8/17/2014
1
Public Works and Emergency Management
APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt 1
We Are Emergency Responders; Public Worksin All‐Hazards Emergencies and Traffic Incidents
APWA CONGRESS , August 20, 2014, Toronto, ON
Public Works and Emergency Management
Dave Bergner, M.A., PWLF; APWA Emergency Management Committee
Public Works Superintendent, Retired
Traffic Incident /Emergency Management Specialist, Gannett-Fleming
Bob Lowry, M.P.A.,P.E., PWLF
Public Works Director, Carrolton, TX
Jeff May, P.E.; APWA Emergency Management Committee
Assistant Public Works Director, Des Moines, IA;
Ron Ditmars, B.S., CPM
Public Works Superintendent, Olathe, KS
Yuko Nakanashi, PhD, M.B.A.
Consultant, NCHRP Synthesis: Training and Exercise for Maintenance and Operations Personnel in All-Hazards Emergencies and Traffic Incidents
2APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
Public Works and Emergency Management
OVERVIEW• Public Works an “emergency responder”• Public Works has critical roles and responsibilities.• Some disciplines reluctant to acknowledge this.• Many in Public Works unaware or indifferent of roles.• Public Works must consider Emergency Management as
important as design, construction, operation, maintenance• Training and certification improves status
3APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
)
8/17/2014
2
Public Works and Emergency Management
Disasters Occur Everywhere, Anytime Natural‐‐‐ storms, floods, tornadoes, hurricanes, earthquakes, landslides, blizzards, sinkholes, volcanoes, tsunami•Technological‐‐‐ structural collapses, pipeline ruptures, explosions, fires, transportation accidents (highway, rail, air, watercraft)•Human‐‐‐ special events, riots, crimes, terrorism
• 90% of all presidentially declared disasters are weather related, causing about 500 deaths and nearly $14 billion in damage yearly.
4APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
Public Works and Emergency Management
Most disasters are from Natural Causes
5APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
Public Works and Emergency Management
APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt 6
8/17/2014
3
Public Works and Emergency Management
When Disasters Strike• Local governments expected to handle Response first 72 hours• State and Federal aid may not be available
• May need Mutual Aid from other local jurisdictions• Not all incidents qualify for Federal assistance
• Local governments responsible for Recovery• Public Works lead agency for:
• Debris Management • restoration of critical infrastructure.
7APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
Public Works and Emergency Management
NIMS defines preparedness as "a continuous cycle ofplanning, organizing, training, equipping, exercising, evaluating, and corrective action in an effort to ensure effective coordination during incident response.“
8APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW
and Emrgy Mgmnt
Public Works and Emergency Management
Emergency Service Sector: Public Works RoleProvide essential emergency support functions:• debris clearance, removal, disposal• emergency traffic operations • repair damage to roads, bridges, tunnels• assess damage to public structures• restoration of utility services Source: FEMA Critical Infrastructure Resource Center
9APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
8/17/2014
4
Public Works and Emergency Management
Traditional Position of Public Works‐Reactionary
• Lack of interest and awareness• Insufficient planning and preparation• Activate after Police and Fire request assistance• Communication, command and control not coordinated• Reluctant to assume lead
10APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
(Google Images)
Public Works and Emergency Management
The New Stance for Public Works‐Proactive
• Recognized as an “emergency responder”
• Response ‐‐‐PW has a critical role
• Recovery and Mitigation‐‐‐ primarily PW mission**
• Prevention and Protection ‐‐‐PW supports police and fire
11APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
**Public Works is lead for Recovery and Mitigation. Take Command of Incident.
Public Works and Emergency Management
Public Works Not like Other Emergency Services
• PW Is not “24‐7”• Focus is on construction, maintenance, operations• Does not have a paramilitary structure• Agencies vary by composition and functions• PW doesn’t have a strong “brand”• Often confused with highway/street contractors
12APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and EmrgyMgmnt
8/17/2014
5
Public Works and Emergency Management
APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
13
“But in emergency management, if you need help from the public works department, you have to have a good relationship and you can’t direct them to do anything, you can only ask for their help.”
