of 22
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
1/22
Shikha Jha
ADB Gender Specialists Annual Exchange and Workshop7 August 2014
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
2/22
Overview
Macroeconomic policy emphasizes
growth and broader goals of well-being
employment and equity not just price stability
Gender-responsive macro policy can promote
equality in education, family benefits, access to credit and
jobs
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
3/22
Status of women in the region
Girls and women face differentialtreatment at all ages
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
4/22
Girls lose out on education
0
2
4
6
8
10
Kyrgyzstan PRC Papua NewGuinea
Afghanistan India Indonesia Philippines
Average years of schooling, 2000-2012
Male Female
Source: ILO, Key Indicators of the Labor Market, 8 thedition
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
5/22
And, women are left behind
0
30
60
90
Kyrgyzstan PRC Papua NewGuinea
Afghanistan India Indonesia Philippines
Labor Force Participation Rate, 2012 (%)
Male Female
Average LFPR for female
Average LFPR for male
Source: ILO, Key Indicators of the Labor Market, 8 thedition
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
6/22
Many are discouraged; stop searching for jobs
Not actively
seeking jobs,
discouraged
workers
Students
Employed
UnemployedJobless
Example: India Youth 2004-05Unemployment rate = 4%
Jobless rate = 29%
Finding a job may take years
Estimated median ages ofschool-leaving and job entry
Indonesia 18 and 22
Philippines 18 and 22
Thailand 18 and 20
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
7/22
Youth joblessness affects women more
0
15
30
45
60
1993-94 2004-05 1994 2004 1991 2006 1995 2005
India Indonesia Philippines Thailand
%Jobless rates for young men versus young women
(15-24)
Male Female
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
8/22
Disparities in work
Women account for most unpaid work
Female-owned businesses
small size of business, lower profits, labor productivityIn paid employment
low wages, glass ceiling, informal employment
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
9/22
Ratio of median wages of young
women to young men
0.72 0.75 0.71
0.870.76
0.89
1.00 1.01
-
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
1993-94 2004-05 1994 2006 1991 2006 1995 2005
India Indonesia Philippines Thailand
%
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
10/22
Growth-induced gender barriers
High prices/ production costsunemployment:women are fired first
Rise in interest ratesreduceswomens access tocredit and financial services
Limited employment in export-orientedmanufacturing due to mechanization and automation
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
11/22
Depth of gender inequality: Rich women
benefit more from public services than poor
0
20
40
60
80
100
BAN CAM IND INO NEP PAK PHI VIE
WealthQintile
Percent of women who received
skilled antenatal care (latest year)
Lowest Second Third Fourth Highest
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
12/22
Gender Gap Index (0-1)
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1PHI
KAZMON
SRI
SIN
LAO
KGZ
THA
PRC
VIE
BRU
TAJBHU
ARMINOAZE
IND
MAL
CAM
KOR
FIJ
NEP
PAK
Iceland
JapanUSA
Source: World Economic Forum, 2013 Global Gender Gap Report
Total inequality = 0Total equality = 1
Gender equitygaps in education health economics and
politics
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
13/22
Gender Gap Index (0-1)
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1PHI
KAZMON
SRI
SIN
LAO
KGZ
THA
PRC
VIE
BRU
TAJBHU
ARMINOAZE
IND
MAL
CAM
KOR
FIJ
NEP
PAK
Iceland
JapanUSA
2006
Source: World Economic Forum, 2013 Global Gender Gap Report
Total inequality = 0Total equality = 1
Gender equalitygaps in education health economics and
politics
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
14/22
Slight improvement in
Gender Gap Index (0-1)
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1PHI
KAZMON
SRI
SIN
LAO
KGZ
THA
PRC
VIE
BRU
TAJBHU
ARMINOAZE
IND
MAL
CAM
KOR
FIJ
NEP
PAK
Iceland
JapanUSA
20132006
Source: World Economic Forum, 2013 Global Gender Gap Report
Total inequality = 0Total equality = 1
Gender equalitygaps in education health economics and
politics
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
15/22
Poorer countries are more biased
against women
-.
2
0
.2
.4
.6
.8
0 20000 40000 60000 80000
2013 GNI per capita (2011 PPP$)
Source: Human Development Report 2014
Gender Inequality Index (0-1):Loss in human developmentdue to gender inequality in reproductive health
empowerment and labor market
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
16/22
Macroeconomic policy for
improving womens
contribution to the economy
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
17/22
Education is key to
better employment prospects
SE Asia Higher education is associated with lowerjobless rates for 25-34 age group
Thailand Bachelors degree increasesjobprospects 5 times compared to no education
To reduce waiting time to get a job, match
education and training with emerging skills high-tech manufacturing participation in global trade and production networks
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
18/22
Catch them young
1/3rdof East Asias growth attributable to youthbulge or demographic dividend'
Reaping the dividend depends on the policyenvironment
education policy
labor market regulations
macroeconomic management
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
19/22
It pays to involve women in market
work
High female labor force participation
accounted for 0.6%1.6% of annual per capita growth inHongkong, Korea, Singapore, Taipei
House work not included in national income
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
20/22
Fiscal policy
Gender-based budgeting
Expenditure allocation to address womens health, social andeducation inequalities (Sri Lanka, Pakistan, Malaysia)
Lower income tax rates/ tax rebates for women (India)
Family benefits
Child care for women garment workers in Bangladesh funded byNGOs, government, donors
Programs for poor women entrepreneurs, e.g., India:Shakti Amma
(Empowered Mothers) program by Hindustan Unilever and IndianNGOs
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
21/22
Monetary policy
To prevent negative consequences for self-employedwomen and low-income groups
Subsidized interest rates for greater access to credit andfinancial services
Cheap credit for programs promoting business start-upsfor young women
8/11/2019 4 Shikha_Macroeconomic Policies for Gender Equity
22/22
Summing up
Macroeconomic policy
Aims for growth and price stability
Gender-responsive macro policy can promote can promote equal participation by women to maximize
development outcomes through
equality in education, access to jobs and credit, andavailability of family benefits