8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

1/20

MULTICRITERIADECISION MAKING

Nailah Firdausiyah,

ST., MT., M.Sc

Metode Analisa

Perencanaan 1

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

2/20

OUTLINE1. Defnisi

.Ta!a"an "en#elesaian $asala!

%.Peneta"an Kriteria&.Conto!

'.S(orin)

*.Pe$+o+otan

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

3/20

Defnisi

Metode #an) di(e$+an)(an dan di),na(an dala$$asala! "en)a$+ilan (e",t,san dan di$a(s,d(an

,nt,( +isa $en)a(o$odasi as"e(-as"e( di l,ar(riteria e(ono$i dan fnansial serta ,)a +isa

$en)i(,t serta(an +er+a)ai "i!a( #an) ter(aitden)an s,at, "ro#e( secara (o$"re!ensi/

dan scientifc (,antitati/ $a,",n (,alitati/2.

Men,r,t S a/r,ddin3 A 44&2

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

4/20

Defnisi

Peran)(at "en)a$+ilan (e",t,san #)di(e$+an)(an ,nt,( $asala!-$asala!

(o$"le(s $,lti(riteria #) $enca(," as"e((,alitati/ dan (,antitati/ dala$ "roses"en)a$+ilan (e",t,san

G,iller$o a Mendo5a3 16662

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

5/20

Ele$en MCDM1. Goal7 T, ,an (e",t,san

. Kriteria 7 Ketent,an ata, s#arat#) (ita ),na(an dala$ $e$ili!

%. Alternati8es 7 Pili!an-"ili!an #an)ada

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

6/20

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

7/20

Ke,n)),lan1. Ke$a$",an ,nt,( $ena$",n) +era)a$ (riteria

dala$ analisis. MCDM da"at $en)),na(an data ca$",ran dan

analisin#a tida( $e$erl,(an +an#a( data.Metode ini $e$,n)(in(an "en))a+,n)an +ai(in/or$asi (,alitati/ $a,",n (,antitati/

%. MCDM $e$,n)(in(an (eterli+atan lan)s,n)+er+a)ai "a(ar3 (elo$"o(3 dan sta(e!older

&. Analisis +ersi/at trans"aran'. MCDM $enca(," $e(anis$e ,$"an +ali( #an)+er(enaan den)an (onsistensi dari "enilaian#an) di+,at

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

8/20

Peneta"an (riteria1. Kriteria !ar,s da"at $en)e8al,asi

. Da"at (,alitati/ dan (,antitati/ %. S,$+er (riteria +isa dida"at dari tena)a

a!li3 standart3 dan +er+a)ai ",sta(a

&. Dises,i(an den)an (ondisi $asala! #an)sedan) dicari "en#elesaiann#a

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

9/20

Metode MCDM1.M,lti-Attri+,te ?al,e T!eor# $et!ods

MA?T2

.O,tran(in) $et!ods

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

10/20

Conto! (as,s1. Terda"at % alternati/ lo(asi PLTN7 @3

dan B. Penent,an lo(asi Pe$+an)(it Listri( Tena)a N,(lir #an) !ar,s $e$en,!i(riteria7

Sa/et# :a(tor A2

ealt! :a(tor >2En8iron$ent :a(tor C2Cost :a(tor D2

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

11/20

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

12/20

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

13/20

Kriteria Alternati/ Pili!an @ Pili!an Pili!an B:a(tor A % 1:a(tor > % 1:a(tor C % 1:a(tor D 1 ,$la! 11 * *

Nor$ali5ed Score *.46H %*.6*H %*.6*H

Kriteria Alternati/ Pili!an @ Pili!an Pili!an B Inter8al

:a(tor A 1 & ' 4-':a(tor > 4 4 '4 1-144:a(tor C - 4 1 - to F:a(tor D 4.& 4. ' 4.& 4 to 1 ,$la! 16.& &. ' '*.&

Nor$ali5ed Score 1 .6H &6. H % .'H

S(orin)

