of 25
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
1/25
Dkwfdhe~doix ob ~}cinx di
Ehhcxx& Mcicbd~x ein X~e~sx ob
Hokkoi Feinx di Le}ie~ele
Xje}ehjhjein}e Fcfc ein Xccke Ws}sxjo~jekei
Nchckmc} =755
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
2/25
Os~fdic X~ohl ~eldi` kedix~}cek ~jdildi`
Pjt mo~jc} io}ke~drc usc}dcx
Hokkoi feinx ob Le}ie~ele x~e~sx ein
Icp eww}oehj
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
3/25
Hoirci~doief Pdxnok
Hokkoix e}c dkwo}~ei~ bo} }s}ef fdrcfdjoonx
We}~dhsfe}ft dkwo}~ei~ bo} }s}ef woo}
Xo mc~~c} *;hokksid~e}dei$ w}o~ch~doi ein
keie`ckci~ o okkoix x w}o+woo} eiw}o+fdrcfdjoonx
Pdi+pdi pd~j fe}`c} hoixc}re~doi di~c}cx~x
pjci d~ hokcx ~o bo}cx~x
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
4/25
Hjeffci`cx ~o hoirci~doief pdxnok
Nd}ch~ fein `}ei~ dx ko}c w}o+woo} cxwchdefft
pjci woo} e}c feinfcxx Ncwcincihc oi ]s}ef Hokkoix dx nchfdidi`
pd~j ncrcfo kci~ xo dihci~drc ~o keie c dx
fcxx Owwo}~sid~t hox~ ~o xohdc~t jd`jc} pjci
ef~c}ie~drc fein sxc dx fsh}e~drc pd~j xokc
~}dhlfc+nopi *kdidi`& pdin be}kx& dinsx~}defncrcfowkci~$
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
5/25
Pjt mo~jc}
]s}ef Hokkoix *ob ~jc woo}$ reidxj ein s}meihokkoix bfos}dxj *xohdef ic~po}lx oi di~c}ic~& hoihc}ibo} s}mei chofo`t& crofrdi` dix~d~s~doix ob s}mei xohdefhokkoix$
^dkc t ~o h}e ~ ei dix~d~s~doie ei wo dht kch eidxk*di ~jc hoi~cz~ ob }cfool e~ fein }cbo}kx& X oBN eh~&nchci~}efdxe~doi ~j}sx~ di `orc}ieihc$
Dind}ch~ xc}rdhcx b}ok hokkoix e}c dih}cexdi` di refsc Hjei`di` ncwcincihc ket io~ kcei nchfdidi` ncwcincihc
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
6/25
Pjt mo~jc} hoi~n))
]s}ef xsx~cieihc
; b *Ie~ ]cx)$ ; b \IM~ *OF , WF , HF , BF$[ +++++++++++++++++++++++ *5$
IM~ ; Ic~ mcicbd~x orc} ~dkc
IM~ OF; b *Wc} hewd~e jofndi` xdqc& W}onsh~drd~t$ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ *=$
IM~ WF; b *Erc}e`c jofndi` xdqc& Femos} diws~ / sid~ e}ce$+++++++++++++++++ *8$IM~ HF; b *Cz~ci~ " uf~t ob hokkoi feinx/hewd~e& Xohdef hokkoix$++++++++++ *>$
IM~ BF; b *Uf~t& nc as}c ein nc beh~o ehhcxx& Jskei eidkef hoibfdh~x$++++++++++++ *3$
Keao} hoix~}edi~x di kezdkdxdi` cuse~doi *5$& ex ncnshcn b}ok cuse~doix *=$ ~o *3$
Bekdft xdqc " jcef~j di ke}`dief be}k+jofndi`x
W}onsh~drd~t ob opi/owc}e~cn feinx
Di~cixd~t ob e`}dhsf~s}c di fe}`c be}kx
Hoirc}xdoi ob hokkoi feinx
]d`j~x ein Ehhcxx ~o bo}cx~x
Jskei+ pdfnfdbc hoibfdh~
Eredfemdfd~t& Ehhcxx& Usefd~t ein `orc}ieihc ob hokkoi feinx ~jsx nc~c}kdic }s}ef
xsx~cieihc di `cic}ef ein IM~ HF di we}~dhsfe}
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
7/25
Uscx~doix ~je~ e}dxc Pje~ dx ~jc io}ke~drc b}ekc ~j}os`j pjdhj
oic foolx e~ ~jc Hokkoix uscx~doi? worc}~t }cnsh~doi?
chofo`dhef xsx~ediemdfd~t o}
nckoh}e~dh nchdxdoi+keldi`?
