of 50
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
1/50
Ley~gbj ea YAE _vyf`is* g's' 1* 2009%01* >0=4
2001 L' Bjjig Dpgik Oigvi~ ae~ YAE _vyf`is
>0
VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI8#>0==
BN_V^BOV< X~iqbjigv dpxevdisis ~imb~f`gm vdi iv`ejemp ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoib~i itbc`gif* isxio`bjjp `g ~imb~f ve vdi it`sv`gm iq`figoi' Fioixv`eg* symmisv`n`j`vp
$abgvbsp#x~egigiss* dpxgev`|bn`j`vp* abjsi#cice~p spgf~eci* xi~segbj`vp* sjiix xdi#gecigb* xspodexbvdejemp* xspodefpgbc`os* igq`~egcigvbj above~s* bgf iqigv#jiqijbj`ig igoeygvi~s b~i ibod oegs`fi~if bs e~`m`gs ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Vdi fbvbb~i f`soyssif `g vi~cs ea }dbv `s bgf `s gev oegs`svigv }`vd vdie~p* vdi oegoixv eaxb~s`cegp* bgf vdi giif ae~ oegqi~m`gm j`gis ea iq`figoi `g isvbnj`sd`gm j`gkbmisniv}iig abov bgf vdie~p' Eg vdi nbs`s ea vd`s bgbjps`s* ` v `s b~myif vdbv ge vdie~p pivigleps igeymd icx`~`obj syxxe~v ve ni booixvif bs b migi~bj itxjbgbv`eg ae~ vdibnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Vdi oegoixv ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi bs b cyjv`obysbjxdigecigeg `s f`soyssif* bgf symmisv`egs ae~ ayvy~i ~isib~od b~i x~eq`fif'
Vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi> `s odb~bovi~`|if np synliov`qijp ~ibj cice~`is ea
ni`gm vbkig sio~ivjp bgf%e~ bmb`gsv egis }`jj np bxxb~igvjp gegdycbg igv`v`is bgfsynliovif ve oecxjit xdps`obj bgf xspodejem`obj x~eoify~is'? Vdi gycni~ ea syod
itxi~`igois dbs niig isv`cbvif np Lboens $200> bs 91) ea vdi xexyjbv`eg* bgf np
Dexk`gs* Lboens* bgf ]isv~yc $200> bs >) ea vdi xexyjbv`eg' Ce~i oegsi~qbv`qi
isv`cbvis cbp ni fi~`qif np oeygv`gm vdi bovybj gycni~ ea obsis vdbv dbqi niig
~ixe~vif np `gqisv`mbve~s' Ae~ itbcxji* Nyjjb~fs $2006 sy~qip ea 2? `gqisv`mbve~s
p`ijfif 2*=88 obsis' ]dbviqi~ vdi gycni~* ai} bsxiovs ea yaejemp dbqi bvv~bovif bs
cyod bvvigv`eg' Ve vdesi }de f`sc`ss vdi xess`n`j`vp vdbv YAEs cbp ni sxboio~bav*
vdi gev`eg ea bnfyov`egs np YAE eooyxbgvs `s siig bs `gdi~igvjp `cxjbys`nji' Ae~
vdesi }de nij`iqi vdbv YAEs b~i ygfi~ vdi oegv~ej ea itv~bvi~~isv~`bjs* bnfyov`egitxi~`igois symmisv nevd b ~bv`egbji ae~ sy~~ixv`v`eys YAE bov`q`vp bgf bg exxe~vy#
g`vp ve jib~g bneyv vdi xy~xesi ygfi~jp`gm syod bov`q`vp' @g issigoi* vdi bnfyov`eg
itxi~`igoi s siig bs bg bgs}i~ ve vdi x~eqi~n`bj ryisv`eg* ]dp fegv vdip jbgf eg
vdi ]d`vi Deysi jb}g5
@g bff`v`eg ve vdi itv~bvi~~isv~`bj dpxevdis`s* vdi~i b~i gyci~eys bjvi~gbv`qi it#
xjbgbv`egs ae~ vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi* cbgp ea }d`od dbqi niig bov`qijp finbvif
`g vdi yaejem`obj j`vi~bvy~i' De}iqi~* vdisi finbvis dbqi eavig sdif cyod ce~i dibv
vdbg j`mdv' Vdi xy~xesi ea vd`s xbxi~ `s ve ojesijp itbc`gi vdi x~exesif itxjbgb#
v`egs $obysis ae~ vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi `g vi~cs ea vdi`~ vdie~iv`obj sv~igmvdsbgf }ibkgissis* bgf ce~i `cxe~vbgvjp* `g vi~cs ea }dbv $`a bgp icx`~`obj iq`figoi
it`svs g vdi`~ syxxe~v' Vdi ~iq`i} feis gev bff~iss syns`f`b~p ssyis }d`od x~isyx#
xesi b xb~v`oyjb~ iv`ejemp' $Ae~ itbcxji* }dbv xjbgivs fe vdi bnfyove~s oeci a~ec5
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
2/50
?8 LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
Ge~ feis `v igvi~vb`g vdi xes`v`eg bfqeobvif np seci vdbv bg ygfi~svbgf`gm ea vdi
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi `s gev bcigbnji ve so`igv`a`o bgbjps`s $b xes`v`eg }`vd }d`od @
f`sbm~ii; Bxxijji* 2006n'
Vdi ^yji ea Xb~s`cegp bgf Vdie~`is ea vdi Bnfyov`eg Itxi~`igoi
Vdi `ssyi ea iq`figoi `s xb~v`oyjb~jp `cxe~vbgv `g ~imb~f ve vdi ~yji ea xb~s`cegp
$eavig ~iai~~if ve bs Eoobcs ~b|e~' Vd`s cbt`c svbvis vdbv }dig `gvi~x~iv`gm b
xdigecigeg* yggioissb~p bssycxv`egs sdeyjf gev ni `gv~efyoif' @v `s `cxe~vbgv ve
icxdbs`|i vdbv xb~s`cegp `s fia`gif `g vi~cs eayggioissb~p bssycxv`egs* gev `g
vi~cs ea ygxexyjb~ bssycxv`egs* f`svy~n`gm bssycxv`egs* e~ ygoegqigv`egbj bs#
sycxv`egs' Bs syod* `v obg ni bssissif egjp `g ~imb~f ve icx`~`obj iq`figoi* bs vdi
icx`~`obj iq`figoi fia`gis }d`od bssycxv`egs b~i e~ b~i gev gioissb~p' B vdie~p
obggev oegv`gyi ve ni fiaigfif eg vdi m~eygfs ea xb~s`cegp `a `v dbs niigf`soega`~cif vd~eymd itxi~`cigv* bgf `g vdi bnsigoi ea x~exi~ visv`gm* xb~s`cegp
np `vsija `s ea j`c`vif qbjyi `g bssiss`gm b vdie~ps qbj`f`vp'
Bg ygfi~svbgf`gm ea vd`s `s issigv`bj niobysi xb~s`cegp `s ~eyv`gijp ysif bs vdi
o~`vi~`eg bmb`gsv }d`od vdie~`is ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi b~i oecxb~if' Bs vdisi
vdie~`is b~i itbc`gif* `v sdeyjf ni kixv `g c`gf vdbv xb~s`cegp `s b ~yji np }d`od
iq`figoi `s ve ni iqbjybvif' @v sdeyjf gev ni oegaysif }`vd iq`figoi `vsija'
DEBTI_
Vdi debt itxjbgbv`eg symmisvs vdbv ~ixe~vs ea bj`ig bnfyov`eg b~i gev degisv
fiso~`xv`egs ea itxi~`igois* nyv b~i sve~`is cbfi yx ve fij`ni~bvijp fioi`qi' @v `s
migi~bjjp bssycif vdbv vdi cev`qbv`eg ae~ syod fioixv`eg j`is `g vdi exxe~vyg`vp ae~
cegivb~p e~ xspodeseo`bj ~i}b~f baae~fif np syod sve~`is' Vdisi exxe~vyg`v`is oi~#
vb`gjp it`sv' Neeks ~ioeygv`gm bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois b~i }`fijp sejf* bgf vdi~i `s
bg bov`qi jiovy~i o`~oy`v ae~ `gf`q`fybjs }de ~ixe~v syod itxi~`igois' Ce~ieqi~*
syxxe~v m~eyxs ae~ bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s* vbjk sde}s* bgf oegai~igois x~eq`fi
exxe~vyg`v`is ae~ seo`bj `gvi~bov`eg bgf oijin~`vp vdbv }eyjf gev evdi~}`si ni bqb`j#
bnji ve vdi itxi~`igoi~'De}iqi~* ve vbki bfqbgvbmi ea syod exxe~vyg`v`is* vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~ cysv
me xynj`o }`vd vdi itxi~`igoi' @g vdi qbsv cble~`vp ea obsis vdi~i `s s`cxjp gevd`gm
`g vdi ~ixe~vi~s nidbq`e~ vdbv }eyjf symmisv syod bg gvigv`eg' Bnfyov`eg itxi~`ig#
oi~s sii cigvbj dibjvd x~eaiss`egbjs ae~ dijx `g oex`gm }`vd vdi itxi~`igoi* e~ vdip
sii bnfyov`eg `gqisv`mbve~s ve envb`g e~ sdb~i `gae~cbv`eg bneyv vdi itxi~`igoi'
Nyv nipegf vd`s j`c`vif oegvbov* vdi itxi~`igoi~ }de meis xynj`o `s b ~b~`vp $iqig `a
nbsif eg vdi c`g`cbj gycni~ ea kge}g obsis* syod bs Nyjjb~fs [2006S fbvbnbsi ea
2*=88 obsis; nbsif eg vdi gycni~ ea isv`cbvif obsis* syod bs Dexk`gs iv bj' [200>S*
vdi x~exe~v`eg ea itxi~`igoi~s }de dbqi megi xynj`o `s iqig ce~i ea b ~b~`vp'Cyod ce~i oeccegjp* vdi itxi~`igoi~ fis`~is bssy~bgoi ea bgegpc`vp'
Eg vdi evdi~ dbgf* fij`ni~bvi c`s~ix~isigvbv`eg obg eooy~ `g vdi bnsigoi ea ge~#
cbj `goigv`qis ae~ fioixv`eg' Booe~f`gm ve vdi F`bmgesv`o bgf _vbv`sv`obj Cbgybj
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
3/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI ?2
ea Cigvbj F`se~fi~s< F_C @Q$Bci~`obg Xspod`bv~`o Bsseo`bv`eg* 2006*abov`v`eys
f`se~fi~ ~iai~s ve `gf`q`fybjs }de ai`mg xdps`obj e~ xspodejem`obj `jjgiss }di~i
vdi cev`qbv`eg ae~ vdi nidbq`e~ `s ve bssyci vdi s`ok ~eji $x' 6=6' Vdbv `s* vdi
xspodejem`obj giif ve ni b xbv`igv `s `vsija spcxvecbv`o ea b f`se~fi~' ]di~ixspodejem`obj spcxvecs x~ifec`gbvi* vdi `gf`q`fybj cbp ojb`c ' ' ' cice~p jess
' ' ' dbjjyo`gbv`egs ' ' ' bgf f`sseo`bv`qi spcxvecs' Vdisi `gf`q`fybjs cbp ni it#
v~icijp symmisv`nji bgf cbp igfe~si cbgp ea vdi spcxvecs n~eymdv yx fy~`gm b
~iq`i} ea spcxvecs $x' 6=>'
Fisx`vi seci xb~bjjijs }`vd bnfyov`eg booeygvs* vdi~i b~i b gycni~ ea odb~bovi~#
`sv`os ea abov`v`eys f`se~fi~ vdbv cbki `v bg ygj`kijp sey~oi ea bnfyov`eg debtis'
_yaai~i~s b~i j`kijp ve dbqi bg itvigs`qi d`sve~p ea desx`vbj`|bv`egs e~ v~ibvcigv
`gvi~qigv`egs* ni itv~icijp ~is`svbgv ve m`q`gm yx vdi ~eji bs xbv`igv* bgf b~i ~ijyo#
vbgv* qbmyi* bgf `goegs`svigv }dig bskif ve x~eq`fi `gae~cbv`eg `g fivb`j' Vdisibgf evdi~ f`aai~igv`bj f`bmgesis b~i gev odb~bovi~`sv`o ea vdi qbsv cble~`vp ea bnfyo#
v`eg itxi~`igoi~s'
@g bgp obsi* ge egi dbs si~`eysjp symmisvif vdbv debtis booeygv ae~ bgp nyv b ai}
ea vdi vdeysbgfs ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi ~ixe~vs' Vdi debt dpxevdis`s dbs niig
bfqbgoif $Kjbss* 2044 ve booeygv ae~ vdi sve~`is ea sxio`a`o bnfyov`eg ojb`cbgvs*
nyv vdi s`goi~`vp $bjni`v gev vdi booy~bop ea cesv bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s `s migi~#
bjjp bokge}jifmif iqig np b~figv skixv`os'
_Y_OIXV@N@J@VP VE _YMMI_V@EG
_ymmisv`eg `s eavig x~exesif bs vdi obysi ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Vd`s dp#
xevdis`s dbs vbkig b gycni~ ea f`aai~igv ae~cs'Dpxgev`|bn`j`vp ~iai~s ve b vbjigv ae~
