74 Howard Simons, Government and National Security...

74 Howard Simons Government and National Security OTPbIBOK H3 ~oKna~a Ha Cbe3~e AMepHKaHcKoro oomecTBa pe~aKToshypOB ra3eT ony(5nHKoBaHHbIA B Editor amp Publisher Apr 26 1986

75 Bok Secrets p 208

76 CIA Weighs Action on Washington Post Article New York Times May 22 1986 CIA Director Urges Inquiry on NBC Broadcast New York Times May 20 1986 The Casey Offensive Columbia Journalism Review 25 no 2 (JulyAug 1986)

77 Columbia Journalism Review 19

78 Jim Anderson The Pot Calls the Kettle Black Washington Post May II 1986

79 Administration is Accused of Deceiving Press on Libya Schultz Justifies Scaring Qaddafi By Us of Press News Execushytives Express Outrage New York Times Oct 3 1986 Spokesman Quits State Department Post on Deception Issue New York Times Oct 9 1986

80 Lesson on Flacking for Government New York Times Aug 30 1984

81 Mike Royko Blowing the Whistle on a Loud Silence at NASA Orlando Sentinel March 11 1986

82 Anthony Marro When the Government Tells Lies Columbia Journalism Review 23 no 6 (March-April 1985) Drew Middleton Barring Reporters from the Battlefield New York Times Magazine Feb 5 1984 36-37 61 69 92 Coverage Efforts Thwarted News Media and the Law JanFeb 1984

83 Pentagon Activates Press Pool to Cover Libya Bombing Press time May 1986 69

84 Christopher H Little Newspaper Law and Fairness 16-18

116

reHpU myl1me

KOH~JlHKThI ME)JW BJIACThIO II EYPHAJIHCTAW

~O ropoAcKoro Mapa 6arpoBO OT pa3APIDKeHIDl

310 HelJeCTHasI Hrpa - 3annmeJI OH Ha KjpHaJIHCTKY

eABa nepecTynHB nopor 3aJIa 3aceAaHHH MyHH~HnaJIHTeTa

HeyxeJIH BbI He nOHHMaeTe 1JTO BbI CAeJIaJIH C MoeH penYTashy

~eH B CBoeH CTaTbe 0 KOMHCCHH no npaBaM lJeJIOBeKa Bbl

COBepmeHHO HenpaBHJIbHO paCCTaBHJIH ~eHTbI H BbIllSITHJIH

JIHIlIb OARH onrn6KH

He )KeJIasI BblcnymaTb OTBeT pa3bSIpeHHbIH rpapoHalJaJIbshy

HHK ABHHYJICH npOlJb a CTOSIBlllHH HenOAaJIeKY ropoAcKOH

COBeTHHK nOAOmeJI 6JIH)Ke H APyxemo6Ho CKJIOHHJICH K Aeshy

BymKe

OTJIH1JHbIH 6bill MaTepHaJI HaKoHe~-To BM CTaJIH Ha

Hamy CTOpOHy He cnymaHTe aTOfO CTaporo JIHca - npoH3shy

Hec OH C SIBHbIM YAOBOJIbCTBHeM

E~a JIH He CaMasI CJIO)KHasI 3apalJa KjpHaJIHCTa - YCTaHOshy

BHTb OTHOmeHHH C lJRHOBHHKaMH pmI KOTOPbIX npeBbillle Bcero

c06CTBeHHble ~eJIH B TOM lJRCJIe 3aQacryro KapbepHble co06shy

pIDKeHHH HeyuHBHTeJIbHO llTO ~HaJIHCTbI He OQeHb-TO AOshy

BepHlOT lJRHOBHHKaM KOTOpble B CBOlO olJepeAb Aep)KaT opeshy

THB opeccbI KpyrOBYIO OOOPOHY He 6pe3ryH CaMbIMH 6eccTbIpshy

HbIMH CpeACTBaMH

MHorne KjpHaJIHCTbI C BeJIHKOH OXOTOH BHpHT ce6H B 06shy

pa3e CBHTOro feoprnSI OTBa)KHO BblcrynaIO~erO C OARHM JIHIlIb

KOllbeM (B AaHHOM cnyqae aTO rrOpTaTHBHbIH KOMnblOTep BHshy

AeOKaMepa HJIH Ha XYAOH KOHeQ cTapoMoARaSI n~asI Mashy

illHHKa) Ha npaBeARYIO 6HTBY C MorytmM [4JaKoHoM (STO KOshy

He1JHO arOHCTH1JHble nOJIHTHKH H rocYAapcTBeHHbIe lJRHOBshy

rJlaBa 1I3 KHlIztt Hellry H Shulte Reportillg Public Affairs Mcmillan Publishing Co Illc New York 1981

117

Hlurn) rOTOBbIM rrpH rrepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTII rrO)KpaTb BCe ITO

TOJIbKO rrOrraneTCSl HHlTO He MO)KeT rroKoJIe6aTb RX HeCOKpyshy

IIDIMOH BepbI B TO qTO mo60H rronyqaTeJIb Ka3eHHoro )KaJIOshy

BaHbSl Bcerna rOTOB rrOKYCHTbCSl Ha 06~eCTBeHHbIe HHTepeshy

CbI a pa306JIaqIfTb ero --- rrepBethImii nOJIr H 06Sl3aHHOCTb

~pHaJIHCTa

PeaJIbHaSI neHCTBHTeJIbHOCTb naJIeKa OT 3TOH qepHo-6eJIOH

KapTHHbI KOHe~o BCTPeqaIOTCSl H HerrOKOJIe6HMbIe BOHHCTshy

BeHHbIe pbInapH 6e3 cTpaxa H yrrpeKa H yrOnJIHBbIe JIHneMeshy

PbI neJIaIOIIWe peKJIaMY H~bIM rrOJIHTHKaM KOTOPbIe 6ecshy

rrpHHnHrrHo rrOJIb3YIQTcSl HX YCJIyraMH Ho Me)Kl1y 3THMH DBYMSl

KPaHHHMH rromoCaMH XBaTaeT MeCTa nJISl BeJIHKOrO MHO)KeCTBa

~HaJIHCTOB H anMHHHcTPaTopoB rro-cBoeMY cny)Kanwx 06shy

~ecTBY H rrOMep)KlfBaIO~ npyr C npyrOM XOTb H BPIDKshy

ne6HbIe HO B neJIOM BrrOJIHe HOpMaJIbHbIe OTHOIIIeHHSl OnHashy

KO nJISl )KypHaJIHCTOB He TaK-TO JIerKO HaHTH rrpaBHJIbHOe

COOTHOIIIeHHe Me)Kl1y COTpYnHHqeCTBOM C rrOJIHTHKaMH H Hashy

6JIIOneHHeM 3a HX neSlTeJIbHOCTbIO 3neCb cpa3Y B03HHKaeT

pSln BorrpOCOB

1 ECJIH Y)K rrpecca H BJIaCTH He B COCTOSlHHH HaCJIIDKshy

naTbCSl HnHJIJIHqeCKOH np~60H B qeM HMeHHO COCTOHT HX COshy

rrepHIfqeCTBO

2 KaK naJIeKO MO)I(HO 3aHTII B rron06HoH KoHKypeHnHH

3 B KaKOH Mepe rrpecce rr03BOJIHTeJIbHO cOTPYnHIfqaTb C

rrpaBHTeJIbCTBOM HJIH rrOMOraTb eMY He CKOMilpOMeTHpOBaB

ce6Sl H CBOH rrpHHnHIlbI

C OnHOH TO~ 3peHHSl KOHKypeHnHSl Me)Kl1y rrpeCCOH H

BJIaCTSlMH HeH36e)I(Ha rrpOCTO rrOTOMY ITO neJIH CTOPOH pa3shy

JIH~I H HeCOBMeCTHMbI )l(YPHaJIHCTbI n06bIBaIOT HHcpopMashy

nHIO B TO BpeMSl KaK 6IOpOKpaTbI CTPeMSlIIWecSl COxpaHHTb

CBoe rrOJIO)KeHHe BOBce He )KeJIaIOT eIO neJIHTbCSl IIpyroe 06bshy

SlCHeHHe 3Toro cOrrepHHqeCTBa COCTOHT B TOM ITO 06~eCTBO

He CJIHIIIKOM nOBepSleT CBOHM H36paHHbIM H Ha3HaqeHHbIM

CJIyraM H HMeHHO rrpecca 3aCTaBJISleT BJIaCTII OTqIfTblBaTbshy

CSl rrepen corpa)Kl1aHaMH B CBORX neHCTBHSlX ECTb H TPeTbe

MHeHHe rrpecca B rrpHHnHrre COBceM He Bpa)Kl1e6Ha rocynap-

CTBY neJIO JIHIIIb B TOM qTO n06bIBaSI HHcpOpManHIO B KOTOPOH

3aHHTepeCOBaHO 06~eCTBO rrpecca rro He06xonHMOCTH OKashy

3bIBaeT naBJIeHHe Ha BJIaCTH 3TO He MeIIIaeT )KYPHaJIHCTaM H

OCPHnHaJIbHbIM JIHnaM rrOHHMaTb H YBIDKaTb npyr npyra qTO H

C03naeT OCHOBY nJISl HOPMaJIbHbIX pa60qIfx oTHoIIIeHHH

ITpH rron06HbIX HHTeprrpeTanHSlX He CTOHT 3a6bIBaTb ITO

Bpa)Kl1e6HOCTb OCTaeTCSl Bpa)KDe6HOCTbIO KaK ee HH rrpHYKpashy

IIIHBaH 113BecTHbIH TOJIKOBbIH CJIOBapb Be6cTepa orrpeneJISleT

correpHHKa KaK OIIIIOHeHTa aHTarOHHCTa Bpara HJIH rrpOTHBshy

HHKa B Hrpe OTHOIIIeHHSl Me)Kl1y rrpeCCOH H BJIaCTSlMH HrpOH

HHKaK He SlBJISlIOTCSl HO 3TO He neJIaeT RX 60JIee rrpOCTbIMH H

MHpHbIMH QT06bI 3TO rrO~CTBOBaTb rrOIlbITaHTeCb paccTashy

BHTb Ha IIIKaJIe OT rrOJIHOH Bpa)Kl1e6HocTH no oTKpoBeHHoro

yronHIfqecTBa CJIeDYIOIIWe CHTYanHH

--- HeKHii 06JIanaTeJIb OCPHnHaJIbHOH nOJI)KHOCTH rrpHrJIashy

rnaeT perropTepa Ha 06en H He pa3pernaeT eMY OIIJIaTHTb CBOIO

nomo CKpOMHOrO CqeTa

--- Qepe3 KaKOe-TO BpeMSl TOT )Ke qIfHOBHHK rrpenJIaraeT

~HaJIHCTY 3aKYJIHCHbIe CBeneHHSl 0 TOM KaK rrpHHHMaJIOCb

peIIIeHHe 0 CTPOHTeJIbCTBe HOBOH 3JIeKTpOCTaHnHH H rrpOCHT

orry6JIHKOBaTb 3TH CBeneHHSlbull

--- )I(YPHaJIHCT 06p~aeTCSl K JIHny ClllITaIO~eMYCSl Heshy

n06pO)KeJIaTeJIeM ero 3aKa3qHKa paCCqHTbIBaSl rronyqHTb

rrpOTlIB TOro KaKHe-TO YJIHKH

--- Pa60TaSI Han CTaTbeH ~HaJIHCT KOHCYJIbTHpyeTcSl C

npyrHM OcpHnHaJIbHbIM JIHnOM 3apaHee 3HaSl qTO TeMa He

rrpenCTaBJISleT nJISl Toro ~oro HHTepeca

--- PerropTep BMeCTe C rrepBbIM anMHHHCTPaTopOM eneT Ha

ceccHIO 3aKOHonaTeJIbHOrO C06paHHSl B npyrOH ropon ITo noshy

pore OH 60JITaeT 0 rrOJIHTIIKe H BbICJIYIIlHBaeT BOCrrOMHHaHHSl

CBoero BH3aBH KaK TOT 6blJl HaqIfHaIOIIWM aDBOKaTOM H C TPYshy

nOM Mor conep)KaTb CeMbIO

--- Korna 3HaKOMna HeT B ropone perropTep HaBenhIBaeTCSl

K ero ceKpeTaprne IIbITaSICb pa3Y3HaTb rrOMep)KlfBaeT JIH TOT

HeKoero KaHDHnaTa Ha nOJI)KHOCTb cpenepaJIbHoro CYnhH

--- 3HaSI ITO anMHHHCTpaTOp B qaCTHOM rrOpSlnKe BCTpeqashy

118 119

eTCSI C lIOMOIIWHKaMH IIbITaSICb yperyJIlIpOBaTh BeCbMa Heshy

lIpHSITHOe neJI])Qe eme He CTaBmee nOCTOSIHHeM rJIaCHOCm

~HaJIHCT lIpHnep~BaeT CBeneHHSI 06 3THX COBemaHHSIX

---- ]KypHaJIHCT 3HaeT rne lIPOHCXOnSIT 3TH 3aKYJIlICHbIe

BCTpetIH H KapayJIlIT y nBepeH tIT06bI paCKOJIOTb Koroshy

HH6ynI H3 yqaCTHHKoB H Y3HaTb lITO HMeHHO 06C))KllaJIOCb H

KTO lITO CKa3aJI

KOHetIHO Ha lIOBeneHHe ~HaJlllCTa B KaJK]JOH H3 3THX

cHTyaQHH BJIHSIIOT MHorHe cpaKTopbI TaKHe KaK pa3Mep

peCTopaHHoro CtIeTa lIpHtIHHa lIoe3nKH Ha ceCCHIO

3aKOHonaTeJI])HOrO C06paHHSI mp8)K ra3eThI H HpaBbI ropona

rne OHa BbIXOnHT lITO 06C))KllaJIOCb BO BpeMS lIepBoro 06ena---shy

6aHaJI])HOCm HJIlI HellTO B8)KHOe XBamT JIlI pelIOPTepy OIlbIshy

Ta lIT06bI lIOHSITh HaCKOJI])KO OH pHCKYeT pelIYTaQHeH lIpHshy

HHMaSI IIpHrJIameHHe

OTHomeHHSI Me~ ~PHaJlllCTOM H tIHHOBHHKOM 3aBHshy

CSIT OT nJIHTeJI])HOCTH 3HaKOMCTBa H CTelIeHH B3aHMHOrO npyshy

gtKeJII06HSI Y pelIoprepa eCTb c06CTBeHHoe HatIaJI])CTBO KOTopoe

MOgtKeT JIlI60 lIpenocrepeTh ero OT JII06bIX HCKymeHHit JIlI60

lIOCOBeTOBaTh corJIaCHThCSI Ha paaneBY 06emaIOIQee QeHHYlO

HHCPOPMaQHIO

He6e3pa3JIHtIHO H MeCTO pa60ThI gtKypHaJIHCTa 6ylb TO

MaJIeHbKHH ropOnOK HJllI BamHHrTOH llpaBna paRr OCPHQHshy

aJI])HOro JIHQa MOgtKeT 6bITb HaCTOJI])KO BbICOK lITO 3m pa3JllIshy

tIHSI TepSIIOT 3HatIeHHe OnHO neJIO eCJIH pelIOpTepa IIpHrJIaCHJI

BJIlISITeJI])Hbrn ceHaTOp HeHanOJIrO 3aeXaBIIIHH C BH3HTOM H COBshy

ceM npyroe eCJIlI BCTPetIa IIpOXOnHT lIO HHHQHamBe KaHnHDaTa

Ha nOJIgtKHOCTh MeCTHoro mepHcpa HaKOHeQ KaK YgtKe rOBopHshy

JIOCb xapaKTep KOHKypeHTHbIX OTHomeHHH MegtKny IIpeCCOH H

tIHHOBHHKaMH 3aBHCHT H OT JIlItIHoro OlIbITa KaJK]JOro OTneJI])shy

Horo ~HaJlllCTa

ECfECTBEImAR HAIIPRJKEHHOCfL

MHorne CtIHTaIOT tITO cymeCTByeT cBoero pona eCTeCTBeHshy

HaSI HalIpSIgtKeHHOCTb B OTHomeHHSIX MegtKny lIpaBHTeJI])CTBOM -

HOCHTeJIeM rocynapCTBeHHOH BJIaCm H IIpeCCOH OCBemaIOmeH

HHTepIIpempyroIQeH H KpHTHKylOmeH HClIOJI])30BaHHe 3TOH

BJlacm lloJIHToJIor I1m3JI])ne COJIa llyJI CtIHTaeT lITO 3Ta Hashy

lIpSIgtKeHHOCTb BbITeKaeT H3 IIpOTHBopetIHBOro CTaTyca ~_

HaJIHCTa

LJT06bI YClIeIIIHO neJIaTh CBOIO pa6ory ~HaJlllCT nOJIgtKeH

lIMeTh nocTYII K lIOJIlITHKaM H lIOJI])30BaThCSI HX noBepHeM HO

lIpH 3TOM OH 06SI3aH lIpaBnHBO HHcpopMHpOBaTb 06mecTBo

]KypHaJIHcTY lIPHXOnHTCSI BCTYlIaTb B KOHcpHneHQHaJIbHbIe

OTHomeHHSI co CBOHMH HCTOtIHHKaMH H OXPaHSITb HX aHOHHMshy

HOCTb HO B TO gtKe BpeMS ero nOJIr COCTOHT B pa306JIatIeHHH Bcex

H BCSItIeCKHX TaHH B HTore OTHomeHHSI MegtKny lIOJIHTHKOM H

~HaJIHCTOM 60JI])me Bcero HaIIOMHHaIOT HeynatIHbrn 6paK

OHH He06xonHMbI npyr npyry H B TO gtKe BpeMS He MOrYT IIpeshy

onOJIeTh B3aHMHOH HeIIpHSI3HH

DpyrOH HCCJIenOBaTeJI]) YIfJI])SIM APHBepc lIOJIaraeT lITO

CJIlIIlIKOM MHOrHe ~PHaJIHCThI COrJIamaIOTCSI Ha POJI]) Hashy

lIepcHHKOB cpenepaJI])HbIX mTaTHbIX H MeCTHbIX tIHHOBHHKOB

PHBepc Ha CTOpOHe Tex pa60THHKOB cpenCTB MaCCOBOH HHCPOpshy

MaQHH KOTopbIe 6POCaIOT BbI30B MHpy OCPHQHaJI])HOH BJIacm

]KYPHaJIHCT He nOJIgtKeH IIpHHHMaTh HHtIero Ha Bepy OTHIOlb He

lIOTOMY lITO tIHHOBHHKH JIrYT TaKoe 6bmaeT HO He 3TO rJIaBHoe

rOpa3no tIame lIpOCBemeHHbIe H gtKeJIaIOIDHe 6JIara 06IQecTBY

tIHHOBHHKH HCKpeHHe BepSIIDHe B neHCTBeHHOCTh CBOHX lIposhy

rpaMM HelIpenHaMepeHHO BBOnSIT lIy6JIlIKY B 3a6JIYgtKneHHe

BpM JIlI OHH 6bI pa60TaJIH CTOJI]) peBHOCTHO eCJIlI 6bI He BepHshy

JIlI B TO lITO neJIaIOT Ho 6ena B TOM tITO tIHHOBHHKH BHnSIT 06shy

meCTBeHHbIe HHTepeCbI co cBoeH c06CTBeHHoH KOJIOKOJI])HH H B

OtIeHb Y3KOH lIepclIeKTHBe ll03TOMY peaJIbHbIe HHTepeCbI

06mecTBa HeMHHyeMo lIOCTPanaIOT eCJIlI He3aBHCHMaSI IIpecca

He 6yneT TIDaTeJI])HO Ha6JI1OnaTh 3a neHCTBHSIMH tIHHOBHHKOB

no MoeMY rny60KOMY y6egtKneHHlO lIOJIHmqecKHit ~HashyJIlICT 06SI3aH lIPOTHBOlIOCTaBJISITh ce6SI BJIacm KaK CKa3aJI

