    36/45

    sectiononeappendixone

    A detailed overview of the BrandFinance Methodology

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    37/45

    1. Determine forecast revenues

    Determine future revenues attributable to the Aeroflot passenger brand over afive year explicit forecast period. This is done by referencing historic trends,market growth estimates, competitive forces , analyst projections and company

    forecasts.

    2. Establish Royalty Rate RangeReview comparable licensing agreements. Analyse margins and value drivers.Establish average royalty rate range for airline sector.

    3. Assess the Brand StrengthDetermine the strength of the brand using the randeta Index. Applyrandeta Index to royalty rate range to determine royalty rate for the brand(see next slide)

    4. Determine the Discount RateDetermine discount rate to calculate the net present value (NPV) of futurebrand earnings (accounting for the time value of money and the associatedrisk).

    5. Brand Valuation Calculation The NPV of post-tax royalties equals the brand value

    Five Steps - Royalty Relief Valuation

    Introduction to Royalty Relief methodology

    X RR tax1

    2

    3

    45

    Revenue Forecast

    - XDiscount Rate

    NPV

    37Valuation methodology

    = Brand

    Value

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    38/45

    38Valuation methodology

    MEASURE KPI WEIGHT PROVIDED BY SCORE

    randeta

    INDEX

    FINANCIAL MEASURES

    50

    NET REVENUE 8.3% BRAND FINANCE 2.5

    FORECASTED GROWTH % 8.3% BRAND FINANCE 2.5

    NET INCOME 8.3% BLOOMBERG 2.5

    MARGIN % 8.3% BLOOMBERG 2.5

    SECURITY/RISK

    MEASURES 50

    VISUAL IDENTITY 11.0% VI360 (see next slide) 2.5

    DISTRIBUTION 11.0% BRAND FINANCE 2.5

    50

    CREDIT RATING 11.0% BLOOMBERG 2.5

    BRAND EQUITY

    MEASURES 50

    FUNCTION 8.3% BRAND FINANCE 2.5

    EMOTION 8.3% BRAND FINANCE 2.5

    CONDUCT 8.3% BRAND FINANCE 2.5

    LOYALTY 8.3% BRAND FINANCE 2.5

    randeta Index determination - EXAMPLE

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    39/45

    39Valuation methodology

    Visual Identity determination VI360

    VI360 is a specialist visual identity management

    company and is part of the Brand Finance group. We

    have a close and formal working relationship driven by

    the recognition that there is a strong link between

    visual identity management and brand value.

    VI360 works with national and international

    organisations to implement, monitor and control the

    visual elements of their brands and manage the holisticview of their visual identities.

    Our aim is to maximize the value of the visual identity

    as a business asset and to ensure that the all round

    visual impression leads to a comparative advantage. We

    do this by working to ensure that all aspects of the

    visual brand identity are managed properly and

    performing as intended.

    Holistic visual identity management requires a

    practical, process driven approach. At the heart of this

    is the visual identity management cycle.

    A brand or visual identity is rarely static and whether a

    company is undertaking a large scale transition or a

    series of evolutionary changes, the phases of the visual

    identity management cycle always apply.

    Improvements can be made that will deliver greater

    brand performance no matter what phase of the cycle

    a company is in.

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    40/45

    Further details of methodology excluded from sample report

    40Valuation methodology

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    41/45

    sectiononeappendixtwo

    2011 BrandFinance Global Intangibles Financial Tracker

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    42/45

    BrandFinance Global Intangibles Financial Tracker 2011

    (GIFT 2011)

    Annual review of global intangible value: Banks and Diversified Financial Services

    BrandFinance GIFT 2011 42

    - 500 1,000 1,500 2,000

    United States

    China

    Britain

    Japan

    Brazil

    Canada

    Australia

    France

    Spain

    Switzerland

    $USD billion

    Tangible Net Assets

    Disclosed Intangible

    Assets (ex g/w)

    Disclosed Goodwilll

    Undisclosed Value

    -20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%

    United States

    China

    Britain

    Japan

    Brazil

    Canada

    Australia

    France

    Spain

    Switzerland

    Tangible Net Assets

    Disclosed Intangible Assets (ex g/w)

    Disclosed Goodwilll

    Undisclosed Value

    Global Banks % DFS Enterprise Value Breakdown

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    43/45

    Excluded from sample report

    Included in full report

    Further analysis taken from GIFT 2011

    43BrandFinance GIFT 2011

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    44/45

    44Disclaimer

    Disclaimer

    Brand Finance has produced this study with an independent and unbiased analysis. The values derived and opinions produced in this

    study are based only on publicly available information and certain assumptions that Brand Finance used where such data wasdeficient or unclear. No independent verification or audit of such materials was undertaken. Brand Finance accepts no responsibility

    and will not be liable in the event that the publicly available information relied upon is subsequently found to be inaccurate.

    The conclusions expressed are the opinions of Brand Finance and are not intended to be warranties or guarantees that a particular

    value or projection can be achieved in any transaction. The opinions expressed in the report are not to be construed as providing

    investment advice. Brand Finance does not intend the report to be relied upon for technical reasons and excludes all liability to any

    organisation.

  • 8/4/2019 2011 Brand Finance Banking 500 Generic Report

    45/45

    Brand Finance plc (London) is the worlds leading independent brand valuation consultancy.We have a global footprint with offices in more than 20 countries. For more informationplease refer to our website:www.brandfinance.com


Recommended