booixv`gm symmisv`egs eaai~if fy~`gm dpxges`s' Abgvbsp x~egigiss ~iai~s ve b xi~#
segbj`vp v~b`v odb~bovi~`|if np b x~if`sxes`v`eg ve igmbmi `g oecxijj`gm* `cbm`gb#
v`qi itxi~`igoi' Vdi abjsi#cice~p spgf~eci ~iai~s ve vdi `gajyigoi ea symmisv`eg
fy~`gm vdi oey~si ea vdi~bxp' Oigv~bj ve ibod ea vdisi oegsv~yovs `s vdi gev`eg vdbv
`cbm`gif iqigvs obg ni itxi~`igoif bs d`sve~`obj iqigvs'
$b) Dpxgev`o Cice~p bgf Dpxgev`|bn`j`vp
Dpxges`s gqejqis x~eoify~is fis`mgif ve cbt`c`|i b synliovs bn`j`vp ve ~isxegf
ve symmisv`eg' Dpxgev`o symmisv`egs ve me nbok `g v`ci bgf ~icicni~ e~ ~ij`qi xbsv
iqigvs dbqi niig }`fijp ysif bs b civdef ae~ ~iv~`iq`gm e~ igdbgo`gm cice~p'
Vd`s gev}`vdsvbgf`gm* `g oegv~ejjif itxi~`cigvs dpxgev`objjp igdbgoif cice~p `s
bv nisv egjp cefisvjp ficegsv~bvif' @gsvibf* bg `go~ibsi `g xsiyfecice~`is $bg
iaaiov vdbv isobjbvis }`vd `go~ibsif x~issy~i ve ~iobjj* `go~ibsif oega`figoi `g vdi
qbj`f`vp ea egis xsiyfecice~`is* bgf go~ibsif sysoixv`n`j`vp ve symmisv`eg e~ jibf#
`gm ryisv`egs b~i ce~i migi~bjjp vdi ~yji' $_ii Ab~vd`gm* 200>; _c`vd* 204? ae~vpx`obj ~iq`i}s ea vd`s j`vi~bvy~i'
@g vdie~p* vdi~iae~i* dpxges`s sdeyjf dbqi b m~ibvi~ xevigv`bj ve o~ibvi bnfyov`eg
itxi~`igois vdbg ve ~iv~`iqi vdic' Vd`s `s xb~v`oyjb~jp v~eynjiseci m`qig vdbv cbgp
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
4/50
?> LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
ce~i bnfyov`eg ~ixe~vs dbqi ici~mif `g vdi oey~si ea dpxges`s vdbg vd~eymd sxeg#
vbgieys ~iobjj $Nyjjb~f* 204=* 2006' Bs syod* `v `s gev sy~x~`s`gm vdbv o~`v`os ea vdi
bnfyov`eg xdigecigeg o`vi vdi so`igv`a`o j`vi~bvy~i eg dpxges`s bs m~eygfs ae~ f`s#
c`ss`gm dpxgev`objjp ~iv~`iqif booeygvs ea bj`ig bnfyov`eg $i'm'* Nbki~* 2008* 200>;Kjbss* 2044' Bg iqbjybv`eg ea vd`s b~mycigv aejje}s'
Bxxj`obn`j`vp ea dpxges`s ~isib~od ve vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' @a dpxgev`o
cice~p `g migi~bj `s sysxiov* vdig dpxgev`objjp ~iv~`iqif cice~p ea bnfyov`egs
cysv ni sysxiov bs }ijj' De}iqi~* vd`s bssycxv`eg fixigfs eg vdi itvigv ve }d`od
vdi itxi~`cigvbj s`vybv`eg `s oecxb~bnji ve vdbv bsseo`bvif }`vd vdi bnfyov`eg it#
xi~`igoi $Bxxijji* 2006b'
_vyf`is vdbv b~i ysif ve migi~bj`|i ve vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi sdeyjf `gqejqi
sey~oi $~iv~`iqbj cbvi~`bjs vdbv b~i j`ki vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi `g rybj`vp' Bn#
fyov`eg cice~`is b~i odb~bovi~`|if np fpgbc`o* icev`egbjjp odb~mif iqigvs vdbv`gsv`jj v~bycb* aib~* bgt`ivp* oegays`eg* bgf bgmi~' Ce~ieqi~* vdip b~i odb~bovi~`|if
np iqigvs se ygysybj bs ve ni eyvs`fi vdi ~bgmi ea ge~cbj dycbg itxi~`igoi'
@g oegv~bsv* vdi nyjk ea jbne~bve~p ~isib~od dbs ysif svbv`o bgf giyv~bj sey~oi
cbvi~`bj syod bs cice~`|if j`svs ea }e~fs' _eci svyf`is dbqi ysif ce~i ~ijiqbgv
cbvi~`bjs ae~ ~iv~`iqbj syod bs sv~iss#`gfyo`gm sv`cyj` $FiX`bge ! _bj|ni~m* 2042;
\ij`m ! Ni`fjicbg* 2042* e~ s`cyjbv`egs ea icev`egbjjp odb~mif iqigvs j`ki boo`#
figvs e~ o~`cis $N~`mdbc* Cbbss* _gpfi~* ! _xbyjf`gm* 204>; Cbjxbss ! Fiq`gi*
2048; _bgfi~s ! ]b~g`ok* 2042' Vdi ~isyjvs ea vdisi svyf`is b~i igv`~ijp oegs`s#
vigv }`vd vdesi ys`gm ce~i cygfbgi cbvi~`bjs' De}iqi~* vdip sv`jj ab`j ve ~ix~efyoivdi sv~bgmigiss ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois* e~ vdi ~bgmi bgf cbmg`vyfi ea ice#
v`egbj svbvis bsseo`bvif }`vd ~ixe~vif bnfyov`egs'
Ce~ieqi~* vdi iaa`obop ea dpxges`s g igdbgo`gm ~iobjj sdeyjf ni ~ijbvif gev egjp
ve vdi k`gf ea cbvi~`bj ve ni ~iv~`iqif* nyv bjse ve vdi obysi ea ae~mivv`gm $fiobp*
`gvi~ai~igoi* ~ix~iss`eg* xspodejem`obj v~bycb* xdps`obj v~bycb* ivo'' _y~x~`s`gmjp*
vdi~i it`svs q`~vybjjp ge ~isib~od eg vd`s ssyi' Ae~ itbcxji* vdi~i b~i ge spsvicbv`o
`gqisv`mbv`egs ea vdi booy~bop e~ iaa`obop ea dpxgev`o ~iobjj `g v~bycb#`gfyoif bc#
gis`b' Vd`s `s ygae~vygbvi* niobysi bgiofevbj ~ixe~vs bgf obsi svyf`is ~imb~f`gm
~iobjj ea v~bycbv`o iqigvs bneygf `g nevd vdi ae~igs`o bgf oj`g`obj j`vi~bvy~i* bgfx~eq`fi cyod ea vdi nbs`s ae~ vdi nij`ia `g dpxgev`o dpxi~cgis`b'
Ea oey~si* }i fe gev kge} `a vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi aejje}s v~bycb#`gfyoif
bcgis`b' A`~sv* vd`s x~isyxxesis bovybj ae~mivv`gm ea seci ~ibj iqigv $bs exxesif ve
bg dpxgev`objjp o~ibvif xsiyfecice~p' _ioegf* `v x~isyxxesis itxi~`igoif v~bycb
$i`vdi~ ve bg bovybj bnfyov`eg e~ ve seci evdi~ iqigv ae~ }d`od vdi ~iobjjif bnfyo#
v`eg `s b so~iig cice~p' Vd`~f* bs }`jj ni f`soyssif jbvi~* vdi qi~p oegoixvs ea
~ix~iss`eg bgf f`sseo`bv`qi bcgis`b b~i oegv~eqi~s`bj $Jeavys* 200?; Easdi ! _`gmi~*
2006'
Vdi~i `s bg bff`v`egbj x~enjic `g ~imb~f ve dpxges`s bgf vdi ciodbg`scs eaae~mivv`gm' ^ibj bj`ig bnfyov`egs c`mdv ni ae~mevvig niobysi ea piv yg`figv`a`if
x~eoissis $bs symmisvif np vdi gyci~eys ~ixe~vs np bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s ea bj`ig
c`gf oegv~ej' Vdi bxxj`obn`j`vp ea dpxges`s ~isib~od ve ygkge}g ciodbg`scs obg#
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
5/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI ??
gev* ea oey~si* ni iqbjybvif'
Migi~bj dpxgev`|bn`j`vp' Ve }dbviqi~ itvigv dpxges`s cbp obysi abjsi itxi~`#
igois ea bj`ig bnfyov`eg* vs xevigv`bj ve fe se sdeyjf go~ibsi bs b synliovs sysoix#
v`n`j`vp ve dpxgev`o symmisv`eg `go~ibsis'^efimd`i~* Meefxbsvi~* bgf Njbvvi~nbyi~ $2002 bssissif dpxgev`o ~isxegs`qi#
giss g b m~eyx ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s }`vd vdi O~ibv`qi @cbm`gbv`eg _obji $]`j#
seg ! Nb~ni~* 20=4' Vd`s `gsv~ycigv iqbjybvis synliovs bn`j`vp ve q`q`fjp `cbm`gi
symmisvif soigis bgf s`vybv`egs' Vdi byvde~s aeygf vdbv* bs b m~eyx* bnfyov`eg it#
xi~`igoi~s }i~i ge ce~i sysoixv`nji ve dpxgev`o symmisv`eg vdbg vdi migi~bj xexy#
jbv`eg'
_xbges* O~ess* F`okseg* bgf Fyn~iy`j $200? ysif vdi Ob~jiveg Yg`qi~s`vp ^i#
sxegs`qigiss ve _ymmisv`eg _obji $_xbges* ^bfvki* Defm`gs* _vbc* ! Ni~v~bgf*
204? ve cibsy~i dpxgev`|bn`j`vp' Vd`s visv cibsy~is vd~ii f`cigs`egs ea dpxgev`|#bn`j`vp< gycni~ ea `vics ve }d`od bg bxx~ex~`bvi ~isxegsi `s cbfi* itvigv ve }d`od
vdi synliov`qi iaaiovs objjif ae~ b~i itxi~`igoif* bgf vdi fim~ii ve }d`od synliovs
~isxegsis b~i xi~oi`qif bs `gqejygvb~p' Vdi ~isib~odi~s aeygf vdbv vdi`~ itxi~`igoi~
xexyjbv`eg }bs ge f`aai~igv a~ec vdi oegv~ejs eg bgp ea vdisi cibsy~is'
_xio`a`o dpxgev`|bn`j`vp' @g b ~ioigv sy~qip ea `gqisv`mbve~s bgf cigvbj dibjvd
x~bov`v`egi~s* Nyjjb~f $2006 aeygf vdbv g`gi eyv ea vig ~isxegfigvs svbvif vdbv
cbgp e~ cesv ea vdi`~ [bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~S synliovs b~i ibsp ve dpxgev`|i $x'
9=9' Nyjjb~fs `gvi~x~ivbv`eg `s vdbv d`s sy~qip sbcxji ea bnfyoviis bxxib~s isxi#
o`bjjp ~`od `g xiexji ea d`md sysoixv`n`j`vp ve dpxges`s $x' 9=9'Bs gevif bneqi* de}iqi~* vd`s xes`v`eg s gev syxxe~vif np ae~cbj visvs ea dpxge#
v`|bn`j`vp' Vdisi synliovs cbp ni d`mdjp dpxgev`|bnji `g siss`egs fif`obvif ve it#
xje~`gm vdi`~ bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois* nyv vdip b~i gev d`mdjp dpxgev`|bnjixi~ si'
Vd`s cbp gev ni bs xb~bfet`obj bs `v siics' E~gi* ]d`videysi* E~gi* ! F`gmis
$2001 dbqi b~myif vdbv vdi oecn`gif iaaiovs ea ~ijbtbv`eg* vdi~bx`sv#dpxgev`sv qbj`#
fbv`eg* bgf ~ixiv`v`qi x~en`gm o~ibvi b s`vybv`eg `g }d`od `gf`q`fybjs obg ni oeg#
s`fi~bnjp ce~i baaiovif np dpxgev`o x~eoify~is vdbg vdi`~ nidbq`e~bjjp bgode~if
~bv`gms ea dpxgev`obj bn`j`vp }eyjf symmisv $x' 2=8'
Bjvi~gbv`qijp* vdi f`so~ixbgop niv}iig dpxges`s soe~is bgf vdi ibsi `g sej`o`v`gmbnfyov`eg booeygvs cbp cibg vdbv secivd`gm bneyv vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi `vsija
cbkis `v xb~v`oyjb~jp sysoixv`nji ve dpxgev`o x~eoify~is' @g abov* ~isib~od dbs `fig#
v`a`if siqi~bj above~s vdbv cbp oegv~`nyvi ve vd`s s`vybv`eg'
A`~sv* dpxgev`o ~iobjj `cx~eqis }dig vdi cbvi~`bj ve ni ~icicni~if `s cibg`gm#
ayj ve vdi `gf`q`fybj $_d`ijfs ! Kget* 2041* }dig vdi icev`egbj* xdps`obj* bgf
oemg`v`qi oegf`v`egs ea vdi e~`m`gbj itxi~`igoi b~i dpxgev`objjp ~i`gsvbvif $Bgfi~#
seg* 2008* bgf bs oegvitv ae~ vdi iqigv `s ce~i d`mdjp `gvim~bvif }`vd vdi cice~p
ve ni ~iv~`iqif $I`od* 2049' Vdisi oegf`v`egs b~i oecceg ve dpxgev`o ~im~iss`eg
ae~ vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi'_ioegf* ~isib~od eg svbvi#fixigfigv jib~g`gm symmisvs vdbv ~ivy~g`gm ve vdi svbvi
ea oegso`eysgiss `g }d`od bg itxi~`igoi e~`m`gbjjp eooy~~if cbp `cx~eqi ~iobjj'
Ae~ itbcxji* ~ivy~g`gm ve b svbvi ea bjoedej $Meef}`g* Xe}ijj* N~icci~* De`gi* !