lIpecc-ceKpeTapb lIOKOHHoro IIpe3HneHTa ~OHCOHa ~OPDgtK

PHnH OTHOmeHHe ocpHQHaJI])HOrO JIHQa K cpenCTBaM MaCCOBOH

120 121

HHltpOPMaQHH onper(eJISleTCH TeM B KaKOH CTeneHH OHH rro ero

MHeHHIO cnoC06CTByroT HJIH npenHTCTByroT )IBH)KeHHIO K 06shy

meH QeJIH B TO BpeMH KaK ~HaJIHCT BOcnpHHHMaeT CBOIO

pa60TY npoCTO KaK OnHCaHHe peaJIbHOH )IeHcTBHTeJIbHOcTH

PaCXO)K)IeHHH Me)K)IY 3THMH TOqKaMH 3peHHH HeH36e)KHbI

IIoJIHTHK cTpeMllTCSI ocyrneCTBHTb CBOH rrpOrpaMMbI CBe~ K

MllHHMYMY B03MO)KHOe conpOTHBJIeHHe H n03TOMY KaK rrpashy

BHJIO OH XOqeT H36e)KaTb oco60ro DIYMa ECJIH 3TO y)IaeTCH

pellIeHHe npHHHMaeTCH 6e3 rry6JIH~bIX )Ie6aToB

He Bce rrOJIHTOJIOrIr pa3)1eJIHIOT nO)lo6HbIe B3rJIH)IbI

HarrpHMep MPBHH KPHCTOJI ClHTaeT 1ffO OTHOllIeHHH rrpecshy

ChI C rocY)IapcTBoM HeJIb3H CqHTaTb cOrrepHHqeCTBoM Bpa)Kshy

)Ie6HOCTb He MO)KeT 6bITb O)lHOCTOpOHHeH ECJIH rrpecca

Bpa)K1(e6Ha rrpaBHTeJIbCTBY )IOJI)KHO JIH rrpaBHTeJIbcTBo rrJIaTHTb

TOH )Ke MOHeToH 51 1(yMaIO qTO )JISI rrpaBHTeJIbCTBa correpshy

HHleCTBO C npeccoH TaKaH )Ke rnyrrocTb KaK H 1(JIH npeccbI

COrrepHHqeCTBO C npaBHTeJIbCTBOM

3TH rrpOTHBOnOJIO)KHbIe TOlCIKH 3peHHH BhIpa)KalOT

rrpHHQHrrHaJIbHO pa3JIH~bIe B3rJISl1bI Ha 06meCTBeHHyro pOJlb

rrpeCCbI H CTaBHT HOBbIe BorrpoCbI

ECTb JIH rrpe)leJI 3a1(HpHCTOCTH KOTOPyro )IOJI)KeH BbIKashy

3bIBaTb )KYPHaJIHCT B OTHOllIeHH5IX C OCPHQHaJThHbIMH JIHIJaMH

CymecTByroT JIH rpaHHQbI HanpmKeHHocTH KOTopbIe perropshy

Tepy He CJIe1(yeT npeCTyrraTb

EcJIH correpHHleCTBO Me)K1(y npeCCOH H BJIaCTblO BOOOme

MO)KeT cyrnecTBoBaTb OHO o3HaqaeT OaJIaHCHpOBaHHe Ha rpaHH

TaKTa H aHTarOHH3Ma cOTpY1(HuqeCTBa H KOHcpJIHKTa TaKoe

paBHOBeCHe OqeHb JIerKO HapyrnHTb

KaK OTMelaJI rrOKOHHhIH 0003peBaTeJIb YOJITep llimIIMaH

eCJIH npecca H npaBHTeJIbCTBO HMeIOT Oomyro 06H3aHHOCTb )Iashy

BaTb OOmeCTBY HCTHHHyro KapTHHY rrpOHCXOr(Hmero He MOshy

)KeT JIH HX correpHuqeCTBO HCKa3HTb 3TY KaPTHHY H 3aTpYr(shy

HHTb ee rrOHHMaHHe nrnpOKOH nyOJIHKOH

TIeoH CHraJI cmTaeT ~PHaJIHCTOB Ba)KHeHnrnMH COI03shy

Tlta6Hblli peoaJltmop JCYPHaIta The National [merest

HHKaMll fOCYr(apCTBeHHOH BJIaCTH BOT 1ffO OH mnneT B cBoeH

KHHre )I(YPHaJIHCTbI H OltpJIqHaJThHbIe JIHIJa

OJIarOrrpHHTHoe OCBemeHHe B npecce MO)KeT cnocoOcrshy

BOBaTb ycnexy npOrpaMMbI BbIr(BHHYTOH r(aHHhIM a)lMHshy

HHCTpaTOpOM B ero CHJIax nOBbICHTb BepOHTHOCTb TaKOro OCBeshy

meHHH npe1(JIO)KHB ~HaJIHcry 3KCKJl103HBHYIO HHltpopMa~

- ony6JIHKOBaB TaKHe CBe)leHHH penopTep nOBbICHT CBOH

npOltpeccHOHaJIbHbIH npecTH)K MHltp0pMllPYH perropTepoB

lIHHOBHHKH H rrOJIHTHKH 06bJtIHO paCClHTbIBaIOT 1ffO Te He

OK~CH He6JIaro)lapHbIMll

ObIBIIIHii rocceKpeTapb reHpH lCHCCH~ep B npHHQHIIe

npH3HaeT peaJIbHOCTb COnepHHqeCTBa Me)K)IY npeCCOH H

BJIaCTblO HO ClHTaeT 1ffO OHO HMeeT CBOH rpaHHQbI BbIcrynaH B

1976 r Ha Cbe3r(e AMepHKaHCKOrO o6mecTBa ra3eTHbIX pe)laKshy

TOPOB lCHCCHH)I)Kep npH3BaJI cper(CTBa MaCCOBOH HHcpopMashy

QHH CTapaTbCH nOHHTb peaJThHbIe CJIO)KHOCTH npHHHTHH nOJIHshy

THqeCKHX pellIeHHH H H36eraTb HeraTHBH3Ma OCBemaH )IeHcrshy

BHH rrOJIHTHKOB

51 XOTeJI 6bI nOWIepKHYTh - CKa3aJI OH TOma -1ffO HaIUa

CTpaHa no MoeMY MHeHHIO npollIJla qepe3 60JIe3HeHHOe H

TPYquoe r(eCHTHJIeTHe OrnollIeHHH Me)K1(y npaBHTeJlbCTBOM H

npeccoH Hepe1(KO HanOMHHalOT KOHltpJIHKTbI nOJIKOBO)lQeB

BHOBb H BHOBb npOHrpbmaIO~x npe)KHHe 6HTBbI

51 BrrOJIHe nOHHMalO Ba)KHOCTb 3)10poBoro COnepHHqeCTBa

Me)K1(Y BJIaCTbIO H cper(CTBaMH MaCCOBOH HHCPOPMaQHH HO Bce

MbI - aMepHKaHQbI yqaCTHHKH 06mero )IeJIa HeJlb3H 3a6bmaTb

1ffO Mllp H nporpecc qeJIOBeqeCTBa B KOHe~OM CqeTe 3aBHCHT

OT aMepHKaHCKOH )IaJThHOBHquOCTH H yrropCTBa

KHccHHr()Kep - npH3HaHHbIH MaCTep TOHKOH apaH)KHshy

POBKH co06memrH 1(JIH npeccbI MHTepecHo 1ffO OH HH pa3Y He

KOMMeHTHpOBaJI B3rJIH1(bI aKKpe1(HTOBaHHOrO npH OeJIOM IJoMe

~HaJIHCTa KOTOPbIH B 1977 f 3aHHJI SlBHO Bpa)K1(e6Hyro

n03HQHIO rro OTHOllIeHHIO K TOmaIUHeMY npe3H)(eHry IJ)KHMMH

KaPTepyKorr(anHCaJI1ffO

Bcero qepe3 rrHTb C rrOJIOBHHOH He)leJlb rrOCJIe BCTyrrJIeHHH

123122

B ~OJDKHOCTb KapTep rrO-BHLlHMOMY BrrOJIHe rrpOHHKCH OTshy

HorneHHeM CBOHX rrpe~eCTBeHHHKOB K CeKpeTHOCTH H OOPbshy

oe C yreIKaMH HHltP0PMaIHH BbIpa3HB Cepbe3H)IO 03aOOIeHshy

HOCTb TeM ITO Iepecqyp MHoro Hapo~a HMeeT ~OCTII K CBe~eshy

HHm 0 CeKpeTHbIX Orrep~Hgx crre~CJIY)KO KapTep 3aRBHJI

ITO HeOOXO~o OrpaHHIHTb ~OCTYII K rrO~OOHbIM ~aHHbIM

B rrpHBe~eHHOM Bbnne OIIHcaHHH neIKO yCMOTpeTb HaMeK

Ha B3aHMHYIO Bpa)K~eOHOCTb rrpaBHTenbCTBa H rrpeCCbI

BrrpOIeM MHome rrOnHTHKH H ~CTpaTOPbl rrpeKpaCHO

rrOHHMaIOT ITO cpe~CTBa MaCCOBOH HHltpOPMaIHH B COCTOmIHB

OKa3aTb BeCbMa cepbe3Hoe BnHHHHe Ha ~eHTenbHOCTb H ~a)e COshy

CTaB rrpaBHTenbCTBa - OOHapO~OBaB HHltpOPM~HIO CaMoro Pa3shy

Horo XapaKTepa rropOH ~a)e COMHHTenbH)IO

ITpecc-ceKpeTapb Eenoro I1oMa MO)KeT rrOTpeOOBaTb

yopaTb C OPHltpHHrOB TeneKaMepbI rrOCIHTaB ITO 3TO B HHTeshy

pecax rrpe3~eHTa Kor~a rrpecc-ceKpeTapb KapTepa l)KoWI

ITay3M HMeHHO TaK H rroCTyrrHn Tene~HanHCT C3M I10shy

H~COH o6bHcHHn ero ~eHCTBHH TaK

ITay3nn CIHTaeT TeneBH~eHHe rOpHIHM cpe~cTBoM

MaCCOBOH HHltpOPMaIHH - Tenerrepe~aIH CHnbHee B03~eHCTshyBYIOTHa ay~opHIOHe)KenHrreIaTHoe cnOBO OH OIeHbHCKYCHO

HCrrOnb3YeT Ha oPHltpHHrax pa3nHIHbIe TpIOKH - HMIIpOBH3ashy

~IO BbmyMKH yxo~ OT BorrpocoB IT03TOMY-TO OH H He XOIeT

ITOObI 3pHTenH BH~enH ero rrOBe~eHHe BO BpeM BCTpeI C

~HanHCTaMH

TaKoe OrrHCaHHe rrpOTHBOpeIHT yoe~eHHIO JlmmMaHa ITO

rrpaBHTenbCTBO 00H3aHO ~aBaTb 06~ecTBY HCTHHHyIO KapTHHY

rrpOHcxo~~ero O~HaKO HnnIOcTpHpyeT B3aHMHoe correpshy

HHIeCTBO Me~ BJIaCTHMH H rrpeccoH BOT ITO rrHllieT rro 3TOMY

rroBo~ rrpecc-ceKpeTapb rrpe3~eHTa l)KoHcoHa l)Kop~ PHWi J1IOobIe rrOnHTlftleCKHe OCJIO)KHeHHH yxy~aIOT OTHomeshy

HHH Me~ rrpeccoH H rrpe3~eHToM B C03HaHHH cOTpy~KOB

Eenoro I1oMa rrpecca acco~HpyeTcH C HerrpHHTHOCTHMH ~M

rrpe3~eHTa PerropTepbI - 3T0 CTopoHHHe HaOJIIO~aTenH 3ashy

~aIO~e Maccy ManOrrpHHTHbIX BorrpocoB

IiLIBAET JIll nOJlE3HAH BPAJKLJEIiHOCIL

KaK CIHTaIOT HeKOTopbIe CTOPOHHHKH TeopHH rrpoTHshy

B060pCTBa Me~ rrpeccoH H rrpaBHTenbCTBOM TaKoe rrposhyTHB06opCTBO rrOJIe3HO MH CHCTeMbI B ~eJIOM rrOCKOnbKY CJIyshy

)KHT 3~0H OT orraCHbIX ~ oo~eCTBa rrOnHTlftleCKHX anbHHshy

COB Ho Bce paBHO He HCHO KaKyIO CTerreHb rrO~OOHOH BPa)shy

~eOHOCTH cne~eT CIHTaTb HeOOXOLlHMOH He BpeLlHT nH 00shy

~eCTBeHHbIM HHTepeCaM CnHTI[KOM CHnbHOe rrpoTHBooOPCTBO

BJIaCTH H rrpeccbI rro~bIBaIO~ee sepy B ~OCTH)KeHHe oo~eHashy

~OHanbHbIX ~eJIeH

ITo MHeHHIO perropTepa )Krong YHTKosepa rrpecca ocseshy

~ag paooTY rrpaBHTenbCTSa ~OJDKHa cne~osaTb TpeM OCHOSshyHbIM rrp~HrraM

1 Cooo~aTb 0 TOM ITO YTBep~aIOT snaCTH

2 BbIHCHHTb HCTHHHOCTb 3THX yrsep~eHHH 3 Orrpe~enHTb MOryr nH paooTaTb rrpe~nO)KeHHbIe rrposhy

rpaMMbI (Hnu eCnH peIfb H~eT 00 Y)Ke ocymeCTBneHHbIX o~eHHshyBaTb CTerreHb HX BbIIIOJIHeHHH H rrpo~THBHOCTH)

3TH pe~errTbI Bbrrng~HT OIeHb rrpocTbIMH H JIOmWblMH

TeM He MeHee rrOnHTonor MTH3JI ~e COJIa ITyJI ~orrycKaeT ~JIH rrpeCCbI e~e o~y ltPYHK~HIO ltpOpMHpOBaTb oo~eCTBeHHbIH KOHceHCYC rro OTHOrneHHIO K oo~eHa~HOHanbHbIM rrOJIBTHIecshy

KHM rrporpaMMaM KOTOPbIH ObI rapaHTHpOBan HX ocymeCTBJIeshy

HHe HeCMOTpH Ha Bce pa3HornaCHH HeH30e)KHbIe B TaKOH

orpOMHOH CTpaHe KaK AMepHKa

CrrocooHa JIB rrpecca O~OBpeMeHHO ~eMeHTHpOBaTb 00shy

~eCTBO H B TO )Ke BpeMH CJI~Tb HCTOlIHHKOM KpHTHKH rro~shy

lac ~a)e H 3JIoyrroTpeOJIHH CBOHM BJIHHHHeM

MHome BepHT ITO rrpecca ~eHCTBHTenbHO crrOCOOHa rro~shy~ep)KHBaTh rrpe~JIO)KeHHH H rrporpaMMbI He BbI3bIBaIO~e pacshy

