Friday, June 24, 2016 9:00am – 1:30pm

9:00 a.m. Registration & Continental Breakfast Location: Power Center Ballroom (Fifth Floor)

9:30 a.m. Welcome and Introduction to the Forum

10 a.m. – 11:45 a.m. Breakout Sessions (Fisher Hall and Rockwell Hall)

12 noon Lunch Location: Power Center Ballroom (Fifth Floor)

12:30 p.m. Plenary Session: Dr. Henk ten Have, M.D., Ph.D.

Director and Professor Center for Health Care Ethics

Duquesne University

2016 Ethics Forum Hosted by Duquesne University

Last Name First Name Group School/Organization Group # Session # Room Building

Adams Brian DUQ Duquesne University 1 1 325 Fisher

Ahmed Ayan DUQ Duquesne University 1 1 325 Fisher

Aidukaitis Bryce TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 1 6 301 Rockwell

Ames Colton DUQ Duquesne University 1 1 325 Fisher

Andonian Alex TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 1 6 301 Rockwell

Andreola Laura DUQ Duquesne University 1 1 325 Fisher

Baldwin Mike DUQ Duquesne University 1 1 325 Fisher

Bandi Kathryn DUQ Duquesne University 2 2 628 Fisher

Bautista Danielle DUQ Duquesne University 2 2 628 Fisher

Behun Marissa DUQ Duquesne University 2 2 628 Fisher

Bizzarro Melanie DUQ Duquesne University 2 2 628 Fisher

Burton Mary DUQ Duquesne University 2 2 628 Fisher

Callipare Ashton DUQ Duquesne University 3 3 722 Fisher

Cannanbilla Pranav DUQ Duquesne University 3 3 722 Fisher

Carcella Michael DUQ Duquesne University 3 3 722 Fisher

Castele Erin DUQ Duquesne University 3 3 722 Fisher

Celani Caelin DUQ Duquesne University 3 3 722 Fisher

Chambers Teressa TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 1 6 301 Rockwell

Clemenza Patrice DUQ Duquesne University 4 4 725 Fisher

Cooper Emily DUQ Duquesne University 4 4 725 Fisher

Correa Josefina PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 2 1 325 Fisher

Cosme Jan-Louis DUQ Duquesne University 4 4 725 Fisher

Cox Abby DUQ Duquesne University 4 4 725 Fisher

Cribbs Marvene DUQ Duquesne University 4 4 725 Fisher

Dalton Emily DUQ Duquesne University 5 7 302 Rockwell

Davis Ben DUQ Duquesne University 5 7 302 Rockwell

del C Ramos Maria PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 2 1 325 Fisher

DeMarco Andrew DUQ Duquesne University 5 7 302 Rockwell

DeMarco Elisabeth DUQ Duquesne University 5 7 302 Rockwell

Edi Sieghe PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 1 3 722 Fisher

Endoni Benney PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 1 3 722 Fisher

Endresen Kirsten TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 1 6 301 Rockwell

Evans Connor DUQ Duquesne University 5 7 302 Rockwell

Furgurson Mia DUQ Duquesne University 6 7 302 Rockwell

Furnari Holly DUQ Duquesne University 6 7 302 Rockwell

Gagliardi Austin DUQ Duquesne University 6 7 302 Rockwell

Garces Amanda DUQ Duquesne University 6 7 302 Rockwell

Gartland Nathan DUQ Duquesne University 6 7 302 Rockwell

Gbosibo Fiyinfolowa PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 1 3 722 Fisher

Gerthoffer Margaret DUQ Duquesne University 7 7 302 Rockwell

Gilmore Kaitlyn DUQ Duquesne University 7 7 302 Rockwell

Goldinger Rebecca DUQ Duquesne University 7 7 302 Rockwell

Hildenbrand Molly DUQ Duquesne University 7 7 302 Rockwell

Hilton Eddie DUQ Duquesne University 7 7 302 Rockwell

Idrobo Elisa TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 1 6 301 Rockwell

Student Alphabetical Roster and Room Locations for Ethics Forum 2016

Ireland Tim DUQ Duquesne University 8 2 628 Fisher

Jimenez Ivan PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 2 1 325 Fisher