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
6/50
?6 LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
_vi~g* 2010 e~ cb~`lybgb $I`od* ]i`gmb~vgi~* _v`jjcbg* ! M`jj`g* 20=9 `gvet`ob#
v`eg* e~ vdi `gajyigoi ea sv`cyjbgvs $_}bgseg ! K`gsney~gi* 20=1 `cx~eqis ~iobjj
ea iqigvs vdbv e~`m`gbjjp eooy~~if fy~`gm vdesi oegf`v`egs' @a dpxges`s x~efyois b
cigvbj svbvi vdbv `g bgp }bp ~isicnjis vdi svbvi fy~`gm }d`od bg bnfyov`eg `s e~`m`#gbjjp itxi~`igoif* ~iobjj ae~ vdbv itxi~`igoi oeyjf ni igdbgoif' _eci bnfyov`eg
itxi~`igoi~s dbqi fiso~`nif b cigvbj svbvi ae~ vdi ~icicni~if iqigv $i'm'* ]inn*
2006 vdbv `s gev ygj`ki vdbv ~ixe~vif np evdi~ synliovs ae~ vdi itxi~`igoi ea ni`gm
dpxgev`|if'
A`gbjjp* vdi j`vi~bvy~i eg dpxges`s dbs x~eq`fif seci iq`figoi vdbv `gae~cbv`eg gev
x~iq`eysjp bqb`jbnji ve oegso`eysgiss obg ni ~iv~`iqif dpxgev`objjp' Ae~ itbcxji*
dpxgev`o ~iobjj dbs niig ~ixe~vif ae~ sv`cyj` x~isigvif synj`c`gbjjp $Kyg|igfe~a*
Jboey~si* ! Jpgod* 204=) e~ fy~`gm migi~bj bgisvdis`b $Odiik* 2090* 2016; Jiq`gseg*
2019)' Bjvdeymd vd`s ~isib~od `s `vsija oegv~eqi~s`bj* `v `cxj`is vdbv `gae~cbv`eg ~im`s#vi~if eyvs`fi ea ge~cbj oegso`eys b}b~igiss cbp ni booissif fy~`gm dpxges`s'
Bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s eavig fiso~`ni kge}jifmi bxxb~igvjp bory`~if `g vd`s }bp'
Vdisi oegs`fi~bv`egs symmisv b nbs`s ae~ vdi sxio`a`o dpxgev`|bn`j`vp envb`gif ae~
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois' Vd`s sdeyjf gev* de}iqi~* ni oegaysif }`vd bg b~mycigv ae~
vdi qi~`f`obj`vp ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois' Vdi above~s f`soyssif oi~vb`gjp bxxjp ve
~ibj iqigvs* nyv vdip oeyjf bjse bxxjp ve itxi~`igois e~`m`gbv`gm `g vdi `cbm`gbv`eg
e~ ygoegso`eys' Vd`s xess`n`j`vp cysv ~icb`g bv vdi svbvys ea oegliovy~i* de}iqi~*
niobysi vdi~i obg ni ge f`~iov iq`figoi vdbv b oegso`eys itxi~`igoi dbf di~iveae~i
~is`fif `g vdi ygoegso`eys'Giqi~vdijiss* v cbp ni ysiayj ve oegs`fi~ vd`s xess`n`j`vp g ~imb~f ve evdi~ bgecb#
jeys itxi~`igois x~exesif ve dbqi `cbm`gbv`qi e~ ygoegso`eys bgvioifigvs' J`ki
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois* xbsv#j`ai `figv`v`is $~i`gob~gbv`egs b~i bjse ibs`jp ij`o`vif
vd~eymd dpxges`s a~ec ge~cbj `gf`q`fybjs $Kbcxcbg* 20=1* b~i ~`od `g fivb`j* bgf
b~i nij`iqif np vdi itxi~`igoi~ bs qi~`f`obj ~iobjj ea bovybj xbsv iqigvs $_xbges* Ny~#
miss* ! Ny~miss* 2006' _xbges iv bj' b~myi vdbv nevd dpxgev`o bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois
bgf xbsv j`qis $bs }ijj bs ij`o`vif cice~`is ea sbvbg`o ~`vybj bnysi bgf cyjv`xji xi~#
segbj`v`is b~i seo`bj o~ibv`egs ' ' ' fivi~c`gif np vdi ygfi~svbgf`gms vdbv synliovs
fiqijex bneyv syod itxi~`igois a~ec vdi `gae~cbv`eg ve }d`od vdip b~i itxesif$x' 6?1' ]divdi~ e~ gev vd`s `gvi~x~ivbv`eg `s oe~~iov* vdi ~eji ea dpxges`s cbp ni
ijyo`fbvif vd~eymd b oegs`fi~bv`eg ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois g ~ijbv`egsd`x ve evdi~
bgecbjeys itxi~`igois ~eyv`gijp booiss`nji ve vdi dpxgev`|if synliov'
_`cyjbv`egs ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Jb}seg $20== bskif dpxgev`|if syn#
liovs ve fiso~`ni iqigvs bsseo`bvif }`vd b symmisvif ojesi igoeygvi~ }`vd b YAE' Di
ojb`cif oegs`fi~bnji s`c`jb~`vp niv}iig vdisi ~ixe~vs bgf vdesi a~ec ~ibj bnfyo#
v`eg itxi~`igoi~s' Vd`s svyfp dbs niig }`fijp o`vif np skixv`os nyv }`fijp o~`v`o`|if
np yaejem`svs $Nyjjb~f* 2040 ae~ `vs civdefejemp* oegojys`egs* bgf migi~bj`|bn`j`vp'
]dbviqi~ `vs qbj`f`vp* `v ~icb`gs vdi egjp f`~iov visv ea vdi ~eji ea dpxges`s `g vdibnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi'6
Jpgg bgf oejjibmyis fiso~`ni b ~ijbvif itxi~`cigv $Jpgg ! Xi||e* 2006; Jpgg !
K`~sod* 2001' Visv`gm vdi x~ic`si vdbv s`c`jb~`v`is aeygf bo~ess bnfyov`eg itxi~`#
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
7/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI ?9
igois obg ni booeygvif ae~ np abc`j`b~`vp }`vd vdisi ijicigvs `g ey~ xexyjb~ oyj#
vy~i* vdip ~ibsegif vdbv igoeygvi~ soigb~`es fij`ni~bvijp bgf oegso`eysjp cbfi yx
np geg#bnfyov`eg#itxi~`igoi~s sdeyjf bxx~et`cbvi vdesi migi~bvif np bovybj bn#
fyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s' Ve visv vd`s* qejygvii~s }i~i bskif ve s`cyjbvi $~eji xjbp vdinidbq`e~ ea bg itoijjigv dpxgev`o synliov bskif ve ~iobjj iqigvs aejje}`gm vdi ensi~#
qbv`eg ea b cpsvi~`eys j`mdv g vdi skp' $Vdi synliovs }i~i gev bovybjjp dpxgev`|if'
J`ki Jb}seg* vdisi itxi~`cigvi~s ~ixe~v oi~vb`g $piv skivodp s`c`jb~`v`is niv}iig
vdi`~ synliovs booeygvs bgf vdesi vpx`objjp aeygf `g vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi j`v#
i~bvy~i'
Eg vdi evdi~ dbgf* ^bgfjis $2006b gevif b gycni~ ea `goegs`svigo`is niv}iig
vdi x~evevpx`obj bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi bgf vdi sve~`is ea v}igvp N~`v`sd synliovs bskif
ve `cbm`gi b ojesi igoeygvi~' Vdisi `goegs`svigo`is `gojyfif ce~i dycbgj`ki ig#
v`v`is* bjcesv ge ~ixe~vs ea fee~}bp bcgis`b $ab`jy~i ve ~iobjj iqigvs bsseo`bvif}`vd igv~p `gve vdi bnfyove~s o~bav* gev b s`gmji cif`obj itbc`gbv`eg* bgf j`vvji
~isicnjbgoi ea bxxb~igv bj`ig cev`qis ve vdesi `gf`obvif `g vdi ~ixe~vs np bovybj
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s'
Bjvdeymd vdisi ~isyjvs siic oegv~bf`ove~p ve vdesi ea Jb}seg bgf Jpgg bgf Xi||e*
`v `s `gvi~isv`gm ve gevi vdbv oecxb~if ve vdi svi~ievpx`obj Bci~`obg bnfyov`eg soi#
gb~`e* N~`v`sd bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s ~ixe~v dycbgj`ki igv`v`is bneyv aey~ v`cis
ce~i eavig* bgf cif`obj itbc`gbv`egs bneyv "%? bs eavig $^bgfjis* 2006n' Vdi~i#
ae~i* vdi ~isyjvs }`vd N~`v`sd synliovs }de b~i bskif ve cbki yx b ojesi igoeygvi~
b~i ce~i oegs`svigv }`vd vdi vpx`obj N~`v`sd bnfyov`eg ~ixe~v vdbg c`mdv evdi~}`sini bxxb~igv'
Ibod ea vdisi svyf`is oeyjf nigia`v a~ec v`mdvi~ civdefejemp bgf ojesi~ itbc`#
gbv`eg ea vdi oegvigv bgf a~iryigop ea vdi migi~bvif ~ixe~vs' @g vdi cibgv`ci*
de}iqi~* vdip symmisv vdbv ijicigvs ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi b~i aeygf `g vdi
`cbm`gbv`egs ea vdi gegitxi~`igoi~ xexyjbv`eg* bgf vdbv oegs`svigop `g bnfyov`eg
booeygvs `s nioec`gm ce~i f`aa`oyjv ve lysv`ap bs iq`figoi ea qi~`f`obj`vp'
@gajyigoi ea dpxges`s bgf dpxgev`svs' Bnfyov`eg gb~~bv`qis obg ni oecxb~if ve
fivi~c`gi `a vdip qb~p booe~f`gm ve vdi xb~v`oyjb~ vdie~iv`obj `goj`gbv`egs ea vdi
`gqisv`mbve~ e~ vdi~bx`sv ij`o`v`gm vdi booeygv' Bjse* booeygvs }d`od ici~mi fy~`gmdpxges`s obg ni oecxb~if }`vd vdesi svicc`gm a~ec oegso`eys itxi~`igoi' _yod
bgbjpsis dbqi niig ob~~`if eyv np Nyjjb~f $2040* 2006' Eg vdi nbs`s ea d`s a`gf#
`gms* Nyjjb~f $2040 oegojyfif vdbv vdi ae~c bgf oegvigv ea bnfyov`eg sve~`is
siics gfixigfigv ea dpxges`s $x' ?' @g b ce~i ~ioigv itbc`gbv`eg* Nyjjb~f $2006
oegojyfis vdbv dpxges`s `s b s`mg`a`obgv above~ `g ~imb~f ve vdi rybgv`vp ea cbvi~`bj
~ioeqi~if* nyv gev `g bgp f`~iov }bp ve vdi oegvigv'
$n) Abgvbsp X~egigiss
Vdi oegoixv eaabgvbsp x~egigiss fiqijexif eyv ea b j`gi ea ~isib~od fis`mgif vea`gf xi~segbj`vp v~b`vs vdbv oe~~ijbvi }`vd dpxgev`|bn`j`vp' Bcegm d`mdjp dpxgev`|#
bnji synliovs* ]`jseg bgf Nb~ni~ $2042* 204?n `figv`a`if b m~eyx ea `gf`q`fybjs
}de oeyjf dbjjyo`gbvi qejygvb~`jp* dbqi `cbm`gb~p itxi~`igois vdbv b~i synliov`qijp
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
8/50
?1 LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