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

14/20

Nor$ali5ed ne;

score ,$la! total 7 % 11F*F*2.Nor$ali5ed score ,nt,( Pili!an @ 7 4.'J 1-11< %2

*.46H3Nor$ali5ed score ,nt,( Pili!an dan B 7 4.'J 1-*< %2

%*.6*HSe$a(in tin))i nilai nor$ali5ed score $en#ata(anse$a(in +an#a( dis,(ai

Catatan71. Nilai ran)(in) ordinal2 nilai nor$ali5ed score

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

15/20

Nor$ali5ed score

Kriteria Alternati/ Pili!an @ Pili!an Pili!an B:a(tor A 4. 4. 1:a(tor > 4.16 4.*6 4.&6':a(tor C 4 4.' 4. ':a(tor D 4.& 4. ' 4.& ,$la! 4. 6 . & .*&'

Nor$ali5ed Score 1 . H &&.&H & . H

Conto!7 :a(tor A $e$",n#ai inter8al 4-' 3$a(aUnt,( $e$+,at s(or Pili!an den)an nilai& (e dala$ inter8al 4-13 $a(a (ita ",n#aol+ 43 o,+ '3nl+ 43 n,+ 13score &3

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

16/20

Nor$ali5ed ne;

score

Kriteria Alternati/ Pili!an @ Pili!an Pili!an B:a(tor A 4. 4. 1:a(tor > 4.16 4.*6 4.&6':a(tor C 4 4.' 4. ':a(tor D 4.& 4. ' 4.& ,$la! 4. 6 . & .*&'

Nor$ali5ed Score 1 . H &&.&H & . H

Conto!7 Unt,( Pili!an @ dala$ :a(tor >den)an nilai asal 4 dan nilai inter8al 1 to144. Ma(a (ita ",n#a ol+ 13

o,+ 1443nl+ 43 n,+ 1and score 43

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

17/20

Pe$+o+otan:a(tor A :a(tor > :a(tor C :a(tor D ,$la!

Le8elKe"entin)

an

* 1 11

>o+ot(e"entin)a

n

'&.'H 1 . H 1 . H 6.1H 144.4H

Kriteria Alternati/ >o+ot Pili!an @ Pili!an Pili!an B:a(tor A '&.'H 4.146 4.&%* 4.'&':a(tor > 1 . H 4.4%' 4.1 4.464:a(tor C 1 . H 4.444 4.461 4.1%*:a(tor D 6.1H 4.4%* 4.4* 4.4%* ,$la! 144.4H 4.1 4 4. 4. 4

Nor$ali5ed Score 14.'H & . H & . H

Conto!7 Kita ",t,s(an +a!;a /a(tor > dan C adala! (ali le+i!"entin) di+andin) /a(tor D. dan :a(tor A adala! % (ali le+i!"entin) dari /a(tor >

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

18/20

Pe$+o+otanKriteria Alternati/ >o+ot Pili!an @ Pili!an Pili!an B

:a(tor A '&.'H 4.146 4.&%* 4.'&':a(tor > 1 . H 4.4%' 4.1 4.464:a(tor C 1 . H 4.444 4.461 4.1%*:a(tor D 6.1H 4.4%* 4.4* 4.4%*

,$la! 144.4H 4.1 4 4. 4. 4Nor$ali5ed Score 14.'H & . H & . H

Catatan7 1. asil s(orin) Pili!an le+i! dis,(ai dari"ada B

. asil "e$+o+otan Pili!an B adala! "ili!analternati/ #an) "alin) +a#a( dis,(ai< di"ili!.

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

19/20

Kesi$",lan

Lo(asi B $er,"a(an lo(asi PLTN #)

$en,r,t (riteria lo(asi Sa/et#3 ealt!3

En8iron$ent3 Cost $er,"a(an lo(asi

ter+ai(

8/18/2019 322830 Lect.12 Multi Criteria Analysis

20/20

TERIMA KASI