Kline Jake DUQ Duquesne University 8 2 628 Fisher

Kolar Brian PITT PHYS University of Pittsburgh 1 5 E103 Fisher

LeClair Jessica TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 2 3 722 Fisher

Lora-Lozada Alexander TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 2 3 722 Fisher

Loughner Lindsay DUQ Duquesne University 8 2 628 Fisher

Ma Tammy TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 2 3 722 Fisher

Magyan Andrew DUQ Duquesne University 9 4 725 Fisher

Malik Faba DUQ Duquesne University 9 4 725 Fisher

Martin Mackenzie DUQ Duquesne University 9 4 725 Fisher

Martin Stephanie DUQ Duquesne University 9 4 725 Fisher

McDougal Keefe DUQ Duquesne University 9 4 725 Fisher

Mihailescu Andrei PITT University of Pittsburgh 10 2 628 Fisher

Moore Shannon DUQ Duquesne University 10 2 628 Fisher

Mraz Margaret DUQ Duquesne University 10 2 628 Fisher

Ogiriki Ikuromor PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 1 3 722 Fisher

Ortiz-Serrano     Tatiana TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 3 1 325 Fisher

Palonis Ian DUQ Duquesne University 10 2 628 Fisher

Parr Jackson PITT University of Pittsburgh 10 2 628 Fisher

Peine Rachel DUQ Duquesne University 11 2 628 Fisher

Pirl Josh DUQ Duquesne University 11 2 628 Fisher

Polonsky Nevo DUQ Duquesne University 11 2 628 Fisher

Provencher Stephen TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 3 1 325 Fisher

Quinones-Ramos   Ana TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 2 3 722 Fisher

Ramsey Donovan DUQ Duquesne University 11 2 628 Fisher

Renk Mollie DUQ Duquesne University 11 2 628 Fisher

Resko Zachary DUQ Duquesne University 12 5 E103 Fisher

Robles Andrick DUQ Duquesne University 12 5 E103 Fisher

Robles Karla TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 2 3 722 Fisher

Roth John DUQ Duquesne University 12 5 E103 Fisher

Sabo Cody DUQ Duquesne University 12 5 E103 Fisher

Sajewski Andrea DUQ Duquesne University 12 5 E103 Fisher

Schultheis Cassidy DUQ Duquesne University 13 5 E103 Fisher

Schultz Autumn DUQ Duquesne University 13 5 E103 Fisher

Seese Brett PITT PHYS University of Pittsburgh 1 5 E103 Fisher

Shaik Sadiq DUQ Duquesne University 13 5 E103 Fisher

Sheehy Taylor DUQ Duquesne University 13 5 E103 Fisher

Smathers Claire DUQ Duquesne University 13 5 E103 Fisher

Spirik Kassandra DUQ Duquesne University 14 5 E103 Fisher

Staines Mar PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 3 4 725 Fisher

Steiner Kyle DUQ Duquesne University 14 5 E103 Fisher

Steinsaltz Matthew DUQ Duquesne University 14 5 E103 Fisher

Sweger Sarah DUQ Duquesne University 14 5 E103 Fisher

Thomas Rebekah DUQ Duquesne University 14 5 E103 Fisher

Tiber Gage DUQ Duquesne University 15 6 301 Rockwell

Tidwell Elizabeth DUQ Duquesne University 15 6 301 Rockwell

Tornes Anibal PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 3 4 725 Fisher

Vera-Rodriguez Darex TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 3 1 325 Fisher

Voloshin Andrew DUQ Duquesne University 15 6 301 Rockwell

Washington Azim PITT BioI University of Pittsburgh 3 4 725 Fisher

Wasson Megan DUQ Duquesne University 15 6 301 Rockwell

Weiner Susan DUQ Duquesne University 15 6 301 Rockwell

West Brittany DUQ Duquesne University 16 6 301 Rockwell

Wilber Kimberly DUQ Duquesne University 16 6 301 Rockwell

Yovanno Remy TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 3 1 325 Fisher

