May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 2
TZMI: A Global Consultancy
TZ Minerals International Pty Ltd
Level 2, 75 Canning Highway,
Victoria Park. WA 6100
Australia
+61 8 9359 6000
Web site: www.tzmi.com
Contact:
David McCoy
+61 437 049 757
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 3
About TZMI
TZ Minerals International (TZMI) is a global, independent consulting and publishing company which specialises in all
aspects of the mineral sands, titanium dioxide and coatings industries.
With a worldwide presence, including head office in Australia, and offices in the US, Africa and China, TZMI’s strength
in consulting services is a result of our extensive practical experience across all elements of the industries and from a
comprehensive and unique database, which has been built up over many years.
TZMI has proven expertise gained from our consultants having many years of direct operating experience in the
industry in chief executive, senior operational, analytical and marketing roles.
TZMI’s publications and data services provide additional benefit for our clients and ensure up-to-date, high-quality and
comprehensive data, analysis and information across the mineral sands, zircon, TiO2 pigment and titanium metal
industries.
To ensure TZMI provides accurate and up to date advice, TZMI maintains the most comprehensive and current
databases of industry production, market information and best practices in the world, including supply and demand
models, technical data and operating cost data for all major producers.
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 4
Two information sources to consider
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 6
1950s were the development boom years
Magnesium - Kroll
DuPont in Newport, DE - 18 ST pa (1948) up to 3,600 ST pa (1955). Closed 1962.
Nippon Electric Metallurgy Co in Chuo-ku, Tokyo – 1,800 lb pm (1951).
Titanium Metals Corp in Henderson, NV - 3,600 ST pa (1952)
Osaka Titanium in Amagasaki, Hygo Pref - 12 tpa (1952).
Nippon Soda Co in Minato-ku, Tokyo - 3 tonnes pm (1953).
Toho Titanium in Chigasaki, Kanagawa Pref – 240 tpa (1954).
Dow in Midland, MI - 100 ST pa pilot plant (1954).
ICI at Wilton, Yorkshire - 1,700 ST pa (1955).
McKechnie Bros Ltd in UK – 110 ST pa pilot plant (1955).
Cramet in Chattanooga, TN - 6,000 ST pa (1955). Closed in 1958.
Le Titanium Francais (JV) in La Praz, France (1956).
Zaporozhye, Ukraine (1956)
Sodium - Hunter
Electro-Metallurgical (Union Carbide) 7,500 ST in 1956
Mallory-Sharon Metals Corp in Ashtabula, OH 1956
ST denotes US unit of 1 ton = 2,000lb = 903 kg
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 7
1960s saw expansion into new countries
BTMK – Russia (1959)
Zunyi Titanium – China (1965)
UKTMP – Kazakhstan (1965)
Source: UKTMP
Source: Zunyi Titanium
Source: VSMPO
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 9
Growth in capacity far exceeds demand growth
China’s sponge capacity and production: 2010 – 2013
200
160
120
80
40
0
‘000 tonnes
+14.8%
+12.2%
2013
82
157
2012
82
145
2011
66
132
58
2010
104
Capacity Production
Source: TZMI database
© TZMI - NOT FOR REPRODUCTION
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 10
Output is dominated by a select number of producers
Breakdown of titanium sponge output: 2013
Jinzhou Huashen
11.0%
Chaoyang Jinda
11.0%
Pangang Titanium
3.9%
Others
10.5%
Chaoyang Baisheng
4.9%
Fushun Titanium Co Ltd
4.3%
Anshan Hailiang
4.3%
Zunyi Titanium
22.1%
Luoyang Sunrui Wanji
12.0%
Tangshan Tianhe
15.9%
Note: Producers with output less than 2,000 tonnes have been included in “Others” category.
Source: TZMI database
© TZMI - NOT FOR REPRODUCTION
Source: Pangang Titanium
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 11
+10,000 by 2015
Overcapacity, but still expanding!
Baoji Lixing Titanium 7,000 by 2015
+10,000 by 2015
+20,000 by 2015 +20,000 no schedule
+10,000 by 2015
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 12
Implications of China’s 12th Five Year Plan
Industry consolidation can be expected where smaller, less efficient plants will be phased out. Total sponge capacity in China could be reduced to around 100,000 tpa.