bs ~ibj bs gegabgvbs`|if iqigvs* bgf }de eoobs`egbjjp dbf f`aa`oyjvp f`sv`gmy`sd`gm
cice~`is ea abgvbs`|if iqigvs a~ec vdesi }d`od bovybjjp dbxxigif' ]`jseg bgf
Nb~ni~ objjif vdisi synliovs abgvbsp x~egi'
Vdie~iv`obj `ssyis' Abgvbsp x~egigiss `s vdie~iv`objjp ~ijiqbgv ve vdi bnfyov`egitxi~`igoi nevd bs b sey~oi ea `cbm`gbv`qi itxi~`igoi* bgf niobysi ea s`c`jb~`v`is
niv}iig vdi itxi~`igois ea abgvbsp#x~egi xi~segs bgf vdesi ea bnfyov`eg it#
xi~`igoi~s' Ae~ itbcxji* vdi abgvbsp x~egi ~ixe~v b d`md `go`figoi ea abjsi x~im#
gbgo`is* xspod`o bgf eyv#ea#nefp itxi~`igois* bxxb~`v`egs* bgf q`q`f sjiix cbmi~p
}d`od aiijs bs `a vdip b~i sii`gm secivd`gm vdbv ~ibjjp it`svs eyv vdi~i e~ vdbv vdip
b~i jeek`gm `gve bgevdi~ f`cigs`eg $]`jseg ! Nb~ni~* 2042* x' ?19' Vdisi itxi#
~`igois dbqi xb~bjjijs }`vd vdesi ~ixe~vif np bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s $Nyjjb~f* 204=*
2006* symmisv`gm vdbv bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s bgf vdi abgvbsp x~egi cbp nijegm ve
vdi sbci xexyjbv`eg'Ce~ieqi~* vdi ij`o`vbv`eg ea `cbm`gbv`qi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois c`mdv ni itboi~#
nbvif `g s`vybv`egs }di~i vdi ici~migoi `s dpxgev`objjp bss`svif' ]`jseg bgf Nb~#
ni~ $2042 aeygf vdbv vdi abgvbsp x~egi ~ix~isigvif 01) ea vdi`~ d`mdjp dpxgev`|bnji
synliovs* bgf fiso~`nif vdi`~ ~isxegsi ve dpxgev`o symmisv`egs bs vdi k`gf ea vd`gm
vdip obg fe `gfixigfigvjp ' ' ' `g vdi`~ fb`jp j`qis $]`jseg bgf Nb~ni~* 204?n* x'
?=='
De}iqi~* synsiryigv ~isib~od dbs sde}g vd`s a`gf`gm ve ni c`sjibf`gm' Bjvdeymd
b ~ijbv`egsd`x niv}iig abgvbsp x~egigiss bgf dpxgev`|bn`j`vp dbs migi~bjjp niig
syxxe~vif* vdi ~ijbv`egsd`x bxxib~s ve ni cyod ce~i cefisv vdbg ]`jseg bgf Nb~#ni~ e~`m`gbjjp ~ixe~vif $Jpgg ! ^dyi* 2044' Ae~ itbcxji* Jpgg* M~iig* ^dyi*
Cb~i* bgf ]`jj bcs $2008 aeygf egjp 2>'4>)21'1) ea vdi`~ d`mdjp dpxgev`|bnji
synliovs $fixigf`gm eg vdi cibsy~i ea dpxgev`|bn`j`vp }i~i abgvbsp x~egi $`g oeg#
v~bsv ve ]`jseg bgf Nb~ni~s 01)' Vd`s f`so~ixbgop `s ~ijbvif ve }divdi~ synliovs
b~i sijiovif eg vdi nbs`s ea vdi`~ dpxgev`|bn`j`vp e~ eg vdi nbs`s ea vdi`~ abgvbsp x~egi#
giss' Abgvbsp#x~egi `gf`q`fybjs b~i j`kijp ve ni d`mdjp dpxgev`|bnji $vdip ob~~p vdi`~
iqi~pfbp vbjigvs `gve vdi dpxges`s s`vybv`eg* nyv d`mdjp dpxgev`|bnji `gf`q`fybjs b~i
gev migi~bjjp abgvbsp x~egi' @g abov* ~ijbv`egsd`xs niv}iig dpxgev`|bn`j`vp bgf bgp
cibsy~i ea `cbm`gbv`qi v~b`vs b~i bovybjjp ry`vi scbjj $K`~sod ! Oeygo`j* 200>'_vyf`is ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s' ^`gm bgf es`gm $2008 oecxb~if b m~eyx ea
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s bgf evdi~s ~ixe~v`gm YAE igoeygvi~s }`vd b m~eyx ea syn#
liovs $oegv~ejs }de itx~issif egjp bg `gvi~isv `g YAEs' Ys`gm b nbvvi~p ea visvs
vdip aeygf vdbv itxi~`igoi~s b~i gev abgvbsp x~egi `g bgp migi~bj sigsi' De}iqi~*
vdi igoeygvi~ synliovs }i~i s`mg`a`obgvjp ce~i j`kijp ve ~ixe~v od`jfdeef itxi~`#
igois ea xspod`o xdigecigb* geg#xdps`obj ni`gms* bgf ve sii gve evdi~ ~ibj`v`is
vdbv evdi~s f`fgv siic ve ni b}b~i ea' Ibod ea vdisi odb~bovi~`sv`os `s oegs`svigv
}`vd abgvbsp#x~egi odb~bovi~`sv`os e~`m`gbjjp ~ixe~vif np ]`jseg bgf Nb~ni~'
Vdi byvde~s `gvi~x~ivif vdi`~ a`gf`gm bs sigs`v`q[`vpS ve geg#e~f`gb~p ~ibj`v`is*nyv bokge}jifmif vdbv vdi ~eji ea syod sigs`v`q`v`isbs obysis* abo`j`vbve~s* e~ ia#
aiovs ea igoeygvi~ itxi~`igoisobggev ni fivi~c`gif a~ec vdi`~ svyfp' Vdip bjse
bokge}jifmif vdbv vdi qbj`f`vp ea vdi bssisscigv cibsy~is vdip ysif dbs niig jb~mijp
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
9/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI ?=
ygvisvif* x~eq`f`gm b ay~vdi~ j`c`vbv`eg eg vdi migi~bj`|bn`j`vp ea vdi`~ a`gf`gms'
@g bgevdi~ svyfp* ^efimd`i~ iv bj' $2002 aeoysif eg synliovs }de civ ojib~jp
fia`gif o~`vi~`b ae~ bg bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Abgvbsp x~egigiss }bs bssissif }`vd
vdi @gqigve~p ea Od`jfdeef Cice~`is bgf @cbm`g`gms $@OC@ $]`jseg ! Nb~ni~*204?b* bg `gsv~ycigv bfbxvif a~ec vdbv ysif np ]`jseg bgf Nb~ni~ $2042 `g vdi`~
sic`gbj svyfp ea vdi abgvbsp x~egi' Vdi byvde~s aeygf ge f`aai~igoi niv}iig @OC@
soe~is ae~ vdi`~ bnfyov`eg#itxi~`igoi~ m~eyx bgf vdbv ~ixe~vif ae~ b ~bgfec sbcxji
ea vdi xexyjbv`eg'
Nb~vdejeci}* Nbsvi~a`ijf* bgf De}b~f $2002 itbc`gif eqi~ egi dygf~if bn#
fyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s bgf oegojyfif vdbv vdi qbsv cble~`vp $4=) dbf d`sve~`is oeg#
s`svigv }`vd egi e~ ce~i ea vdi cble~ spcxvecs aeygf `g vdi abgvbsp#x~egi x~ea`ji'
De}iqi~* vdi byvde~s bssissif abgvbsp x~egigiss np ~iv~esxiov`qi bgbjps`s ea n`e#
m~bxd`obj fbvb ~bvdi~ vdbg bg `gfixigfigv visv ae~ abgvbsp x~egigiss; bgf ea vdi~ixe~vif abgvbsp#x~egi odb~bovi~`sv`os vdi byvde~s itbc`gif* egjp vdi a~iryigop ea
itxi~`igoif xspod`o xdigecigb iqig bxx~ebodis vdbv aeygf np ]`jseg bgf Nb~ni~
$2042 `g vdi`~ abgvbsp#x~egi xexyjbv`eg'
_xbges iv bj' $200? oecxb~if abgvbsp x~egigiss ae~ `gvigsi YAE itxi~`igoi~s
$vdesi ~ixe~v`gm igoeygvi~s }`vd bj`igs* vdesi ~ixe~v`gm egjp ensi~qbv`eg ea f`svbgv
j`mdvs e~ enliovs }d`od vdip `gvi~x~ivif bs YAEs* bgf oegv~ej synliovs ~ixe~v`gm ge
YAE itxi~`igois' Vdi byvde~s aeygf ge svbv`sv`obj f`aai~igoi bo~ess e~ niv}iig
m~eyxs eg abgvbsp x~egigiss bs cibsy~if np vdi @OC@'
Vdip f`f* de}iqi~* a`gf b oe~~ijbv`eg niv}iig @OC@ soe~is bgf bg `gvigs`vp#ea#itxi~`igoi sobji' YAE nij`iqi~s }de }i~i ~ijbv`qijp abgvbsp x~egi vigfif ve ~ixe~v
ce~i ijbne~bvi YAE itxi~`igois' De}iqi~* vd`s ~ijbv`egsd`x cysv ni q`i}if `g
xi~sxiov`qi' Bs vdi byvde~s xe`gv eyv* qi~p ai} synliovs ~ixe~v`gm YAE#~ijbvif it#
xi~`igois bvvb`gif itv~ici soe~is eg vdi @OC@' @g abov* iqig ae~ vdi `gvigsi#
itxi~`igoi~ m~eyx vdi cibg @OC@ soe~i }bs egjp >>'6* b soe~i }d`od `s ~`mdv bv vdi
c`f~bgmi ea vdbv ae~ vdi migi~bj xexyjbv`eg $Jpgg ! ^dyi* 2044' _xbges iv bj'
oegojyfif vdbv vdi`~ a`gf`gms ojib~jp oegv~bf`ov vdi dpxevdisis vdbv YAE ~ixe~vs
iqig `gvigsi YAE ~ixe~vs odb~bovi~`|if np syod siic`gmjp n`|b~~i itxi~`igois bs
c`ss`gm v`ci bgf oeccyg`obv`eg }`vd bj`igseooy~ x~`cb~`jp `g `gf`q`fybjs }deb~i d`mdjp abgvbsp#x~egi $x' 1>0'
Bs b a`gbj oeccigv eg vdi q`bn`j`vp ea vdi abgvbsp#x~egi dpxevdis`s* bg itxi~`#
cigv visv`gm ]`jseg bgf Nb~ni~s e~`m`gbj fiso~`xv`eg ea abgvbsp#x~egi itxi~`igois
bs ni`gm bs ~ibj bs ~ibj s ea ~ijiqbgoi' dyi bgf Jpgg $204= bskif b jb~mi m~eyx
ea abgvbsp#x~egi synliovs ve dbjjyo`gbvi b _vp~eaebc oyx' Bjvdeymd vdisi synliovs
}i~i ry`vi syooissayj bv vd`s vbsk* ai} bso~`nif ~ibj`sv`o x~exi~v`is ve vdi dbjjyo`#
gbvif itxi~`igoi' @a vdi abgvbsp x~egi obg ~ibf`jp f`sv`gmy`sd `cbm`gif sv`cyj`
a~ec ~ibj egis* vdig iqig eg vdie~iv`obj m~eygfs vdi abgvbsp#x~egi itxjbgbv`eg ea
vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi `s s`mg`a`obgvjp oecx~ec`sif'
$o) Abjsi#Cice~p _pgf~eci
Vdi b~mycigv vdbv vdi~bxp ae~ ~ibj e~ `cbm`gif v~bycb cbp jibf ve ~ioejjio#
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
10/50
?4 LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
v`egs ea iqigvs vdbv giqi~ dbxxigif dbs niig vi~cif vdi abjsi#cice~p spgf~eci
$Mejfsvi`g* 200>'
E~`m`gbjjp* vdi abjsi#cice~p spgf~eci }bs fiqijexif ve symmisv bg `bv~emig`o
e~`m`g ae~ booeygvs ea od`jfdeef sitybj bnysi bgf sbvbg`o ~`vybj bnysi' De}iqi~*vdi abjsi#cice~p spgf~eci dbs bjse niig eaai~if $ae~ b j`sv ea ~ix~isigvbv`qi b~#
v`ojis sii Mevj`n* 200? bs bg itxjbgbv`eg ae~ bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois' $@v `s gev yg#