Kona B Oo~eCTBe H TeM CaMbIM ltpopMHpOBaTb eLlHHCTBO MHeHHH

B Ha~HOHanbHOM MaClliTaOe O~aKO rrpOTHBHHKH 3TOH ~eH

OTMeIaIOT ITO He TaK-TO JIeIKO rrpOBeCTH IeTKyIO rpaHH~y

Me~ CrrOpHbIMH H OTHOCHTenbHO oeCCrrOpHblMH BOrrpOCaMH

124 125

IIpeKpaCHhIM rrpHMepOM MO)KeT CJIY)KHTh OCBemeHHe

aMepHKaHCKHMH cpeuCTBaMH MaccoBOli HHqOpMaQHH BOmI B

HHuOKHTae B 1968 r auMHHHCTpaQHSI JlHHAOHa IVKoHcoHa Hashy

3BaJIa SIHBapcKoe HaCTylIJIeHHe rrpHypOtIeHllOe K BheTHaMCKoMy

rrpa3oHHKY TeT KPyrrHOH rrooeuoH COI03HHKOB pa3pymHBIllell

ooecrrocooHoCTh BheTKOHra COTpyuHHKH auMHHHCTpaQHH

pe3Ko KPHTHKOBaJIH rrpeccy HaCTaHBaBIIIYIO lITO AJISI aMepHshy

KaHCKHX BOHCK 3Ta orrepaQHSI ooepHyJIaCh qaKTHtIeCKHM rropashy

)KeHHeM qepe3 HeCKOJlhKO JIeT rrOCJIe rryOJIHKaQHH uOKYMeHshy

TOB IIeHTaroHa C rroupooHoH HHqopMaQHeH 00 yqaCTHH CllA

B BOHHe B HHooKHTae rrpecca H rryoJIHKa Y3HaJIH lITO aMepHKaHshy

C-Koe BoeHHoe PYKOBOuCTBO Ha caMOM uene rrpeKpacHo 3HaJIO

lITO BheTKOHr COXpaHHJI CBOH pecypchI H BoiiHa oyueT rrposhy

uOJI)KaThCSI

XOTSI aoMHHHCTpaQHSI HaCTaHBaJIa ~ITO BoiiHa BO BheTHaMe

BeJIaCh pauH 3aIQHThI MHpa H CBOOOAhI MHJIJIHOHhI aMepHKaHshy

QeB CtIHTaJIH HHatIe H rrpecca HHqOpMHpOBaJIa aYAHTOpHIO 00

3THX paCXO)K]leHHSIX BO B3rJISIAax 3TH ueOaThI rrpeKpaCHO

HJIJIIOCTpHpyroT OOCY)K]leHHe SIEHO KOHqJIHKTHOH rrpOOJIeMhI

BhI3BaBIlleH Cephe3Hhle CrrOphI B OOmeCTBe OPHaKO HeTpYWIO

rrpHBecm H upyme rrpHMephI rue KOHqJIHKTHOCTh He CTOJlh

3aMeTHa

- qTOOhI He uorrYCTHTh pa3BHTHSI HHqIDmHH rrpaBHTeJlhshy

CTBO rrpOCHT HaCeJIeHHe He 3arracaThCSI TOBapaMH BrrpOK H

rrpecca rryOJIHKyeT 3TH oOpameHHSI

- qTOOhI YMeHhIIIHTh tIHCJIO )KepTB uOPO)KHhIX rrposhy

HcmeCTBHH rrpaBHTeJlhCTBO rrpH3hmaeT aBTOMOOHJIHCTOB rroJlhshy

30BaThCSI rrpHCTSI)KHhIMH peMHSIMH H He rrpeBhIIllaTh rrpeshy

ueJIa CKOPOCTH Ha uoporax

- B QeJISIX 3amHThI OKp~aIOmeH cpeAhI BJIaCTH HaCTaRshy

BaIOT Ha rrepepaOOTKe KOHcepBHhIX OaHOK H OYMa)KHhIX OTXOshy

uOB H rrpH3hmaroT HaCeJIeHHe TmaTeJIhHO 3aKphmaTb BOuOshy

rrpOBOoHhIe KpaHhI

- IIpecca rrpeBpamaeT crraceHHoro BO BpeMSI JIeCHorO rrashy

)Kapa MeJIBe)KOHKa CMOKH B CHMBOJI OOPbObI 3a COXpaHeHHe

JIeCHbIX OoraTCTB

126

- IIpecca rrouuep)KHBaeT BbIIIYCK OOJIHraQHH uJISI

qHHaHCHpOBaHHSI IIIKOJI OHOJIHOTeK H rrpOtIHX rrOJIe3HbIX

yqpe)K]leHHH

HeJIb3SI 3apaHee CKa3aTb BbI30BYT JIH 3TH cHTyaQHH

pa3HornaCHSI B OOmeCTBe - Bce 3aBHCHT OT Toro KaKOBa oyshy

ueT peaKQHSI rryOJIHKH B QeJIOM H CaMHX 3aHHTepeCOBaHHbIX

rpyrrrr B tIaCTHOCTH IIOtITH JIIOOOH BblrryCK OOJIHraQHH CBSI3aHshy

HMH C yseJIHtIeHHeM HaJIOra Ha COOCTBeHHOCTb HaBepHSIKa

OKa)KeTCSI CrrOpHhIM ueJIOM illoqepbI-uaJIbHOOOHmHKH CKOshy

pee Bcero 3aSIBSIT lITO 55-MHJlhHhm rrpeueJI CKOPOCTH Ha aBshy

TOCTpauax ueHCTBHTeJlhHO MO)KeT crraCTH CKOJlhKO-TO )KH3HeH

HO CJIHIllKOM uoporo OOOHpeTCSI lIM H BceH CTpaHe ua K TOMy

)Ke MaJIO KTO oyueT ero COOJIIOuaTb

B OOmeM rrpecca oe3YCJIOBHO - Ba)KHeHIIIHH HHCTpYMeHT

HHqopMHpOBaHHSI OOmeCTBa 0 rrpoQecce rrpHHSITHSI rrOJIHTHshy

tIeCKHX peIlleHHH HO HaCKOJlhKO OHa crrocooCTByeT OOmeCTshy

BeHHOMy CrrJIOtIeHHIO - 3TO eme BOrrpOC ECJIH ua)Ke HeKoe

peIlleHHe BHerrme He BbI3bIBaeT OCOObIX pa3HornaCHH H3 3Toro

BOBce He CJIeuyeT lITO rrpecca ero rrOMep)KHT A rrOKa HeT KOHshy

Qa crropaM tITO eCTh cpeuCTBa MaccoBoH HHqOpMaQHH - rrapTshy

Hep BJIaCTH HJIH )Ke ee correpHHK

)KYPHaJIHCTbI H caMH KPHTHKYIOT rrpeccy H3BecTHbIH

rryOJIHQHCT IIaTpHK BbIOKeHeH 3aHlIMaBIIIHH Ba)KHyro u0JI)Kshy

HOCTh B BeJIOM nOMe IIpH rrpe3HpeHTe HHKcoHe CtIHTaeT lITO

rrpecca BCTylIaeT B IIpOTHBOOOPCTBO JIHIllD c TeMH JIHQaMH H

HHCTHTYTaMH C KOTOPbIMH paCXO)JHTCSI BO MHeHHSIX a C OCshy

TaJIhHhIMH cOrJIaCOBbIBaeT CBOH ueHCTBHSI H COTpYAHHtIashy

eT B TO )Ke BpeMSI 0003peBaTeJlh HbIO-JloPK TaiiMc TOM

BHKep HaCTOSITeJlhHO rrouqepKHBaeT lITO cOrrepHHtIeCTBO Me)K]ly

cpeucTBaMH MaccOBOH HHqOPMaQHH H BJIaCTSIMH HeOOXOpHMO

qacTo rOBopSIT lITO rrpaBHTeJlhCTBO HepaOOTOCIIOCOOHO

eCJIH tIHHOBHHKH He B COCTOSIHHH peIllHTb BHYTpeHHHX rrposhy

OJIeM 3a 3aKpbIThIMH JlBepSIMH OpHaKO uOKYMeHTbI IIeHTaroHa

o BoiiHe BO BheTHaMe C HeObmaJIOH SICHOCTbIO peMOHCTpHpyshy

lOT lITO eCJIH OqHQHaJIbHhle JIHQa 3amHmeHhI OT Hau30pa 00shy

127

meCTBa nyCTh H BeChMa HenpIDITHOrO HX oeHCTBIDI aOCOJIIOTshy

HO HeKOHTpOJrnpyeMbI

llPYIlIE nplIIHIILI PA3HOTJIACUii

CTapasICh HamynaTh pa3YMHbIe rpamruhI conepHHtleCTBa

l()PHaJIHCThI H aoMHHHCTpaTOpbI rrpaKTHlIeCKH HHKoroa He Haxoshy

IID Oomero Sl3hIKa ITo MHeHmo IIOJIHTOJIOra ITOJIa YHBepa aTO

MO)lHO OTlIaCTH OObSlCHHTh JIHTepaTypHOH qOPMOH npelshy

CTaBJIeHHSI HOBOCTeH rle rocnooCTByroT JIHOO nOXBaJIhI JIHOO

nOpHrraHHSI B TO )le BpeMSl CTHJIb aHaJIHTHKOB HeHTpaJIeH C

OOSl3aTeJIhHbIM conOCTaBJIeHHeM IOCTOHHCTB H HelOCTaTKOB

pa3JIHllHbIX nOJIHTHlIeCKHX KypCOB )KypHaJIHCThI)Ie 3aSlBJISIlOT

lITO Sl3bIK COBpeMeHHbIX IIOJIHTHKOB BeChMa OaJIeK OT cnOKOHshy

HOH oecnpHCTpaCTHOCTH XOTSI CaMH OHH aToro MorYT H He

3aMelIaTh

YHJIbSlM KPHCTOJImiddot paCCy)KrJaeT no-IpyroMY ITo ero MHeshy

HHIO )lYPHaJIHCTaM (KaK BIIpOlIeM H nOJIHTHKaM) lIaCTO He XBashy

TaeT CnerrHaJIhHbIX 3HaHHH lITOOhI IeHCTBHTeJIbHO cephe3HO

OOc~aTh CJIO)lHble npOOJIeMbI COBpeMeHHoro rOCYIapCTBa

IToaTOMY nHIIIeT KPHCTOJI peIIopTephI orpaHHlIHBaIOTCSI

rrpOrreuypHbIMH aCneKTaMH nOJIHTHlleCKHX peIIIeHHii B KOTOshy

phIX OHH HenJIOXO pa30HpaIOTCSI onHChmaSI CKIDKeM n03HIIHH

OTIeJIbHbIX KorrrpeCCMeHOB HJIH XOo cyoeOHbIX 3aceoaHHH B

HTore IIooaraeT KPHCTOJI BMeCTO TOllHOH nooalIH qaKTOB TOpshy

)leCTByeT rrpHCTpaCTHbIH H BOHHCTBeHHbm CTHJIb

PelaKTOp rapOJlbl nHCTOH He COrJIaCeH C TaKOH HHTepshy

npeTaIIHeH OH YTBep)KrJaeT lITO KpHTHKa IIpeCCbI HaIIpaBJIeshy

Ha He Ha CaMO rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO a Ha KOHKpeTHbIX JIHrr ero COshy

CTaBJISIIOrrrHX - nOJIHTHKOB H aoMHHHCTpaTopOB

ITpOTHBHHKH MOrYT pa3oeJIIDh Koe-KaKHe rreJIH H B3rJISlshy

IbI A~OKaTbI lIaCTO HMeIOT Oomyro rreJIb OIDKe eCJIH BbICTYshy

IIaIOT B KalIeCTBe rrpOTHBHHKOB B JIIOOOM cJIYlae SI He BCTpeshy

CbIH HpBtlHa KpllcmOlla 8 npOtUlOJf ZJlaea lUmama compyOHIIKoe BuqeshynpealloeHma KyaiJlla

lIaJI HH erJHHOro IOpHCTa KOTOPbIH ObI He 3aSlBJIstJI lITO HCTHHa

H crrpaBeIJIHBOCTb Ha ero CTopOHe

llHCTOH IeJIaeT Ba)IHOe YTOllHeHHe

sI He B BOCTopre OT Oe3IJYMHoro HCIIOJIb30BaHIDI CJIOBa

laquoconepHHlIeCTBOraquo IJISI OIIHcaHHSI OTHOIIIeHHH npeCCbI C

npaBHTeJIbCTBOM B JIIOOOM cJIYlae He CJIeuyeT CllHTaTh lITO

rrpecca Bpa)KrJeOHa aMepHKaHCKHM HHCTHTYTaM OIHaKO CBOshy

OOIHasI npecca IOJI)KHa HCnOJIb30BaTh He OrJHH JIHDIb IOOpOshy

IJYIIIHbm CKenCHC HO H Ipyme HHCTpYMeHThI

llHCTOH pac~aeT BIIOJIHe pa3YMHO ITOJIHTHlleCKOMY peshy

nOPTepy e)leIHeBHO npHXOrJHTCSI CTaJIKHBaTbCSI C TeMH OT KOro

3aBHCHT paOOTa OOJlblIIHX H MaJIhIX rOCYlapCTBeHHhIX yqpe)lshy

IeHHH COOOmeHHSI 0 nporpaMMax BbICTYnJIeHHSlX H oeHCTshy

BHSIX aTHX JIIOIeH IIOCTOSIHHO MeJIbKaIOT B HOBOCTSIX lITO CaMO

no ceoe rrpeBpamaeT HX B OOmeCTBeHHble qHrypbI )KYPHaJIHCThI

ropa31O lIame IIOJIyqaIOT CBeleHHSI nOJIh3YSlCh JIHlIHbIMH

KOHTaKTaMH B npaBHTeJIbCTBeHHbIX BelOMcTBax He)leJIH H3yshy

lIaS IOKYMeHTbI

OCHOBHble cpymcrrHH CJly)IObI BHYTpeHHHX COOPOB CllIA

(qelepaJIhHOrO HaJIoroBoro BelOMCTBa) peIKO ooc~aIOTCSI H

ocnapHBaIOTCSI rrpeCCOH KOTOpaSl TeM He MeHee CBoeBpeMeHHO

HHqopMHpyeT HaCeJIeHHe 0 HaJIorOBbIX npaBHJIax H HX H3Meshy

HeHHSlX

TaK Ha3hmaeMble OTHOIIIeHHSl conepHHlIeCTBa B03HHKaIOT

nol BJIHSlHHeM MHOfHX qaKTOPOB Bce MO)leT OKa3aTbCSI BIDKshy

HbIM - )lYPHaJIHCTCKHH CTHJIb XapaKTep peoaKTHpOBaHHSI

MeCTO IaHBoro co06meHHSI cperJH IPyrHX HOBOCTeH BhmaJIH

CJIYlaH KOrla HcnOJIb30BaHHe MHOr03HallHbIX rJIarOJIOB IIpeshy

BpamaJIO COBepIIIeHHO HeHTpaJIhHble no 3aMbICJIY pelaKTOpOB

COOOmeHHSI B nOlITH lITO OOBHHeHIDI

CEKPETLrnPABIITEJILCTBA

MO)IHO CrrpOCHTh rrpH KaKHX OOCTOIDeJIbCTBax BTOp)leshy

HHe npeCCbI B IeJIa BJIaCTeH HallHHaeT IIPHOOpeTaTb xapaKTep

128 129

Heo60CHOBaHlIOro H IIOTOMY He~OIIYCTIIMOm IIpOTImOCTOsIllID[

ITo MHeHHIO HeKOTOpbIX KypHaJIHCTOB peIIOpTep BIIpase

HCIIOJIb30BaTh JII06yro HHCPOpM~IO IIOIIaBIJIYlO B ero pym

DHH ClJJITaIOT CfIO TaKruI YCTaHOBKa CaMa IIO ce6e HeMHHyeMO

BbI3bIBaeT BpaK~e6HOCTb MeK~y cpe~CTBaMH MaccoBot

lmCPOPMawm H IIpaBHTeJIbCTBOM

B 1970 r o603peBaTeJIb AxlteK AHJepcoH IIOJIYIllJI ITyshy

JIHIIepOBCKyro IIpeMHIO 3a TO CfIO 06HapO~OBaJI KOHltp~eHshy

DHaJIbHbIe ~eTaJIH 3ace~aHHH IIpe3H~eHTCKoro COBeTa

H~OHaJIbHOH 6e30IIaCHOCTH AAMmmCTp~SI PHtJap~a HHKshyCOHa BHeIIIHe He BbIKa3bffiaJIa IIpeWIOqTeHHSI HH O~OH H3 CToshy

POH B HH~O-II8KHCTaHCKOM KOHcpJIHKTe O~HaKO COBeTHHK

IIpe3~eHTa IIO BOIIpocaM HaDHOHaJIbHOH 6e30IIaCHOCTH reHpIl

KHCCH~ep 3a 3aKpbIThIMH ~epSIMH TPe60BaJI CfI06bI roshy

cy~apCTBeHHbIH ~eIIapTaMeHT 3aHSlJI IIPOIIaKHCTaHCKyro II0311shy

DHIO AH~epCOH IIo~eprcSI KpHTHKe 3a TO CfIO IIO MHeHHIQ

BJIaCTeH em IIY6JIHK~SI HaHeCJIa yrnep6 H~OHaJIbHOH 6e3oshy

IIaCHOCTH AMepHKH

MOKHO B03pa3lITb CfIO A~epCOH IIOJIYIllJI CBOH CBe~eshyHHSI B BbICIImX KOp~Opax BJIaCTH a CaM cpaKTHlIeCKH HCIIOJIshy

HHJI pOJIb KYPbepa DeHCTBHTeJIbHO peIIopTep MOKeT CTaTh opyshy

~eM lHHOBHHKa KeJIaIOIDerO OpraHH30BaTh YTeIKY HHcpopMashy

DHH yK eCJIH ~HaJIHCT pa3~o6bIJI 3aKpbIThIe CBe~eHHSI HX

IIpaKTIIIeCKH HeB03MOKHO 3aCeKpeTHTb CHOBa H TaKruI IIY6shy

JIHK~SI 06bIlIHO JIHIIIb YCIIJIHBaeT OIDyIDeHHe Bp~e6HOCTH

Me~ IIpeCCOH H BJIaCTSIMH

BOT IIpeKpaCHbIH IIpHMep IIo~06HOH CHTYawm DOIIYCTIIM

cpHpMa IIJIaHllpyeT IIOCTPOHTh HOBoe IIpeWIpHSITHe II cpa3y

HeCKOJIbKO ropo~OB BbIp(lKaIOT KeJIaHHe IIpe~OCTaBHTb CBOIO

TeppHTOpHIO - cTPoHTeJIbCTBO o6eIDaeT ThICSIlIH pa60llllX MeCT

H 3KOHOMHlIeCKOe IIpODBeTaHHe XO~SIT CJIym lITO cpHpMa

CKJIOHSleTCSI B IIOJIb3Y o~oro H3 ropO~OB Bce IIeperOBopbI

~ 3a 3aKpbIThIMH ~epSIMH H ropO~CKHe lHHOBHHKH yseshy

peHbI CfIO 06Hapo~oBaHHe IIpe~apHTeJIbHOrO pemeHHSI MOKeT

IIOMemaTb YCIIexy c~eJIKH PeIIopTep ropO~CKOH ra3eThI 06eshy

130

IDaeT coxpaHHTb 3TOT ceKpeT OKH~aSl MOMeHTa Kor~a BJIaCTH CaMII C~eJIaIOT ocpHDHaJIbHOe 3aHBJIeHHe

B HTore HHCPOPM~SI 6y~eT IIpe~aMepeHHO IIOJIOKeHa IIO~ CYKHO XOTSI B KOHDe KOHDOB H Bb~eT Ha IIOBepXHOCTh Ho ~eshy

JIO B TOM CfIO IIpaBHJIO B03~epKHTeCb OT IIY6JIHKaDHH IIOKa

He IIOJIYIllTe OT Hac 3KCKJII03HBHyro HHltPOPM~IO He Bce~a JIerKO IIpHMeHHTh

ra3eTa ~yroro ropo~a maHChI KOToporo He CTOJIb 6JIeshy

CTSIIDH 3HaeT CfIO TepSlTh HelIero H BIIOJIHe MOKeT 06Hapo~oshy

BaTh 113BeCTHble eH CBe~eHHSI B HTore TaHHOe CTaHOBHTCSI SI8shy

HbIM HecMoTPSI Ha Bce IIpe~OCTepeKeHHSI MYHH1umaJIbHbIX lHHOBHHKOB

38KYJIHCHOe o6c~eHHe 3TOH rHIIOTeTHlIeCKOH C~eJIKH MOKeT IIpHBeCTH H K ~yrHM IIOCJIe~CTBHSIM CK(lKeM cpHpMa

MOKeT YCTaHOBlITb aBTOMaTHlIeCKOe 06opy~oBaHHe H lIBCJIO

pa60lIBx MeCT OK(lKeTCSI B ~ecSITh pa3 MeHhme lIeM HMeSIJIHCb

ropo~cKHe BJIaCTH TeppHTopHSl BbmeJIeHHaH ropo~OM IIO~ cTPOHTeJIbCTBO 3aBO~a He 6meT HCIIOJIb30BaHa OIITHMaJIbHbIM

06pa30M Y c~eJIKH OK(lKeTCSI 60JIbme MHHyCOB lIeM IIJIIOCOB

ECJIH 6bI C CaMoro HalIaJIa o6cy~eHHe 6bIJIO OTKPbIThlM 3Toro

6bI He IIpOH30IIIJIO B HTore peIIopTep cornaCHBlIIHHCSI IIPOMOJIshy

lIaTh pHcKyeT IIOTepeH IIpocpeCCHOHaJIbHOH 06neKTHBHOCTH H

He3aBHCHMOCTH

KAKHE fPAIIIIIlLI HE CJIEnYET llPECTYllATL

TeJIepeIIOpTep B IIpSIMOM 3cpupe HeIIpHHY~eHHO 6ece~shyeT C M3POM ropo~a Do IIOPbI ~O BpeMeHH em BOIIpOCbI BIIOJIHe

6e306H~I - CTpOHTeJIbCTBO HOBbIX OlIBCTHbIX coopYKeHHii

y60pKa CHera H IIpH06peTeHHe MYJIHDHIIaJIHTeTOM YlIacTKa 6eshy

pera ~JISI 30HbI OT~IXa Ho XO~ 6ece~I MeHSleTCSI Ha IIPOIIIJIOH

He~eJIe o~ H3 lIJIeHOB MYJIHDHIIaJIbHOrO COBeTa HeO~aHHO

IIO~aJI B OTCTaBKY COCJIaBIIIHCb Ha ~eJIa H ceMeHHbIe IIpo6JIeMbI

IfBOT peIIOpTep BHe3aIIHO CIIpaIIIHBaeT M3pa KaK IIOBJIHSleT yxo~ 3Toro lIJIeHa COBeTa Ha IIpe~CTOSlIDee mJIOCOBaHHe IIO IIOBO~

131

BBe~eHHH rOpO~CKOrO rro~oxo~oro HaJIOra ~3p MTHOBeHHO

qyeT HeJI~Oe - 3Ta TeMa OTHlOWgt He oe300H~a - H OTBeqaeT

C OCTOpmKHOCThIO

3~eCb eCTb HM qeM 3amMaTbCH MYHHDHrraJIbHOMY COshy

BeTY Eoo HO eCJIH BbI He B03pIDKaeTe H rrOKa He XOTeJI ObI

rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM

PerropTep OCTaBJIHeT CKOJIb3KyID TeMY H rrepeXO~T K ~Yshy

rHM BOrrpOCaM O~aKO OCTaeTCH HerrOHHTHbIM Kor~a HMeHHO

CKpbIToe H BHeIIIHe He3aMeTHOe correpHWIeCTBO Me~ BJlacshy

THMH H rrpeccofi Ha~eT qpe3MepHO YCJIO)lllHTb paoOTY MMHshyHHCTpaTHBHbIX OpraHOB (B ~aHHOM cnyqae - ropO~CKHX)

HH O~HH )KYPHaJIHCT He CTaHeT YTBep~aTh ~O BrrOJIHe

3aKOHHbIfi Borrpoc 0 rrOCJIe~CTBHHX OTCTaBKH qJIeHa MYHHshy

nHrraJIbHOrO COBeTa MO)l110 rrOCqHTaTb He~orrYCTHMbIM ~aBJIeshy

HHeM Ha M3pa Ho ~O rrpOH30fi~eT eCJIH ~HaJIHCT He rrpHshy

MeT BO BHHMaHHe He)KeJIaHHe M3pa oocy~aTh 3TY TeMY H Bepshy

HeTCH K Hefi BTOpH~O ~a eIDe rrpHcoBoKyrrHB ~O rp~aHe

HMelOT rrpaBO Ha HHCPOPMaDHIO IlorrYCTHM TaK)Ke ~O rrOCJIe

eIDe o~ofi YKJIOWIHBofi perrJIHKH perropTep HaCTaHBaR Ha OTshy

BeTe rrOBTopHT BOrrpOC H B TpeTHfi pa3

IIpH )KeJIaHHH )KypHaJIHCT MO)KeT BHe3arrHO rrpeBpaTHTh

crrOKOHHoe H ~~eJIlOOHOe HHTepBblO B He~o BeCbMa HerrpHshy

HTHoe H3pH~HO rrO~rrOpTHB OTHorneHHH Me~ CTOpOHaMH

IIpe~cTaBHM ceoe qTO perropTep B~yr rrpOH3HeceT rrOBepshy

HyBrrrnCb K 3pHTeJIHM IIocMoTpHTe HaBbIoopHoe JIHDO He )KeJIashy

lOIDee OTBeqaTh Ha Borrpoc BbI3BaHHbrn Harnefi 3aOOTofi 00 00shy

IDeCTBeHHbIX HHTepecax A rrOTOM BHOBb ooepHeTcH K rJIaBe

ropo~a H CrrpOCHT I1TaK rocrro~ M3P BbI cooHpaeTecb OTBeshy

qaTb HJIH HeT

Borrpoc 0 KOTOPOM ~eT peTh OblJl 3MaH 3MOJIrO ~o TOshy

ro KaK oece~a rrepelliJla B CTOJIb HarrpH)KeHHyID cpa3Y ECJIH

perroPTep crrepBa ~aeT Borrpocy rroBHcHYTb B B03mXe a 3aTeM

arpeccHBHo HaCTaHBaeT Ha OTBeTe TO TaKOe rrOBe~eHHe MO)l110

cqeCTh He~oopOCOBeCTHbIM rro OTHorneHHIO K cooece~y C

~yrofi CTOPOHbI eCJIH )KYPHaJIHCT )KeJIaR COXpaHHTb XOpO-

IIIHe OTHOrneHHH C M3POM rr03BOJIHeT TOMY oe3 rrOCJIe~cTBHfi

YKJIOHHTbCH OT OTBeTa OH He BbrnOJIHHeT cBoefi rrpocpecshy

CHOHaJIbHOfi 00H3aHHOCTH HHcpopMHpOBaTh rryOJIHKY 000 Bcex

acrreKTax H rrOCJIe~CTBHHX OTCTaBKH qneHa MYHHDHrraJIbHOrO

COBeTa IIYCTh H HeCKOJIbKO PHCKOBaHHO ~ ceOH CaMoro HO

~HaJIHCT Mor ObI rrorrpOOOBaTh rrOCHJIbHee HIDKaTh Ha M3pa

TaKHM 00pa30M OTHomeHHH correpHWIeCTBa OKa3bmaIOTCH

OaJIaHCHpOBaHHeMHarpaHHTaKTaH aHTarOHH3Ma COTP~eCTBa H rpyoofi Bp~eoHoCTH

A BOT ~yrofi rrpHMep IIpe~ce~aTeJIb MeCTHOrO IDKOJIbHOshy

ro COBeTa rro rrpocpeccHH Bpaq Oepe)KeT BpeMH H BCTpeqaeTCH C

perrOpTepaMH TOJIbKO B qaCbI paoOTbI COBeTa PerropTep YTpeHshy

Hefi ra3eTbI c~aIOInHfi ~o BrrpaBe 3MaBaTb OCPHnHaJIbHbIM

JIHDaM BOrrpOCbI B JIIOooe BpeMH CYTOK B rrOJIHOTh rrO~HMaeT rrpe~ce~aTeJIH C rrOCTeJIH ~OObI 3MaTh HeCKOJIbKO BOrrpOCOB 0

IDKOJIbHbIX ~eJIax ToMY 3Ta BOJIbHOCTb KIDKeTCH KaK MHHHMyM

HeYMeCTHofi H B HTore OH pacDeHHBaeT H CaMoro ~HaJIHCTa Hero rryOJIHKamm KaK KOHCPPOHTanHOHHbIe Bce MOrJIO ObI