No new sponge projects (other than expansion of existing facilities) are expected to come online in the short term, unless there is a surge in domestic demand/China is able to penetrate the overseas market. According to the Plan,
sponge exports are targeted to increase to 30% of total production.
Improved plant utilisation and cost effectiveness with the rationalisation of the sector.
Source: Jinchuan Titanium
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 13
TiCl4 capacity and output distribution
Total capacity over 200,000 tpa
Total capacity between 100,000-200,000 tpa
Total capacity between 50,000-100,000 tpa
Total capacity less than 50,000 tpa
< 10,000
10,000 - 25,000
25,000 - 50,000
> 50,000
Scale of production (tpa)
Guangxi
Sichuan
Hebei
Fujian
Inner Mongolia Liaoning
Henan
Heilongjiang
Tianjin
Shandong
Jiangsu
Hubei
Gansu
Shanxi
Guizhou
A large proportion of TiCl4 facilities are concentrated in North Eastern provinces – Liaoning, Hebei and Shandong. However, it is understood that
many plants have been shut down due to bad market conditions and environmental regulations.
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 14
Feedstocks for TiCl4 in China
Heavily reduced slag (>91% TiO2) is used in molten-salt chlorinators and small diameter fluid-bed
chlorinators.
Some rutile, but supply of domestic rutile is limited – lack of resources.
Synthetic rutile made from reactive hard rock ilmenite from Panzhihua region
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 16
US output increasing
US sponge production: 2005-2013
12,000
16,000
20,000
4,000
8,000
2005 2012 2011 2010 2013 2006 2007 2009 2008
Source: TZMI database
© TZMI - NOT FOR REPRODUCTION
Source: TIMET
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 17
Ust-Kamenogorsk Titan-Magnesium Kombinat
UKTMP Sponge production: 2005-2013
30,000
2011 2013 2012 2010 2007 2006 2009 2008 2005 Source: TZMI database
© TZMI - NOT FOR REPRODUCTION
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 18
Zaporozhye Titanium & Magnesium Combine
ZTMC Sponge production: 2005-2013
10,000
2008 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2007 2006 2005 Source: TZMI database
© TZMI - NOT FOR REPRODUCTION
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 19
Japan is a critical player
Japanese sponge production: 2005-2013
10,000
50,000
40,000
30,000
20,000
60,000
2006 2007 2005 2009 2012 2010 2013 2011 2008
Source: Osaka Titanium
Source: TZMI database
© TZMI - NOT FOR REPRODUCTION
Source: Toho Titanium
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 20
India now developing sponge technology
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 21
A new facility is in planning for Saudi Arabia
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 22
What’s hurting the global sponge industry?
Over capacity, particularly in China.
Value of sponge compared to scrap over the last 24 months
Improvement of buy-fly ratios and vertically integrated supply chains
0
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
Sponge stock
Q1
13
Scrap stock
Q3
13
Q3
12
Q1
12
Q3
11
Q1
11
Q3
10
Q1
10
Q3
09
Q1
09
Q3
08
Q1
08 Source: USGS
US quarter ending stocks: 2009-2013
May 14 INTERNATIONAL TITANIUM ASSOCIATION: SORRENTO, ITALY © 2014 23
TZMI multi-client work
Titanium Feedstock
Annual Review
Next edition Q2 2014
Mineral Sands Report
PDF report - published monthly
Global TiO2 Pigment Producers:
Comparative Cost & Profitability
Study
Updated Q1 2014
TiO2 Pigment
Annual Review
Next edition Q2 2014
Zircon Annual Review
Next edition Q2 2014
Titanium Metal
Annual Review
Next edition Q2 2014
China Newsletters
PDF report - published monthly
TiO2 Market Insight
Published monthly
TZMI Data Reports
-TiO2 Feedstock Matrix – published annually
- Zircon Trade Matrix – published annually
- Zircon Quarter-to-Quarter published quarterly
TiO2 Pigment Industry Report
PDF report - monthly
TiO2 Pigment
Price Forecast
Published Quarterly