2015 Year End Results
General Fund
Major Enterprise Funds
1
City Commission Work Session
March 2, 2016
2015 Year End Results Summary 1. In 2015, total General Fund sources grew 2.6%
compared to 2014.
2. Total General Fund uses increased 2% ($3.2
million) when compared to the previous year and
were 4% under budget due to savings in several
categories, some attributable to lead time needed to
purchase equipment.
3. Note: The final revised budget included additional
budget margin to ensure that no department would
exceed its final budget.
4. We had a good year. While we were more than
successful in achieving our budget goals, we need
to remain mindful of our longer term challenges,
infrastructure in particular.
2
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
3
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 Year End Statement Notes 1. Amounts may not sum due to rounding.
2. Does not include special projects, which are reported separately.
3. 2015 Budget includes adopted budget only and does not include prior year's encumbrances.
4. Actual amounts include expenditures against current year appropriation and against prior year's appropriation that carried forward.
5. Other Revenues includes interest earnings, special assessments and operating transfers in.
6. Other Uses include debt service and miscellaneous operating transfers out.
7. EMS (Emergency Medical Service) fees are reported on a cash basis in 2014.
4
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 Year End Tracking The tables below illustrate the significant variances
that can occur from month to month in the General
Fund. Strong growth in income tax, combined with
reduced spending, provided funding to address some
critical needs.
5
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
6
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
7
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
8
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 Income Tax Revenues 1. Income tax grew 4.6% or $4.8 million in 2015,
which was on target for the revised forecast.
a) Withholding collections were up a sizable $3.8M or 4.2%.
b) Taxes on business profits were down slightly, with the tax
on corporate profits climbing $657,700 while partnerships
sank almost $800,000.
c) The tax paid by individuals dropped about $50,000.
d) 2015 collections includes $312,700 in JEDD payments
from prior years.
e) Refunds were down $853,600 or 27% in 2015.
In 2015, Income Tax revenue enjoyed its highest
growth rate (not level of collections) since 1995, or
in 20 years!
9
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
10
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 General Fund Revenues 2. Property Tax and Other Tax revenues came in at the
estimate, reflecting a decline of 5% (or $300,000).
a) Property values declined 8.1% in the 2015 collection year
when compared to the previous year. Total property tax
revenue decreased a lesser 5.6% due to a higher
collection rate (the highest since 2008).
b) Total property taxes collected in the General Fund were
$5.35 million in 2015. (Property tax revenues of $6.5
million went to the Debt Retirement Fund.)
c) The 2015 millage distribution was maintained at the 2014
levels.
d) Hotel lodging tax receipts totaled $605,000 in 2015, an
increase of 7% over 2014.
11
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 Revenues Property Tax Collections – General and Bond Retirement Funds
12
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 General Fund Revenues
3. Waste Collection fees for 2015 totaled $9.1 million
and are at the same level as 2014.
4. EMS Fees are up 20% due, in part, to an extra
month’s billings being credited to 2015 (13
months). This also means 2016 will reflect 11
months. When the extra month is factored out,
collections grew 9% on increased transports and a
higher rate of collections.
5. Other Charges for Services came in 1%
($200,000) under budget but reflect growth of 2%
over 2014.
13
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 General Fund Revenues 6. Local Government Fund revenues also came in at
the revised estimate and increased 5% or $300,000
over 2014. This performance reflects the strong
growth in state revenue sources offset by the nearly
two-thirds cut to the municipal direct allocation.
7. Other Intergovernmental Revenues declined 22%,
reflecting $1.2 million less revenues largely due to
the Racino payment reduction ($1.0 million to
$250,000). In addition, the Inheritance Tax
declined $280,000.
14
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 General Fund Revenues
8. Fines and Forfeits decreased 26% ($900,000)
mostly due to the elimination of public safety photo
enforcement.
9. Revenues from licenses and permits grew 12%
reflecting increased construction activity.
10. Other revenue declined 11% when compared to
2014. Revenues in 2014 reflect a reimbursement of
$892,000 from BWC due to strong financial
performance. No reimbursement was received in
2015.
15
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 General Fund Expenditures 1. Personnel costs for 2015 were under budget by 2%
or $2.1 million. Personnel costs grew 4% in 2015
compared to 2014. Various factors were at work:
a) But for the 27th payroll ($2.7 million) in 2015, total growth
in personnel costs would have been 1.4%.
b) A 3% wage increase was given to all employee groups.
c) The average number of employees in the General and
Street Maintenance Funds decreased by 13 full-time
positions, or 1%, from 1,212 to 1,199.
d) Some departments experienced vacancy savings higher
than originally planned in the budget.
e) Uniform Fire personnel received their retro pay ($530,000)
in January, 2016 rather than in 2015 due to the timing of
the labor fact-finding process.
16
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 General Fund Expenditures 2. Contracts and materials costs declined 6% (or $2.1
million) from 2014. Expenditures in 2015 were also
8% below the revised budget (or $3.2 million).
Lower electricity costs
Lower maintenance agreement costs (full
implementation of VOIP resulted in additional savings
of $303,000), computer software maintenance costs
decline $111,000
Lower use of outside legal counsel (-$289,000)
3. Capital equipment expenditures planned for 2015
were $1.0 million less than planned due to the
acquisition time needed on larger pieces of
equipment. All purchases should be completed in
2016 ($979,000 in pending purchase orders).
17
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2015 General Fund Expenditures 4. The capital improvements transfer increased $4.7
million given due to favorable budget performance.
Several projects were funded that also help us
make progress toward our significant infrastructure
needs.
5. The Development Fund transfer totaled $2.5 million
reflecting a return to a more normal funding level,
from the $5.0 million allocated in 2014.
18
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
2016 Cash Reserve: $23.2 million
19
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
Note: The 2015 Cash Reserve before Use of Fund Balance was $24.3M. The $2.5M planned Use of the Reserve in 2015 was not used due to favorable budget performance.
General Fund Budget Metric One of our financial goals is to ensure major tax
sources meet or exceed personnel costs, the major
cost center of the General Fund budget. We have
met the goal in 2011, 2012, 2014, and 2015.
Note: Personnel costs in 2015 exclude the 27th pay costing $2.7 million.
20
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
Summary of General Fund Transfers
21
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
Additional Information on Capital Transfers
22
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
Note: As a result of revenue exceeding our original estimates and under-
spending in other budget categories, we were able to transfer funds for critical
capital improvement and technology needs.
Various Updates 1. Golf Fund ended year with a small negative
balance (-$18,633) having withstood a rainy
season that significantly restricted play.
2. Fleet Management completed repayment of
General Fund loan.
3. Health Insurance Fund experienced higher than
planned claims expenditures – more detailed
analysis to follow.
4. The City experienced a decline in the State of Ohio
Bureau of Workers’ Compensation (BWC)
Experience Modifier (EM) rating for 2016 which will
reduce the City’s future premiums.
23
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
Various Updates
5. Each Community Service Area (CSA) group has
met for an initial organizational meeting.
a) Chair or Co Chairs being identified
b) Departments asked to do additional review of measures
c) Each group discussed potential areas of additional
collaboration.
6. Planning meetings held regarding citizen
engagement related to 2017 budget (Budget
Games). OMB is working with department to
identify various budget options.
24
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
Today’s Key Takeaways
25
Finance Committee Briefing 2015 General Fund Year End Results
1. 2015 was a good year.
2. We took advantage of our positive budget variances and allocated dollars toward some critical needs in capital and technology.
3. We still have a long-term budget challenge, particularly in the area of infrastructure maintenance and replacement.