oecceg ae~ bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s ve sii cigvbj dibjvd x~eaiss`egbjs ae~ spcx#
vecs bsseo`bvif }`vd b nij`iqif e~ sysxiovif bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Bjvdeymd vdi
sxegvbgieys ici~migoi fy~`gm vdi~bxp ea b oecxjivijp ygsysxiovif bnfyov`eg it#
xi~`igoi `s bxxb~igvjp ry`vi ~b~i $nbsif eg vdi migi~bj jbok ea ~iai~igois ve syod
obsis `g vdi oj`g`obj j`vi~bvy~i; sii* de}iqi~* Mevj`n* 2001* vdi abjsi#cice~p spg#
f~eci oeyjf ni b above~ `g ig~`od`gm bg it`sv`gm bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi* o~ibv`gm
}deji gi} itxi~`igois nipegf vdesi ae~ }d`od vdi oj`igv `g`v`bjjp x~isigvs* bgf ae~db~fig`gm oegq`ov`eg `g ~imb~f ve vdi qbj`f`vp ea vdi itxi~`igoi'
Mb~~p bgf Jeavys $2006 ~iq`i} ~isib~od ys`gm aey~ f`aai~igv sey~ois ea symmis#
v`eg ve sde} vdbv sysoixv`n`j`vp ve abjsi cice~p `s gev bg itojys`qi x~exi~vp ea
i`vdi~ dpxges`s e~ sxio`bj `cbm`gbv`qi x~exigs`v`is' ^bvdi~* `v ~iajiovs b ~isxegs`qi#
giss ve symmisv`eg vdbv dbs niig bcxjp ficegsv~bvif ae~ vdi migi~bj xexyjbv`eg*
bgf cbp ni eoobs`egif np vdi xb~v`oyjb~ fpgbc`os vdbv obg it`sv `g vdi vdi~bxiyv`o
igq`~egcigv' Vdi`~ ~iq`i} ficegsv~bvis vdi `gajyigoi ea $b jibf`gm ryisv`egs* $n vdi
symmisvif it`svigoi ea `vics e~ iqigvs `g b x~iq`eysjp ensi~qif soigi* $o vdi v~bgsae~#
cbv`eg ea b ~ioejjiov`eg vd~eymd gi} `gae~cbv`eg $`gbooy~bvi ~iv~`iqbj oyis* bgf $fbooixvbgoi ea b oecxjivi cice~p ae~ secivd`gm vdbv giqi~ dbxxigif ve vdi synliov'
Vdi byvde~s oegojyfi vdbv vdisi oegqi~m`gm itxi~`cigvs x~eq`fi oecxijj`gm
iq`figoi vdbv `v `s gev db~f bv bjj ve cbki xiexji v~yjp nij`iqi vdip dbqi siig e~
itxi~`igoif secivd`gm vdip dbqi gev}`vdeyv bgp dpxges`s bv bjj $xx' ?1911'
@gfiif* np ficegsv~bv`gm cice~p o~ibv`eg ae~ s`mg`a`obgv bgf v~bycbv`o s`vybv`egs*
vdisi svyf`is ~iayvi vdi b~mycigv vdbv cice~p bjvi~bv`egs obg eooy~ egjp ae~ v~`q`bj
fivb`js bgf ae~ gegv~bycbv`o iqigvs'
Vdi oegoi~g bneyv vdi~bx`sv `gajyigoi eg vdi nij`ias bgf cice~`is ea oj`igvs `s
syaa`o`igvjp m~ibv vdbv b gycni~ ea x~eaiss`egbj e~mbg`|bv`egs `g vdi cigvbj dibjvda`ijf $Bci~`obg Xspod`bv~`o Bsseo`bv`eg Neb~f ea V~ysviis* 200?; Bci~`obg Xsp#
odejem`obj Bsseo`bv`eg* 2006; Bci~`obg _eo`ivp ea Oj`g`obj Dpxges`s* 2009 dbqi
ae~cbjjp obyv`egif vdi`~ cicni~s bmb`gsv x~bov`ois vdbv c`mdv itboi~nbvi vdi xe#
vigv`bj ae~ abjsi cice~`is' Bg ivd`os oecc`vvii `g yaejemp $Bnfyov`eg _vyfp Oeg#
ai~igoi Ivd`os Oecc`vvii dbs vbkig b s`c`jb~ xes`v`eg }`vd ~imb~f ve `gqisv`mbve~s
bgf cigvbj dibjvd x~eaiss`egbjs }e~k`gm }`vd bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s $Mevj`n*
Bxxijji* ^efimd`i~* ! Ajbcny~`s* 2006' Vdi si~`eysgiss }`vd }d`od vd`s bfceg`#
v`eg dbs niig vbkig np yaejem`svs `s ~iajiovif `g vdi abov vdbv vd`s Ivd`os Oefi dbs
niig igfe~sif np vdi vd~ii cble~ yaejem`obj e~mbg`|bv`egs $Oigvi~ ae~ YAE _vyf`is*Aygf ae~ YAE ^isib~od* Cyvybj YAE Giv}e~k'
@g sx`vi ea syod obyv`egs* vdi~i sv`jj it`sv b gycni~ ea cigvbj dibjvd x~bov`v`egi~s
}de oegv`gyi ve ysi bmm~iss`qi viodg`ryis $i'm'* a~iryigv dpxges`s siss`egs* syx#
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
11/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI ?0
xe~v bgf f`soyss`eg m~eyxs ve itxje~i ae~ bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois* bgf ve x~eq`fi $`g
vdi bnsigoi ea `gfixigfigv oe~~ene~bv`gm iq`figoi qbj`fbv`eg ea vdi itxi~`igoi bs
`gf`obv`qi ea bg bovybj bj`ig bnfyov`eg' Vdisi x~bov`ois b~i eavig ~bv`egbj`|if `g
vi~cs ea vdi icev`egbj s`goi~`vp ea vdi oj`igv* e~ vdi bxxb~igv `cx~eqicigv `g x~i#sigv`gm spcxvecs vdbv eooy~s fy~`gm vdi oey~si ea v~ibvcigv' De}iqi~* bs egi vdi~b#
x`sv $Gbsd* 2006 gevif g ~iq`i}`gm vdi j`vi~bvy~i eg ~ioeqi~if cice~p bgf v~bycb LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
$o) Vdi Xspod`objjp _igs`v`qi Xi~segbj`vp
Bjvdeymd itxi~`igoi~s eavig ~imb~f vdicsijqis bs dbq`gm `go~ibsif xspod`o bn`j`#
v`is bs bg bavi~iaaiov ea bg bnfyov`eg $Nyjjb~f* 2006; ^`gm* 200>* cbgp ~ixe~v jegm
d`sve~`is ea esvigs`njp xb~bge~cbj iqigvs x~ioif`gm vdi`~ bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois
$Nbsvi~a`ijf* 2006; Nyjjb~f* 204=; ^bgfjis* 2044; ^`gm* 200>' Eg siqi~bj cib#
sy~is* bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s sdb~i xi~segbj`vp odb~bovi~`sv`os }`vd gegitxi~`igoi~s
}de oegs`fi~ vdicsijqis ve ni xspod`objjp sigs`v`qi' Ae~ itbcxji* ^`gm $2008
aeygf b oegsvijjbv`eg ea v~b`vs g oecceg niv}iig bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s bgf gf`#
q`fybjs }de ojb`c ve ni ijiov~`objjp sigs`v`qi $ve dbqi bgecbjeys iaaiovs eg ijio#
v~`obj fiq`ois' Nbsif eg b oecxb~`seg ea vdi xi~segbj`vp odb~bovi~`sv`os ea v}igvp
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s bgf vdesi ea d`mdjp syooissayj I_X synliovs* Ledgseg $2006
aeygf vdbv bv jibsv seci itxi~`igoi~s sdb~i v~b`vs }`vd synliovs }de dbqi xi~ae~cif
}ijj `g ~icevi q`i}`gm itxi~`cigvs'
B gycni~ ea `gqisv`mbve~s dbqi oegs`fi~if vdisi xspod`o x~exigs`v`is bs b xes#
s`nji obysi ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' `gm $200> symmisvs b oeggiov`eg niv}iig
xspod`objjp sigs`v`qi xi~segbj`vp v~b`vs bgf d`s cefij ea vdi igoeygvi~#x~egi xi~#
segbj`vp' ^bgfjis $2044 dbs fiso~`nif vdi xspod`o d`sve~`is ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`#
igoi~s bs vdi kip ve vdi igv`~i [bnfyov`egS cpsvi~p'
De}iqi~* gi`vdi~ vdi itxi~`igoi~s xi~segbj`vp v~b`vs* vdi d`md `go`figoi ea ~i#
xe~v`gm bxxb~igvjp xb~bge~cbj xdigecigb* ge~ gvi~x~ivbv`egs ea vdi`~ itxi~`igois*
b~i enliov`qi iq`figoi ea i`vdi~ xb~bge~cbj bov`q`vp e~ bg itxi~`igoi~s xspod`o
bn`j`vp' Gegi ea vdi svyf`is ~ixe~v`gm vdi xspod`o d`sve~`is ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`ig#
oi~s dbqi f`~iovjp visvif vd`s* bgf `gqisv`mbve~s obggev irybvi itxi~`igoi~s bgio#
fevbj ~ixe~vs }`vd iq`figoi ea vdi xb~bge~cbj' Vdi fbvb vijj ys egjp vdbv `gf`q`fybjs
}de ~ixe~v bnfyov`egs vigf ve ~ixe~v xb~bge~cbj itxi~`igois bs }ijj' Vd`s abov
bjegi `s }e~vdp ea ay~vdi~ so~yv`gp* isxio`bjjp `g j`mdv ea vdi abov vdbv bnfyov`eg
itxi~`igoi~s vpx`objjp ~ixe~v xspod`o $vijixbvd`o oeccyg`obv`eg }`vd vdi`~ bnfyo#
ve~s $Nyjjb~f* 2006'
_JIIX BGECBJ@I_
Vdi synliov`qi bgf xdps`ejem`obj oegoec`vbgvs ea sjiix b~i eavig symmisvif bs bg
itxjbgbv`eg ae~ vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi $_xbges iv' bj'* 200?; Nbki~* 2009' Vdi
~ibsegs ae~ vd`s b~i gyci~eys' Bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois b~i oeccegjp ~ixe~vif bs
dbq`gm eooy~~if bv nifv`ci e~ fy~`gm vdi oey~si ea sjiix' Vdip b~i a~iryigvjp a`~sv
~icicni~if bs vdi oegvigv ea bg bxxb~igv $bjni`v ygysybj f~ibc* e~ bs evdi~}`si
dbq`gm b f~ibcj`ki* synliov`qi rybj`vp' Bgf vdip b~i booecxbg`if np vdi itxi~`#
igoi ea xb~bjps`s* bgevdi~ oegf`v`eg bsseo`bvif }`vd sjiix'=
_jiix xb~bjps`s `s odb~bovi~`|if np bg `gbn`j`vp ve ceqi $itoixv ae~ vdi ipis*
}d`ji siic`gmjp b}bki' @g bff`v`eg ve itxi~`igoi ea vdi xb~bjps`s `vsija* vdi oegf`#v`eg `s eavig booecxbg`if np aiij`gms ea bgt`ivp* aib~* e~ f~ibf' Fy~`gm bg bvvbok ea
sjiix xb~bjps`s* vdi `gf`q`fybj vpx`objjp `s b}b~i ea d`s e~ di~ sy~~eygf`gms* nyv eg
evdi~ eoobs`egs vdi svbvi ea oegso`eysgiss s jiss jyo`f e~ s booecxbg`if np dpxgb#
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
15/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI 6?