Cory Lyman, Director of Emergency Management for Salt Lake City, Utah, describing transition from law enforcement into emergency management. Police Chief Magazine, July, 2014
Public Works and Emergency Management
Risk Assessment: Threats, Hazards, Vulnerabilities
Review your community’s history: • What has occurred • What is likely to occur • What would be role of your agency • What would be needed to respond• What are the resource gaps • How to acquire needed resources or assistance
FEMA Comprehensive Preparedness Guide 201: Threat and Hazard Identificationand Risk Assessment (THIRA).
14
APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and EmrgyMgmnt
All-Hazards Emergency Operations Plan
APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt 15
Operations• Identify, obtain and keep ready equipment, tools, supplies • Have backup notification and communication systems • Anticipate potential situations; be flexible in plans • Safety is highest priority; debris fields are dangerous• Brief personnel on coping with shock, stress• Policy on salvaged personal property • Expect frequent maintenance and repair• Consider employees home situations• Track deployed personnel and equipment • Documentation (ICS forms)
West Valley City, UT PW employees train for emergencies; Jake Arslanian, APWA Reporter, January, 2005
8/17/2014
6
Public Works and Emergency Management
16APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
Ref: http://www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume‐163/issue‐9/Features/vacuum‐trucks‐key‐to‐successful‐trench‐
rescue.html
CASE STUDY: Interagency Cooperation‐‐‐Trench RescueAnderson (IN) DPW’s vacuum trucks, light stands, and compressor proved critical to success. Support from Police, Development, DPW, and Planning departments.HCTRT members had cross‐trained with local municipal and private‐sector vacuum trucks during trench training while using the rescue vacuum system.
Public Works and Emergency Management
APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
17
• IS‐100pw Introduction to Incident Command System• IS‐200 ICS for Single Resources/ Initial Action• IS‐700 Intro to National Incident Management System• ICS‐300 Intermediate Incident Command (3‐day class)• ICS‐400 Advanced Incident Command (2‐day class)
• IS‐552 P.W. Role in Emergency Management• IS‐554 Emergency Planning for P.W.• IS‐556 Damage Assessment for P.W.• IS‐558 P.W. in Disaster Recovery• IS‐559 Local Damage Assessment• IS‐632 Introduction to Debris Operations
Public Works and Emergency Management
APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
18
• IS‐701 NIMS Multiagency Coordination System • IS‐702 NIMS Public Information Systems • IS‐703 NIMS Resource Management• IS‐704 NIMS Communications Management• IS‐706 NIMS Intrastate Mutual Aid • MGMT 317 Disaster Management for Public Services (2‐day course through TEEX)
• IS‐800 Intro to National Response Framework • IS‐803 Emergency Services Function #3‐‐‐
Public Works
8/17/2014
7
Public Works and Emergency Management
APWA Congress 2014 Bergner FINAL PW and Emrgy Mgmnt
19
FEMA Center for Domestic Preparedness Recommended Public Works Courses:Technical Emergency Response Training for CBRNE Incidents (TERT)Hazard Assessment and Response Management for CBRNE Incidents (HARM)Instructor Training Certification (ITC)Emergency Responder Hazardous Materials Technician for CBRNE Incidents (ERHM)Field Force Command and Planning (FFC)Standardized Awareness Authorized Training Program, Train‐the‐Trainer (SAAT)Environmental Health Training in Emergency Response Operations (EHTER Ops)Hazardous Materials Technician for CBRNE Incidents (HT)Incident Command: Capabilities, Planning and Response Actions for All Hazards (IC)Pandemic Planning and Preparedness (P3)Advanced Public Information Officer: Health and Hospital Emergencies (APIOHHE)L339 REP Core Concepts Course (RCCC)L‐304 REP Exercise Evaluation Course (REEC)
Traffic Incident Management
Traffic Incident:• Any unplanned event that disrupts normal flow of traffic • Duration usually short‐term; major incidents longer
Traffic Incident Management:
“A planned and coordinated multi‐disciplinary process to detect, respond to, and clear traffic incidents so that traffic flow may be restored as safely and quickly as possible.