ObITb HHaqe eCJIH ObI pe~aKTOp ra3eTbI YCTyrrHJI rrpOCboe

rrpe~ce~aTeJIH H OT03BaJI perropTepa

Kor~a B 1971 r ra3eTe HbIO-lloPK TafiMc ~aJIOCb rroJIYshy

qHTh KOIlHlO cOBeprneHHo CeKpeTHOrO MHorocTpaHH~oro OTshy

qeTa ~HHCTepCTBa OOOpOHbI 00 aMepHKaHCKHX ~eficTBHHX BO BbeTHaMe ee pe~aKToPbI HaqaJIH rryOJIHKOBaTb 3TH ~OKYshyMeHThI Tor~aIIIHHfi MHHHCTP IOCTHnHH IQKOH ~eJIJI ~o-shyOHJICH cy~eoHoro rroCTaHOBJIeHHH BpeMeHHo 3arrpeTHBrnerO

~aJIbHefimyIO rrYOJIHKanH1O 3THX MaTepHaJIOB Ha TOM OCHOBashy

HHH ~O OHa 3aTparHBaJIa HHTepeCbI HanHOHaJIbHofi oe30rracshy

HOCTH Coe~eHHbIX IIITaTOB

B 3TOM cnyqae rrpaBHTeJIbCTBO perrrnJIO qTO rrpecca rrepeshy

llIJIa rpaHHnbI ~orryCTHMoro H rrOTOMY ee H~O OCTaHOBHTh

IlIDKe HeKOTopbIe qJIeHbI ~HaJIHCTCKOro Koprryca COqJIH ~o HeJIb3H OblJlO rrpe~aBaTb omaCKe CTOJIb ~eJIHKaTHbIe CBe~eHlIH HeCMOTpH Ha TO ~O QTqeT OblJl rrOWOTOBJIeH 3a HeCKOJIbKO JIeT

~O HaqaJIa ero rryOJIHKanHH B ra3eTe

133132

XOTSI BepXOBHblH Cy~ CIIIA B KOHIJe KOHIJOB rrOMep)KaJI

rrpaBo rrpeCCbI rreqaTaTb yrrOMIIH)TbIe ~OKMeHTbI IIeHTarOHa

H HbIO-HOPK TaltMc B0300HOBHJIa rryOJIHKaIJIDO aTO He CImMashy

eT rrpOOJIeMbI 0003HaqeHHOH B 3amaBHH HaCTOlllI1erO pa3~eshy

JIa - ~O KaKOH CTerreHH rrpecca MO)KeT rrpOTHBorroCTaBlISIIL

ceoll rOCy)IapCTBeHHOH BJIacm OOII1HH OTBeT Ha aTOT Borrpoc

TaK ~O CHX rrop H He cltP0PMYJIHPOBaH

PA11II AlIMIfHlifCTPATHBHOrO YIJO6CTBA

Koppecrro~eHT BrrOJIHe COJIH)HOH ra3eTbI oCBemaroIIJHH

paoOTy MyHHIJHIIaJIHTeTa Y3HaeT ltITO OTKpbIDaCb Ba)KHaR aAMHshy

HHcTpamBHaR BaKaHCHII rrOCKOJIbKY rrpe)KHlffi OOJI~aTeJIb aToA

~OJI)KHOCTH yrneJI B OCTaBKy PaOOTall H~ perrOpTa)KeM ~shy

HaJIHCT Y3HaeT Koe-KaKHe Ba)KHble ~eTaJIH Map XOqeT Ha3Hashy

ltIHTb Ha OCBooo~BlileeCII MeCTO CBoero rrOJIHTHltIeCKOrO COI03shy

HHKa OWIaKO He MO)KeT C~eJIaTb aTom oe3 COrJIaCHII CBoeH rrapshy

mH IIPH aTOM OH XOqeT H30e)KaTb HerrpHIITHOH CHryaIJHH KOToshy

paR B03HHKHeT eCJIH rrapmll OTKpblTO He O~OOPHT ero rrepBom

BblOopa Be~Tor~a rrpH~eTCSI rrpe~O)KHTbary~OJI)KHOCTbKOMYshy

HHOy~ ellJe TaKltITO HeT Hlfqero y~HTeJIbHOrO ltITO Map rrpe~shy~ ~

rrOltIHTaeT Becm rreperOBopbI 0 Ha3HaqeHHH H rrapmHHOM O~Oshy

opeHHH B ceKpeTe OT rrOCTOpOHHHX

C TOltIKH 3peHHII caMoro Mapa TaKall TaKmKa BrrOJIHe ~Oshy

rrycmMa OWIaKO perropTep 00SI3aH 3~aTb caMOMY ceoe p~ BOshy

rrpOCOB ECJIH pa~ y~OOCTBa ropO~CKoro HaqaJIbCTBa OH B03shy

~ep)KHTCII OT JIIOOblX HaMeKOB Ha TO KOMY Map XOqeT rrpe~OCTashy

BHTh OTKpbmrnyroCII BaKaHCIDO He rrocTp~aroT JIH HHTepeCbI

OOllJeCTBa AeHCTBHTeJIbHO JIH rOpO)KaHaM Ba)KHO Y3HaTh HMII

Ka~~aTa 3a HeCKOJIbKO WIeH ~O Toro KaK OHO oy~eT oOnsmshy

JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo

B03HHKaIOT H ~pyrHe BorrpOCbI GrOHT JIH TpaTHTb CHJIbI

Ha ~OObmaHHe cBegeHHH KOTopbIe TaK HJIH HHaqe oy~ BCKope

OltpHIJHaJIbHO oOHapO~OBaHhI He oygeT JIH rryOJIHKaIJHII HMeH

Ka~aTOB ~o OltpHIJHaJIbHOm OObSIBJIeHHSI Bcem JIHIIIb He~shy

HOH rrOpqeH OTHoIlleHHH C BJIaCTIIMH

B CBII3H co CKa3aHHbIM He JIHIIIHe rrpHBeCTH MHeHHSI

pegaKTOpOB HbIO-HoPK TaHMC MaKca ltlgtpeHKeJIII H ~eHMshyca PecToHa BOT ltITO rrHIlleT ltIgtpeHKeJIb 00 YOJIa)KeHHH a~shyHHcTpaTopoB H ero rrOCJIe~CTBHIIX

B ObITHOCTb MOIO ~rrJIOMamqeCKHM KoppeCrrOH~eHTOM MHe rrpHXO~JIOCb CrrOpHTb C PeCToHoM OH CqHTaJI qTO ~JIII

rrpeCTH)Ka ra3eTbI qpe3BblqaiiHo rrOJIe3HO 3a TpH WIg ~o 0ltpHshy

IJaJIbHOrO OObSIBJIeHHII pa3Y3HaTb H cooolI1HTb Koro Ha3HaqIfJIH

HOBbIM rrOCJIOM B MocKBe B rro~oOHbIX cJIyqallx II rOBOshy

PHJI laquo~eHMC II Mory aTO BbIIICHHTb 3TO HeCJIO)KHO ga H 3aHshy

MeT Bcem rrapy WIeH 3a aTO)Ke BpeMlll CMOry pa3Y3HaTb Koe-qTO

rrOBa)KHee HO rrOTpaTHB BpeMl Ha TBoe 38]aHHe MbI oe3B03shy

BpaTHO yrryCTHM ary OOJIee B~ HHltpOPMaIJHIO 3aqeM )Ke

TpaTHTb ClfJIbI ltITOObI Y3HaTh HMII rrOCJIa KOTOpoe Bce paBHO

CTaHeT H3BeCTHbIM H3 OltPHIJHaJIbHbIX HCTOltIHHKOBraquo

PeCTOH CltIHTaJIltITO II He rrpOSIBJIIIIO ~OCTaToquoro pBeHHII

IIo ero MHeHHIO rJIaBHall ~06po~eTeJIb ra3eTltIHKa - Bcer~a OblTb rrepBbIM PeCTOH yrBep)KAaJI ltITO OOblKHOBeHHe )KAaTb

COOOlI1eHHII BJIaCTeH HMeHHO B TOT MOMeHT Korga BJIaCm )Keshy

JIaroT cgeJIaTb aTO COOOllJeHHe MO)KeT rrpHBecm K He~opa-3MeHHIIM B ropa3go OOJIee cepbe3HbIX CHryaIJHIIX

OllACHOCTH KYMOBCTBA

IIpe~Ce~aTeJIb MyHHI1HIIaJIbHOH KOMHCCHH BOIlleJI B peCTOshy

paH H HarrpaBlIJICII K gaJIbHeMY CTOJIHKY IIo rryrH OH cep~eltIHO

rro3gopOBaJICII C perropTepOM MeCTHOH ra3eTbI H rrpe~JIO)KHJI

eMY 03HaKOMHTbCSI C rrJIaHaMH peKOHCTpYKIJHH raBaHH KOTopble

CaM rrpe~Ce~aTeJIb aKTHBHO rrOMep)KHBaJI )KypHaJIHCT ObID

qpe3BblqaHHO ~OBOJIeH CTOJIb ~py)KeCKHM OOpallJeHHeM co

CTOPOHbI BJIHllTeJIbHOrO JlHIJa TeM OOJIee ltITO PllgOM ObIDO rrOJIHO

3HaKOMbIX

MO)KHO crroplITb KaK CTOJIb IBHoe H rryOJIHltIHoe rraHHopashy

TCTBO rrOBJIHSIeT Ha TO KaK HarrHIlleT perropTep 0 nOKa3aHHOM

eMY npoeKTe OgHaKO OnHCaHHaR cHryaI1Hll rr03BOJIlleT 3~aTh

134 135

pH~ 3aKOHHhIX BorrpOCOB 06 OTHomeHHHX MeK~y a~MRshy

HHcTpaTOpaMH H rrpeccoH

Pa60Ta ~HaJIHCTa COCTOHT B TOM IT06hI 3HaKOMHTh rry6shy

JIHKy C ~eHTeJIhHOCThlO BJIaCTeH BhIIIOJIHHH CBOH rrpocpecshy

CHOHaJIhHhle 06H3aHHOCTH OH BCTpeIaeTCH C H3BeCTHhIMH R

BJIHHTeJIhHhIMH (Ha MeCTHOM mTaTHOM HJIH cpe~epaJIhHOM ypOBHe) CpHrypaMH Ha~eTCH JIH pa60THHK cpe~CTB MaCCOBoA

ImcpopMa~ KOTOPOMY 6hI He rrOJIhCTHJIO BHHMaHHe TaKHX JIIOshy

~eH ~ae eCJIH 3TO JIHIIIh rrpHBeTCTBHe B JIIO~OM MeCTe A rroshy

~06HhIe 3HaKH BHHMaHHH ChIIIHTCH CrrJIOIIIh H PHJJOM ~ae H 6e3

rrpenMIBJIeHHH KoppeCrrOH~eHTCKOrO y~ocTOBepeHHH - ocp~shyaJIhHhIM ~aM xopomo H3BeCTHO BJIHHHHe rrpecchI

Pe3YJIhTaTOM rrpHHTeJIhCKHX oTHomeHHH MeKm lHHOBshy

HHKaMH H perroprepaMH IaCTO 6bIBalOT KOCBeHHhIe c~eJIKH Koshy

HelHO HeT HHKaKOH pelH 0 rpy60M rrowcyrre TIpOCTO ~Hashy

JIHCT MOKeT He BKJIIOlHTh B perropTa KOe-KaKHe HerrpHHTHhIe

CBe~eHHH rrpeKpaCHO OC03HaBaH ITO HMeHHO TaK MOKHO COshy

XpaHHTh H pacrrOJIOKeHHe BhICOKOrrOCTaBJIeHHOrO 3HaKOMOrO

H CJIe~OBaTeJIhHO CBOH c06cTBeHHhIH ~ocTyrr K BaKHOH HHCPOpshy

Ma~mI A BOT Ipe3MepHaH crpaCTh K pa306JIaIemIHM IpeBaTa

PHCKOM YTPaTHTh 3TOT ~OCTyrr BrrOJIHe rroHHTHo ITO ~Hashy

JIHCTaM cBoHCTBeHHa OCTOPOKHOCTh rrpH pa60Te C MaTepHashy

JIaMH yrpOKaIO~HMH HX KOHTaKTaM B OCP~aJIhHOM MHpe

3~ech B03HHKaeT cBoe06pa3HhIH rrapa~OKc )KypHaJIHCT

rrorrpocry He MOKeT pa60TaTh 6e3 rro~06HbIX CBH3eH HO eCJIH

OHH CTaHOBHTCH lJepecIyp 6JIH3KHMH H YCTOAIHBbIMH TO OR

CaM rrpeBp~aeTCH B lJaCTb a~HCTpaTHBHOH CHCTeMhI H

eMY OKa3hIBaeTCH Bhlro~eH CKpblBaTh 3JIoyrrOTpe6JIeHHH OT

rJIa3 rry6JIHKH a He pa306JIat IaTh HX KOHelHO C 3THM HCKymeshy

HHHM MOKHO CrrpaBHThCH ITO H ~eJIaIOT xoponme ~HaJIHCshy

ThI Koppecrro~eHT O~OH H3 BanmHITOHCKHX ra3eT ~eHMC

MaKKapTHH rrpe~yrrpeK~aeT ITO rrOTepH He3aBHCHMOCTR

rropo~aeT H 60JIee cephe3Hhle rrp06JIeMhI OH IIHIIIeT

HeKOTophIe perropTephI HaCTOJIhKO aaraKHpOBaHhI OcpHshy

~aJIhHhIMH JIH~aMH ITO rrepeCTaIOT 6hITh 6ecrrpHCTpaCTHhIMH

136

ua6JI1O~aTeJIHMH H ~ae XOTH 3TO KpamIHH CJIYlaH ~eHCTBYshylOT B KaIeCTBe pyrrOpOB CBOHXrrOKpOBHTeJIeH lIM~eHe XOIeTCH

nOJIh30BaThCH ~yrHMH HCTOlJHHKaMH HHCPOPM~ BhIHCKHshy

BaTh H rry6JIHKOBaTh aJIhTepHaTHBHhle TOlJKH 3peHHH CBhIKshy

uysnmCh C rro~o6HoH POJIhIO TaKHe ~HaJIHCThI cpaKTHIeCKH

CTaHOBHTCH HeocpH~HaJIhHhlMH rrpecc-areHTaMH Tex 0 KOM

IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI

11JIH 3~ThI OT ~HaJIHCTCKOH Ha30HJIHBOCTH c~eCTshyByeT Macca cpe~cTB 3TO ~eH3ypa (TaM r~e OHa B03MOKHa)

orpaHHIeHHe ~ocTyrra K HHCPOPM~ H rrpOCTO 06MaH ~shy

tbIH orrhITHhIH rrpe~CTaBHTeJIh BJIaCTH 3HaeT HeMaJIO rro~o6HhIX rrpHeMoB

y rrpecchI O~aKO eCTh cpe~cTBa 3~ThI CaMoe Tpa~shy~oHHoe H3 KOTOPhIX - pa3Y3HaTh H C006~Th 0 C06hITHHX

KOTophle Koe-KTO H3 HaIaJIhCTBa rrpe~oIeJI 6bI coxpaHHTh B

TaHHe OT nmpoKOH rry6JIHKH B pe3YJIhTaTe ~HaJIHCThI H

npe~cTaBHTeJIH BJIaCTH Bce BpeMH pa3hIrphIBalOT BoeHHbIe

cpaeHHH HCXO~ KOTOPhIX 06hJtIHO HHIeHHhIH

TIOKoHHhIH ra3eTHhIH pe~aKTop BM HhIOTOH CBHTO Beshy

PHBIIIHif B He06xo~oCTh 3~opoBoro npOTHB06opCTBa Me~ npeccoH H IHHOBHHKaMH rrOOIIWHJI CBOHX COTPy~OB BhIshy

HIOXBBaTh 3JIoyrrOTpe6JIeHHH BJIaCTeH OH rrpe~pe~aJI ITO

HHor~a CKphITaH Bp~a cpe~CTB MaccoBoH HHcpopMa~HH H

OCP~aJIhHOro MHpa MOKeT rrpORBHThCH B OTKphIryID

TIOJIHTHK ~OJIKeH CPOpMHpOBaTb y ny6JIHKH ~o6poKeshyJIaTeJIhHOe OTHomeHHe K npaBHTeJIhCTBy a ~HaJIHCT 06H3aH

nOCTaBJIHTh 06beKTHBHhle H TOlJHhIe cBe~eHHH 0 pa60Te rrpaBHshy

TeJIhCTBa l1Hor~a 3TH ~eJIH HaCTOJIhKO paCXOAHTCH ITO rroshy

JHTHK XBaTaeT MHKPOCPOH H 3aBepHeT rry6JIHKy ITO KYPHaJIHCT

- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb

)KYPHaJIHCT Hepewco MOKeT OKa3aThCH B CJIOKHOM rrOJIOshy

KeHHH rro OTHomeHHIO K OCP~aJIhHhIM JIH~aM lbH ~eJIH H

137

rrOJllITllleCKHe KypCbI OTHIOWgt He Bcerna cOBrranaIOT BOT lITO

mImeT 0 TaKHX ClfTya~ll5lX YllJIb5lM CMOJIJI

KOHrpeCCMeHbI neJI5ITC5I CBeneHll5lMll OTHIOnb He ll3

aJIbTPYH3Ma II BepbI B llneaJIbI neMOKpaTllll OHll neJIaIOT ITO

paWf c06CTBeHHOll BbIrOWgtI co06~a51 )J()PHaJIllCTY JIlIillb TO

liTO ClIllTaIOT rrOJIe3HbIM nJI5I ce651 Ho 3aKOHonaTeJllI II aDMllshy

HllCTpa~51 HepenKO llMeIOT COBceM pa3HbIe ~eJllI II llMeHHO

rrOlTOMY rrepBbIe Hepe~o rrpeBp~aIOTC5IB eCTeCTBeHHbIX COI03shy

HllKOB perropTepOB II B HallJIYllilllle llCTOllHllKH llHcpopMa~

IIo MHeHllIO rep6ePTa raHca )J()PHaJIlICT II rrOJllITllK CB5I3ashy

HbI CllCTeMOll B3allMHbIX 06513aTeJIbCTB KOTOpa51 KaK 6bI BTSIIHshy

BaeT )KypHaJIlICTa B rrpo~ecc rrpllH5ITll51 rrOJllITlllleCKllX pememm

rr03BOJI5151 YBllneTb ITOT rrpo~ecc C ll3HaHKH B 6JIaronapHOCTh

3a ITY OCBenOMJIeHHOCTb )J()PHaJIlICT ll36eraeT OTKPbITO 3aTPashy

rllBaTb Koe-KaKlle acrreKTbI ne5lTeJIbHOCTll rrpaBllTeJIbCTBa

PerropTep 3HaeT Bce (llJllI rrollrn Bce) HO He 060 BceM MOshy

)KeT paccKa3aTb rry6J1lIKe IIoJllITllK co cBoell CTOPOHbI paccKashy

3bIBaeT )J()pHaJIllcTY Bce (llJllI MaKcllMYM Toro lITO MO)KeT ce6e

rr03BOJllITb) rrpeKpacHo rrOHllMa5l lITO MHoroe ll3 CKa3aHHoro

Hll rrpll KaKllX YCJIOBll5lX He rr05lBllTC5I B CJIenyIO~eM BbmYCKe

ra3eTbI OTHOmeHll51 Me)Kny rrOJIllTllKOM II )KypHaJIllCTOM

60JIbIIIe HarrOMllHaIOT rrepeT5IrllBaHlle KaHaTa lIeM yrrop5IIJOshy

lIeHHyIO CllCTeMY IIOJllITllK Bcerna IIbITaeTC5I C006~Tb rrOMeHbshy

IIIe a perropTep - orry6JIllKOBaTb rr060JIbIIIe HO He rrOiWOPTllTh

oTHomeHllll C llCTOllHllKOM llHcpopMa~llll

3TO rrepeT5IfllBaHlle KaHaTa Hllrne He 3aMeTHO HaCTOJIbKO

CllJIbHO KaK B xone ll36llpaTeJIbHbIX KaMrraHllll BrrpolleM

MHOrlle ClIllTaIOT lITO ITO 6ecKoHellHbIll rrpo~ecc rrOCKOJIbKY

rrOJllITllKll rrOCT05IHHO 03a60lleHbI cJIenyIOIIQfMll BbI60paMll

ECJIll aBTopbI penaK~lloHHOll CTaTbll rropyrllBaIOT rroJllIshy

TllKa OHll 06bllJH0 He 3a6bIBaIOT liTO ra3eTHoe HallaJIbCTBO Ha

CJIenyIO~X BbI60pax MO)KeT rrOMep)KaTb ero KaHWfnaTypy

HeB3llpa51 Ha Bce HenOCTaTKll KpllTllKY )Ke Bcerna MO)KHO

CM5IfllllTb Ha3BaB ee KOHCTPYKTllBHOll 3Ha51 lIeJIOBelleCKyIO

rrpllpony He IIpllXOWfTC5I YWfBJI5ITbC5I liTO )J()PHaJIlICT rrpllshy

138

5ITeJIbCTByIO~ C OCPll~aJIbHbIM JIlI~OM He 3aMeTllT rrposhy

rraraHWfCTCKOll C~OCTll llCXOn~X OT ITOrO JIlI~a rrpeccshy

peJllI30B II orry6JIllKyeT llX CO[lep)KaHlle rrOllTll (llJllI rrOJIHOCTbIO)