mem`o%dpxgexecx`o dbjjyo`gbv`egs' $Vdi ae~ci~ vi~c ~iai~s ve itxi~`igois }d`od
eooy~ fy~`gm vdi v~bgs`v`eg a~ec }bk`gm ve sjiix`gm; vdi jbvvi~ fy~`gm vdi v~bgs`v`eg
a~ec sjiix`gm ve }bk`gm'
Nevd sjiix xb~bjps`s bgf dpxgbmem`o%dpxgexecx`o dbjjyo`gbv`egs eooy~ `g ge~#cbj xiexji $Aykbfb* 2006; evd* 20=4* nyv vdip cbp bjse ni spcxvecbv`o $`g seci
obsis vdi egjp eqi~v spcxvec; ^evd* 20=4 ea b sjiix f`se~fi~ objjif gb~oejixsp' B
gb~oejixv`o bvvbok obg eooy~ fy~`gm ge~cbj fbpv`ci bov`q`v`is e~ iqig }d`ji f~`q#
`gm' Fy~`gm b gb~oejixv`o bvvbok b xi~seg cbp oegv`gyi nidbq`e~ bsseo`bvif }`vd
}bkiayj oegso`eysgiss nyv jbvi~ dbqi ge cice~p ae~ }dbv di f`f' Vdi ix`sefis obg
jbsv dey~s $Cee~o~eav* 2040* x' >1>' Vd`s bsxiov ea gb~oejixsp `s ~ic`g`soigv ea
c`ss`gm v`ci `g bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois'
$b) Oeccegbjv`is Niv}iig _jiix Bgecbj`is bgf Bnfyov`eg Itxi~`igois
@g bff`v`eg ve vdi d`md x~iqbjigoi ea g`mdvv`ci eooy~~igoi* vdi ygbooeygvif#ae~
xbssbmis ea v`ci* bgf vdi itxi~`igoi ea xb~bjps`s* nevd bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois bgf
sjiix bgecbj`is cbp ni ~ixe~vif vd~eymdeyv vdi j`aisxbg $bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois
dbqi niig ~ixe~vif np peygm od`jf~ig* bfejisoigvs* bfyjvs* bgf vdi ijfi~jp; vdi spcx#
vecs ea sjiix f`se~fi~s cbp xi~s`sv bo~ess vdi j`aisxbg* bgf nevd cbp dbqi b mi#
giv`o e~ abc`j`bj d`sve~p $bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois eavig eooy~ }`vd`g abc`j`is bgf
bo~ess migi~bv`egs; b s`c`jb~ ~ijbv`egsd`x it`svs ae~ q`ov`cs ea sjiix f`se~fi~s [Degfb*
Bsbkb* Vbg`cy~b* ! Ay~ysde* 204?S'
$n) Oegvigv ea Bnfyov`eg Itxi~`igois bgf _jiix Bgecbj`is
Vdi oegvigv ea sjiix bgf bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois dbs bjse niig oecxb~if' Nbki~
$2008 odb~bovi~`|is vdi oegvigv ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois bs b ojbss`o* vitvneek
fiso~`xv`eg ea dpxgbmem`o dbjjyo`gbv`eg $x' >92' Ae~ Nbki~* vd`s vitvneek fi#
so~`xv`eg `gojyfis mdesvs* bj`igs* cegsvi~s* ivo'* bgf ae~ }d`od vdi dbjjyo`gbve~
`s ygbjvi~bnjp oegq`goif ea vdi ~ibj`vp ea vdi igv`~i itxi~`igoi $x' >98' De}iqi~*
itoixv g obsis ea gb~oejixsp $}di~i vdi sjiixi~ meis a~ec }bkiayjgiss f`~iovjp gve
^IC sjiixvdi svbmi ea sjiix cesv ojesijp bsseo`bvif }`vd f~ibc`gm* cesv dpx#
gbmem`o bgf dpxgexecx`o itxi~`igois gqejqi svbv`o cbmis e~ soigis $sii _odbovi~*20=1* ae~ b ~iq`i}' Bgf iqig ae~ vdi dbjjyo`gbve~p itxi~`igois `g gb~oejixsp* `g
vdi cble~`vp ea obsis* vdi [dbjjyo`gbve~sS b~i b}b~i ea vdi yg~ibj`vp ea vdi`~ xi~oix#
v`egs $^evd* 20=4* x' ?6'
Ce~ieqi~* vdi~i `s ge iq`figoi vdbv dpxgbmem`o dbjjyo`gbv`eg odb~bovi~`sv`objjp
`gojyfis bj`igs' Eg vdi evdi~ dbgf* bxxb~`v`egbj itxi~`igois xi~ si b~i gev ygoec#
ceg' Dyaae~f $204> itbc`gif syod itxi~`igois bo~ess b }`fi ~bgmi ea oyjvy~is' Di
objjs vdisi itxi~`igois vdi Ejf Dbm xdigecigeg $`g ~iai~igoi ve vdi migi~`o odb~#
bovi~`sv`os ea vdi itxi~`igoi bs aeygf `g Gi}aeygfjbgf v~bf`v`eg' Vdisi `gojyfi
dib~`gm bgf%e~ sii`gm secivd`gm [i'm'* vdi Ejf Dbm e~ seci evdi~
bxxb~`v`egS oeci gve vdi ~eec bgf bxx~ebod vdi nif; $? ni`gm x~issif
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
16/50
66 LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
eg vdi odisv e~ sv~bgmjif; $6 `gbn`j`vp ve ceqi e~ o~p eyv ygv`j i`vdi~
ni`gm n~eymdv eyv ea vdi svbvi np seciegi ijsi e~ n~ibk`gm vd~eymd vdi
aiij`gm ea xb~bjps`s eg egis e}g' [Dyaae~f* 204>* xx' 2822S
Dyaae~f ryisv`egs }divdi~ vd`s sxio`a`o`vp ea oegvigv bo~ess oyjvy~is obg ni yg#
fi~sveef s`cxjp `g vi~cs ea sjiix xdps`ejemp' @g vd`s oegvitv* di o`vis bg ensi~qb#
v`eg ea Ficigv $b cble~ a`my~i `g sjiix ~isib~od* x' 2=8S
Dyaae~f xe`gvs eyv vdbv }dig vdi sbci x~exes`v`eg s bxxj`if ve b xb~v`oyjb~ k`gf
ea oegvigv ~ixibvif `g vdi itxi~`igois ea cbgp `gfixigfigv synliovs* nevd vdi giif
bgf vdi xevigv`bj cxe~vbgoi ea syod bg booeygv`gm b~i m~ibvjp cyjv`xj`if $x' 2=8'
Ficigvs ensi~qbv`eg }bs `g ~iai~igoi ve f~ibcs `g migi~bj* bgf Dyaae~fs `g ~iai~#
igoi ve vdi Ejf Dbm' Nyv vdi`~ oeccigvs b~i iqig ce~i mi~cbgi ve vdi d`mdjp
sxio`a`o bgf oegs`svigv fivb`js ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi'
$o) Feoycigv`gm b ^ijbv`egsd`x Niv}iig _jiix Bgecbj`is
bgf Bnfyov`eg Itxi~`igois
Fisx`vi vdi bxxibjs ve xb~s`cegp bgf bgbjemp* bs piv vdi~i dbqi niig ge f`~iov
visvs ea b j`gkbmi niv}iig sjiix bgecbj`is bgf bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois' ^efimd`i~
$2006 ~ixe~vs b seci}dbv m~ibvi~ `go`figoi ea dpxgbmem`o `cbmi~p `g b synsiv ea
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s* nyv feis gev x~eq`fi bgp iq`figoi vdbv vdi oegvigv ea vd`s
`cbmi~p iqi~ vbkis vdi ae~c ea bg bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Mevj`n $2001 x~eq`fis b
oj`g`obj obsi svyfp symmisv`gm b ~ijbv`egsd`x niv}iig b sjiix f`se~fi~ bgf bg bnfyo#
v`eg itxi~`igoi* nyv vdi eqi~bjj x~iqbjigoi ea sjiix f`se~fi~s `g vdi bnfyov`eg#
itxi~`igoi~ xexyjbv`eg `s gev kge}g' Ygv`j syod iq`figoi `s bqb`jbnji* vdi sjiix#bgecbj`is itxjbgbv`eg ~icb`gs piv bgevdi~ `gvi~isv`gm nyv ygficegsv~bvif dpxevd#
is`s'
X_PODEXBVDEJEMP
F`se~fi~s vdbv c`mdv booeygv ae~ abjsi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois e~ vdi`~ bsseo`bvif
spcxvecbvejemp `gojyfi xspodes`s $dbjjyo`gbv`egs bgf fijys`egs* aej`i fiyt
$sdb~if xspodev`o spcxvecs n~eymdv bneyv np b ojesi ~ijbv`egsd`x niv}iig vdi xi~#
o`x`igvs* oegqi~s`eg ~ibov`egs $xdps`ejem`obj cbg`aisvbv`egs ea b xspodesecbv`ogbvy~i; ae~ itbcxji* cb~ks* njevodis* bgf f`soeje~bv`egs ea vdi sk`g* f`sseo`bv`qi
f`se~fi~s $bcgis`b* aymyi* bgf evdi~ oegf`v`egs ~isyjv`gm `g v`ci jess bgf f`sve~#
v`eg* f`se~`igvbv`eg* bgf ygbooeygvif#ae~ }bgfi~`gms* cyjv`xji xi~segbj`vp f`se~#
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
17/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI 69
fi~ $}d`od g bff`v`eg ve c`ss`gm v`ci cbp ni odb~bovi~`|if np cissbmis a~ec bgf%
e~ fybj figv`v`is }`vd sxio`a`o evdi~s* bgf Cygodbysig spgf~eci $sija#`gaj`ovif
`gly~p e~ abjsi ojb`cs ea xdps`obj spcxvecbvejemp'
Xspodexbvdejemp obg ni bssissif booe~f`gm ve b cigvbj dibjvd x~bov`v`egi~s oj`g`#obj `cx~iss`eg $nbsif eg `gvbki `gvi~q`i}* oj`g`obj d`sve~p* e~ f`bmges`s bs iqejqif
`g vdi oey~si ea vdi~bxp* e~ eg vdi nbs`s ea svbgfb~f`|if visvs' Nevd bxx~ebodis
dbqi niig ysif `g iqbjybv`gm bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s' ^imb~fjiss ea vdi civdef ea
bssisscigv* `v sdeyjf ni icxdbs`|if vdbv bnge~cbj`vp cysv ni isvbnj`sdif `gfixig#
figv ea bnfyov`eg xdigecigejemp `vsija' Ae~ itbcxji* _odgbnij $2006 fiso~`nis
s`c`jb~`v`is niv}iig vdi xy~xe~vif itxi~`igois ea bg bjjimif bnfyov`eg q`ov`c bgf
vdi spcxvecbvejemp ea f`sseo`bv`qi f`se~fi~s' Eg vdi nbs`s ea vdisi s`c`jb~`v`is vdi
~ibfi~ `s bskif ve bssyci vdbv vdi ~ixe~vif bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois b~i obysif np
f`sseo`bv`qi f`se~fi~s' De}iqi~* niobysi vdi synliov `s giqi~ bovybjjp f`bmgesif bsf`sseo`bv`qi* _odgbnijs b~mycigv `s nbsif gev eg b ae~cbj visv ae~ xbvdejemp* nyv eg
bg bxxibj ve xb~s`cegp'
Iqig }dig ae~cbj visvs b~i ysif* vdi`~ `gvi~x~ivbv`eg `s oecx~ec`sif np vdi abov
vdbv vdip cbp ab`j ve f`sv`gmy`sd niv}iig f`sseo`bv`qi vigfigo`is bgf f`sseo`bv`qi