Effective TIM reduces the duration and impacts
of traffic incidents and improves the safety of
motorists, crash victims, and responders.” FHWA Traffic Incident Management Website
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final
20
Levels of Incidents per MUTCD
• Chapter 6‐I, Control of Traffic Through Traffic Incident Management Areas, defines traffic incidents as:
• minor ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ up to 30 minutes duration
• intermediate ‐‐‐ 30 minutes to 2 hours
• major ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ 2‐24 hours
• (if exceeds 24 hours other chapters of Part 6 apply)
• Different factors influence these determinations
• Level can change upon a particular discipline’s involvement
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final21
8/17/2014
8
Challenges with Traffic Incidents
• Responders have different command structures, SOPs
• Lack of coordination among disciplines
• confusion/ conflict as to who in charge
• poor communication
• insufficient training
• Media and public not well informed
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final22
Training Together
Traffic Incident Management Responder course • 4‐hour, no‐cost class for all disciplines • Can be hosted by organizations
such as APWA Chaptersor individual agencies
• Table‐top exercises• Public Works/Transportation needed in classes• Web‐based Responder course in development • Train‐the–Trainer course, (1.5 days); Public Works needed
• FHWA Office of Emergency Transportation Operations• Product of SHRP L‐12
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final 23
Public Works/DOT Capabilities
• Public Works / DOTs responsible for road and traffic systems operations and maintenance
• Employees routinely work on the streets and highways
• Trained and equipped for temporary traffic control
• Experienced with various situations and incidents
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final24
8/17/2014
9
TIM Prepares for Other Emergencies
The policies, procedures and methods for Traffic Incident Management are the basis for better communication, coordination, cooperation and capability in other emergencies and events
PLAN PREPARE PERFORM
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final25
For More Information…
FHWA, Office of Transportations Operations fhwa.dot.gov/etotim
• Best Practices in Traffic Incident Management • 2010 Traffic Incident Management Handbook • Traffic Incident Management in Work Zones Primer • Guide to Incident Command System for Transportation Professionals • Traffic Control Concepts for Incident Clearance Primer • Metropolitan Traffic Management Center‐Concept of Operations
• Kim Vasconez, Team Leader, Traffic Incident & Events ManagementFHWA Office of Traffic Operations, Kimberly.vasconez @usdot.gov
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final26
Other TIM Information Sources
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final
27
• Emergency Responder Safety Institute respondersafety.com• I‐95 Corridor Coalition i95coalition.org/i95/TrainingTIM Network timnetwork.org
• National Highway Institute nhi.fhwa.dot.gov/training/course
• Freeway Management and Operations• Managing Travel for Planned Special Events• Using the Incident Command System at Highway Incidents• Work Zone Traffic Control for Maintenance Operations (web)• Basics of Work Zone Traffic Control (web)• Principles of Evacuation Planning (web)• Safe and Effective Use of Law Enforcement in Work Zones (web)
• International Municipal Signal Association imsasafety.org• Work Zone Traffic Control Technician certification course
8/17/2014
10
Questions?
c. Monte Vista Associates, LLC; APWA Congress 2014 final
28
8/17/2014
1
A Regional Approach to Emergency Response
The North Central Texas Public Works Emergency Response Team
American Public Works AssociationAugust 20, 2014
Overview
•Background
•Current Status
•Future Plans
Background
Concern expressed in several forums
• North Central Branch Texas Public Works Association
• North Central Texas Council of Governments Public Works Council
8/17/2014
2
Objectives
• Enhance the ability to deal with major emergencies beyond existing resources
• Create a cooperative arrangement that enables jurisdictions to:
• Simplify/streamline the process to request and obtain assistance
• Identify available regional resources• Recover more quickly• Work out legal and financial issues in advance
Objectives
Focused on preparedness and initial response for short term recovery
• Help stabilize the incident• Operational period: 36 hours
Terms of the agreement:
• NIMS approach• Voluntary support Your decision to
participate
Terms of the Agreement
Operational Costs: • Pay your own way; • No reimbursements for first operational period
Insurance (workmen’s compensation, auto, etc.): • Each party responsible for own actions
Agreement Processing: • PWERT will facilitate and provide repositoryof
information
8/17/2014
3
How it works
General Procedures:
• Requesting Agency fills out checklist and Info Form
• Ask for PWERT Assistance to obtain resources or Locate & contact agencies in the agreement
• Responding Agency:o Analyze & Validate resources availableo Obtain authority to deployo Complete Checklist & Formo Dispatch Resources
Current Status
Thirty-three (32) municipalities in the Dallas/Fort Worth Metro-plex, including Fort Worth and Arlington, have already executed
all the documents and many more communities are in the process of doing so.