6e3 pe[laKTHpOBaHll5l He yrrOM5IHYB llCTOllHllKllHCPOPM~llll EbITb

MO)KeT TaKOe rrOBe[leHlle onacrn IIpOCTllTeJIbHO pe[laKTopaM

He60JIbIIIllX ra3eT KOTOPbIM Ba)KHO rrOTOpOIIllTbC5I OTrrellaTaTb

THpa)K K CPOKY HO K rrO[l06HbIM OIIpaB[IaHll5IM lIepec-qyp lIaCTO

rrpll6eraIOT II PYKoBoWfTeJllI Ipyrnx ll3[1aHllll IIo[l06Ha51 rrpaKshy

TllKa -qpeBaTa TeM liTO rrpecca BMeCTO Toro lIT06bI CJIY)KllTb 06shy

~ecTBY MO)KeT rrpeBpaTllTbC5I B Hepacc~aIO~ CJIJ)KaHKY

BJIaCTell

AJI5I )KypHaJIllCTa JIy-qrnee opY)KHe rrpoTllB KYMoBcTBa C

OCPll~llaJIbHbIMll JIlI~aMll - rrOHllMaHlle liTO KYMOBCTBO orraCHO

II He3aBllCllMOCTb c06CTBeHHbIX CY)K[IeHllll BOT MHeHlle pe[laKshy

Topa HbIO-HOPK TallMc A)KellMCa PecToHa CTOpoHHllKa YMeshy

peHHoro rrpOTllB060pCTBa Me)KIJY Cpe[lCTBaMll MaccoBoll llHshy

CPOPM~llllll BJIaCT5IMll

EcJIlI II rrpecca II rrpaBllTeJIbCTBO CPYHK~llOHllPyIOT HOpshy

MaJIbHO TO OHll 51BJI5IIOTC5I COI03HllKaMll II orrllpaIOTC5I Ha TY

lIaCTb 06~ecTBa KOTOpa51 He 6e)KHT OT peaJIbHOCTll a XOlleT Bllshy

[IeTb ee TaKOll KaKOBa OHa eCTb YMHbIe rrOJIllTllKH He MOryT

laquoMaHllrrYJIllpOBaTbraquo perropTepaMll a xopOIIIlle )KypHaJIllCTbI

OTHIOWgt He ClIllTaIOT liTO llX CB5ITa51 06513aHHOCTb - rrOCllJIbHee

laquoBpe3aTbraquo rrpaBllTeJIbCTBY AJI5I rrpeCCbI II rrOJIllTlllleCKOll

CllCTe MbI rOpa3[10 rrOJIe3Hell He Bpa)K[lOBaTb a COTPYIHllllaTb

Ipyr C [IpyrOM II 3[1PaBOMbIC~M MeHbillllHCTBOM 06~ecTBa

II0JlXJIECTLIBATEJIb IlJIII CTOPOJKEBOH IIEC

MeCTHa51 rrpecca oc06eHHo IcpcpeKTllBHa B BbIIIOJIHeHllll

cJIenyIO~x CPYH~ll PerropTepCKa51 - TOllHOe II B3BemeHHoe llHcpopMHpoBaHlle

HaCeJIeHll51 0 pa60Te BJIaCTell

KOHTPOJIbHa51 (cpYHK~51 CTOpO)KeBoro rrca) - BbI5IBJIeHlle

[IaHHbIX 06 oIIIll6Kax HeKOMIIeTeHTHOCTll llJllI 3JIoyrroTpe6JIeshy

Hll5IX OCPll~llaJIbHbIX~

139

KpHTHqeCKasI - He3aBHCHMaH OIJeHKa )(eHTeJIbHOCTH pa3shy

JIHlffihlX yqpe~eHHH H OltpHIJHaJIbHbIX JIHIJ

KOMMYHHKaIJHOHHaH - rry6JIHKaIJHH pa3JIH~IX MHeHHH H

)(HCKYCCHH no HHTepeCYIOmHM 06IIJeCTBO BOnpOCaM

3aIIJHTHaH (ltpYHKIJHH oM6Y)(CMeHa) - nOMOIIJb rpa~aHaM B

)(OBe)(eHHH HX MHeHHH )(0 CBe)(eHHH BJIaCTeH

B )(onOJIHeHHe K 3THM HeCOMHeHHbIM 3a)(aqaM npeCCbI

HeKOTopbIe )K)pHaJIHCThI H nOJIHTOJIOrH ynOMHHaIOT eIIJe 0)(Hy

- OHa BhlCTynaeT B KaqeCTBe nO)(XJIeCTbIBaTeJIH n06y~aH coshy

rpa~aH K OCyIIJecTBJIeHHIO Tex HJIH HHbIX IJeJIeH cnoc06CTshy

BYIOIIHX (no ee MHeHHlO) 06IIJeCTBeHHOMY 6JIarOCOCToSIHHIO

O)(HaKO CJIOBO nO)(XJIeCThIBaTeJIb aCCOIJHHpyeTCSI C peBshy

HOCTHbIM 3HTY3HacToM B3HpaIOIIHM Ha OKpyxaIOIIJee qepe3

P030Bble O~H He 3aMeqaH HHKaKHX He)(OCTaTKOB HeKOTopbIe

xypHaJIHCThI npe)(JIaralOT 3aMeHHTb 3TO CJIOBO Ha 06IIJeCTBeHshy

HbIH OpraHH3aTOp HJIH OTBeTCTBeHHbIH rpax)(aHHH He3aBHshy

CHMO OT Ha3BaHHH pe H)(eT 06 O)(HOM H TOM xe npecca COJIHshy

)(apH3HpyeTcH C 06IIJeCTBOM H CTapaeTCH cnOC06CTBOBaTh ero

npOIJBeTaHHIO nOCKOJIbKY OT nOCJIe)(Hero 3aBHCHT 6Y)(yIIJee cashy

MOH npeCCbI K COXaJIeHHIO 3Ta ltPYHKIJHH He Bcer)(a COBMecshy

THMa C TeMH ltPYHKIJHHMH ~O nepeqHCJIeHbI Bbnne

M3p He60JIbIllOrO ltpJIOpH)(CKOrO ropO)(Ka O)(HaK)(bI 3aMeshy

THJI MOJIO)(OMY penopTepy QIHOK HaM He nyxeH 60JIbIllOit

ropo)( HaM HyxeH XOPOUlUU MaJIeHbKHH ropo)( 3TO 6bIJIO

CKa3aHO B CBH3H C npe)(JIOXeHHeM BJIaCTeH lllTaTa npOJIOlKHTD

Herro)(aJIeKY HOBYIO aBTOCTpa)(y B CBH3H C 3THM B03HHKaeT BOshy

npoc eCJIH 60JIbIIIHHCTBO ropoxaH npH)(epxltHBaJIOCb Toro xe

MHeHHH ~o H M3P 6bIJIa JIH npecca 06H3aHa BCTaTb Ha Ty xe

TO~y 3peHHH I1JIH MoxeT 6bITb )(OJIr npeccbI COCTOHJI B HHOM

_ 6ecnpHCTpaCTHO pacCMOTpeTb rrpe)(JIOXeHHe BJIaCTeit IIITashy

Ta H 03HaKOMHTh 06IIJeCTBO co CBOHMH BbIBo)(aMH )(axe eCJIH

OHH He COBna)(aIOT C MHeHHeM 60JIblllHHCTBa OTBeT 3aBHCHT OT

Toro B qeM pe)(aKIJHH ra3eTbI BH)(HT CBOIO OCHOBHYIO 3a)(aqy

HeCKOJIbKO JIeT Ha3a)( fep6ePT faHC 06HapYKHJI ~O KHshy

TeJIH ropo)(a JIeBHTTaYH B IIITaTe HblO-J]gtKepcH XOTeJIH tIT06h1

MeCTHasI ra3eTa pHCOBaJIa ropO)(CKYIO lKH3Hb JIHIllb B 06JIashy

ropoxeHHOM BH)(e HH B KoeM cnyqae He BbIHOCH copa H3 H36h1

QHH He xeJIaJIH 06HapO)(OBaHHH HHKaKHX CBe)(eHHit 6pocalOshy

mHX TeHb Ha HX ropo)(

Bcer)(a eCTb BepOHTHOCTh qTO XYPHaJIHCThI H pe)(aKTophl

OKaxyTCH rrepe)( He06xo)(HMOCTblO npHHHMaTb TpY)(Hble peIlleshy

HlIH Bhl3BaHHbIe TeMH HJIH HHbIMH HerrpHHTHbIMH CHTYaIJHHMH

I13-3a 3Toro pa60THHKaM npeccbI qaCTeHbKO npnxO)(HTCH BbIshy

CTynaTb B KaqeCTBe CTopoxeBbIX rrCOB HJIH OTBeTCTBeHHbIX

rpa~aH BOT O)(HH JIHlllb npHMep

- PerropTep BnOJIHe KOMlleTeHTHO OCBell~aeT pa60TY Coshy

BeTa no 3)(paBOoxpaHeHHIO CBoero oKpyra TaK qTO ay)(HToshy

pHH XOPOIllO OCBe)(OMJIeHa 0 )(eHTeJIbHOCTH 3Toro Be)(OMCTBa

trreHbI COBeTa co cBoeit CTOPOHbI BCgqeCKH CTapaIOTcH y6eshy

)(HTh ny6JIHKy B nOJIe3HOCTH 3TOit opraHH3aIJHH

COBeT - 3TO KpynHaH OpraHH3aIJHH B KOTOPOH eCTb Heshy

CKOJIbKO OT)(eJIOB 3aBe)(ylOIIJaH O)(HHM H3 HHX 6e3ynpe~0 pa60shy

TaeT nO~H )(Ba)(IJaTb JIeT O)(HaKO He3aBHCHMaH ay)(HTOpCshy

KaH npOBepKa 06HapYlKHBaeT qTO 3Ta )(aMa BeCbMa BOJIbHO

06paIIJaJIaCL C 61O)(xeTOM H3-3a qero )(Be ThICgqH )(OJIJIapOB

6bIJIH H3paCXO)(OBaHbI He rro Ha3HaqeHHlO TIoKa 3TH ltpaKTbI He

CTaJIH )(OCTOHHHeM rnaCHOCTH 3aBe)(ylOIIJaH pelllaeT B03Mecshy

TIlTh COBeTY paCTpaqeHHhIe )(eHbrn H )(OCpOlffiO yHTH B )(06poshy

BOJIbHylO OTCTaBKY COBeT OOCy)(HB CHTYaIJHlO 3a 3aKpbITbIMH

)(BepHMH y)(OBJIeTBOpHeT npocb6y 3aBe)(ylOIIJeit O)(HOBpeMeHshy

HO npHHHMaH MepbI )(JIH npe)(ynpe~eHHH no)(06HbIX HHIJHshy

)(eHTOB qJIeHbI COBeTapelllalOT 3aMHTb )(eJIO H He 06cy~aTh ero

C npeccoit

)KYPHaJIHcTY Ha)(o pellIHTL HaCTaHBaTb JIH Ha nOJIHOM

paCCJIe)(oBaHHH H 06Hapo)(oBaHHH nonyqeHHbIX cBe)(eHHit HJIH

gtKe COrJIaCHThCH C MHeHHeM COBeTa COqTH BCJIe)( 3a HHM ~o nyshy

6JIHKawIH CTOJIb )(YPHO naxHyIIJeit HCTOpHH HHKOMY He npHHeceT

nOJIb3bI B no)(06Hoit CHTyaIJHH 60JIbllIHHCTBO ero KOJIJIer pashy

3YMeeTCH npe)(llOqJIH 6bI nepBbm BapHaHT - Ha TOM OCHOBaHHH

lITO ny6JIHKa HMeeT npaBO Ha nOJIHYIO HHltpOPMaIJHIO 0 pa60Te

140 141

CTOJTh BruKHOrO yqpe)KJeHlISI KaK COBeT no 3mgtaBOOXPaIlemnobull

O~aKO H~CSI H CTOPOHHlIKH mgtyrOH TOIKH 3peHlISI geHLm

B03BpameHLI rrpOKypa1)pa He BMeIIIlIBaJIaCb H JIYIllIe Bcero

rrpOCTO He no~aTb III)Ma

KaK nOKa3aJIO 06CJIegoBaIlHe pe3YJThTaTbI KOToporo 6bIJIR

ony6JIHKOBaHbI B 1971 r B )KypHaJIe Ila6JIHK OnHHHoH

KBOpTepJIH rrpecca KaK npaBIDIO CTOHT Ha cTPa)Ke aBTOPHshy

TeTa MeCTHbIX BJIaCTeH OKa3aJIOCb lITO MeCTHaSI npecca lIame

3anwmaeT HHCTHTYTbI MeCTHOH BJIaCTH He)KeJIB c006maeT 0

C06bITIISIX MOrymHX B03MYTHTb 06meCTBeHHoe cnOKOHCTBHe

B 3TY JIOByrnKY nOWIac nonagaIOT ga)Ke ra3eTbI ygOCToshy

HBIillIecSi OTJIHtlliH O~a MeCTHaSi ra3eTa Ha IOre CIlIA rogashy

MH OTMeqaBmaSiCSI B 06meaMepHKaIlCKOM MacmTa6e 3a pashy

306JIaqeHHe Y)KaCaIOmHX YCJIOBHH cogep)KaHHSI 3aKJIIOlIenshy

HbIX H gHCKpHMHHanHII MeHbIilllHCTB B cocegHHx paHoHax

pegKO OKa3bmaJIaCb CTOJTh )Ke 6eCKOMIIpOMHCCHOH no OTHOshy

meHHIO K BJIaCTSIM C06CTBeHHOrO ropoga 3a 1IT0 ee KpHTlIKOBashy

JIB mgtyrne ra3eTbI IIITaTa

Korga fep6epT faHC npOBOglIJI 06CJIegoBaIlHe B neBHTshy

TaYHe OgHH H3 MeCTHbIX penOPTepOB OTKpOBeHHO rrpH3HaJICSI

lITO He CTaIleT nelIaTaTb HlIqerO gypHoro 0 HeKOM MeCTHOM geSlshy

TeJIe a npOCTO C rJIa3Y Ha rJIa3 norOBopHT C HHM 0 ero rrpOClIeshy

Tax faIlC 06bSlCHSIeT 3TY n03HnHIO CKJIOHHOCTbIO ~HaJIHCTOB

K OTO)KJeCTBJIeHHIO c06cTBeHHblx HHTepecoB C HHTepeCaMII

CBoero co06mecTBa II ero JIHgepoB Il03ToM)-TO ~HaJIHCTbI

cTapaIOTcSI OrpaJIHqHTb KpHTHKY H cogeHCTBOBaTb TeM mmaM H

nOJIHTHlleCKHM nporpaMMaM KOTopble no HX MHeHlIIO 3acnyshy

)KHBaIOT no~ep)KKH npeccbI faIlc CCblJlaeTCSI Ha npHMep ogshy

nora pegaKTOpa He )KaJIeBmerO MeCTa gJISi nOJIO)KHTeJThHOrO

OCBemeHHSI geSlTeJThHOCTH HeKOH MeCTHOH OpraIlH3anHH no

xpaHHBmero nog CYKHOM C006meHHSI 0 ee BHYTpeHHHX HeypSIgHshy

nax nOCKOJIbKY 3Ta OpraHH3anHSI npHHOCHJIa HeMaJIYIO nOJTh3Y

corpa)KJaIlaM

apyrne pegaKTOpbI HaCTaHBaIOT Ha OOJIee nOJIHOM H 06beKshy

THBHOM oCBemeHHH MeCTHLlX C06bITHH PegaKTOp O~OH 1I3 rashy

3eT Cpe~ero 3arraga no~epKHYJI 1IT0 eCJIH ~HaJIHCT He BbIshy

nOJIHSleT O~OBpeMeHHO CPYHKnHH CTOpO)KeBOrO nca H nogshy

xneCTbmaTeJISI TO B KOHne KOHnOB pHcKyeT OTopBaTbCSI OT ayshy

)IlITOpHH H nOJIHOCTbIO JIHIillITbCSI BJIHSlHlISI TOT )Ke pegaKTOp

OTMeTHJI lITO nHHH3M gJISI ~HaJIHCTa OlIeHb onaceH

IJpyrOH pegaKTop npegyrrpeglIJI lITO ra3eTe He CJIegyeT

CJIHIIIKOM YSJIeKaTbCSI pOJThIO 06meCTBeHHoro OpraIlH3aTopa

no ero CJIOBaM ~HaJIHCT BnpaBe JII06HTb H XBaJIHTb CBOH

ropog HO OlIeHb nJIOXO eCJIH OH HrHOpHpyeT cepbe3Hble nposhy

6JIeMbI JIHillb 6bI He CrryrHYTh rrpegrrpHHlIMaTeJIeH H3 gpyrHX

MeCT

XOTSI nogxneCTbmaIlHe B lIHCTOM BHge He BXOglIT B lIHCJIO

06S13aI1HOCTeH penopTepa OH He MO)KeT H He gOJI)KeH OTPbIshy

BaTbCSI OT Tex C KeM no cocegCTBY )KHBeT H gJISI Koro TPYglITCSI

XOTSI H TP~O rrpegJIO)KHTb 0~03HaqflbIH penenT ~HaJIHCTshy

CKoro nOBegeHlISI MO)KHO nOCOBeTOBaTb He OCTaBaTbCSI rnyshy

XHM K np06JIeMaM OKP~aIOmHX ECJIH 3TO OTHOmeHHe COqeTashy

eTCSI C npocpeCCHOHaJIH3MOM H HpaBCTBeHHOH OTBeTCTBeHshy

HOCTbIO ~HaJIHCT 3aHMeT gOJI)KHoe MeCTO B CBoeM co06shy

meCTBe )l(YPHaJIHCTY 06gyMbmaIOmeM) KaK gOCTOHHO nocTPoshy

HTb OTHOmeHHSl C BJIaCTSIMH CTOHT BCnOMHHTb CJIOBa ~oHa

MHJThTOHa

IlpeBbIIIle Bcex cB060g SI CTaBJIIO cB060gy CJIOBa cB060gy

OTKPbITO BblCKa3bmaTbCSI B COOTBeTCTBHH C c06cTBeHHbIMH

y6e)KJeHHSIMH H C06CTBeHHOH COBeCTbIO 3TO cB060ga HO He

npaBo lIHTaTeJTh Me MO)KeT TPe60BaTb 3HaHHSI OH MO)KeT JIHillb

TPe60BaTb npaBa npH06peTaTb 3HaIlHe CBOHMH C06CTBeHHbIMH

YCHJIHSIMH

3HaHHe HeJTh3S1 rryTaTb C MHeHHeM KOTopoe MO)KeT 6bITb

npOH3BOJThHbIM H HlI Ha qeM He OCHOBaHHbIM ECJIH lIHTaTeJTh

XOqeT 06JIagaTb 3HaHHeM OH gOJI)KeH noJIYllHTh HaCTOJThKO nOJIshy

Hble H TOqflble cBegeHlISI 0 npegMeTe HaCKOJThKO B lIeJIOBeqeCshy

KHX CHJIax HX g06bITb

06peTeHlIe TaKOrO 3HaIlHSI Bce PaBHO OCTaIleTCSI JIHillb nepshy

BbIM 3TarrOM Ero eme npegcTOHT nOHSlTb H YCBOHTb - JIHIIIb

142 143

TorAa ero MOJKHO 06cYXCAaTb H CTPOHTb Ha HeM AOBOAbI B

crrope B03MOJKHO 1JHTaTeJIb H He IIpOCHT HH1JerO KpOMe ltpaKshy

TOB H 3TO BIIOJIHe cepbe3Hoe Tpe60BaHHe Ho xltypHaJIHCT B

IIHCaTeJIb XOTHT CB060AHO rOBOpHTh H CIIOPHTh OHU OOJlXHbl

CaMU U 006bt6amb 3HaHue U npenOOHocumb ew O1cpyxalOUJUM

3TH CJIOBa coxpaHHIOT CHJIY H AJIH COBpeMeHHblX

xltypHaJIHCTOB KaK rOBOpHJI rappH TPYM3H HYJKHO JIH60 He

60HThCH )Kapa JIH60 y6HpaTbcH H3 KYXHH

lKYPHAJIHCTCKOE PACCJIE11OBAHHE

PeIIopTep YKPblJlCH B pOmHIJe HH3KOPOCJIbIX IIaJlbM IIpHshy

XJIOIIHYJI Ha ce6e Har(oeAJIHBOro KOMapa H 3aMep B O)KH)aHHH OH

Y3HaJI H3 Har(eJKHOrO HCTO~HKa liTO OAHH H3 60CCOB ar(MHshy

HHCTpaqHH oKpyra HCIIOJIb30BaJI MYHH~aJlbHbrU 6YJIbA03ep

IIpOKJIaAbmaH IIO)Jbe3AHYID AOpOry K COOCTBeHHOMY 3eMeJIbHoshy

MY YlIaCTKy QT06bI IIpOBepHTb ITO peIIOpTep peIllHJI IIpHOOrshy

HYTb K CaMOMY Har(eJKHOMY cIIoc06y - y6eAHTbCH ~O

- IWyrOH peIIOpTep IIpHlIIeJI K qnmaHCOBOMY KOHTpOJIepy

H3AaTeJIbCKOH ltpHpMbI lIT06bI TOT IIOMOr eMY pa306paTbcH B

AeTaJIHX rOAH~OrO ltpHHaHCOBOrO OTlleTa HeKOH 60JIbHHIbI OH

peIIIHJI IIpOBepHTb ITOT OTlleT Y3HaB IIO CBOHM KaHaJIaM 0

COMHHTeJIbHOM IIepeBOAe lIaCTH 60JIbH~bIX ltpOHAOB IIpeAshy

Ha3HalleHHbIX AJIH 3KCTpeHHbIX 06CTOHTeJIbCTB Ha ~Ie ClIeTa

Me~CKOrO IIepCOHaJIa

- Erne OAHa xltypHaJIHCTKa ~eJIbIX TpH HeAeJIH IIpOCHAeJIa B

apXHBe MeCTHOrO CYAa H3Yl1aH pemeHHH MexceBOH KOMHCCHH B XOAe cKpynyJIe3HOH IIpOBepKH OHa y6eAHJIaCb lITO KOMHCCillI