iaaiovs' Ae~ itbcxji* Xe}i~s $2006b bssissif b m~eyx ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s eg
vdi Xesv#V~bycbv`o _v~iss F`se~fi~ $XV_F synsobji ea vdi CCX@* bgf eg vdi Xi~oix#
vybj Bjvi~bv`eg _obji $XB_' XV_F `s oe~~ijbvif }`vd f`sseo`bv`qi vigfigo`is' Vdi
XB_* bgevdi~ cibsy~i ea f`sseo`bv`eg* iqbjybvis nidbq`e~ `g vdi fecb`gs ea oegv~ej*
sija#ceg ve~`gm* oegoibjcigv* oegso`eysgiss* bgf sigse~p itxi~`igoi' Xe}i~s aeygfb ojib~ oe~~ijbv`eg niv}iig bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois bgf ijiqbvif XV_F bgf XB_ soe~is'
Bjvdeymd Xe}i~s }bs x~`cb~`jp oegoi~gif }`vd vdi `cxj`obv`egs ea vdisi ~isyjvs
ae~ vdi~bxp* `v `s ojib~ a~ec di~ f`soyss`eg vdbv f`sseo`bv`qi xdigecigejemp }bs
oegs`fi~if egjp bs b xess`nji obysi ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi bgf gev bs b xes#
s`nji iaaiov' Nyv bgpegi itxi~`igo`gm bg bovybj bnfyov`eg np bj`igs c`mdv ni it#
xiovif ve dbqi ijiqbvif soe~is eg vdi cibsy~is bssissif' @gfiif* `g cygfbgi obsis
ea feoycigvif v~bycb $q`ov`cs ea ~bxi* vi~~e~`sc* }`vgiss`gm bg bv~eo`vp ijiqbvif
soe~is eg vdi k`gf ea cibsy~is ysif np Xe}i~s b~i nevd itxiovif bgf envb`gif
$]`jseg* 2008'
$b) Bssisscigvs ea Xbvdejemp
Oj`g`obj @cx~iss`eg' @g seci svyf`is* f`bmges`s `s gev nbsif eg bgp svbgfb~f`|if
visv ae~ xbvdejemp* nyv eg bssisscigv `gvi~q`i}* nidbq`e~bj ensi~qbv`eg* bgf `cx~is#
s`eg ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s synliov`qi booeygv' Ae~ itbcxji* Cbok $2006
svyf`if =1 bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s* bgf x~eq`fis obsi svyf`is ea 2?' De}iqi~* gev`gm
vdbv b ayjj nbvvi~p ea xspodeciv~`o visvs `s v`ci oegsyc`gm bgf itxigs`qi $x' 2=*
Cbok dbf egjp aey~ ea d`s =1 obsis ae~cbjjp visvif ae~ xspod`bv~`o f`se~fi~ $egi dbf
bj~ibfp niig desx`vbj`|if ae~ xspod`bv~`o ~ibsegs; vdi evdi~ vd~ii visvif ge~cbj'Evdi~ svyf`is fe icxjep xspodejem`obj visvs* nyv f`bmges`s s sv`jj jb~mijp synlio#
v`qi' Ae~ itbcxji* Njeiodi~* Ojbcb~* bgf Dexk`gs $2049 f`soyss vdi a`gf`gms ea
_jbvi~ $2049* b xspodejem`sv }de f`f b nj`gf iqbjybv`eg ea g`gi bnfyov`eg it#
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
18/50
61 LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
xi~`igoi~s' _jbvi~ aeygf ge iq`figoi np }d`od vdi ~ixe~vif bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois
oeyjf ni booeygvif ae~ eg vdi nbs`s ea b cigvbj f`se~fi~' De}iqi~* vdi visvs ysif ve
iqbjybvi xbvdejemp }i~i x~eliov`qi visvs $^e~sodbod* Vdicbv`o Bxxi~oixv`eg Visv*
vdi qbj`f`vp ea }d`od `s xb~v`oyjb~jp fixigfigv eg vdi seci}dbv isevi~`o sk`jjs$Ob~seg ! Nyvodi~* 200> ea vdi `gf`q`fybj bfc`g`svi~`gm vdic' Bjvdeymd vdi~i `s
ge ~ibseg ve ryisv`eg _jbvi~s sk`jjs `g vd`s ~imb~f* vdi abov ~icb`gs vdbv vdi oegojy#
s`egs ea vd`s svyfp b~i nbsif eg vdi `gvi~x~ivbv`eg ea b s`gmji `gf`q`fybj'
Lboenseg bgf N~yge $2006 oejjiovif itvigs`qi gb~~bv`qi fbvb eg vdi xi~segbj d`s#
ve~`is bgf bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois ea v}ijqi gf`q`fybjs' Nbsif eg oj`g`obj cx~iss`eg*
vdip aeygf vdbv gegi ea vdi gb~~bv`qis oegvb`gif ijicigvs vdbv }eyjf symmisv vdi
xdigecigejemp ea bgp oy~~igvjp ~ioemg`|if xspod`bv~`o spgf~eci $x' ?81' Giqi~#
vdijiss* desx`vbj ~ioe~fs sde}if vdbv v}e ea vdi`~ synliovs dbf syaai~if a~ec b cble~
xspod`bv~`o `jjgiss b~eygf vdi v`ci ea vdi`~ bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Vd`s `jjysv~bvis vdifbgmi~ `g ys`gm oj`g`obj `cx~iss`eg np `vsija bs vdi civdef ea bssisscigv'
Ibod ea vdisi svyf`is x~eq`fis symmisv`qi fbvb* nyv ibod `s j`c`vif `g vi~cs ea
civdefejemp' ^imb~fjiss ea vdi iaa`obop ea vdisi bxx~ebodis ae~ vdi oj`g`o* vdi`~
ysiayjgiss bs ~isib~od fbvb `s oecx~ec`sif np jbok ea ~ixibvbn`j`vp $niobysi ea vdi
jbok ea svbgfb~f`|if cibsy~icigv* e~ vdi fixigfigoi ea f`bmgesv`o eyvoeci eg vdi
xi~seg fe`gm vdi f`bmges`s* vdi bnsigoi ea oegv~ej synliovs* bgf%e~ vdi scbjj sbcxji
s`|is svyf`if'
_vbgfb~f`|if visvs ae~ xbvdejemp' Ce~i itvigs`qi svyf`is ys`gm svbgfb~f`|if `g#
sv~ycigvs dbqi niig ob~~`if eyv np b gycni~ ea `gqisv`mbve~s' Xb~gijj bgf _x~`gkji$2008 visvif eqi~ >88 synliovs ~ixe~v`gm YAE itxi~`igois eg vdi C`ggisevb
Cyjv`xdbs`o Xi~segbj`vp @gqigve~p $CCX@* b xspodeciv~`o `gsv~ycigv vdbv `s sig#
s`v`qi ve xspodexbvdejemp' Bjvdeymd vdi byvde~s oegojyfi vdbv ge eqi~v xspodexb#
vdejemp }bs `gf`obvif $x' 69* b ojesi~ itbc`gbv`eg ea vdi`~ fbvb symmisvs vdbv
bcegm vdesi synliovs }de fiso~`nif oeccyg`obv`eg }`vd igv`v`is* seci dbf soe~is
eg oi~vb`g CCX@ synsobjis $i'm'* sobji 4vdi synsobji bssiss`gm sod`|exd~ig`o
vigfigop vdbv oeyjf ni oegs`fi~if `g vdi bnge~cbj ~bgmi'
@g b s`c`jb~ svyfp* ^efimd`i~ iv bj' $200> ysif vdi CCX@ @@ $~iq`sif qi~s`eg ea
vdi CCX@ ve iqbjybvi b m~eyx ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s sijiovif booe~f`gm ve bcyod ce~i sv~`ov fia`g`v`eg ea itxi~`igoi~ vdbg vdbv ysif np Xb~gijj bgf _x~`gkji'
Bmb`g* ge eqi~v xbvdejemp }bs `gf`obvif ae~ vdi m~eyx bs b }deji* nyv }bs symmis#
v`qi ae~ oi~vb`g `gf`q`fybjs `g vdi sbcxji'
_xbges iv bj' $200? oecxb~if b m~eyx ea oegv~ej synliovs ve 60 `gf`q`fybjs }de
dbf ~ixe~vif YAE#~ijbvif itxi~`igois' Vdi YAE ~ixe~vi~s }i~i f`q`fif `gve syn#
liovs }de ci~ijp sb} yg`figv`a`if j`mdvs bgf vdesi }de dbf ce~i ijbne~bvi ojesi
igoeygvi~s' Ve bssiss xspodejem`obj dibjvd* b nbvvi~p ea visvs }bs bfc`g`svi~if $vdi
sod`|exd~ig`b synsobji ea vdi CCX@* ^esigni~ms _ija#Isviic _obji* vdi Cbm`obj
@fibv`eg _obji* vdi Xi~oixvybj Bni~~bv`eg _obji* Vijjimigs F`aai~igv`bj Xi~segbj`vpRyisv`eggb`~i' Vdi byvde~s aeygf vdbv vdi`~ igoeygvi~ synliovs soe~if ge je}i~ eg
bgp cibsy~i ea xspodejem`obj dibjvd vdbg vdi oegv~ejs* bgf dbf d`mdi~ xspodejem`#
obj dibjvd soe~is vdbg vdi oegv~ejs eg cbgp ea vdi cibsy~icigvs' Vdip oegojyfi
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
19/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI 6=
vdbv vdisi a`gf`gms x~eq`fi ge syxxe~v }dbvseiqi~ ae~ vdi dpxevdis`s vdbv YAE
~ixe~vi~s b~i xspodejem`objjp f`svy~nif $x' 1>4* bgf vdi egys `s eg vdesi }de
abqe~ vdi xspodexbvdejemp dpxevdis`s ve x~eq`fi syxxe~v ae~ `v $x' 1>0'
Oj`g`obj bgf svbv`sv`obj ge~cbj`vp'Fisx`vi vdisi a`gf`gms* vdi `cxj`obv`eg eamigi~bj ge~cbj`vp obg ni ry`vi c`sjibf`gm' Ge~cbj obg ni ygfi~sveef `g vdi
oj`g`obj sigsi bs gev xbvdejem`obj* e~ `g vdi svbv`sv`obj sigsi bs gev s`mg`a`obgvjp
f`aai~igv a~ec bqi~bmi' A~ec b oj`g`obj xi~sxiov`qi* vdi fbvb se ab~ b~i ygbcn`my#
eys' Cesv bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois obggev ni booeygvif ae~ `g vi~cs ea kge}g xsp#
odejem`obj f`se~fi~ bs cibsy~if eg svbgfb~f`|if xspodeciv~`o visvs'
Vd`s gev}`vdsvbgf`gm* b gycni~ ea svyf`is dbqi sde}g vdbv bnfyov`eg itxi~`igo#
i~s b~i gev ~ix~isigvbv`qi ea vdi migi~bj xexyjbv`eg' Ae~ itbcxji* Xb~gijj bgf
_x~`gkji $2008 aeygf vdbv synliovs ojb`c`gm oeccyg`obv`eg }`vd bj`igs dbf b x~e#
xigs`vp ae~ ygysybj aiij`gms* vdeymdvs* bgf bvv`vyfis; }i~i sysx`o`eys* f`sv~ysvayj*`cbm`gbv`qi; bgf dbf sod`|e`f vigfigo`is' ^`gm bgf ^es`gm $2008 aeygf vdbv vdi`~
synliovs ~ixe~vif ce~i sigs`v`q`vp ve gege~f`gb~p ~ibj`v`is bs od`jf~ig' efimd`i~ iv
bj' $2002 aeygf ce~i jegij`giss* jiss dbxx`giss* bgf xee~i~ sjiix' Cbok $2006
~ixe~vs ni`gm sv~yok np de} cbgp bnfyoviis obci a~ec n~ekig decis e~ dbf egi