Information
Contacts:
Bob Kopp: 972-466-3181; ([email protected])
Bob Lowry: 817-937-4934 ([email protected])
Melanie Devine: 817-695-9138; ([email protected])
PWERT Website:
http://www.nctcog.org/ep/Special_Projects/PWERT/Index.asp
8/17/2014
4
Questions and Discussion
8/17/2014
1
PUBLIC WORKS PROFESSIONALS AS FIRST RESPONDERS: HOW CAN WE BE READY?
Jeff May
Assistant Public Works Director, city of Des MoinesAPWA Emergency Management Committee
APWA Congress, August 20, 2014 Toronto, ON
1APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
IN 2003 PRESIDENTIAL DIRECTIVE HSPD-8, (NATIONAL PREPAREDNESS), CLEARLY STATED PUBLIC WORKS PERSONNEL ARE FIRST RESPONDERS
2APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
THERE SHOULD BE NO QUESTION!
ARE PUBLIC WORKS PERSONNEL
FIRST RESPONDERS?
3APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
8/17/2014
2
COMMUNICATION AND OUTREACH
• EDUCATE UPPER MANAGEMENT AND GOVERNING BODIES ON THE IMPORTANCE OF PREPAREDNESS AND TRAINING
• EDUCATE LOCAL AGENCY STAFF – ESPECIALLY PUBLIC WORKS TEAM
4APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
LOTS OF RESPECT…BUT NOT FOR US
5APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
RESPECT MAY NOT BE MUTUAL
• TO MINIMIZE FIRE/PD FEELING “THREATENED”, PRESENT EFFORTS AS A COMMITMENT TO BECOMING BEST AT THOSE JOBS EXPECTED OF PUBLIC WORKS: MITIGATION, RESPONSE AND RECOVERY
• WE PROVIDE ACCESS TO THE AREAS THAT FIRE AND POLICE NEED • WE MAINTAIN ESSENTIAL INFRASTRUCTURE DURING THE EVENT• WE REMAIN LONG AFTER FIRE AND POLICE ARE GONE TO RECOVER FROM
THE EVENT
PUBLIC WORKS IS PUBLIC SAFETY!6APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
8/17/2014
3
WHERE TO START
• COMMUNICATION
• WE NEED TO SPEAK THE SAME LANGUAGE
7APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
NATIONAL INCIDENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM THE NATIONAL INCIDENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM (NIMS) IDENTIFIES CONCEPTS AND PRINCIPLES THAT ANSWER HOW TO MANAGE EMERGENCIES FROM PREPAREDNESS TO RECOVERY REGARDLESS OF THEIR CAUSE, SIZE, LOCATION OR COMPLEXITY.
NIMS PROVIDES A CONSISTENT, NATIONWIDE APPROACH AND VOCABULARY FOR MULTIPLE AGENCIES OR JURISDICTIONS TO WORK TOGETHER TO BUILD, SUSTAIN AND DELIVER THE CORE CAPABILITIES NEEDED TO ACHIEVE A SECURE AND RESILIENT NATION.
8APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
NIMS/ICS COURSES• ICS-100 – INTRODUCTION TO INCIDENT COMMAND SYSTEM (ONLINE)
• ICS-200 – ICS FOR SINGLE RESOURCES AND INITIAL ACTION INCIDENTS (ONLINE)
• ICS-300 – INTERMEDIATE ICS FOR EXPANDING INCIDENTS
• ICS-400 – ADVANCED ICS (SENIOR LEVEL STAFF)
• IS-552 – PUBLIC WORKS ROLE IN EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
• IS-554 – EMERGENCY PLANNING FOR PUBLIC WORKS
• IS-556 – DAMAGE ASSESSMENT FOR PUBLIC WORKS
• IS-558 – PUBLIC WORKS AND DISASTER RECOVERY
• IS-700 – NIMS, AN INTRODUCTION
• IS-800 – NATIONAL RESPONSE FRAMEWORK (NRF), AN INTRODUCTION9APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
8/17/2014
4
ICS – NOT JUST FOR DISASTERS, “EVERY EVENT”
• ICE/SNOW STORMS
• FLOODING
• WIND STORMS
• SPECIAL/COMMUNITY EVENTS
10APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
PUBLIC WORKS IS PUBLIC SAFETY
Public Works is a first responder!11APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
TRAINING AND EXERCISES
• EVERYONE NEEDS TO BE ON THE SAME PAGE
• TRAIN TOGETHER TO WORK TOGETHER
12APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
8/17/2014
5
TYPES OF TRAINING
• WORKSHOPS
• TABLE TOP EXERCISES
• DRILLS
• START SIMPLE – INCREASE COMPLEXITY OVER TIME
13APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
IMPORTANT CONTACTS
• STATE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AND HOMELAND SECURITY