Zakutansky Paul DUQ Duquesne University 16 6 301 Rockwell

Zarenkiewicz Jessica DUQ Duquesne University 16 6 301 Rockwell

Ziegler Phillip DUQ Duquesne University 16 6 301 Rockwell

Ziko    Kliment TECBIO University of Pittsburgh 3 1 325 Fisher

Zummo Anthony PITT PHYS University of Pittsburgh 1 5 E103 Fisher

Ethics Forum – June 24, 2016 Breakout Session 1 – Room 325 Fisher Hall Moderator: Joseph Ayoob, Ph.D. Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 1 Duquesne University

Case: Polywater and the Role of Skepticism Brian Adams Ayan Ahmed Colton Ames Laura Andreola Mike Baldwin

Mentor: Weier Hao University of Pittsburgh, Training and Experimentation in Computational Biology Research Experiences for Undergraduates (TECBioREU), Group 3

Case: Tyrone Hayes, the Herbicide Atrazine, and the Syngenta Company

Darex Vera-Rodriguez Stephen Provencher

Remy Yovanno Kliment Ziko Tatiana Ortiz-Serrano Mentor: Jocelyn Sunseri

University of Pittsburgh, Department of Biomedical Informatics, Group 2

Case: Big trouble in the world of “Big Physics” Maria del C Ramos Josefina Correa Ivan Jimenez

Mentor: Dr. David Boone

Ethics Forum – June 24, 2016

Breakout Session 2 – Room 628 Fisher Hall Moderator: James Henderson, Ph.D. Student Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 2 Duquesne University

Case: Rosalind Franklin and the Controversy Kathyrn Bandi

Danielle Bautista Marissa Behun Melanie Bizzarro Mary Burton Mentor: Sumedha Sethi Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 8 Duquesne University

Case: The Darsee Case Timothy Ireland Jake Kline Josh Kotchey Lindsay Loughner Mentor: James Henderson

Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 10 Duquesne University

Case: VIOXX Andrei Mihailescu

Shannon Moore Margaret Mraz Ian Palonis Jackson Parr Mentor: Shiv Upadhyay

Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 11 Duquesne University

Case: Wakefield paper anti-vaccine paper Rachel Peine Josh Pirl Nevo Polonsky Donovan Ramsey Mollie Renk Mentor: Amanda Zielen

Ethics Forum – June 24, 2016

Breakout Session 3 – Room 722 Fisher Hall Moderator: Cassandra Hanley, Ph.D. Student Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 3 Duquesne University

Case: Concussion Research and the NFL, Using Reports incorrectly Ashton Callipare

Pranav Cannanbilla Michael Carcella Erin Castele Caelin Celani Mentor: Cassandra Hanley

University of Pittsburgh; Training and Experimentation in Computational Biology Research Experiences for Undergraduates (TECBioREU), Group 2

Case: The Thalidomide Story Jessica LeClair

Alexander Lora-Lozada Tammy Ma Karla Robles

Ana Quinones-Ramos Mentor: Marta Wells

University of Pittsburgh, Department of Biomedical Informatics, Group 1

Case: Giving Proper Credit Seighe Edi Ikuromor Ogiriki Fiyinfolowa Gbosibo Benney Endoni Mentor: Dr. David Boone

Ethics Forum – June 24, 2016

Breakout Session 4 – Room 725 Fisher Hall Moderator: David Boone, Ph.D. Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 4 Duquesne University

Case: Flint Water Scandal Patrice Clemenza

Emily Cooper Jan Louis-Cosme Abigail Cox Marvene Cribbs Mentor: Inoka Pathiraja

Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 9 Duquesne University

Case: The Tuskegee Syphilis Study Andrew Magyan

Faba Malik Mackenzie Martin Stephanie Martin

Keefe McDougal Mentor: Alexander Rupprecht

University of Pittsburgh, Department of Biomedical Informatics, Group 3

Case: The Thalidomide Story Azim Washington Anibal Tornes Mar Staines

Mentor: Dr. David Boone

Ethics Forum – June 24, 2016

Breakout Session 5 – Room E103 Fisher Hall Moderator: Phillip Palmer, Ph.D. Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 12 Duquesne University Case: Woo-Suk’s stem cell research Zachary Resko Andrick Robles John Roth Cody Sabo Andrea Sajewski