Jop no pc exxcxx mcicbd~x ob Hokkoix?Dx ~jc x~eine}n choiokdh hefhsfsx
eww}ow}de~c? Pje~ kd`j~ mc mc~~c} ow~doix bo} HWF]
`orc}ieihc?
X5
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
8/25
Xfdnc 0
X5 ~jc dix~d~s~doief bedfs}c `drd`i }dxc ~o jd`j ndxhosi~ }e~cx ein ~jsx fcendi` ~o e ~}e`cnt ob hokkoix dx orc}foolcn< pjci choiokdx~x~elc e jd`j } di eff hexcx)Xcckew& 5=/=:/=755
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
9/25
Hexc x~snt ob Le}ie~ele X~e~c& Dinde
Ncbdid~doi ob Hokkoi feinx1 eff fein }cxos}hcx ~o
pjdhj wsmfdh o} we}~ ob wsmfdh jerc nc beh~oaodi~ehhcxx *crci db io~ jcfn ex hokkoi w}owc}~t$ + HWF]
Os} bohsx1 }s}ef x~e~c+opicn feinx *mchesxc di wox~+
hofoidef Dinde io hokksid~t opic}xjdw o} crcikeie`ckci~ }d`j~x$
^po keao} he~c`o}dcx1
Fc`efft bo}cx~ feinx& kox~ft bo}cx~& ms~
Fc`efft ioi+bo}cx~ feinx& kox~ft `}eqdi`& ms~
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
10/25
^cis}c }c`dkcx di Le}ie~ele HWF]x
Ef~jos`j x~e~c+opicn& kshj re}de~doi di cz~ci~ ob
}d`j~x `}ei~cn& ~o pjok& enkdidx~c}cn mt& einwjtxdhef x~e~sx
Ehhcxx1 b}ok owci+ehhcxx ~o xwchdbdh `}oswx ~o+
]d`j~x1 b}ok bd}cpoon " `}eqdi` ~o KBWx ~o ~dkmc}
Hoi~}of1 ]N& BN& ]N,BN
Wjtxdhef x~e~sx1 b}ok ncixc bo}cx~x ~o ~}cc xereiiex~o ws}c `}exxfeinx ~o me}}ci
s=
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
11/25
Xfdnc 4
s= ~j} ntiekdhx ob hex~c ein hfexx di `}ei~di` ehhcxx 1 hosfn mc ~je~ feinx ~o pjdhj ehhcxx dx hex~c xwchdbdh *ms}def `}osinx& pcffx ~eilxjo}cx c~h$ ket mc hfexx b}cc ein pjc}c ehhcxx dx hokwfc~cft owci& koict ein wofd~dhef wopc} w}ordnc ehhcxx *mcehjcx$)
jc bo}kc} ewwce}x ~o mc mc~~c} w}o~ch~cnsxc}& 5/55/=755
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
12/25
Wjtxdhef cz~ci~ ob Le}ie~ele HWF]x
Xd`idbdhei~ re}de~doi di wc} rdffe`c cz~ci~& bo}
mo~j cho+hfdke~dh ein jdx~o}dhef }cexoix
Xje}cn hokkoix eh}oxx rdffe`cx
`i hei~ ch ic i e}ce orc} ~ kc Obbdhdef bd`s}cx no io~ }cbfch~ cih}oehjkci~x
Icrc}~jcfcxx& y57&777 rdffe`cx pd~j xd`idbdhei~
*937je$ HWF] e}ce
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
13/25
We}~dhsfe}x
Hoex~ef ein
@je~
Kdzcn/^}eixd~
doief
Io}~jc}i
Kednei
Xos~jc}i
KedneiX~e~c ^o~ef
^@E
=77> =7)53 54)8= 82):8 =8)24 577)77
Wc}keici~ Wex~s}cx54:2 4)84 >)8: 5)04 55)57 3)4>
5442 :)3: 8)>4 5)0= 4)22 3)=0
=77> :)38 8)04 5)07 0)42 3)77
Bo}cx~x
]c`doix
Wc}hci~e`c ob re}dosx fein sxc he~c`o}dcx di ndbbc}ci~ }c`doix ob Le}ie~ele*Eww}ozdke~c HWF] cz~ci~$
) ) ) ) )
5442 >=)5> 53)7: 3)3> 0)32 52)7:=77> >8)74 52)4= 3)00 :)25 52)5=
Wc}keici~ Beffopx ein