• COUNTY EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
• FEMA
MAKE THE CONTACTS BEFORE YOU NEED THEM
14APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
EVERY EVENT/DISASTER IS ALSO AN OPPORTUNITY TO LEARN
• TRAINING EXERCISE
• SNOW EVENT
• FLOOD EVENT
• WIND EVENT
• COMMUNITY EVENT
ALWAYS CONDUCT AN AFTER ACTION REVIEW15APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
8/17/2014
6
BE PREPARED• COORDINATE WITH ADJACENT JURISDICTIONS
• COORDINATE WITH NON-LOCAL JURISDICTIONS
• WORK WITH PRIVATE SECTOR ON PRE-ARRANGED CONTRACTS
• GET UNIT 5 CERT TRAINING: “LIGHT SEARCH AND RESCUE (SAR) OPERATIONS”
• CREATE DEBRIS MANAGEMENT PLAN (FEMA 325 DEBRIS MANAGEMENT GUIDE)
• CREATE ICS CHARTS FOR PROGRESSIVELY EXPANDING ALL-HAZARDS EVENTS
(WITH YOUR AGENCY’S STAFF POSITIONS AND TITLES)
• UNDERSTAND EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT ASSISTANCE COMPACTS (EMAC)
16APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
PUBLIC WORKS MANAGEMENT PRACTICES MANUALCHAPTER 8 – EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
DEVELOP THE “3 P’S”OF:
• POLICIES
• PRACTICES
• PROCEDURES
FOR EACH OF THE 18 ELEMENTS
17APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
SUMMARY
• EDUCATE – UPPER MANAGEMENT, GOVERNING BODIES, PERSONNEL
• NIMS TRAINING
• TRAINING – EXERCISES & CLASSROOM
• MAKE CONTACTS WITH STATE & COUNTY EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT
• COORDINATE WITH FIRE, POLICE, OTHER JURISDICTIONS
• BE A PUBLIC WORKS CHAMPION
• FAMILIARIZE YOURSELF WITH EMAC
• USE ICS 18APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
8/17/2014
7
FINAL EXAM
FIRST AND LAST QUESTION –
IS PUBLIC WORKS A FIRST RESPONDER?
19
APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
QUESTIONS
JEFF MAY
ASSISTANT PUBLIC WORKS DIRECTOR/
SEWER MAINTENANCE ADMINISTRATOR
CITY OF DES MOINES
(515) [email protected]
20APWA Congress 2014, PW Emergency Responders J.May,v.2
8/17/2014
1
Incorporating NIMS into Snow and Ice Operations
City of Olathe Fast Facts
Located 20 miles Southwest of Downtown Kansas City
62 Square Miles
24th Fastest Growing Community in the U.S. (pop. Over 100,000)
Population: 130,000
5th Largest City in State of Kansas
Our Streets and Sidewalks
213 Collector Lane Miles
381 Arterial Lane Miles
1,539 Cul-de-sacs
1,252 Lane Miles
658 Residential Lane Miles
613 Miles of Sidewalks
8/17/2014
2
NIMS Chain of Command
Incident Commander
Streets Superintendent
Planning Chief
Field Operations Supervisor
Operation Section Chiefs
Shift Supervisors
Operation Section Chiefs
Shift Supervisors
15 Residential
Teams of 3
5 Primary
Teams of 2
Operation Section Chiefs
Shift Supervisors
Logistics Chief
Snow Dispatcher
Operation Section Chiefs
Shift Supervisors
Public Information Officer
PW Strategic Comm. Analyst
Safety Officer
HR Safety Coordinator
Planning Chief
Field Operations Supervisor
NIMS in Communications
Chain of Command Pre-Event Planning
Reverse Calling Notification
System
ICS 213 Updates AAR
External Communications
• Social Media• Press Releases• Media• Emergency Snow
Homepage• Snow Plow Map• NotifyJoCo• Customer Service• Emergency Snow
Hotline
8/17/2014
3
Internal Communications
ICS 213 Report• Sent to city
employees and City Council at the end of each shift
• Less formal, periodic updates to communications staff during shifts
8/17/2014
1
<August 20, 2014>Dr. Yuko Nakanishi
NAKANISHI RESEARCH & CONSULTING, LLC
2014 APWA Congress & ExpoNakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC
8/17/20142014 APWA Congress & Expo
Nakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC 2
Above: Responders create a safe zone for incident response operations by blocking lanes with a fire engine and traffic cones. (FHWA/Ronald Moore)
8/17/2014
2014 APWA Congress & ExpoNakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC
3
• Minor traffic incidents
• Vehicle fires• Minor train/ bus
accidents• Accidents w/
injuries but no fatalities
• Train derailment• Major bus / rail
transit accidents• Major truck
accidents• Multi‐vehicle
crashes• Hazmat spills• Injuries & fatalities
• Train crashes• Airplane crashes• Hazmat incidents• Multi‐vehicle
accidents• Tunnel fires• Multiple injuries &
fatalities
• Port/airport incidents
• Large building fire or explosion
• Industrial incidents
• Major tunnel/ bridge closure
• Terrorist attack/WMD• Floods, blizzards,
tornadoes• Transportation
infrastructure collapse • Extended power/
water outage• Riots• Mass casualties
Classification LOCAL REGIONAL STATE NATIONAL
Examples
Expected Duration 0‐2 HOURS 2‐24 HOURS DAYS WEEKS
Public Preparedness High for local Low for national
Need for interoperabilityIncreased coordination complexityGreater State / Federal involvement
INCIDENT SCALE / PUBLIC PREPAREDNESS /INTERGOVERNMENTAL – MULTIJURISDICTIONAL INVOLVEMENT
Source: John Contestabile, JHU/APL, formerly with MDOT
8/17/2014
2
Classification LOCAL REGIONAL STATE NATIONAL
Expected Duration 0‐2 HOURS 2‐24 HOURS DAYS WEEKS
They must: Recognize various hazards Know what to do, what not to do Be ready to be the first on the
scene, if an incident transitions from simple to complex
Integrate themselves into the ICS organization
8/17/20142014 APWA Congress & ExpoNakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC 4
Public Preparedness High for local Low for national
Need for interoperabilityIncreased coordination complexityGreater State / Federal involvement
They must work:(1) In Traffic,(2) Under the Public Eye,(3) With equipment difficult
to operate/maneuver(4) In noisy, dirty, non-
climate-controlled conditions/environment
National Incident Management System (NIMS)
Incident Command System (ICS)National Response Framework (NRF)Multiagency Coordination Systems
(MACS)
8/17/20142014 APWA Congress & Expo
Nakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC 5
NIMS… Is comprehensive, nationwide,
scalable, and dynamic Takes an All-Hazards approach Is a standardized resource
management procedure that enables collaboration
Used to manage small incidents (e.g. traffic incidents), special events (e.g. parades), or large incidents (e.g. terrorism, disasters)
8/17/20142014 APWA Congress & Expo
Nakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC 6
Components1. Preparedness2. Communications
& Information Management
3. Resource Management
4. Command & Management
5. Ongoing Management & Maintenance
Source: 2008 NIMS core document
8/17/2014
3
B: Multiagency Coordination Systems (MACS)
A: Incident Management System (ICS)
8/17/2014 72014 APWA Congress & Expo, Nakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC
(1) Preparedness (2)Communications & Information Management(3) Resource Management (4) Command & Management(5) Ongoing Management & Maintenance
Source: 2008 NIMS core document
Characteristics of ICS: Organizes on-scene
operations All levels of gov’t,
NGOs, & private sector Single command point Defines responder
responsibilities Common Terminology Respond to immediate
situation Flexible command lead
8/17/20142014 APWA Congress & ExpoNakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC
8
Sections: 1. Command2. Operations 3. Planning4. Logistics 5. Finance/Admin
Operations Section
Single Resources
Strike Team
Task Force
Operations Section
Road Crew Utilities Specialist Traffic Control Crew
8/17/20142014 APWA Congress & ExpoNakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC
9
Operations Section
Road Crew
HazMat Specialist
Utilities Specialist
Heavy Equipment Operator
Traffic Control Crew
Note: As the incident grows, so will Operations. Other Pub Works / Transp resources may be added.