Mentor: Tyler Umstead Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 13 Duquesne University

Case: Laetrile Cassidy Schultheis Autumn Schultz Sadiq Shaik Taylor Sheehy Claire Smathers Mentor: Colleen Nolan Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group14 Duquesne University

Case: Sterilization of specific races on West Coast Kassandra Spirik Kyle Steiner Matthew Steinsaltz Sarah Sweger

Rebekah Thomas Mentor: Linnea Manley

University of Pittsburgh, Physics Group, Group 1

Case: VIOXX Brian Kolar Brett Seese Anthony Zummo Mentor: Susan Perlman

Ethics Forum – June 24, 2016

Breakout Session 6 – Room 301 Rockwell Hall Moderator: Ashley Blystone, Ph.D. Student Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 15 Duquesne University

Case: Washington D.C. Water Crisis Gage Tiber Elizabeth Tidwell Andrew Voloshin Megan Wasson Susan Weiner Mentor: Emily Mashuda

Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 16 Duquesne University

Case: Woo-Suk’s Stem Cell Research Brittany West

Kimberly Wilber Paul Zakutansky Jessica Zarenkiewicz Phillip Ziegler Mentor: Muzamil Saleem

University of Pittsburgh; Training and Experimentation in Computational Biology Research Experiences for Undergraduates (TECBioREU), Group 1

Case: The Tuskegee Syphilis Study Bryce Aidukaitis Alex Andonian Teressa Chambers Kirsten Endresen Elisa Idrobo

Mentor: Luong Nguyen

Ethics Forum – June 24, 2016

Breakout Session 7 – Room 302 Rockwell Hall Moderator: Kayce Tomcho, Ph.D. Student Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 5 Duquesne University Case: Chandra’s Patented Multivitamins Emily Dalton Ben Davis Andrew DeMarco Elisabeth DeMarco Connor Evans

Mentor: Kayce Tomcho Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 6 Duquesne University

Case: Legionnaire Outbreak at Pittsburgh VA Hospital Mia Furgurson

Holly Furnari Austin Gagliardi Amanda Garces Nathan Gartland Mentor: Amanda Dumi Bayer School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, Group 7 Duquesne University

Case: Hela Cells Margaret Gerthoffer Kaitlyn Gilmore Rebecca Goldinger Molly Hildenbrand Eddie Hilton Mentor: Sean Fischer

Henk ten Have, M.D., Ph.D. -- 2016 Ethics Forum Speaker Dr. Henk ten Have studied medicine and philosophy at Leiden University, the Netherlands. He received his medical degree in 1976 from Leiden University and his philosophy degree in 1983. He worked as a researcher in the Pathology Laboratory, University of Leiden (1976-1977), as a practicing physician in the Municipal Health Services, City of Rotterdam (1978-1979), and as a Professor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Medicine and Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Limburg, Maastricht (1982-1991). From 1991 he was a Professor of Medical Ethics and the Director of the Department of Ethics, Philosophy and History of Medicine in the University Medical Centre Nijmegen, the Netherlands. In September 2003 he joined UNESCO as Director of the Division of Ethics of Science and Technology, working at the Headquarters in Paris, France. Since July 2010 he is Director of the Center for Healthcare Ethics at Duquesne University in Pittsburgh, USA. In 2011 he was appointed as Adjunct Professor at King Saud bin Abdulaziz University for Health Sciences, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

Duquesne University would like to thank the following

groups for supporting the 2016 Ethics Forum:

Training and Experimentation in

Computational Biology Research

Experiences for Undergraduates

(TECBioREU)

Duquesne University Chemistry NIH-SRE

Duquesne University Chemistry NSF-REU

Duquesne University Center for

Computational Sciences

Gaussian, Inc.

Duquesne University Pain

Undergraduate Research Experience

(PURE)

Duquesne University would like to thank the following

groups for supporting the 2016 Ethics Forum:

University of Pittsburgh, Department of

Physics

United States Department of Defense

National Science Foundation

National Institutes of Health

Duquesne University Mylan

School of Pharmacy

University of Pittsburgh, Department

of Biomedical Informatics