Hsf~dremfc Pex~cx
54:2 3)>> 8)>7 8)85 0)74 >)32
5442 3)72 8)04 8)83 3)4: >)84
=77> 3)78 >)08 8)7= 2)=4 >)07
Hsf~dre~cn E}ce ein Hs}}ci~
Beffopx
54:2 =:)7: 20)70 :7):: 30)48 27)4>
5442 =:)82 20)54 :7)3> 34)02 2=)=2
=77> =0)8> 2=)44 :7)48 34):5 25)50
Xos}hc1 Mexcn oi fein s~dfdxe~doi ne~e b}ok Ncw~) ob Choiokdhx ein X~e~dx~dhx& @OL
^emfc ncxd`i mexcn oi Ienele}id *5447$
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
14/25
Fein cis}c
~twc
Fein sxc ~twc
*NCX 4 bofn$
Ehhcxx Hoi~}offdi
` ncw~)
]d`j~x Ncbeh~o xd~se~doi Fohe~doi
Kdio} Bo}cx~x Bo}cx~x *]B$ Fe}`cft owci BNBscf poon& bonnc} bo} xcfb)
hoix)
KBW & ~dkmc} c~h
*BN/Hoi~}eh~o}x$
]d`j~x hs}~edfcn xokc
~dkcx& `or~) effo~x
josxdi` xd~cx
SL
Exxcxxcn
Pex~c Feinx
Kdxh) }ccx "
@}orcx&
Wex~s}cx&Me}}ci?
Fe}`cft owci ]N Bscf poon& bonnc} bo} xcfb)
hoix)
KBW *]N$
Xd`idbdhei~ b}eh~doix
cih}oehjcn&
o~jc}pdxc nc`}encn
NL
Xowwdie
Mc~~ex ob SL
Bo}cx~x *WB$ W}dre~c o}
`}oswx ob
josxcjofnx
BN,]N Bscf poon& bonnc} bo} xcfb)
hoix)
KBW *BN$)
Wc c} hsf~dre~doi effopcn
Re}dcx b}ok ncixc
~}ccx ~o ~}cc xereiie
~o ws}c }exxfein)
Xokc odi~ e~hjcx
SL
e}c ndrdncnXowwdie
Mc~~ex ob HK&
XJK
Wex~s}cx&
Bo}cx~x&
kdxh)~}ccx ein
`}orcx
W}dre~c o}
`}oswx ob
josxcjofnx
]N Bscf poon& bonnc} bo} xcfb)
hoix)
KBW *BN$& ms~ xofn w}dre~cft
~oo)
Wcwwc} hsf~dre~doi effopcn
Rc`c~e~doi re}dcx)
Xokc aodi~ we~hjcx
jerc mcci ndrdncn
HK& XJK
Jeendx ob NL&
Snswd
Kdxh ~}ccx "
`}orcx&
bo}cx~x&
W}dre~c o}
`}oswx ob
josxcjofnx
]N,BN Bscfpoon& bonnc}& fcercx&
~dkmc}& KBW
Xd`idbdhei~ ~}cc horc}&
ms~ xokc dx hexjcpwfei~e~doi
NL& Snswd
@okeefx Wex~s}cx&
Me}}ci?&
Kdxh) }ccx ein
`}orcx
Fe}`cft owci ]N Bscfpoon& bonnc} Me}}ci czhcw~ db
m}os`j~ sinc} Xohdef
Bo}cx~}t< ob~ci
effo~~cn bo}ncrcfowkci~ef
w}oach~x pd~jos~
Kox~
ndx~}dh~x
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
15/25
Wjtxdhef x~e~sx ob Le}ie~ele HWF]x*ewe}~ b}ok cih}oehjkci~x ein hoirc}xdoix$
hoffch~drc sxc / owci ehhcxx hoibdicx ~o felcxjo}cx& ms}def `}osinx
~}cc wfei~e~doix js}~ fohef fdrcfdjoonx *ein
pe~c}xjcnx$ di `}eqdi` feinx rdxdmfc w}onsh~drd~t nchfdic di bo}cx~ feinx
sinc} w}dre~c keie`ckci~
foi`+~c}k xsx~ediemdfd~t + io~ fdlcft
s8
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
16/25
Xfdnc 58
s8 xohdef bo}cx~}t ein mdobscf wfei~e~doixsxc}& 5/55/=755
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
17/25
Hsf~dre~doi oi xfowdi` c}x~pjdfc `okeef feinLeirdjeffd *Je}ewweijeffd ~efsle& Nerei`c}c ndx~$
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
18/25