Source: FHWA NIMS Workbook (link here)
8/17/2014
4
Source: 2008 NIMS core document
Purposes of MACS: Coordinate activities above the field level Prioritize demands for critical resources
8/17/2014
2014 APWA Congress & Expo,Nakanishi Research &
Consulting, LCC
10
8/17/20142014 APWA Congress & Expo
Nakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC 11
Scientific American – NYU Poly Professional LearningNakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC 128/17/2014
Building, Sustaining, Deliveringthe core capabilities in the National Preparedness Goal
NRF is always in effect Twenty years of guidance &
experience
History:◦ 1992: Federal Response Plan◦ 2004: National Response Plan◦ 2008: National Response Framework
NRF Structure:1. Base Document2. Emergency Support
Function Annexes[?]
3. Support Annexes[?]
4. Incident Annexes[?]
Source: 2013 NRF
8/17/2014
5
ESF#3:PublicWorks&EngineeringCoordinator: US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), w/in the Department of Defense
Key Response Core Capabilities: Infrastructure Systems, Critical Transportation, Public and Private Services and Resources, Environmental Response/Health and Safety, Fatality Management, Mass Care Services, Mass Search & Rescue Operations
Source: 2013 NRF
ESF#1:TransportationCoordinator: US Department of Transportation
Key Response Core Capability: Critical Transportation
ESF#1 in Action: Traffic lights under repair in TX. (FEMA.gov)
ESF#3 in Action:USACE Engineers inspecting generators(www.USACE.army.mil)
8/17/20142014 APWA Congress & ExpoNakanishi Research & Consulting, LLC
13
OTHER TRAINING TOPICS
• Emergency Operation Plans (EOPs)
• Procedures and Protocols
• Mutual Aid and Assistance Agreements
• APWA Mission Ready Packages
• Continuity Capability
• Preparedness Cycle
• Exercises and the HSEEP Exercise Cycle
Emergency Operations Plans (EOPs)
EOPs…– Are ongoing plans to respond to a variety of potential hazards.
– Explain roles and responsibilities, including those of Public Works staff members.
Source: CPG 101
Formats– Traditional Functional (most
common)– Emergency Support Function
(for State‐level EOPs)– Agency‐ or Department‐Focused
(for Smaller agencies)
(Resource) For details on content, format, & process:
FEMA Comprehensive PreparednessGuide 101 (version 2)
8/17/2014
6
States Florida. Florida Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan, Florida State Emergency Response Team, Tallahassee, FL, 2012, [Online]. Available:
Iowa. Iowa Emergency Response Plan, Iowa Homeland Security and Emergency Management Division, Johnston, IA, October 2010, http://homelandsecurity.iowa.gov/documents/misc/HSEMD_IAEmergencyResponsePlan_OCT2010.pdf
Ohio. State of Ohio Emergency Operations Plan, Ohio Emergency Management Agency, Ohio Department of Public Safety, Columbus, OH, 2013, [Online]. Available: http://ema.ohio.gov/EOP_Detail.aspx
Texas. State of Texas Emergency Management Plan, Texas Division of Emergency Management, Texas Department of Public Safety, Austin, TX, May 2012, https://www.txdps.state.tx.us/dem/documents/planState/state_plan.pdf
Vermont. State of Vermont Emergency Operations Plan, Vermont Division of Emergency Management and Homeland Security, Waterbury, VT, 2013, [Online]. Available: http://vem.vermont.gov/sites/vem/files/Base%20Plan_20131202.pdf
Cities
Santa Cruz, CA. Emergency Operations Plan, 2013,
Newport News, VA. City of Newport News Emergency Operations Plan, Dec. 2011,http://www.nngov.com/emergency‐management/downloads/EOP%20Basic%20Plan%20‐%20public%20Knowledge%20Document.pdf
http://floridadisaster.org/documents/CEMP/2012/2012%20State%20CEMP%20Basic%20Plan%20‐%20Final.pdf
Bellevue, WA. Emergency Operations Plan, Dec. 2012,
http://www.cob.org/documents/fire/emergency‐operations‐plan.pdf
Counties East Baton Rouge Parish, LA.Emergency Operations Plan (EOP), July 2013,
https://brgov.com/dept/oep/plan/BasicPlan/BASICPLAN2000.pdf
Harris County, TX. “Basic Plan Executive Summary & Annexes,” 2014, [Online]. Available: http://www.hcoem.org/Documents/20140422_BasicPlanAnnex_ExecutiveSummary.pdf
Fairfax County, VA. Fairfax County Emergency Operations Plan, June 2011, http://www.fairfaxcounty.gov/oem/documents/eop‐2011‐final.pdf