HBHO 6JIarOBOJIHJIa K HeKOTOpbIM 3eMJIeBJIar(eJIb~aM B pe3YJIbshy

TaTe 1Jero HX YlIaCTKH CHJIbHO IIOACKOlHJlH B ~eHe

To lIeM 3aHHMaJIHCb Bce ITH peIIopTepbI 06b~0 Ha3b1shy

BaIOT xltypHaJIHCTCKHM paCCJIeAOBaHHeM TeJIepeIIopTep KapJI

BepHCTaHH KaK-TO OTMeTHJI lITO xopomaH xltypHaJIHCTCKaH pashy

60Ta BcerAa IIpeAIIOJIaraeT 3JIeMeHTbI paCCJIeAOBaHHH IJeHshy

CTBHTeJIbHO B KaKOM-TO IIJIaHe Bce peIIopTepbI BpeMH OT Bpe-

MeHH KaK 6bI H CbIrnHKH OAHaKO IIO OTHOmeHHIO K AeHcTshy

BHHM BJIaCTH TepMHH xltypHaJIHCTCKOe paCCJIeAOBaHHe rrpHshy

oGpeJI 60JIee rJIY60KHit H KOHKpeTHbrU CMbICJI OH 0603HallaeT

aKTHBHbrU IIOHCK HHltpOPM~H KOTOPYID KOe-KaKHe BJIHHTeJIbshy

Hble JIH~a H rpyrrIIbI IIpeAIIo1JJIH 6b1 Aep)KaTb B TaHHe OT coshy

rpa)KAaH

KoppecrroHAeHT MoxceT 003 oc06bIX YCHJIHit BblHCHHTh B

apXHBe IIITaTa HaCKOJIbKO AOXOAbI TpeHepa YHHBepCHTeTcKoH

ltpYT60JIbHOH KOMaHAbI IIpeBbIIlIalOT 3apIIJIaTY rrpe3HAeHTa

yHHBepcHTeTa Ho eCJIH OH 3axolleT Y3HaTh He 6blJl JIH HeKTO

3a1JHCJIeH B YHHBepCHTeT 3a CBOH crropTHBHble ycrrexH 6e3

AOJIJKHoit YlIe6Hoit IIOAfOTOBKH TO 1JT06bI IIOJIYlHTh AOCTyII K

AOKYMeHTaM IIpHeMHOH KOMHCCHH IIPHAeTCH 3aTpaTHTb KYAa

60JIbme BpeMeHH H ycHJIHii

KaK IIpaBHJIO xopomHit peIIopTep 06JIar(aeT MHOrHMH IIposhy

ltpeccHOHaJlbHbIMH KalleCTBaMH II03BOJIHIOrnHMH ycneIIllio IIpOshy

BeCTH KBaJIHltp~OBaHHOe paCCJIeAOBaHHe OAHaKO 1JaCTO 3Ta

3ar(a1Ja Tpe6yeT H AOrrOJIHHTeJIbHbIX AOCTOHHCTB TaKHX KaK

- CnoKoitCTBHe H qpe3BbIllaHHaH HaCTOHrIHBOCTh YMeHHe

npoitm AO Ko~a Aaxce IIO JIOJKHoMY cJIeAY H He YHbmaH BHOBb

Ha1JaTb C Ha1JaJIa pacnYThmaTh HOBYID HHT01IKY

- QYThe II03BOJIHlOrnee Aaxce B OTCYTCTBHe AOCTOBepHOH

HHltpOPMaIJHH rrpeAIIOJIOXCHTh lITO HeJI3AHO lITO-TO B AaTCKOM

KOpOJIeBCTBe 3AopOBaH IIOA03pHTeJIbHOCTb II03BOJIHIOrnaH

npeOAOJIeTh eCTeCTBeHHoe XCeJIaHHe 6pOCHTb paCCJIeAOBaHHe

- ThepAaH ysepeHHOCTb lITO rpa)KAaHe HMeIOT npaBO Ha

IIOJIHYlO HHltpOpMaIJHIO 060 BceM liTO 3aTparHBaeT ax HHTepeshy

CbI H Ha lITO OHH paCXOAytOT CHOH AeHbrn IIOKynaH TOBapbl

BHOCH HaJIOrn BbIIIJIa1JHBaH roHopapbI 3a ycJIYfH JIH60 IIpOshy

neHThI rro 6aHKOBCKHM 3aHMaM

- Xopomee BJIar(eHHe JIOrHKoit H aHaJIHTH1JeCKHMH HaBbIshy

KaMH a TaKXCe rOTOBHOCTh He xcaJIeTh CHJI Aaxce IIpH IIOHHMashy

HHH Toro lITO H3 TpeXMec~oit pa60TbI MoxceT TaK H He BbrUTH

HHKaKoit ny6JIHKaqHH

ECTb erne oAHa CTopOHa xltypHaJIHCTCKOro paCCJIeAOBaHHH

144 145

nOBbITlIaIQrnaH TpeOOBaHH51 K TeM KTO 3aHHMaeTCll STHM qeJIoyj

3aqaqa paCCJIeqoBaHHll COCTOHT B pa300JIaqeHHH

HHB H BbI1lBJIeHHH BHHOBHbIX npHlIeM penoPTep BbICT)lIIaeT

pOJm 06BHHHTeJIll Ero BbmOAbI qomKHbI ObITb TOqIIbIMH 11

eKTHBHbIMH - OT STOrO 3aBHCllT OJIaronorryqHe H nm~j

)KHBbIX JIIQqeB 3TO HeJIerKOe OpeMll H Cepbe3Hall

CTBeHHOCTb

KOHeqHO OObeKTaMH )KypHaJIHCTCKHX paCJlIOAUlIi11U1H

CTaHOBHTCll He TOJIbKO rocyqapCTBeHHble yqpe)KqeHHll 11

PYKOBOWiTeJIH H COTPYAHHKH PenopTepbl TOqIIO TaK )Ke

MaIQTCH qeJIaMH npOMbIillJIeHHbIX KOMnaHHB H

yqpe)KqeHHB nOJIHTHqeCKHX opraHH3anHB H ~ n ~

HbIX OOrneCTB HepeqKo ObIBaeT ~O paCCJIeqoBaHHe BbIXOAHT

qaneKo 3a paMKH nepBOHaqaJIbHOrO npeqMeTa

OPfAHlI3AUIDI PA60TLI

AHOHHMHbIB TeJIecpOHHbIB 3BOHOK pa3qaJICll B peqa~

ra3eTbI BO BpeMll HOqHOB CMeHbI KOma B oTqeJIe HOBOCTeB nashy

PHJIO HeOObllIHOe CnOKOBCTBHe YTPeIIHHM HOMep Y)Ke OblJI cqm

B neqaTb H THIITHUY He Hapyrnano ~O KpOMe IITHITeHHH

npHeMllHKe HaCTPoeHHOM Ha BOJIHY nommeMCKOB CB1l3H

3BOHHBIITHB cpa3Y B3sIJI ObIKa 3a pora BaM pe01lTa Haqo OhI

nOHHTepeCOBaTbCH 3eMeJIbHbIM ~IaCTKOM MHCTepa lJOKMaHa

HaliAeTe KOe-qTO JIIQOOnblTHoe OH OTKa3anCH npeqcTaB1ITbCll

HO 3aBepHJI penopTepa ~O TOT He nOTPaTHT BpeMeHH 3pll

TaKHe OTPbIBOqIIbIe cBeqeHHH H HaMeKH Hcxoq1lITIHe OT

oqHTeJIbHbIX HJIH qeM-TO paCCep)KeHHbIX HHcpopMaTopOB Heshy

peqKo qaIOT HaqanO TrnaTeJIbHOMY npoceHBaHHIQ BeJIHKOrO MHOshy

)KeCTBa ocpHnHaJIbHbIX OYMar B nOHCKax KpYITHOrO HJIH MeJI-middot

Koro )KYJIbHHIeCTBa B qaHHoM CJI~Iae npOBepKa MOrJIa nOKashy

3aTb 1ITO yqaCTOK Korqa-To qHCJIHBIITHMCll 3a lJoKMaHoM

)KHqaHHo neperneJI B qpyrne PYKH npHqeM STa nOKynKa noq03shy

pHTeJIbHO COBnana C HaqaJIOM OcpHnHarlbHO He

neperOBopOB 0 BbIqeJIeHHH 3eMJIH noq CTpOHTeJIbCTBO

3aBoqa KaK pa3 HenoqaneKY OT yqaCTKa

KaKHe Obi cBeqeHHll HH nonyqHJI penopTep OH npe)Kqe

Bcero qOJI)KeH OOAYMaTb B03MO)KHble nOCJIeqCTBHll HX OOHashy

poqoBaHH1l K qeMY MOryT npHBeCTH ~pHarmCTCKHe paCKonshy

KH qTO CJIeqyeT 1I3yqHTh H npOBepHTh KaKHe H Kyqa nOTllshy

HYTCll HHTOlJKH HaCKOJIbKO Ba)KHyro HHcpopMa~ MO)KHO noshy

JIyqHTb KaK HTorH paCCJIeqoBaHHll nOBJIH1[IQT Ha MeCTHble

qeJIa B neJIOM H Ha Tex JIIQqeB KOTopble 0YAYT BT1lHYTbI B ero

OPOHTY CKOJIbKO BpeMeHH nOHapOOHTCll ~OOhl pa3MOTaTb

BeCb KnyOOK Kyqa H K KOMY npHqeTCll OOpaTHTbCll 3a noshy

MOInbIQ rqe HCKaTb HCT01IHHKH OTHOcgrneMCll K qeny HHCPOpshy

ManHH PenopTepy HeOOXOAHMo OTBeTHTb Ha MlIOrHe TaKHe BOshy

npOCbl erne qo cpaKTlfqeCKOrO Haqana paCCJIeqoBaHH1l

HepeqKo nOJIe3HO 3apaHee npHKHHYTb MaKCHMaJIbHblM H

MHHHMaJIbHblB BapHaHTbl B03MO)KHbIX pe3YJIbTaTOB paCCJIeshy

qoBaHHll HanpHMep MO)KeT cnyqHTbCll ~o penopTep oOHapyshy

)KHT JIHITIh CPaKT BbIqeJIeHHll HeKHM qlfHOBHHKOM qsyx TblCHl1

qOJIJIapOB Ha 3aKYITKH HeOOXOAHMOCTb KOTOPbIX He OqeBHAHa

C qPyrOB CTOPOHbl paCCJIeqoBaHHe MO)KeT qoKa3aTb qTO

STOT )Ke qlfHOBHHK CHCTeMaTlfqeCKH 3anYCKan JIany B OOrneCTshy

BeHHyro Ka3ny H qeJIO naXHeT qJIll Hero KpynHbJM lliTpacpOM

HJIH TIQpeMHbJM cpOKOM

Mnorqa ~HarmcT cpa3y BbIKJIaqhmaeT Bce CaMoMY noqoshy

3peBaeMoMY npeqoCTaBJIsI1[ TOMY B03MO)KHOCTb onpaBqaTbCll H

n03)Ke npOBepllll ero pa3bllCHeHHll

PaCCJIeqoBaHHe KaK npaBHJIO pa3BeTBJIHeTCll no MlIOrHM

HanpaBJIeHHHM TaK qTO ~HarmCT H~aeTCll B CaMOAHcnHnshy

JIHHe H YMeHHH He nOTep1lTb 3a qepeBbllMH JIeca OqeHh Ba)KHO

MeTOAHqIIO CHCTeMaTH3HpOBaTb cBeqeHH1l H HMeTb AJIH K3)Kshy

qoro qeJIa Xopornyro KaPTOTeKY CaMbm oCBeqOMJIeHHbIB )Kypshy

HaJIHCT He MO)KeT 3HaTb Bcem nOSTOMY OqeHb B3)KHO scpcpeKshy

THBHO npHoopeTaTb HY)KHble cBeqeHHll KoppecnoHqeHT

CJIY)KObl HOBOCTeB raHHeTa POoePT XeA)Kec peKOMeHAYeT HHshy

Korqa He npeHeoperaTh MHeHH1lMH CnenHarIHCTOB KOTopble MOshy

ryT 3HaqHTeJIbHO nOMOTh B coope 11 aHarIH3e HHcpopManHH

lJonYCTHM BbI 3aHHMaeTeCb KaKOM-TO KopnOpanHeB HO

146 147

MaJIO ITO 0 HeH 3HaeTe H~e ee KOHKypeHTa KOTOPbUi

COrJIaCHTCSI C BaMII COTpygHlfCIaTb H KOTOPOM BbI MO)l(eTe noshy

BepSITb H rrorrpOCHTe ero 03HaKOMHTb Bac C THIIlfCIHbIMH OCO~

5eHHOCTSlMH pa50TbI rrOn05HbIX rrpenrrpHSlTHH Xen)I(ec

peKOMeHnyeT 5e3 CTpaxa 05paII(aTbcSI 3a rrOMO~IO K 5aHKHpaM

5yxraJITepaM 5Hp)l(eBbIM 5pOKepaM H IOpHCTaM K~Ui H3

HHX - CrrenHaJIHCT B CBoeH oooaCTH H MHorne C rOTOBHOCTbIO

OTKJIHKHYTCSI Ha rrpocb5y 0 rrOMOInH eCJIH rrpocSIIIJHH 0TKp0shy

BeHHO rrpH3HaeTCSI ITO eM He XBaTaeT KOMIIeTeHTHOCTH

OEPAIDEHlIE C IIcrOlHHKAMH

TOwIKOM K ~HaJIHCTCKOMy paCCJIenOBaHHIO MO)l(eT CTaTb

He TOJIbKO aHOHHMHbIH 3BOHOK HO rrpaKTlfCIeCKH JII050e COshy

05IneHHe rrpWleM rJIaBHYIO pOJIb HrpaIOT HMeHHO rronyqeHHble

CBeneHHSI a He TO oTKyna OHH rrOCTYIIHJIH PerropTep rrpOBepSlshy

eT ltpaKTWleCKHe naHHble KaKOB 5bI HH 5bIJI HX HCTOlHHK

IIOJIYlHB HHltpopManHIO gtKypHaJIHCT nOJI)I(eH OneHHTb

HMeHHO HHltP0PMaIJHIO a He MOTHBbI cy5beKTa OT KOTOPOro OHa

rrocTyrrHJIa HenOBOJIbHbIH CJIY)I(aInHH KOToporo B03MO)I(H0

050IIIJIH C rrOBbIIIIeHHeM CHrHaJIH3HpyeT B ra3eTY ITO Hashy

IaJIbHHK XaJITYPHO BeneT neJIOrrpOH3BonCTBO KpyrrHbIH lHHOBshy

HHK MO)l(eT HalaTb HcrrpaBJISlTb rpexH CBoero BenoMcTBa

rrpocTo YCTaB OT pa3rnJIbnSlHCTBa 5IOpoKpaTH3Ma H MeJIKoA

KoppyrrnHH Cop H3 H35bI MO)l(eT BbmeCTH H CrrenHaJIHCT KOToshy

pOM HanoeJIH rronalIKH 3a Ka3eHHbIH CIeT H~IM JIIOnSIM

C rrOJIHTlfCIeCKHMH CBSl3S1MH

)l(YPHaJIHCT EHJIJI CJIOYT rrpHBOnHT TaKoH rrpHMep

B 1972 r OnHH ltpJIOPHnCKHH rrOCTOBOH C 50JIbIIIHM CTa)I(eM

pa50TbI B rrOJIHnHH rrO)l(aJIOBaJICSI Ha CBoero HalaJIbHHKa B ra3eshy

Ty Tyn3H B ThTYCBHJIJIe OH rrpHHec KcepoKoIIHH TpexcOT

IIITpaltpHbIX KBHTaHnHH H3BJIeleHHbIX rro ero CJIOBaM H3 3arrepshy

Toro SlInHKa B roponCKoM yrrpaBJIeHHH rrOJIHIJHH Bce IIITpaltj)bl

5b1JIH aHHYJIHPOBaHbI no npHKa3y cTapIIIHX oltpHnepOB nOJImJHH

H CaMoro HalaJIbHHKa XOTSI HH 0nHH H3 OIIITpaltpOBaHHbIX He

05paInaJIcSI B cyn C )l(aJI050H Ha He3aKOHHOCTb IIITpaltj)a

148

PerropTep 5b1cTpo 05Hap~ ITO KBHTaHnHH 5b1JIH BbIshy

nHcaHbI Ha HMSI roponcKHX lHHOBHHKOB rrOJIHTHKOB 5aHKOBCKHX

CJIY)IaInHX - lJIeHOB 3arOpOnHOro KJIY5a rne COCTOSIJI H IIIeltj)