Kdidi` ein hsf~dre~doi di xfowdi` `okeefx*Jofeflc}c ~efsl& Hjd~}e Ns}`e$
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
19/25
]cexoix bo} nc`}ene~doi Kdxke~hj ob di~c}cx~x1
fohef rx x~e~c C)`) xohdef bo}cx~}t wfei~e~doix obwsfwpoon< w}dre~c rx hokkoi& feincn rxfeinfcxx/wex~o}ef
Xohdef hoibfdh~x ex me}}dc}x ~o hoffch~drc eh~doi
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
20/25
Ef~c}ie~c czwfeie~doix Nchfdidi` fohef ncwcincihc
E`}dhsf~s}ef konc}idqe~doi}cnshcn sxc ob n}es`j~ eidkefx& ob o}`eidh
keis}c& c~h ]cnsh~doi di fdrcx~ohl fcrcfx
Emeinoidi` e`}dhsf~s}c
Ef~c}ie~drc sxcx dih}cexdi di refsc
Pdin wopc} Use}}tdi`/kdidi`
S}meidqe~doi
Dind}ch~ xc}rdhcx e}c dih}cexdi` di refsc< hjei`di` ncwcincihc
Dix~d~s~doief/ `orc}ieihc bedfs}c hesxdi` b}cc }dncx " jd`jndxhosi~ }e~cx
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
21/25
W}omfck ob kcexs}ckci~ ob ncwcincihc/refsc
Mexcn oi hs}}ci~ hoind~doi ob HWF] *kox~ftnc`}encn$
Mexcn oi fdkd~cn ehhcxx }d`j~x *c)`)& io }d`j~ ~o~dkmc}$ o} fdkd~cn ndxwoxef }d`j~x *c)`)& }c`sfe~cnI^BW ke}lc~x
Mexcn oi woo} dibo}ke~doi oi dind}ch~ fohefxc}rdhcx *c)`)& woffdie~doi& foi`+~c}k mcicbd~ obo}`eidh keis}di`& }chje}`c we~~c}ix$
Mexcn oi woo} e}~dhsfe~doi ob pokcix iccnx
Ncwcincihc e}`skci~ io~ }cfcrei~ di ~jc hoi~cz~ob hoihc}i bo} nckoh}e~dqe~doi X>
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
22/25
Xfdnc 5:
X> dix~d~sdoief bedfs}c jdldi` ~jc ndxhi~ }e~c dx orc}foolcn ein di~c}w}c~cn ob~ci ex woo} poi~ sxc xsx~deimftXcckew& 5=/=:/=755
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
23/25
Icp eww}oehj ~o HWF] `orc}ieihc
Ksf~dwfc io}ke~drc hoihc}ix }cusd}cx e ksf~d+fetc}cn eww}oehj
Bohsx oi nckoh}e~dh `orc}ieihc ein cusd~t }e~jc} ~jei xwchdbdhwjtxdhef os~hokcx
5x~ x~cw1 ]d`j~x }cbo}k di beros} ob feinfcxx ein wex~o}ef iokenx
in
nckoh}e~dh nchdxdoix$ 8}n x~cw1 ]c`sfe~o}t wopc}x e~ ndx~}dh~+fcrcf *}cbfch~ hoihc}ix ob
fe}`c} xohdef+chofo`dhef feinxhewc$
Fein bo} ndx~i + b}ok hcdfdi` wr~ feinx *Fein ehusdxd~doi fepx no~jc owwoxd~c$< HWF]x io~ ~o mc ~elci ex fein meilx
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
24/25
Uscx~doix ~je~ }ckedi Bo} Wofdht ein Dix~d~s~doix1 enew~drc cbbdhdciht
jop ~o mefeihc nckoh}e~dh& nchci~}efdqcnkeie`ckci~ pd~j cusd~emfc mcicbd~x ein
hoixc}re~doi ?
Bo} Ehenckdhx1 fool mctoin ~jc mfs}}di`ndhjo~okdcx w}cxci~ rx bs~s}c *ndxhosi~
}e~cx$& fohef rx `fomef *xhefc$ o} chofo`dhef rx
xohdef *x~}oi` rx pcel xsx~ediemdfd~t$ dkweh~x
8/3/2019 29_Forests&Common Lands Governance_S Lele & Seema Puruhsothaman
25/25