St. Louis County, MO. Basic Emergency Operations Plan, January 2013, [Online]. Available: http://www.stlouisco.com/Portals/8/docs/document%20library/police/oem/beop%20and%20esfs/BEOP%20for%20web.pdf
http://www.cityofsantacruz.com/Modules/ShowDocument.aspx?documentid=34608
SAMPLE
EOPs
Procedures and Protocols
Types of Procedural Documents:• Standard Operating Procedure or Operations Manual[hover]
• Field Operations Guide or Incident Management Handbook[hover]
• Mobilization Guide[hover]
• Job Aid[hover]
What are Protocols?• Established guidelines for action under specified conditions
(such as an emergency)
• Guidelines based on training and delegation of authority(to permit specific personnel to assess a situation, to execute a task or function
rapidly, or to escalate their efforts before requiring further authorization)
Source: 2008 NIMS core document
Mutual Aid & Assistance Agreements
MutualAidAgreements• Automatic: Agreements that permit
the automatic dispatch and response of requested resources without incident‐specific approvals.
• Local: Agreements between neighboring jurisdictions or organizations that involve a formal request for assistance.
• Regional: Substate regional mutual aid agreements between multiple jurisdictions that are often sponsored by a council of governments/similar regional body.
• Statewide/Intrastate: Agreements, often coordinated through the State, that incorporate both State and local governmental and NGO resources.
AssistanceAgreements• Interstate: Out‐of‐State
assistance through the Emergency Management Assistance Compact (EMAC) or other formal State‐to‐State agreements.
• International: Agreements between the United States and other nations for the exchange of Federal assets in an emergency.
• Other: Any agreement, whether formal or informal, used to request or provide assistance and/or resources among jurisdictions at any level of government (including foreign), NGOs, or the private sector.
Source: 2008 NIMS core document
8/17/2014
7
EMAC Mission Ready Packages
Go directly to EMAC MRPs:www.emacweb.org/index.php/learnaboutemac/
module‐positions/mission‐ready‐package
Video: www.emacweb.org/index.php/video‐using‐mrp‐models
APWA Emergency Mgmt Resource Center: www.apwa.net/ResourceCenter/Category
/Emergency‐Management
Preparedness Cycle
• Emergency Plans should– Address training & exercise requirements,
– Describe how personnel, equipment, resources support emergency management
– Provide mechanisms for• Setting priorities;
• Integrating multiple jurisdictions, entities, functions;
• Establishing relationships;
• Maintaining COOP/COG
• Ensuring responder safety
• Ensuring infrastructure resiliency
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Source: CPG 101
Exercises
• Discussion‐based– Safe, non‐stressful environment
– Types: Seminars, Workshops, Table‐top Exercises, Games
• Operations‐based– Real‐time, realistic setting
– Types: Drills, Functional Exercises, Full‐Scale Exercises
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Source: HSEEP 2013
8/17/2014
8
CHALLENGES AND SOLUTIONS
• Major Challenges
• Solutions
• Upcoming Synthesis Publication (44‐12)
• Trends and Issues
Audience: Adult Learners• Experienced, skilled
• Problem‐centered motivation
Instructor[Src]Training Material[Src]
Other Students[Src]
Synchronous• Live instructor
• Fixed time• Live Interaction via web or in‐person
Interactive training is ideal. This means interaction with:
Asynchronous• Learner’s schedule & pace
• Can be less costlyVS.
Upcoming NCHRP Synthesis 44‐12
Goals:• Identify interactive emergency training tools and sources for M&O field personnel of State DOTs and local PWs
• Identify obstacles to implementation• Create a Toolkit of relevant training and exercise information.
Results found in the final published report.
InteractiveTrainingforAll‐HazardsEmergencyPlanning,Preparation,andResponseforMaintenance&OperationsFieldPersonnel
8/17/2014
9
Trends and Issues in Training
• Motivation and training
• Training transfer
• Certification and credentialing
• Training of contractors
• Training and reductions in agency liability, workers comp claims, insurance premiums
• Changes in equipment, technology – increased complexity means more training is required