rrOJIHnHH a TaK)l(e HX neTeH CTporo rOBopSl pacnopIDKeHHSI Hashy

IaJIbHHKa rrOJIHnHH 05 aHHYJIHpOBaHHH IIITpaltj)OB He 5bIJIH

npOTHB03aKOHHbIMH HO HX 050CHOBaHHOCTb BbIrJISIneJIa SlBHO

COMHHTeJIbHoH PerropTep Orry5JIHKOBaJI CBOH BbmOnhI H Iepe3

HeCKOJIbKO MeCSIIJeB HaIaJIbHHK rrOJIHnHH rrOTepSlJI CBOIO nOJI)l(shy

HOCTb

Te KTO B035~aeT cyne5HbIe HCKH HepenKO C006InaIOT

perrOpTepaM Kyna 50JIbIIIe CBeneHHH IeM nOSIBJISleTCSI B oltpH-

nHaJIbHbIX rrpOTOKOJIax ltIgtHPMa rron03peBaIOInaSI ITO rrpHshy

5blJIbHbIH rocynapCTBeHHbIH KOHTpaKT MOleT yrrJIbITh y Hee

H3 pyK rrOCKOJIbKY KOHKypeHTbI naJIH KOM HanO Ha JIarry

CKopee Bcero C rOTOBHOCTbIO noneJIHTCSI 3THMH CBeneHHSIMH C

~HaJIHCTOM

EbmaeT ITO rrepBOHalaJIbHble CBeneHHSI rrocTyrraIOT OT

mo5HTeJIeH CJIYXOB KOTopbIe na)I(e He Bcerna OC03HaIOT ITO MOshy

rYT npHIHHHTb HerrpHSlTHOCTH c05CTBeHHOMY HalaJIbCTBY

TIonqac JIIOnH neJISlTCSI HHltj)opManHeH IT05bI npoCTO 05JIershy

lHTb nyrny rronqepKHBaSl ITO CaMII HM B qeM He 3aMeIIIaHbI

BHHa JIe)I(HT Ha KOM-TO npyrOM KOe-KOM HPaBHTCSI pOJIb Bceshy

3HaeK H OHM C rOTOBHOCTbIO BbInaIOT ~PHaJIHCTY HCTOPHH He

BHYIIIaIOInHe nOBepHSI XOTSI HHorna H conep)l(aInHe peaJIbHble

ltj)aKTbI QT05bI rrOMep)l(aTb CBOIO penYTanHIO TaKHe JIIOnH rroshy

CTOSlHHO rOHSIIOTCSI 3a HOBbIMH CIIJIemSlMH I1x pBeHHe He fiY)I(shy

naeTCSI B orrJIaTe H rronqac K HHM CTOHT 05paTHTbCSI IT05bI rroshy

JIYlHTb Koe-KaKHe naHHbIe HenOCTYIIHbIe rrOCTOpOHHHM Ho K

TaKHM HHltj)opMaTOpaM CJIenyeT OTHOCHTbCSI KPaHHe OCTOPO)I(HO

rrOCKOJIbKY HX paCCKa3bI HanrrmrOBaHbI rrpeyneJllfC[eHHSIMH

liHorna HHltj)OPManHSI rrpHXOnHT H3 COBepIIIeHHO HeO)I(HnaHshy

HbIX HCTOlHHKOB KaK-TO HanpHMep He Ha3BaBIIIaSI ce5S1 CTyshy

neHTKa KOHcepBaTOpHH co05InHJIa ITO 0nHH H3 rrpoltj)eccopoB

5YKBaJIbHO 3aCTaBJISleT ee 5paTb norrOJIHHTeJIbHbIe YPOKH H rrJIashy

THTb 3a HHX JlHlIIHHe COTHH nOJIJIapoB )l(YPHaJIHCTCKOe pacshy

149

Cne~OBa1H1e OOHapYlKHnO TITO 3THM 3aHHMaJIHCb H ~pyrne npeshy

no~aBaTeJIH OT Iero rrOCTpa~aJIH ~eCHTKH CT~eHTOB

ECTb MHoro ~pyrnx MOTHBOB rro KOTOPbIM mo~ ~eJI5ITCH

HHcpopMalHeM - OOH~a MeCTb KOpblCTb H TOMY rrO~OOHoe

YBOJIeHHblM HJIH o60~eHHbrn Harpa~OM IHHOBHHK HJIH nOJIHTHK

gtKeJIaIOmHM CBeCTH ClleThI C KOHKypeHTaMH MOgtKeT OXOTHO 00shy

maTbCH C perropTepOM rrpOHBJIHIOmHM HHTepec K ero paCCKashy

3aM OTHIO~b He Bce rrO~TBep~aeTCH HO YCHJIeHHO lHPKYJIHshy

pyroIlHe CJlYXH OOblIHO 3aCJIYlKHBaIOT npOBepKH - ~IMa oe3

OrHH He ObmaeT

lJagtKe y~HBHTeJIbHO KaK MHoro CBe~eHHM MorYT ~aTb

perropTepy ToproBbIe areHThI He ~OOHBlliHeCH KOHTPaKTOB H

ooypeBaeMbIe gtKeJIaHHeM HaCOJIHTb KOHKypeHTaM liIMeHHO rro

TaKHM CHrHaJIaM BblmeJI Ha HHTepeCHbIM CJIe~ perropTep O~OM

H3 ra3eT Cpe~Hero 3aIla~a OH OOHapYlKHJI TITO TpH TpaHcrropTshy

HbIe CPHPMbI rrpe~JIOgtKHJIH MYHHIIHnaJIbHbIM BJIaCTHM CBOH

yCJIyrH Ha y~HBHTeJIbHbIM 06pa30M CXO~HbIX YCJIOBHHX OKashy

3aJIOCb ITO KOHTOPbI 3THX CPHPM pacnOnOgtKeHbI B O~OM II

TOM gtKe 3~aHIm a HX MeHerpKepbI HMeJIH MHOrOIHCJIeHHbIe 00shy

mHe ~CJIOBbIe HHTepeCbI Ka)K]lbIH MeHe~ep rrpH rro~aIe 3aHBshy

KH B nHCbMeHHOM cpopMe 3aHBHJI TITO HH C KeM He ~orOBapHshy

BaJICH 0 TapHcpax H ~yrHX YCJIOBHHX KOHTpaKTa CoopaHHble

gtKypHa-JIHCTOM CBe~eHHH n03BOJIHJIH npe~nOJIQ)KHTb ITO

MeIe~gtKe-Pbl BCTynHJIH ~pyr C ~pyroM B TaMHblM crOBOp -

HapymcHHe 3aKOHa HaKa3yeMoe mTpaltpOM HJIH TIOpeMHbIM

3aKJIIOIeHHeM

Eme O~Ha MHoroooemaIOmaH OOJIaCTb KypHaJIHCTCKHX

paCCJIe~OBaHHH - rocy~apCTBeHHble CyOCII~ TbICHIH TaKHX

CyOCH~M pacnpe~eJIHIOTCSI eKero~o npIIIeM Ka~aSl II3 HHX

BbI~eJISleTCSI Ha onpe~eJIeHHbIX YCJIOBH5IX II p~ onpe~eJIeHshy

HOM IICJIH HaIIpIIMep rrOMOmH KaKOM-TO rpynne 3MaIa penopshy

Tepa - Y3HaTb ObIJIII JIH 3TH ycnoBIISI COOJIIO~eHbI a IIeJIb

BbmOJIHeHa

150

3AIIUITA KOHCbH)JEHlJIIAJIbHOCfH HCfOQHHKOB

Y crrex KYPHamICTCKOro paCCJIe~OBa1HISi B pemalOmeH CTeshy

neHH 3aBHCHT OT OTHomeHIIM penopTepa C TeMH KTO ~eJIHTCH C

HHM CBe~eHH5IMH Ha YCJIOBH5IX KOHcp~eHIIIIaJIbHOCTII )KypHashy

JIHCTy He 00Sl3aTeJIbHO 3HaTb rrOIeMY ero HHltpopMaTopbI HaCTashy

HBalOT Ha TaKHX YCJIOBHX HO OH ~OJIKeH n03aOOTHThCH TITOObl

HX HMeHa OCTamICb Hepa3rJIarneHHblMH HYKHO II30eraTb JIIOshy

OblX ~eHCTBHH KOTopble MOrJIH Obi npIIBeCTH K paCKpbITHIO aHOshy

HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB

KOHeIHO HH O~IIH nOCTaBmHK ~HaJIIICTCKOM HHCPOpshy

MalHH He OOJIMaeT a6cOmOTHbIM npaBOM Ha aHOHHMHOCTb II

KypHaJIHCT He MOgtKeT ero rapaHTIIpOBaTb HanpHMep cy~S1 MOshy

gtKeT pacnop~bCSI TITOObl penopTep B IIHTepecax npaBOcyshy

~HSI COOOmHJI OTKy~a OH nOJIYIHJI Te HJIH IIHbIe CBe~eHIISI

npHIeM B Harne BpeMH TaKIIe paCnOpSIKeHHSI OT~aIOTCSI Iame

IeM B npOmJIOM )KypHaJIIICTaM peKOMeH~eTCSI CJIe~Tb 3a

npeIIe~eHTaMH 3Toro po~a II ObITb B Kypce pacnpOCTpaHeHHbIX

IOpII~HIeCKIIX HOpM H cy~eoHbIX pemeHIIH OTHOCSlmHXCSI K

npaBy cpe~CTB MaCCOBOH HHltpOPMaIIIIII ooeperaTb TaMMy aHOshy

HHMHbIX HCTOIHHKOB B HeKOTopbIX CJIYIaSIX 3aKOH pa3pemaeT

He pa3rJIaIIIaTh HX HMeHa HO TaK ObmaeT ~aJIeKO He Bcer~a

Heooxo~o TmaTeJIbHO ConOCTaBIITb IIeHHOCTb CBe~eHHH

nOJIYIeHHbIX OT aHOHHMHoro OCBe~OMHTeJISI C nocne~CTBIIshy

S1MH KOTopble MOKeT HMeTh pemeHIIe cy~a npe~CbmalOmee

Ha3BaTh ero HMSI TIyqmaH CTpaTernH COCTOHT B TOM TITOObI He

CTaBIITb B YSl3BHMOe nOJIOKeHIIe HH caMoro ~pHamICTa HH ero

HHcpopMaTOpOB H~o npHJIOlKHTb MaKCIIMYM YCIIJIHH TITOObI

no~ep~b nyOJIHKyeMble MaTepIIaJIbI nocpe~cTBoM 0ltpIIIIHshy

aJIbHbIX ~oKyMeHToB H ~yrHX no~ooHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB lJaKe

B IaCTHbIX 3anHC5IX ~HaJIHCTa aHOHHMHble OCBe~OMHTeJIH He

~OJIKHbI BbIcTynaTb no~ nO~JIHHHbIMH HMeHaMH - ropa3~0

oe30naCHeH nOJIb30BaTbCH KJIHIKaMH PeKOMeH~eTCH orpaHIIshy

IHTh ~O aOCOJIIOTHOrO MHHHMYMa IIICJIO JIHII cnOCOOHbIX onpeshy

~eJIHTb KaHaJIbl aHOHHMHOH HHcpopMaIIIIH

151

PerropTepa KOTOPbIH YHWITO)l(aeT HJill rrepe~eJIbmaeT 3a-middot

IIHCH nOclle TOrO KaK OHH OqJHWIaJIbHO 3aTPeOOBaHbI OpraHClMH

rrpaBocy~H MOryT OOBHHHTb B Heysa)l(eHHH K cy~ CaMoe HMe)I(HOe - KaK MO)I(HO paHbme H30aBHTbCH OT BCeX ~OKYMeHshy

TaJIbHbIX CB~eTeJIbCTB co~ep)l(aIWIx HHqgtopManHIO KOTOpag

MO)l(eT rrOBJIeIb paCKpbITHe HCTOlHHKa

EbmmHH )K)1JHaJIHCT KJIapK MOJIJIeHXOCPCP rrpe~pe~aeT

MOJIO~IX perrOPTepOB

rI0 TeX rrop rrOKa Bac He OCBOOO~HT OT OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH

3a 3aIWITY CBOHX KOHcp~eHWIaJIbHbIX HCTOlHHKOB HM BClMH

Bcer~a BHCHT ~aMOKJIOB MeI OrrJIaThI ycnyr MBOKaTa lliTPacpa

HJill ~a)I(e TIOpeMHOrO 3aKJIIOIeHHH He OOH3aTeJIbHO KpaTKOro

fl3~aTeJIb MO)l(eT B3HTb Ha ceOH paCXO~I HO CpOK BaM rrp~eTshy

CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy

KAK BLITIOJIHlITb 3A1JAqy

)l(YPHaJIHCTCKOe paCCJIe~OBaHHe Hepe~o TPeoyeT OCOObIX

YCHJillH BeCbMa IaCTO perropTep IIbITaeTCH pa3~OObITb CBeshy

~eHHH KOTopbIe rocy~apcTBeHHaH opraHH3anHH HJill IaCTHaH

cpHpMa XOTeJill ObI ~ep)l(aTb B ceKpeTe TIOCKOJIbKY KoppecrrOHshy

~eHTbI He BrrpaBe BbI3BaTb K ceoe CBH~eTeJIeH rrOBeCTKaMlI

rrpHXO~TCH rrpHoeraTb K HHbIM MeTO~aM

XopOIIIHe perropTepbI rrpHMeHHIOT ~JIH CBOHX paCKorrOK

CaMbIe pa3HbIe HHCTPYMeHThI OIeHb rrOMoraeT YMeHHe yoe~

rrOTeHIIHaJIbHbIX HHcpopMaTopOB ITO HM BbITO~O rro~eJillThshy

CH ~IMH CBe~eHHHMH ECJill )K)1JHaJIHCT rrOJIb3yeTcH BceMH

~OCTYIIHblMH eMy aprYMeHTaMH ~JIH rronyqeHHH Heooxo~oA HHcgtopManHH 3TO COBceM He 03HaIaeT ITO OH HapymaeT rrposhy

cpeCCHOHaJIbHYIO 3THKy

3aMeCTHTeJIb OKpY)I(Horo rrpoKypopa MO)l(eT rrpeKpaCHO

rrOHHMaTb ITO OOJIa~aeT B3pbmoorraCHOH HHcpOpManHeH HO

OTCIO~a COBceM He BbITeKaeT ITO OH 3aXOIeT OOCY~Tb ee c

)K)1JHaJIHCTOM 3MaIa perroPTepa H COCTOHT B TOM ITOObI yoeshy

~Th CJIY)l(HTeJIH 3aKOHa ITO OH rrpOBepHT COOOmeHHbIe eMY

CBe~eHHH Ha CTopOHe H He oy~eT CCbmaTbCH HH Ha caMoro 3aMshy

npOKypopa HH Ha ero Be~OMCTBO

YMeJIbIe perropTepbI Hepe~KO CTaJIKHBaIOT HCTOIHHKH

nOaMH HarrpHMep )K)1JHaJIHCT MO)l(eT HaMeKHyTb HecrOBOpshy

IHBOMy cooece~y ITO paCCJIe~OBaHHe B OCHOBHOM 3aKOHshy

1IeHO H ITO B ero COOCTBeHHbIX HHTepecax nyqme rrO~eJillThCH

He~OCTaIOmHMH CBe~eHHHMH (rrpH 3TOM HerrJIOXO rrpHcoBoKyshy

IlllTh KOe-KaKHe CPaKTbI ITOObI HCTOlHHK He COMHeBaJICH B OCBeshy

~OMJIeHHOCTH perropTepa) B 3TOM cnyqae ~pHaJIHCT rrposhy

H3Bo~HmHii paCCJIe~OBaHHe Be~eT ceOH TaK KaK 0YWO Y)l(e

3HaeT Bce OCHOBHbIe CPaKThI XOTH Ha ~eJIe B03MO)I(H0 Bcero

JIHllib OJIecpyeT

B oece~e COBceM He Bpe~o HarrYCTHTb Ha ceOH ysepeHHbIH

B~ ~aBaH rrOHHTh ITO ~OrrOJIHHTeJIbHbIe BOrrpOCbI 3MaIOTCH

TOJIbKO pa~ BHmeH TOlHOCTH B TO )I(e BpeMH perropTep ~OJI)I(eH

HeH3MeHHO OKa3bmaTh cooece~HKY ~oJI)I(Hoe YSa)l(eHHe Eeshy

ce~a c rr03HIIHH CHJIbI HHor~a rrpHHocHT neHHYIO HHcpopMashy

IIHIO HO rrpHOeraTh K 3TOH TaKTHKe CJIe~eT C OCTOPO)I(HOCThIO

TIpOBO~H )K)1JHaJIHCTCKOe paCCJIe~OBaHHe IaCTO rrpHxoshy

~HTCH HCrrOJIb30BaTb KOHKypeHnHIO Me)l(~y pa3JIHIHbIMH

opraHH3aWIHMH KOHelHO 3TO He 3HaIHT ITO perropTep ~OJIshy

)I(eH rrOCBHTHTh Bce CBoe BpeMSI paCKarrbIBaHHIO Bcex H BCHIeCshy

KHX OCHHblX rne3~ HO eMy He rpex rrOMHHTb H HCrrOJIb30BaTh

TO OOCTOHTeJIbCTBO ITO Ka~oe Be~OMCTBO HMeeT CBOH HHTeshy

peCbI H CHMrraTHH Ha pa3JillIHHX Me~ KOTOPbIMH BO HMH HCshy

THHbI He B030paHHeTCH H CbIrpaTh

Hepe~o OIeHb rrOMoraeT rrpe~apHTeJIbHaH rryOJIHKanHH

JIlIIITh IaCTH HMeIOmHXCH MaTepHaJIOB ~a)I(e eCJill paccJIe~oshy

BaHHe eme He 3aKOHIeHO BOT ITO 06 3TOM rrHllieT PooepT Kapo

PerropTepbI-HOBHIKH ObICTPO rrpHxo~HT K Bbmo~y ITO

HHcpOpManHH KOTOPYIO TaK TPY~O rrOJIYlliTb Ha paHHeH CTashy

~moooro HOBoro paCCJIe~OBaHHH HaIHHaeT rrocTyrraTh B H30shy

OHJillH cpa3y rrOCJIe rrOHBJIeHHH B rreIaTH rrepBOH )I(e CTaTbH C

Ke COOpaHHblMH CBe~eHHHMH B Ka~OH 3aHHTepeCOBaHHOH

opraHH3anHH Ha~yTCH OOpnbI 3a rrpaB~y mooHTeJill rrowashy

152 153

mITh HaIaJIbCTBY H npOCTO HeAOBOJIbHble KOTopble OXOTHO

nOAeJISITCSI TeM ITO 3HaIOT

OIlbITHble )l()PHaJIHCTbI 6bICTPO H YMeJIO HaXOASIT KOHshy

TaKThI C caMbIMH pa3HbIMH HCTOIHHKaMH HY)KHbIX CBeAemut

CJIeAYeT nOMHlITb ITO Oltp~HaJIbHble AOKYMeHThI H 3aIIHshy

CH 6eceA C IHHOBHHKaMH H nOJIHTHKaMH 06bIIH0 AOnOJIHHIOT

APyr APyra HaIaB C AOKYMeHTOB ~HaJIHCT MO)KeT 3a)Jan

nOTOM H 60JIee KOHKpeTHble BonpOCbI C APyrOH CTOPOHbI Aoshy

KYMeHTbI n03BOJISIIOT npOBepHTh H O~eHHTh YCTHYIO HHltPOpshy

Ma~HIO T~aTeJIbHO H3yIHB oltpH~aJIbHhle 6YMarH H ny6JIHKashy

~HH )KYPHaJIHCT JIerIe pacn03HaeT JIO)Kb KorAa c06eceIlHllK

nOIlbITaeTCSI BBeCTH ero B 3a6JIY)KAeHHe KpOMe Toro OCHeshy

AOMHTeJIb MO)KeT nepeAYMaTb H OTKa3aThCSI OT CBOHX CJIOB HO

eCJIH Y ~HaJIHCTa J)Ke eCTb Ha)Je)KHbIe Oltp~HaJIbHbIe AOshy

KYMeHThI 3TO CAeJIaTh KYAa TpYAHeH

KoppecnOHAeHT HbIOCAaH P06ePT rpHH peKOMeHAYeT

AJISI )KYPHaJIHCTCKOro paCCJIeAOBaHHSI TaKTHKY MeAJIeHHO

3aTSIrHBaeMOH neTJIH no ero MHeHHIO JIyIlle Bcero HaIaTb

co BTopocreneHHbIX ~ H C06bITHH H nOCTeneHHO He rrpHBshy

JIeKaSI BHHMaHHSI K paCCJIeAOBaHHIO nOA6HpaTbCSI K rJIaBHbDl

ltpHrypaM He B036~aSI HX nOA03peHW

KaK-TO peAaKTOp KeHT ltIgtPHJIaHA BMeCTe C ABYMSI COTpYAshy

HHKaMH 3aHHMaJICSI paCCJIeAOBaHHeM MaXHHa~HH HbIO-HOPKshy

CKOH MaltpHH nbITaBllieHCSI nOJIYIHTh BbIrOAHbIe KOHTpaKTbI Ha y60PKY yJIH~ H YCTaHOBKY ToprOBbIX aBTOMaTOB BOT ITO OB

BCnOMHHaeT

CHaIaJIa MbI BbrrnJIH Ha HeCKOJIbKHX BTopocTeneHHbIX

ytIaCTHHKOB 3TOH orrepa~HH 3aTeM MOH nOMO~HKH BbUshy

BHJIH ABYX PYKOBOmlTeJIeH KOTOPbIX rrpoHHTepBbIOHpoBaJIB

B pa3Hoe BpeMSl H rrOOAHHOIKe T~aTeJIbHOe CpaBHeHHe 3anBshy

ceH 3THX 6eceA 06HapY)KHJIO rrpoTHBopeIHSI KOTopble

nOCJIY)KHJIH oTrrpaBHbIMH TOIKaMH AJISI npOAOJI)KeHBI

paCCJIeAOBaHHSI bull

BbIBaeT H TaK ITO )l()PHaJIHCT OTKa3aBIIIHCb OT ooxollHbIX

nYTeH MO)KeT CHJIbHO ynpOCTHTh 3a)JaIY H COKpaTHTh

IS4

1JOJI)KHTeJIbHOCTbpaCCJIeAOBaHHSI HarrpHMepBMeCTO Toro ITOObI

TPaTHTb MHorne IaCbI pacKaIlbIBaSI B MYHH~HnaJIbHbIX apshy

XBBax CBeAeHHSI 06 H~eCTBe KpYIIHorO 3eMJIeBJIaAeJIb~a JIYIIIIe HaIaTh C 6HorpaltpHIeCKOrO CrrpaBOIHHKa HJIH rrpSIMo noshy

3BOHHTb ero ceKpeTapIO JlIOmI C nOJIO)KeHHeM B 06~eCTBe Heshy

peAKo ~eCJIaBHbI H coo6~aIOT 0 ce6e HeMaJIO cBeAeHHit rrOAshy

IepKHBaIO~X BX 60raTCTBO B BJIHSIHHe TaKBM rryTeM peshy

rropTep MO)KeT c6epeIb HeMaJIO BpeMeHH IQUI pellieHHSI 60JIee

cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM

BOT 0 IeM e~e ~O nOMHHTh ~a BKJIIOIeHHble B KPyr

~HaJIHCTCKOro paCCJIeAOBaHHSI IaCTO BbIAaIOT 06HJIbHYIO

BHltpOPM~ HO nbITaIOTCSI BbICTaBHTh ce6SI B BbIrOAHOM CBeTe

ECJIH OHH B IeM-TO H rrpB3HaIOTCSI TO HaCTaHBaIOT ITO He COshy

BepIIIHJIH HHIerO rrpOTHB03aKOHHoro PerropTepy CJIeAYeT He

TOJIbKO npOBepHTh Bce co06~eHHble eMY ltpaKThI HO TaK)Ke AaTb

co6eceAHHKaM B03MO)KHOCTh CaMHM npOKOMMeHTHpOBaTb Bce

BbIABBHYTDle npomB HHX 06BHHeHBSI QeJIb ~HaJIHCTa - COshy

6paTh 06beKTHBHbIe CBeAeHHSI B BbISICHHTh HCTHHY a He rrOAshy

JIOBHTh TO HJIH HHoe ~O HHKorAa He CJIeAYeT rrpeHe6peraTh

KOHCYJIbT~eH C IOPHCTOM OC06eHHO eCJIH HY)KHO 06eCrreIHTh

ceKpeTHOCTb BCTOIHHKOB nOJIYIeHHOH HHltpopMa~HH HJIH

rrpOBepHTh npOTHB03aKOHHbI JIH paCCJIeAYeMble AeHCTBBSI

HaKOHe~ )KYPHaJIHCT 06SI3aH B36eraTh Aa)Ke nYCTSIIHbIX

OIIIH60K CKOJIbKO 6bmo CJlYIaeB KorAa Oltp~aJIbHbIM JIH~aM SIBHO 3aMelliaHHbIM B He6JIarOBHAHbIX AeJIHlliKax YAaBaJIOCb