e~ ce~i bjoedej`o xb~igvs $x' 2=' Xi~dbxs cesv v~eynj`gm* _vegi#Ob~cig $2006
aeygf vdbv 9=) ea di~ synliovs ~ixe~vif sy`o`fi bvvicxvs ib~j`i~ `g j`ai $oecxb~if
}`vd 2'>4) `g vdi migi~bj xexyjbv`eg'
X_PODEFPGBC@O VDIE^@I_
@v dbs niig symmisvif $_bmbg* 2001; Qbjjii* 2010 vdbv s`c`jb~ vdicis bxxib~`gm `g
nevd d`sve~`obj aejkje~i $i'm'* igoeygvi~s }`vd ab`~`is* ijqis* bgmijs bgf oegvicxe~b~p
bnfyov`eg booeygvs gf`obvi b oecceg e~`m`g g vdi dycbg xspodi' $Ae~ b f`soyss`eg
ea vdi aejkje~`o f`cigs`egs ea vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi* sii Nyjjb~f* 2002' B gycni~
ea xspodefpgbc`o vdie~`is0 dbqi niig x~exesif ve itxjb`g vdi cbg`aisvbv`eg ea vdisi
x~eoissis bs vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi' Oecceg ve vdisi vdie~`is `s vdi gev`eg vdbv
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois b~i b x~efyov ea vdi ygoegso`eys c`gf' Vdi vdie~`is f`aai~*
de}iqi~* `g ~imb~f ve vdi`~ fiso~`xv`eg ea vdisi ygoegso`eys x~eoissis e~ `g ~imb~f vevdi s`vybv`egs fiicif ~isxegs`nji ae~ vdi`~ bov`qbv`eg'
$b) _o~iig Cice~`is ae~ Od`jfdeef Bnysi
B oe~~ijbv`eg niv}iig ~ixe~vif bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois bgf ~ixe~vif od`jfdeef bnysi
itxi~`igois dbs niig oegs`svigvjp aeygf np ~isib~odi~s bgf oj`g`o`bgs $Jb`ne}* 2040;
Xe}i~s* 2006b* 2006n; ^`gm ! ^es`gm* 2008; ^efimd`i~ iv bj'* 200>' Bg enq`eys
$bjvdeymd gev gioissb~`jp oe~~iov `gvi~x~ivbv`eg ea vd`s oe~~ijbv`eg `s vdbv bovybj eo#
oy~~igois ea od`jfdeef bnysi cbg`aisv bs abjsi cice~`is ea bj`ig bnfyov`eg'
Ae~ itbcxji* Xe}i~s $2006b symmisvs vdbv vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi si~qis bs bso~iig cice~p ae~ od`jfdeef sitybj bnysi niobysi bnfyov`eg np bj`igs `s jiss
sv~issayj vdbg oega~egv`gm vdi v~bycb ea od`jfdeef bnysi xi~xiv~bvif np ~ijbv`qis e~
abc`jp a~`igfs $x' 60* bgf ~iobsv`gm vdi itxi~`igoi [ea ib~jp od`jfdeef bnysiS bs
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
20/50
64 LEY^GBJ EA YAE _VYF@I_
b sijiov`eg }`vd syod b m~bgf xy~xesi [`'i'* ae~ vdi bj`igs oesc`o enliov`qisS c`mdv
~isve~i cibg`gm ve j`qis vd~ibvigif np v~bycbv`o cice~`is $Xe}i~s* 2006n* x' 61'
@g syxxe~v ea vd`s oegvigv`eg* Xe}i~s $2006b b~myis vdbv ijiqbvif XV_F bgf
XB_ soe~is aeygf `g nevd bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s bgf q`ov`cs ea od`jfdeef bnysi`cxjp vdbv bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi~s b~i q`ov`cs ea od`jfdeef bnysi' Vd`s sdi bssycis
niobysi ijiqbvif soe~is eg vdisi sobjis b~i kge}g ve ni b oegsiryigoi ea v~bycb'
Nyv }dp sdeyjf vdip ni ~imb~fif bs bgp nivvi~ iq`figoi ae~ vdi v~bycb ea od`jf
bnysi vdbg vdi v~bycb ea bj`ig bnfyov`eg5 Vdi bgs}i~* ea oey~si* bxxibjs ve xb~s`#
cegp* gev iq`figoi'
Giqi~vdijiss* b oe~~ijbv`eg niv}iig od`jfdeef bnysi bgf vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`#
igoi `s b xi~s`svigv a`gf`gm* bgf vdi `cxj`obv`eg vdbv od`jfdeef bnysi obysis vdi
bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi fisi~qis ob~iayj itbc`gbv`eg' Vdi b~mycigvs bxxibj ve xb~#
s`cegp isxio`bjjp fisi~qis so~yv`gp'Oegs`fi~ vdi aejje}`gm xspodefpgbc`o bssycxv`egs vdbv cysv ygfi~j`i vd`s `g#
vi~x~ivbv`eg2?* M~ea d`csija bokge}jifmif vdbv b obysbj gitys niv}iig vdi bovybj n`e#
jem`obj n`~vd bgf vdi ygoegso`eys cbv~`tis ae~ vdisi itxi~`igois ~icb`gs ve ni is#
vbnj`sdif $x'04'
$o) Bne~v`eg Bgt`ivp
_vbop $200> ex`gis vdbv vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi* bv jibsv vdi oeccegjp ~i#
xe~vif bsxiov $Lboens* 200> ea vdi itxi~`igoi fibj`gm }`vd migiv`o n~iif`gm bgf
dpn~`f nbn`is* `s `g abov b ~ij`q`gm ea vdi bne~v`eg itxi~`igoi* }divdi~ vdi jbvvi~ `s
7/31/2019 46118831 Stuart Appelle the Abduction Experience a Critical Evaluation
23/50
BXXIJJI< VDI BNFYOV@EG ITXI^@IGOI 92
bovybjjp ~ibj e~ ci~ijp cbm`gb~p $x' 6' Ce~i sxio`a`objjp* di ~imb~fs `v bs a`gfs M~esses fibs d`mdjp ~ijiqbgv ve d`s e}g svyfp ea ojesi#igoeyg#
vi~ itxi~`igois' J`ki M~esse* ^`gm ~imb~fs syod itxi~`igois bs iq`figoi ae~ vdi iqe#
jyv`eg ea oegso`eysgiss' Ce~i sxio`a`objjp* di siis vdic bs dijx`gm ve fiqijex ey~
jbvigv obxbo`v`is ae~ `cbm`gbj xi~oixv`eg $x' >68' ^`gms ysi ea vdi vi~c `cbm`gbj
sdeyjf gev ni oegaysif }`vd `cbm`gb~p' Vdi f`sv`gov`eg niv}iig vdi vi~cs svics a~ecvdi }e~k ea Oe~n`g $20=> }de dpxevdis`|if vdi it`svigoi ea bg bjvi~gbvi ~ibj`vp
booissif np q`s`egb~`is bgf cpsv`os fy~`gm bjvi~if svbvis ea oegso`eysgiss' Oe~n`g
fiso~`nis vd`s }e~jf bs egvejem`objjp ~ibj* vdbv `s* bs ~ibj e~ ce~i ~ibj vdbg vdbv itxi#
~`igoif fy~`gm iqi~pfbp oegso`eysgiss' `gm b~myis vdbv bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois oeci
a~ec oegvbov }`vd vd`s `cbm`gbj ~ibjc* bgf vdbv `v obg ni itxiovif vdbv eqi~ v`ci vdi
iqejyv`egb~p cecigvyc [bsseo`bvif }`vd vdisi itxi~`igoisS }`jj isvbnj`sd bgf svbn`#
j`|i vdisi `cbm`gbj fecb`gs bs ey~ sdb~if ~ibj`vp' $x' >68
^`gm bgf M~esse b~i gev vdi egjp svyfigvs ea yaejemp ve b~myi ae~ b oeggiov`eg
niv}iig YAE xdigecigb* evdi~ ~ibj`v`is* bgf iqejyv`egb~p ae~ois' Vdecxseg $2002siis b~odivpxbj `cbmi~p `g YAE igoeygvi~s' CoKiggb $204= symmisvs vdbv vdi
itv~bvi~~isv~`bj `s vdi dycbg eqi~seyj `g `vs migi~bj bgf xb~v`oyjb~ itx~iss`eg eg
vdi xjbgiv $x'2=' _v~`ini~ $`g Fbnn ! Jbgmiq`g* 2008* oegs`fi~s vdi bj`igs bs
c`f}`a`gm ey~ n`~vd gve vdi gegxdps`obj }e~jf}d`od s vdi`~ e~`m`g* bgf ~ix~i#
sigvbv`qi ea bg iqejyv`egb~p svix nipegf ey~s }d`od dbs ici~mif gve ey~ }e~jf bs
b ~isyjv ea bov`egs eg vdi geg#xdps`obj xjbgi $x'62' Qbjjii $2008 symmisvs vdbv
`g b Lygm`bg `gvi~x~ivbv`eg ' ' ' vdi dycbg ygoegso`eys oeyjf ni x~eliov`gm bdibf
ea `vsija vdi `cbmi~p }d`od `s gioissb~p ae~ ey~ e}g jegm#vi~c sy~q`qbj nipegf vdi
ygx~ioifigvif o~`sis ea vdi >8vd oigvy~p $x' 221' Cbok $2006 oegojyfis vdbvvdi bnfyov`eg xdigecigeg* `v siics ojib~* `s bneyv }dbv `s piv ve oeci' @v x~i#
sigvs* ry`vi j`vi~bjjp* q`s`egs ea bjvi~gbv`qi ayvy~is $x' 6>>' Bgf xdps`o`sv ]eja
$2006 vbkis vdi xes`v`eg vdbv=8 di iqbjybvif `g }d`od vdi bnfyov`eg itxi~`igoi
nim`gs }`vdeyv bgp bxxb~igv `gvi~qigv`eg np YAEs e~ igv`v`is bgf }d`od cbp ni
odb~bovi~`|if bs x~`cb~`jp e~ igv`~ijp cigvbj' Ae~ itbcxji* `g egi obsi $obsi />80
vdi itxi~`igoi~ ~ixe~vif xdps`obj `gvi~bov`eg bgf oeccyg`obv`eg }`vd bg bj`ig bn#
fyove~ ae~ b xi~`ef ea v`ci fy~`gm }d`od vdi itxi~`igoi~ ~icb`gif `g vdi x~isigoi ea
ayjjp oegso`eys `gqisv`mbve~s $}de ensi~qif ge bvvicxvif bnfyov`eg `g x~em~iss'Nyjjb~f ~iai~s ve syod obsis bs xspod`o bnfyov`egs fy~`gm }d`od vdi bjvi~if svbvi#`vic vicxe~bj#jeni synsobji ea vdi Xi~segbj Xd`jesexdp @gqig#
ve~p* bg bssisscigv `gsv~ycigv fis`mgif np Xi~s`gmi~ bgf Cbkb~io $204= sxio`a`#
objjp ve cibsy~i v~b`vs bsseo`bvif }`vd vicxe~bj#jeni jbn`j`vp' Ys`gm Xi~s`gmi~ bgf
Cbki~ios e}g cibsy~i ea vd`s qb~`bnji* _xbges iv bj' aeygf ge f`aai~igois niv}iig
oegv~ej synliovs bgf itxi~`igoi~s' Vd`s a`gf`gm nib~s gev egjp eg vdi BJX dpxevdis`s'@v `s bjse oegv~b~p ve bgp symmisv`eg vdbv vicxe~bj#jeni jbn`j`vp* np q`~vyi ea `vs e}g
sxegvbgieys bov`q`vp* cbp ni b s`mg`a`obgv obysi ea bnfyov`eg itxi~`igois'
$n) Bjji~m`o ^ibov`egs
Nyffig $2006 b~myis ae~ b cyod }`fi~ oegv~`nyv`eg ea ijiov~ecbmgiv`o iqigvs
vdbg vdbv dpxevdis`|if np Fiqi~iyt bgf Xi~s`gmi~