National Fire Protection Association 1 Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA 02169-7471 Phone: 617-770-3000 • Fax: 617-770-0700 • www.nfpa.org M E M O R A N D U M TO: NFPA Technical Committee on Laboratories Using Chemicals FROM: Joanne Goyette, Administrator, Technical Projects DATE: August 8, 2013 SUBJECT: NFPA 45 FD TC Ballot Circulation (F2014) The August 7, 2013 date for receipt of the NFPA 45 First Draft ballot has passed. The preliminary First Draft ballot results are shown on the attached report. 28 Members Eligible to Vote 10 Ballots Not Returned (R. Anderson, W. Barlen, J. Dembishack, M. Hudkins, J. Johnson, J. Kidd, P. Puhlick, D. Quigley, R. Ramirez, and S. Waller) In accordance with the NFPA Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards, attached are reasons for negative votes for review so you may change your ballot if you wish. Abstentions and affirmative comments are also included. Ballots received from alternate members are not included unless the ballot from the principal member was not received. If you wish to change your vote, the change must be received at NFPA on or Thursday, August 15, 2013 . Members who have not returned a ballot may do so now. Such changes should be submitted through the NFPA Vote.net Ballot Site . The return of ballots is required by the Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards.
Transcript
National Fire Protection Association 1 Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA 02169-7471 Phone: 617-770-3000 • Fax: 617-770-0700 • www.nfpa.org
M E M O R A N D U M TO: NFPA Technical Committee on Laboratories Using Chemicals FROM: Joanne Goyette, Administrator, Technical Projects DATE: August 8, 2013 SUBJECT: NFPA 45 FD TC Ballot Circulation (F2014)
The August 7, 2013 date for receipt of the NFPA 45 First Draft ballot has passed. The preliminary First Draft ballot results are shown on the attached report. 28 Members Eligible to Vote 10 Ballots Not Returned (R. Anderson, W. Barlen, J. Dembishack, M. Hudkins, J. Johnson,
J. Kidd, P. Puhlick, D. Quigley, R. Ramirez, and S. Waller) In accordance with the NFPA Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards, attached are reasons for negative votes for review so you may change your ballot if you wish. Abstentions and affirmative comments are also included. Ballots received from alternate members are not included unless the ballot from the principal member was not received. If you wish to change your vote, the change must be received at NFPA on or Thursday, August 15, 2013. Members who have not returned a ballot may do so now. Such changes should be submitted through the NFPA Vote.net Ballot Site. The return of ballots is required by the Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards.
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
FR-95, New Section after 1.1.1, See FR-95
Total Voted : 18
FR-144, Global Input, See FR-144
Total Voted : 18
Results by Revision
FR-113, Global Input, See FR-113
Total Voted : 18
FR-96, Section No. 1.1.2, See FR-96
Total Voted : 18
NFPA 45 LAB-AAA (F2014) First Draft BallotCirculation Report
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 17Affirmative with Comment 1
Samuel A. Denny With the addition of the Permitted Stories Below Grade column in Table 5.1.1, Footnote c should be deleted.
Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 17Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 1
Richard P. Palluzi I beleive the exception which warns of the potential for the hood ventilation alone to be inadequate to prevent a build up of flammable vapors is required. I thought we agree to reword the exception to meet NFPA standards but retain the concept within the mandatory section of the standard.
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 17Affirmative with Comment 1
William F. Guffey I propose the following additions and change to make this section retroactive to existing labs: 6.5.1 Written fire prevention procedures shall be established for all new and existing laboratories. (1) Safe handling and storage of chemicals, flammable and combustible liquids, pyrophoric and other reactive compounds and compressed gases and cryogenic liquids. (5) Daily inspection of the means egress from the laboratory to ensure it is maintained free of obstructions. This shall include exit door(s) from the lab and exit access aisles. (6) Good housekeeping procedures shall be established. (7) 6.5.3 Combustible contents and furnishings shall not be used in a laboratory work area unless it meets the minimum requirements of Section 10.3 of the Life Safety Code. 6.5.2 Maintenance Procedures. Maintenance and testing procedures shall be established for chemical fume hoods, alarm and detection equipment and laboratory equipment.
Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 17Affirmative with Comment 1
William F. Guffey I propose the following change to make this section retroactive to existing labs and require written plans: 6.5.3.1 Written plans for laboratory emergencies shall be established for new and existing laboratories.
Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 17Affirmative with Comment 1
Andrew Minister Editorial: the word "which" in sub-paragraphs 1 and 2 should be deleted for the text to read correctly.
Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28
Total Voted : 18
FR-121, Section No. 8.8.3.2, See FR-121
Total Voted : 18
FR-108, New Section after 8.8.1.1, See FR-108
Total Voted : 18
FR-78, Section No. 8.8 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See FR-78
Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 17Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 1
Richard P. Palluzi While I understand the committee's desire to respond to critics of the negative wordign of thsi section, I remain concerned that - as worded - this sectio nshall be used to justify unneeded, unnecessary and costly automatic fire surpression systems of limited effectiveness due to limited understanding of the hazards by local AHJ and due to heavy promotion by suppliers of thsi equipment.
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Total Voted : 18
FR-8, Section No. 8.10.3.1, See FR-8
Total Voted : 18
FR-143, Section No. 8.10.3 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See FR-143
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 17Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 1
Richard P. Palluzi The wording remains vague and open to improper application by less knowledgable personnel. It is not clear what "special ventilation" is requiredor can do. Since explosion proof electric or air motors are readily available and since the alternatives are often poorly understood and implemented I think this provisio nshould be eliminated or reworded to provide more concrete guidance.
Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10
Total Voted : 18
FR-114, New Section after 12.1.5.3, See FR-114
Total Voted : 18
FR-49, Section No. 12.1.1 [Excluding any Sub-Sections], See FR-49
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 17Affirmative with Comment 1
Diane L. Kroll 13.3.1.3 For existing educational and instructional laboratories that do not have a separate preparation room, the dispensing of bulk quantities of chemicals for experiments or demonstrations shall be performed prior to the arrival of the students in the classroom. COMMENT: I agree with what appears to be the intent of statement, to ensure students are not present during performance of bulk dispensing. However see the language, “prior to the arrival of the students” as time limiting. Modifying the language to read, “whenever the students are not in the classroom” retains the author's/committee's apparent intent and expands the timeframe for dispensing of bulk quantities. For example, the instructor could excuse students from the classroom to perform such dispensing of bulk quantities if needed or dispensing may be performed after students leave the classroom for any reason. i.e., For existing educational and instructional laboratories that do not have a separate preparation room, the dispensing of bulk quantities of chemicals for experiments or demonstrations shall be performed whenever the students are not in the classroom.
Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
Eligible to Vote: 28Not Returned : 10Richard R. Anderson, William H. Barlen, John L. Dembishack, III, Michael E. Hudkins, Jason D. Johnson, Jeffrey S. Kidd, Peter Puhlick, David R. Quigley, Ricardo A. Ramirez, and Stephen Waller
Vote Selection Votes CommentsAffirmative 18Affirmative with Comment 0Negative 0Abstain 0