BbIHrn cyxmm H3 BOAhI HJIH KaK MHHHMYM nOAOpBaTh AOBeshy

pHe K 06BHHHTeJISIM BMeHHO B3-3a MeJIKHX HeTOIHOCTeH B peshy

rroPTa)Kax BBJIJI CnOYT BblliOJIHHBrnHH HeMaJIO )KYPHaJIHCTCKHX

paCCJIeAOBaHHH KaK-TO co06~ ITO cYMMa KOTOPyro M)HHshy

~aJIbHaSI KOMHCCHSI YIIJIaTHJIa 3a 3eMJIIO AJISI aBTOCTOSIHKH

OKaJaJIaCb Ha CTO Tp~aTh ThICSII AOJIJIapOB Bbrrne peaJIbHOH

CTOHMOCTH YIaCTKa orrpeAeJIeHHOH OltPH~aJIbHbIM o~e~KOM - H aTO rrpH TOM ITO rOAOM paHbllie TY )Ke 3eMJIIO MO)KHO 6bmo KynBTh Aa)Ke 3a MeHblliBe AeHbrn OAHaKO CnOYT AorrYCTBJI

KpOXOTHYIO HeTOIHOCTb OH HarrHCaJI ITO KOMHCCHSI Y)Ke

ISS

rrpHOOpeJIa ~aCTOK a Ha CaMOM ueJIe K STOM BpeMeHH rrpOIIDIO

mIIIIb roJIOCoBrume rrorrOBO)Jy sTOii cuemrn 113-3a SToii-TO OnrnOKH

tIJIeHhI KOMHCCHH rrouHSlJIH CTpamHblii myM XOTSI BO BceM

OCTaJIbHOM lKYPHaJIHCT HH Ha iiory He OTKJIOHHJICSI OT HCTmIbI

II03llHee CJIOyrIIHCaJI lITO uOCTOBepHOCTh CaMoro CJIaooro 3BeHa

lKYPHaJIHCTCKOrO cooo~eHHSl B TOtIHOCTH paBHa uOCTOBepHOCTD

CaMoro cooo~eHHSl -aTO cepbe3Hbm ypOKllJISI BcexperrOPTepoB

KAK nOJIh30BAThCH O(f)IfIUIAJIhIlLIMH MATEPIlAJIAMII

JIaypeaThI lKYPHaJIHCTCKHX rrpeMHii uOHaJIbu BaPTJIeTT H

~eiiMC CTHJI He OTpHI1aIOT lITO KOrraThCSI B 3aJIexax CyxHX B

rrOHatIany MaJIOrrOHSlTHbIX uOKYMeHTOB H CTaTHCTHIeCKHX uaushy

HbIX-BeCbMaCKYtIHOO3aHS1THeHo OHHBMecreCTeMOTMetIaIOT

lITO H3~eHHe O~~aJIbHblX OYMar H apXHBHbIX uaHHblX 3Hashy

tIHTeJIbHO rrOMoraeT perroprepy BbmOJIHSlTh BaxueAmyro 06shy

~eCIBeHHYIO~~-HaomouaTh 3aueSlTeJIbHOCThIOrocyuapshy

CTBeHHbIX HHCrnTyrOB H HH~pMHpOBaTh 00 aTOM oo~eCIBo

IIOtITH K~OO cepbe3Hoe lKYPHaJIHCTCKOe paCCJIeuOBaHHe

OCHOBaHO Ha uoKYMeHTaJIbHoii HH~PMaImf MueT JIB petIb 0

rocyuapCTBeHHOM ytIpexueHHH HJIH tIaCTHOii KoprropaQHH

Bcerua HaiiuyrCSI HeOOXOllHMble uOCbe H3 KOTOPblX MO)KHO KaK

M03aHKY COCTaBHTb rroJIHYIO Kaprnuy EcJm perropTep 3auHMashy

eTCSI paCCJIeuOBaHHeM ueSlTeJIbHOCTH tIacTHoii ~HpMbI TO CBeshy

ueHHSI 0 Heii MO)KHO rrOJIYtIHTh B yqpe)KlleHHSlX pa3JIHtIHOrO

YPOBHSI KaK MeCTHbIX TaK H ~uepaJIbHbIX Yxe BJIaueSl crrpashy

BOtIHOH HH~pMaQHeH lKYPHaJIHCT MoxeT OOpaTHTbCSI Herroshy

cpeuCTBeHHO K PYKOBOuClBY ~HpMbI ECJIH eM He yuaCTCSI rronymiddot

tIHTh OTBeTa Ha CBOH BorrpOCbI TO uOTOmHDm perroPTep pa3llOshy

oyueT HeOOXOllHMble CBeueHHSI H B upyrnx MecTax TOtIHO TaK

xe xypHaJIBCT BeueT paCCJIeuOBaHHe ueSlTeJIbHOCTH rocyshy

uapCTBeHHbIX yqpe)KlleHHit

156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH

BOBAH DPE311)JEHTCKAH nOJIlIT1IKA II TEJIEBII)JEHIIE

B 1988 r ceHaTOp I(gtK03ecp BaAueH HatIaJI obmo OOPbO

3a rrpe3HlleHTCm rroCT HO Bce ero Haue)Kllbl rrOmJIH rrpaxOM

Korua rryoJIHKa Y3HaJIa lITO OH YJIHtIeH B IIJIarnaTe ollHoii B3

petIeii JIBuepa opHTaHcKoii JIeiiOOpBcTCKOH rrapTBB HeiiJIa

KmmoKa Pa3MbIIIIJISISl 00 aTOM ra3eTa lliIO-RoPK TaitMc OTshy

MeTHJIa lITO 3a rrOCJIellHHe TpBllQaTh JIeT TeJIeBBueHBe ~yuuashy

MeHTaJIbHO B3MeHHJIO CTPYKTypy rrOJIBTHIeCKHX KaMIIaunA B

IISITHlleCSlThIe rOllbI rrpecca ueiiCIBOBaBmaSl B Te BpeMeHa C rroshy

uatIH rrapTBHHblX JIBuepOB CKopee Bcero rrpOCTO OCTaBBJIa

Obi 003 BHBMaHHSI pa300JIatIeHHSI rrouOOHbIe 3aKpbmmBM BaAshy

ueuy (PaBHO KaK B rSpB XaPTY) IIyrb B BeJIbm uOM

B Harne BpeMSl OTMetIaeT lliIO-ROPK TaitMc CHTyawrn

pallHKaJIbHO B3MeHHJIaCb - cpeuClBa MaccoBoii BH~OPMaQHB

CaMB oQeHBBaIOT KaHllBuaTOB Ha rrOJIBTHIeCKBe uOJI)KHOCTB

BHlle03aIIHCH C rrOJIHoit yOOllHTeJIbHOCThIO uOKa3aBnrne lITO

ceHaTOp BaAueH B lliIO-XsMmIIHpe KOIIHpOBaJI BbICTyIIJIeHBe

KJrnHoKa B B caMOM ueJIe OKa3aJIBCb MO~bIM cpeucTBoM

B03ueiicTBHSI Ha rryOJIHKY B Harne BpeMSl TeJIeKOMHKB TmIa

I(gtKOHHB KapcOHa B uSBBlla JIeTTepMaHa BrrOJIHe crrOCOOHbI rroshy

KOHtIBTb C HeKOTOpbIMH rrpeTeHlleHTaMH Ha rrOJIBTBtIeCKBe

rrOCThI KaK STO B rrpOB30IIDIO c BaAueHOM

lliIO-RoPK TaitMc JIBmb C 3arr03ururneM rrpB3HaJIa lITO

3a rrOCJIellHHe Tp~aTh JIeT rrpoB30uma peBOJIIOQBSI B xapaKshy

repe B B03ueiicTBHH cpeuCTB MaCCOBoii BH~OPMaQHH KaK B

caMHX CoeuBHeHHbIX IIITaTax TaK H B upyrnx pa3BBTbIX

HH)JyCTPBaJIbHbIX oO~eCTBax 310 BHOBb tIeTKO rrpoueMOHshy

CTPHPOBaJIB rrepBBtIHhIe rrpe3HueHTCKBe BbIOOPbI 1988 r

HaomouaTeJIB rrpaKTHiecKB He OOHap~ HBKaKOit rrpBshy

157

Hlurn) rOTOBbIM rrpH rrepBOH B03MO)I(HOCTII rrO)KpaTb BCe ITO

TOJIbKO rrOrraneTCSl HHlTO He MO)KeT rroKoJIe6aTb RX HeCOKpyshy

IIDIMOH BepbI B TO qTO mo60H rronyqaTeJIb Ka3eHHoro )KaJIOshy

BaHbSl Bcerna rOTOB rrOKYCHTbCSl Ha 06~eCTBeHHbIe HHTepeshy

CbI a pa306JIaqIfTb ero --- rrepBethImii nOJIr H 06Sl3aHHOCTb

~pHaJIHCTa

PeaJIbHaSI neHCTBHTeJIbHOCTb naJIeKa OT 3TOH qepHo-6eJIOH

KapTHHbI KOHe~o BCTPeqaIOTCSl H HerrOKOJIe6HMbIe BOHHCTshy

BeHHbIe pbInapH 6e3 cTpaxa H yrrpeKa H yrOnJIHBbIe JIHneMeshy

PbI neJIaIOIIWe peKJIaMY H~bIM rrOJIHTHKaM KOTOPbIe 6ecshy

rrpHHnHrrHo rrOJIb3YIQTcSl HX YCJIyraMH Ho Me)Kl1y 3THMH DBYMSl

KPaHHHMH rromoCaMH XBaTaeT MeCTa nJISl BeJIHKOrO MHO)KeCTBa

~HaJIHCTOB H anMHHHcTPaTopoB rro-cBoeMY cny)Kanwx 06shy

~ecTBY H rrOMep)KlfBaIO~ npyr C npyrOM XOTb H BPIDKshy

ne6HbIe HO B neJIOM BrrOJIHe HOpMaJIbHbIe OTHOIIIeHHSl OnHashy

KO nJISl )KypHaJIHCTOB He TaK-TO JIerKO HaHTH rrpaBHJIbHOe

COOTHOIIIeHHe Me)Kl1y COTpYnHHqeCTBOM C rrOJIHTHKaMH H Hashy

6JIIOneHHeM 3a HX neSlTeJIbHOCTbIO 3neCb cpa3Y B03HHKaeT

pSln BorrpOCOB

1 ECJIH Y)K rrpecca H BJIaCTH He B COCTOSlHHH HaCJIIDKshy

naTbCSl HnHJIJIHqeCKOH np~60H B qeM HMeHHO COCTOHT HX COshy

rrepHIfqeCTBO

2 KaK naJIeKO MO)I(HO 3aHTII B rron06HoH KoHKypeHnHH

3 B KaKOH Mepe rrpecce rr03BOJIHTeJIbHO cOTPYnHIfqaTb C

rrpaBHTeJIbCTBOM HJIH rrOMOraTb eMY He CKOMilpOMeTHpOBaB

ce6Sl H CBOH rrpHHnHIlbI

C OnHOH TO~ 3peHHSl KOHKypeHnHSl Me)Kl1y rrpeCCOH H

BJIaCTSlMH HeH36e)I(Ha rrpOCTO rrOTOMY ITO neJIH CTOPOH pa3shy

JIH~I H HeCOBMeCTHMbI )l(YPHaJIHCTbI n06bIBaIOT HHcpopMashy

nHIO B TO BpeMSl KaK 6IOpOKpaTbI CTPeMSlIIWecSl COxpaHHTb

CBoe rrOJIO)KeHHe BOBce He )KeJIaIOT eIO neJIHTbCSl IIpyroe 06bshy

SlCHeHHe 3Toro cOrrepHHqeCTBa COCTOHT B TOM ITO 06~eCTBO

He CJIHIIIKOM nOBepSleT CBOHM H36paHHbIM H Ha3HaqeHHbIM

CJIyraM H HMeHHO rrpecca 3aCTaBJISleT BJIaCTII OTqIfTblBaTbshy

CSl rrepen corpa)Kl1aHaMH B CBORX neHCTBHSlX ECTb H TPeTbe

MHeHHe rrpecca B rrpHHnHrre COBceM He Bpa)Kl1e6Ha rocynap-

CTBY neJIO JIHIIIb B TOM qTO n06bIBaSI HHcpOpManHIO B KOTOPOH

3aHHTepeCOBaHO 06~eCTBO rrpecca rro He06xonHMOCTH OKashy

3bIBaeT naBJIeHHe Ha BJIaCTH 3TO He MeIIIaeT )KYPHaJIHCTaM H

OCPHnHaJIbHbIM JIHnaM rrOHHMaTb H YBIDKaTb npyr npyra qTO H

C03naeT OCHOBY nJISl HOPMaJIbHbIX pa60qIfx oTHoIIIeHHH

ITpH rron06HbIX HHTeprrpeTanHSlX He CTOHT 3a6bIBaTb ITO

Bpa)Kl1e6HOCTb OCTaeTCSl Bpa)KDe6HOCTbIO KaK ee HH rrpHYKpashy

IIIHBaH 113BecTHbIH TOJIKOBbIH CJIOBapb Be6cTepa orrpeneJISleT

correpHHKa KaK OIIIIOHeHTa aHTarOHHCTa Bpara HJIH rrpOTHBshy

HHKa B Hrpe OTHOIIIeHHSl Me)Kl1y rrpeCCOH H BJIaCTSlMH HrpOH

HHKaK He SlBJISlIOTCSl HO 3TO He neJIaeT RX 60JIee rrpOCTbIMH H

MHpHbIMH QT06bI 3TO rrO~CTBOBaTb rrOIlbITaHTeCb paccTashy

BHTb Ha IIIKaJIe OT rrOJIHOH Bpa)Kl1e6HocTH no oTKpoBeHHoro

yronHIfqecTBa CJIeDYIOIIWe CHTYanHH

--- HeKHii 06JIanaTeJIb OCPHnHaJIbHOH nOJI)KHOCTH rrpHrJIashy

rnaeT perropTepa Ha 06en H He pa3pernaeT eMY OIIJIaTHTb CBOIO

nomo CKpOMHOrO CqeTa

--- Qepe3 KaKOe-TO BpeMSl TOT )Ke qIfHOBHHK rrpenJIaraeT

~HaJIHCTY 3aKYJIHCHbIe CBeneHHSl 0 TOM KaK rrpHHHMaJIOCb

peIIIeHHe 0 CTPOHTeJIbCTBe HOBOH 3JIeKTpOCTaHnHH H rrpOCHT

orry6JIHKOBaTb 3TH CBeneHHSlbull

--- )I(YPHaJIHCT 06p~aeTCSl K JIHny ClllITaIO~eMYCSl Heshy

n06pO)KeJIaTeJIeM ero 3aKa3qHKa paCCqHTbIBaSl rronyqHTb

rrpOTlIB TOro KaKHe-TO YJIHKH

--- Pa60TaSI Han CTaTbeH ~HaJIHCT KOHCYJIbTHpyeTcSl C

npyrHM OcpHnHaJIbHbIM JIHnOM 3apaHee 3HaSl qTO TeMa He

rrpenCTaBJISleT nJISl Toro ~oro HHTepeca

--- PerropTep BMeCTe C rrepBbIM anMHHHCTPaTopOM eneT Ha

ceccHIO 3aKOHonaTeJIbHOrO C06paHHSl B npyrOH ropon ITo noshy

pore OH 60JITaeT 0 rrOJIHTIIKe H BbICJIYIIlHBaeT BOCrrOMHHaHHSl

CBoero BH3aBH KaK TOT 6blJl HaqIfHaIOIIWM aDBOKaTOM H C TPYshy

nOM Mor conep)KaTb CeMbIO

--- Korna 3HaKOMna HeT B ropone perropTep HaBenhIBaeTCSl

K ero ceKpeTaprne IIbITaSICb pa3Y3HaTb rrOMep)KlfBaeT JIH TOT

HeKoero KaHDHnaTa Ha nOJI)KHOCTb cpenepaJIbHoro CYnhH

--- 3HaSI ITO anMHHHCTpaTOp B qaCTHOM rrOpSlnKe BCTpeqashy

118 119







KTO lITO CKa3aJI














HHCPOPMaQHIO










Horo ~HaJlllCTa








HaJIHCTa






























120 121





















































BHH rrOJIHTHKOB


















123122
























~HanHCTaMH


















~OHanbHbIX ~eJIeH



















124 125














uOJI)KaThCSI








3aMeTHa











rrpOBOoHhIe KpaHhI



JIeCHbIX OoraTCTB

126



yqpe)K]leHHH

































127














3aMelIaTh




































lIaS IOKYMeHTbI





HeHHSlX











128 129

















IIaCHOCTH AMepHKH

















130

















He3aBHCHMOCTH









131



C OCTOpmKHOCThIO



rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM






















qaTb HJIH HeT


































133132





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157







KTO lITO CKa3aJI














HHCPOPMaQHIO










Horo ~HaJlllCTa








HaJIHCTa






























120 121





















































BHH rrOJIHTHKOB


















123122
























~HanHCTaMH


















~OHanbHbIX ~eJIeH



















124 125














uOJI)KaThCSI








3aMeTHa











rrpOBOoHhIe KpaHhI



JIeCHbIX OoraTCTB

126



yqpe)K]leHHH

































127














3aMelIaTh




































lIaS IOKYMeHTbI





HeHHSlX











128 129

















IIaCHOCTH AMepHKH

















130

















He3aBHCHMOCTH









131



C OCTOpmKHOCThIO



rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM






















qaTb HJIH HeT


































133132





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157





















































BHH rrOJIHTHKOB


















123122
























~HanHCTaMH


















~OHanbHbIX ~eJIeH



















124 125














uOJI)KaThCSI








3aMeTHa











rrpOBOoHhIe KpaHhI



JIeCHbIX OoraTCTB

126



yqpe)K]leHHH

































127














3aMelIaTh




































lIaS IOKYMeHTbI





HeHHSlX











128 129

















IIaCHOCTH AMepHKH

















130

















He3aBHCHMOCTH









131



C OCTOpmKHOCThIO



rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM






















qaTb HJIH HeT


































133132





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157
























~HanHCTaMH


















~OHanbHbIX ~eJIeH



















124 125














uOJI)KaThCSI








3aMeTHa











rrpOBOoHhIe KpaHhI



JIeCHbIX OoraTCTB

126



yqpe)K]leHHH

































127














3aMelIaTh




































lIaS IOKYMeHTbI





HeHHSlX











128 129

















IIaCHOCTH AMepHKH

















130

















He3aBHCHMOCTH









131



C OCTOpmKHOCThIO



rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM






















qaTb HJIH HeT


































133132





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157














uOJI)KaThCSI








3aMeTHa











rrpOBOoHhIe KpaHhI



JIeCHbIX OoraTCTB

126



yqpe)K]leHHH

































127














3aMelIaTh




































lIaS IOKYMeHTbI





HeHHSlX











128 129

















IIaCHOCTH AMepHKH

















130

















He3aBHCHMOCTH









131



C OCTOpmKHOCThIO



rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM






















qaTb HJIH HeT


































133132





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157














3aMelIaTh




































lIaS IOKYMeHTbI





HeHHSlX











128 129

















IIaCHOCTH AMepHKH

















130

















He3aBHCHMOCTH









131



C OCTOpmKHOCThIO



rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM






















qaTb HJIH HeT


































133132





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157

















IIaCHOCTH AMepHKH

















130

















He3aBHCHMOCTH









131



C OCTOpmKHOCThIO



rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM






















qaTb HJIH HeT


































133132





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157



C OCTOpmKHOCThIO



rOBOpHTh 00 3TOM






















qaTb HJIH HeT


































133132





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157





























JIeHO rrYOJIHltIHo






























3HaKOMbIX




134 135


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157


































136






IIHIJIYTbull

OPYIKHE BOHmI


















- nOCJIe~ CBOJIOlb



137




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157




































138











BJIaCTell























139































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157































































C npeccoit








140 141

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157

































corpa)KJaIlaM













MeCT











MHJThTOHa






YCHJIHSIMH








142 143






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157






































rpa)KAaH






























144 145







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157







CTBeHHOCTb































































146 147



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157



































148









HOCTb







~HaJIHCTOM




















149










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157










OrHH He ObmaeT
















3aKJIIOIeHHeM







BbmOJIHeHa

150









HHMHbIX HCTOIHIIKOB


























151













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157













CH OTObmaTb CaMOMy






























JIHllib OJIecpyeT
























152 153

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157

























BCnOMHHaeT










IS4








cepbe3HbIX np06JIeM
























ISS































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157































156

Cma1-lf1U POmMaH






























157

Date post:	24-Sep-2020
Category:	Documents
Upload:	others
View:	2 times
Download:	0 times

74 Howard Simons, Government and National Security...

Documents